Literature DB >> 35601252

Colombian political leaders on Twitter during the Covid-19 pandemic.

Michael Haman1, Milan Školník1, Jan Čopík2.   

Abstract

This study analyzes the use of Twitter by Colombian political elites during the Covid-19 pandemic, employing qualitative and quantitative methods and techniques. We collected Twitter data on the Colombian president, the mayor of Bogota, and all the members of the Congress of Colombia. We then analyzed qualitatively the content of the most popular tweets sent by President Iván Duque, Mayor Claudia López, and Gustavo Petro, the leader of the opposition. We also analyzed the growth in the number of their followers during the pandemic. We found that the most popular tweets from Colombian opposition politicians were often related to criticism of the government. López also informed her constituency about the state of the capital. President Duque's most popular tweets were primarily informative. During the pandemic, all three politicians gained a significant number of Twitter followers.
© 2022 Policy Studies Organization.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Covid‐19; Twitter; political actors; political communication; social media

Year:  2022        PMID: 35601252      PMCID: PMC9115228          DOI: 10.1111/lamp.12249

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Lat Am Policy        ISSN: 2041-7365


INTRODUCTION

In times of crisis, it is important to keep the population informed. Political representatives give recommendations and instructions on how people should behave to protect their own lives and their loved ones and minimize the damage in general to overcome the crisis as quickly and effectively as possible. One of the communication tools of the twenty‐first century accessible to the public that helps inform the population during crisis situations is the social network Twitter (Bakker et al., 2019; Eriksson & Olsson, 2016; Helsloot & Groenendaal, 2013; Interdonato et al., 2019; Kawchuk et al., 2020; O'Loughlin et al., 2017; Pond, 2016). The importance of Twitter as an effective communication tool is currently being examined during the global Covid‐19 pandemic in all countries of the world, including Colombia. In this country, the use of Twitter has already been studied in the context of the peace process (Barreto‐Galeano et al., 2019; Barrios et al., 2019; Cortés & Jurado, 2018; Fabra‐Mata & Mygind, 2019; Quintero Jurado & Marín Cortés, 2018). Its use during the election campaign has also been examined (López Londoño, 2018; Ordoñez Salinas et al., 2016; Prada Espinel & Romero Rodríguez, 2018; Ruano et al., 2018), and attention has been focused on the use of Twitter in general from the point of view of users or influencers (Durán‐Vaca & Ballesteros‐Ricaurte, 2020; Hernández Rodríguez, 2017; Hopke et al., 2016; Hung & Calderón, 2011). Yet, the use of Twitter in Colombia has not been studied in the context of a crisis. Twitter can be a communication platform for Colombians to find necessary information from the political representatives on how to deal with the crisis. At the same time, the platform can be a political arena where politicians use the topic of the coronavirus to their own advantage. We examine how the selected political elites in Columbia communicated on this social network during the Covid‐19 pandemic. The study is divided into two main parts. The theoretical and methodological part presents an overview of the current state of research on the topic of Twitter in relation to politicians and crises. The theoretical framework of crisis exploitation is introduced, the methodological procedure is explained, and the choice of politicians for the purposes of analysis is justified. In the analytical part, word clouds are analyzed. Furthermore, a content analysis of the 50‐most‐tweeted messages is performed. Finally, whether the selected politicians benefited from the crisis in the form of an increase in their followers is examined over a certain period. The programming language R is used for the analysis.

THEORETICAL APPROACHES

Social media and politicians

Politics has increasingly become a media issue over the last 30 years. It is therefore not surprising that this period is referred to as the third age of political communication, which is characterized by the diversification of the media environment and the intensifying role of new media in the process of interaction between political actors and the public (Blumler & Kavanagh, 1999). In the context of political communication, mass media are receding into the background with the rise of the Internet and social networks. Thanks to social networks, politicians can reach citizens and voters directly, which represents a huge saving compared to mass media in terms of both time and money. Another indisputable advantage is that they can get feedback from citizens, whether in the form of a direct comment, like, or following. Such interaction with users or citizens opens a space for more direct involvement in the political process. Citizen participation in public affairs is generally vital to a democracy, so social media strengthens the democratic process by bridging the gap between politicians and citizens (Bennett & Entman, 2000; Coleman & Blumler, 2009). Politicians can use social networks to inform and interact with citizens as well as to mobilize them. This strategy can be effective not only during election campaigns but also during crises, which politicians can use to their political advantage.

