Christoph Gerke1,2, Irene Zabala Gutierrez1, Diego Méndez-González2,3, M Carmen Iglesias-de la Cruz2,3, Francisca Mulero4, Daniel Jaque2,3,5, Jorge Rubio-Retama1,2. 1. Department of Chemistry in Pharmaceutical Sciences, Faculty of Pharmacy, Complutense University of Madrid, 28040 Madrid, Spain. 2. Ramón y Cajal Institute for Health Research (IRYCIS), Ctra. Colmenar Viejo, 28034 Madrid, Spain. 3. Nanomaterials for Bioimaging Group, Departamento de Fisiología, Facultad de Medicina, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Avda. Arzobispo Morcillo 2, 28029 Madrid, Spain. 4. Molecular Imaging Unit, Spanish National Cancer Research Centre (CNIO), C. de Melchor Fernández Almagro 3, 28029 Madrid, Spain. 5. Departamento de Física de Materiales, Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, 28049 Madrid, Spain.
Abstract
We present a simple methodology to design a pretargeted drug delivery system, based on clickable anti-programmed death ligand 1 (anti-PD-L1) antibodies (Abs) and clickable bovine serum albumin (BSA) nanoparticles (NPs). Pretargeted drug delivery is based on the decoupling of a targeting moiety and a drug-delivering vector which can then react in vivo after separate injections. This may be key to achieve active targeting of drug-delivering NPs toward cancerous tissue. In pretargeted approaches, drug-delivering NPs were observed to accumulate in a higher amount in the targeted tissue due to shielding-related enhanced blood circulation and size-related enhanced tissue penetration. In this work, BSA NPs were produced using the solvent precipitation methodology that renders colloidally stable NPs, which were subsequently functionalized with a clickable moiety based on chlorosydnone (Cl-Syd). Those reactive groups are able to specifically react with dibenzocyclooctyne (DBCO) groups in a click-type fashion, reaching second-order reaction rate constants as high as 1.9 M-1·s-1, which makes this reaction highly suitable for in vivo applications. The presence of reactive Cl-Syd was demonstrated by reacting the functionalized NPs with a DBCO-modified sulfo-cyanine-5 dye. With this reaction, it was possible to infer the number of reactive moieties per NPs. Finally, and with the aim of demonstrating the suitability of this system to be used in pretargeted strategies, functionalized fluorescent NPs were used to label H358 cells with a clickable anti-PD-L1 Ab, applying the reaction between Cl-Syd and DBCO as corresponding clickable groups. The results of these experiments demonstrate the bio-orthogonality of the system to perform the reaction in vitro, in a period as short as 15 min.
We present a simple methodology to design a pretargeted drug delivery system, based on clickable anti-programmed death ligand 1 (anti-PD-L1) antibodies (Abs) and clickable bovine serum albumin (BSA) nanoparticles (NPs). Pretargeted drug delivery is based on the decoupling of a targeting moiety and a drug-delivering vector which can then react in vivo after separate injections. This may be key to achieve active targeting of drug-delivering NPs toward cancerous tissue. In pretargeted approaches, drug-delivering NPs were observed to accumulate in a higher amount in the targeted tissue due to shielding-related enhanced blood circulation and size-related enhanced tissue penetration. In this work, BSA NPs were produced using the solvent precipitation methodology that renders colloidally stable NPs, which were subsequently functionalized with a clickable moiety based on chlorosydnone (Cl-Syd). Those reactive groups are able to specifically react with dibenzocyclooctyne (DBCO) groups in a click-type fashion, reaching second-order reaction rate constants as high as 1.9 M-1·s-1, which makes this reaction highly suitable for in vivo applications. The presence of reactive Cl-Syd was demonstrated by reacting the functionalized NPs with a DBCO-modified sulfo-cyanine-5 dye. With this reaction, it was possible to infer the number of reactive moieties per NPs. Finally, and with the aim of demonstrating the suitability of this system to be used in pretargeted strategies, functionalized fluorescent NPs were used to label H358 cells with a clickable anti-PD-L1 Ab, applying the reaction between Cl-Syd and DBCO as corresponding clickable groups. The results of these experiments demonstrate the bio-orthogonality of the system to perform the reaction in vitro, in a period as short as 15 min.
