Vladimir Girik1, Suihan Feng1,2, Hanaa Hariri3, W Mike Henne3, Howard Riezman1. 1. Department of Biochemistry, University of Geneva, Geneva 1205, Switzerland. 2. National Centre of Competence in Research (NCCR) in Chemical Biology, University of Geneva, Geneva 1205, Switzerland. 3. Department of Cell Biology, UT Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, Texas 75390-9039 United States.
Abstract
Lipid metabolism is spatiotemporally regulated within cells, yet intervention into lipid functions at subcellular resolution remains difficult. Here, we report a method that enables site-specific release of sphingolipids and cholesterol inside the vacuole in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Using this approach, we monitored real-time sphingolipid metabolic flux out of the vacuole by mass spectrometry and found that the endoplasmic reticulum-vacuole-tethering protein Mdm1 facilitated the metabolism of sphingoid bases into ceramides. In addition, we showed that cholesterol, once delivered into yeast using our method, could restore cell proliferation induced by ergosterol deprivation, overcoming the previously described sterol-uptake barrier under aerobic conditions. Together, these data define a new way to study intracellular lipid metabolism and transport from the vacuole in yeast.
Lipid metabolism is spatiotemporally regulated within cells, yet intervention into lipid functions at subcellular resolution remains difficult. Here, we report a method that enables site-specific release of sphingolipids and cholesterol inside the vacuole in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Using this approach, we monitored real-time sphingolipid metabolic flux out of the vacuole by mass spectrometry and found that the endoplasmic reticulum-vacuole-tethering protein Mdm1 facilitated the metabolism of sphingoid bases into ceramides. In addition, we showed that cholesterol, once delivered into yeast using our method, could restore cell proliferation induced by ergosterol deprivation, overcoming the previously described sterol-uptake barrier under aerobic conditions. Together, these data define a new way to study intracellular lipid metabolism and transport from the vacuole in yeast.
Lipids
are heterogeneously distributed in eukaryotic cells with
their composition varying among the specific subcellular compartments.[1] This heterogeneity is achieved even though most
lipid species are first synthesized in one organelle and transported
to other organelles for use or further modification. Although most
enzymes responsible for lipid metabolism have been identified, how
lipids are transported within cells is much less known, and many lipid
transportation routes are still waiting to be established. Importantly,
new methods are needed to be able to quantify the flux of lipids between
intracellular compartments.In recent years, a number of lipid
transfer proteins (LTPs) have
been found to facilitate non-vesicular lipid transport through contact
sites between organelles.[2] In many cases,
structural information and in vitro lipid transfer assays need to
be established to validate the roles of LTPs in lipid transport. This
can be a challenging task because many LTPs are transmembrane proteins
and lack detailed structural information. Mass spectrometry (MS)-based
lipidomics techniques can contribute to our understanding of transport
by providing quantitative analysis of many chemically diverse lipid
species. Designed to carry out lipidome-wide scans, it has been particularly
useful when combined with genetic perturbation in yeast or mammalian
cells.[3−6] Nevertheless, the results of gene deletion do not always translate
into lipid profile changes. For example, simply removing one LTP may
not generate changes in lipid profiles if a lipid transportation route
is maintained by several proteins with overlapping functions, as seems
to be often the case. Clearly, it is desirable to develop new approaches
that overcome gene redundancy issues and do not rely on in vitro protein–lipid
reconstruction.Previously, we have developed a series of coumarin
(Cou)-based
photocleavable (caged) lipid probes targeted to mitochondria and lysosomes,
respectively.[7,8] Upon illumination, these probes
quickly decomposed, thereby releasing the corresponding native lipid
molecules inside the targeted organelle. Using isotope-labeled sphingosine
as a lipid precursor, we detected its metabolic products by MS with
high sensitivity and showed that sphingolipid metabolic patterns depend
highly on subcellular localization.[7] While
this strategy is firmly established in mammalian cells, it was unclear
whether the same concept is applicable to yeast, an extensively used
model organism for studying lipid homeostasis owing to its simplicity,
ease of genetic manipulation, and similar organization to metazoans
on cellular and subcellular levels.To explore their use in
yeast, we applied mitochondrial-targeted
caged probes onto Saccharomyces cerevisiae (S. cerevisiae) and found surprisingly
that these probes accumulated inside the vacuole instead of mitochondria.
