The therapeutic properties of Curcuma (ginger and turmeric's family) have long been known in traditional medicine. However, only recently have guaiane-type sesquiterpenes extracted from Curcuma phaeocaulis been submitted to biological testing, and their enhanced bioactivity was highlighted. Among these compounds, phaeocaulisin A has shown remarkable anti-inflammatory and anticancer activity, which appears to be tied to the unique bridged acetal moiety embedded in its tetracyclic framework. Prompted by the promising biological profile of phaeocaulisin A and by the absence of a synthetic route for its provision, we have implemented the first enantioselective total synthesis of phaeocaulisin A in 17 steps with 2% overall yield. Our route design builds on the identification of an enantioenriched lactone intermediate, tailored with both a ketone moiety and a conjugated alkene system. Taking advantage of the umpolung carbonyl-olefin coupling reactivity enabled by the archetypal single-electron transfer (SET) reductant samarium diiodide (SmI2), the lactone intermediate was submitted to two sequential SmI2-mediated cyclizations to stereoselectively construct the polycyclic core of the natural product. Crucially, by exploiting the innate inner-sphere nature of carbonyl reduction using SmI2, we have used a steric blocking strategy to render sites SET-unreceptive and thus achieve chemoselective reduction in a complex substrate. Our asymmetric route enabled elucidation of the naturally occurring isomer of phaeocaulisin A and provides a synthetic platform to access other guaiane-type sesquiterpenes from C. phaeocaulis─as well as their synthetic derivatives─for medicinal chemistry and drug design.
The therapeutic properties of Curcuma (ginger and turmeric's family) have long been known in traditional medicine. However, only recently have guaiane-type sesquiterpenes extracted from Curcuma phaeocaulis been submitted to biological testing, and their enhanced bioactivity was highlighted. Among these compounds, phaeocaulisin A has shown remarkable anti-inflammatory and anticancer activity, which appears to be tied to the unique bridged acetal moiety embedded in its tetracyclic framework. Prompted by the promising biological profile of phaeocaulisin A and by the absence of a synthetic route for its provision, we have implemented the first enantioselective total synthesis of phaeocaulisin A in 17 steps with 2% overall yield. Our route design builds on the identification of an enantioenriched lactone intermediate, tailored with both a ketone moiety and a conjugated alkene system. Taking advantage of the umpolung carbonyl-olefin coupling reactivity enabled by the archetypal single-electron transfer (SET) reductant samarium diiodide (SmI2), the lactone intermediate was submitted to two sequential SmI2-mediated cyclizations to stereoselectively construct the polycyclic core of the natural product. Crucially, by exploiting the innate inner-sphere nature of carbonyl reduction using SmI2, we have used a steric blocking strategy to render sites SET-unreceptive and thus achieve chemoselective reduction in a complex substrate. Our asymmetric route enabled elucidation of the naturally occurring isomer of phaeocaulisin A and provides a synthetic platform to access other guaiane-type sesquiterpenes from C. phaeocaulis─as well as their synthetic derivatives─for medicinal chemistry and drug design.
Natural products extracted
from the rhizomes of the widely distributed
plant genus Curcuma (e.g., common turmeric) have
long been known for their therapeutic properties, as exemplified by
the use of these plants in traditional Indian and Chinese medicine.[1] A recent report by the European Medicines Agency
also highlights their potential societal worth.[2] Among these compounds, guaiane-type sesquiterpenes—featuring
the characteristic 5,7-fused carbocyclic skeleton and pendant methyl
groups—have gained significant traction as privileged scaffolds
due to their antitumor, anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, and antibacterial
activity.[3] In particular, phaeocaulisins—obtained
from Curcuma phaeocaulis and Curcuma wenyujin (Figure a)[4]—have
demonstrated, most importantly, the ability to inhibit lipopolysaccharide
(LPS)-induced nitric oxide (NO) production in RAW 264.7 macrophages.