The development of
innovative approaches for targeted therapy (drug
delivery) of selective areas is of utter importance in current biomedical
and clinical research, especially for oncology. The cytotoxicity of
most drugs applied in chemotherapy limits the amount of the drug which
can be administrated, potentially resulting in an ineffective concentration
in the diseased tumor tissue. Furthermore, they cause severe adverse
effects, affecting patients’ quality of life during chemotherapy.[1,2] These two aspects make a targeted application of such drugs highly
desirable. Despite the efforts in recent years and numerous publications
in this area, only very few approaches succeed the translation into
clinics. Especially, targeted therapies based on nanoparticles (NPs)
are still falling well short of their expectations with only a very
small number of FDA-approved treatments in oncology.[3] Most established NP-based drug formulations are Doxil (liposomal
doxorubicin)[4] and Abraxane (albumin NP
bound paclitaxel).[5] Despite a significant
reduction of side effects, both these types of formulations solely
make use of a less effective passive (EPR-based) accumulation in the
tumoral tissue. An active targeting (receptor-mediated targeting)
of tumors using NP-based formulations is currently not approved by
the FDA. A possibility to overcome this current lack of clinical translation
could be the combination of cancer-specific antibodies (Abs), especially
those already established in clinics, such as anti-human epidermal
growth factor receptor 2 or anti-programmed death ligand 1 (anti-PD-L1)
Abs, with NP-based drug-delivering vectors. Direct conjugation of
the Abs to the NPs showed to be not an optimal option, resulting in
many cases in a similar or in an even lower tumor accumulation compared
to a passive accumulation of the non-functionalized NPs in comparison
to their Ab-functionalized counterparts.[6,7] A possible
explanation is the drastic increase in the hydrodynamic diameter of
the NP size once they are functionalized with Abs or even with Fab
and F(ab)2 fragments, which then affects their distribution
or EPR-based tumor uptake. The second explanation is the enhanced
recognition of Ab-functionalized NPs by the reticuloendothelial system
(RES). In fact, some reports suggest that properly shielded NPs can
feature longer circulation times compared to Ab-functionalized NPs.[8,9]A possible solution that is showing promising results in primary
in vitro and in vivo tests is the so-called pretargeted drug delivery.
In pretargeted approaches, an active targeting molecule, such as an
Ab or a peptide, is previously injected into an organism, resulting
in an abundant accumulation at the targeted site. After its accumulation,
a drug-delivering system, which is known to be well shielded from
the RES and thus has a long circulation time, is subsequently injected.[8,9] Both parts, the targeting molecule and the drug-delivering system,
expose reactive functional groups, which can undergo a covalent conjugation
within the living organism. A pretargeted drug delivery approach is
schematically shown in Scheme . The applied reactions must be highly bio-orthogonal and
fast proceeding and high yielding, even at low concentrations and
in presence of complex biological media. In this vein, different types
of click reactions have been developed, which are suitable for in
vitro and even in vivo applications.[10,11] Researchers
in the group of Bertozzi were pioneers in this field, applying for
the first time the reaction between azide and dibenzocyclooctyne (DBCO)
in a living cell, thereby facilitating its later implementation inside
a living organism.[12] Reaction kinetics
were, however, not optimal for in vivo application, reaching second-order
reaction rate constants of 10–3 to 10–2 M–1 s–1, depending on the used
DBCO derivative.[10,13,14] Most prominent click reaction for in vivo applications is the inverse
electron demanding Diels–Alder reaction between trans-cyclooctene (TCO) with tetrazines, reaching more suitable second-order
reaction rate constants of 103 to 104 M–1 s–1. The first clinical phase I
study of click to release TCO-based prodrugs was approved by the FDA
in 2019, releasing chemotherapeutic drugs at the tumor site upon reaction
with different tetrazine derivatives.[11,15] Despite the
broad application of TCO and tetrazines, a major disadvantage is the
instability of TCO, which can undergo isomerization to the more stable
but almost unreactive cis-cyclooctene (CCO) isomer,
for example, under UV irradiation.[16] Most
suitable alternative, reaching reaction rates in a similar order (101 to 102 M–1 s–1) but providing better stability, is the strain-promoted sydnone–alkyne
cycloaddition (SPSAC) between chlorosydnone (Cl-Syd) derivatives and
DBCO, developed by the groups of Specklin and Taran.[17]
Scheme 1
Overview of the Pretargeted Drug-Delivering Approach
toward PD-L1
Overexpressing NSCLC Tumor Tissue, Applying Two Subsequent Injections
of Clickable anti-PD-L1 Antibodies and Clickable BSA NPs
Here, we now present a proof-of-concept study
of a potential Cl-Syd–DBCO-based
pretargeted drug delivery system, combining well-studied biocompatible
elements, similar to those applied in FDA-approved formulations in
oncology therapy, thereby paving the way to an active drug delivery
formulation based on NPs.As active targeting moiety, anti-PD-L1
(B7-H1) Abs will be applied
and functionalized with clickable DBCO moieties. Anti-PD-L1 Abs are
widely applied in immunotherapy as checkpoint inhibitors, especially
in non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) but also as treatment in other
types of cancer, as proven by the three FDA-approved PD-L1 inhibiting
Abs currently available in the market.[18−20] The therapy is based
on the inhibition of the PD-L1 receptor, upregulated in the microenvironment
of multiple types of cancers. PD-L1 overexpression results in the
deactivation of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs) which, in turn,
do not recognize the diseased cells and do not eliminate them. After
PD-L1 inhibition, cytotoxic T cells are reactivated and are able to
attack and eliminate cancer cells. Even though immunotherapy is highly
effective in some patients, their overall response rate (ORR) is generally
low. The ORR of PD-L1 monotherapy, for example, merely lies between
14 and 24%.[21] Due to these unsatisfying
numbers, currently, PD-L1 therapy is often combined with conventional
platin-based or paclitaxel chemotherapy.[22] We believe that the simple modification of the anti-PD-L1 Abs and
albumin-based NPs, which are also used in combination therapy (anti-PD-L1
combined with Abraxane used in advanced NSCLC[21]), will be a straightforward procedure to potentially increase treatment
outcomes due to a higher accumulation of drug-loaded NPs at the tumor
site (see Scheme ).
