Overcoming peri- and ortho-selectivity in C-H methylation of 1-naphthaldehydes by a tunable transient ligand strategy.

Methyl groups widely exist in bioactive molecules, and site-specific methylation has become a valuable strategy for their structural functionalization. Aiming to introduce this smallest alkyl handle, a highly regioselective peri- and ortho-C-H methylation of 1-naphthaldehyde by using a transient ligand strategy has been developed. A series of methyl-substituted naphthalene frameworks have been prepared in moderate to excellent yields. Mechanistic studies demonstrate that peri-methylation is controlled by the higher electronic density of the peri-position of 1-naphthaldehyde as well as the formation of intermediary 5,6-fused bicyclic palladacycles, whereas experimental studies and theoretical calculations inferred that a 5-membered iridacycle at the ortho-position of 1-naphthaldehyde leads to energetically favorable ortho-methylation via an interconversion between the peri-iridacycle and ortho-iridacycle. Importantly, to demonstrate the synthetic utility of this method, we show that this strategy can serve as a platform for the synthesis of multi-substituted naphthalene-based bioactive molecules and natural products. This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry.

Introduction

The methylation strategy is of particular importance in accessing or optimizing bioactive molecules owing to the ubiquity of methyl groups in these pharmacological entities (Fig. 1A).[1] The development of site-specific methylation has attracted significant attention in the rapid construction and late-stage functionalization of complex structures.[2] Although a few regioselective methylation methods are well-developed for the transition metal (TM)-catalyzed ortho-C–H functionalization of benzene,[3] the precise site-selectivity control on polyaromatic ring systems (e.g. naphthalene) remains largely absent,[4] due to their possession of at least two proximal sites, the peri- and ortho-positions (Fig. 1B).

Fig. 1

(A) Methyl groups in natural products and bioactive molecules. (B) Selectivity from benzene to naphthalene. (C) Peri- and ortho-C–H functionalizations of naphthalene. (D) Regioselective C–H methylation of 1-naphthaldehydes with tunable TDGs.

With the help of immobilized directing groups, such as picolinamides,[5] thioethers,[6] carboxylic derivatives,[7] amines,[8] hydrosilyls,[9] carbamates,[10] pyridyls,[11] phosphines,[12] and sulfonamides,[13]advances in peri- and ortho-C–H functionalization have been made, but most of these ligands have been restricted to C–H sp2 functionalization (e.g. arylation, alkenylation, alkynylation, cyanation, etc.) and suffer from extra steps for installation and removal of directing groups (Fig. 1C). Although the transient directing group (TDG) strategy has been consequently devised to avoid using immobilized directing groups,[14] TDG promoted C–H alkylation remains extremely challenging. The only example, demonstrated by the Sorensen group, showed that the in situ formation of Schiff bases with benzaldehydes and orthanilic acids promoted ortho-C–H methylation and fluorination.[15] Our recent study has successfully extended the peri- and ortho-C–H oxygenation of polyaromatic rings.[16] Inspired by these discoveries, we envisioned that the precise site-selectivity control of proximal C–H alkylation of the naphthalene ring might be achieved via the incorporation of TDGs (Fig. 1D). To the best of our knowledge, we herein wish to disclose the first regioselective peri- and ortho-C–H methylation of 1-naphthaldehyde via TDG catalysis. The study not only features the site-specific metal incorporation and C–H cleavage, but also details mechanistic driving forces by providing consistent experimental and computational evidence.

