Amrita Chakrabarti1,2, Monika Kaushik3, Juveria Khan3, Deepanshu Soota4, Kalairasan Ponnusamy5, Sunil Saini6, Siddharth Manvati3, Jhalak Singhal2, Anand Ranganathan2, Soumya Pati1, Pawan Kumar Dhar3,7, Shailja Singh2. 1. Department of Life Sciences, Shiv Nadar University, Greater Noida 201314, Uttar Pradesh, India. 2. Special Centre for Molecular Medicine, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi 110067, India. 3. School of Biotechnology, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi 110067, India. 4. National Centre for Biological Sciences, Bangalore 560065, India. 5. National Centre for Disease Control, New Delhi 110054, India. 6. Department of Biophysics, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi 110029, India. 7. Special Centre for Systems Medicine, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi 110067, India.
Abstract
We asked if transfer RNA (tRNA) ever got an opportunity of translating its own sequence during evolution, what would have been the function of such tRNA-encoded peptides (tREPs)? If not, could one artificially synthesize tREPs to study the corresponding functional outcomes? Here, we report a novel, first-in-the-class, chemically synthesized tREP-18 molecule originating from the Escherichia coli tRNA sequence showing potent antileishmanial property. As a first step, E. coli tRNAs were computationally translated into peptide sequence equivalents and a database of full-length hypothetical tREPs was created. The tREP sequences were sent into sequence, structure, and energy filters to narrow down potential peptides for experimental validation. Based on the functional predictions, tREPs were screened against antiparasitic targets, leading to the identification of tREP-18 as a potential antiparasitic peptide. The in vitro assay of chemically synthesized tREP-18 on the Ag83 strain of Leishmania donovani showed its potent antileishmanial property (IC50 value of 22.13 nM). The atomic force microscopy and scanning electron microscopy images indicated significant alteration in the cytoskeletal architecture of tREP-18-treated parasites. Also, tREP-18 seems to destabilize the mitochondrial membrane potential of parasites, disrupting their cellular integrity and leading to parasitic death. The cellular assays of the tREP-18 peptide on the BS12 strain, a clinical isolate of post-kala azar dermal leishmaniasis, demonstrated its significant efficacy at an IC50 value of 15 nM. The tREP-18 peptide showed a toxic effect on the amastigote stage of the parasite, showing macrophage pathogen clearance at a concentration of 22.5 nM. This study provides the proof of the concept of making a new class of functional peptides from tRNA sequences. It also opens a huge untapped tRNA-peptide space toward novel discoveries and applications. In the future, it would be interesting to perform tREP edits and redesign tREPs toward specific applications.
We asked if transfer RNA (tRNA) ever got an opportunity of translating its own sequence during evolution, what would have been the function of such tRNA-encoded peptides (tREPs)? If not, could one artificially synthesize tREPs to study the corresponding functional outcomes? Here, we report a novel, first-in-the-class, chemically synthesized tREP-18 molecule originating from the Escherichia coli tRNA sequence showing potent antileishmanial property. As a first step, E. coli tRNAs were computationally translated into peptide sequence equivalents and a database of full-length hypothetical tREPs was created. The tREP sequences were sent into sequence, structure, and energy filters to narrow down potential peptides for experimental validation. Based on the functional predictions, tREPs were screened against antiparasitic targets, leading to the identification of tREP-18 as a potential antiparasitic peptide. The in vitro assay of chemically synthesized tREP-18 on the Ag83 strain of Leishmania donovani showed its potent antileishmanial property (IC50 value of 22.13 nM). The atomic force microscopy and scanning electron microscopy images indicated significant alteration in the cytoskeletal architecture of tREP-18-treated parasites. Also, tREP-18 seems to destabilize the mitochondrial membrane potential of parasites, disrupting their cellular integrity and leading to parasitic death. The cellular assays of the tREP-18 peptide on the BS12 strain, a clinical isolate of post-kala azar dermal leishmaniasis, demonstrated its significant efficacy at an IC50 value of 15 nM. The tREP-18 peptide showed a toxic effect on the amastigote stage of the parasite, showing macrophage pathogen clearance at a concentration of 22.5 nM. This study provides the proof of the concept of making a new class of functional peptides from tRNA sequences. It also opens a huge untapped tRNA-peptide space toward novel discoveries and applications. In the future, it would be interesting to perform tREP edits and redesign tREPs toward specific applications.
Transfer
RNAs (tRNAs) are small non-coding RNAs (76–90 nucleotides
in length) that ferry amino acids to the ribosomal interface for constructing
specific polypeptide chains.[1] To explain
their origin and evolution, models have been proposed to imply direct
duplication and evolution of RNA hairpin encoding genes[2] and co-evolution of primordial tRNA with their
association to translation machinery.[3]Furthermore, disrupted tRNA genes have been reported in the form
of intron-containing tRNA,[4] split tRNA,[5,6] and permuted tRNA in archaea.[7] The evolutionary
reasons behind these unexpected forms of tRNA gene sequences are unclear.[8] The asymmetric combinations of tRNA halves have
been postulated to generate tRNA diversity.[9] Recent evidence has shown that tRNA-derived small RNAs are generated
following cleavage at specific sites by distinct nucleases and have
multiple biological functions.[10] However,
no study has ever exploited the translation of tRNAs and/or the biological
significance of tRNA-derived peptides. To address these unsolved puzzles
and exploit their therapeutic implications, we decided to design novel
tRNA-based peptides and screen them against visceral leishmaniasis
and its convoluted form, post-kala-azar dermal leishmaniasis (PKDL).