Results
and Discussion
Synthesis and Reaction Rate Constant Determination
of the Clickable
Cl-Syd Derivative
Other than the DBCO derivatives, which
are widely used, the Cl-Syd compounds required for the stated approach
are not commercially available and were thus synthesized. An adapted
protocol from Kolodych and Taran was used for the synthesis of the p-carboxyphenyl-chlorosydnone derivative.[23] A schematic overview of the synthesis and the structure
of the final Cl-Syd are shown in Scheme a. Based on this protocol, the final Cl-Syd
derivative was synthesized with an overall yield of 1.6% (four-step
synthesis with low yielding last step, see Scheme a) and a purity above 88% (determined by
HPLC, impurities not reactive in next amine coupling steps). Details
of the synthesis and information about the characterization of the
intermediates and the final compound are stated in the Supporting Information.
Scheme 2
(a) Reaction Overview
of p-Carboxyphenyl-Chlorosydnone
According to the Published procedure[23]; (b) Reaction Overview of the SPSAC Click Reaction
between a Cl-Syd Derivative and a DBCO Derivative; (c) 1H NMR (500 MHz, D2O/DMSO-d6) Data of the Chemical Shift Region from 8.25 until 7.65 ppm, Showing
the Variation in Chemical Shift of the Signals of the Cl-Syd Neighbored
Phenyl Moiety during the Course of the Reaction, without the Presence
of the DBCO Derivative (0 s) as well as for Six Further Time Points
between 60 and 1200 s of Reaction Time; and (d) Consumption of the
Cl-Syd Derivative Over the Reaction Time with the DBCO Derivative
in Excess
Conditions
for each reaction
step of the synthesis of p-carboxyphenyl-chlorosydnone
(i) aminobenzoic acid and sodium chloroacetate dissolved in H2O were refluxed overnight; (ii) addition of sodium nitrite
to p-carboxyphenyl N-substituted
α-amino acid in HCl (10%) at 0 °C and subsequent stirring
overnight under N2; (iii) Baker–Ollis syndone synthesis[24] of the N-nitroso derivative
of p-carboxyphenyl N-substituted α-amino acid.
The N-nitroso derivative was stirred in acetic acid
anhydride at 100 °C for 3 h; and (iv) to a solution of p-carboxyphenyl-sydnone in dioxane/HCl (1 M) 2/1, sodium
hypochlorite (10%) was added dropwise, and the reaction stirred for
4 h. Yields are given for each reaction step.
(a) Reaction Overview
of p-Carboxyphenyl-Chlorosydnone
According to the Published procedure[23]; (b) Reaction Overview of the SPSAC Click Reaction
between a Cl-Syd Derivative and a DBCO Derivative; (c) 1H NMR (500 MHz, D2O/DMSO-d6) Data of the Chemical Shift Region from 8.25 until 7.65 ppm, Showing
the Variation in Chemical Shift of the Signals of the Cl-Syd Neighbored
Phenyl Moiety during the Course of the Reaction, without the Presence
of the DBCO Derivative (0 s) as well as for Six Further Time Points
between 60 and 1200 s of Reaction Time; and (d) Consumption of the
Cl-Syd Derivative Over the Reaction Time with the DBCO Derivative
in Excess
Conditions
for each reaction
step of the synthesis of p-carboxyphenyl-chlorosydnone
(i) aminobenzoic acid and sodium chloroacetate dissolved in H2O were refluxed overnight; (ii) addition of sodium nitrite
to p-carboxyphenyl N-substituted
α-amino acid in HCl (10%) at 0 °C and subsequent stirring
overnight under N2; (iii) Baker–Ollis syndone synthesis[24] of the N-nitroso derivative
of p-carboxyphenyl N-substituted α-amino acid.
