| Literature DB >> 35437820 |
Sophie Lee1, Justin Fernandez2, S Ali Mirjalili1, Joshua Kirkpatrick1.
Abstract
The paranasal sinuses (maxillary, frontal, ethmoid, and sphenoid sinuses) are complex anatomical structures. The development and growth of these have been investigated utilizing a number of different methods ranging from cadaveric analysis to modern cross sectional imaging with 3D modeling. An understanding of normal pediatric paranasal sinus embryology and development enables us to better determine when pathology may be affecting the normal developmental process. Cystic fibrosis, chronic sinusitis, deviated nasal septum and cleft lip and palate are some of the conditions which have been shown to effect paranasal sinus development to varying degrees. Functional endoscopic sinus surgery (FESS) is becoming increasingly common and an understanding of sinus anatomy together with when periods of rapid growth occur during childhood is important clinically. Although concerns have been raised regarding the impact of FESS on facial growth, there is limited evidence of this in regards to either changes in anthropomorphic measurements or clinical assessments of symmetry post operatively.Entities:
Keywords: anatomy; embryology; ethmoid; frontal; functional endoscopic sinus surgery; maxillary; pediatric paranasal sinuses; sphenoid
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35437820 PMCID: PMC9544638 DOI: 10.1002/ca.23888
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Clin Anat ISSN: 0897-3806 Impact factor: 2.409
FIGURE 1Paranasal sinus overview
FIGURE 2Literature search strategy for reports of paranasal sinus development in children. *Google scholar search limited to first 30 pages (300 hits)
Previous studies analyzing MS dimensions in children—length (anterior–posterior), height (cranio‐caudal), and width (transverse)
| Author | Sample size ( | Age (years) | Population | Methodology | Mean measurements from youngest age group studied (mm) | Mean measurements from oldest age group studied (mm) | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Length | Height | Width | Length | Height | Width | |||||
| Weiglein et al., | 134 | 0–12 | Austria | Dried skulls |
8–13 (age 0) |
3–4 (age 0) |
3–5 (age 0) |
35–40 (age 12) |
22–28 (age 12) |
20–29 (age 12) |
| Wolf et al., | 102 | 0–12 | Austria | Dried skulls + cadavers |
10 (age 0) |
4 (age 0) |
3 (age 0) |
34–38 (age 4–8) |
22–26 (age 4–8) |
18–24 (age 4–8) |
| Schaeffer, | Not stated | 0–18 | USA | Cadavers |
7–8 (at birth) |
4–6 (at birth) |
3–4 (at birth) |
31–33 (age 18) |
20–21 (age 18) |
19–21 (age 18) |
| Robinson et al., | 24 normal controls | 0–19 | USA | X‐ray |
26 (age 0) |
10 (age 0) | — |
41 (age 19) |
33 (age 19) | — |
| Bhushan et al., | 139 | 0–18 | USA | CT |
R: 25.1 L: 24.3 (age < 6) |
R: 17.8 L: 17.6 (age < 6) |
R: 16.5 L: 16 (age < 6) |
R: 36 L: 36.7 (age > 12) |
