| Literature DB >> 35455237 |
Roshina Rabail1, Waqar Ahmed1, Madiha Ilyas2, Muhammad Shahid Riaz Rajoka3, Abdo Hassoun4,5, Abdur Rauf Khalid6, Moazzam Rafiq Khan1, Rana Muhammad Aadil1.
Abstract
COVID-19 remains a deadly disease that poses a serious threat to humanity. COVID-19 vaccines protect the public and limit viral spread. However, public acceptance is significantly dependent on the efficacy and side effects (SEs) of the vaccinations being produced. Four important mechanisms have been examined for COVID-19 vaccines: DNA-based, mRNA-based, protein-based, and inactivated viruses. Vaccination safety research was formerly limited to manufacturer-sponsored studies, but numerous additional cross-sectional survey-based studies conducted globally have contributed to the generation of vaccine-related safety data reports. Twenty-seven studies and twenty-four case reports published-up till 2021 were overviewed for the presentation of SEs and their severity. Injection site pain remained the most dominant localized SE, while headache and fatigue were the most prevalent systemic SEs. Most studies reported that all vaccinations were safe, with very little or no adverse effects, but the nature of SEs was reported to be more persistent in DNA- and mRNA-based vaccines, while inactivated viral vaccines were associated with longer-duration SEs. Overall, SEs were found to be more dominant in women and youngsters. Case reports of adverse reactions have also been documented, but there is still a need to find out their pathological linkage with the COVID-19 vaccination.Entities:
Keywords: AstraZeneca side effects; COVID-19 vaccination side effects; Moderna side effects; Pfizer side effects; Sinopharm side effects; Sputnik V side effects
Year: 2022 PMID: 35455237 PMCID: PMC9031559 DOI: 10.3390/vaccines10040488
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Vaccines (Basel) ISSN: 2076-393X
Most-utilized vaccinations against COVID-19.
| Local/Given Name | Codename | Type | Origin: Company/Country | Approval/Authorization | Efficacy Trials | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pfizer | BNT162b2 Vaccine | Uridine nucleoside modified mRNA (encodes the receptor-binding domain or full-length version of SARS-CoV-2 spike protein) | BioNTech (Germany) in collaboration with Fosun Pharmaceuticals (Shanghai, China) and Pfizer (Canada) | FDA-approved; FDA Emergency Use Authorization (EUA); WHO-approved in 103 countries; among first vaccines to get EUA in December 2020 | 95% efficacy. | [ |
| Moderna | mRNA-1273 Vaccine | mRNA-based vaccine designed to express the coronavirus spike protein | Massachusetts (the United States) along with the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases and Biomedical Advanced Research and Development Authority | FDA-approved; FDA (EUA); WHO-approved in 76 countries; among first vaccines to get EUA in December 2020 | 94% efficacy; safe during pregnancy. | [ |
| Janssen | Ad26.COV2.S | Adenoviral-based vaccine | Johnson and Johnson/the United States, the Netherlands. | FDA-approved; FDA (EUA); WHO-approved in 75 countries | 13 trials in 3 countries. | [ |
| AstraZeneca/Vaxzevria | AZD1222 Vaccine/ChAdOx1 | Chimpanzee Adenovirus-Vectored vaccine | Oxford University under British pharmaceutical company | FDA (EUA); WHO emergency use listing (EUL) WHO-approved in 124 countries | 70% efficacy. | [ |
| Sputnik V | Gam-COVID-Vac | Adenoviral-based vaccine | Gamaleya National Research Centre of Epidemiology and Microbiology (Moscow, Russia) | FDA (EUA) | 91.6% efficacy; | [ |
| Convidecia/CanSino | Ad5-nCoV Vaccine | The recombinant vaccine which involves replication-defective adenovirus type 5 as vector | Tianjin, China in collaboration with the Beijing Institute of Biotechnology in the Academy of Military Medical Sciences | - | 90% efficacy. | [ |
| Covaxin Vaccine | BBV152 | Inactivated vaccine candidate; deactivated rabies vaccine as a vehicle for coronavirus proteins | Bharat Biotech (India) in collaboration with Thomas Jefferson University of Philadelphia, Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) and National Institute of Virology (Pune, India) | FDA (EUA) | - | [ |
| Sinopharm | New Crown COVID-19 Vaccine | Inactivated vaccine candidate | Wuhan Institute of Biological Products, (China) | FDA (EUA); WHO (EUL); WHO-approved in 68 countries | 79.34% efficacy. | [ |
| Sinovac/CoronaVac | CoronaVac Vaccine | Adsorbed (inactivated) vaccine | Sinovac Life Sciences Co. Ltd. (China) in collaboration with Instituto Butantan | WHO emergency use listing (EUL); WHO-approved in 41 countries | 65% efficacy; 22 trials in 2 countries. | [ |
| Covishield | AZD1222 | (Oxford/ | Serum Institute of India | WHO-approved in 46 countries? | 2 trials in 1 country | [ |
| Novavax | NVX-CoV2373 | Antigenic components (spike (S) protein) generated in vitro (Viral subunit) | - | - | - | [ |
Figure 1Most-utilized COVID-19 vaccinations and their frequently reported SEs.
