Synthesis and Characterization of High-Entropy-Alloy-Type Layered Telluride MBi2Te4 (M = Ag, In, Sn, Pb, Bi).

Recently, high-entropy alloys (HEAs) and HEA-type compounds have been extensively studied in the fields of material science and engineering. In this article, we report on the synthesis of a layered system MBi2Te4 where the M site possesses low-, middle-, and high-entropy states. The samples with M = Pb, Ag1/3Pb1/3Bi1/3, and Ag1/5In1/5Sn1/5Pb1/5Bi1/5 were newly synthesized and the crystal structure was examined by synchrotron X-ray diffraction and Rietveld refinement. We found that the M-Te2 distance was systematically compressed with decreasing lattice constants, where the configurational entropy of mixing at the M site is also systematically increased. The details of structural refinements and the electrical transport property are presented.

1. Introduction

High-entropy alloys (HEAs) are alloys containing five or more elements with a concentration range of 5–35 at% [1,2]. Due to the effects of high configurational entropy of mixing (ΔSmix), which is defined as ΔSmix = −R Σ ln c, where c and R are the compositional ratio and the gas constant, respectively, the HEAs have exhibited high performance, such as high stability or toughness under extreme conditions [1]. Since 2018, we have developed HEA-type compounds with a complicated structure (more complicated alloy-based HEAs) [3]. In such compounds with two or more crystallographic sites, random and scattered atomic bond lengths are expected due to the introduction of a HEA-type site, which is a crystallographic site satisfying the definition of HEA by alloying. In the BiS2-based RE(O,F)BiS2 (RE: rare earth) and cuprate RE123 (REBa2Cu3O7-) layered superconductors [4,5,6], in which the RE site is alloyed with five elements, we found that the introduction of HEA site does not largely affect electronic states because the superconducting transition temperature (Tc) of HEA-type samples was comparable to that for zero- or low-entropy samples. However, in BiS2-based REO0.5F0.5BiS2, the modification of local structure, the decrease in in-plane atomic displacement parameter U11, was observed, and the superconducting properties were improved by the increase in ΔSmix at the RE site [7]. This trend suggests that the presence of the HEA site affects the local structure of the layered system. For the cases of low-dimensional structure, we studied quasi-two-dimensional TrZr2 (Tr: transition metal) and found that the Tc is insensitive to ΔSmix [8,9]. However, the entropy dependent evaluation of the sharpness of the specific heat jump at Tc in TrZr2 samples clearly showed anomalous broadening as ΔSmix increased [10]. The results suggest that the HEA states would affect the superconducting gap opening. More recently, HEA-type van-der-Waals layered superconductors were designed and synthesized [11]. For the cases of three-dimensional structures, we have investigated the effect of the introduction of HEA sites in NaCl-type MTe [12,13,14] and A15-type Nb3X and V3X [15,16]. In both systems, the increase in ΔSmix resulted in the decrease in Tc. However, anomalous robustness of superconductivity under high pressure was found to be induced by increasing ΔSmix in MTe with a CsCl-type structure (high-pressure phase) [17], which is similar to that observed in a HEA superconductor Ti-Zr-Hf-Nb-Ta [18]. Therefore, three-dimensional HEA-type compounds will be important to find out the universality in HEA-type superconducting materials. In addition, in V3X, intrinsic phase separation, which results in the satisfaction with the condition of compositionally-complexed-alloy (CCA) states, was observed, and the upper critical field was improved by the formation of the CCA states [17]. Therefore, the three-dimensional system is also unique in the effects of HEA in compounds. Furthermore, recent studies on HEA effects in thermoelectric materials have suggested that the HEA effects can be very useful for achieving high thermoelectric performance in three-dimensional and quasi-two-dimensional systems [19,20,21,22,23]. Based on those interests in HEA-type compounds with functionality, we decided to study the effect of HEA in a layered system PbBi2Te4. Recently, pressure-induced superconductivity was reported in Ref. [24]. Having considered the modification of local structure in HEA-type compounds and the positive effects on superconductivity in the layered REO0.5F0.5BiS2 system [7], we expected the emergence of superconductivity by the HEA effects in MBi2Te4 where M is occupied by Ag, In, Sn, Pb, and Bi. Unfortunately, we could not observe superconductivity in the HEA-type (Ag1/5In1/5Sn1/5Pb1/5Bi1/5)Bi2Te4, but the observed structural changes would be useful for material design with the concept of HEA.