Phaeocaulisin A (1), first isolated in 2013 from C. phaeocaulis, shows noteworthy inhibitory activity
against NO production and, compared to other guaiane-type sesquiterpenes
from its family, has a low IC50 value of 1.5 μM,
thus making it a promising non-cytotoxic anti-inflammatory agent.[4] Interestingly, preliminary structure–activity
relationship studies indicated that its bioactive properties are tied
to its characteristic acetal C1–C11 oxygen bridge, which is
a unicum in guaiane-type sesquiterpenes.[4] In addition, cell counting experiments and methyl thiazolyl tetrazolium
(MTT) assays have highlighted the ability of phaeocaulisin A to potently
suppress both growth and proliferation in A375 human melanoma cells.[5] Its importance has been recognized by two patents
describing its use as a targeted therapy drug for melanoma and as
a treatment for autoimmune diseases associated with metabolic disorder
of nitric oxide production.[5] Despite these
promising biological features and the rising relevance of guaiane-type
sesquiterpenes in pharma, asymmetric synthetic routes to guaiane-type
sesquiterpene lactones, phaeocaulisins,[6] and, in particular, to phaeocaulisin A (1) are yet
to be developed.
Figure 1
Guaiane-type sesquiterpenes from C. phaeocaulis and our strategy for the enantioselective synthesis of phaeocaulisin
A. (a) Structurally diverse terpenoids, isolated from the rhizomes
of C. phaeocaulis, exhibit enhanced
anti-inflammatory activity. (b) Retrosynthetic analysis of one of
the most biologically active and structurally intriguing members of
the above class of guaiane-type sesquiterpene: phaeocaulisin A. The
retrosynthesis builds on two SmI2-mediated cyclizations
to forge the key 1,4-diO (C3-C1) and 1,6-diO (C3-C8) patterns through
an umpolung strategy. The stereocenters are highlighted; the guiding
stereocenter (C12) is established in triol 11 (highlighted
in red).
Guaiane-type sesquiterpenes from C. phaeocaulis and our strategy for the enantioselective synthesis of phaeocaulisin
A. (a) Structurally diverse terpenoids, isolated from the rhizomes
of C. phaeocaulis, exhibit enhanced
anti-inflammatory activity. (b) Retrosynthetic analysis of one of
the most biologically active and structurally intriguing members of
the above class of guaiane-type sesquiterpene: phaeocaulisin A. The
retrosynthesis builds on two SmI2-mediated cyclizations
to forge the key 1,4-diO (C3-C1) and 1,6-diO (C3-C8) patterns through
an umpolung strategy. The stereocenters are highlighted; the guiding
stereocenter (C12) is established in triol 11 (highlighted
in red).Intrigued by both its potential
biological application as a targeted
therapy for melanoma and its unique structure featuring a peculiar
bridged acetal moiety, we set out to synthesize phaeocaulisin A (1). To this end, we took into consideration the following
synthetic challenges: (i) the enantioselective construction of five
stereocenters, four of which are contiguous and four are tetrasubstituted,
and (ii) the formation of an acetal functionality, whose oxygen atoms
are part of a bridged heterocycle and an unsaturated lactone ring.
Our retrosynthetic analysis of 1 builds on the identification
of the 1,4- and 1,6-dioxygenated patterns defined by the substituents
at the C3–C1 and C3–C8 carbons embedded within structures 6 and 7, respectively (Figure b).[7] Taking advantage
of the umpolung reactivity offered by the single-electron reduction
of carbonyl compounds using the archetypal single-electron transfer
(SET) reductant samarium(II) iodide (SmI2, Kagan’s
reagent),[8] we envisaged that both motifs
can be built by two sequential SmI2-mediated couplings
between the lactone and the ketone carbonyls of intermediates 7 and 8, respectively, and a pendant-conjugated
electron-deficient olefinic system—thus forging the characteristic
5,7-fused skeleton of the natural product (i.e., construction of the
C1–C5 and C7–C8 bonds).[9] These
disconnections led to the identification of stereodefined lactone 8 as the key intermediate in our synthesis, whose three-dimensional
arrangement would guide the diastereoselective formation of the three
stereocenters generated during the SmI2-mediated cyclizations.