COVID-19 vaccinations and their reported SEs.
| Vaccine Name | Methodology | Participant/Area | Date/Duration | Minor Side Effects | Major Side Effects | Duration | Concluding Remarks | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pfizer– | A collaborative study between the American Academy of | 414 cutaneous reaction cases | December 2020–February 2021 | Local injection site reactions, urticarial eruptions, morbilliform eruptions. | Pernio/chilblains, cosmetic filler reactions, zoster, herpes simplex flares, pityriasis rosea. | - | The presence of a cutaneous reaction to the first vaccine dose, when it appears 4 h after injection, is not a contraindication to receiving the second dose of the Pfizer or Moderna vaccine. | [ |
| Pfizer–BioNTech COVID-19 | Google Form-questionnaire (online survey) | 455 individuals Saudi Arabia inhabitants | 10–21 January 2021 | Injection site pain, headaches, flu-like symptoms, fever, tiredness, fast heartbeat, whole-body aches, difficulty breathing, joint pain, chills, drowsiness. | Bell’s palsy, lymph node swelling and tenderness. | - | - | [ |
| Pfizer–BioNTech COVID-19 | Pharmaceutical and Medical Devices Agency (PMDA) reported adverse events following immunization (AEFI) | 578,835 doses | February–March 2021 | - | 181 suspected event reports of anaphylaxis and anaphylactoid symptoms (reporting rate: 8.1/100,000 doses) | - | In 171 of these 181 cases, women developed these symptoms. | [ |
| Pfizer–BioNTech COVID-19 (64.5%) | Cross-sectional trial with an independent online questionnaire | 1245 HCWs | 24 January–10 March 2021 | Soreness, fatigue, myalgia, headache, chills, fever, joint pain, nausea, muscle spasm, sweating, dizziness, flushing, feelings of relief, brain fogging, anorexia, localized swelling, decreased sleep quality, itching, tingling, diarrhea, nasal stuffiness, palpitations. | - | - | - | [ |
| Pfizer–BioNTech COVID-19 | Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS); Food and Drug Administration Adverse Event Reporting System (FAERS) | Women aged ≤50 years with hormonal contraceptive use | 19 March 2021 | - | 68 thromboembolic events | 1–6 days after vaccination | - | [ |
| Pfizer–BioNTech COVID-19 | Cross-sectional survey-based study | HCW in the Czech Republic | January–February 2021 | Injection site pain, fatigue, headache, muscle pain, chills. | - | 1 or 3 days | SEs more prevalent among the ≤43-year-old age group. | [ |
| Moderna COVID-19 vaccine | CDC report | 108 case reports of severe allergic | 21 December 2020–10 January 2021 | Pruritus, rash, itchy sensations in the mouth | 10 cases of anaphylaxis (2.5 anaphylaxis cases/million Moderna COVID-19 | 7–30 min after vaccination | - | [ |
| AstraZeneca | Online survey | Total 705: | - | Injection site pain, shoulder pain, muscle aches, headaches, fever, chills, weakness, nausea, vomiting, diarrhea in both vaccines. | - | - | AstraZeneca causes more SEs. | [ |
| Pfizer-BioNTech, | Online questionnaire | 599 HCWs in the Federal Republic of Germany | February–April 2021 | Injection site pain, headache, fatigue, muscle pain, malaise, chills, joint pain. More than one-sixth participants reported at least one oral side effect, including mucosal lesions, oral paresthesia, taste disturbance. | - | 1–3 days | mRNA-based vaccines: more local SEs. | [ |
| Pfizer- | COVID symptom study app | 282103 individuals (aged 16–99 years) | 8 December 2020–10 March 2021 | Headache, fatigue, chills, shivering, diarrhea, fever, arthralgia, myalgia, | - | 1–2 days | Adverse effects are more frequently reported in younger individuals, women, and among those who previously had COVID-19. | [ |
