Federica Curti1,2, Simone Fortunati1, Wolfgang Knoll2,3, Marco Giannetto1, Roberto Corradini1, Alessandro Bertucci1, Maria Careri1. 1. Department of Chemistry, Life Sciences and Environmental Sustainability, University of Parma, 43124 Parma, Italy. 2. Biosensor Technologies, AIT-Austrian Institute of Technology GmbH, Konrad-Lorenz-Straße 24, 3430 Tulln an der Donau, Austria. 3. Department of Scientific Coordination and Management, Danube Private University, A-3500 Krems, Austria.
Abstract
Efficient and timely testing has taken center stage in the management, control, and monitoring of the current COVID-19 pandemic. Simple, rapid, cost-effective diagnostics are needed that can complement current polymerase chain reaction-based methods and lateral flow immunoassays. Here, we report the development of an electrochemical sensing platform based on single-walled carbon nanotube screen-printed electrodes (SWCNT-SPEs) functionalized with a redox-tagged DNA aptamer that specifically binds to the receptor binding domain of the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein S1 subunit. Single-step, reagentless detection of the S1 protein is achieved through a binding-induced, concentration-dependent folding of the DNA aptamer that reduces the efficiency of the electron transfer process between the redox tag and the electrode surface and causes a suppression of the resulting amperometric signal. This aptasensor is specific for the target S1 protein with a dissociation constant (KD) value of 43 ± 4 nM and a limit of detection of 7 nM. We demonstrate that the target S1 protein can be detected both in a buffer solution and in an artificial viral transport medium widely used for the collection of nasopharyngeal swabs, and that no cross-reactivity is observed in the presence of different, non-target viral proteins. We expect that this SWCNT-SPE-based format of electrochemical aptasensor will prove useful for the detection of other protein targets for which nucleic acid aptamer ligands are made available.
Efficient and timely testing has taken center stage in the management, control, and monitoring of the current COVID-19 pandemic. Simple, rapid, cost-effective diagnostics are needed that can complement current polymerase chain reaction-based methods and lateral flow immunoassays. Here, we report the development of an electrochemical sensing platform based on single-walled carbon nanotube screen-printed electrodes (SWCNT-SPEs) functionalized with a redox-tagged DNA aptamer that specifically binds to the receptor binding domain of the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein S1 subunit. Single-step, reagentless detection of the S1 protein is achieved through a binding-induced, concentration-dependent folding of the DNA aptamer that reduces the efficiency of the electron transfer process between the redox tag and the electrode surface and causes a suppression of the resulting amperometric signal. This aptasensor is specific for the target S1 protein with a dissociation constant (KD) value of 43 ± 4 nM and a limit of detection of 7 nM. We demonstrate that the target S1 protein can be detected both in a buffer solution and in an artificial viral transport medium widely used for the collection of nasopharyngeal swabs, and that no cross-reactivity is observed in the presence of different, non-target viral proteins. We expect that this SWCNT-SPE-based format of electrochemical aptasensor will prove useful for the detection of other protein targets for which nucleic acid aptamer ligands are made available.
Entities:
Keywords:
COVID-19; DNA aptamer; DNA nanotechnology; electrochemical sensors; single-walled carbon nanotubes
The
development of rapid, easy-to-use, portable devices for the
detection and quantification of specific proteins is key to more efficient
and effective laboratory practices and clinical decisions.Particularly
with the emerging risks to public health posed by
virus outbreaks and spreading of pathogens, new approaches for the
detection of protein antigens are needed that can combine high specificity
and sensitivity with a cost-effective and time-saving procedure. Electrochemical
biosensors are especially amenable for this purpose because they can
be easily engineered into point-of-care (POC) diagnostic devices enabling
the rapid detection and quantification of selected targets.[1−5] The current COVID-19 pandemic caused by the spread of the severe
acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) has emphasized
the importance of having at hand efficient and reliable analytical
platforms. This disease continues to claim victims and to determine
disruptions in healthcare systems, economies, and social life worldwide.[6−8] The deployment at a fast pace of different COVID-19 vaccines has
had a huge impact on the pandemic by offering protection from severe
and acute forms of the disease and therefore helping reduce hospitalization
and mortality.[9,10] Nevertheless, vaccines alone
are not able to contain the spread of the virus, and complementary
measures must be enforced.[11,12] Efficient and focused
testing is necessary for timely spotting SARS-CoV-2 infection, monitoring
the diffusion of the disease, and curbing transmission of the virus.[13,14] COVID-19 diagnostics has taken center stage in everyday life, especially
where proof of a negative test is a requirement for traveling and
for accessing public and private spaces.[15,16] Currently, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is the gold standard
method to detect SARS-CoV-2 infection, enabling quantification of
viral RNA with high sensitivity and specificity. However, PCR is reagent-intensive
and requires trained personnel and relatively expensive instrumentation.