Another synthetic design feature was the identification of an initially
set stereocenter (C12, red) whose absolute stereochemistry would guide
the construction of all other stereocenters. Therefore, for the synthesis
of 8, we aimed to design a short route featuring a single,
established, enantioselective reaction; we anticipated that the Sharpless
asymmetric dihydroxylation[10] of a Negishi
adduct,[11] obtained from commercially available
alkynes 12 and 13, would allow the enantioselective
synthesis of intermediate 8 in a few steps (Figure b). Our synthetic
design not only provides, for the first time, an asymmetric route
to phaeocaulisin A (1) but also potentially paves the
way to the synthesis of other members of the guaiane-type sesquiterpene
family extracted from C. phaeocaulis and their derivatives, thus enabling their study and application
in medicinal chemistry.
Results and Discussion
Synthesis of the Cyclization
Substrates
Our synthetic
endeavors commenced with the synthesis of lactone 8,
the substrate for the first proposed key SmI2-mediated
reductive cyclization. Commercially available 3-butyn-1-ol 12 (∼0.50 £/g) was submitted to sequential E-selective alkyne carboalumination and in situ iodination,[12] and then to the tert-butyldiphenylsilyl
(TBDPS) protection of its primary alcohol functionality. This provided
straightforward access to vinyl iodide derivative 14 in
decagram quantities (Scheme ). The latter was used as a coupling partner in a palladium-catalyzed
Negishi coupling[11] with trimethylsilyl-protected
alkyl zinc reagent 15, prepared in two steps from 13 following a previously reported procedure,[13] thus affording 1,5-eneyne 16 in excellent
yield. This set the stage for the introduction of the guiding stereocenter
at C12 (phaeocaulisin A numbering) via Sharpless asymmetric alkene
dihydroxylation.[10] In an initial attempt, 16 was subjected to the standard enantioselective dihydroxylation
conditions, using AD-mix-β and running the reaction at 0 °C.
This furnished the desired syn-diol 17 in good yield, albeit in a moderate enantiomeric ratio (75% yield,
85:15 e.r.; see the SI). A survey of the
most commonly adopted commercially available hydroquinidine-based
ligands for the process identified (DHQD)2Pyr as the ligand
of choice. Under these conditions, the desired mono-TBDPS-protected
triol 17 was isolated in 81% yield and 96:4 e.r. on a
decagram scale. The TBDPS-protecting group is vital to achieve high
enantioselectivity since a smaller tert-butyldimethylsilyl
(TBS) group failed to effectively shield one of the enantiotopic faces
of the alkene, and the corresponding mono-protected triol was obtained
with low levels of enantioinduction (60:40 e.r.). Crucially, this
transformation defines the configuration of the tertiary alcohol stereocenter
at C12 (c.f. numbering in phaeocaulisin A (1), Figure b, red), which dictates
the diastereoselective installation of all of the other stereocenters
in the natural product. The absolute stereochemistry of 17 was initially inferred based on the Sharpless mnemonic device[10] and later corroborated by single-crystal X-ray
crystallographic analysis of a more advanced intermediate (i.e., 7 Me ester, vide infra). Next, we sought to set the adjacent
C11 stereocenter and, at the same time, install a vinyl handle; this
serves as a strategic precursor for the dienoate functionality. Preliminary
optimization studies performed on the TBS-protected analogue of 17 (see the SI) showed the oxidation
of the secondary alcohol moiety to be challenging: even mild oxidants—including
Dess–Martin periodinane (DMP),[14] 2-iodoxybenzoic acid (IBX),[15] SO3·py/DMSO (Parikh–Doering oxidation),[16] and tetrapropylammonium perruthenate/NMO (TPAP,
Ley oxidation)[17]—failed to give
the desired hydroxyketone 18 in a synthetically useful
yield, and oxidative cleavage of the 1,2-diol functionality was in
all cases the preferred pathway (see the SI). To overcome this issue, we envisaged employing oxidation conditions
in which the alcohol activator and the base are not present simultaneously,