| Pfizer-BioNTech, AstraZeneca, | An interactive web-based | 1736 (18–86 years age). | 1 January–10 April 2021 | Fatigue, body pain, headache, muscle pain, fever, gastrointestinal effects (nausea, vomiting, anorexia, and diarrhea) in all three vaccines; tenderness or swollen lymph nodes in Pfizer; sweating, dizziness, dry cough, anxiety, shortness of breath, tachycardia, abdominal pain, sore throat, joint pain, nasal discharge in AstraZeneca | Six cases: (four- Pfizer and two AstraZeneca) admitted into the hospital due to severe hypotension, generalized body aches, shortness of breath, and fever of more than 39 °C. | 1–2.5 days | Signs and symptoms are more persistent for AstraZeneca | [ |
| AstraZeneca, Sputnik-V and Covaxin | 503 HCWs in Birjand (Iran) | 21 February–7 March 2021 | Injection site pain, fatigue, muscle pain, fever in all three vaccines. | - | - | SEs more persistent in female; Sputnik V and Covaxin reported lower SE occurrence in the elderly. | [ | |
| Sinopharm (51.1%) and | Semi-structured interviews on a phone call | 1004 Jordanian adults with no history of previous allergies | 10 March–2 April 2021 | Local and systemic effects: | No serious cases of hospitalization. | - | Pfizer was associated with greater rates, while Sinopharm was associated with a longer duration of SEs. | [ |
| Sinopharm | Google form | 583 Iranian multiple sclerosis (MS) patients | 1 May–22 May 2021 | Malaise, fatigue, fever, shivering, body pain, headache. | Five recipients (0.9%) reported MS relapse. | - | - | [ |
| AstraZeneca | Cross-sectional survey-based study | 92 HCWs/Germany and the Czech Republic | March 2021 | injection site discomfort, fatigue, muscle pain, chills, feeling unwell, nausea, headache | No serious cases of hospitalization/no blood disorder. | - | Chronic diseases were not associated with an increased risk of SE. | [ |
| Janssen | VAERS | 64 anxiety-related events | 7–9 April 2021 | tachycardia (rapid heart rate), hyperventilation (rapid breathing), dyspnea (difficulty breathing), chest pain, paresthesia (numbness or tingling), light-headedness, hypotension (low blood pressure), headache, pallor, or syncope | 17 reports of syncope (fainting): | Immediately after vaccination. | - | [ |
| Sputnik V | Observational study | 3236 reports out of 13,435 HCW | February–April 2021 | pain in the injection site, fatigue, body pain, headache, fever, joint pain, chilling, drowsiness. | - | - | SEs more frequent in females and younger | [ |
| Sputnik V | E-questionnaire | 2558 people from San Marino; aged 18-89 years | 4 March–8 April 2021 | Local site pain, nodules, swelling, warmth, asthenia, headache, joint pain, muscle pain, chills, malaise, fever. | - | - | Sputnik V shows a strong tolerance profile in the population aged ≥60 years. | [ |
| Sputnik V | An observational cohort study by the Ministry of Health of Buenos Aires City (CABA) | 707 HCWs in Hospital Italiano de Buenos Aires | 5–20 January 2021 | Injection site pain, redness, swelling. Fever, diarrhea, muscle pain. | - | - | - | [ |
| Sputnik V | LabelStudio data labeling tool to label the dataset | 4579 entities | December 2020–April 2021 | Injection site pain, fever, fatigue, headache, insomnia, nausea, vomiting, redness, pruritus, swelling, lymph nodes enlargement, diarrhea, chills. | - | - | - | [ |
| Sinopharm | Cross-sectional survey | The United Arab Emirates | January–April 2021 | Injection site pain, | No serious cases of hospitalization. | - | SEs are more common in ≤49 years of age and females. | [ |
| Sinopharm | Web-based cross-sectional survey. | ≥18 years of age 2000 resident of Karachi | 11 April–23 April 2021 | Fever, muscle pain, chills, arm pain, breathlessness, diarrhea, cough, flu, fatigue, chest pain, headache, abdominal pain, swelling in the legs and arms, multiple bruises, productive bleeding. | - | - | - | [ |
| Sinopharm COVID-19 | Closed-ended questionnaire | 155/400 Healthcare workers (HCWs) >18 years old; | March 2021 | Pain at the injection site, weariness, headache, light-headedness, myalgia. | No serious cases of hospitalization. | - | More SE in the 24–42-year age group; Sinopharm vaccine has no or minor negative effects. | [ |