Both of these disease manifestations are caused by the species of
the protozoan obligate parasite, genus Leishmania (Kinetoplastida,
Trypanosomatidae), which is usually anthroponotic in origin and transmitted
by the bite of female phlebotomine sand flies. Globally, an estimated
0·7–1 million newly reported cases of leishmaniasis emerge
every year from the 100 endemic countries. Thus, there is a requirement
to develop new potent antileishmanials that are less prone to resistance
development. Toward this, for the first time, we identified a novel
membrane binding peptide that was in silico translated from tRNA of
the Escherichia coli genome with superb
antiparasitic activities. This finding opened a new horizon for the
better acceptance of peptides as a drug modality against leishmaniasis.
To achieve this aim, the structure of hypothetical peptides was computationally
predicted, followed by (a) the chemical synthesis of lead peptides,
(b) experimental determination of their possible function(s), and
(c) evaluation of cellular footprints for their functional property.We have established a novel combinatorial approach involving in
silico analysis tools and synthetic biology applications to characterize
prokaryotic tRNA variants from the mg1655 strain of E. coli. Based on computational biology and structural
analyses, we finally synthesized tREP-18 as the lead
peptide following screening against an antiparasitic database. The
tREP-18 showed strong potency against the laboratory and clinical
strains of Leishmania donovani at 40
and 15 nM (≥IC50) concentrations, respectively, while mammalian
cells were found to be absolutely tolerant to the presence of tREP-18 in the mM range. Importantly, the tREP-18 peptide was efficient at reducing amastigote cell viability within
a macrophage at a minimal concentration of 22.5 nM. Precisely, the
peptide targeted both the stages of the parasite competently. This
work has provided novel insight into noncanonical applications of
prokaryotic tRNA and laid a sound foundation for future development
of tRNA-derived antileishmanial peptides.
Materials
and Methods
Bioinformatics-Based Novel Peptide Screening
We retrieved the tRNA gene sequences of E. coli strain K-12 sub-strain MG1655, from the genomic tRNA database that
contained tRNA genes. 87 tRNA gene sequences were retrieved and computationally
translated into protein sequences using the Transeq tool[11] of the European Bioinformatics Institute (https://www.ebi.ac.uk/Tools/st/emboss_transeq/). Each tRNA sequence was then translated into protein sequences
and the sequences with stop codons were removed. Furthermore, we computationally
modeled the three-dimensional (3D) structure of the peptide using
the Phyre server[12] (http://www.sbg.bio.ic.ac.uk/phyre2/). The modeled structures were energy minimized and validated using
GROMACS 5.1[13] (https://www.gromacs.org/) and
PROCHECK[14] (https://www.ebi.ac.uk/thornton-srv/software/PROCHECK/), respectively. To filter the most stable peptide, we subjected
the models to FOLDX-based stability analysis[15] (https://foldxsuite.crg.eu/). The stable peptides were screened against the antiparasite peptide
database[16] (http://crdd.osdd.net/raghava/parapep/). The peptides with high similarity in the database were considered
for experimental validation such as tREP-18. Based on the minimum E-value obtained, tREP-18 was further chosen for estimating
its binding efficacy with the lipid bilayer using the orientation
of proteins on membrane (OPM) server[17] (http://opm.phar.umich.edu)
that shows the spatial arrangements of peptides with respect to the
hydrocarbon core of the lipid bilayer. To design a negative control
for these two peptides, we have generated a scrambled peptide using
the Phypre server by changing aspartic acid and glutamic acid at the
7th and 20th positions to proline.
Parasite
Culturing and Treatment
The promastigote form of L. donovani (Ag83 strain) was cultured at 26 °C
in M199 media (GIBCO, India)
pH 7.4 supplemented with 10% (v/v) inactivated fetal bovine serum
(FBS) (GIBCO, India) and 0.02 mg/mL gentamycin (Life Technologies,
USA). L. donovani BS12 strain, a clinical
isolate of PKDL, was obtained as a kind gift from Dr. Mitali Chatterjee
(Institute of Post-Graduate Medical Education and Research and Seth
Sukhlal Karnani Memorial Hospital, Kolkata, India). These isolates
were routinely cultured at 22 °C in modified M199 medium (GIBCO,
India) with 100 U/mL penicillin–streptomycin (Gibco, Invitrogen,
Thermo Fisher Scientific, NY), 8 μM hemin (4 mM stock made in
50% triethanolamine) (Sigma, USA), and 25 mM N-[2-hydroxyethyl]piperazine-N0-[2-ethanesulfonic
acid] (Sigma), supplemented with 10% heat inactivated FBS.[18,19] The strain in cultures was maintained between 106 and
107 cells/mL for continuous exponential growth in the BSL2
laboratory facility. 1 × 106 cells/mL of parasite
count was constantly maintained for all the experiments. tREP-18 and scrambled peptides, respectively, were resuspended in dimethyl
sulphoxide (Sigma-Aldrich) for the preparation of a 1 M stock solution.
The working concentrations for tREP-18 were varied, ranging
from 1 to 40 nM. Following IC50 calculation, higher concentrations
of the peptide were chosen for performing all in vitro experiments
at different time intervals. Parasites without any inhibitor treatment
were maintained as negative controls.
Cellular
Viability of J774.A1 Cells
The J774.A1 murine macrophage
cell line was grown in Roswell Park
Memorial Institute (RPMI) 1640 medium in the presence of 10% (v/v)
FBS with 100 U/mL penicillin–100 μg/mL streptomycin (Gibco,
Invitrogen, Thermo Fisher Scientific, NY) at 37 °C (humidified)
and 5% CO2. The cells were seeded in 96-well plates at
a seeding density of 30 000 cells/well and allowed to adhere
overnight at 37 °C. Adhered cells were treated with tREP-18 and scrambled peptides in a dose-dependent manner for 24 h. Control
was maintained without the addition of any peptide. Cytotoxic effects
were assessed using the 3-[4,5- dimethylthiazol-2-yl]-2,5-diphenyl
tetrazolium bromide (MTT) assay kit (Sigma-Aldrich). The conversion
of MTT to formazan crystals by viable cells was measured at 595 nm.
The J774.A1 murine macrophage cell line was a kind gift from Prof.