This unexpected finding led us to synthesize a series of caged lipids,
including sphinganine (Sa), phytosphingosine (PHS), and cholesterol,
which were applied to investigate vacuole-derived lipid metabolism
(Figure A). Using
MS as a readout, we characterized the metabolic products of vacuolar
sphingoid bases, explored potential effectors on the sphingolipid
metabolic pathway, and provided clear evidence that an endoplasmic
reticulum (ER)-anchored protein, which also contacts the vacuole surface,
Mdm1, facilitated sphingolipid turnover. Additionally, we successfully
delivered cholesterol into S. cerevisiae using the same strategy. We showed that cholesterol can restore
cell proliferation induced by ergosterol deprivation, and that deletion
of NCR1, the orthologue of NPC1, which is important
for cholesterol transport in mammals,[9,10] did not strongly
affect vacuole-derived cholesterol utilization in yeast cells. Collectively,
our approach, which combines synthesis, imaging, lipidomics, and genetic
modification, defined a new way of studying intracellular lipid transport
and metabolism in S. cerevisiae.
Figure 1
Schematic illustration
of MS-based metabolic tracking of vacuole-targeted
photocleavable (TPPCou) lipid probes. (B) Synthesis of TPPCou-caged
lipids and chemical structures of TPPCou-caged sphingoid bases. For
long-chain sphingoid bases (LCBs), (a) bis-(4-nitrophenyl) carbonate,
diisopropylethylamine, dimethylformamide, r.t., 3 h; (b) LCB, 60 °C
3 h, 40–60%. For TPPCou-Chol, cholesteryl chloroformate, DCM,
DMAP, 18 h, 60%.
Schematic illustration
of MS-based metabolic tracking of vacuole-targeted
photocleavable (TPPCou) lipid probes. (B) Synthesis of TPPCou-caged
lipids and chemical structures of TPPCou-caged sphingoid bases. For
long-chain sphingoid bases (LCBs), (a) bis-(4-nitrophenyl) carbonate,
diisopropylethylamine, dimethylformamide, r.t., 3 h; (b) LCB, 60 °C
3 h, 40–60%. For TPPCou-Chol, cholesteryl chloroformate, DCM,
DMAP, 18 h, 60%.
Materials
and Methods
Chemicals and Reagents
All internal lipid standards,
C17PHS (PHS), and C17Sa (sphinganine) were purchased from Avanti Polar
Lipids (Alabaster, AL). Yeast media components: glucose monohydrate,
Bacto Peptone, Bacto yeast extract, and Bacto agar were purchased
from BD Biosciences (Sparks, MD); yeast synthetic drop-out amino acid
supplements were from Sigma (St. Louis, MO). Plasmids pBP73G-Mdm1-green
fluorescent protein (GFP) and pBP73G-Nvj1-GFP were created as previously
described.[11]
Yeast Strains and Culture
Baker’s yeast S. cerevisiae were grown in standard rich medium
supplemented with adenine and uracil or in synthetic defined medium.[12] Yeast strains were constructed using standard
techniques.[13] Yeast strains used in the
present study are listed in the Table S1 (Supporting Information).
Fluorescence Microscopy and Image Analysis
Cells were
grown in YPUAD or selective synthetically defined (SD) medium to the
exponential phase, washed, and resuspended in low-fluorescence medium
(LFM)SD medium lacking folate and riboflavin. Cells were put onto
Concanavalin-A pretreated glass slides and incubated at room temperature
for 5 min. The samples were imaged immediately with the LSM700 Zeiss
confocal microscope using a 100× oil immersion objective. Quantification
of fluorescence intensity was carried out using ImageJ software. Pearson’s
correlation coefficients were calculated using EzColocalization ImageJ
plugin.
Labeling with Synthetic Chemical Probes
Yeast cells
were grown in YPUAD or SD medium to the logarithmic phase, labeled
with triphenylphosphonium (TPP)-Cou probes for 20 min at 30 °C,
centrifuged at 800g, resuspended in LFM medium, and
processed for imaging as described above.
Chemical Synthesis, Photouncaging,
and Lipidomics
The
detailed description of ultraviolet (UV) uncaging, sphingoid base
and lipidome analysis, as well synthesis of the caged probes can be
found in the Methods Section in the Supporting Information.
