| Literature DB >> 35645302 |
Bruno Trovato1, Benedetta Magrì1, Alessandro Castorina2,3, Grazia Maugeri1, Velia D'Agata1, Giuseppe Musumeci1,4.
Abstract
Huntington's disease (HD) is a rare, hereditary, and progressive neurodegenerative disease, characterized by involuntary choreatic movements with cognitive and behavioral disturbances. In order to mitigate impairments in motor function, physical exercise was integrated in HD rehabilitative interventions, showing to be a powerful tool to ameliorate the quality of life of HD-affected patients. This review aims to describe the effects of physical exercise on HD-related skeletal muscle disorders in both murine and human models. We performed a literature search using PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science databases on the role of physical activity in mouse models of HD and human patients. Fifteen publications fulfilled the criteria and were included in the review. Studies performed on mouse models showed a controversial role played by exercise, whereas in HD-affected patients, physical activity appeared to have positive effects on gait, motor function, UHDMRS scale, cognitive function, quality of life, postural stability, total body mass, fatty acid oxidative capacity, and VO2 max. Physical activity seems to be feasible, safe, and effective for HD patients. However, further studies with longer follow-up and larger cohorts of patients will be needed to draw firm conclusions on the positive effects of exercise for HD patients.Entities:
Keywords: Huntington’s disease; exercise; motor function; mouse models; rehabilitation; skeletal muscles
Year: 2022 PMID: 35645302 PMCID: PMC9149967 DOI: 10.3390/jfmk7020040
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Funct Morphol Kinesiol ISSN: 2411-5142
Figure 1Motor symptoms related to disease progression.
Characteristics of included studies.
| Authors/Year | Study Design | Model | Sample Size | Intervention | Result | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pilot clinical trials | Humans | n = 40 | 8 h a day for 5 days and 4 h a day for one day per week, repeated three times afor 1 year of physical, occupational and speech therapy, cognitive rehabilitation and respiratory exercises | Significant improvement of motor performance and activities of day living and maintaining of cognitive function | Intensive rehabilitation treatments may have a positive effest on motor and functional performance in patients with Huntington’s disease | |
| Mouse general health and behavioral assessment | Mice | n/a | Voluntary wheel running exercise from juvenile age (4 weeks) to adulthood (9 months). Open field and rotarod test at 5 months of age | Motor deficts on rotarod test delayed by wheel running as well as rear-paw clasping. Enviormental enrichment and wheel running decreased the abnormal locomotor activities | Voluntary wheel running started before the symptomatic stage of the disease can delay the onset of some motor deficits in HD mice | |
| Mouse general health and behavioral assessment | Mice | n = 54 | Voluntary running exercise from an age of 44 days to an age of 113 days. Morris water maze test at 88 days old, rotarod test at 100 days old and open field test at 103 days old | Running exercise worsened the HD motor deficits and accelerated its onset | Running is not effective in delaying HD symptoms. Exercise is not beneficial and may have a negative effect in the mouse model analyzed | |
| Randomized controlled trials | Humans | n = 20 | Supervised group sessions of 9 months, once per week; 5 min warm-up, 10 min aerobic exercise, 40 min resistance exercise, 5 min cool-down. 6 months of home-based exercise 3 times per week. Occupational therapy for 1 h fortnight, for 6 months | Reduction of the loss of postural and dynamic stability; mild improvement in quality of life, depression and cognition; significant improvement in fat-free mass and strength | Multidisciplinary rehabilitation program is feasible and well tollerated in early to middle stage HD patients. Patients also reported therapeutic benefits | |
| Prospective intervention study | Humans | n = 37 | Physiotherapy, occupational and speech therapy, gym and/or swimming training, 8 h 5 days per week for 1 year. | Significant gains in balance, gait, activities of day living, quality of life, anxiety and depression | Multidisciplinary rehabilitation improved balance, gait function, and quality of life | |