and the tertiary alcohol moiety is masked in situ. Based on this rationale, the TBS-protected analogue of 17 was submitted to classic Swern conditions using 2.0 equivalents
of activated sulfoxide to give the desired mono-TBS-protected dihydroxyketone
in excellent yield (86% yield; see the SI). Pleasingly, when these conditions were tested on the enantioenriched
mono-TBDPS-protected triol 17, the reactivity translated
smoothly to afford decagram quantities of the corresponding dihydroxyketone 18 (89% yield). To ensure the diastereoselective installation
of the stereocenter at C11, we envisioned a chelate-controlled Lewis
acid-mediated Grignard addition to the ketone moiety of 18. This was realized using the commercially available LaCl3·2LiCl complex,[18] which served a
dual role in (i) granting chelation between the carbonyl and the vicinal
alcohol oxygen at C12—despite the bulky TBDPS group—and
(ii) suppressing the detrimental enolization of the ketone functionality
in the presence of excess vinylmagnesium bromide. The reaction was
reliably carried out on the decagram scale to obtain the desired diastereomer 19 in 75% yield, together with 20% of the undesired isomer
C11-epi-19 (both diastereoisomers can
be isolated separately by column chromatography) without erosion of
the diastereoselectivity (3.7:1 d.r.) seen on a smaller scale. When
other Lewis acids were trialed in this protocol, the Grignard addition
reaction suffered from low diastereoselectivity or unproductive enolization
was the dominant pathway, and starting material 18 was
returned upon quenching. Simultaneous deprotection of both the primary
alcohol and the alkyne moiety of 19 was achieved by treatment
with tetrabutylammonium fluoride (TBAF) in THF. The reaction provided
crystalline triol 11, which was submitted to single-crystal
X-ray analysis to establish its relative stereochemistry—this
being in agreement with the Cram-chelate model for nucleophilic addition
to ketones bearing α-stereocenters. The absolute configuration
of 11 was later confirmed by the analysis of more advanced
intermediates (i.e., 7 Me ester and 6, vide
infra) and is in agreement with the Sharpless mnemonic.[10] Again, the 1,2-diol functionality within 11 proved to be sensitive toward most oxidation conditions,
with oxidative cleavage of the C11–C12 bond proving facile
(see the SI). Even the employment of Fetizon’s
reagent (silver(I) carbonate on Celite)[19]—commonly used in oxidative lactonization
protocols—failed
to afford the desired lactone 20. Extensive screening
of conditions revealed that TEMPO-mediated oxidations were the most
effective procedures to give 20: using 1,3-diiodo-5,5-dimethylhydantoin
(DIH) as the terminal oxidant, the desired lactone could be obtained
in good yield (81% on gram scale), although the efficiency of the
oxidation was lower on the decagram scale. At this stage, the pendant
alkyne moiety of 20 was regioselectively hydrated under
Au(I)-catalyzed conditions to provide methyl ketone 9.[20] Finally, building on preliminary optimization
studies with a model substrate (see the SI), 9 was exposed to Ag-mediated, Pd-catalyzed Heck conditions
and coupled first with known β-iodomethacrylate Me ester 10(21) and later with its tert-butyl ester analogue (both prepared from known acid 21(22)) to afford multigram quantities
of both dienoates 8. These substrates were used to test
the feasibility of the key SmI2-mediated cyclization reactions.
Scheme 1
Enantioselective Synthesis of Key Intermediates 8
Synthetic route, summarizing
reagents and conditions, to enantioenriched dienoates 8: substrates for the SmI2-mediated cyclization reactions.
Cp, cyclopentadienyl; DMF, dimethylformamide; TBDPS, tert-butyldiphenylsilyl; THF, tetrahydrofuran; TMS, trimethylsilyl; DMSO,
dimethyl sulfoxide; TBAF, tetrabutylammonium fluoride; DIH, 1,3-diiodo-5,5-dimethylhydantoin.
Enantioselective Synthesis of Key Intermediates 8
Synthetic route, summarizing
reagents and conditions, to enantioenriched dienoates 8: substrates for the SmI2-mediated cyclization reactions.