Results and Discussion
Results
TPPCou-Caged
Sphingoid Bases Accumulate in the Yeast Vacuole
The TPP cation
is a well-known mitochondrial targeting motif and
has been used to deliver a wide range of small molecules into the
mitochondrial matrix in mammalian cells.[14] In the past, we have used TPP-modified Cou as a photocleavable protecting
group to prepare caged sphingolipids targeting to the mitochondria
in mammalian cells. Unlike in HeLa cells, the TPP-coupling strategy
has not been widely used in yeast, yet several studies in the pathogenic
yeast Candida albicans showed that
TPP-conjugated antifungal compounds inhibited multidrug resistance
efflux pumps and interfered with mitochondrial functions.[15,16] In another study, TPP was coupled to a fatty-acid anion-stimulated
respiration and thus was presumably targeted to mitochondria in S. cerevisiae, but no visual localization studies
supporting mitochondrial localization were provided.[17]Therefore, we examined the localization of TPP- Cou-caged
compounds, which are easily seen using a fluorescence microscope because
the Cou is also a fluorophore in addition to being a photocleavable
protecting group. Because it was unclear whether these caged probes
would accumulate in yeast mitochondria, we incubated the caged Sa
(Mito-Sa, Supporting Information, Figure S1A) in S. cerevisiae expressing a fluorescent
mitochondrial marker, Mdh1-mCherry. To our surprise, while we recorded
a strong fluorescence signal in the Cou channel, the staining pattern
did not overlap with the Mdh1-mCherry signal, but rather looked like
the vacuole (Supporting Information, Figure S1B). This unexpected finding prompted us to examine colocalization
with a vacuole marker, Vph1-mCherry, which consistently overlapped
well with the Cou fluorescence (Supporting Information, Figure S1C). Because Mito-Sa localized to the
mitochondria in HeLa cells, but to the vacuole in yeast cells, we
renamed it to TPPCou-C18Sa in order to avoid any confusion. Because
PHS is the major form of LCBs in yeast,[18] we synthesized and purified TPPCou-C17PHS, to distinguish it from
the native C18PHS (Figure B), and investigated its localization in S.
cerevisiae. Using fluorescence microscopy, we have
found, consistently, that TPPCou-C17PHS accumulates inside the vacuole,
but not the mitochondria (Figure A–D). To learn which factors affect the vacuole
staining, we treated the cells with diethylaminocoumarin-caged PHS
(Cou-PHS) without the TPP cation and TPPCou alone, respectively (Supporting
Information, Figure S2A–C), but
both failed to generate any meaningful fluorescence signals, indicating
that both the TPP cation and a lipid chain are compulsory for effective
transport of caged probes into the vacuole. It is possible that TPPCou
was pumped out by yeast efflux pumps[19] because
the TPP cation could be delivered into yeast cell only by applying
pulsed electric fields.[20]
Figure 2
TPPCou-C17PHS accumulated
in the yeast vacuole. (A,B) Representative
fluorescence images of yeast cells stably expressing mCherry-tagged
(red) mitochondrial marker protein Mdh1 (A) or vacuolar protein Vph1
(B) stained with 10 μM TPPCou-C17PHS (blue). Bars, 5 μm,
(C) intensity plots of white dotted lines shown on (A,B) for the indicated
fluorescent channels. (D) Quantification of colocalization of TPPCou-C17PHS
with a mitochondrial marker (Mdh1-mCherry) and vacuole marker (Vph1-mCherry),
respectively. (E–G) Quantification of mean intracellular fluorescence
intensity of TPPCou-C17PHS. Cells were treated with 20 μM TPPCou-C17PHS
for 15 min in the presence of indicated conditions. *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ****p < 0.0001, ns., not significant, Student’s t-test.
TPPCou-C17PHS accumulated
in the yeast vacuole. (A,B) Representative
fluorescence images of yeast cells stably expressing mCherry-tagged
(red) mitochondrial marker protein Mdh1 (A) or vacuolar protein Vph1
(B) stained with 10 μM TPPCou-C17PHS (blue). Bars, 5 μm,
(C) intensity plots of white dotted lines shown on (A,B) for the indicated
fluorescent channels. (D) Quantification of colocalization of TPPCou-C17PHS
with a mitochondrial marker (Mdh1-mCherry) and vacuole marker (Vph1-mCherry),
respectively. (E–G) Quantification of mean intracellular fluorescence
intensity of TPPCou-C17PHS. Cells were treated with 20 μM TPPCou-C17PHS
for 15 min in the presence of indicated conditions. *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ****p < 0.0001, ns., not significant, Student’s t-test.Due to the dependence on the sphingoid
base, we postulated that
proteins involved in long-chain base uptake may play a role in the
internalization of TPPCou-C17PHS. Indeed, we found a significant decrease
of fluorescence signals in the absence of fatty acyl-CoA synthetases
(faa1, faa4) and/or transporter
(fat1), which have been shown to affect uptake of
exogenous sphingoid bases[21] (Figure E). Next, we treated the cells
with TPPCou-C17PHS in the presence of CCCP and bafilomycin A1, respectively.
Either disrupting the proton gradient with CCCP or blocking vacuolar
V-ATPases with bafilomycin significantly reduced the fluorescence
intensities of TPPCou-C17PHS, suggesting that the vacuole staining
is dependent on the pH gradient across the vacuolar membrane (Figure F). Furthermore,
we investigated whether the uptake of TPPCou-C17PHS was via endocytosis.