Rentala Madhubala’s laboratory at the School of Life Sciences,
JNU, New Delhi.
Cytotoxicity Assay by LDH
The lactate
dehydrogenase (LDH) cytotoxic assay was performed as per standard
protocol (CytoTox 96 Non-Radioactive Cytotoxicity Assay-Promega, USA).
Initially, promastigotes of the Ag83 strain and the BS12 strain of
PKDL were suspended into a 96-well microtiter plate (100 μL
well volume). For calculating IC50, parasite samples in triplicates
were exposed to various concentrations (1–100 nM) of both tREP-18 peptides at 26 °C for 24 h. Colorimetric quantification
of toxicity toward promastigotes upon treatment with various concentrations
of the peptides was carried out using the LDH assay. Further percentage
growth inhibition was calculated using the formulaAs per the formula, the spontaneous
LDH activity = activity of the untreated cells, and the maximum LDH
activity = activity of the amphotericin B-treated cells. These values
were transferred to the GraphPad Prism version 8.0.1, and the IC50
value for tREP-18 was generated for the Ag83 and PKDL strains of L. donovani using a sigmoidal dose–response
model with the nonlinear regression tool. The time-dependent cytotoxicity
of tREP-18 was also examined with log phase promastigotes (1 ×
106/mL) of the Ag83 strain and the BS12 strain of PKDL,
respectively. The parasite samples in triplicates were exposed to
various concentrations (1–40 nM) of tREP-18 and incubated at
26 °C for 24, 48, and 72 h, respectively. Amphotericin B (3 μg/mL)
(Sigma-Aldrich)-treated parasites were used as the positive control
in in vitro assays. Finally, the percentage cytotoxicity of tREP-18 was calculated by normalizing with an amphotericin
B treatment that rendered 100% cytotoxicity. Promastigotes were also
treated with scrambled peptides and their cytotoxicity on parasites
was evaluated for 24, 48, and 72 h, respectively, by the LDH assay
as described in the previous experiment. The untreated log phase of
promastigotes (1 × 106/mL) was maintained as negative
controls.
Apoptotic Assay
L.
donovani Ag83 promastigotes undergoing apoptosis in
both treated and untreated samples were measured by propidium iodide
(PI) staining. After exposure to the peptide for a period of 72 h,
cells were harvested, phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) washed and stained
with PI (5 μg/mL) (Life Technologies, USA). This was followed
by an incubation period of 20 min at 37 °C. Subsequently, cells
were washed for excessive stain removal and resuspended in 250 μL
of PBS. Cells were further analyzed through BD FACS Diva and visualized
using a fluorescence microscope with a 510–560 nm filter block
for the detection of PI red fluorescence.
Morphological
Study of Promastigotes by Scanning
Electron Microscopy
A morphological study of tREP-18-treated promastigotes was examined by scanning electron microscopy
(SEM). Sample preparation for SEM was carried out with slight modification
in the protocol.[20] Cells were incubated
with 40 nM of tREP-18 for 72 h at 26 °C. These promastigotes
were then harvested at 1100 g for 15 min at room temperature (RT),
followed by the addition of fresh media. EM-grade glutaraldehyde was
directly added to the cells containing M199 media to a final concentration
of 2.5% glutaraldehyde (from a 25% stock of EM-grade glutaraldehyde).
The cells were centrifuged for 10 min at 800g and
the media was removed. Promastigotes were then resuspended in 0.1
M phosphate buffer (pH 7.2) and washed twice. These promastigotes
were further fixed with 2.5% (v/v) glutaraldehyde in the same buffer
for 120 min. Glass coverslips were cleaned with ethanol followed by
immersion in a 0.1% (w/v) solution of poly-l-lysine (sigma)
in water. Coverslips were then rinsed in water and left to air-dry
in the laminar hood. A 200 μL of cell suspension was added to
each coverslip, ensuring the coverslip was completely covered by the
cell suspension. Next, these coverslips were placed in individual
wells of a 12-well tissue culture plate. This plate was left for 10
min at RT for the cells to settle down and adhere to the coverslips.
The adherence was checked using a Nikon inverted microscope (Eclipse
Ts2-FL, USA). Samples were then post fixated in 1% osmium tetroxide
for 1 h and dehydrated by gradient acetone concentration (50–100%)
for 20 min each. Thereafter, samples were treated with 100% hexamethyldisilane
at RT for 5 min and mounted on aluminum stubs with adhesive carbon
tape. Prior to SEM application, a thin gold layer was coated by means
of a sputter coater (SC7640, Polaron Equipment, England, U.K). The
samples were observed under an environmental, variable pressure scanning
electron microscope (Carl Zeiss EV0-40, Cambridge, U.K.) at a voltage
of 20 kV and a working distance of 10 mm.
Study
of Surface Topology of tREP-18-Treated L. donovani Promastigotes Using Atomic Force Microscopy
Sample preparation
for the atomic force microscopy (AFM) analysis
was carried out as per the standard protocol.[21] Cells were incubated with 40 nM of the peptide for 72 h at 26 °C.
These promastigotes were then harvested by centrifugation at 1100g for 15 min at RT, washed with 0.1 M phosphate buffer (pH
7.2), and fixed with 2.5% (v/v) glutaraldehyde in the 0.1 M phosphate
buffer for 1 h. Cells were washed using the phosphate buffer and overlaid
onto poly-l-ornithine (Sigma)-coated microslides having a
dimension of 10 mm × 10 mm. Samples were then washed twice in
molecular biology grade water (Sigma) and dried in laminar hood airflow.
Scanning of promastigote cells was carried out using a TT-AFM atomic
force microscope. A 50 μm scanner was used, and the instrument
operation was performed in the tapping and noncontact mode. Image
details were calculated using XEI software in first-order flattened
20 × 20 μm2 areas in the center of the cell
body.