2. Materials and Methods

The samples of PbBi2Te4 (nominal ΔSmix = 0), (Ag1/3Pb1/3Bi1/3)Bi2Te4 (MEA, nominal ΔSmix = 1.10 R), and (Ag1/5In1/5Sn1/5Pb1/5Bi1/5)Bi2Te4 (HEA: nominal ΔSmix = 1.61 R) were synthesized using solid-state reaction. Since the optimal annealing condition changed according to the composition (and possibly due to the difference in entropy of mixing), we optimized the annealing conditions for the MEA and HEA samples. For example, using the same condition as MEA for the HEA composition resulted in the scattering of Ag concentration in the obtained sample. To avoid inhomogeneous compositions, we optimized the condition, and a detailed investigation was performed on the best samples. The raw materials were wires of Ag (99.9%, Kojundo Chemical Laboratory, Sakado, Japan) and powders of In (99.99%, Kojundo Chemical Laboratory, Sakado, Japan), Sn (99.99%, Kojundo Chemical Laboratory, Sakado, Japan), Pb (99.9%, Kojundo Chemical Laboratory, Sakado, Japan), Bi (99.999%, Kojundo Chemical Laboratory, Sakado, Japan), and Te (99.999%, Kojundo Chemical Laboratory, Sakado, Japan). For PbBi2Te4, the stoichiometric mixture of raw materials was sealed in an evacuated quartz tube (with a pressure lower than 0.5 Pa), heated at 1093 K for 24 h in a box-type electric furnace and cooled to 373 K with a cooling rate of −5 K/h. Finally, the sample was furnace-cooled after all heat treatments. A similar procedure, except for annealing conditions, was applied to other samples and the heating condition was optimized by checking X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns collected on Miniflex600 (RIGAKU, Akishima, Japan; CuKα). For the MEA sample, the stoichiometric mixture of raw materials was heated at 1273 K for 24 h and cooled to 673 K with a cooling rate of −12 K/h followed by holding the temperature at 673 K for 50 h in an evacuated quartz tube. For the HEA sample, the stoichiometric mixture of raw materials was heated at 1323 K for 10 h and cooled to 623 K with a cooling rate of −12 K/h, followed by holding the temperature at 623 K for 50 h in an evacuated quartz tube. The obtained samples contained single crystals with a shiny plane. The chemical compositions of samples were evaluated by energy-dispersive X-ray spectrometry (EDX) using an SEM-EDX system (TM3030 scanning tunneling microscope (Hitachi Hightech, Tokyo, Japan) equipped with an EDX spectrometer (SwiftED, Oxford, UK) on a shiny plane of the samples. The composition was evaluated by taking an average of 13 points. The synchrotron X-ray diffraction (SXRD) patterns were obtained using the multiple microstrip detector MYTHEN system [25] at the BL02B2 beamline of the synchrotron facility SPring-8 (Harima, Japan) with X-ray of 25 keV (wavelength, λ = 0.496118(1) Å). We used powder samples for SXRD, and the powders were sealed in a boro-silicate glass capillary with a diameter of 0.1 mm. The Rietveld structure refinements were performed using the JANA2020 software [26]. The image of the crystal structure was drawn using the VESTA software [27]. The electrical resistivity was measured by the four-probe method on a Physical Property Measurement System (PPMS, Quantum Design, San Diego, CA, USA). For the PbBi2Te4 and HEA samples, the resistivity measurements were performed with selected crystals having a flat plane. The size of the PbBi2Te4 and HEA samples is 0.1 × 1.2 × 1.7 mm3 and 0.4 × 1.2 × 2.6 mm3, respectively. The terminals were fabricated using Ag paste and Au wires with a diameter of 25 μm. Magnetization was measured by a superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID) magnetometer on MPMS3 (Quantum Design, San Diego, CA, USA).

3. Results

The SEM image for the HEA sample is shown in Figure 1d. In Table 1, actual compositions for the M site estimated by EDX are listed. In the EDX analysis, the Bi site was assumed to be fully occupied with Bi, and the M-site composition was analyzed. The obtained values for the MEA and HEA samples are Ag0.18Pb0.32Bi0.50Bi2Te4 and Ag0.14In0.15Sn0.25Pb0.14Bi0.32Bi2Te4, respectively. We found that even for PbBi2Te4, Bi-rich composition with ΔSmix = 0.61R for the M site was obtained. A similar trend of Bi-rich composition was observed in Reference [22]. For the MEA and HEA samples, a slight deviation of the actual composition from the nominal ones was observed, but the expected ΔSmix was almost preserved: ΔSmix = 1.02R and 1.55R for MEA and HEA, respectively.