The N-nitroso derivative was stirred in acetic acid
anhydride at 100 °C for 3 h; and (iv) to a solution of p-carboxyphenyl-sydnone in dioxane/HCl (1 M) 2/1, sodium
hypochlorite (10%) was added dropwise, and the reaction stirred for
4 h. Yields are given for each reaction step.To verify the published second-order reaction rate constants of
the here used Cl-Syd, we performed a kinetic study using a Cl-Syd
and a DBCO derivative as model compounds. We deliberately did not
make use of the p-carboxyphenyl-chlorosydnone during
this kinetic study but rather used a Cl-Syd model compound with a
higher molecular weight that contains an amide linkage in contrast
to the free carboxylic acid group on the phenyl moiety. Thereby, factors
such as size-related diffusion or steric hindrance and the influence
of the free acid on the reaction rate are taken into consideration
in the kinetic study, giving a more relevant value for the later application
of this click reaction. After the attempt to monitor the reaction
via the formation of a fluorescent product (λex:
315 and λem: 385 nm), as published by the group of
Taran and Specklin,[17] a monitorization
using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy was chosen since
the DBCO starting material already shows a strong fluorescence at
the same wavelength as the formed SPSAC click product that hampers
the possibility to follow the reaction kinetics, as mentioned by Taran
and Specklin.[17] Therefore, the rate constant
values given by those authors which are in the order of 102 M–1 s–1 should be treated with
caution.Although no proton is directly involved in the click
reaction,
the course of the click reaction was able to be monitored via 1H NMR due to the variation in the chemical shift of the signals
from the Cl-Syd neighbored phenyl moiety during the course of the
reaction (8.15 and 7.95 ppm for Cl-Syd to 8.05 and 7.85 ppm in the
click product in D2O/DMSO-d6, see Scheme c).
The consumption of Cl-Syd, as shown in Scheme d, was determined using the integrals of
the disappearing signals for the phenyl moiety, which was subsequently
applied in the calculation of the second-order reaction rate constant.
The calculated rate constant for the here used system of 1.9 M–1 s–1 was similar to the previously
calculated constant for p-carboxyphenyl-chlorosydnone
from HPLC data (1.6 M–1 s–1).[23] Having obtained the same rate constants as published
for p-carboxyphenyl-chlorosydnone applying HPLC analysis,
it can be stated that the application of an amide-coupled Cl-Syd with
higher molecular weight does not negatively affect the reaction kinetics.
Although the reaction kinetics do not reach rate constants of TCO-tetrazine-based
bio-orthogonal reactions, the superior chemical stability of the Cl-Syd
groups in comparison with the TCO-ones, it is an interesting feature
that simplifies the storage of the reactive molecules and increases
the result reliability. The determined reaction rate constant is with
a value of 1.9 M–1 s–1 2 orders
of magnitude larger compared to those of common SPAAC reactions using
azides, which have been previously applied in vivo.[13,14] Therefore, the successful application of this reaction for in vivo
applications can be assumed with high confidence.
Synthesis and
Characterization of Clickable BSA NPs
The bovine serum albumin
(BSA) nanoparticles, on which the clickable
Cl-Syd groups were aimed to be immobilized eventually, were generated
by the desolvation method, using an established protocol from the
working group of Rubio-Retama (for details, see the experimental section).[25] The formed
BSA NPs (Figure )
were stirred overnight. After multiple purification steps by centrifugation,
NPs with a hydrodynamic diameter of 140 nm were isolated. ζ-potential
analysis revealed a highly negative surface charge of −35 mV,
which is in accordance with stated ζ-potentials for this type
of NPs prepared at pH 8.5.[25] The BSA NPs
were held in carbonate buffer with a pH 8.5 at 4 °C until further
usage. After 1 month of storage at 4 °C, the NPs neither showed
a change in their hydrodynamic diameter nor ζ-potential, thereby
demonstrating their high stability. Besides confirming the size of
the NPs, the high monodispersity of the NPs was proven by scanning
electron microscopy (SEM) analysis. Results from DLS and SEM analyses
of the synthesized BSA NPs are shown in Figure b,c.
Figure 1
(a) Preparation overview of FITC-functionalized
CS-BSA NPs with
(I) being the generation of the BSA NPs by the desolvation method,
(II) the functionalization of the BSA NPs with FITC, and (III) the
final functionalization with the NHS ester of the here used Cl-Syd
derivative; (b) SEM image of the non-functionalized BSA NPs; (c) DLS
results of the non-functionalized BSA NPs (yellow) and BSA NPs functionalized
with FITC (orange) and BSA NPs functionalized with FITC and Cl-Syd
(red); and (d) ζ-potential of the non-functionalized BSA NPs
(yellow) and BSA NPs functionalized with FITC (orange) and BSA NPs
functionalized with FITC and Cl-Syd (red).