Using cells that lack end3, essential for endocytosis,[22] we found that the fluorescence intensities from end3Δ cells are even slightly higher than the ones
from the wildtype (WT) cells (Figure G), suggesting that the transport does not rely on
endocytosis. Notably, the average fluorescence intensities under both
conditions (Figure G) are relatively lower compared to other experiments (Figure E,F), likely caused by the
differences among the yeast strain backgrounds. Together with the
imaging data of TPPCou-C18Sa (Supporting Information, Figure S1), we showed that the TPPCou-caged lipids
accumulated inside the yeast vacuole, and that elements crucial for
the import and localization include the proton gradient across the
vacuolar membrane and proteins required for sphingoid base and fatty
acid import.
Figure 3
Comparison of D7- Sa conversion to PHC and IPC. (A) Chemical structure
of deuterated TPPCou-Sa. (B) Schematic illustration of the experimental
design. (C) Simplified metabolic routes of Sa. (D–G) Quantification
of PHC_C_18/26 and IPC_C_18/26 using two D7- Sa delivery methods as
indicated. Error bars represent SD, n = 3.
Metabolism of Vacuole-Released Sphingoid
Bases is Less Dependent
on LCB4
In S. cerevisiae,
the levels of LCB are tightly regulated by coordinated action of metabolic
enzymes.[23] We have previously reported
that Lcb4 kinase is essential for incorporating exogenous LCBs into
complex sphingolipids,[24] and its activity
accounts for 95% of long-chain base kinase activity.[25] Lcb4 has been localized to the Golgi, late endosomes,[26] but more direct localizations without protein
tagging found it on the cortical ER juxtaposed to the plasma membrane.[27] Given the localization of Lcb4 outside of the
vacuole, it is therefore interesting to know whether the conversion
of vacuole-released sphingoid bases into dihydroceramides is also
subject to regulation by Lcb4. To this end, we prepared a caged, deuterated
C18 Sa probe (TPPCou-Sa-D7, Figure A) and analyzed its metabolic
products after photoreleasing in WT and mutant cells lacking LCB4
(lcb4Δ), respectively. In parallel, we used
exogenously added C18 Sa (Sa-D7) as a control (Figure B). The downstream metabolites of the deuterated
Sa include phytoceramides (PHCs) and inositol phosphorylceramide (IPC),
which can be detected by MS (Figure C). Indeed, we observed that conversion of the sphingoid
base into PHC and IPC was drastically reduced in lcb4Δ cells (Figure D,E), similar to that in our previous study.[24] Decreased PHC and IPC synthesis was also found in the vacuole-released
Sa-D7 experiments, but to a much lesser extent (Figure F,G). These results suggest that a large
part of the Lcb4-dependence for complex sphingolipid production from
exogenous sphingoid bases may be related to cellular uptake. However,
this cannot be the entire dependence because some dependence was also
seen in vitro after reconstitution.[24] In
contrast, our data here show that a large part of the recycling pathway
of sphingoid bases from the vacuole into complex sphingolipids does
not depend on LCB4, consistent with the previously described Lcb4
localization in proximity to the plasma membrane.[27]Comparison of D7- Sa conversion to PHC and IPC. (A) Chemical structure
of deuterated TPPCou-Sa. (B) Schematic illustration of the experimental
design. (C) Simplified metabolic routes of Sa. (D–G) Quantification
of PHC_C_18/26 and IPC_C_18/26 using two D7- Sa delivery methods as
indicated. Error bars represent SD, n = 3.
Metabolism of Vacuole-Released C17PHS
The lysosome/vacuole
serves as a primary site to break down complex lipid molecules into
basic building blocks, which are later transported to other sites
such as ER for lipid synthesis.[28] These
processes of storage and recycling are of fundamental importance and
have been linked to a number of diseases, but many aspects, particularly
on the sphingolipid transport, remain elusive.[29] Previously, we have applied the local uncaging methods
in HeLa cells to show that sphingolipid metabolism and turnover have
distinct properties depending on the subcellular localization of the
release,[7] though the mechanism of lipid
transport was not defined. Here, we applied the same principle to
examine vacuole-released sphingolipid metabolism, with a particular
focus on lipid transport.The vacuole maintains a low pH environment
and hosts a range of enzymes to disassemble lipid molecules. To assess
the stability of caged probes after import into the vacuole, cells
were treated with TPPCou-C17PHS, collected before or after UV illumination,
and analyzed by MS (Figure B). We could detect some C17PHS even without illumination,
likely due to undesired enzymatic activities in the vacuole. Nevertheless,
the majority remained intact, judging from the UV light-released C17PHS,
which is about four times higher than the control. After learning
that the majority of the caged probe was intact, we analyzed its metabolic
products after uncaging and compared to the ones delivered by extracellular
addition of C17PHS. PHS can be transported from the vacuole to the
nuclear ER, where it is converted into various ceramides and other
complex sphingolipids (Figure A, Supporting Information Figure S3). Our analysis showed that exogenously added C17PHS was predominantly
converted into PHC-C (PHC-C_C43). In photo-released cells, however,
a significantly higher proportion of C17PHS was used for the synthesis
of PHC-B (PHC-B_C43) and shorter-chain ceramides (Figure C). Although the amount of
C17PHS being delivered into intracellular space was different under
the two experimental conditions, these results clearly revealed subcellular
dependence of sphingolipid metabolism, in accordance with our previous
findings in mammalian cells.