Crisis exploitation

The theory of crisis exploitation can be described as, “the purposeful utilization of crisis‐type rhetoric to significantly alter levels of political support for public office‐holders and public policies” (Boin et al., 2009, p. 83). A crisis creates a space for political actors to propose political innovations and organizational reforms, redefine issues, gain popularity, and, above all, criticize their opponents. Crises create political opportunity windows not only for established politicians but also for new holders of public office (Keeler, 1993). During crises, there is an effort to capitalize on the disruption brought about by unforeseen events and to defend and strengthen political positions and authority, attract public attention, and remove old policies and create new ones. In times of crisis, political actors can call for changes that are otherwise difficult to implement in a period of stability, for reasons such as the nature of the political system, powers of veto, and the balance of powers (Hay, 2002; Kuipers, 2005).

LITERATURE REVIEW: USE OF TWITTER

There are several debates addressing the use of Twitter that can be related to the global Covid‐19 pandemic. Studies have considered the use of Twitter in emergency situations. They have monitored whether social networks such as Twitter are used in emergency situations at all, and if so, what communication strategies are used to inform the public, how the public and emergency authorities communicate with each other, whether information via Twitter actually has a real influence on the mitigation of emergency situations, and much more (Alshareef & Grigoras, 2017; Hughes & Palen, 2009; Lachlan et al., 2016; Latonero & Shklovski, 2011; Laylavi et al., 2016, 2017; Martínez‐Rojas et al., 2018; Panagiotopoulos et al., 2016; Parsons et al., 2018; Power et al., 2014; Purohit et al., 2013). The use of Twitter in crisis situations and natural disasters has been explored (Finch et al., 2016; Muniz‐Rodriguez et al., 2020). Research on Twitter as a communication tool has been carried out not only for crises related to natural elements but also for political events that escalate into a state of crisis. Finally, the representation of politicians on Twitter has been examined (Alonso‐Muñoz & Casero‐Ripollés, 2018; Bracciale & Martella, 2017; Burbach, 2017; Kissas, 2020; Masroor et al., 2019; Schneiker, 2019; Tromble, 2018). It is the role of politicians to inform the public in times of crisis, and they have used social networks such as Twitter to do so. At the same time, politicians can benefit politically from a crisis (Kreuder‐Sonnen, 2018). Our study contributes to the debate on the use of Twitter for both crisis and political purposes in the case of Colombia.

METHODOLOGY

In the initial phase of this study, we collected information on the Twitter accounts of members of the Colombian Congress. Of course, not every member of the Colombian Congress has a Twitter account. We looked only at original tweets and excluded retweets. We identified 254 Twitter accounts that tweeted in the analyzed period from March 6 to June 25, 2020. Twitter application programming interface (API) offers a range of information. We gathered tweets and other Twitter data in R with rtweet package (Kearney, 2019). Given that Colombia is a presidential system, the current president Iván Duque and the former president Juan Manuel Santos were added to the list. Furthermore, given that BogotE is the political center of all important state institutions and has a population of almost 8 million, the mayor of the capital, Claudia López, was also included in the list. We were interested in the number of followers in deciding whom to analyze. Figure 1 shows that Juan Manuel Santos, the former president from 2010 to 2016, has the largest number of followers on Twitter. As of June 26, 2020, more than 5.5 million people follow him. In second place is the current senator Álvaro Uribe, who held the office of head of state from 2002 to 2010. Almost 5 million Twitter users follow this representative of the Democratic Center Party. In third place, with almost 4 million followers, is the senator and representative of the center‐left electoral coalition List of Decency (Lista de la Decencia), Gustavo Petro. The current mayor of Bogota and the representative of Alianza Verde (Green Alliance), López ranks fourth among the most‐followed politicians on Twitter, with a number exceeding 2,300,000 followers. The current president Duque (@IvanDuque) from the Democratic Center (Centro Democrático), is in fifth place, with less than 2 million followers on Twitter.
Figure 1