(a) Preparation overview of FITC-functionalized
CS-BSA NPs with
(I) being the generation of the BSA NPs by the desolvation method,
(II) the functionalization of the BSA NPs with FITC, and (III) the
final functionalization with the NHS ester of the here used Cl-Syd
derivative; (b) SEM image of the non-functionalized BSA NPs; (c) DLS
results of the non-functionalized BSA NPs (yellow) and BSA NPs functionalized
with FITC (orange) and BSA NPs functionalized with FITC and Cl-Syd
(red); and (d) ζ-potential of the non-functionalized BSA NPs
(yellow) and BSA NPs functionalized with FITC (orange) and BSA NPs
functionalized with FITC and Cl-Syd (red).The stable BSA NPs were subsequently functionalized with the previously
synthesized Cl-Syd groups. The choice to synthesize the carboxy-benzene
derivative was based on two reasons: first due to the high reactivity
derived from the sydnone when bound to a phenyl group[23] and second because the presence of the carboxylic acid
group can be used directly to covalently bind the Cl-Syd to the BSA
NPs by well-established amide coupling protocols. Therefore, the carboxylic
acid of the Cl-Syd derivative was activated using DCC/NHS (N,N′-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide/N-hydroxysuccinimide) and subsequently purified, as described
by the groups of Specklin and Taran.[17] Subsequently,
BSA NPs were functionalized with the NHS-activated Cl-Syd derivative,
as described in the experimental section.
DLS analysis revealed a slight increase in hydrodynamic diameter after
functionalization but no significant change in ζ-potential (165
nm, ζ-pot. −31 mV) and good stability of the Cl-Syd-functionalized
BSA NPs (CS-BSA NPs from here on) in carbonate buffer (pH 8.5). It
was observed that the initial and the CS-BSA NPs were less stable
in PBS buffer, even at an elevated pH of 8.0; thus, carbonate buffer
(pH 8.5) was used for functionalization reactions, washing steps,
and final storage until usage. The here added amounts of DMSO did
not affect the stability of the BSA NPs, as investigated in control
experiments (data not shown). Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy
and 1H NMR analyses were ambiguous to directly prove the
linkage of the Cl-Syd moieties on the NP surface.To prove the
presence of fully functional clickable groups, a click
reaction with a DBCO bearing cyanin dye was performed. As clickable
dye, DBCO-modified sulfo-cyanine-5 dye (DBCO-sCy5) was chosen. To
100 μL of a solution of 1 mg/mL CS-BSA NPs in carbonate buffer
(pH 8.5), four different amounts of DBCO-sCy5 were added (final concentrations
of DBCO-sCy5 of 25, 50, 100, and 250 μM) and incubated for 4
h at RT. After excessive washing steps, the CS-BSA NPs incubated with
DBCO-sCy5 showed an intense blue color, thereby proving the presence
of the Cl-Syd moieties on the BSA NP surface (Figure ). For the sake of comparison, images of
non-functionalized BSA NPs, which were incubated with the same concentrations
of DBCO-sCy5, are shown as well. The non-functionalized BSA NPs, also
after incubation using high dye concentrations of 250 μM, did
not show any coloration, thereby excluding the possibility of non-specific
physisorption of the dye on the BSA NPs. By fluorescence measurements,
complete consumption of the 25 μM and 50 μM sCy5-DBCO
after incubation with clickable BSA NPs was observed. No remaining
dye was detected in the first supernatant after CS-BSA NP centrifugation,
as shown in Figure c,d (right). Supernatants of the non-functionalized BSA NPs incubated
with a final dye concentration of 25 and 50 μM, on the other
hand, show an intense blue color since no reaction between the dye
and the BSA NPs occurred (Figure c,d, left). The photoluminescent (PL) emission of the
supernatants isolated from the non-functionalized BSA NPs increases
proportionally with the concentration of DBCO-sCy5 added to the solution
(see red linear regression in Figure e). When plotting the PL emission of the supernatants
removed from the incubated CS-BSA NPs, an increasing linear regression
can be observed above a DBCO-sCy5 concentration of 100 μM, which
runs parallel to the regression of the supernatants removed from non-functionalized
BSA NPs (see orange regression in Figure e). The x-axis interception
of this second linear regression can give information about the amount
of clickable Cl-Syd moieties present per BSA NP since the amount of
consumed DBCO-sCy5 can be directly correlated to the total amount
of clickable groups on the NP surface. The DBCO-sCy5 concentration,
which is required to completely saturate the CS-BSA NPs, was determined
to be 85 μM, as given by the x-axis interception.
The two linear regressions of the PL emission of separated supernatants
plotted against the initial DBCO-sCy5 concentration are shown in Figure e, including the
concentration at the x-axis interception. Considering
that 0.1 mg/mL of BSA NPs with a hydrodynamic diameter of 120 nm corresponds
to a total number of 6 × 1012 BSA NPs per mL (approx.
1 pmol), it can be concluded that each CS-BSA NP is functionalized
with approximately 15.000 Cl-Syd moieties. A detailed description
of this calculation can be found within the Supporting Information section.