This leads, on the one hand, to waiting times that are not compatible
with the highly frequent testing enforced in wealthy countries and
determines, on the other hand, a series of practical obstacles to
a widespread application in low-resource settings.[17,18] Cost-effective, time-saving point-of-care (POC) tests that can complement
PCR-based methods are therefore much needed. Lateral flow immunoassays
enable the rapid detection of a SARS-CoV-2 antigen by using low-cost,
portable hardware.[19] However, their relatively
low sensitivity and specificity is a limit to their ability to provide
unambiguous information for accurate diagnostics and therefore to
their potential to guide healthcare and policy measures.[20] In response to these limitations, several electrochemical
COVID-19 immunosensors were recently developed that enabled ultrasensitive
detection of SARS-CoV-2 antigen proteins.[21−24] A particular format of electrochemical
sensors is E-DNAs. These are rapid, simple, reagent-free sensors that
leverage target-induced conformational or structural changes in a
DNA-based architecture or in a DNA aptamer to generate a measurable
output following variation of the electron transfer efficiency between
a redox reporter and the electrode surface.[25−27] In the context
of COVID-19, Kelley and coworkers achieved detection of viral particles
within 5 min through a chronoamperometry strategy based on electrodes
modified with hybrid DNA-antibody receptors targeting the SARS-CoV-2
spike (S) protein displayed on the virion surface.[28] In aptamer-based E-DNAs, an electrochemical signal is generated
when a binding-induced change in the structure folding of a redox-tagged
aptamer leads to a change in the relative position of the redox reporter
with respect to the electrode surface.[29] Recently, Idili et al. applied this strategy to COVID-19 diagnosis
and performed electrochemical detection of the SARS-CoV-2 S protein
by using gold electrodes modified with a DNA aptamer engineered to
undergo a binding-induced conformational change.[30] In such a context, here we report the development on an
electrochemical sensing platform based on cheap, commercially available
single-walled carbon nanotube screen-printed electrodes (SWCNT-SPEs)
functionalized with a redox-tagged DNA aptamer selected against the
receptor binding domain (RBD) of the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein S1 subunit.[31] Binding-induced folding of this DNA aptamer
in the presence of the target S1 protein leads to a concentration-dependent
suppression in the registered amperometric signal. We demonstrate
that this aptasensor specifically recognizes and detects the target
S1 protein both in a buffer solution and in an artificial complex
matrix, requiring only a few hours of incubation and no additional
reagents.
