| Literature DB >> 35570360 |
Abstract
This study highlights how people get important information on COVID-19 according to age groups by employing social network analysis for Twitter. First, people have different key players according to the age groups. For example, while universities and journals play a crucial role in the adults' networks, news media have a significant impact on the elderly's networks. Second, people have different characteristics of social network groups according to age. For example, people belong to small groups, and barely communicate with others across the groups in the teens' networks, whereas people in each group have strong communication networks with other groups in the elderly's networks. Third, this study shows that people utilise different domains to share COVID-19 information according to age. For example, while twitter.com ranks first in the children, teens, and elderly's networks, cnn.com places first in the adults' networks.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; age; coronavirus; social network analysis; twitter
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35570360 PMCID: PMC9348123 DOI: 10.1002/hpm.3500
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Health Plann Manage ISSN: 0749-6753
Descriptive statistics
| Graph metric | Children | Teens | Adults | Elderly |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Graph‐type | Directed | Directed | Directed | Directed |
| Vertices | 18,064 | 1496 | 16,563 | 17,297 |
| Unique edges | 30,629 | 2083 | 17,977 | 25,131 |
| Edges with duplicates | 4183 | 175 | 5287 | 1992 |
| Total edges | 34,812 | 2258 | 23,264 | 27,123 |
| Self‐loops | 1840 | 297 | 1193 | 2053 |
| Reciprocated vertex pair ratio | 0.008 | 0.029 | 0.010 | 0.010 |
| Reciprocated edge ratio | 0.016 | 0.057 | 0.020 | 0.020 |
| Connected components | 1751 | 391 | 1300 | 2189 |
| Single‐vertex connected components | 652 | 155 | 541 | 904 |
| Maximum vertices in a connected component | 12,040 | 73 | 12,592 | 10,135 |
| Maximum edges in a connected component | 26,783 | 318 | 18,079 | 18,372 |
| Maximum geodesic distance (diameter) | 23 | 6 | 19 | 25 |
| Average geodesic distance | 6.040 | 1.911 | 4.545 | 6.831 |
| Graph density | 0.000 | 0.001 | 0.000 | 0.000 |
| Modularity | 0.833 | 0.848 | 0.784 | 0.878 |
| Minimum PageRank | 0.222 | 0.292 | 0.260 | 0.221 |
| Maximum PageRank | 750 | 22 | 1843 | 335 |
| Average PageRank | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 |
| Median PageRank | 0.549 | 0.749 | 0.529 | 0.573 |
Top 20 key players in children
| No | PR | Name | Description | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | D1 | 750.3 | Amalina | Doctor of Medicine in London |
| 2 | D2 | 510.8 | Zoë Hyde | Doctor at the University of Western Medical School |
| 3 | O1 | 170.2 | UNICEF | Humanitarian Aid Organisation |
| 4 | O2 | 130.0 | WHO | World Health Organisation |
| 5 | O3 | 120.0 | WHO African Region | WHO African |
| 6 | P1 | 95.2 | Scott Morrison | The Prime Minister of Australia |
| 7 | T1 | 85.2 | Melinda Gates | Amaerican Philanthropist Co‐founded the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation |
| 8 | O4 | 76.2 | UN Human Rights | Organisation for Human Right |
| 9 | D3 | 75.8 | Kerryn Phelps | One of Australia's Best‐Known Doctors |
| 10 | P2 | 54.0 | Justin Trudeau | Prime Minister of Canada |
| 11 | R1 | 52.8 | Henrietta H. Fore | Executive Director of UNICEF |
| 12 | A1 | 45.9 | Agnes Callamard | Human Rights Activist |
| 13 | P3 | 37.1 | Greg Abbott | Governor of Texas |
| 14 | O5 | 34.4 | Amer Acad Paediatrics | The American Academy of Paediatrics for the Health of all Children. |
| 15 | F1 | 33.5 | Azra Ghani | Professor of Infectious Disease Epidemiology at Imperial College London |
| 16 | N1 | 29.2 | RT | Russian International Television Network |
| 17 | R2 | 27.8 | Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyes | Director General of the World Health Organisation |
| 18 | P4 | 26.9 | Gary Gannon | Irish Social Democrats Politician |
| 19 | P5 | 26.1 | SAnna Marin | Prime Minister of Finland |
| 20 | P6 | 25.9 | Hanna Kosonen | Minister of Science and Culture in Finland |
Abbreviations: Activists, A; D, Doctors; Professor, F; Institute, I; Journals, J; News media, N; Organisation, O; Politicians, P; PR, PageRank; R, Researcher; T, other; U, Universities.
