| Literature DB >> 35621029 |
Aida Abdraimova1, Stéphane Besançon2, Jill Portocarrero3, Kaushik Ramaiya4,5, Asel Dunganova1, Margaret Ewen6, Hans Hogerzeil7, Maria Lazo-Porras3,8, Richard Laing9,10, Molly Lepeska6, Happy Nchimbi11, Assa Sidibé12, Andrew Swai5, Janeth Tenorio-Mucha3, John S Yudkin13, Jessica H Zafra-Tanaka3, Aida Zurdinova14, David Beran8.
Abstract
AIMS: To describe and compare the health system responses for type 1 diabetes in Kyrgyzstan, Mali, Peru and Tanzania.Entities:
Keywords: developing countries; health delivery of health care; insulin; type 1 diabetes
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35621029 PMCID: PMC9543552 DOI: 10.1111/dme.14891
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Diabet Med ISSN: 0742-3071 Impact factor: 4.213
Data on each surveyed country [1; 23; 24]
| Kyrgyzstan | Mali | Peru | Tanzania | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Geographical location | Central Asia | West Africa | South America | East Africa |
| World Bank income group [23] | Lower‐middle‐income | Low‐income | Upper‐middle‐income | Lower‐middle‐income |
| Gross National Income per capita Purchasing Power Parity (current US$) [23] | 5110 | 2280 | 12,450 | 3140 |
| Monthly salary of lowest paid government worker (US$) | 75.9 | 71.9 | 282.9 | 129.0 |
| Population [23] | 6,322,800 | 19,077,690 | 31,989,256 | 56,318,348 |
| Life‐expectancy at birth (total years) [23] | 71.4 | 58.9 | 76.5 | 65.0 |
| Health expenditure (% of Gross Domestic Product) [23] | 6.2 | 3.8 | 5.0 | 3.7 |
| UHC service coverage index (Index for the coverage of essential health services, using tracer interventions: reproductive, maternal, newborn and child health, infectious diseases, noncommunicable diseases and service capacity and access. Presented on a scale of 0 to 100 [24] | 70 | 38 | 77 | 43 |
| Number of people with type 1 diabetes [1] (Number of people with type 1 diabetes estimated from data collected during this study) | 2910 (2324) | 1550 (628) | 3860 (737) | 10,970 (4000) |
| Period of data collection | January to March 2018 | April to July 2018 | February to June 2018 | May to July 2019 |
| Number of Regions included in the assessment | 3 (Bishkek, Issy Kul and Osh) | 8 (Bamako, Gao, Kayes, Koulikoro, Mopti, Segou, Sikasso, and Timbuktu) | 1 (Lima) | 1 (Dar es Salaam) |
| Total number of interviews | 333 | 362 | 35 | 43 |
| Macro | 4 | 10 | 8 | 15 |
| Meso | 121 | 83 | 5 | 10 |
| Micro | 208 | 269 | 22 | 18 |
FIGURE 1Availability in the public and private sectors of different diabetes supplies
Annual costs of different components of diabetes care in Kyrgyzstan, Mali, Peru and Tanzania
| Country | Kyrgyzstan | Mali | Peru | Tanzania | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Minimum | Maximum | Minimum | Maximum | Minimum | Maximum | Minimum | Maximum | |
| Insulin | $0.0 | $0.0 | $189.6 | $216.0 | $120.0 | $441.6 | $153.6 | $172.6 |
| Syringes | $36.5 | $73.0 | $73.0 | $73.0 | $32.9 | $43.8 | $29.2 | $51.1 |
| BGM | $16.0 | $27.6 | $26.6 | $31.3 | $17.5 | $25.1 | $10.7 | $10.7 |
| Strips | $233.6 | $635.1 | $341.6 | $432.2 | $222.1 | $666.2 | $226.3 | $666.2 |
| Consultation fee | $0.0 | $0.0 | $10.8 | $10.8 | $0.0 | $10.8 | $0.0 | $1.8 |
| HbA1c | $37.6 | $37.6 | $50.8 | $84.0 | $54.0 | $84.0 | $0.0 | $52.7 |
| Transportation costs | $1.0 | $1.0 | $14.4 | $14.4 | $5.6 | $5.6 | $4.4 | $26.4 |
| Total | $324.7 | $774.3 | $706.8 | $861.6 | $452.0 | $1277.1 | $424.2 | $981.5 |
| Number of days' wages of lowest paid unskilled government worker to afford 1‐month of care for Type 1 diabetes | 10.7 | 25.5 | 24.6 | 29.9 | 4.0 | 11.3 | 8.2 | 19.0 |
Note: Assuming 2 vials of insulin per month; 1 syringe per day; cost of BGM amortized over 2 years; 2 blood glucose tests per day; 1 consultation every 3 months; 1 HbA1c test every 3 months; Travel for 1 consultation every 3 months.