Figure 4
Metabolism of vacuole-released C17PHS. (A) Metabolic
scheme of
C17PHS after the vacuole-specific uncaging. After transport from the
vacuole to the ER, PHS is converted into PHC-B, which is transported
further to the Golgi, where PHC-B is metabolized into IPC-B. (B) Analysis
of C17PHS levels before (−UV) and after (+UV) UV uncaging in
cells labeled with 5 μM TPPCou-C17PHS. (C) Comparison of ceramide
species derived from TPPCou-C17PHS (after photorelease) or extracellularly
added C17PHS. Error bars represent SEM, n = 3 *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001, ns, not significant, Student’s t-test.
Metabolism of vacuole-released C17PHS. (A) Metabolic
scheme of
C17PHS after the vacuole-specific uncaging. After transport from the
vacuole to the ER, PHS is converted into PHC-B, which is transported
further to the Golgi, where PHC-B is metabolized into IPC-B. (B) Analysis
of C17PHS levels before (−UV) and after (+UV) UV uncaging in
cells labeled with 5 μM TPPCou-C17PHS. (C) Comparison of ceramide
species derived from TPPCou-C17PHS (after photorelease) or extracellularly
added C17PHS. Error bars represent SEM, n = 3 *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001, ns, not significant, Student’s t-test.
MDM1 Facilitated Sphingolipid
Turnover
Lipids can be
transported within cells by two types of pathways, vesicular and non-vesicular,
but for most lipids it is thought that majority of traffic is carried
out by non-vesicular trafficking, most likely involving LTPs and membrane
contact sites (MCS), areas where membranes from two organelles are
found in close apposition.[30] Nucleus-vacuole
junctions (NVJs) are an example of MCS between the vacuole and the
nuclear ER wrapped around the nucleus forming a contiguous membrane.[31] A number of imaging-based studies indicated
the universal presence of MCS, but functional studies are still lagging
behind.[32] In recent years, we have identified
Mdm1 as a tethering protein that localized to the ER but formed contacts
with the vacuole and lipid droplets in yeast.[33,34]MDM1 is highly conserved in metazoans and plays
essential roles in regulating lipid homeostasis.[35,36] We have found that mutations in yeast MDM1 perturb
sphingolipid metabolism, but whether this tether is involved in interorganelle
lipid trafficking remained elusive.[11] In
support of a potential lipid-trafficking model, recent structural
predictions using the machine-learning algorithm Alphafold2 indicate
that Mdm1p and its orthologs contain a putative novel lipid transport
region formed from two of its domains, the PXA and PXC, which fold
intramolecularly into a bidomain module with a large hydrophobic cavity.[37] Motivated by these observations, we next examined
whether Mdm1 may influence ER-vacuole lipid trafficking.We
used the vacuole-specific uncaging method to examine whether sphingolipid
turnover is influenced by Mdm1p over time. Accordingly, we developed
a pipeline in which C17PHS was first released inside the vacuole,
and its metabolic products were measured by MS at different time points.
PHC-B_C43 and IPC-B_C43 are two of the major metabolic products derived
from C17PHS and gave lowest signal-to-noise ratios, hence were selected
in our analysis. Our data showed that the accumulation of both PHC-B_C43
and IPC-B_C43 was significantly higher in cells, in which MDM1 was overexpressed (Figure A,B). However, when we overexpressed NVJ1, another established nuclear ER-vacuole junction (NVJ)
tether,[31] we did not observe any significant
difference when compared to the control cells (Figure C,D). This striking contrast between MDM1 and NVJ1 overexpression, which both
promote increased MCS formation, indicates that MDM1 promoted the turnover of vacuolar sphingolipids by additional means
than its role in MCS formation. Intriguingly, when we attempted to
use mdm1Δ or nvj1Δ knockout
strains in the “pulse-chase” experiments, we detected
high levels and variable quantities of endogenous C17 sphingolipids.
Because those sphingolipids share the same chemical structures with
the ones converted from the C17PHS after uncaging, it was difficult
to deduce any conclusion from those experiments. The reason for the
appearance of odd-chain sphingolipids in these mutants is unknown.