R: 35.6 L: 35.8 (age > 12) |
R: 24.6 L: 24.9 (age > 12) |
| Sánchez Fernández et al., | 100 normal controls | 1–88 | Spain | CT |
16 (age 1–5) | — |
8 (age 1–5) |
26 (age > 20) | — |
18.7 (age > 20) |
| Lorkiewicz‐Muszynska et al., | 170 | 1–17 | Poland | CT |
F: 14.4 M: 10.4 (age 1) |
F: 5.8 M: 4.3 (age 1) |
F: 7.1 M: 4.3 (age 1) |
F: 40 M: 38.8 (age 17) |
F: 27.5 M: 30.2 (age 17) |
29.5 (age 17) |
| Degermenci et al., | 361 | 0–18 | Turkey | CT |
R: 13.3 L: 13.4 (age 1) |
R: 11 L: 11.1 (age 1) |
R: 8.4 L: 8.8 (age 1) |
33.6 (age 18) |
R: 33.5 L: 34.7 (age 18) |
R: 21.4 L: 22.2 (age 18) |
| Lee et al., | 65 | 0–18 | New Zealand | CT |
9.4 (0–1) |
12.5 (0–1) |
16.5 (0–1) |
43.0 (16–18) |
46.3 (16–18) |
33.9 (16–18) |
| Adibelli et al., | 1383 | 0–18 | Turkey | MRI |
6.9 (age 0–2.9 mo) |
4.1 (age 0–2.9 mo) |
2.6 (age 0–2.9 mo) |
34.2 (age 15–18) |
31.8 (age 15–18) |
28.1 (age 15–18) |
| Barghouth et al., | 179 | 0–17 | Switzerland | MRI |
7.3 (at birth) |
4 (at birth) |
2.7 (at birth) |
38.8 (age 16) |
36.3 (age 16) |
27.5 (age 16) |
Previous studies analyzing maxillary sinus volumes in children
| Author | Sample size ( | Age (years) | Population | Methodology | Mean volumes from youngest age group studied (cm3) | Mean volumes from oldest age group studied (cm3) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Barghouth et al., | 179 | 0–17 | Switzerland |
MRI, volume via ellipsoidal formula
|
0.08 (at birth) |
18.3 (age 16) |
| Adibelli et al., | 1383 | 0–18 | Turkey | MRI, volume via ellipsoidal formula |
0.16 (age 0–2.9 mo) |
23.65 (age 15–18) |
| Degermenci et al., | 361 | 0–18 | Turkey | CT, volume via ellipsoid formula & analysis with Cavalieri's principle |
0.95 (R), 0.98 (L) (age 1) |
12.74 (R), 13.54 (L) (age 18) |
| Bhushan et al., | 139 | 0–18 | USA | CT, volume via rectangular formula length × width × height |
8.76 (R), 8.12 (L) (age < 6) |
33.16 (R), 34.14 (L) (age > 12) |
| Lorkiewicz‐Muszynska et al., | 170 | 0–18 | Poland | CT, volume via average of pyramid & sphere volumes |
F: 0.36, M: 0.1 (age 1) |
F: 13.2, M: 15.17 (age 17) |
| Ikeda et al., | 20 normal controls | 4–79 | Japan |
CT, volume via trapezoidal formula
|
11.0 (age 4–9) |
20.5 (age ≥ 15) |
| Sánchez Fernández et al., | 100 normal controls | 1–88 | Spain | CT, volume via with trapezoidal formula |
0.6 (age 1–5) |
13.07 (age > 20) |
| Karakas & Kavakli, | 91 | 5–55 | Turkey | CT, volume calculated with Cavalieri's principle |
F: 7.03 (R), 6.6 (L) M: 5.34 (R), 6.7 (L) (age 5–10) |
F: 11.13 (R), 11.53 (L) M: 15.04 (R), 15.97 (L) (age > 25) |
| Jun et al., | 173 | 0–80 | Korea | HRCT images (2.5 mm slice thickness), 3D automatic reconstruction |
7.38 (age 0–10) |
18.67 (age 21–30) |
| Park et al., | 260 | 0–25 | Korea | HRCT images (1 mm slice thickness), 3D automatic reconstruction |
0.75 (age 0) |
14.78 (age 25) |
| Smith et al., | 32 | 6–18 | USA | CBCT, 3D manual reconstruction |
