| Literature DB >> 35465457 |
Patrick Opoku Asuming1, Deborah Aba Gaisie1, Caesar Agula2, Ayaga Agula Bawah2.
Abstract
The Covid-19 pandemic is widely speculated to have disrupted the delivery of primary health care in low-income countries. Yet, there is little rigorous empirical research identifying this effect. This paper estimates the impact of Covid-19 on facility and skilled delivery and utilisation of antenatal care (ANC) services by comparing these outcomes for women who were pregnant/delivered before and during the Covid-19 period. The results show that Covid-19 led to 23% and 25% reductions, respectively, in the likelihood of facility delivery and four or more ANC visits during pregnancy. These findings highlight the need to build more resilient health systems in low-income settings.Entities:
Keywords: Covid‐19; Ghana; antenatal care; facility delivery; skilled delivery
Year: 2022 PMID: 35465457 PMCID: PMC9015309 DOI: 10.1002/jid.3627
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Int Dev ISSN: 0954-1748
Population and confirmed Covid‐19 cases by region
| December 2020 | August 2021 | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Region | Total cases | Total population | Cases per 100 000 population | Region | Total cases | Total population | Cases per 100 000 population |
| Greater Accra Region | 30 140 | 5 055 883 | 596 | Greater Accra Region | 61 436 | 5 055 883 | 1215 |
| Ashanti Region | 11 170 | 5 924 498 | 189 | Ashanti Region | 19 745 | 5 924 498 | 333 |
| Western Region | 3095 | 2 214 660 | 140 | Western Region | 6533 | 2 214 660 | 295 |
| Bono East Region | 788 | 594 712 | 133 | Eastern Region | 5527 | 3 318 853 | 167 |
| Central Region | 2108 | 2 605 492 | 81 | Central Region | 4216 | 2 605 492 | 162 |
| Eastern Region | 2624 | 3 318 853 | 79 | Volta Region | 3781 | 1 907 679 | 198 |
| Western North Region | 665 | 1 168 235 | 57 | Bono East Region | 2201 | 594 712 | 370 |
| Ahafo Region | 530 | 927 960 | 57 | Bono Region | 1992 | 1 168 807 | 170 |
| Bono Region | 635 | 1 168 807 | 54 | Northern Region | 1693 | 1 948 913 | 87 |
| Volta Region | 761 | 1 907 679 | 40 | Upper East Region | 1339 | 1 302 718 | 103 |
| Oti Region | 244 | 759 799 | 32 | Ahafo Region | 1001 | 927 960 | 108 |
| Northern Region | 566 | 1 948 913 | 29 | Western North Region | 947 | 1 168 235 | 81 |
| Upper East Region | 384 | 1 302 718 | 29 | Oti Region | 687 | 759 799 | 90 |
| Upper West Region | 91 | 868 479 | 10 | Upper West Region | 523 | 868 479 | 60 |
| Savannah Region | 62 | 1 133 768 | 5 | North East Region | 236 | 588 800 | 40 |
| North East Region | 22 | 588 800 | 4 | Savannah Region | 164 | 1 133 768 | 14 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Note: Table 1 shows the total number of confirmed cases and the number of cases per 100 000 population as at December 2020 and August 2021.
Sources: Ghana Statistical Service and Ghana Health Service website (https://www.statsghana.gov.gh/regionalpopulation.php?population=MTgyMTAwODAwNS45Nzg1&&Savannah®id=14) (https://ghs.gov.gh/covid19/dashboardm.php).