Figure 2
(a) Schematic overview of the experiments, including
a control
experiment using non-functionalized BSA NPs, which was performed to
evaluate the unspecific physisorption of the DBCO-sCy5 on the surface
of the BSA NPs (left), and the specific reaction between functionalized
CS-BSA NPs and DBCO-sCy5, to evaluate the reactivity of the moieties;
(b) images to show the aspect of the purified BSA NPs (N for nanoparticles)
after incubation with DBCO-sCy5 at four different concentrations [(I):
25 μM, (II): 50 μM, (III): 100 μM, and (IV): 250
μM], showing the aspect of non-functionalized BSA NPs (control
experiment) on the left and the aspect of CS-BSA NPs on the right;
(c) images to show the aspect of the first supernatant removed (S
for supernatant) after incubation with DBCO-sCy5 at four different
concentrations [(I): 25 μM, (II): 50 μM, (III): 100 μM
and (IV): 250 μM], showing the aspect of supernatant removed
from non-functionalized BSA NPs (control experiment) on the left and
the aspect of supernatant removed from CS-BSA NPs on the right; (d)
results from fluorescent measurement of the first supernatants removed
for the non-functionalized (control experiment) (left) and CS-BSA
NPs (right); and (e) PL emission representation of the first supernatants
obtained after incubating the DBCO-sCy5 with different concentrations
of non-functionalized (control experiment) and Cl-Syd functionalize
BSA, indicating the x-axis interception of the linear
regression for the plot of sCy5 emission of the first supernatants
removed from CS-BSA NPs after incubation used to calculate the amount
of Cl-Syd moieties per BSA NP.
(a) Schematic overview of the experiments, including
a control
experiment using non-functionalized BSA NPs, which was performed to
evaluate the unspecific physisorption of the DBCO-sCy5 on the surface
of the BSA NPs (left), and the specific reaction between functionalized
CS-BSA NPs and DBCO-sCy5, to evaluate the reactivity of the moieties;
(b) images to show the aspect of the purified BSA NPs (N for nanoparticles)
after incubation with DBCO-sCy5 at four different concentrations [(I):
25 μM, (II): 50 μM, (III): 100 μM, and (IV): 250
μM], showing the aspect of non-functionalized BSA NPs (control
experiment) on the left and the aspect of CS-BSA NPs on the right;
(c) images to show the aspect of the first supernatant removed (S
for supernatant) after incubation with DBCO-sCy5 at four different
concentrations [(I): 25 μM, (II): 50 μM, (III): 100 μM
and (IV): 250 μM], showing the aspect of supernatant removed
from non-functionalized BSA NPs (control experiment) on the left and
the aspect of supernatant removed from CS-BSA NPs on the right; (d)
results from fluorescent measurement of the first supernatants removed
for the non-functionalized (control experiment) (left) and CS-BSA
NPs (right); and (e) PL emission representation of the first supernatants
obtained after incubating the DBCO-sCy5 with different concentrations
of non-functionalized (control experiment) and Cl-Syd functionalize
BSA, indicating the x-axis interception of the linear
regression for the plot of sCy5 emission of the first supernatants
removed from CS-BSA NPs after incubation used to calculate the amount
of Cl-Syd moieties per BSA NP.
In Vitro Assays of Clickable BSA NPs and Clickable Anti-PD-L1
Abs
After proving the successful coupling of the clickable
groups on the NP surface, an in vitro assay was performed to demonstrate
the potential of the DBCO-anti-PD-L1/CS-BSA NP system for pretargeted
drug delivery in lung cancer. As cell line, the human NSCLC cell line
H358 was chosen since anti-PD-L1 therapy, and its combination with
Abraxane is an FDA-approved therapy and widely used for treatment
of this type of lung cancer.[21] Furthermore,
PD-L1 overexpression in H358 cells line has been confirmed previously.[26] For the assay, clickable anti-PD-L1 Abs and
clickable BSA NPs, which can be visualized by a fluorescent microscope
or a well-plate reader, were required. Since the Cl-Syd moieties were
coupled to the BSA NPs, the corresponding reactive DBCO groups for
the SPSAC click reaction were covalently bound to the anti-PD-L1 Abs.
The anti-PD-L1 Abs were functionalized with a DBCO derivative bearing
an activated NHS-ester, allowing for its direct coupling to primary
amine groups of the Abs. Furthermore, the DBCO derivative contained
a short polyethylene glycol spacer of four repeating units (PEG4), thereby ensuring flexibility and spacing between the clickable
groups and the targeting Ab (see Figure a). The detailed Ab functionalization conditions
are given in the experimental section. Using
an anti-PD-L1 to DBCO-PEG4-NHS ratio of 1:5 for the functionalization
of primary amine groups of the Ab, an introduction between 2 and 3
DBCO moieties can be expected as observed in earlier studies applying
similar coupling procedures.[27]
Figure 3
(a) Functionalization
of anti-PD-L1 Ab with DBCO-NHS; (b) overview
of the in vitro assay, showing the first control experiment without
addition of an Ab (left), the second control experiment with the addition
of non-functionalized anti-PD-L1 (center) and the experiment using
the clickable anti-PD-L1 Ab, resulting in the accumulation of CS-BS
NPs on the surface of H358 cells (right); (c) PL emission spectra
obtained from the cell cultures used in the control 1, control 2,
and the pretargeted reaction named as the click test; and (d) microscopy
results including the optical images of the H358 cells (left) and
the fluorescent images of the same cells (right) showing a strong
fluorescent signal on the H358 cells previously treated with clickable
anti-PD-L1 Abs (bottom right).