Because neither MDM1 nor NVJ1 is
essential for cell growth, cells do not seem to rely on a single component/pathway
to transport lipids between the vacuole and the ER. The functional
redundancy and/or quick metabolic adaptation could also mean that
overexpression rather than gene deletion is more suitable to capture
differences in the metabolic tracking studies using our method. In
addition, our lipidomics analysis indicated that major lipid profiles
were not significantly shifted after the photorelease (Supporting
Information, Figure S4), most likely because
the LCBs delivered to the cells are tracers and only comprise a very
small portion of the endogenous lipid pool.
Figure 5
MDM1 facilitated sphingolipid turnover. Lipid
analysis of sphingolipids derived from vacuole-released C17PHS after
UV uncaging in cells overexpressing empty vector, Mdm1 (A,B) or Nvj1
(C,D). Data represents the average of three independent experiments.
Error bars represent SEM. *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001, ns, not significant,
Student’s t-test.
MDM1 facilitated sphingolipid turnover. Lipid
analysis of sphingolipids derived from vacuole-released C17PHS after
UV uncaging in cells overexpressing empty vector, Mdm1 (A,B) or Nvj1
(C,D). Data represents the average of three independent experiments.
Error bars represent SEM. *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001, ns, not significant,
Student’s t-test.
Cholesterol Delivered to Yeast Using TPPCou as Cargo
Cholesterol
is a fundamentally important molecule to human health,
yet its physiological roles are still not clearly defined and some
are highly debated.[38] This is partially
because cholesterol is so abundant and essential in mammalian cells
that any experimental means for reducing cholesterol levels faces
the risk of jeopardizing numerous cellular functions. In contrast,
WT yeast does not produce cholesterol and use another sterol, ergosterol,
for maintaining cellular activities. Having engineered a yeast strain
that effectively produces cholesterol, we demonstrated previously
that functions of ergosterol can be partially replaced by cholesterol,
which makes yeast an attractive model organism for studying cholesterol
transport and metabolism.[39] However, while
mammalian cells import cholesterol through receptor-mediated endocytosis, S. cerevisiae does not take up sterols under aerobic
conditions termed aerobic sterol exclusion.[40]To gain insights into cholesterol transport, we prepared TPPCou-caged
cholesterol (TPPCou-Chol, Figure A) and inspected whether it can be effectively delivered
to the vacuole in WT yeast cells. As hoped for, the probe was successfully
delivered into the vacuole, like the TPPCou-C17PHS (Figure B,C). In addition, we measured
the cholesterol uptake under various conditions and found that cholesterol
was indeed delivered to the cells using TPPCou-Chol, although there
was only minimal additional effect due to UV illumination (Figure D). These results
suggest that most TPPCou-Chol was cleaved by enzymes prior to UV exposure,
which also partially explains why the fluorescence signals from TPPCou-Chol
were weaker than the ones from TPPCou-caged LCBs (Figure B,C). Despite lacking optical
control on the TPPCou-Chol, the data marked the successful vacuole-targeted
delivery of cholesterol under aerobic conditions, enabling us to further
investigate cholesterol transport in S. cerevisiae. First, we blocked endogenous ergosterol biosynthesis using fenpropimorph,[41] then treated cells with TPPCou-Chol in increasing
amounts, and monitored cell growth. The growth curves indicated that
TPPCou-Chol effectively rescued the deficiency of ergosterol in a
dose-dependent manner (Figure E), while free cholesterol-treated cells failed to alleviate
any cell growth suppressed by fenpropimorph (Figure F). Using fenpropimorph, we also performed
another set of experiments on ncr1 knockout cells.
We observed similar growth curves positively correlated with the amount
of TPPCou-Chol, but did not see any significant difference between
WT and ncr1 knockout cells (Figure G,H). Our results suggest that Ncr1p is not
essential for transporting cholesterol from the lysosomes/vacuoles,
in agreement with suggestions from previous findings.[10,42] Overall, our data showed that the vacuole-specific uncaging approach
is not limited to sphingoid bases and has the potential for broader
application to study lipid recycling. Furthermore, we have established
a novel protocol to introduce sterols into aerobically grown yeast,
overcoming the sterol exclusion mechanism, which should permit future
studies on the function of sterols in cell biology.