Experimental Section
Materials
Sodium chloride (NaCl;
ACS reagent ≥99.0%), sodium bicarbonate (NaHCO3;
ACS reagent ≥99.7%), disodium hydrogen phosphate (Na2HPO4; anhydrous 99.99% Suprapur), potassium dihydrogen
phosphate (KH2PO4; 99.995% anhydrous basis,
Suprapur), sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS; ACS reagent ≥99.0%),
Trizma Base (puriss. p.a., ≥99.7%), N-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)-N′-ethylcarbodiimide hydrochloride (EDC; purum, ≥98.0%
(AT)), N-hydroxysuccinimide (NHS; purum, ≥97.0%
(AT)), 4-morpholineethanesulfonic acid monohydrate (MES; BioXtra,
≥99.0% (T)), pyrene (98%), ethanolamine (ACS reagent ≥99.0%),
hydrochloric acid (HCl; 37% w/v), potassium chloride (KCl; ACS reagent,
≥99.0%), sodium hydroxide (NaOH; ACS reagent, ≥97.0%),
dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO; anhydrous ≥99.9%) were purchased
from Sigma-Aldrich (Milan, Italy). Viral Transport Medium (VTM) was
purchased from CleaniSciences (Guidonia Montecelio, Italy). The following
synthetic probes were purchased from Metabion International AG (Plannegg,
Germany): redox-tagged SARS-CoV-2 aptamer: 5′-AttoMB2-CGC AGC
ACC CAA GAA CAA GGA CTG CTT AGG ATT GCG ATA GGT TCG GTT TTT –
C7 Amino-3′; SARS-CoV-2 aptamer: 5′-CGC AGC ACC CAA
GAA CAA GGA CTG CTT AGG ATT GCG ATA GGT TCG GTT TTT-C7 Amino-3′;
redox-tagged thrombin aptamer: 5′-AttoMB2-TAA GTT CAT CTC CCC
GGT TGG TGT GGT TGG T-C7 Amino-3′; redox-tagged PDGF aptamer:
5′-AttoMB2-CAG GCT ACG GCA CGT AGA GCA TCA CCA TGA TCC TG-C7
Amino-3′. SARS-CoV-2 Spike protein (S1) and Influenza A H1N1
(A/California/04/2009 (H1N1)) were purchased from Twin Helix Srl (Milan,
Italy). Recombinant Coronavirus Spike Protein MERS-CoV S1 was purchased
from Vinci-Biochem Srl (Vinci, Italy). Buffers were prepared as follows:
MES buffer: 0.1 M MES (pH adjusted to 5 with NaOH); Tris-buffered
saline (TBS): 0.1 M Trizma base (pH adjusted to 7.4 with HCl); carbonate
buffer (CB): 0.1 M NaHCO3, 0.1% w/v SDS (pH adjusted to
9 with NaOH); phosphate-buffer saline (PBS): 1.37 M NaCl, 0.08 M Na2HPO4, 0.027 M KCl, 0.012 M KH2PO4 (pH adjusted to 7.4 with HCl); reading buffer (RB): PBS.
Single-walled carbon nanotube screen-printed electrodes (SWCNT-SPEs)
were purchased from Metrohm Italiana Srl (Varese, Italy).
Aptamer Immobilization on SWCNT-SPEs
The SWCNT surface
was initially treated with 0.2 M EDC and 0.05 M
NHS in MES buffer (50 μL) for 30 min to activate the carboxylic
groups of the carbon nanotubes, followed by rinsing with water. Subsequently,
50 μL of redox-tagged SARS-CoV-2 aptamer (500 nM) solution in
CB was deposited onto the SWCNT electrode and left incubating for
2 h. The electrode was then thoroughly washed with water. A capping
step of 30 min using ethanolamine in TBS (50 mM) was carried out to
quench the unreacted active ester groups. Next, the surface was washed
with TBS. A solution of pyrene as a backfilling agent in DMSO (500
nM) was deposited on the electrode (50 μL) for 30 min, after
which the electrode was rinsed first with DMSO and then with water.
Determination of the Aptamer Surface Density
Fluorescence spectroscopy was used to estimate the surface density
of the covalently immobilized SARS-CoV-2 aptamer. The emission of
the redox-tag AttoMB2 conjugated to the aptamer sequence was collected
in solution at λEm = 680 nm (λEx = 650 nm) before (I) and after (I) the aptamer immobilization on the electrode
(Figure S2). The ΔI percentage was used to estimate the number of aptamer probes
per mm2 tethered to the CNTs (see eqs 1–6 in the SI). The measurements were replicated three times,
and the value obtained is reported as the mean value ± standard
deviation.