Colombian politicians and Twitter followers. Source: Authors' elaboration

Colombian politicians and Twitter followers. Source: Authors' elaboration We selected President Duque, Senator Petro (@petrogustavo), and Mayor López (@ClaudiaLopez) for the analysis. The purpose is to capture the interaction on Twitter between the top government officials and the most prominent faces of the opposition during the coronavirus crisis. Former President Santos is no longer in public office, and Uribe is from the same political party as the current head of state, so the two former presidents were not included in the analysis. The choice of the three politicians not only reflects the government and the opposition but also provides insight into Covid‐19 and related measures by the country's top official, the capital's top official, and a senator who, as a former Bogota mayor and presidential candidate, combines the standing of Duque and López. We monitored the influence of these three selected politicians on Twitter. We performed word clouds revealing which words dominated tweets and what politicians emphasized in communications. We collected all tweets sent by @IvanDuque, @ClaudiaLopez, and @petrogustavo from March 6 to June 25, 2020. We eliminated stop words from tweets by using R package stopwords (Muhr et al., 2020), through snowball in this package. During the processing of tweets, we also removed numbers and transformed words to lowercase. We focused on a sample of the 50 most popular tweets to find out what the purpose was of these posts. This process is achieved through content analysis and coding of tweets based on their communication goals (Rufai & Bunce, 2020). The tweets were (1) informative (politicians informed about the virus and related measures); (2) morale‐boosting (politicians thanked people, praised their courage, or wanted them to undertake acts of patriotism); (3) politically motivated in general (when the issue of Covid‐19 is addressed, but the government is not attacked or praised, for instance, putting forward proposals); (4) critical of the government (as having done something wrong during the crisis) or critical of political rivals; (5) praising the government (as having done something good during the crisis) or praising political rivals; or (6) other (tweets are not related to the Covid‐19 pandemic). We also monitored whether there was an increase in the number of followers and which of the analyzed three politicians gained the most followers during the coronavirus crisis. Twitter API does not provide data about the growth of followers, so we collected the data continuously from June 2019 to June 2020.

RESULTS

Figure 2 shows the words most used by President Duque during the pandemic. The term “prevenciónyacción” (prevention and action), which the head of state used most often in his tweets, completely dominates. It was a hashtag that he used very frequently. Other frequent words were “pandemia,” “covid,” and “medidas” (measures), “envivo” (live), or “salud” (health). These words were directly related to the spreading virus and measures to protect the health of the population. Other frequently used words were “país” (country), “gobierno” (government), “colombianos” (Colombians), and “nacional” (national), or “president” (president) and “Colombia” (Colombia). It is clear from this analysis that, during the ongoing pandemic, it was important for the president to mention the activities of his government, emphasizing in his tweets the country he governs and its people, that is, those affected by the coronavirus crisis. His tweets were not dominated by other words that were not related to the crisis. For example, he did not deal significantly with economic issues, the process of reintegrating the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC) into society, or the issue of drugs. He rarely targeted his political opponents during the crisis.
Figure 2

Word cloud for @IvanDuque. Source: Authors' elaboration

Word cloud for @IvanDuque. Source: Authors' elaboration For the current mayor of Bogota, the capital of Colombia was in first place during the pandemic, as revealed by López's tweet cloud, shown in Figure 3. The word “Bogotá” was the most mentioned. The emphasis on the city stems not only from the function of mayor in general but also from the fact that at the time of the pandemic she was solely responsible for the situation in the capital. Unlike the president, she was not responsible for policy in relation to the situation across the country. This word was immediately followed by terms such as “hoy” (today) or “gracias” (thank you). López often gave information about the situation for a specific day. She also thanked all those who fought the spreading disease, such as doctors, security forces, and those who provided supplies of basic food and medicine. She often tweeted about the pandemic, as demonstrated by words such as “salud” (health), covid, “medidas” (measures), “cuarantena” (quarantine), and “vida” (life). She also often tweeted that “personas” (persons) should stay at home—“casa”—to prevent the spread of the virus. She often criticized or adopted reports from the “gobierno nacional” (national government). Compared to President Duque, the words that López used frequently in individual tweets were more varied. While the president's most emphasized word was prevention and action in the fight against coronavirus, for the mayor of Bogota the most emphasized word was simply Bogot. The whole country was important to Duque, and the capital was important to López.
Figure 3