Top 20 key players in teens
| No | PR | Name | Description | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | O1 | 21.5 | American Psychological Association | The Largest Organisation of Psychologists in the US |
| 2 | I1 | 13.0 | Indiana State Department of Health | The Indiana State Department of Health |
| 3 | O2 | 12.2 | MentalHealthFirstAid | National Programme for Mental Illness and Substance Use |
| 4 | I2 | 10.8 | Ottawa public health | Ottawa's Health Information, Programs & Services |
| 5 | O3 | 8.9 | Healthychildren | Official Parenting Website of the American Academy of Paediatrics |
| 6 | F1 | 6.2 | Miranda van Tilburg | Professor of Clinical Research at Campbell Univeristy |
| 7 | A1 | 6.2 | Mandy Sanghera | International Human Rights Activist |
| 8 | O4 | 4.4 | Bullying UK | UK Charity |
| 9 | N1 | 4.0 | SchoolLibraryJournal | American Monthly Magazine for Young People |
| 10 | O5 | 3.9 | JED | Organisation for Teens and Young Adults |
| 11 | O6 | 3.9 | Human Rights Campaign | The Largest LGBTQ Advocacy Group |
| 12 | O7 | 3.6 | Junior Achievement | Global Non‐Profit Youth Organisation |
| 13 | O8 | 3.5 | Minding Your Mind | Organisation for Ending Stigma and Destructive Behaviours Associated With Mental Health Issues |
| 14 | N2 | 3.4 | CNBC | The World Leader in Business NEWS |
| 15 | A2 | 3.0 | Jamie Margolin | American Climate Justice Activist |
| 16 | O9 | 2.9 | NAGC | Promotes Awareness of the Needs of Children and Teens |
| 17 | O10 | 2.9 | C. Elizabeth Dougherty | Organisation for Supporting Children, Youth and Adults Facing Complex Illness |
| 18 | O11 | 2.7 | NCMEC | National Centre for Missing and Exploited Children |
| 19 | N3 | 2.6 | news.com.au | Australia's #1 News Site |
| 20 | N4 | 2.6 | Local 12/WKRC‐TV | Cincinnati's Trusted Source for Breaking News |
Top 20 key players in adults
| No | PR | Name | Description | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | I1 | 1842.8 | CDC | The Centres For Disease Control And Prevention |
| 2 | U1 | 162.7 | UC san Francisco | The University of California, San Francisco |
| 3 | D1 | 132.8 | Dena Grayson | American Medical Doctor |
| 4 | R1 | 73.5 | Eric Feigl‐ding | American Public Health Scientist |
| 5 | F1 | 60.3 | Mehmet Oz | Columbia University professor |
| 6 | U2 | 60.2 | RoyalCollegeObsGyn | The Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists |
| 7 | O1 | 47.1 | WHO | World Health Organisation |
| 8 | O2 | 39.8 | Sport England | Non‐Departmental Public Body |
| 9 | O3 | 38.8 | WHO South‐East Asia | WHO South‐East Asia |
| 10 | O4 | 34.5 | The RCM | British Midwives Organisation |
| 11 | J1 | 30.2 | Microbes & Infection | Journal for Infection & Immunity |
| 12 | P1 | 29.9 | John Cornyn | United States Senator |
| 13 | I2 | 26.3 | Health Canada and PHAC | Agency of the Government of Canada for Public Health |
| 14 | F2 | 24.3 | Zoë Hyde | Faculty at the University of Western Medical School |
| 15 | O5 | 18.8 | WHO African Region | WHO African Region |
| 16 | P2 | 18.7 | Steve Herman | America's White House Bureau Chief |
| 17 | J2 | 16.6 | JAMA | The Journal of the American Medical Association |
| 18 | I3 | 15.3 | HHS.gov | United States Department of Health and Human Services |
| 19 | U3 | 14.4 | HarvardPublicHealth | Public health School of Harvard University |
| 20 | U4 | 14.4 | CCDD at Harvard Chan | The Centre for Communicable Disease Dynamics at Harvard |
Top 20 key players in elderly
| No | PR | Name | Description | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | R1 | 335.1 | BlueSky | Researcher IT Consultant/Software Engineer |
| 2 | N1 | 165.7 | QuickTake by bloomberg | Global News the World Needs Today |
| 3 | I1 | 161.8 | CDC | Centres for Disease Control and Prevention |
| 4 | N2 | 111.6 | OffGuardian | Independent News and Opinion Website |
| 5 | F1 | 106.2 | Christian Christensen | Professor of Journalism at Stockholm Univ |
| 6 | P1 | 86.1 | Andrew Cuomo | Governor of New York |
| 7 | F2 | 69.6 | Jane Philpott | Dean of the Queen's University Faculty of Health Sciences |
| 8 | O1 | 61.1 | World Economic Forum | Organisation for Improving the State of the World |
| 9 | N3 | 53.8 | BBC Radio 4 Today | BBC's long‐running early morning news |
| 10 | P2 | 53.0 | Helen Whately | British conservative party politician who was appointed Minister of State at the Department of Health and Social Care |
| 11 | P3 | 41.8 | Donald J. Trump | The US President |
| 12 | T1 | 39.7 | Social Media Company | |
| 13 | R2 | 34.9 | Zaeem Zia | Director Health Information Systems GB/District Health Officer |
| 14 | P3 | 31.1 | Yediyurappa | Chief Minister of Karnataka |
| 15 | O2 | 30.1 | Workers party of Britain | Organisation for workers Party of Britain |
| 16 | N4 | 27.4 | Science News | American Bi‐Weekly Magazine |
| 17 | O3 | 26.6 | Code of Vets™ | Organisation Dedicated to Assisting America's Veterans. |
| 18 | P4 | 26.3 | David Vance | American Politician |
| 19 | A1 | 23.4 | Shaun King | American Writer, Civil Rights Activist |
| 20 | A2 | 22.5 | Vanessa Beeley | British Activist and Blogger |
FIGURE 1PageRank
FIGURE 2Social networks for the typical case
FIGURE 3Social networks for groups
Top five domains in the networks
| Children | Teens | Adults | Elderly | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Domains | Count | Domains | Count | Domains | Count | Domains | Count | |
| 1 | twitter.com | 362 | twitter.com | 45 | cnn.com | 235 | twitter.com | 393 |
| 2 | gofundme.com | 105 | slj.com | 20 | twitter.com | 227 | weforum.org | 173 |
| 3 | techfordaddy.com | 80 | youtube.com | 15 | cdc.gov | 39 | cbc.ca | 82 |
| 4 | co.uk | 74 | co.uk | 11 | co.uk | 34 | co.uk | 59 |
| 5 | com.au | 57 | npr.org | 11 | org.uk | 27 | youtube.com | 54 |