Quantification of Mitochondrial Membrane Potential
Mitochondrial membrane (Δψm) potential was assessed
using flow cytometry and fluorescence microscopy-based analyses with
5,6-dichloro-2-[3-(5,6-dichloro-1,3-diethyl-1,3-dihydro-2H-benzimidazol-2-ylidene)-1propenyl]-1,3-diethyl-iodide (JC-1) (Life
Technologies, USA) as a probe. The range of concentration from 4 to
40 nM of the peptide was used for treatment. Treated and untreated
groups were incubated for a period of 24 h. Parasites were washed
with PBS, the JC-1 probe was added to a 6 μM final concentration,
and samples were analyzed using BD FACS Diva. The labeled cells were
also allowed to adhere to the glass slides for visualization under
the Nikon Ti-DH eclipse fluorescence microscope (USA). The approximate
fluorescence excitation/emission maxima of 514/529 nm for the monomeric
form and 585/590 nm for the J-aggregate form were used.
Promastigote Proliferation Assay
Cell growth and multiplication
were assessed by flow cytometry and
fluorescence microscopy with 6-carboxyfluorescein diacetate succinimidyl
ester (CFDA-SE, Life Technologies, USA) as a probe. Ag83 parasites
were washed thrice with 0.1 M PBS. The cells were labeled with 2.8
μg/mL CFDA-SE dye and incubated at 37 °C for 10 min with
3 to 4 times of intermittent mixing. Following this, cells were resuspended
in ice-cold M199 medium and later centrifuged at 1200g for 10 mins (4 °C). The pellet was then suspended
in fresh medium. Cells were treated with the peptide at different
concentrations and were analyzed using a flow cytometer (BD FACS DIVA)
for three consecutive replicates at 24 and 48 h. The labeled cells
were also allowed to adhere to glass slides for visualization under
the Nikon TI-DH eclipse fluorescence microscope (USA). Fluorescence
intensity was determined using an excitation filter at 485 nm and
an emission filter at 535 nm. The number of parasites was also determined
by staining with trypan blue every 24 h for a period of 72 h. Quantification
of the viable parasites was determined by counting the parasites with
the clear cytoplasm (non-stained) using a Neubauer hemocytometer with
a coverslip. Three independent experiments were performed, and the
data were expressed as the mean ± standard deviation (SD).
Effect of tREP-18 Peptide Against Intracellular
Amastigotes
The J774.A1 murine macrophage cell line was plated
at a cell density of 5 × 105 cell well–1 in a six-well flat bottom plate. For infection, late-stage L. donovani rich in metacyclic promastigotes was
added at a ratio of 10:1 along with the peptide of interest. After
12 h, uninfected promastigotes were washed off with PBS. Infected
macrophages were treated with the tREP-18 peptide at nearly an IC50
concentration and incubated for 72 h. Amphotericin B was taken as
a positive control. After incubation, visualization and counting of
intracellular parasite load were performed using Giemsa staining (Sigma-Aldrich).
Statistical Analysis
Student’s
t-test was applied to evaluate significant differences between treatment
and control samples in all the experiments performed using the analysis
of variance (ANOVA) test. The P-value < 0.05 and p-value < 0.01 were considered to be significant (indicated
as * and **, respectively). Results represent the mean ± SD of
a minimum of three independent experiments. The calculated IC50 value and all the statistical analyses were performed using
GraphPad Prism version 8.01.
Results
In Silico Retrieval, Translation of tREPs
from E. coli Genome, and Evaluation
of the Cytotoxic Effect of Lead tREP
A total of 87 tRNAs
from the E. coli tRNA database were
retrieved and computationally translated into corresponding amino
acid equivalents. Of these, 60 translated sequences showed one or
more stop codons and were discarded [Table S1]. The remaining 29 full-length peptides were then finalized into
two peptides, namely tREP-18 and tREP-22, based on in silico analyses.
The selection was based on their total energy with a minimum E-value
[Figure a], length
of sequence, and structural resemblance with the peptides in the antiparasitic
database [Figure b].
The total energy was calculated using the FoldX tool, which uses the
3D structure of the peptide and provides quantitative estimation of
the importance of the interactions contributing to the stability of
the peptide, and the E-value was obtained from the similarity search
against the antiparasitic database. As a negative control, a scrambled
form of tREP-18 was computationally designed, synthesized, and experimentally
tested [Figure c].
The binding efficiency of tREP-18 with the membrane of promastigotes
was computationally predicted to be relatively high (delta G energy
score = −3.5 kcal/Mol, using the virtual membrane depth of
4.2 Å). The delta G energy is provided by the OPM server, which
is calculated as a sum of two terms: (i) a solvent accessible surface
area-dependent term that accounts for van der waals, H-bonding, and
entropy of solvent molecules; and (ii) an electrostatic term that
includes solvation energy of dipoles and ions, and the deionization
penalty of ionizable groups in a nonpolar environment. A total of
four residues were predicted to be involved in the binding, constituting
alanine 1,4 (A), serine 2 (S), and valine 3 (V) [Figure d]. To evaluate the cytotoxic
effects of tREP-18 on L. donovani Ag83
promastigotes, the standard LDH assay[22] was performed. The IC50 value of tREP-18 was found
to be 22.13 nM (Figure e). The CC50 evaluation of the peptide in J774.A1 cells was detected
to be 275 μM [Table S2]. The concentration-dependent
response of parasites to the tREP-18 peptide showed percent inhibition
up to 66.21% at 40 nM concentration at 24 h, whereas the scrambled
peptide demonstrated 22.37% at the same concentration [Figure e]. Promastigotes treated with
amphotericin B, which was taken as a positive control, showed ∼95%
growth inhibition. For calculating the IC50 value, a 1–100
nM range of concentration was taken into consideration. Thus, tREP-18
was found to have a potent antileishmanial effect.