Word cloud for @ClaudiaLopez. Source: Authors' elaboration

Word cloud for @ClaudiaLopez. Source: Authors' elaboration Based on Senator Petro's tweet cloud, shown in Figure 4, both “Colombia” and “Bogotá” were important for the former presidential candidate and former mayor of Bogota. These two words were the most common in his tweets, as were “health” and “virus,” which related directly to the ongoing global “pandemic.” Other common words concerning the coronavirus crisis were “vida” (life), covid, and “cuarantena” (quarantine). The opposition leader often mentioned the current president Duque or his government—“gobierno”—in tweets, either criticizing or praising it. A very frequent topic in the tweets of the former mayor of Bogota was López's controversial intention to demolish the “Hospital San Juan.” Petro often commented on the ongoing pandemic with a specific topic and at the same time distinguished himself both from a former presidential challenger in general and his successor as mayor (see Table 1).
Figure 4

Word cloud for @petrogustavo. Source: Authors' elaboration

Table 1

Sample Covid‐19 tweets by topic

NameTopicTweet in SpanishTranslation to EnglishDate
Iván Duque Márquez—https://twitter.com/IvanDuque Informative: 76%Quiero informarle a todos los colombianos: A partir de las 00:00 horas del 23 de marzo, queda prohibida la llegada de todos los vuelos internacionales de pasajeros a los aeropuertos del país, por un periodo de 30 días.I want to inform all Colombians: As of 00:00 h on March 23rd, all international passenger flights are prohibited from arriving at the country's airports, for a period of 30 days.March 19, 2020, 2:25 p.m.
Morale‐boosting: 8%Los colombianos nos debemos sentir orgullosos de lo que somos. Los invito a que en estos 19 días de cuarentena pongamos la bandera en nuestras casas, balcones, redes o perfiles. Estamos más unidos que nunca como país y no vamos a parar ni de crecer ni de soñar ni de construir.We Colombians should feel proud of who we are. I invite you to put the flag on our houses, balconies, social networks, or profiles during these 19 days of quarantine. We are more united than ever as a country, and we will not stop growing or dreaming or building.March 25, 2020, 1:07 p.m.
Political: 6%Los migrantes venezolanos enfrentan la dictadura y ahora una pandemia; no podemos referirnos a ellos de manera despectiva. Pese a dificultades, seguiremos trabajando para ellos con programas sociales que tenemos y continuaremos haciéndolo de la mano con alcaldes y gobernadores.Venezuelan migrants face the dictatorship and now a pandemic; we cannot refer to them in a derogatory manner. Despite the difficulties, we will continue to work for them with the social programs we have and will continue to do so hand in hand with mayors and governors.April 5, 2020, 2:46 a.m.
Other: 10%Todo el peso de la ley debe caer sobre quienes promuevan el tráfico de personas y la explotación sexual de mujeres o niños. Nada excusa a quienes pretenden vulnerar los derechos humanos de las comunidades indígenas.The full weight of the law must fall on those who promote human trafficking and the sexual exploitation of women or children. Nothing excuses those who seek to violate the human rights of indigenous communities.March 25, 2020, 2:36 p.m.
Gustavo Petro—https://twitter.com/petrogustavo Informative: 10%El virus llegó en avión a Bogotá, a sus barrios ricos, y por transmilenio se repartió a toda la ciudad.The virus arrived by plane to Bogotá, to its rich neighborhoods, and by transmilenio [rapid transit bus in Bogotá]it was distributed to the whole city.May 14, 2020, 12:19 p.m.
Political: 24%Ha muerto un médico en Bogotá por el virus. Es el reflejo del abandono de la salud. A los médico(a)s lo(a)s transformaron en obreros mal pagos y sin estabilidad, A los pacientes los transformaron en clientes, A la ciencia la volvieron negocio.A doctor in Bogotá has died from the virus. It is a reflection of the abandonment of health. Doctors were transformed into poorly paid and unstable workers, patients were transformed into clients, and science was turned into business.April 11, 2020, 4:33 p.m.
Criticism: 16%No salgan a comprar por favor. Los padres valen más que un televisor importado. No dejen ir a los niños y niñas al colegio en agosto. El gobierno está llevando a la sociedad a la enfermedad y la muerte.Please do not go out to shop. Parents are worth more than an imported television. Don't let the children go to school in August. The government is leading society to illness and death.June 19, 2020, 2:45 p.m.