(a) Functionalization
of anti-PD-L1 Ab with DBCO-NHS; (b) overview
of the in vitro assay, showing the first control experiment without
addition of an Ab (left), the second control experiment with the addition
of non-functionalized anti-PD-L1 (center) and the experiment using
the clickable anti-PD-L1 Ab, resulting in the accumulation of CS-BS
NPs on the surface of H358 cells (right); (c) PL emission spectra
obtained from the cell cultures used in the control 1, control 2,
and the pretargeted reaction named as the click test; and (d) microscopy
results including the optical images of the H358 cells (left) and
the fluorescent images of the same cells (right) showing a strong
fluorescent signal on the H358 cells previously treated with clickable
anti-PD-L1 Abs (bottom right).For CS-BSA NP visualization, the NPs were functionalized with a
suitable dye. Fluorescein was used as fluorescent dye, which was coupled
to primary amine groups of the BSA as isothiocyanate derivative [fluorescein
isothiocyanate (FITC)]. The initial BSA NPs were first functionalized
by FITC, followed by the introduction of the Cl-Syd click groups,
applying the protocol stated earlier (see the Experimental Section
for both coupling procedures). Each functionalization step was monitored
by DLS and ζ-potential measurements (results shown in Figure c,d). Again, a slight
increase in the hydrodynamic diameter of the BSA NPs was observed
after each coupling procedure. Hydrodynamic diameter was found to
be 190 and 220 nm for FITC and FITC + Cl-Syd-functionalized BSA NPs,
respectively (see Figure c,d). The ζ-potential was not significantly affected
by the functionalization of the BSA NPs and resulted in a value of
−32 mV after FITC coupling and −36 mV after the subsequent
Cl-Syd introduction. Besides the morphological analysis, also the
fluorescence of the BSA NPs after FITC and Cl-Syd coupling was measured.
For both types of BSA NPs, FITC, and FITC + Cl-Syd bearing NPs, a
strong emission at 525 nm after excitation at 480 nm was observed,
proving the successful incorporation of FITC groups on the surface
of the BSA NPs.The developed in vitro assay included three
different sets of experiments,
two of which being control experiments either lacking the addition
of Ab or using non-functionalized anti-PD-L1 Ab. The in vitro assay
was performed as follows: first, H358 cells were transferred into
wells of a 24-well-plate and cultured for 24 h. In the second step,
some wells were incubated with the DBCO-functionalized anti-PD-L1
Abs (click-test, see Figure b), whereas other wells were incubated with non-functionalized
anti-PD-L1 Abs (control 2, see Figure b). In both cases, 2.5 μg of Abs was added into
each well and incubated for 4 h at 37 °C, allowing the anti-PD-L1
Abs to interact and bind to the overexpressed PD-L1 on the cell surface
of the H358 cells. Into an additional two wells, neither functionalized
nor non-functionalized anti-PD-L1 were added (control 1, see Figure b). After the Ab
incubation steps, all wells were washed three times with PBS buffer,
and new PBS buffer (pH 7.4) was added. As the next step, 50 μg
of FITC-functionalized CS-BSA NPs were added to all wells and incubated
for 15 min to see the immediate reaction of the clickable NPs with
H358 cell-adhered clickable anti-PD-L1. Thereby, only a very short
interaction between the two clickable counterparts is allowed, mimicking
a brief encounter in the organism. Each experiment (control 1, control
2, and click test, see Figure ) was performed in duplicate. After incubation, the wells
were extensively washed, and cells were subsequently fixed using a
2% paraformaldehyde solution in PBS.Once fixed, the cells were
analyzed using a fluorescent microscope
coupled to a spectrometer. In the two control experiments, no fluorescent
signal of the FITC and thus no accumulation of the CS-BSA NPs can
be observed after an incubation time of 15 min (see Figure c). In the set in which the
clickable anti-PD-L1 Ab was used, a significant accumulation of CS-BSA
NPs around the H358 cells was observed, giving a signal 24-fold higher
than the obtained signal from the control experiments (see Figure d). This result proves
the successful coupling of the CS-BSA NPs to the clickable Abs and
the bio-orthogonality of the reaction on the pretargeted cells after
short incubation times. Since no accumulation of CS-BSA NPs was observed
in the control experiments, a highly specific accumulation, only once
DBCO moieties are present on the H358 cell surface, was proven. In
the experiments that lacked DBCO, no unspecific binding can be seen
after 15 min incubation time.