Figure 1

Rietveld profile fitting results for MBi2Te4: (a) PbBi2Te4 (d-spacing range; d > 0.67 Å), (b) MEA (d > 0.66 Å), and (c) HEA (d > 0.67 Å). The red dots show the measured data (Iobs), and the blue lines are the fitted profiles (Ical). The green line is the difference curve (Iobs-Ical), and the black, violet and pink ticks are the peak positions for the main phase (MBi2Te4) and the impurity of PbBi4Te7 and PbTe. The PbBi2Te4 sample included PbBi4Te7 (21%) and PbTe (13%). The MEA sample included PbBi4Te7 (38%). The HEA sample included PbBi4Te7 (16%). (d) SEM image of the HEA sample.

Table 1

Occupancies of atoms in the M site. The numbers in the brackets are standard deviations.

Nominal Composition	Occupancy of Atom in M-Site
	Ag	In	Sn	Pb	Bi
PbBi2Te4	–	–	–	0.7(2)	0.3(1)
(Ag1/3Pb1/3Bi1/3)Bi2Te4	0.18(3)	–	–	0.32(2)	0.50(3)
(Ag1/5In1/5Sn1/5Pb1/5Bi1/5)Bi2Te4	0.14(3)	0.15(3)	0.25(3)	0.14(3)	0.32(2)

The SXRD patterns and the Rietveld fitting results are shown in Figure 1. In the multi-phase Rietveld refinements, the impurity amount was also refined. For PbBi2Te4 (Figure 1a), two impurity phases of PbBi4Te7 (21%) and PbTe (13%) were detected. The MEA and HEA samples included 38% and 18% of the PbBi4Te7 impurity. The formation of impurity phases would be understood by the presence of three phases (PbTe, PbBi2Te4, and PbBi4Te7) in the ternary phase diagram at similar temperature regions. Although we tried to optimize annealing conditions, the amount of impurity phases could not be reduced. In the HEA sample, however, the amount of impurity was the lowest, which would suggest that the MBi2Te4 phase was stabilized by the HEA effect at the M site [28].

The structural parameters obtained from the Rietveld refinements are listed in Table 2a–c, and the typical bond distances are plotted in Figure 2 as a function of ΔSmix/R (EDX) at the M site. With increasing ΔSmix, the M-Te2 distance decreases, which is probably well explained by the change in average ionic radius. The shrinkage of the M-Te2 distance affects other structural parameters; the Te2-M-Te2 angle increases, the MTe6 octahedron is compressed along the c axis, and the BiTe6 octahedron is compressed along the ab plane. Although those changes would be caused by chemical pressure effects, which is the shrinkage of unit cells and/or bonds by the decrease in the average ionic size at the M site, we found an interesting trend in the isotropic displacement parameter (Uiso) at the M site. With increasing ΔSmix, Uiso at the M site clearly decreases (Table 2). In the Discussion, we briefly discuss the origin and commonality of this trend in HEA-type compounds.

Table 2

Refinement results for the SXRD data. In analysis, the occupancy of 3a site atoms were fixed nominal values, respectively.