Figure 1
Structural
stability analysis of t-RNA peptides along with in silico
screening against the antiparasite peptide database and their inhibitory
effect on promastigotes. (a) Graphical representation total free energy
values of t-RNA peptides depicted stability of their high-resolution
3D structures; (b) table represented filtered sequence similarity
profiles of tRNA peptides based on screening against the antiparasitic
peptide database; (c) representative 3D structures of
tREP-18 and the scrambled peptide revealed the presence of an α-helix
and a turn in tREP-18 while the scrambled peptide showed random coiling;
(d) membrane binding affinity of the tREP-18 peptide was found to
be in a moderate range, given the minimum depth/hydrophobic thicknesss
is 1 Å; (e) percentage inhibition of promastigotes treated with
the tREP-18 peptide was evaluated at 24 h using the LDH assay and
plotted as a sigmoidal curve. Data normalization was performed by
taking into consideration the cytotoxicity induced by the positive
control (amphotericin B-3 μg/mL) as 100%. IC50 values for promastigotes
of the Ag83 strain were analyzed using GraphPad Prism, represented
as the mean ± SD where n = 3, independent experiments.
Structural
stability analysis of t-RNA peptides along with in silico
screening against the antiparasite peptide database and their inhibitory
effect on promastigotes. (a) Graphical representation total free energy
values of t-RNA peptides depicted stability of their high-resolution
3D structures; (b) table represented filtered sequence similarity
profiles of tRNA peptides based on screening against the antiparasitic
peptide database; (c) representative 3D structures of
tREP-18 and the scrambled peptide revealed the presence of an α-helix
and a turn in tREP-18 while the scrambled peptide showed random coiling;
(d) membrane binding affinity of the tREP-18 peptide was found to
be in a moderate range, given the minimum depth/hydrophobic thicknesss
is 1 Å; (e) percentage inhibition of promastigotes treated with
the tREP-18 peptide was evaluated at 24 h using the LDH assay and
plotted as a sigmoidal curve. Data normalization was performed by
taking into consideration the cytotoxicity induced by the positive
control (amphotericin B-3 μg/mL) as 100%. IC50 values for promastigotes
of the Ag83 strain were analyzed using GraphPad Prism, represented
as the mean ± SD where n = 3, independent experiments.
tREP-18 Treatment Imposes
Severe Depletion
in Parasite Metabolic Viability Both in Time- and Dose-Dependent Manner
A dose- and time-dependent release of LDH was observed when promastigote
cells were treated with tREP-18. The maximum LDH release
was observed at 72 h in amphotericin B treated promastigotes (Avg.
O.D. 0.946), representing 100% cytotoxicity [Figure a(i)]. tREP-18 was able to induce
the highest level of cytotoxicity (up to 92.83%) at 40 nM at 72 h
vis-à-vis LDH release at 48 and 24 h, which showed 70.27 and
66.21%, respectively, while the scrambled peptide-treated samples
showed 24.41% cytotoxicity at 72 h [Figure a(ii)]. Furthermore, to explore the mechanistic
reasons for the increment of LDH levels that correlate with tREP-18-induced
parasite growth inhibition, estimation of parasitic cell death was
performed using the standard PI-based assay (Riccardi and Nicoletti,
2006). The highest percentage of PI positivity could be obtained at
72 h (95.5%) following treatment with 40 nM of tREP-18 concentration,
similar to the level of cytotoxicity induced by amphotericin B treatment
in promastigotes (positive control), which showed 97.6% of PIPOS cells (Figure b). The results indicated a persistent reduction in parasite
growth along with enhanced cell death as represented by the PI positivity
against tREP-18 treatment.
Figure 2
Elucidation of tREP-18 on the metabolic cell
viability of promastigotes,
[a(i)] Bar graph represented LDH release by tREP-18-treated promastigotes
in the dose- and time-dependent manner, with a maximum effect at 40
nM for 72 h; [a(ii)] treatment of scrambled peptides in promastigotes
demonstrated non-cytototxic effects at 72 h; [b(i)] flow cytometry
histograms demonstrated the significant death of parasites at 72 h
following peptide treatment (Pro refers to promastigotes); [b(ii)]
tREP-18 treatment at 40 nM of concentration showed 95.5% of PI positivity
in promastigotes at 72 h; the graph represents the mean ± SD
of minimum n = 3 independent experiments performed
using ANOVA test for all the assays, *p-value <
0.05 was considered significant.
Elucidation of tREP-18 on the metabolic cell
viability of promastigotes,
[a(i)] Bar graph represented LDH release by tREP-18-treated promastigotes
in the dose- and time-dependent manner, with a maximum effect at 40
nM for 72 h; [a(ii)] treatment of scrambled peptides in promastigotes
demonstrated non-cytototxic effects at 72 h; [b(i)] flow cytometry
histograms demonstrated the significant death of parasites at 72 h
following peptide treatment (Pro refers to promastigotes); [b(ii)]
tREP-18 treatment at 40 nM of concentration showed 95.5% of PI positivity
in promastigotes at 72 h; the graph represents the mean ± SD
of minimum n = 3 independent experiments performed
using ANOVA test for all the assays, *p-value <
0.05 was considered significant.
tREP-18 Enforces Strong Antiproliferative
Effect in L. donovani Promastigotes
To further understand the impact of tREP-18 peptide treatment on
cellular phenotype promastigotes, we studied promastigote proliferation
using live staining with CFDA-SE (a strong membrane permeant dye)
[Figure a(i,ii)].
The CFDA-SE dye, upon cleavage by esterases within the cell, generates
reactive amine products that covalently bond with intracellular lysine
to generate fluorescence. Based on this assay, it was inferred that
tREP-18 could strongly attenuate the cell division/progression of
promastigotes, while the scrambled peptide conferred hardly any impact.
This finding was also supported by trypan blue exclusion assay-based
determination of growth kinetics in tREP-18-treated parasites that
showed significant enhancement in cell death [Figure b].
Figure 3
Effect of tREP-18 on the proliferation of promastigotes.