4.8 (age 6) |
17.37 (age 18) |
| Rennie et al., | 480 | 1–25 | South Africa | CT (0.625–1.25 mm slice thickness), automatic 3D reconstruction |
1.61 (R), 1.57 (L) (age 1–3) |
12.58 (R), 12.64 (L) (age 22–25) |
| Lee et al., | 65 | 0–18 | New Zealand | CT (<3 mm slice thickness) 3D manual reconstruction |
0.81 (0–1) |
21.63 (age 16–18) |
FIGURE 3Maxillary sinus development with age
FIGURE 4Frontal and ethmoid sinuses
Previous studies that have analyzed FS measurements in children
| Author | Sample size ( | Age (years) | Population | Methodology | Mean measurements from youngest age group studied (mm) | Mean measurements from oldest age group studied (mm) | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Length | Height | Width | Length | Height | Width | |||||
| Schaeffer, | Not stated | 0–20 | USA | Cadavers |
3.5 (age 6–12 months) |
2 (age 6–12 months) |
2 (age 6–12 months) |
17 (age 19–20) |
26 (age 19–20) |
26 (age 19–20) |
| Weiglein et al., | 134 | 0–12 | Austria | Dried skulls |
7–13 (age 4) |
4–9 (age 4) |
4–10 (age 4) |
13–21 (age 12) |
12–26 (age 12) |
15–22 (age 12) |
| Wolf et al., | 102 | 0–12 | Austria | Dried skulls & cadavers |
4–8 (age 1–4) |
6–9 (age 1–4) |
4–7 (age 1–4) |
6–10 (age 4–8) |
15–16 (age 4–8) |
8–10 (age 4–8) |
| Valverde et al., | 20 | 7–17 | Japan | Lateral X‐ray | — | — |
7.15 (age 8) | — | — |
10.78 (age 17) |
| Gagliardi et al., | 31 | 7–18 | Aboriginal Australians | Lateral X‐ray |
7.2 (M) 8.1 (F) (age 8) |
15.3 (M) 12.4 (F) (age 8) | — |
20.5 (M) 17.1 (F) (age 18) |
36.9 (M) 40.2 (F) (age 18) | — |
| Spaeth et al., | 5600 | 0–25 | Germany | CT of skulls |
7.83 (M) 11.67 (F) (age 6) | — |
11.92 (M) 11.58 (F) (age 6) |
17.38 (M) 16.11 (F) (age 25) | — |
27.98 (M) 26.39 (F) (age 25) |
| Sánchez Fernández et al., | 100 | 1–88 | Spain | CT |
7 (age 6–10) | — |
7 (age 6–10) |
13 (age > 20) | — |
18 (age > 20) |
| Yun et al., | 352 | 1–23 | Korea | CT, 3D reconstruction |
2.3 (age 4) |
1.8 (age 4) |
4.1 (age 4) |
21.6 (age 20) |
27.9 (age 20) |
52.8 (age 20) |
| Barghouth et al., | 12 | 0–17 | Switzerland | MRI | — | — | — |
12.8 (age 16) |
21.9 (age 16) |
24.5 (age 16) |
| Adibelli et al., | 612 | 0–18 | Turkey | MRI |
3.5 (age 3–5.9) |
5.2 (age 3–5.9) |
4.8 (age 3–5.9) |
16.6 (age 15–18) |
36.9 (age 15–18) |
38.3 (age 15–18) |
Previous studies that have analyzed FS volume in children
| Author | Sample size ( | Age (years) | Population | Methodology | Mean volumes from youngest age group (cm3) | Mean volumes from oldest age group (cm3) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sánchez Fernández et al., | 100 | 1–88 | Spain |
CT, volume via trapezoidal formula
|
0.7 (age 6–10) |
3.7 (age > 20) |
| Karakas & Kavakli, | 91 | 5–55 | Turkey | Axial CT, volume calculated with Cavalieri's principle |
F: 1.23 M: 1.19 (age 5–10) |
F: 3.5 M: 8.41 (age > 25) |