| Randomized feasibility study | Humans | n = 31 | 12 weeks of walking and cycling aerobic training at 55–75% of predicted HRmax; resistance exercises for lower limbs (2× 8–12 reps at 60–70% of 1 RM) | Moderate effect sizes showed benefits for cognitive and walking measures. | A structured exercise intervention gives improvements in motor function and quality of life in HD patients | |
| Randomized controlled pilot study | Humans | n = 25 | home-based exercise for 8 weeks consisting of gradual progressive walking exercise 3 times per week | Walking speed and gait variability improvement with large effect sizes. Balance, funtion and level of phisical activity also had a significant improvement | Home based exercise are feasible, beneficial and safe for HD mid-stage patients | |
| Prospective intervention study | Humans | n = 10 | Physiotherapy occupational and speech therapy, gym and/or swimming training, 8 h five days per week for two years | Non significant decline of gait, balance and cognitive measures. Not significant increasing for quality of life, activities of day living and motor function | Intensive multidisciplinary rehabilitation is well tollerated among midlle stage HD patients. | |
| Exploratory study | Humans | n = 15 | 1 h of aerobic and resistance training per week in clinic; 1 h of home based exercises 3 times per week; occupational therapy once every 2 weeks | Significant volumetric grey matter improvement and significant increasing of verbal learning and memory | Multidisciplinary rehabilitation may have a positive impacts on gray matter changes and cognitive functions in HD patients. | |
| Randomized controlled trial | Humans | n = 32 | 12 weeks of 30 min cycling training (65–85% of age predicted HRmax) and 10–15 min of strengthening exercises (2× 10–12 reps) | Improvement in VO2max, general fitness and motor function | A short-term exercise progam is safe, feasible and may be beneficial for midlle stage HD patients | |
| Clinical trials | Humans | n = 24 | 10 weeks of 30 min cycling (65%VO2peak) 3 times per week, 8 weeks of HIIT (4 × 4 min at 90–95% of HRpeak with 3 min low-intensity rest intervals at 70% of HRpeak) 3 times per week and endurance training 3 times per week | Motor deficit stabilization, VO2max significant improvement | Specified exercise programs may induce therapeutic beneficial effects in HD patients | |
| Clinical trials | Humans | n = 24 | 10 weeks of 30 min cycling (65%VO2peak) 3 times per week, 8 weeks of HIIT (4 × 4 min at 90–95% of HRpeak with 3 min low-intensity rest intervals at 70% of HRpeak) 3 times per week and endurance training 3 times per week | Increasing in the activity of citrate synthase, complex III, complex V and succinate cytochrome c reductase | HD patients could benefit from an endurance training program in terms of delaying the progressive muscular dysfunction. The training program was also safe and feasible. | |
| Pilot clinical trials | Humans | n = 29 | 9 months of aerobic and resistance training 2 times per week, bilingual exercise, dual-task training 1 time per week for 1-h, computerized cognitive training 3 times per week for 1 h and social activities. | Maintanance of serum BDNF levels, decreasing of cortisol and melatonin concentration | A program of multidisciplinary rehabilitation may be useful for maintaining peripheral BDNF levels and decreasing the hypothalamic volume loss in preclinical HD individuals | |
| Mouse general health and behavioral assessment | Mice | n = 16 | Running at a speed of 8.0 m/min for 40 min for first week; starting from second week exercise running at 10.0 ± 1.5 m/min 3 times per week for a 12-week period. Final month of exercise with running speed set at 20 ± 1.5 m/min | Treadmill exercise resulted in improved mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation complex activity. Improvement were also registered fot glycolisys, pyruvate deidrogenase and carboxylase activity | Treadmill exercise may be beneficial for motor behavior thanks to reverisng deficits in mitochondrial function in a rodent model of HD | |
| Mouse general health and behavioral assessment | Mice | n = 40 | 30 min of treadmill running once a day for 14 days; running speed set at 2 m/min for the first 5 min, then at 5 m/min for the next 5 min and at 8 m/min for the last 20 min of exercise | Treadmill running exercise rescued motor coordination and suppressed caspase-3 expression | Running exercise could be beneficial in improving quinolinic acid-induced loss of spatial learning ability and coordination in HD mouse model | |