Praise: 2%Fue difícil pero es una buena decisión. Ahora viene una época difícil para todas las familias colombianas pero con disciplina se superará la adversidad. Mi apoyo a su medida de confinamiento obligatorio, Duque.It was difficult but it is a good decision. Now comes a difficult time for all Colombian families but with discipline adversity will be overcome. My support for your measure of mandatory confinement, Duque.March 21, 2021, 3:36 a.m.
Other: 48%Colombia debería parar un día ante la brutalidad del Estado en contra de la niñez en nuestro país.Colombia should stop one day in the face of the brutality of the State against children in our country.June 26, 2020, 1:57 a.m.
Claudia López Hernández—https://twitter.com/ClaudiaLopez Informative: 42%3 buenas noticias para Bogotá: (1) Ayer llegaron 100.000 pruebas @Uniandes (2) Hoy llegaron otras 100.000 pruebas @SectorSalud (3) El lunes sale compra por $36.000 millones en material de bioseguridad para todo nuestro personal médico. El lunes empezamos testeo activo preventivo!3 good pieces of news for Bogotá: (1) Yesterday 100,000 tests arrived @Uniandes (2) Another 100,000 tests arrived today @SectorSalud (3) On Monday we will purchase $36 billion in biosecurity material for all our medical personnel. On Monday we start active preventive testing!April 11, 2020, 9:52 p.m.
Morale‐boosting: 2%Gracias Bogotá! Hoy hicimos el mayor ejercicio de cultura ciudadana y autocuidado de nuestra historia! La ciudadanía cumplió voluntariamente #SimulacroVitalBogota! Gracias a equipos @Bogota por su gran trabajo! Suerte a Antioquia, Santander y el Valle que comienzan hoy!Thank you Bogota! Today we did the biggest exercise in citizen culture and self‐care in our history! The citizens complied voluntarily #SimulacroVitalBogota! Thanks to the @Bogota teams for their great work! Good luck to Antioquia, Santander and the Valley starting today!March 3, 2020, 12:56 a.m.
Political: 18%Con todo respeto. Las pequeñas y medianas empresas son el corazón económico de Bogotá y Colombia. Emplean al 60% de nuestra gente. Ni siquiera les han ayudado a pagar su nómina menos a salvarlas. Y la prioridad que se está discutiendo es salvar a Avianca, una empresa extranjera?With all due respect. Small and medium‐sized companies are the economic heart of Bogota and Colombia. They employ 60% of our people. They have not even helped them to pay their payroll, let alone save them. And the priority being discussed is to save Avianca, a foreign company?April 29, 2020, 1:42 p.m.
Criticism: 18%El Gobierno Nacional que no ha cumplido con la entrega de un solo ventilador UCI provoca hoy mayor aglomeración en Bogotá. Sitios cerrados sin buena ventilación son los de mayor riesgo de contagio. ¿Subir las ventas y bajar las vidas? Qué insensatez! No cuidan y sí dañan!The National Government that has not come through with the delivery of a single ICU ventilator today causes greater agglomeration in Bogota. Closed places without good ventilation are the ones with the highest risk of contagion. Up sales and down lives? What nonsense! They do not care and they are harmful!June 19, 2020, 2:20 p.m.
Praise: 4%Esa es la decisión correcta! Agradezco al Presidente haber tenido en cuenta información epidemiológica Bogotá que indica que debemos ir hasta primera semana de Mayo. Tiempo adicional lo usaremos en más pruebas, control epidemiológico activo y ampliación de capacidad hospitalaria.That's the right decision! I thank the President for having taken into account epidemiological information from Bogotá that indicates we should go until the first week of May. Additional time will be used for more tests, active epidemiological control and expansion of hospital capacity.April 6, 2020, 11:34 p.m.
Other: 16%Es absolutamente injustificable que hagan un acuerdo para mantener las condiciones salariales de los jugadores y en cambio suspendan los contratos de las jugadoras de los equipos femeninos! @SantaFe a recapacitar y cambiar esa inaceptable discriminación! #LasLeonasSeRespetanIt is absolutely unjustifiable that they make an agreement to maintain the players' salary conditions and instead suspend the contracts of the women's teams' players! @SantaFe should rethink and change this unacceptable discrimination! #LasLeonasSeRespetanApril 7, 2020, 4:22 p.m.