Results and discussion

Peri-C–H methylation

Initially, we began our investigation by conducting peri-C–H methylation of 1-naphthaldehyde. Interestingly, the desired peri-C–H methylated product was detected in low yield after a 36 h reaction that used 10 mol% of Pd(OAc)2 as the catalyst, 60 mol% of glycine (TDG1) as the TDG, 2.0 equivalents of AgOAc as the oxidant, 2.5 equivalents of potassium methyl trifluoroborate as the methylating reagent, and acetic acid (0.2 M) as the solvent (Table S1†). Striving to improve the reaction efficiency, we examined numerous oxidants and found that Cu(TFA)2-xH2O (ref. 17) performed better than other oxidants. Previously reported F+ oxidants failed to give the C–H methylation product at the peri-position.[15] Next, screening of basic additives showed that two equivalents of CsOAc gave a better yield (35%). Surprisingly, the addition of H2O that facilitated the solubility of trifluoroborate salt improved the yield to 43%, and yet adopting soluble methylboronate MeBF3(Bu4N) and other methylating reagents inhibited the yield (Tables S1 and S2†). The screening of solvents, for example, hexafluoroisopropanol (HFIP) further promoted the reaction yield to 48%, while only traces of ortho-product 3a or bi-methylated product 4a were detected. Subsequent optimization of TDG ligands demonstrated that the presence of L,X-type TDGs is critical to C–H methylation, probably because the peri-selectivity relied on the formation of bicyclic palladacycles (Table 1). Using carbonyl as the X-branch of the ligand (TDG1, 7, 8) preferably gave the peri-product, whereas reactions involving the use of sulfonic acid as the X-branch (TDG2, 5) and monodentate ligands (TDG3, 6) were biased towards the bi-methylated product. Meanwhile, extended L,X-TDGs (TDG4, 5, 9) triggered a higher ratio of Pd insertion at the ortho-position, since the bicyclic palladacycle with a 5,6-fused ring has the most favorable ring strain.[18] However, steric L,X-type TDGs (TDG10–12), which destabilized the conformation of bicyclic palladacycles, reduced the reactivity.

Effects of TDGs on peri-C–H methylation of 1-naphthaldehydea,b

Experiments were performed under the following reaction conditions: 1a (0.3 mmol), CH3BF3K (1.05 mmol), Pd(OAc)2 (10 mol%), TDG (60 mol%), Cu(TFA)2-xH2O (0.6 mmol), CsOAc (0.6 mmol), HFIP : AcOH = 7 : 1 (1.5 mL), H2O (3.0 mmol), 90 °C, sealed tube, 36 h.

Yields were determined by 1H NMR analysis of the crude reaction mixture using CH2Br2 as the internal standard.

With the optimal reaction conditions in hand, we next explored the scope of peri-C–H methylation (Table 2). Various substituted 1-naphthaldehydes bearing electron-neutral, donating and withdrawing groups were smoothly methylated in uniformly moderate yields. Substrates with substituents in universal positions could provide the corresponding products. Gratifyingly, sulfonates (2e, 2f, 2t) and acrylates (2m, 2q) were amenable with the reaction system. Previously prohibited substrates, such as those with formidable withdrawing and donating groups (2j, 2y), also gave the desired products. The limitation of the method occurs only on the steric substitution at the 7-position (2x).

Scope of 1-naphthaldehyde for peri-C–H methylationa,b

Under the same conditions as in Table 1.

Isolated yields.

Ortho-C–H methylation

Although we have detected the existence of ortho-products (TDG3, Table 1) during the optimization of peri-C–H methylation, the yield with Pd catalyst is difficult to improve after futile efforts. The higher electron density at the peri-position allows the C–H activation to inevitably occur prior to the ortho-position. Inspired by previous studies,[19] we hypothesized that iridium may override the unnecessary activation at the peri-position. To our delight, the ortho-C–H methylated product was found dominantly when using [Cp*IrCl2]2 and TDG3, although accompanied by a trace quantity of di-methylated 4a. Extensive screening of solvents, oxidants, additives and methylating reagents resulted in no yield enhancement (Tables S3 and S4†), while thorough investigation of the TDGs implicated that simple anilines were superior to the L,X-type ligands (Tables 3 and S3†). Finally, we identified that meta-EWG containing TDGs (TDG25, 28) were the optimal ligands for ortho-C–H methylation.