Detection of S1 Protein
A solution
of S1 protein at different concentrations (0.3, 1, 3, 10, 25, 30,
50, 100, 300, and 500 nM) in PBS was incubated for 2 h, at room temperature,
on the electrode surface, followed by rinsing with PBS. Next, 50 μL
of PBS was deposited onto the surface and the electrochemical measurement
was performed by acquiring a DPV scan with the following parameters:
potential range from −1.1 to −0.2 V; step potential
+0.00495 V; modulation amplitude +0.04995 V; modulation time 0.102
s; interval time 0.4 s. The same protocol was applied during specificity
studies, when a thrombin aptamer and a PDGF aptamer, respectively,
were immobilized onto the electrode surface and exposed to S1 protein,
as well as when MERS-CoV S1 and Influenza-A H1N1 proteins were incubated
onto the electrode surface previously functionalized with the SARS-CoV-2
aptamer. This protocol and acquisition parameters were also used for
measurements of S1 protein diluted in VTM as the binding buffer (50
and 100 nM).
Competitive Experiments
of S1 Protein Binding
The electrode surface was functionalized
as described above with
a redox-tagged SARS-CoV-2 aptamer. The target S1 protein (100 nM concentration,
PBS) was incubated with an unlabeled version of the same SARS-CoV-2
aptamer sequence for 2 h at room temperature. This solution was then
transferred onto the electrode surface and left incubating for 2 h.
Then, the electrode surface was washed with PBS and 50 μL of
PBS were deposited onto the surface to carry out the electrochemical
measurement by acquiring a DPV scan with the same parameters reported
in Section .
Data Analysis
The current signals
obtained from the electrochemical measurements as a function of the
corresponding S1 protein concentrations were analyzed in OriginPro
(OriginLab) by using the Langmuir-type equation reported below:where KD is the
dissociation constant and a and c are the fitting parameters of the Langmuir equation. All the measurements
were replicated three times, and all the figures show the mean values
± standard deviations. The limit of detection (LOD) and limit
of quantification (LOQ) were determined according to Eurachem guidelines
(https://www.eurachem.org).
Results and Discussion
Immobilization
of SARS-CoV-2 DNA Aptamer
Several aptamers have been recently
artificially evolved that can
specifically bind to the S1 protein of SARS-CoV-2 and can potentially
support new therapeutic strategies for COVID-19.[31−34] DNA aptamers can be used in lieu
of antibodies as specific recognition elements in the development
of SARS-CoV-2 biosensors, enabling a range of sensing platforms with
optical or electrochemical readout.[30,32,35−40] Besides their use as “static” synthetic receptors,
aptamers are useful as “dynamic” probes in folding-based
E-DNAs. In this work, we propose a novel E-DNA format for the single-step,
reagent-free detection of the S1 protein that leverages cheap, commercially
available SWCNT-SPEs as the sensing substrate. SWCNT-SPEs are a promising
electrochemical platform because they are cheaper than standard gold
electrodes, they show intrinsic electrocatalytic properties and a
high conductivity that both improve electron transfer processes at
the interface and provide enhanced amplification of current signal,
and they offer a larger surface area for immobilization of an increased
number of probes and receptors.[41−43] The sensing mechanism of our
sensor is based on a rearrangement in the redox-tagged aptamer structure
induced by binding to the target S1 protein, which translates in a
measurable electrochemical output. A fast electron transfer is observed
in the absence of the target protein because of the π–π
interactions between the redox-tagged DNA aptamer and the carbon nanotubes
that bring the AttoMB2 tag in close proximity to the electrode surface.
Conversely, in the presence of the target, the aptamer undergoes a
binding-induced structural folding that increases the distance between
the redox tag and electrode surface, thus reducing the efficiency
of the electron transfer process and causing a decrease in the registered
amperometric current (Figure ).