Word cloud for @petrogustavo. Source: Authors' elaboration Sample Covid‐19 tweets by topic A content analysis of the 50 most popular tweets by the current president of Colombia, Duque, revealed that informative tweets dominated. The president informed the Colombian public about the measures being prepared or already being implemented in connection with the spreading coronavirus disease and explained the reasons for these measures. They included the closure of schools, restrictions on free residence within the state, and the interruption of international traffic. An example is a ban on the arrival of aircraft with international passengers at Colombian airports for 30 days. President Duque occasionally sought to support the Colombian people verbally to bear the brunt of the pandemic's negative effects. Above all, he tried to evoke feelings of patriotism. On Twitter, the president called on Colombians to join the hoisting of national flags as a symbol of unification in the fight against coronavirus. In some places, there was purely political content in presidential tweets about the coronavirus. Examples include the commentary on the neighboring regime in Venezuela, and Colombia's promise to continue social programs for Venezuelans. Tweets that praised the government or where the president praised himself or his cabinet ministers for their success in the fight against coronavirus were not among the 50 most popular tweets. Tweets praising, for instance, the mayor of Bogota for her actions were also not among the 50 most popular tweets. Duque did not use Twitter to criticize members of the government or opposition, thus manifesting as a leader who felt there were more important matters than criticism from the opposition. The current senator and former challenger to the current president, Gustavo Petro, who can be considered the leader of the Colombian opposition, compared to Duque was more diverse in terms of content in the 50 most popular tweets. He used informative tweets minimally. For example, he stated that the virus had arrived in the area by plane. There is no motivational content in any of the senator's top 50‐most‐tweeted tweets calling on Colombians to demonstrate unity or patriotism or have strength in the fight against coronavirus. Still, Petro's tweets contained comments with political content. He did not directly attack the government, but as an opposition politician, he criticized the state of Colombian healthcare, which, according to him, has turned from public service to business, resulting in poor quality care during the coronavirus crisis. The former presidential candidate also often criticized the government. He questioned, for example, the repeal of coronavirus measures and argued that the government's decision would only bring illness and death. An opposition leader once praised President Duque for imposing a quarantine on the country. He acknowledged the seriousness of the decision and openly expressed his support. Petro's tweets were also characterized by the fact that he often dealt with things unrelated to the global pandemic on Twitter. For example, Petro's tweets confronted former President Uribe over his relationship with Pablo Escobar, mentioned the involvement of Vice President Ramírez's brother in the heroin trade, and drew attention to state brutality toward Colombian children. The current mayor of Bogota and former senator López, like President Duque, was responsible for the safety of people who, in her case, were living in the Colombian capital. She often used the social network Twitter to inform the city's population about the implemented anticoronavirus measures, such as population testing. Motivational content was also in her top 50 tweets. López thanked the people of Bogota for a well‐managed anticoronavirus exercise. Her tweets also had a political charge, which was quite frequent among the 50 popular tweets. She mentioned, for example, the need to support small and medium‐sized enterprises, which had been affected by the economic repercussions of the coronavirus crisis, to the detriment of large companies. López did not hold back on criticism of the government and president. Her critical tweets were more frequent in comparison to those of her opposition colleague Petro. An example is her criticism of the promised lung ventilators, which did not reach hospitals. The mayor praised the president only twice. She positively acknowledged his idea to extend preventive isolation for a few more days. Her tweets during the period under study also included several topics not related to the coronavirus pandemic. An example is her criticism of the different levels of pay between men's and women's sports teams. There were limitations in focusing on the 50‐most‐popular tweets. We identified all original tweets sent by Petro or López and filtered out those containing the keywords Duque, “gobierno,” or “president.” We identified 521 tweets by Petro and 117 by López and evaluated the content of these tweets as to whether they were positive or negative, discovering that these tweets confirmed the findings from the 50‐most‐popular tweets relating to the criticism of the government. Figure 5 shows the number of Twitter followers gained by @IvanDuque, @ClaudiaLopez, and @petrogustavo from June 3, 2019, to June 29, 2020. On June 3, 2019, @IvanDuque started with more than 800,000 followers, @ClaudiaLopez had over 1.3 million followers, and @petrogustavo had almost 3.45 million followers.
Figure 5