Conclusions
In
this work, BSA NPs with a mean hydrodynamic diameter of 120
nm and ζ-potential of −36 mV were synthesized, which
have been functionalized with clickable moieties based on Cl-Syd.
This molecule confers pretargeting properties to the BSA NPs that
could be used to accumulate them in a specific area that has been
previously targeted by an Ab equipped with a corresponding clickable
DBCO group. The previously reported second-order reaction rate constant
of 2 M–1·s–1 was confirmed
for the here used Cl-Syd DBCO click pair, monitoring the reaction
by NMR spectroscopy. The concept of pretargeted drug delivery has
been tested in two ways: first, a click reaction between CS-BSA NPs
and a DBCO-functionalized sCy5 was performed to determine the performance
of the system in conditions with low steric hindrance; this experiment
permitted to infer the number of reactive moieties existing on the
surface of the BSA NPs which determined to be approximately 15.000
molecules per NP. Second, the click reaction was carried out in an
in vitro experiment, between clickable CS-BSA NPs and anti-PD-L1 Ab
functionalized with DBCO, that had been previously incubated with
PD-L1 overexpressing H358 cells. The results of these experiments
demonstrate the suitability of this click reaction to perform the
pretargeting strategy in vitro between two subunits, BSA NPs and anti-PD-L1
Abs, which are not exempt from steric hindrance using incubation times
as short as 15 min. From the encouraging results of this work on pretargeting
of CS-BSA NPs combined with the use of anti-PD-L1 Ab as the pretargeting
moiety, a well-established FDA-approved checkpoint inhibitor, we realize
the bright future of this and similar platforms to achieve simultaneous
immuno- and pretargeted chemotherapy of different cancers that overexpress
PD-L1. In ongoing studies, the here described system will be tested
in vivo, thoroughly evaluating the biodistribution of the two clickable
components and their successful reaction inside a living organism.
Furthermore, paclitaxel encapsulated CS-BSA NPs will be prepared,
and a potential improvement of a pretargeted combinational immunotherapy
in comparison to a common combinational immunotherapy using anti-PD-L1
and Abraxane will be examined.
Experimental Section
Synthesis of BSA NPs
The BSA NPs were synthesized by
the desolvation methods, applying an established protocol from the
group of Rubio-Retama.[25] In short, to a
solution of 5 mg of BSA in 1 mL of carbonate buffer (20 mM, pH of
8.5), 4 mL of ethanol was added at a flow rate of 3 mL/min. Upon addition
of ethanol, the BSA NPs precipitated, and 11.5 μL of glutaraldehyde
(0.25 wt %) was added for BSA cross-linkage, thereby ensuring their
stability.
Functionalization of BSA NPs with NHS-Activated
Cl-Syd
To functionalize the BSA NPs with clickable Cl-Syd
groups, 50 μL
of an NHS-activated Cl-Syd stock in DMSO (30 mM) was added to a suspension
of BSA NPs at a concentration of 1 mg/mL in carbonate buffer (pH 8.5).
The reaction was stirred overnight and subsequently purified by centrifugation.
The BSA NPs were washed three times with carbonate buffer.
Functionalization
of BSA NPs with FITC
For FITC introduction,
50 μL of a FITC stock in DMSO (6.4 mM) was added to 1 mg/mL
BSA NPs in carbonate buffer (pH 8.5). The reaction was allowed to
proceed for 3 h at RT. FITC-functionalized BSA NPs were purified by
three washing steps using carbonate buffer.
Anti-PD-L1 Functionalization
with Clickable DBCO Moieties
For the Ab functionalization,
5 μL of DBCO-PEG4-NHS stock (2.2 mM) in DMSO was
added to a solution of 330 μg
of anti-PD-L1 in 200 μL of PBS (pH 8.0) and incubated for 4
h at RT. After the coupling, the DBCO-functionalized Abs were purified
by centrifugal concentrators with a molecular weight cutoff of 50
kDa.
Authors: Fan Zhang; Di Huang; Lei Zhao; Tao Li; Sujie Zhang; Guoqing Zhang; Fang Yuan; Jie Zhang; Yuzi Zhang; Zhengyi Zhao; Longgang Cui; Jing Zhao; Guoqiang Wang; Shangli Cai; Yuezong Bai; Jinliang Wang; Yi Hu Journal: Ther Adv Med Oncol Date: 2020-07-06 Impact factor: 8.168
Authors: Raffaella Rossin; Sandra M van den Bosch; Wolter Ten Hoeve; Marco Carvelli; Ron M Versteegen; Johan Lub; Marc S Robillard Journal: Bioconjug Chem Date: 2013-06-18 Impact factor: 4.774
Authors: Michael J Mitchell; Margaret M Billingsley; Rebecca M Haley; Marissa E Wechsler; Nicholas A Peppas; Robert Langer Journal: Nat Rev Drug Discov Date: 2020-12-04 Impact factor: 84.694