Figure 1
(a) Schematic illustration of the working principle of the aptasensor
based on the conformational change in a redox-tagged SARS-CoV-2 aptamer
upon interaction with the target S1 protein. A suppression of the
output current is observed in the presence of S1 protein because of
the structural rearrangement in the aptamer folding that moves the
redox reporter away from the electrode surface. (b) Secondary structure
of the AttoMB2-modified SARS-CoV-2 aptamer used in this work, based
on a recently discovered aptamer sequence.[31]
(a) Schematic illustration of the working principle of the aptasensor
based on the conformational change in a redox-tagged SARS-CoV-2 aptamer
upon interaction with the target S1 protein. A suppression of the
output current is observed in the presence of S1 protein because of
the structural rearrangement in the aptamer folding that moves the
redox reporter away from the electrode surface. (b) Secondary structure
of the AttoMB2-modified SARS-CoV-2 aptamer used in this work, based
on a recently discovered aptamer sequence.[31]To fabricate the aptasensor, we
used a modified version of a recently
published SARS-CoV-2 DNA aptamer that specifically binds to the receptor
binding domain (RBD) of the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein S1 subunit.[31] We conjugated the aptamer at its 3′ terminus
with an AttoMB2 tag, a derivative of the common redox tag methylene
blue that generates an electrochemical signal measured by DPV and
also allows for performing fluorescence spectroscopy measurements
based on its emission properties. A free amine group was introduced
instead at the 5′ terminus of the aptamer sequence to allow
covalent anchoring to the electrode surface through the formation
of an amide bond with the carboxylic groups present on the SWCNTs,
using EDC/NHS as a coupling mixture. This coupling reaction had been
already used in several works[43−45] and was further optimized by
diluting the aptamer in carbonate buffer (pH = 9) with 0.1% SDS to
increase the wettability of the CNT hydrophobic surface. The concentration
of the aptamer in the carbonate buffer solution used for covalent
immobilization on the electrode surface was 500 nM, based on a previous
work in which we investigated different concentrations of biotinylated
amine-modified DNA probes to maximize surface functionalization, using
an enzyme-based reaction to generate an electrochemical signal proportional
to the amount of DNA probes attached to the electrode surface (Figure S1).[44] The
surface density of the aptamer was estimated by means of fluorescence
spectroscopy following the emission of the AttoMB2 tag at λ
= 680 nm before and after the immobilization of the aptamer onto the
surface (Figure S2). A value of (1.7 ±
0.4) · 1013 aptamer molecules per mm2 was
obtained, which is higher than the average values generally found
in the literature for E-DNAs based on gold electrode substrates.[46,47] The electrode surface was eventually treated with a solution of
pyrene in DMSO as a backfilling agent to minimize non-specific adsorption
of the biomolecules contained in the analyzed samples. This pyrene-based
backfilling strategy was developed and applied in previous works and
proved particularly efficient in reducing non-specific adsorption
of non-target biological molecules when compared to other common blocking
strategies such as BSA.[43,44]
S1 Protein-Aptamer
Interaction Analysis
The sensor was then exposed to increasing
concentrations of S1
protein from 0.3 to 500 nM in PBS buffer, and DPV voltammograms were
acquired. We observed a signal-off behavior, i.e., a decrease in the
amperometric signal given by the AttoMB2 redox reporter, after interaction
of the aptamer with the different concentrations of the S1 protein,
which likely depends on AttoMB2 moving away from the electrode surface
upon target-induced folding of the DNA aptamer (Figure a). The decrease in the registered amperometric
current can be expressed as signal suppression % with respect to the
current signal measured in the absence of S1 protein. The obtained
data were analyzed by means of a Langmuir-type binding curve model
and the dissociation constant value between the aptamer attached to
the electrode surface and its target S1 protein was KD = 43 ± 4 nM (Figure b). This is in good agreement with the affinity measured
in solution by means of fluorescence spectroscopy reported for the
original aptamer (KD = 45 ± 10 nM).[31] In particular, it was possible to obtain a limit
of detection (LOD) of 7 nM and a limit of quantification (LOQ) of
21 nM (Figure c).