Twitter followers gained each week. Source: Authors' elaboration

Twitter followers gained each week. Source: Authors' elaboration From each Twitter account, it is possible to compare the pre‐pandemic period to a period during the Covid‐19 pandemic. On March 6, 2020, the first case of Covid‐19 in Colombia was confirmed (Ministerio de Salud y Protección Social, 2020). Since that date, increased interest in news on Covid‐19 is to be expected among the public. Before the global pandemic, there were only minimal increases in the number of followers on the Twitter accounts of the president, senator, and mayor of Bogota. The only two exceptions were during the election of López in October 2019 (Argüelo, 2019), when there was increased interest in following her account, and in November 2019, when Colombians went on strike and all three selected politicians commented on the event on the social network (Newbery, 2019). This fact signals that user interest in the Twitter accounts of politicians grows at a time of significant events, something confirmed by the increase in the number of followers after the first case of coronavirus in Colombia. In the second half of March 2020, when the virus began to spread rapidly and anticoronavirus measures began to be implemented, all three politicians saw an increase in the number of followers, and in the case of Duque and López, there was a massive weekly increase. Particularly in 1 week, from March 16 until 23, 2020, @IvanDuque gained more than 120,000 followers, @ClaudiaLopez gained more than 140,000 followers, and @petrogustavo gained more than 30,000 followers. The data on the number of followers was always collected on Mondays. All Twitter follower increases were significant, but their increase differs because of the total number of followers. Petro did not gain as many followers as the president and mayor of Bogota due to the content of individual tweets. President Duque and Mayor López were responsible for the security of Colombians, or the inhabitants of Bogota. For this reason, informative tweets predominated in their case. The public was interested in information during the pandemic, so they followed the two executive politicians on Twitter. Senator Petro, as a legislator, did not have executive opportunities to deal with the crisis and provided only minimal information about Covid‐19‐related matters. As of June 29, 2020, @IvanDuque had more than 1.9 million followers, @ClaudiaLopez had over 2.3 million followers, and @petrogustavo had almost 3.9 million followers. Figure 5 shows that there is increased public interest in a politician during political events such as strikes or elections, but in times of emergency there may be a very significant increase in followers if the politician is providing citizens with information that interests them in relation to the crisis.