Figure 6
Vacuole-released cholesterol
rescues growth of ergosterol-depleted
yeast cells. (A) Chemical structure of TPPCou-Chol. (B) Representative
confocal images of yeast cells stably expressing mCherry-tagged (red)
vacuolar marker protein Vph1 stained with 50 μM TPPCou-Chol
(blue) for 20 min at 30 °C. Bars, 5 μm. (C) Intensity profile
of the white dotted line in (B) in TPPCou-cholesterol and Vph1-mCherry
channel, respectively. (D) GC–MS analysis of vacuole-released
cholesterol in yeast cells treated with 50 μM TPP-Cou-cholesterol
or ethanol (CTRL) and subjected to UV uncaging (+UV). Cholesterol
amounts are shown as percentage of total ergosterol levels. Data represents
the average of three independent experiments. Error bars represent SEM. (E) Growth curves of cells treated with TPPCou-Chol
in the presence of fenpropimorph (8 μM). (F) Growth curves of
cells treated with free cholesterol in the presence of fenpropimorph
(8 μM), or ethanol (CTRL) as indicated. (G,H) Growth curves
of WT or ncr1Δ mutant cells. Cells were grown
in the presence of fenpropimorph (8 μM), TPPCou-Chol or control
(ethanol). Cells were incubated in a plate reader, and the growth
was recorded by taking regular optical density measurements at 30
°C. Individual values represent the average of four biological
replicates. Error bars represent SEM.
Vacuole-released cholesterol
rescues growth of ergosterol-depleted
yeast cells. (A) Chemical structure of TPPCou-Chol. (B) Representative
confocal images of yeast cells stably expressing mCherry-tagged (red)
vacuolar marker protein Vph1 stained with 50 μM TPPCou-Chol
(blue) for 20 min at 30 °C. Bars, 5 μm. (C) Intensity profile
of the white dotted line in (B) in TPPCou-cholesterol and Vph1-mCherry
channel, respectively. (D) GC–MS analysis of vacuole-released
cholesterol in yeast cells treated with 50 μM TPP-Cou-cholesterol
or ethanol (CTRL) and subjected to UV uncaging (+UV). Cholesterol
amounts are shown as percentage of total ergosterol levels. Data represents
the average of three independent experiments. Error bars represent SEM. (E) Growth curves of cells treated with TPPCou-Chol
in the presence of fenpropimorph (8 μM). (F) Growth curves of
cells treated with free cholesterol in the presence of fenpropimorph
(8 μM), or ethanol (CTRL) as indicated. (G,H) Growth curves
of WT or ncr1Δ mutant cells. Cells were grown
in the presence of fenpropimorph (8 μM), TPPCou-Chol or control
(ethanol). Cells were incubated in a plate reader, and the growth
was recorded by taking regular optical density measurements at 30
°C. Individual values represent the average of four biological
replicates. Error bars represent SEM.
Discussion
In eukaryotic cells, distinct lipid distribution
and metabolism are associated with subcellular compartments, but related
tools to directly address these issues are very limited. Recently,
we have developed a local uncaging strategy that offers a direct experimental
means to study organelle-specific lipid metabolism. Here, we introduced
this concept in the yeast system and we have extended its application
to intracellular lipid transport. Together with MS, we provide quantitative
information of sphingolipid metabolism, its dependence on sphingosine
kinase, and unveiled the active role of Mdm1p in facilitating the
conversion of LCBs into ceramides. In addition, by releasing cholesterol
in the vacuole, we showed that cholesterol can effectively rescue
the deficiency of ergosterol, that cholesterol transport was not substantially
hindered by the removal of NCR1, and that it is possible
using this method to introduce sterols into aerobically grown yeast.The fluorescence-imaging data shows that TPPCou-caged lipids accumulated
in the vacuole, but it is still unclear why they are enriched inside
vacuole instead of mitochondria. The TPP cation is known as a mitochondrial
targeting signal and has been extensively used in HeLa cells, yet
we did not find any targeting to mitochondria in yeast. Previously,
antifungal TPP-coupled compounds could be targeted to mitochondria
in the pathogenic yeast C. albicans.[15,16] Another study demonstrated that TPP-conjugated
with a fatty acid stimulated yeast mitochondrial respiration,[17] but the localization of the compound was not
addressed and its effects on mitochondria could have been indirect.
It has been known that cationic chemotherapeutic drugs are trapped
in lysosomes, organelles analogous to the yeast vacuole.[43] It is also known that the budding yeast expresses
multiple H+-drug antiporters and at least one of which, Vba4p, is
found in the vacuolar membrane.[44] The activity
of H+-antiporters depends on the vacuolar pH gradient, and experiments
using CCCP and bafilomycin indicate that the pH gradient is essential
to localize the TPP-Cou probes inside the vacuoles. Although CCCP
is commonly used as an uncoupler of mitochondrial potential, it has
also been shown to equilibrate the yeast vacuolar pH with that of
the extracellular medium.[45] It is difficult
to rule out the possibility that some of the TPPCou-based probes went
into mitochondria, but the amount accumulated in mitochondria is under
the detection threshold and thus must be limited. We explored the
uptake mechanism of TPPCou-caged lipids using knockout strains, and
our results show that probe uptake involves the participation of acyl-CoA
synthases but is independent of endocytosis. Because the vacuole is
a recycling hub for breaking down complex lipids into building blocks,
it is not a surprise that we observed partial hydrolysis of TPPCou-C17PHS
prior to UV illumination, and that TPPCou-Chol was completely decomposed.