Summary table of findings
| Health system element current framework/colours for WHO Health System Building Blocks | Kyrgyzstan | Mali | Peru | Tanzania |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Positive policy environment | UHC package includes free provision of insulin and other diabetes supplies and overall coverage | |||
| National policies include diabetes in all countries, but the focus is primarily on Type 2 diabetes especially in Peru | ||||
| Organization of the health system | Care for Type 1 diabetes mainly centralized; PHC not equipped to manage Type 1 diabetes | |||
| Guidelines only for Type 2 diabetes | Dependent on donations | Guidelines only for Type 2 diabetes | Dependent on donations; some decentralization of Type 1 diabetes care | |
| Data collection | Although data collection tools exist they do not allow for a clear picture of the burden of diabetes | |||
| Data collection system for type 1 diabetes integrated into the Ministry of Health | Specific database for Type 1 diabetes, but not integrated into national system | No specific data collection system for Type 1 diabetes | Specific database for Type 1 diabetes, but not integrated into national system | |
| Diagnostic tools and infrastructure | Poor availability and affordability of reagents and diagnostic tools | |||
| HbA1c only available in the private sector | HbA1c available in public and private sectors | |||
| Medicine procurement and supply | Human insulin included on national Essential Medicine List; problems with quantification of needs and distribution of insulin within the country | |||
| Central procurement; national essential medicines list includes analogue insulin; insulin is not available in private pharmacies; available at PHC | Central procurement; donations of insulin for children and youth; available at PHC | Regional procurement; insulin only available at hospitals | Central procurement; donations of insulin for children and youth; available at PHC | |
| Availability and affordability of medicines and care | Insufficient provision of syringes and variable availability; variable availability of BGMs and high cost of these tools | |||
| 100% availability of insulin in the public sector; no availability of BGMs in public sector, but provision of strips and meters by insurance scheme | Relatively poor availability of insulin in the public sector; BGMs only present in private sector | Relatively poor availability of insulin in the public sector; no availability of BGMs in public sector | 94% availability of insulin in public sector; good availability of BGMs in both public and private sector | |
| Healthcare workers | Numbers and training of professionals; Type 1 diabetes managed by specialists; in some specialized centres nurses and other health professionals involved | |||
| Patient education and empowerment | Delivered by specialists; mainly focused on nutrition | |||
| Specific education and support for type 1 diabetes that is delivered only at tertiary‐level facilities | Specific tools developed | Specific education and support for type 1 diabetes that is delivered only at tertiary‐level facilities | Specific tools developed; involvement of the Tanzanian Diabetes Youth Alliance | |
| Adherence issues | Overall socio‐economic situation and barriers to care; inappropriate approaches to patient education | |||
| Community involvement and diabetes associations | Financial sustainability | |||
| Specific diabetes association for Type 1 diabetes; mainly in capital city | Diabetes association mainly focuses on Type 2 diabetes; national representation | Specific diabetes association for Type 1 diabetes; mainly in capital city | Diabetes association mainly focuses on Type 2 diabetes with national representation, but there is the presence of a Youth Group | |