CONCLUSION

This study explores the use of the social network Twitter by Colombian political elites. President Duque's Twitter accounts as a representative of the ruling elite were analyzed, as well as Bogota's Mayor López, and the senator and presidential candidate Petro as a representative of the opposition. The research was carried out using quantitative methods with the programming language R, and a qualitative content analysis of the most popular tweets was also performed. From the word clouds, it was found that from the first case of Covid‐19 in Colombia, on March 6, 2020, until the end of the study period, the topic of the coronavirus crisis dominated the tweets of all three selected politicians. The course of the pandemic and anticoronavirus measures that the Colombian public should follow were often tweeted. In addition, it was noted that Duque often addressed the whole country, while López exclusively addressed Bogota, which are logical outcomes based on their positions. Both Colombia as a whole and the capital Bogotá were important in Petro's tweets, which testifies to his interest in becoming the country's president, while taking into account the inhabitants of the capital as a former mayor. A content analysis of the top 50‐most‐popular tweets reveals that President Duque's tweets were largely informative, which relates to the fact that, as head of the executive branch, he was responsible for timely information and the safety of Colombians. López was in a similar situation, often informing the people of Bogota about the measures taken, but as a representative of the opposition she also criticized the government. Petro's tweets were more diverse in terms of content, since he was not responsible for information for and safety of the population as a senator, so he had significantly fewer informative tweets in comparison. Instead, he often addressed the political agenda, including issues not directly related to the global pandemic. During the crisis, there was also a significant increase in the number of followers on Twitter for all three politicians and a rapid increase for the president and mayor of Bogota, which is natural, since the two had information that was important to the public. There is room for further research in several areas. First, it is possible to expand research and analyze the discourse of other political elites, such as members of Congress. We found that 87% of all retweets of tweets sent by members of Congress during the analyzed period could be attributed to only 10% of the members of Congress with Twitter accounts. Therefore, a small majority of congress members dominate the Twitter‐sphere in Colombia, but further analysis lies outside the scope of this investigation. These results are presented in the Appendix, and we encourage further research in this direction. We looked for differences in information between government and opposition parties because, due to the nature of the presidential system, it is possible that even congress members from government parties had reservations about how the government approached the crisis. It is also possible to focus on the reactions of other political elites and representatives of civil society to the contents of the tweets of selected politicians—whether they criticized them or, on the contrary, valued their awareness. The research demonstrates that, in times of crisis, the political elite and the public can agree on several things (Merkley et al., 2020). When the coronavirus crisis is over, the government's actions can be evaluated to assess whether they have been timely and effective, and attention can be paid to whether this might open topics for many politicians such as population security, healthcare quality, and the role of the public sector. A comparison of coronavirus and postcoronavirus agenda setting on Twitter could be carried out. In any case, the coronavirus crisis has proved to be an opportunity to strengthen the communication reach of politicians on the social network Twitter, from which they can benefit in their further political activities when the crisis is over.
  4 in total

1.  Social Media Use in Emergency Response to Natural Disasters: A Systematic Review With a Public Health Perspective.

Authors:  Kamalich Muniz-Rodriguez; Sylvia K Ofori; Lauren C Bayliss; Jessica S Schwind; Kadiatou Diallo; Manyun Liu; Jingjing Yin; Gerardo Chowell; Isaac Chun-Hai Fung
Journal:  Disaster Med Public Health Prep       Date:  2020-02       Impact factor: 1.385

2.  Colombian political leaders on Twitter during the Covid-19 pandemic.

Authors:  Michael Haman; Milan Školník; Jan Čopík
Journal:  Lat Am Policy       Date:  2022-04-19

3.  World leaders' usage of Twitter in response to the COVID-19 pandemic: a content analysis.

Authors:  Sohaib R Rufai; Catey Bunce
Journal:  J Public Health (Oxf)       Date:  2020-08-18       Impact factor: 2.341

4.  Misinformation about spinal manipulation and boosting immunity: an analysis of Twitter activity during the COVID-19 crisis.

Authors:  Greg Kawchuk; Jan Hartvigsen; Steen Harsted; Casper Glissmann Nim; Luana Nyirö
Journal:  Chiropr Man Therap       Date:  2020-06-09
  4 in total
  1 in total

1.  Colombian political leaders on Twitter during the Covid-19 pandemic.

Authors:  Michael Haman; Milan Školník; Jan Čopík
Journal:  Lat Am Policy       Date:  2022-04-19
  1 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.