| Rennie et al., | 480 | 1–25 | South Africa | Axial CT (0.625–1.25 mm slice thickness), 3D reconstruction |
0.49 (R) 0.44 (L) (age 1–3) |
4.76 (R) 4.31 (L) (age 22–25) |
| Park et al., | 260 | 0–25 | Korea | CT, 3D reconstruction, automatic volume calculation |
0.003 (age 2) |
3.764 (age 25) |
| Yun et al., | 352 | 1–23 | Korea | CT, 3D reconstruction, automatic volume calculation |
0.07 (R) 0.11 (L) (age 4) |
3.9 (R) 4.5 (L) (age 20) |
| Adibelli et al., | 612 | 0–18 | Turkey |
MRI, volume via ellipsoidal formula
|
0.25 (age 3–5.9) |
6.28 (age 15–18) |
FIGURE 5Sphenoid sinus development with age
Previous studies that have analyzed sphenoid sinus measurements in children
| Author | Sample size ( | Age (years) | Population | Methodology | Mean measurements of youngest age group studied (mm) | Mean measurements of oldest age group studied (mm) | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Length | Height | Width | Length | Height | Width | |||||
| Schaeffer, | Not stated | 1–14 | USA | Cadavers |
1.5 (age 1) |
2.5 (age 1) |
2.5 (age 1) |
12 (R), 7 (L) (age 14) |
14 (R), 15 (L) (age 14) |
9 (R), 14 (L) (age 14) |
| Wolf et al., | 102 | 0–12 | Austria | Dried skulls + cadaver heads |
4–6 (age 1–4) |
3–5 (age 1–4) |
6–8 (age 1–4) |
11–14 (age 4–8) |
7–11 (age 4–8) |
9–11 (age 4–8) |
| Weiglein et al., | 134 | 0–12 | Austria | Dried skulls |
4–6 (age 4) |
3–5 (age 4) |
6–8 (age 4) |
12–20 (age 12) |
9–16 (age 12) |
10–18 (age 12) |
| Sánchez Fernández et al., | 100 normal controls | 1–88 | Spain | CT |
13 (age 6–10) | — |
9 (age 6–10) |
18 (age > 20) | — |
15 (age > 20) |
| Spaeth et al., | 5600 | 0–25 | Germany | CT |
6.82 (M) 9.33 (F) (age 3) | — |
6.42 (M) 8.77 (F) (age 3) |
32.91 (M) 27.96 (F) (age 25) | — |
33.45 (M) 32.78 (F) (age 25) |
| Barghouth et al., | 95 | 0–17 | Switzerland | MRI |
5.8 (age 3) |
8.0 (age 3) |
5.8 (age 3) |
23 (age 16) |
22.6 (age 16) |
12.8 (age 16) |
| Szolar et al., | 401 | 0–15 | Austria | MRI |
6.2 (age 1–2) |
6 (age 1–2) |
7.4 (age 1–2) |
22.1 (age 13–14) |
20.6 (age 13–14) |
26.5 (age 13–14) |
| Reittner et al., | 800 | 0–14 | Austria | MRI |
8.4 (age 1–2) |
10.2 (age 1–2) |
6.2 (age 1–2) |
29.1 (age 14–15) |
26.8 (age 14–15) |
29.6 (age 14–15) |
| Adibelli et al., | 876 | 0–18 | Turkey | MRI |
0.35 (age 6–8.9 mo) |
0.37 (age 6–8.9 mo) |
0.33 (age 6–8.9 mo) |
32.0 (age 15–18) |
28.1 (age 15–18) |
23.8 (age 15–18) |
Previous studies that have analyzed volumetric growth of the sphenoid sinus in children
| Author | Sample size ( | Age (years) | Population | Methodology | Mean volume youngest age cohort (cm3) | Mean volume oldest age cohort (cm3) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Karakas & Kavakli, | 91 | 5–55 | Turkey | CT, volume calculated with Cavalieri's principle |
2.96 (M) 3.14 (F) (age 5–10) |
8.53 (M) 7.88 (F) (age > 25) |
| Sánchez Fernández et al., | 100 normal controls | 1–88 | Spain | CT, volume calculated with trapezoidal rule |