Descriptive statistics
| Variables | Pre‐Covid | Post‐Covid | Full sample |
|---|---|---|---|
| Number of pregnancies | 312 | 223 | 535 |
| Number of women | 228 | 228 | 288 |
| Average age of woman at birth: Mean (sd) | 27.82 (6.40) | 28.95 (6.84) | 28.29 (6.60) |
|
| |||
| Never married | 15 (4.81%) | 6 (2.69%) | 21 (3.93%) |
| Married/living together | 292 (93.59%) | 214 (95.96%) | 506 (94.58%) |
| Separated/divorce/widowed | 5 (1.60%) | 3 (1.35%) | 8 (1.49%) |
|
| |||
| Poorest | 70 (22.58%) | 49 (22.58%) | 119 (22.58%) |
| Poorer | 54 (17.42%) | 46 (21.20%) | 100 (18.98%) |
| Middle | 69 (22.26%) | 38 (17.51%) | 107 (20.30%) |
| Richer | 61 (19.68%) | 52 (23.96%) | 113 (21.44%) |
| Richest | 56 (18.06%) | 32 (14.75%) | 88 (16.70%) |
|
| |||
| No occupation | 47 (15.06%) | 48 (21.52%) | 95 (17.76%) |
| Student | ‐ | 2 (0.90%) | 2 (0.37%) |
| Farming | 140 (44.87%) | 88 (39.46%) | 228 (42.62%) |
| Trading/selling | 76 (24.36%) | 44 (19.73%) | 120 (22.43%) |
| Hairdressing/dressmaking | 23 (7.37%) | 15 (6.73%) | 38 (7.10%) |
| Housewife | 14 (4.49%) | 17 (7.62%) | 31 (5.79%) |
| Other occupation | 12 (3.85%) | 9 (4.04%) | 21 (3.93%) |
|
| |||
| None | 145 (46.47%) | 99 (44.39%) | 244 (45.61%) |
| Primary | 59 (18.91%) | 48 (21.52%) | 107 (20.00%) |
| Middle school/JHS/JSS | 80 (25.64%) | 56 (25.11%) | 136 (25.42%) |
| Secondary + | 28 (8.97%) | 20 (8.97%) | 48 (8.97%) |
|
| |||
| Less than 1 km | 136 (43.59%) | 95 (42.60%) | 231 (43.18%) |
| Between 1 and 2 km | 50 (16.03%) | 32 (14.35%) | 82 (15.33%) |
| Between 2 and 3 km | 29 (9.29%) | 23 (10.31%) | 52 (9.72%) |
| More than 3 km | 97 (31.09%) | 73 (32.74%) | 170 (31.78%) |
| Duration of pregnancy: mean (sd) | 9.10 (0.53) | 9.04 (0.42) | 9.08 (0.49) |
| Parity: mean (sd) | 1.25 (0.44) | 1.90 (0.39) | 1.52 (0.53) |
| Delivered at facility | 200 (64.10%) | 144 (64.57%) | 344 (64.30%) |
| Had skilled delivery | 205 (65.71%) | 147 (65.92%) | 352 (65.79%) |
| Had four or more ANC visits | 251 (80.45%) | 172 (77.13%) | 423 (79.07%) |
| Delivered during Covid period | 223 (41.68%) | ||
| More than 5 months of pregnancy spent during Covid | 322 (60.87%) |
Note: This table presents the descriptive characteristics of the respondents in the study. The figures are calculated at the pregnancy level, and separate columns are presented for pre‐Covid and post‐Covid pregnancies together with the full sample.
Abbreviation: ANC, antenatal care.
Impact of Covid‐19 on facility delivery and skilled delivery
| Variables | Margins |
|---|---|
|
| |
| Delivery during Covid | −0.149 |
| Age of woman at delivery | −0.209 |
| Age squared | 0.004 |
| Parity | 0.040 (0.024) |
| Had four or more ANC visits | 0.203 |
| Constant | 2.658 |
| Observations | 527 |
|
| 0.134 |
| Number of women | 288 |
|
| |
| Delivery during Covid | −0.111 (0.072) |
| Age of woman at delivery | −0.211 |
| Age squared | 0.004 |
| Parity | 0.011 (0.018) |
| Had 4 or more ANC visits | 0.205 |
| Constant | 2.745 |
| Observations | 527 |
|
| 0.136 |
| Number of women | 288 |
Note: The table presents results from a fixed‐effects (FE) model. The outcome variable for results in Panel A is an indicator that takes a value of 1 if a woman delivered in a facility. The outcome variable for results in Panel B is an indicator that takes a value of 1 if a woman had skilled delivery. All the covariates included in the FE model are time‐varying and all regressions controlled for month of delivery. Standard errors are reported in parentheses. Standard errors are clustered at the enumeration area level.
p < 0.01.
< 0.05.
p < 0.10.
Impact of Covid‐19 on having four or more ANC visits
| Variables | Margins |
|---|---|
| More than 5 months of pregnancy spent during Covid | −0.196 |
| Age of woman at delivery | 0.089 (0.093) |
| Age squared | −0.000 (0.001) |
| Parity | 0.023 (0.040) |
|
| |
| 6 months (ref) | |
| 7 months | −0.262 (0.175) |
| 8 months | −0.471 (0.346) |
| 9 months | −0.055 (0.050) |
| 10 months | −0.162 (0.120) |
| Constant | −1.271 (1.787) |
| Observations | 521 |
| Number of women | 295 |
|
| 0.036 |
Note: The table presents results from a fixed‐effects model. The outcome variable is an indicator that takes a value of 1 if a woman spent more than 5 months of her pregnancy during Covid. All the covariates included in the FE model are time‐varying, and all standard errors are clustered at the enumeration area level.
p < 0.01.
p < 0.05.
p < 0.10.