Figure 2
(a) DPV
voltammograms obtained in the presence of S1 SARS-CoV-2
protein in the concentration range 0.3–300 nM. (b) Binding
curve based on a Langmuir-type equation describing the response current
as a function of the S1 protein concentration. Highlighted is the
concentration range in which response is linear. (c) Calibration curve
obtained by linear fit of the response current values in the 20–100
nM S1 protein concentration range (in all the figures, data are reported
as mean value ± SD, n = 3).
(a) DPV
voltammograms obtained in the presence of S1 SARS-CoV-2
protein in the concentration range 0.3–300 nM. (b) Binding
curve based on a Langmuir-type equation describing the response current
as a function of the S1 protein concentration. Highlighted is the
concentration range in which response is linear. (c) Calibration curve
obtained by linear fit of the response current values in the 20–100
nM S1 protein concentration range (in all the figures, data are reported
as mean value ± SD, n = 3).
Specificity in the S1 Protein–Aptamer
Interaction
Further evidence of the interaction between the
DNA aptamer and the target S1 protein, which supports the switching
mechanism proposed for the developed aptasensor, was achieved by means
of a competitive experiment[48] in which
the S1 protein (100 nM) was pre-incubated in solution with a non-redox-tagged
version of the same SARS-CoV-2 aptamer sequence, utilized as a competitor.
Binding of this aptamer to the RBD of the target S1 protein would
result in impeding subsequent binding to the redox-tagged aptamer
on the electrode surface (Figure a). When the S1 protein was pre-treated with the aptamer
competitor, only a slight change in the current signal was observed
compared with that in the absence of the protein (Figure b), and the signal suppression
was only a fraction (∼17%) of that obtained in the absence
of the competitor at the same concentration of S1 protein (Figure c). This suggests
that the RBD of the S1 protein was already occupied by the competitor
inhibiting further binding, and the aptamer immobilized on the surface
retained its conformational structure maintaining the redox reporter
AttoMB2 close to the electrode surface.
Figure 3
(a) Schematic illustration
of the aptasensor behavior when pre-treating
the target S1 protein with the same SARS-CoV-2 aptamer, lacking the
redox reporter, as a competitor in solution. (b) DPV voltammograms
in the absence of the target protein (only aptamer, dark blue line),
in the presence of 100 nM S1 protein pre-incubated with an excess
of competitor aptamer (+ S1 protein + competitor, green line), and
in the presence of the S1 protein at 100 nM concentration (+ S1 protein,
light blue line). (c) Relative signal suppression obtained when measuring
the amperometric current in the presence of S1 protein 100 nM (light
blue bar) and in the presence of the same protein incubated with the
aptamer competitor (white bar). (d) Specificity of the sensor evaluated
by using different aptamer sequences immobilized onto the electrode
surface (SARS-CoV-2, PDGF, and thrombin aptamer) in the presence of
S1 protein at 100 nM concentration in PBS (left panel), and by using
different proteins at 100 nM concentration in PBS (S1 SARS-CoV-2,
S1 MERS and H1N1) when the SARS-CoV-2 aptamer is immobilized onto
the electrode surface (right panel) (in all the figures data are reported
as mean value ± SD, n = 3).