| Covishield | Web-based self-report submission or vaccine event reporting system | 5637 HCWs in India | 16 January–6 February 2021 | Mild fever, myalgia, cold, cough, headache, local pain, swelling, fatigue, diarrhea, rigors, joint pain, nausea | - | - | - | [ |
| Sinovac | Questionnaire | 355 nurses in Turkey | - | fatigue, headache, arthritis, sore throat, nausea, fever, vertigo, nasal flow, appetite changes, diarrhea, itchiness, abdominal pain, cough, | - | - | - | [ |
| Different/Others | Online poll | 2002 | February 2021 | Fever, dyspnea, flu-like illness, weariness, local reactions. | Few serious adverse effects such as anaphylaxis, in viral vector-based immunizations. | - | mRNA vaccines linked with higher but milder incidence of any side effect. | [ |
| Different/Others | VAERS | 9442 reports of adverse events in the United States | March 2021 | Dizziness, headaches, discomfort, muscular spasms, myalgia, paresthesia. | Stroke (17), GBS (32), facial palsy (190), transverse myelitis (9 cases), acute disseminated encephalomyelitis (6 cases). | - | The rare occurrence of tinnitus, dysphonia, convulsions, and herpes zoster recurrence was reported. | [ |
Case studies with reported SEs of COVID-19 vaccinations.
| Vaccine | Cases | Patient | Date/Duration | Complication/Side Effects | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| mRNA-based COVID-19 immunization | Case I | 73-year-old female | 16 days after the first dose | Acute zoster ophthalmicus (HZO) in right V1 dermatome | [ |
| Case II | 69-year-old female | 10 days after the first dose | HZO in left V1 dermatome | ||
| Case II | 72-year-old female | 13 days after the first dose | An eruption in the left V1 dermatome | ||
| Inactivated COVID-19 immunization | 7 cases | 30–55 year seven patients (3 males) | Within 15 days of first dose | Ocular adverse effects: episcleritis, anterior scleritis, acute macular neuroretinopathy, acute middle maculopathy, subretinal fluid | [ |
| mRNA-based COVID-19 immunization | One case | 80-year-old female on hemodialysis for two and half years | 4 days after the first dose | Takotsubo cardiomyopathy with LV outflow tract obstruction | [ |
| mRNA-based COVID-19 immunization | One case | 29-year- old male | 6 days after the first dose | Multiple cranial neuropathy | [ |
| Inactivated COVID-19 immunization | One case | 18-year-old female | 5 days after second dose | Anterior uveitis associated with juvenile idiopathic arthritis (JIA) | [ |
| viral vector-based COVID-19 immunization | Two cases | - | - | Transverse myelitis is a neurological disorder; unlikely to be related to the vaccine as the patient already had multiple sclerosis | [ |
| mRNA-based COVID-19 immunization | One case | 29-year-old female | 16 days after the second dose | Autoimmune side effect: antineutrophil cytoplasmic autoantibody (ANCA)-associated vasculitis of acute kidney injury | [ |
| mRNA-based COVID-19 immunization | Case I | 53-year-old male with no previous history | 8 days after the second dose | Severe immune thrombocytopenia (ITP); platelet count of 2 × 109/L | [ |
| Case II | 67-year-old male previous chronic ITP patient but no history of recent flares of ITP | 2 days after the first dose | Severe ITP; platelet count of 2 × 109/L | ||
| Viral vector-based COVID-19 immunization | Case III (Janssen COVID-19 vaccine) | 59-year-old female with a history of chronic ITP | 2 days after the first dose | Severe ITP; platelet count of 64 × 109/L | |
| mRNA-based COVID-19 immunization | One case | 82-year-old female | 2 weeks after the first dose | Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS) with generalized body aches, paresthesia, and difficulty walking | [ |
| mRNA-based COVID-19 immunization | Case I | 47-year-old female | 15 days after first dose | Lympho-proliferative disease: left infra-clavicular non-painful lump along with fatigue, myalgia, and mild pyrexia to 38 °C | [ |