1.5 (age 1–5) |
3.5 (age > 20) |
| Park et al., | 260 | 0–25 | Korea | CT, 3D reconstruction |
0.018 (age 1) |
3.418 (age 25) |
| Rennie et al., | 480 | 1–25 | South Africa | CT, 3D reconstruction |
0.1966 (R) 0.2729 (L) (age 1–3) |
4.584 (R) 4.735 (L) (age 22–25) |
| Barghouth et al., | 95 | 0–17 | Switzerland | MRI, sinus volume index calculated with ellipsoidal formula | — |
2.7 (age 16) |
| Adibelli et al., | 876 | 0–18 | Turkey | MRI, sinus volume index calculated with ellipsoidal formula |
0.004 (age 6–8.9 mo) |
4.96 (age 15–18) |
Previous studies that have analyzed ethmoid sinus dimensions in children
| Author | Sample size ( | Age (years) | Population | Methodology | Mean measurements for youngest age cohort (mm) | Mean measurements for oldest age cohort (mm) | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Length | Height | Width | Length | Height | Width | |||||
| Schaeffer, | Not stated | 0–14 | USA | Cadavers |
Anterior: 2 Posterior: 2 (newborn) |
Anterior: 5 Posterior: 5 (newborn) |
Anterior: 2 Posterior: 4 (newborn) |
Anterior: 5–23 Posterior: 8–20 (age 14) |
Anterior: 9–16 Posterior: 9–15 (age 14) |
Anterior: 10 Posterior: 14 (age 14) |
| Weiglein et al., | 134 | 0–12 | Austria | Dried skulls | 8–12 (age 0) | 5–7 (age 0) | 2–3 (age 0) | 24–30 (age 12) | 15–20 (age 12) | 8–10 (age 12) |
| Wolf et al., | 102 | 0–12 | Austria | Dried skulls + cadavers | 8–12 (newborn) | 1–5 (newborn) | 1–3 (newborn) | 18–24 (age 4–8) | 10–15 (age 4–8) | 9–13 (age 4–8) |
| Spaeth et al., | 5600 | 0–25 | Germany | CT of skulls |
M: 26.33 F: 28.29 (age 3) | — |
M: 8.35 F: 8.85 (age 3) |
M: 40.73 F: 37.54 (age 25) | — |
M: 16.58 F: 14.79 (age 25) |
| Sánchez Fernández et al., | 100 normal controls | 1–88 | Spain | CT | 21 (age 1–5) | — | 7 (age 1–5) | 24 (age > 20) | — | 13 (age > 20) |
| Adibelli et al., | 1452 | 0–18 | Turkey | MRI | 26.2 (age 0–2.9 mo) | 6.7 (age 0–2.9 mo) | 6.1 (age 0–2.9 mo) | 55.2 (age 15–18) | 21.9 (age 15–18) | 16.4 (age 15–18) |
Previous studies that have analyzed volumetric growth of the ethmoid sinus in children
| Author | Sample size ( | Age (years) | Population | Methodology | Mean volumes in youngest age cohort (cm3) | Mean volumes in oldest age cohort (cm3) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sánchez Fernández et al., | 100 normal controls | 1–88 | Spain | CT, volume calculated with trapezoidal rule | 0.6 (age 1–5) | 5.5 (age > 20) |
| Park et al., | 260 | 0–25 | Korea | HRCT images (1 mm slice thickness), 3D reconstruction | 0.409 (age 0) | 4.462 (age 25) |
| Adibelli et al., | 1452 | 0–18 | Turkey | MRI, sinus volume index calculated | 0.25 (age 0–2.9 mo) | 4.62 (age 15–18) |
| Rennie et al., | 480 | 1–25 | South Africa | CT (0.625–1.25 mm slice thickness), 3D reconstruction |
0.7367 (R) 0.7169 (L) (Age 1–3) |
4.624 (R) 4.557 (L) (Age 22–25) |