[a(i)]
Rate of proliferation was determined by the change in CFDA-SE-stained
promastigotes as represented by flow cytometry histograms, depicting
huge cellular multiplication arrest upon treatment with the 40 nM
peptide at 24 and 48 h, respectively, Pro refers to untreated promastigotes;
[a(ii)] nominal decrement observed in percentage of CFDA-SE positive
promastigotes when treated by higher concentration of the tREP-18
peptide for 24 and 48 h; (b) increment in the number of trypan blue-stained
parasites was evident following tREP-18 treatment in a dose-dependent
manner; n = 3, *p-value < 0.05
was considered significant.
Effect of tREP-18 on the proliferation of promastigotes.
[a(i)]
Rate of proliferation was determined by the change in CFDA-SE-stained
promastigotes as represented by flow cytometry histograms, depicting
huge cellular multiplication arrest upon treatment with the 40 nM
peptide at 24 and 48 h, respectively, Pro refers to untreated promastigotes;
[a(ii)] nominal decrement observed in percentage of CFDA-SE positive
promastigotes when treated by higher concentration of the tREP-18
peptide for 24 and 48 h; (b) increment in the number of trypan blue-stained
parasites was evident following tREP-18 treatment in a dose-dependent
manner; n = 3, *p-value < 0.05
was considered significant.
tREP-18 Treatment Causes Severe Membrane Distortion
in Parasites
After establishing the cytotoxic
effect of tREP-18 on Leishmania promastigotes, the detailed
morphometric analysis of treated parasites was studied using SEM and
AFM. At a 40 nM concentration of tREP-18, the swelling
and rupture of promastigote membranes were observed compared to untreated
parasites in SEM [Figure a]. Furthermore, AFM analysis unraveled profound alterations
in membrane topology, including perturbed membrane architecture, constricted
cellular structures, and shortened flagella, as denoted by substantial
changes in the width (W) to height (H) ratio, from 0.1158 to 0.393 following treatment [Figure b]. Although the untreated
promastigotes showed normal elongated spindle-shape parasites with
an anterior and long flagellum. Additional surface topological analysis
revealed a significant change of the RMS roughness value (Rq) of 4.083 in the treated promastigotes as
compared to a 1.323 value, indicating distorted membrane cytoskeleton.
Figure 4
Surface
topology and morphometric analysis of L.
donovani promastigotes treated with tREP18. (a) Surface
scanned micrographs of promastigotes in SEM at 1.5KX and 20.00KX magnifications
demonstrated intact promastigotes in healthy control with constricted
and disordered cellular architecture obtained in tREP-18-treated promastigotes;
(b) AFM micrographs indicated severe topological alteration of the
surface of tREP-18-treated promastigotes as compared to untreated
promastigotes. The peptide treatment at 30 and 40 nM has drastically
impaired the width (W) to height (H) ratio in treated parasites.
Surface
topology and morphometric analysis of L.
donovani promastigotes treated with tREP18. (a) Surface
scanned micrographs of promastigotes in SEM at 1.5KX and 20.00KX magnifications
demonstrated intact promastigotes in healthy control with constricted
and disordered cellular architecture obtained in tREP-18-treated promastigotes;
(b) AFM micrographs indicated severe topological alteration of the
surface of tREP-18-treated promastigotes as compared to untreated
promastigotes. The peptide treatment at 30 and 40 nM has drastically
impaired the width (W) to height (H) ratio in treated parasites.
tREP-18 Caused Disruption of the Mitochondrial
Membrane and Destabilization of Redox Potential in L. donovani
Finally, to study the effect
of tREP-18 on the mitochondrial membrane potential (ΔΨm)
of promastigotes, we have used a lipophilic, cationic dye (JC-1) exhibiting
green fluorescence that enters the mitochondria and gets accumulated
into a reversible complex oligomeric form, known as J aggregates emitting
red fluorescence. This formation of J aggregates from its monomeric
form depicts a healthy (ΔΨm) in parasites. Thus, to explore
if tREP-18 has any impact on ΔΨm of promastigotes,
we have evaluated the change in fluorescence intensities using flow
cytometry-based analysis and confocal imaging. In healthy untreated
promastigotes, a PE/FITC ratio corresponding to a higher red to green
ratio (0.87) was observed, representing hyperpolarised mitochondrion,
suggesting a stable ΔΨm [Figure a(i)]. However, in the case of tREP-18-treated promastigotes, a drastic reduction in ΔΨm correlated
with an increasing concentration of the peptide that could be matched
with the amphotericin B treatment [Figure a(ii)]. The fluorescence signals were also
evaluated using confocal microscopy. The confocal images represented
enhanced levels of red fluorescence, which denotes more J aggregate
formation due to higher ΔΨm, whereas shifting toward lower
red or accumulation of higher green fluorescence implies a strong
indication of destabilized ΔΨm. Notably, the mitochondrial
uptake of JC-1 dye was found to decrease with tREP-18 treatment as compared to healthy promastigotes, which was then manifested
as stronger green fluorescence due to monomeric JC-1 formation. Intense
red fluorescence was observed in control groups, suggesting JC-1 aggregation
due to stable ΔΨm, whereas green fluorescence was detected
in treated samples [Figure b]. Based on this observation, it was inferred that tREP-18 treatment leads to the disruption of the mitochondrial
membrane structure. Because PKDL can be life-threatening with the
manifestation of disfiguring lesions leading to visceralization of
organs,[23] we then evaluated the impact
of both tREP-18 and its scrambled form as a negative
control, on the clinical isolate of the PKDL strain, BS12 of Leishmaniaspp. The tREP-18 peptide demonstrated its potent antileishmanial efficacy as shown
by its IC50 value (15 nM) in the PKDL strain [Figure c]. Based on the LDH assay results, the tREP-18 treatment showed optimal toxicity at 1 nM with 34%
cell death and maximum toxicity at 40 nM with 98% of death in PKDL
promastigotes, comparable to the cytotoxic effect imposed by amphotericin
B treatment [Figure d]. Whereas the scrambled peptide hardly showed any toxic effect
for a period of 72 h. This data strongly suggests that tREP-18 may adversely affect the metabolic cell viability of the BS12 strain
of PKDL.