| Case II | 46-year-old female | 5 days after first dose | Left supraclavicular and axillary painful multiple enlarged lymph nodes, along with headaches, chills. | ||
| Case III | 42-year-old female | 18 days after the first dose | Left axillary lymph nodes up to 2 cm in diameter | ||
| mRNA-based COVID-19 immunization | Case I | 64 -year-old female with a history of shellfish allergy | Within 10 min of the first dose | Hypersensitivity reaction with generalized pruritus, urticaria, and self-reported tachycardia | [ |
| Case II | 39-year-old female with history of allergic rhinitis | Within 15 min of the first dose | Hypersensitivity reaction with chest and neck urticarial and mild facial angioedema | ||
| Inactivated COVID-19 immunization | One case | 18-year-old female with a history of antinuclear antibody positive oligoarticular juvenile idiopathic arthritis (JIA) | 5 days after the second dose | Bilateral anterior uveitis with reduced visual acuity in both eyes | [ |
| Viral vector-based COVID-19 immunization | One case | 74-year-old male | 3 days after the dose | Severe cutaneous adverse reaction with panhypopituitarism secondary to craniopharyngioma resection, vision loss of the left eye, neurogenic bladder, and obstructive sleep apnea | [ |
| Viral vector-based COVID-19 immunization | One case | 41-year-old morbidly obese gentleman | Within four weeks of dose | Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS) | [ |
| mRNA-based COVID-19 immunization | One case | 72-year-old female | 1 day | Idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura with a rash, spontaneous oral bleeding, headache and easy bruising or abnormal bleeding. | [ |
| mRNA-based COVID-19 immunization | Case I | 74-year-old female | 8 days after the first dose | COVID arm: pruritic, erythematous plaque with mild scaling on her left upper arm, rash spread to 15 cm in diameter over 10 days | [ |
| Case II | 62-year-old female | 8 days after the first dose | COVID arm: Pruritic erythematous rash on her left deltoid, began as a maculopapular eruption over the injection site | ||
| Case III | 54-year-old female | 7 days after the first dose | COVID arm: Erythematous, non-scaly patch on her left upper arm | ||
| Case IV | 72-year-old female | 10 days after the first dose | COVID arm: Erythematous patch on left deltoid surrounding the injection site, pruritic, warm to the touch, and measured 14 cm in diameter | ||
| mRNA-based COVID-19 immunization | Case I | 77-year-old male with a history of Psoriasis and Crohn’s Disease | 2 days after the first dose | Shingles (herpes zoster) with severely painful, unilateral dermatomal herpetiform eruptions | [ |
| Case II | 65-year-old male | After second dose | Shingles (herpes zoster) with painful, erythematous, clustered skin eruptions and pruritus | ||
| mRNA-based COVID-19 immunization | Case I | 58-year-old male | 1 day after first dose | Varicella-zoster virus reactivation: herpetiform umbilicated vesicle with fever and cervical lymphadenopathy | [ |
| Case II | 47-year-old female | 5 days after the first dose | Varicella-zoster virus reactivation: herpetiform umbilicated vesicle with fever and dysesthesia | ||
| Case III | 39-year-old male | 3 days after the first dose | Varicella-zoster virus reactivation: painful Herpetiform umbilicated vesicles | ||
| Case IV | 56-year-old female | 2 days after the second dose | Varicella-zoster virus reactivation: herpetiform umbilicated vesicle with fever and dysesthesia | ||
| Case V | 41-year-old female | 16 days after the second dose | Varicella-zoster virus reactivation: herpetiform umbilicated vesicle with fever and dysesthesia | ||
| mRNA-based COVID-19 immunization | Case I | 52-year-old male | 2 weeks after the dose | Anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic antibody (ANCA) glomerulonephritis | [ |
