| Literature DB >> 35505383 |
David P Kennedy1, Karen Chan Osilla2, Joan S Tucker3.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Social networks may play positive and negative roles in the lives of young adults experiencing homelessness (YEH) who are transitioning into housing. Social networks can influence their alcohol and/or other drug (AOD) use, as well as provide immediate and long-term support necessary for a successful transition.Entities:
Keywords: Alcohol and other drug use; Data visualization; EgoWeb 2.0; Homelessness; Housing first; Motivational interviewing; Social network intervention; Transitional age youth
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35505383 PMCID: PMC9066760 DOI: 10.1186/s13722-022-00307-4
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Addict Sci Clin Pract ISSN: 1940-0632
Fig. 1Example figures from hypothetical MI-SNI session. Network contacts are represented by circles (graph “nodes”) and lines between nodes represent network contacts who interacted with each other in the past 2 weeks. The layout of the nodes, generated with the Fruchterman–Reingold force-directed placement algorithm highlights structural characteristics of the network, such as isolates (completely disconnected nodes) and components (a set of nodes tied together but disconnected from other nodes). The structural layout is consistent across the three diagrams. The “Connections” figure on the left (a) uses node color, node size, and line thickness to highlight other characteristics of the network structure, including the centrality of network actors (depicted by larger and darker nodes) and stronger relationship ties between actors (highlighted with thicker lines). The other figures use node size and color to highlight network composition. The AOD use figure in the middle highlights drinking and drug use partners with size and color ranging from small green nodes (no AOD use by network member) to large red nodes (participant uses with more than usual). The “Support” figure on the right depicts network members with size and color (large purple = supportive now and in the future, small purple = supportive now only, small orange = not supportive)
Illustrative quotes for acceptability theme
| Theme | Participant quotes |
|---|---|
| Understandability | [BT12]: “It all made sense” [BT13]: “It’s fairly straightforward and for a majority of people…Did a good job at making it clear.” [BT11]: “It went smoothly. It was easy to comprehend what was going on.” |
| Enjoyability and Ease of use | [BT32]: (Q: Why would you recommend it?) “Just for its simplicity: one, two, three. It won’t take you too long…I think that it's super simplistic, super straightforward…It doesn’t take long at all, so people that have anxiety and stuff can easily do this session…The length of it’s fine. That’s actually perfect for people with anxiety like myself. I don’t like really sitting down for too long and having to answer a lot of questions. So, this is perfect…I was just like, okay, this is going by actually pretty fast.” [BT14]: “I didn’t feel like it was long…It’s not that long… I thought it was really good, the length was good.” [BT14]: “It’d be interesting. Very interesting because it’s definitely going to change, at least for me it would change a lot…There’s weeks where I’m here a lot, weeks where I’m out a lot, like you’re at school or looking for a job…So there’s just a lot of people that I actually talk to…you said it was going to be four times? Well, if you do…that would helpful.” [BT14]: “It doesn’t only have to be about this. It can be about other stuff. It can be used for high school students…This is actually a very versatile thing.” [BT31]: “I enjoyed it. It was very relaxing. I didn't really feel stressed out. And I just had surgery a couple days ago…I really enjoyed this. This was very fun…I thought I was going to dread today… but I enjoyed it. I really had fun.” [BT12]: “I actually liked it.” [BT14]: “I actually liked this.” [BT32:] “It’s not really invasive, like most questionnaires would be [BT32]: “I think I liked everything.” |
| Barriers to acceptability | [BT14]: “For me, I can’t sit through things like that…so it’s helpful that somebody was right there trying to help doing it.” [BT14]: “Just how you’re saying it is like it would be when you do the two-week intervals, would be the best thing.” [BT32:] “It’s kind of weird, especially from the angle that I was doing it. She is my case manager, so it’s even weirder to peer over her shoulder. So, I was like, um…I don’t like doing this…if I was going to be forced to do this, I would have just said anything to get it over with.” [BT32:] “When I first moved in here, I don’t think I would have done this…Because before this I was homeless. I was not really in…anywhere, so I really didn’t communicate with anybody. Before that I was in a shelter, and even then I didn’t talk to anybody except the case manager to help me find housing. So I think it would be something that would be more appropriate if it was somebody who was here for maybe one month. Who they start making connections with here.” [BT13]: “I’m not really too keen on documenting all that. I’d rather do it on my own than…you know, be more private about it…I know you guys are confidential everything and all that, but it’s just the way that I feel.” [BT13]: “It’s something that’s pretty obvious that a lot of people do without even really realizing…it crosses people’s minds about how their relationships are and who they should interact with more, and who are the real supportive people and then who are the people that are just enablers and whatnot.” ([added]: “But nobody does it as thoroughly”) [BT11]: “Maybe offering a plan, like okay, what did you not like? Asking specific questions about the graphs or whatever and then being like what can you do, who can you go to to get what you need, or just coming up with a little plan for the next two weeks to refer to… because that was me coming up with…and my best thinking got me in a homeless shelter.” |