(a) Structure parameters of PbBi2Te4. Space group R3¯m; Z = 3; a = 4.43910(8) Å, c = 41.6331(12) Å; wRp = 0.082; RB = 0.116, RF = 0.082, goodness-of-fit = 10.67.
Atom	Site	Symmetry	g	x	y	z	Uiso (Å2)
Pb	3a	3¯ m	1	0	0	0	0.032(1)
Bi	6c	3m	1	0	0	0.42913(11)	0.0296(12)
Te	6c	3m	1	0	0	0.13669(10)	0.0127(7)
Te2	6c	3m	1	0	0	0.2878(2)	= Uiso (Te)
(b) Structure parameters of MEA. Space group R3¯m; Z = 3; a = 4.42165(11) (8) Å, c = 41.331(2) Å; wRp = 0.054; RB = 0.076, RF = 0.059, goodness-of-fit = 6.32.
Atom	Site	Symmetry	g	x	y	z	Uiso (Å2)
Ag	3a	3¯ m	1/3	0	0	0	0.015(2)
Pb	3a	3¯ m	1/3	0	0	0	= Uiso (Ag)
Bi	3a	3¯ m	1/3	0	0	0	= Uiso (Ag)
Bi2	6c	3m	1	0	0	0.42750(7)	0.0325(8)
Te	6c	3m	1	0	0	0.13618(9)	0.0100(6)
Te2	6c	3m	1	0	0	0.28980(12)	= Uiso (Te)
(c) Structure parameters of HEA. Space group R3¯m; Z = 3; a = 4.40848(9) Å, c = 41.2768(15) Å; wRp = 0.063; RB = 0.101, RF = 0.076, goodness-of-fit = 8.84.
Atom	Site	Symmetry	g	x	y	z	Uiso (Å2)
Ag	3a	3¯ m	1/5	0	0	0	0.007110(15)
In	3a	3¯ m	1/5	0	0	0	= Uiso (Ag)
Sn	3a	3¯ m	1/5	0	0	0	= Uiso (Ag)
Pb	3a	3¯ m	1/5	0	0	0	= Uiso (Ag)
Bi	3a	3¯ m	1/5	0	0	0	= Uiso (Ag)
Bi2	6c	3m	1	0	0	0.42785(7)	0.0333(8)
Te	6c	3m	1	0	0	0.13631(8)	0.0143(9)
Te2	6c	3m	1	0	0	0.29037(9)	= Uiso (Te)

Figure 2

(a) Schematic representation of the unit cell of MBi2Te4, looking along the crystallographic a-axis. (b–e) Atomic distance of M-Te2, Te-Te, Bi-Te and Bi-Te2. The blue lines are eye guides.

In Figure 3, the temperature dependences of electrical resistivity (ρ) normalized by that at 300 K (ρ (T)/300 K) are displayed. For both the PbBi2Te4 and HEA samples, metallic conductivity, which is regarded by the decrease in ρ with decreasing temperature, is observed. For the HEA sample, the temperature dependence is weak and the residual resistivity at the lowest temperature is larger than that for PbBi2Te4. A similar trend was observed in other HEA-type materials as reviewed in Ref. [3]. Therefore, we consider that the HEA state introduced in the M site in MBi2Te4 affects transport properties in this system as well. Although we measured ρ and magnetization down to 1.8 K, no superconducting signal was observed. Since the present samples contain impurity phases as described in the refinement part, high quality samples are desired to further discuss the effect of the HEA states on transport properties.

Figure 3

Temperature dependences of electrical resistivity ratio for PbBi2Te4 and the HEA sample.

4. Discussion

Here, we briefly discuss the origin of the decrease in Uiso in MEA (Ag0.18Pb0.32Bi0.50Bi2Te4) and HEA (Ag0.14In0.15Sn0.25Pb0.14Bi0.32Bi2Te4). When one or more sites of compounds were substituted by different elements, an increase in disorder on atomic distance is expected, and off-centering of the atomic position is also expected. Although the increase in disorder due to element substitutions should strongly depend on the type of compounds (crystal structure), an increase in Uiso is simply expected for compounds with element solution. However, in this system, Uiso decreases with increasing ΔSmix as shown in Figure 4. We consider that the decrease in Uiso is correlating with the change in lattice vibration. According to Ref. [29], PbBi2Te4 possesses anharmonic lattice vibration. In our recent study on a BiS2-based layered system RE(O,F)BiS2, we showed that lattice anharmonicity is enhanced in the low-entropy region, and is suppressed in the middle-to-high entropy region [30]. According to those facts, we consider that the decrease in Uiso in MBi2Te4 is also related to the suppression of the anharmonic vibration. Hence, the synthesis and structural characterization for MBi2Te4 with different ΔSmix would give a strategy to tune lattice vibration in functional materials.

Figure 4

ΔSmix/R dependence of Uiso at the M site.

5. Conclusions

We synthesized a new layered system MBi2Te4 where low-, middle-, and high-entropy states are present in the M site: the samples with nominal M = Pb, Ag1/3Pb1/3Bi1/3, and Ag1/5In1/5Sn1/5Pb1/5Bi1/5 were synthesized by solid-state reaction. The crystal structure was examined by synchrotron X-ray diffraction and Rietveld refinement. We found that the M-Te2 distance was systematically compressed with decreasing lattice constants, where ΔSmix at the M site is also systematically increased. We found that Uiso at the M site decreases with increasing ΔSmix. The result is similar to that observed in other systems with anharmonic lattice vibration. Therefore, we concluded that the increase in ΔSmix results in the suppression of anharmonicity in MBi2Te4.