Cp, cyclopentadienyl; DMF, dimethylformamide; TBDPS, tert-butyldiphenylsilyl; THF, tetrahydrofuran; TMS, trimethylsilyl; DMSO,
dimethyl sulfoxide; TBAF, tetrabutylammonium fluoride; DIH, 1,3-diiodo-5,5-dimethylhydantoin.
SmI2-Mediated Cyclizations
With an efficient
route in hand to stereoselectively access enantiomerically enriched
lactone dienoates 8 on the gram scale, we tackled the
development of the SmI2-mediated cyclizations that would
construct the polycyclic skeleton of phaeocaulisin A (1). According to the synthetic plan outlined in Figure , we first investigated the cyclization of 8 to deliver spirocyclic enoate 7. It was envisaged
that SET reduction of the ketone moiety of 8 by SmI2 would trigger 5-exo-trig cyclization of
the resulting ketyl radical 22 onto the pendant-conjugated
diene, thus forming the spirocyclic all-carbon five-membered ring
of the natural product (Scheme a). Further reduction of the radical intermediate stemming
from the cyclization event—by another equivalent of SmI2—and subsequent γ-protonation of the so-formed
extended enolate 23 would deliver compound 7. One anticipated challenge was the tendency of extended enolates
of conjugated esters to give mixtures of α- and γ-protonated
products or favoring α-protonation depending on the cation (known
as the extended enolate problem).[7] The
SmI2-mediated cyclization reaction was initially trialed
using the methyl ester analogue of dienoate 8 (Scheme b). Building on model
studies (see the SI), preliminary experiments
were performed using 2.2 equivalents of SmI2, in both the
absence and presence of various proton sources and HMPA at −78
°C. Unfortunately, all of these attempts yielded the desired
cyclization products in low amounts (≤15% NMR yield) as a mixture
of alkene regioisomers 7 and iso-7, the latter (obtained via α-protonation of intermediate 23) undesirably being the major component of the mixture.
Even though the combined yield of 7 Me ester was low
in all cases, the high levels of diastereoselectivity with which the
two new stereocenters were generated were encouraging. Importantly,
in all cases, the preferred pathway was the undesired opening of the
lactone ring to form carboxylic acid by-product 26. This
unwanted reactivity arises from SET from SmI2 to the dienoate
fragment of 8—as opposed to its ketone moiety—thus
generating radical intermediate 24 (Scheme b). This, through sequential
lactone ring opening and a second SmI2-promoted SET reduction,
delivers carboxylate 25, which, upon α-protonation
of its Sm-enolate functionality, gives 26. In order to
avoid this pitfall, we sought to kinetically disfavor the reduction
of the dienoate system within 8 by increasing the steric
bulk around the ester moiety; SmI2 reduces carbonyls via
an inner-sphere electron transfer mechanism, which requires coordination
of the metal center to the carbonyl oxygen prior to the SET event.[23] Therefore, we proposed that the use of the more
sterically encumbered tert-butyl ester analogue of 8—in place of the previously employed methyl ester—would
render the dienoate moiety unreceptive to SET due to unfavorable steric
interactions, thus fostering the formation of ketyl radical 22 and driving the desired cyclization reaction (Scheme c). Pleasingly, when 8tert-butyl ester was submitted to the previously
employed cyclization conditions (2.2 equivalents of SmI2, in the presence of HMPA, t-BuOH, and THF and at
−78 °C), the desired spirocyclic product 7tert-butyl ester was obtained in 46% NMR yield,
albeit as a 1:2.3 mixture of regioisomers 7 and iso-7 (Scheme c, optimization, entry 1). Crucially, the reaction
remained highly diastereoselective for the desired C7, C8 isomer as
confirmed by single-crystal X-ray crystallographic analysis of a later
intermediate (i.e., 6, vide infra). The use of tripyrrolidinophosphoric
acid triamide (TPPA)—a nontoxic alternative to the carcinogenic
and mutagenic HMPA—as the Lewis basic ligand for SmI2, and t-BuOH as the proton source, boosted the efficiency
of the cyclization reaction, affording the spirocyclic product in
56% NMR yield with 1:2.7 r.r., again in favor of iso-7 (entry 2). To reverse the observed regioselectivity
and obtain selectively the desired isomer 7, we screened
different proton sources; we envisaged that their steric properties
could influence the ratio of site protonation upon quenching of the
enolate intermediate (α- vs γ-protonation, c.f. structure 23 in Scheme a). A survey of various proton sources identified the use of bulky
2,4,6-tri-tert-butylphenol (2,4,6-TTBP) as optimal
(see the SI); the formation of 7tert-butyl ester over iso-7 was now favored (1.3:1 r.r.) in good isolated yield and
with excellent diastereoselectivity even on a 1 mmol scale (entry
3). Under these conditions, the formation of the corresponding lactone
ring-opening product 27 was limited to 11% NMR yield.