| Mouse general health and behavioral assessment | Mice | n = 40 | 30 min of treadmill running once a day for 14 days; running speed set at 2 m/min for the first 5 min, then at 5 m/min for the next 5 min and at 8 m/min for the last 20 min of exercise | Treadmill running exercise enhanced the production of neurotrophic factors in the brain and ameliorated memory and learnig ability | Treadmill exercise influences positively the cell proliferation in the hippocampal dentate gyrus by ameliorating the BDNF expression in HD rats; hence, treadmill exercise has beneficial effects HD symptoms | |
| Mouse general health and behavioral assessment | Mice | n = 128 | 11 days of training in Lashley III maze, then rotarod training for 1 day; lastly, 14 days of training in Lashley III maze again | There were no significant improvement in mice performance after training | Physical exercise on the rotarod did not significantly improve motor coordination of R6/2 mice, but it did not induced deleterious effects | |
| Mouse general health and behavioral assessment | Mice | n = 140 | 4 weeks of voluntary wheel running exercise | Wheel running exercise and chronic setraline treatment prevent depressive like behaviours by correcting the 5-HT1A autoreceptor dysfunction | Wheel-running exercise improved cognition and prevented depressive-like behaviours in R6/1 HD mice | |
| Mouse general health and behavioral assessment | Mice | n = 320 | Running at a speed of 8.0 m/min for 40 min for first week; starting from second week exercise running at 10.0 ± 1.5 m/min 3 times per week for 6 months. Final month of exercise with running speed set at 20 ± 1.5 m/min | CAG140 KI mouse did not show significant worsening in performace at the rotarod test and forced swimmig test compared to wild type animals | A long term training program of running exercise is effective in delaying the onset of depression like behaviors in CAG140 KI mouse model of HD when started before the onset of motor symtoms | |
| Mouse general health and behavioral assessment | Mice | n = 67 | Running wheel exercise 14 h per day, for five days for 22 weeks. Behavioural testing every for weeks | Wheel running produced some benefit on stride length and reduction of striatal neuronal cell loss | Chronic wheel running exercise enhance cognitive funtion, reduce striatal cell loss in in the R6/1 HD mouse indicating that exercise may be benficial in HD | |
| Mouse general health and behavioral assessment | Mice | n/a | Forced endurance training protocol consiting in 30 min of rotarod set at 15 rpm, 5 day/week. Mice had also the oppurtunity to pratice voluntary running exercise in their cages | Endurance training was detrimental for HD mice, inducing the activation of AMPK in skeletal muscles | Physical activity that causes an high energy demands should be proposed to HD patients with caution |
Figure 2Intriguing timeline of physical exercise and multidisciplinary rehabilitation interventions with their relative outcomes.
Overview description of physical activity interventions. CG: control group; IG: intervention group; n/a= not available.
| Authors | Participants Characteristics | Intervention Programs | Measured Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| n = 40 (M = 17; F = 23) | Respiratory exercise, speech therapy, physical therapy, occupational therapy, cognitive rehabilitation exercise | Balance, gait, depression, cognitive status, activities of day living | |
| n = 20 (M = n/a; F = n/a) | Aerobic exercise, resistance exercise, home-based occupational therapy | Motor function, cognition, body composition, postural stability, quality of life | |
| n = 37 (M = 18; F = 19) | Physiotherapy, occupational and speech therapy, gym/swimming exercises, group discussions | Motor function, quality of life, cognitive function, depression/anxiety | |
| n = 31 (M = 16; F = 15) | Aerobic training, resistance exercise | Motor function, quality of life | |
| n= 25 (M = n/a; F = n/a) | Resistance exercise, balance exercise. | Gait, balance, quality of life | |
| n= 15 (M = 8; F = 7) | Home-based aerobic and resistance exercises, occupational therapy | Grey matter volume, verbal learning, memory | |
| n= 32 (M = 16; F = 16) | Aerobic training, resistance exercise | Motor function, fitness, cognition | |
| n= 24 (M = 24; F = 0) | Aerobic and endurance training, high-intensity interval training | Motor function, dementia, cardiovascular performance | |
| n= 24 (M = 24; F = 0) | Aerobic and endurance training, high-intensity interval training | Mitochondrial function | |
| n= 29 (M = 10; F= 19) | Aerobic exercise, resistance exercise, dual-task, bilingual exercise, cognitive training | Grey matter volume, BDNF concentration |