(a) Schematic illustration
of the aptasensor behavior when pre-treating
the target S1 protein with the same SARS-CoV-2 aptamer, lacking the
redox reporter, as a competitor in solution. (b) DPV voltammograms
in the absence of the target protein (only aptamer, dark blue line),
in the presence of 100 nM S1 protein pre-incubated with an excess
of competitor aptamer (+ S1 protein + competitor, green line), and
in the presence of the S1 protein at 100 nM concentration (+ S1 protein,
light blue line). (c) Relative signal suppression obtained when measuring
the amperometric current in the presence of S1 protein 100 nM (light
blue bar) and in the presence of the same protein incubated with the
aptamer competitor (white bar). (d) Specificity of the sensor evaluated
by using different aptamer sequences immobilized onto the electrode
surface (SARS-CoV-2, PDGF, and thrombin aptamer) in the presence of
S1 protein at 100 nM concentration in PBS (left panel), and by using
different proteins at 100 nM concentration in PBS (S1 SARS-CoV-2,
S1 MERS and H1N1) when the SARS-CoV-2 aptamer is immobilized onto
the electrode surface (right panel) (in all the figures data are reported
as mean value ± SD, n = 3).The same experiment conducted extending the incubation time up
to 24 h led to no significant effects in the measured current signal
(p > 0.05) and therefore in the calculated relative
signal suppression % (Figure S3). This
indicated that an incubation time of 2 h was enough for achieving
tight binding of the aptamer to its target spike protein, which indirectly
suggested that the same incubation time would work also when the binding
event involves the redox-tagged aptamer immobilized on the electrode
surface.We then tested the ability of our aptasensor to recognize
its target
S1 protein in a specific manner. To do so, we first exposed it to
two different viral proteins from Middle East respiratory syndrome
coronavirus (MERS-CoV) and Influenza A H1N1 as model potential interfering
pathogens. At saturating concentrations (100 nM), signal suppression
of only ∼15% when using the MERS-CoV protein and of ∼19%
when using the Influenza A H1N1 protein, respectively, were registered
with respect to the signal suppression % obtained with the target
S1 protein (Figure d, right). To have further confirmation that the changes in the current
signal were specific to binding of the S1 protein to its cognate aptamer
ligand, we immobilized two different aptamer sequences, a thrombin
DNA aptamer and a prostate-derived growth factor (PDGF) DNA aptamer,
on the electrode surface, and exposed them to the S1 protein. We selected
these aptamers because they had been previously used in the development
of folding-based electrochemical sensors.[49,50] In the presence of 100 nM S1 protein, a 15% signal suppression with
the thrombin aptamer and a 21% signal suppression with the PDGF aptamer,
with respect to the signal suppression obtained using the correct
S1 protein–aptamer couple, were observed, showing that cross-reactivity
was minimal (Figure d, left).
S1 Protein Detection in
Viral Transport Medium
To test the aptasensor ability to
function in a more challenging
matrix mimicking a real-world scenario, we investigated its performance
when using S1 protein samples in viral transport medium (VTM), an
artificial complex matrix used in the clinic for rapid antigen detection
tests. Its composition includes physiologically balanced isotonic
buffered solution at neutral pH, a stabilizing protein component,
and antibacterial and antifungal agents.When the aptasensor
was exposed to VTM-based solutions of S1 protein at concentrations
of 50 and of 100 nM, a decrease in the measured current signal was
observed (Figure a).
Values of signal suppression % of 15% and 36% were obtained (Figure b). These values
indicate that the aptasensor is still capable of recognizing and detecting
the target S1 protein in a concentration-dependent manner, although
the use of a complex matrix such as VTM has an impact on its analytical
performances and leads to signal suppression values that are lower
than those obtained using S1 protein samples in PBS (Figure b). Among the many possible
effects, a change in the ionic strength of the medium due to the high
salt concentration in the VTM can be a major cause of interference
as this is known to affect the binding affinity properties of DNA
aptamers.[51,52] However, we note that the response of the
aptasensor was only slightly affected by the use of undiluted VTM,
especially when compared with analogous effects observed with other
COVID-19 biosensors.[53] For a better contextualization
of the performances of the developed aptasensor, we have reported
in Table the characteristics
of several recent biosensors with relevance to our sensor format,
that is, consisting of a nanostructured substrate and targeting a
protein antigen from SARS-CoV-2.
Figure 4
(a) DPV voltammogram obtained in the presence
of target S1 protein
in VTM at 50 and 100 nM. (b) Histograms showing the sensor performance,
expressed as signal suppression %, when the S1 protein is dissolved
in PBS (blue bars) or VTM (red bars) (mean value ± SD, n = 3).