The size of the proton source seems to be the main parameter influencing
the protonation process, since a relationship between the pKa of the proton sources and either the combined
yield or regioselectivity of the process could not be established.
To confirm the role of the tert-butyl ester functionality,
we performed a control experiment subjecting 8 Me ester
to the optimized SmI2-mediated conditions (using TPPA and
2,4,6-TTBP). As expected in this case, the reaction delivered prevalently
ring-opened carboxylic acid 26 together with iso-7, while the desired cyclization product 7 Me ester was observed only in low yield. Interestingly,
cyclic voltammetry studies showed that the most reducible site of 8 remains the dienoate system regardless of the substitution
at the ester moiety, thus underlining the operation of kinetic control
in the selective SET reduction of the ketone moiety (Scheme d). Remarkably, this study
represents a rare example in which the chemoselectivity of a SmI2-mediated SET reduction can be altered by rationally exploiting
the innate inner-sphere electron transfer mechanism of SmI2.[23]
Scheme 2
Synthetic Design and Optimization
of the Key SmI2-Mediated
Cyclization
Yields determined by 1H NMR analysis using MeNO2 as the internal standard.
Asterisks denote isolated yield. (a) Postulated reactivity in the
SmI2-mediated cyclization of 8 to produce 7 through SET reduction of its ketone moiety. (b) An initial
attempt using 8 Me ester afforded the undesired carboxylic
acid 26 as the major product. (c) Increasing the steric
bulk around the ester moiety of 8 alters the chemoselectivity
of the SmI2 reduction: design and optimization of the key
SmI2-promoted cyclization using 8tert-butyl ester as the substrate. (d) Electrochemical characterization
of dienoates 8. HMPA, hexamethylphosphoramide; THF, tetrahydrofuran;
TPPA, tripyrrolidinophosphoric acid triamide; 2,4,6-TTBP, 2,4,6-tri-tert-butylphenol.
Synthetic Design and Optimization
of the Key SmI2-Mediated
Cyclization
Yields determined by 1H NMR analysis using MeNO2 as the internal standard.
Asterisks denote isolated yield. (a) Postulated reactivity in the
SmI2-mediated cyclization of 8 to produce 7 through SET reduction of its ketone moiety. (b) An initial
attempt using 8 Me ester afforded the undesired carboxylic
acid 26 as the major product. (c) Increasing the steric
bulk around the ester moiety of 8 alters the chemoselectivity
of the SmI2 reduction: design and optimization of the key
SmI2-promoted cyclization using 8tert-butyl ester as the substrate. (d) Electrochemical characterization
of dienoates 8. HMPA, hexamethylphosphoramide; THF, tetrahydrofuran;
TPPA, tripyrrolidinophosphoric acid triamide; 2,4,6-TTBP, 2,4,6-tri-tert-butylphenol.While the presence
of the bulky tert-butyl ester
group renders the conjugated ester moiety unreceptive to SET, thus
promoting the first radical cyclization reaction (from 8 to 7), for the same reason, it would disfavor the second
planned SmI2-mediated cyclization (c.f. Figure b, from 7 to 6); SET from SmI2 to the electron-deficient olefin
within 7 initiates the process (Scheme a). Accordingly, exposure of 7tert-butyl ester to the SmI2-mediated
cyclization conditions (vide infra) provided the
tricyclic product 28 in low yield and with low diastereoselectivity,
with the majority of the starting material being recovered. To prepare 7 for the reductive cyclization process, we exchanged the tert-butyl ester group for its Me ester analogue and converted
the inseparable unconjugated iso-7 isomer
into 7 Me ester via base-assisted isomerization. Compound 7 Me ester was then treated with 2.2 equivalents of SmI2 in the presence of t-BuOH to afford the
desired bridged seven-membered ring structure (i.e., Me ester analogue
of 28) in 30% yield. The use of other proton sources,
such as H2O, promoted reduction of the alkene bond, with
no cyclization being observed. Crucially, addition of TPPA, in conjunction
with t-BuOH, triggered the desired 6-exo-trig/lactonization cascade process and allowed the direct isolation
of lactone 6—unequivocally characterized by single-crystal
X-ray crystallography—from 7 Me ester with high
diastereocontrol (>20:1 d.r.), thus completing the assembly of
the
tetracyclic skeleton of the natural product (Scheme a). Mechanistically, we believe that the
seven-membered ring formation proceeds via intermediate 29, stemming from two sequential SETs from SmI2 to the conjugated
alkene system of 7.