Figure 5
Effect of tREP-18 treatment on ΔΨm of Ag83 promastigotes
and cytotoxic effect of tREP-18 on the PKDL strain. [a(i,ii)] Effect
of the concentration-dependent treatment of tREP-18 on ΔΨm
of Ag83 promastigotes indicated by the conversion in monomer to oligomer
forms of JC-1 using flow cytometry histograms and confocal micrographs.
The shift in intensity of red fluorescence (JC1 aggregates/PE) to
green fluorescence (JC1 monomers/FITC) implies ΔΨm in
promastigotes following tREP-18 treatment. The bar graphs denote the
change in PE/FITC ratio corresponding to tREP-18-induced alterations
in JC1 aggregate/monomer formation in promastigotes. The higher ratio
refers to a healthy mitochondrial membrane and the lower ratio denotes
destabilized membrane potential; (b) confocal micrographs depicted
intense red fluorescence in control groups, whereas green fluorescence
was observed in samples treated with peptides; (c) percentage inhibition
was evaluated using the LDH assay for 24 h of tREP-18 treatment and
IC50 was calculated using GraphPad prism; (d) cytotoxic effects of
both tREP-18 and scrambled peptides on clinical PKDL isolate BS12
were determined, respectively, for 72 h; where n =
3, p-value < 0.05 indicated as * for all the experiments
performed.
Effect of tREP-18 treatment on ΔΨm of Ag83 promastigotes
and cytotoxic effect of tREP-18 on the PKDL strain. [a(i,ii)] Effect
of the concentration-dependent treatment of tREP-18 on ΔΨm
of Ag83 promastigotes indicated by the conversion in monomer to oligomer
forms of JC-1 using flow cytometry histograms and confocal micrographs.
The shift in intensity of red fluorescence (JC1 aggregates/PE) to
green fluorescence (JC1 monomers/FITC) implies ΔΨm in
promastigotes following tREP-18 treatment. The bar graphs denote the
change in PE/FITC ratio corresponding to tREP-18-induced alterations
in JC1 aggregate/monomer formation in promastigotes. The higher ratio
refers to a healthy mitochondrial membrane and the lower ratio denotes
destabilized membrane potential; (b) confocal micrographs depicted
intense red fluorescence in control groups, whereas green fluorescence
was observed in samples treated with peptides; (c) percentage inhibition
was evaluated using the LDH assay for 24 h of tREP-18 treatment and
IC50 was calculated using GraphPad prism; (d) cytotoxic effects of
both tREP-18 and scrambled peptides on clinical PKDL isolate BS12
were determined, respectively, for 72 h; where n =
3, p-value < 0.05 indicated as * for all the experiments
performed.
tREP-18-Treated L. donovani Demonstrated Significant Reduction in
the Amastigote Model of Macrophage
Infection
We further evaluated the cytotoxic effects of the
peptide on infective intracellular amastigotes [Figure a(i)]. The number of amastigotes per infected
macrophage was found to be predominantly reduced in tREP-18-treated samples (∼1 amastigotes/macrophages), whereas control
untreated macrophages had ∼4 number of amastigotes/macrophages
[Figure a(ii)]. The
percentage of macrophages infected is also less following tREP-18 treatment as compared to untreated control [Figure a(iii)]. The results clearly demonstrated tREP-18 treatment has a pronounced effect on intracellular
amastigotes in an exceptionally low micromolar range, suggesting its
potential antileishmanial activity in both stages.
Figure 6
Leishmanicidal
activity of tREP-18 against intramacrophage amastigotes.
(a) Geimsa-stained images represented impact of tREP-18 treatment
on mouse macrophages infected with L. donovani amastigotes; [a(ii)] bar graph represents the number of amastigotes
per macrophage in both untreated and treated cells that were counted
at a single cell level, where n = 20 distinct cells;
[a)iii)] bar graph illustrates the percentage of infected macrophages
for untreated and treated counterparts per six-well plates.
Leishmanicidal
activity of tREP-18 against intramacrophage amastigotes.
(a) Geimsa-stained images represented impact of tREP-18 treatment
on mouse macrophages infected with L. donovani amastigotes; [a(ii)] bar graph represents the number of amastigotes
per macrophage in both untreated and treated cells that were counted
at a single cell level, where n = 20 distinct cells;
[a)iii)] bar graph illustrates the percentage of infected macrophages
for untreated and treated counterparts per six-well plates.
Discussion
tRNAs
are ancient molecular elements that predate full-fledged
translational machinery. Although their primary evolutionary role
has been to ferry amino acids to the ribosomal surface, some studies
suggest that tRNAs may be recruited by some viruses for insertion
and replicating purposes.[24] tRNA molecules
have a monophyletic origin, with modern molecules derived from the
universal translator. It is quite likely that cells may use the structural
and functional flexibility of tRNAs to handle responsibilities that
are beyond their traditional job descriptions. Taking into consideration
this innate potential, here we provide the proof-of-the-concept of
functional tRNA peptides as first-in-the-class molecules.A
total of 87 tRNA gene sequences from the E. coli genome (MG1655) were computationally translated into corresponding
peptide sequence equivalents. All the hypothetical peptides were passed
through a series of bioinformatics-based filters. A total of 29 stable
peptides were generated from full-length translates for deeper in
silico study. Out of 29 full-length peptides, tREP-18 was selected
for experimental validation based on total energy and E-value (1.9) against an antiparasitic database [Table S1 and Figure a,b].Suitable cell survival assays were designed to
validate the predicted
antiparasitic property of tREP-18. The tREP-18 was also tested against several cancer cell lines and microbes but
did not show any growth-influencing property. Interestingly, the IC50
value for tREP-18 on Leishmania promastigotes was found to be 22.13 nM [Figure e]. The assessment of the CC50 value for tREP-18-treated J774.A1 cells was found to be 275 μM
suggesting its nontoxic impact on the host macrophages [Table S2]. The in silico membrane binding studies
revealed a relatively higher delta G energy score
of −3.5 kcal/Mol for tREP-18, suggesting its probable
interaction with parasite membrane proteins [Figure d], leading to an experimentally determined
IC50 value [Figure e]. The significant tREP-18 IC50 and CC50 values encouraged further
in vitro validation.The LDH assay-based evaluation of tREP-18-induced
cytotoxicity in promastigotes demonstrated a linear dose- and time-dependent
correlation. This assay involved a cell death enzymatic marker that
showed the maximal growth inhibitory impact of tREP-18 at 40 nM, which drastically impairs the metabolic viability of promastigotes.