Illustrative quotes for positive benefits theme
| Theme | Participant quotes |
|---|---|
| Learning/new insights | [BT12]: “It would maybe make you realize more.” [BT13]: “The possibility’s always there that it can make them more aware and change their life” [BT14]: “Just how everybody that I talk to is connected. It made me think about their relationship… And I was over here thinking I wonder what their relationship’s like?” [BT31]: “And it made me kind of learn that I actually have to go through with my goals.” [BT31]: “I learned who supports me and who I can depend on.” [BT12]: “Made me realize…my community that I reach out to and stay connected to.” [BT11]:“It doesn’t offer a solution. It just offers a note of self-awareness but it doesn’t offer any solutions. If they just have that information but no way to change it, then they’re not going to make a change.” |
| Enhancement of motivation to change | [BT31]: “I benefitted from it and I've been here for seven months and I want to change.” [BT32:] “You might learn something and you might change your outcome—your outcome might change your whole entire life.” [BT13]: “It can make them more aware and change their life” [BT12]: “It depends like your point of view, how motivated you are” [BT14]: (Q: would it be interesting to see what the change is?) “It’d be interesting. Very interesting because it’s definitely going to change, at least for me it would change a lot because I’m always doing different things. There’s weeks where I’m here a lot, weeks where I’m out a lot, like you’re at school or looking for a job…So there’s just a lot of people that I actually talk to.” [BT11]:[counter example]: “If they just have that information but no way to change it, then they’re not going to make a change.” |
| Making AOD changes | [BT31]: “Anybody who wants to make a change in their life and is willing to stop their substance abuse or anything, I feel like they can benefit from it.” [BT32:] “People that are reluctant to talk about their substance abuse would be more open to doing so in this format.” [BT11]: “Just thinking about who do I talk to on a daily basis. Are they supportive in my life? If I was in that mindset, would I use with these people and would they enable me to use with them? It was good to think about that.” |
| Building social support | [BT11]: “That might give them the motivation they need to get someone in their life that they can rely on…they can start creating a stable foundation for themselves if they’re unhappy with their support or lack of support in their life currently.” [BT13]: “I think it would help them adjust…Like how much you really interact with those people and whether or not they’re going to be helpful at the moment or if they’re going through it themselves, or if they’re an enabler, or just those people that are genuinely supportive and will continue to be supportive.” [BT31]: “I wish—like there's a boy… who used to be here. He had a substance abuse problem, a drinking problem, and he just got exited. I wish that this would have been there when he was here, because I know he personally could have benefited from this and I know that he needs it… he has a problem and he needed help and this probably would have helped. And it would have made him realize everyone who supports him and you know, how to cut people out and it would have—he would have benefitted so much from it. And I just wish he could have did it.” |
| Usefulness to some but not others | [BT12]: “It depends like your point of view, how motivated you are.” [BT13]: “For me personally, it’s not really helpful for me as an individual...I got my own whole plan that I don’t necessarily share with anybody…for somebody else that hasn’t really thought about it too much and is not as aware as I am, I think it would be a lot more helpful for them. I see that it can do a lot of good and really help other people…It depends on who they are, the little bit of information that they divulge, I guess.” [BT13]: “But there’s a lot of people that I know that could really benefit from this type of thing because it really puts it out there how these relationships with certain people affect everything.” [BT13]: “If you’re willing to really take into consideration everything that is given to you clearly on the diagrams and all that, and makes you want to change your environment; then yeah, I think it would really help.” [BT13]: “The possibility’s always there that it can make them more aware and change their life, I guess.” [BT13]: “For a majority of people that come through here, I think it would be helpful for some. For—yeah, for most, actually.” [BT14]: “It would be good for somebody who’s been here a while.” [BT31]: “Maybe for other people, like I'm pretty advanced and I'm pretty smart. So, I get things more than an average person does. So, I can't judge. I don't really know a lot of these people here. So, maybe you could do it like more intuitive for people who don't understand but also not make it too complicated.” [BT31]: “Yeah, I mean, if anybody is willing to make a change in their life, it's beneficial for them…But they have to want to make a change…Because you can't save somebody who doesn't want to be saved.” [BT32]: “It’s really depending upon the person’s struggle.” [BT32]: “It’s going to be like a challenge for those people that are trying to change their patterns, like change their life. Because if they have to name people that they don’t even associate with and they see that result, it’s like…this means nothing then.” |