Scheme 3
Completion of the Total Synthesis
of (−)-Phaeocaulisin A and
Structural Revision of Its Naturally Occurring Enantiomer
(a) The final steps toward
the synthesis of (−)-phaeocaulisin A, featuring the two key
SmI2-mediated cyclizations and the installation of the
endocyclic double bond. (b) Structural revision of the naturally occurring
(+)-phaeocaulisin A based on the comparison of both the specific rotation
and the CD spectrum of the synthetic and the natural sample. TPPA,
tripyrrolidinophosphoric acid triamidetris(N,N-tetramethylene)phosphoric acid triamide; 2,4,6-TTBP, 2,4,6-tri-tripyrrolidinophosphoric
acid triamide; 2,4,6-TTBP, 2,4,6-tri-tert-butylphenol;
TFA, trifluoroacetic acid; DBU, 1,8-diazabicyclo[5.4.0]undec-7-ene;
THF, tetrahydrofuran; TMSOTf, trimethylsilyl trifluoromethanesulfonate;
LDA, lithium diisopropylamide; DBDMH, 1,3-dibromo-5,5-dimethylhydantoin;
SM, starting material.
Completion of the Total Synthesis
of (−)-Phaeocaulisin A and
Structural Revision of Its Naturally Occurring Enantiomer
(a) The final steps toward
the synthesis of (−)-phaeocaulisin A, featuring the two key
SmI2-mediated cyclizations and the installation of the
endocyclic double bond. (b) Structural revision of the naturally occurring
(+)-phaeocaulisin A based on the comparison of both the specific rotation
and the CD spectrum of the synthetic and the natural sample. TPPA,
tripyrrolidinophosphoric acid triamidetris(N,N-tetramethylene)phosphoric acid triamide; 2,4,6-TTBP, 2,4,6-tri-tripyrrolidinophosphoric
acid triamide; 2,4,6-TTBP, 2,4,6-tri-tert-butylphenol;
TFA, trifluoroacetic acid; DBU, 1,8-diazabicyclo[5.4.0]undec-7-ene;
THF, tetrahydrofuran; TMSOTf, trimethylsilyl trifluoromethanesulfonate;
LDA, lithium diisopropylamide; DBDMH, 1,3-dibromo-5,5-dimethylhydantoin;
SM, starting material.
Endgame and Structural
Revision of the Natural Product
Having built the bridged
tetracyclic architecture of phaeocaulisin
A, we aimed to complete our synthetic route by introducing the unsaturation
between the C4 and C5 carbons in the natural product (Scheme a). Initially, we planned to
achieve this formal oxidation of 6 via a syn-selenoxide elimination from the corresponding C4-substituted phenyl
selenide (not shown, see the SI) to deliver
the endocyclic alkene product selectively. To this end, we protected
the tertiary alcohol groups of 6 as trimethylsilyl (TMS)
ethers to obtain its C8- and C12-OTMS derivative in almost quantitative
yield. Subsequent deprotonation of the lactone moiety using lithium
diisopropylamide (LDA)—forming the corresponding enolate—and
quenching with phenylselenyl chloride (PhSeCl) afforded a separable
mixture of two diastereomers of the targeted selenide (4:1 d.r.).