As the probes are stable in acidic solvents during the purification
steps, consistent with our previous results,[7] the cleavage is unlikely caused by the low pH of the vacuoles but
should have occurred in the vacuole, not before delivery there, because
incubation with TPPCou alone did not lead to vacuolar labeling. On
the other hand, the successful delivery of LCBs and cholesterol also
suggests a possible broader application of using TPPCou as cargo to
transport other lipid molecules to the vacuole in S.
cerevisiae.The major lipid-trafficking routes
are organized by non-vesicular
lipid transport, particularly through MCS with the involvement of
a large group of LTPs. Several imaging-based studies revealed the
precise localization of these proteins, but functional studies often
lag behind. Herein, we released PHS in vacuole and monitored its metabolic
products over time to establish a system, which can directly measure
the influence of LTPs on lipid movement and metabolism. Our results
showed that overexpressing Mdm1, an ER-vacuole tethering protein,
facilitated formation of ceramide and IPC species, unlike another
nuclear ER-vacuole junction protein, Nvj1. Because ceramide synthases
are localized to the nuclear ER, active lipid transport from vacuole
to the ER is a prerequisite before the metabolic conversion. We have
previously shown that mdm1 mutants suppress cell
survival in myriocin treated plating assays,[11] but details were lacking because suppressing sphingolipid biosynthesis
by myriocin can have profound effects on numerous aspects of cellular
activities. In our current study, we measured the real-time metabolic
flux of sphingolipids originating from the vacuole, thus providing
a direct link between Mdm1p and the metabolic turnover of sphingoid
bases. Our recent studies also found that Mdm1p directly interacts
with fatty acids via its hydrophobic N-terminal region and promotes
lipid droplet formation.[33,34] It is unclear for now
whether Mdm1p directly binds LCBs, but even if the direct interaction
occurs, it is likely that the mechanisms are somewhat different because
the head group of sphingoid bases is much more polar and hydrophilic
than fatty acids. However, it is notable that recent structural predictions
using Alphafold2 suggest that Mdm1p and its orthologs encode a putative
LTP-like module composed of its PXA and PXC domains.[37] An intriguing model is that this LTP-like module is capable
of transporting lipids including C17PHS at interorganelle contacts.We also demonstrated that the same principle can be used to study
cholesterol transport in yeast using growth as a functional readout,
highlighting the flexibility and compatibility of our approach for
studying local lipid metabolism. As cholesterol plays essential roles
in maintaining numerous cellular functions, switching the system to S. cerevisiae should offer more freedom to modulate
its levels and to introduce analogs.In metabolic flux studies,
our method should be able to scan multiple
lipid transfer protein candidates without the requirement of detailed
information on protein structures. Arguably, our design relies on
biochemical conversion and hence enzymatic activities, but this requirement
should be matched without difficulty thanks to the abundance of numerous
lipid metabolic enzymes (Supporting Information, Figure S3). In future applications, we can use lipid molecules
bearing a clickable motif and a diazirine, which allows crosslinking
to proteins in close proximity after exposing to an orthogonal UV
light to photouncage, as has been previously demonstrated.[46] In this case, after photouncaging, crosslinking
followed by “click” chemistry with a fluorophore should
enable us to visualize lipid localization over time without relying
on enzymatic activities, though it will lack the information of lipid
species.In conclusion, we presented here a novel technique
of delivering
lipid precursors specifically to the vacuole in S.
cerevisiae, which enabled us to visualize and track
lipid recycling from the vacuole. It has also provided a novel method
to bypass the sterol exclusion barrier of aerobically grown yeast.
Together with MS-based lipidomics, we have found that Mdm1p plays
an active role in mediating sphingolipid metabolism. Collectively,
our approach provides a new framework of analyzing lipid transporters
without prior structural information or in vitro reconstitution.
Authors: Cleiton M Souza; Tatjana M E Schwabe; Harald Pichler; Birgit Ploier; Erich Leitner; Xue Li Guan; Markus R Wenk; Isabelle Riezman; Howard Riezman Journal: Metab Eng Date: 2011-06-30 Impact factor: 9.783
Authors: Krishnamurthy Malathi; Katsumi Higaki; Arthur H Tinkelenberg; Dina A Balderes; Dorca Almanzar-Paramio; Lisa J Wilcox; Naz Erdeniz; Francis Redican; Mahajabeen Padamsee; Ying Liu; Sohail Khan; Frederick Alcantara; Eugene D Carstea; Jill A Morris; Stephen L Sturley Journal: J Cell Biol Date: 2004-02-16 Impact factor: 10.539