Illustrative quotes for visualization reactions theme
| Theme | Participant quotes |
|---|---|
| General positive comments | [BT14]: “Just seeing the different graphs” [BT11]: “I liked the visualization of the support system.” [BT32]: “I enjoyed seeing the diagrams. It’s like the first time that I’ve seen any type of diagram system, so it was nice.” |
| Understandability | [BT11]: “I think it was helpful in the way that it kind of validated like I’m not alone and I do have a lot of people that I can depend on that…I don’t just have people in my life that I talk to constantly that aren’t there for me. I have people in my life I talk to that care about me. So that’s good to validate that.” [BT12]: “It shows you the people that are connected with each other and know each other…the fact that it gets you out of your head and it’s more organized. It’s on paper and you can look at it a little more clearly. That’s a big plus” [BT13]: “It made sense to me but it’s not really helpful…I believe everybody’s different, so a majority of people are visual learners. I believe it will help the majority of the people that come through.” [BT31]: “I feel like the ones who support you are important, but I feel like the ones who are not supportive of you are important, as well; that should stick out more because you need to understand, like, why—if those people you can't be supported by them, then you have to realize within yourself why you need to let them go, if they're not going to support you—like how I said, if it's not beneficial for you, you shouldn't really have it…Maybe—because red is a very stick-out color, so red—I like that for support, but you also need to find another color that's bright and brings your eye up, to make you realize these people don't support you.” |
| New insights | [BT11]: “Seeing the interconnectedness of my interpersonal relationships, that was interesting…I have good groups of people in my life that are different but are equally reliable.” [BT12]: “You can figure out your connections and your…the kind of people that you’re connected and trusted.” [BT12]: “Being able to compare the relationships, not just with you and those people that you list, but with those people between them, too and how each person can affect you…helps you compare how you interact with certain people versus the people that are more supportive and whatnot.” [BT14]: “I was able to actually see my relationships and how they are built, whether I can talk to people, whether I hang out with them and do substances and drinking with them.” [BT14]: “Didn’t really think about that because I talk to these people every day, and then I saw it and I’m like I didn’t realize that they knew…that I’ve introduced them and they’ve talked before.” [BT31]: “I liked the graphs…to make me realize and understand I have these people who support me, even though just saying it, seeing it is a whole different thing and knowing these are the people I have support and that they support me.” [BT32]: “The showing of like your support groups and the people that may have an impact on you if they’re users and whatnot. That way you can see really—like actually put into visual who’s not helping you anymore and why your life is the way it is…It was just these are your circles and this is where the lines go. They might be chaotic but that’s because your life is, well, this is based off you, you know?” [BT32]: “The diagram showed how many people are not there and how many people are maybe there.” |
| Triggering changes in social support | [BT11]: “That might give them the motivation they need to get someone in their life that they can rely on.” [BT11]: “I could use that as a tool to reevaluate some relationships I have in my life.” [BT12]: “I learned the difference between the people that are connected and motivated. And we reach out to each other…And I probably…I noticed the people that I wouldn’t hang out with, you know?” [BT14]: “At the end you can see who’s been the constant, right there. And then decide…. you can see what you’re doing and how you can change it, who you’re hanging out with, who’s been somebody that you’re always in communication with.” [BT14]: “It kind of made me realize that I need to build more connections…when I saw it was all connected it helped me because I was like I need to build better connections, more personal connections…Because if you do, either when they leave or you leave, you can keep in contact and you can just have somebody there always like that, who understands where you’re coming from and just helps you out.” [BT32]: “The people that are outside sources are labeled even in the visuals as outside sources…that way you can see like if you need help, you can reach out to these outside sources.” [BT32]: (Q: Do you think seeing the diagrams will help people turn to support more?) “I would imagine so. That was my thought process when I saw it all…as I was seeing it visually, I was like, yeah, I would turn to these people more often than these other people.” [BT32]: (Q: Do you think seeing the diagrams will help people change their social networks?) “If they’re openminded with their representation of what works and what doesn’t, you know, just based off their diagram alone might help them redesign their social networking structure. Maybe.” |