Surprisingly, despite the presence of the two bulky OTMS groups, 1H nOe NMR experiments indicated that the endo-isomer—obtained by the electrophile approaching the Li-enolate
on the bottom face—was the major component of the mixture.
With selenium installed on the bottom face (C4-Se and C5-H in anti-arrangement), syn-elimination upon
oxidation of the Se-atom could only promote the formation of the exocyclic
double bond, thus giving rise to phaeocaulisin A regioisomer iso-1. Isomerization of the exocyclic double
bond to deliver 1 could not be achieved under a variety
of conditions (see the SI). Therefore,
we sought to exploit the endo-selectivity seen in
the lactone α-functionalization process to install a leaving
group at C4 that could undergo elimination via an anti-mechanism and provide access to the endocyclic double bond of 1. α-Bromination was chosen as previous reports have
shown that anti-elimination can be promoted in kindred
systems by the silver acetate (AgOAc)-assisted cleavage of C-Br bonds.
Pleasingly, protection of the tertiary alcohols of 6 (as
above) followed by α-deprotonation of the lactone moiety using
LDA and quenching of the Li-enolate with 1,3-dibromo-5,5-dimethylhydantoin
(DBDMH) yielded the desired endo-bromide 30 in 60% NMR yield and with excellent diastereoselectivity (>20:1
d.r.). Anti-elimination was then accomplished by
treating crude 30 with AgOAc in DMF at 50 °C to
afford the endocyclic unsaturated product almost exclusively. Finally,
deprotection of the silyl ethers with aqueous HCl in THF furnished
phaeocaulisin A in 45% overall yield over four steps. Our total synthesis
was designed based on the absolute stereochemical configuration of
the naturally occurring enantiomer of phaeocaulisin A reported in
the contribution describing its isolation[4] assigned based on empirical rules using its circular dichroism (CD)
spectrum.[24] However, the specific rotation
recorded for our synthetic sample was of the same magnitude, but of
opposite sign, with respect to that of the isolated natural product.
In addition, we found that the CD spectrum of our sample was opposite
to that of the isolated sample (Scheme b). This indicates that the original absolute stereochemistry
of phaeocaulisin A was misassigned and the natural occurring sesquiterpene
extracted from C. phaeocaulis is actually
the enantiomer of the synthesized compound (−)-1. Interestingly, this example provides an exception to the empirical
rule used in CD to assign the absolute stereochemistry of α,β-unsaturated
γ-lactones based on their characteristic Cotton effect at specific
wavelengths.[24] More importantly, this study
underlines once again the paramount role of total synthesis in confirming
the structure of natural products.
Conclusions
We
have developed an asymmetric route to the guaiane-type sesquiterpene
phaeocaulisin A: a 17-step sequence delivers the target compound in
2% overall yield. Our strategy builds on the enantioselective synthesis
of a lactone dienoate intermediate, which is then “folded”
using two sequential diastereoselective SmI2-mediated cyclizations
to construct the unique tetracyclic framework of the natural product.
Crucially, we have used a steric blocking strategy to render sites
in a complex substrate SET-unreceptive, overriding natural reactivity
and achieving chemoselectivity in a reductive cyclization—a
strategy that is unprecedented in SmI2 chemistry. Through
our synthesis, we have identified and amended the absolute stereochemical
configuration assigned to the naturally occurring enantiomer of (+)-phaeocaulisin
A. Our route prepares the ground for the synthesis of other sesquiterpenes
from C. phaeocaulis as well as their
synthetic derivatives. Given the biological activity of phaeocaulisin
A and guaiane-type sesquiterpenes in general, we believe that synthetic
studies, such as ours, will promote their evaluation and exploitation
in biology and medicine.
Authors: Charlotte Morrill; Áron Péter; Ilma Amalina; Emma Pye; Giacomo E M Crisenza; Nikolas Kaltsoyannis; David J Procter Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2022-07-20 Impact factor: 16.383