This effect was found to closely match the effect of amphotericin
B on growth of parasites at 72 h, whereas the scrambled peptide represented
minimal cytoxicity for the same dose and time period [Figure ].Next, we asked if tREP-18 treatment has any impact
on the cellular proliferation of L. donovani promastigotes. To answer this, we performed a cell-based assay using
CFDA-SE, a cell membrane permeable dye. The results demonstrated that tREP-18 could significantly reduce the promastigote proliferation
[Figure a(i,ii)].
These data were also strongly corroborated by the results obtained
from a growth kinetic assay that showed a significant depletion in
the number of promastigotes, suggesting enhanced cell death [Figure b].Based on
these readouts, we examined if tREP-18 would trigger any
morphological changes in the membrane architecture of parasites. To
answer this, we performed SEM- and AFM-based analysis of tREP-18-treated
promastigotes. The high-resolution microscopic images show ultrastructural
changes in the membranes of treated parasites, significant alteration
in promastigotes morphology with visible loss in intercellular networking
and ruptured cytoskeletal architecture [Figure a,b]. Collectively, observations indicate
that tREP-18 destabilized the cellular topology, causing
intrusion in parent cell division and leading to growth arrest, which
later induced parasite death.To decipher the effect of tREP-18 on mitochondrial
membrane potential (ΔΨm), an initial cellular event that
has been reported as a marker of cell death in leishmania sp.,[25] we used a lipophilic cationic dye JC1 to understand
ΔΨm in treated parasites. In healthy cells, JC1 monomers
can cross the mitochondrial membrane and get converted into a reversible
oligomeric form of J aggregates that emit red fluorescence. This phenomenon
was significantly affected in parasites treated at 40 nM tREP-18 due to disrupted ΔΨm. Thus, we assume that tREP-18-induced membrane destabilization is precedent to the impaired ΔΨm.
The disruption of ΔΨm has been reported to generate reactive
oxygen species, a direct hallmark of apoptosis [Figure a(i,ii),b, Table S3]. This finding was strongly corroborated by PI positive promastigotes
as shown previously [Figure b(i,ii)].We then asked whether tREP-18 could show similar effects
in the clinical form of L. donovani involved in PKDL manifestation. To resolve this query, we used the
BS12 strain (clinical isolate of PKDL) for investigating the antileishmanial
potential of the peptide using the LDH assay. As assumed, tREP-18 demonstrated significant growth inhibition in BS12 at a much lower
concentration of 18 nM ≥ IC50 [Figure c,d].It is noteworthy that studies
involved in the discovery of antileishmanial
peptides have majorly focused on evaluating their activities against
the promastigotes form of the parasite. However, recent advancements
involving certain membrane-targeting antimicrobial peptides have been
found to be effective for both promastigote and amastigote forms of
parasite.[26] The efficacy of the tREP-18 peptide on the L. donovani amastigotes
was studied following treatment with tREP-18 at 22.5
nM of concentration (∼IC50 value). A pronounced decrement in
intracellular amastigotes was observed, suggesting high activity of
the peptide against promastigote and amastigote forms [Figure ]. Our results indicated tREP-18 as a promising candidate for the development of anti-infective
therapeutics targeting Leishmania. The details of the strategy have
been explained in the working model [Figure ].
Figure 7
Working model for discovery and translational
application of tREP-18.
Working model for discovery and translational
application of tREP-18.In summary, to our best knowledge, this is the first report that
demonstrates the emergence of a new class of functional molecules,
that is, tRNA-encoded peptides (tREPs). In the future, it would be
interesting to redesign tREPs from various organisms, build a library
of tREPs, and study the structure and function relationship of tREPs.
Overall, this work has laid a foundation for a new class of molecules
and opened a new evolutionary window to explore deeper aspects of
tREPs.
Authors: David Van Der Spoel; Erik Lindahl; Berk Hess; Gerrit Groenhof; Alan E Mark; Herman J C Berendsen Journal: J Comput Chem Date: 2005-12 Impact factor: 3.376
Authors: Sara Khalili; Mehdi Mohebali; Elaheh Ebrahimzadeh; Ebrahimzadeh Shayan; Samira Mohammadi-Yeganeh; Mehrdad Moosazadeh Moghaddam; Samira Elikaee; Behnaz Akhoundi; Mohammad Kazem Sharifi-Yazdi Journal: Vet Res Forum Date: 2018-12-15 Impact factor: 1.054
Authors: Fábio Madeira; Young Mi Park; Joon Lee; Nicola Buso; Tamer Gur; Nandana Madhusoodanan; Prasad Basutkar; Adrian R N Tivey; Simon C Potter; Robert D Finn; Rodrigo Lopez Journal: Nucleic Acids Res Date: 2019-07-02 Impact factor: 16.971
Authors: Lawrence A Kelley; Stefans Mezulis; Christopher M Yates; Mark N Wass; Michael J E Sternberg Journal: Nat Protoc Date: 2015-05-07 Impact factor: 13.491