| Triggering changes in AOD use | [BT12]: (Q: Do you think seeing the diagrams will help residents change their drinking?): “Because (they) pretty much…guide you… Showed you…the people that you don’t have healthy relationships with.” [BT14]: “It shows you who you’re most likely to drink with versus who you’re most likely not to, so you’re going to be like, okay, I’m not going to hang out with person, he’s having drinks. So limit or set boundaries for myself and for them.” [BT32]: (Q: Do you think seeing the diagrams will help residents change their drinking?): “Possibly…Because the way that it’s formatted makes you really think about things. But at the same time, if the person isn’t really willing and does the session, it could go either way.” |
Illustrative quotes for MI-SNI interface reactions theme
| Theme | Participant quotes |
|---|---|
| Name listing | (Q: was it difficult naming 15 people?) [BT11]: “Kind of hard.” [BT12]: “Not at all…Fifteen; I think that’s a good amount of people.” [BT13]: “Moderately, just on the spot…by the end of the 15 names I thought of another whole different set of names that I could have said and changed the outcome of the graphs and all that.” [BT14]: “It was a lot of people to really think about. I was like okay, 15 people. I was kind of reaching for people that I actually talk to…I feel like it’s too many…Ten to 12, maybe. Ten or 11. Ten, 11, 12, one of those because… for me it’s like I’m homeless, I do use some substances and I don’t like to have a big circle. I have little, close people that may know what I do or I do it with them, I get it from them and stuff like that. That’s for me. Because some of those people I talk to only in here, not outside of here…I wish I would have brought my cell phone so I could see who I’ve been talking to.” [BT31]: “That actually wasn't very hard.” [BT32]: “Some people such as myself, we don’t have 15 people to name off. Sometimes we only have like three people in our lives…(Q: But you were able to come up with 15?) They just weren’t all close buddies…I don’t really talk to people so it’s like this is hard. So that comes up, it’s going to be like a challenge for those people that are trying to change their patterns, like change their life. Because if they have to name people that they don’t even associate with and they see that result, it’s like…this means nothing then…Like incorporate even it’s just somebody that you say hello to once in a while, whether it’s a good person or a bad person. Just notate it like if you don’t have many people in your life, basically, include any outside sources.” [BT14]: (Q: was it comfortable providing names?) “The people that I named I know wouldn’t mind if I talked about them like that… if I come up with nicknames and stuff, later in time I’m going to be like, who the hell is this?…If I gave initials, I’m like, oh, this is going to be this person and this person, but who was I talking about?” |
| Discussions of screen wording | [BT11]: “The one part where it says people that you would use with and it says use a normal amount and then use more than—I think I’m a real addict, so there is no normal use for me. When I use, it’s excessive and there’s no moderation and there’s no control. So I think when non-addicts take it, they can relate to that and be like oh, yeah, I didn’t really want to get that fucked up. But if a real addict like me is taking it, every time with everyone if I ever use with them, it would be excessive. Every time.” [BT14]: “I liked how they asked about, what are your immediate goals, what do you want to accomplish?” [BT31]: “I also liked the way that the questions were worded and how you worded them to get the point across and also it helped me understand more better.. I probably wouldn't have said the right thing or what I actually meant, if the questions were worded differently…Also the choices that you had were very good choices. Do you know what I'm talking about? Like when you pick the two things, they were good choices, too.” [BT31]: “I would like to pick more than just two places to improve, because I wanted to pick all of them, because I feel like I need all of them. I need to improve my mental health and substance abuse and get out of here and keep my job and—you know? So if there could be more options.” [BT31]: “And then I noticed with the substance use, there wasn't an option for “using less with”…Because I don't want to be using the same amount. I want to slowly go off, to where eventually I'm at a point where I don't need it anymore. I don't have to do it. I've found different coping skills, I've found another way, you know?…Because I don't want to use more, I don't want to use the same. I want to slowly use less.” [BT31]: “It felt very scripted and very monotone and not flowing…I would rather have it to where she just says what rolls off right and it doesn't feel like she's being, say this and this and—you know?” |
| Computer interface | [BT13]: “I guess nowadays it’d be a lot easier doing it on a computer. But I think that they should get a case manager or somebody else to be there with them and bring up new ideas that they’re not necessarily thinking of at the moment.” [BT32]: “Sometimes the pages become extremely too bright. So in technical format, dull it down. Dull the brightness down.” |