| Case II | 39-year-old male | Immediately after second dose | Acute kidney injury (AKI) with nephritic syndrome, de novo vasculitis | ||
| Case III | 81-year-old male | Mild after the first dose, worsened after the second dose | AKI, proteinuria, de novo vasculitis | ||
| mRNA-based COVID-19 immunization | Case I | 86-year-old female | 7 days after the dose | Encephalopathy associated with non-convulsive status epilepticusat, poor neurological function, acute confusion, Visual hallucinations, Left frontal headache | [ |
| Case II | 73-year-old male | 7 days after the first dose | Encephalopathy associated with non-convulsive status epilepticusat, staring episodes, restlessness, cognitive deficits. | ||
| mRNA-based COVID-19 immunization | Case I | 64-year-old woman with chronic idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura (ITP) | 2 days after the first dose | Acute immune thrombocytopenia with oral bleeding and generalized petechiae. | [ |
| Case II | 61-year-old woman with scleroderma | After the second dose | Acute immune thrombocytopenia with petechiae on both legs after. | ||
| Case III | 73-year-old woman | 11 days after the first dose | Acute immune thrombocytopenia with generalized petechiae. | ||
| mRNA-based COVID-19 immunization | Case I | 35-year-old Caucasian woman, stable history of clinically isolated demyelinating syndrome (CIS), | Twenty-one days after the second dose | CNS demyelination: New neurologic symptoms with ataxia/dysmetria in the right upper extremity, and mild gait ataxia, with an Expanded Disability Status Scale (EDSS) score of 2.5. | [ |
| Case II | 26-year-old white Hispanic woman no significant past medical history | Fourteen days after the second dose | CNS demyelination: New visual symptoms involving the right eye, mild blurring, progressed to worsening blurriness and pain with eye movement OD. | ||
| Case III | 24-year-old Vietnamese woman | One day after the second dose | CNS demyelination: Presented with new onset left eye vision changes; visual symptoms in the right eye with blurred vision and pain on eye movement with monocular decreased visual acuity. | ||
| Case IV | 64-year-old Caucasian man with no history of neurologic diseases, | Eighteen days after the first dose | CNS demyelination: Pain and paresthesia in his upper abdomen progressed to right lower extremity numbness, weakness, pain and numbness in the bilateral lower extremities, saddle anesthesia, sphincter dysfunction, and balance/gait difficulty. | ||
| Case V | 33-year-old Caucasian man with no significant past medical history | One day after the second dose | CNS demyelination: Unilateral painless blurring of vision with visual acuity of 20/50 OS and multiple T2 hyperintense white matter lesions on brain MRI. | ||
| Case VI | 44-year-old Caucasian woman with a medical history of MS at age 20 when | Six days after the second dose | CNS demyelination: Transient low-grade fever with new neurological symptoms including numbness that ascended from her feet to the middle of her waist without any bowel or bladder incontinence. EDSS score of 1.5 with mild right deltoid and iliopsoas weakness. | ||
| Case VII | 48-year-old Caucasian woman with a history of the Clinically isolated demyelinating syndrome (CIS) | 15 days after the first dose | CNS demyelination: developed with a painful sensation behind her right eye, worsening with eye movement; Brain MRI showed three new T2 hyperintense white matter lesions compared to prior imaging 2 years earlier. | ||
| Inactivated COVID-19 immunization | One case | A 76-year-old female | 1 day after vaccination | Acute asthma exacerbation with multiple infiltrations in both lungs and ground-glass shadows in both lung fields. | [ |
Figure 2Clinical cases for adverse effects after COVID-19 vaccinations.