Table 1
Characteristics
of Recently Developed
Nanostructured Biosensors for SARS-CoV-2 Detection
nanostructured
substrate
transduction
recognition
element
SARS-CoV-2
target element
LOD
reference
carbon nanotubes
optical
ACE2 receptor
RBD
9.5 nM
(54)
chitosan/graphitic carbon
photo-electrochemical
aptamer
RBD
0.12 nM
(55)
nitride cadmium selenide
gold-coated platinum
nanoparticles
electrochemical
aptamer
nucleocapsid protein
8.33 pg/mL
(56)
carbon
nanotube FET
electronic
SARS-CoV-2 S1 antibody
spike protein
4.12 fg/mL
(57)
single-walled carbon nanotubes
electrochemical
aptamer
RBD
7 nM
this work
(a) DPV voltammogram obtained in the presence
of target S1 protein
in VTM at 50 and 100 nM. (b) Histograms showing the sensor performance,
expressed as signal suppression %, when the S1 protein is dissolved
in PBS (blue bars) or VTM (red bars) (mean value ± SD, n = 3).
Conclusions
Folding-based E-DNAs that use target-induced changes in an aptamer
structure have been previously designed and enabled protein detection
on gold electrodes.[30,58,59] In this context, we investigated a novel folding-based electrochemical
biosensor based on cheap, highly conductive SWCNT-SPEs as a new substrate
for aptamer-based E-DNAs, allowing the development of a rapid and
reagent-free electrochemical sensing platform for the single-step
detection of the SARS-CoV-2 S1 protein. This biosensor benefits from
the advantageous physicochemical properties of SWCNT-SPEs and leverages
a folding-based mechanism that results in significant changes in the
measurable amperometric current upon specific binding of the S1 protein
to a DNA aptamer ligand. The obtained LOD and LOQ in the low nanomolar
range, together with the high specificity for the target protein and
the low cross-reactivity in the presence of interfering viral proteins,
all suggest the potential use of this aptasensor as a compact, easy-to-use
sensing device for the detection of the S1 protein in a buffer solution
or in a complex biological matrix. As the expected concentration of
S1 spike protein in an aqueous or VTM-based sample can largely vary
depending on sample pre-treatment, which can include lysis, pre-concentration,
or purification processes, the “fitness for purpose”
of the aptasensor to analyze an unknown sample should be evaluated
within a given context and specific working conditions.[60] The aptamer sequence used in this work was demonstrated
to fold up and bind to the Spike protein on the virion surface, inducing
neutralization of the whole SARS-CoV-2 virus and blocking cell infection in vitro.(31) Based on these results,
it is likely that the same aptamer sequence used in the development
of our aptasensor would be able to interact and bind to the spike
protein displayed on the surface of the virion, therefore enabling
detection of the whole SARS-CoV-2 virus. Further studies will be needed
to perform validation of the sensor using spiked and/or real samples
in VTM to determine analytical parameters, including an LOD and an
LOQ, relevant to the whole virus as the target analyte. We conclude
that the versatility and the simplicity of our design, in which a
DNA aptamer as a specific, dynamic recognition element is combined
with a CNT-based electrode substrate, could inspire the development
of many more electrochemical platforms of this kind. As new aptamers
designed to bind to desired target biomolecules are generated through
SELEX, a variety of new sensors can be envisioned with applications
in a wide range of fields.
Authors: Rebecca L Pinals; Francis Ledesma; Darwin Yang; Nicole Navarro; Sanghwa Jeong; John E Pak; Lili Kuo; Yung-Chun Chuang; Yu-Wei Cheng; Hung-Yu Sun; Markita P Landry Journal: Nano Lett Date: 2021-02-26 Impact factor: 11.189
Authors: Hanie Yousefi; Alam Mahmud; Dingran Chang; Jagotamoy Das; Surath Gomis; Jenise B Chen; Hansen Wang; Terek Been; Lily Yip; Eric Coomes; Zhijie Li; Samira Mubareka; Allison McGeer; Natasha Christie; Scott Gray-Owen; Alan Cochrane; James M Rini; Edward H Sargent; Shana O Kelley Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2021-01-22 Impact factor: 15.419