Scope of 1-naphthaldehyde for ortho-C–H methylationa,b

Experiments were performed under the following reaction conditions: 1a (0.3 mmol), CH3BF3K (0.6 mmol), [Cp*IrCl2]2 (5 mol%), TDG (20 mol%), AgNTf2 (0.06 mmol), AgOAc (0.75 mmol), AcOH (1.5 mL), 90 °C, N2, sealed tube, 5–10 min.

Isolated yields.

Yields were determined by 1H NMR analysis of the crude reaction mixture using CH2Br2 as the internal standard.

TDG28 was used instead of TDG25.

TDG29 was used instead of TDG25, 30 min.

With the optimized procedure in hand, we next explored the scope of ortho-C–H methylation. All the substituted 1-naphthaldehydes previously studied for peri-C–H methylation were revisited. It was found that not only all sorts of electron properties but also universal sites of substituted naphthaldehydes were well-tolerated to generate the expected ortho-products with excellent yields. Although substrates with steric hindrance and electron-donating substituents[19] were found to inhibit the reactivity, 3-aminobenzonitrile (TDG28) dramatically promoted the reactivity of these steric (1k, 1l and 1m) and electron donating substrates (1h and 1y). When the di-CN TDG group was used (TDG29), the yield of 3y further increased to 71%, indicating that the electron-withdrawing TDG is favorable for ortho-C–H methylation. The poor convertion of peri-occupied substrates (2a and 1ab) inspired our further study of mechanism.

Synthetic applications to naphthalene-based derivatives and natural products

Based on the above studies, we devoted our efforts to demonstrating the synthetic utility of this protocol. As shown in Scheme 1, methylated products 2a and 3a can be obtained on gram scales with 48% and 81% yields respectively. Diverse di-substituted naphthalene derivatives were achieved via sequential C–H functionalization at the proximal positions of aldehydes with reactive groups, such as alkyl, aryl, halogen, sulfonamide, and alkoxy. Interestingly, 2,8-dimethyl-1-naphthaldehyde 4a could be obtained if the methyl group was first introduced at the 2-position (Table 3) rather than at the 8-position (Scheme 1).

Scheme 1

Synthesis of diverse naphthaldehydes via sequential C–H functionalizations. Reaction conditions: (a) 1a or 3a, CH3BF3K (3.5 eq.), Pd(OAc)2 (10 mol%), TDG (60 mol%), Cu(TFA)2-xH2O (2 eq.), CsOAc (2 eq.), HFIP : AcOH = 7 : 1, H2O (10 eq.), 90 °C, sealed tube, 36 h. (b) 1a, CH3BF3K (2 eq.), [Cp*IrCl2]2 (5 mol%), TDG (20 mol%), AgNTf2 (20 mol%), AgOAc (2.5 eq.), AcOH, 90 °C, N2, sealed tube, 4 h. (c) 2a, [Ru(p-cymene)Cl2]2 (5 mol%), AgSbF6 (20 mol%), 2-methyl-3-(trifluoromethyl)aniline (20 mol%), 4-chlorobenzoic acid (0.5 eq.), 1-ethyl-1H-pyrrole-2,5-dione (1.5 eq.), DCE : HFIP = 5 : 1, 60 °C, N2, sealed tube, 36 h. (d) 2a, Pd(OAc)2 (10 mol%), methyl 4-iodobenzoate (2 eq.), 2-amino-2-methylpropanoic acid (40 mol%), AgTFA (1 eq.), HFIP : TFA = 9 : 1, 110 °C, sealed tube, 24 h. (e) 2a, [CpIrCl2]2 (4 mol%), 3-trifluoromethylaniline (40 mol%), 4-methylbenzenesulfonyl azide (2 eq.), AgPF6 (24 mol%), DCE, 100 °C, N2, sealed tube, 36 h. (f) 2a or 3a, NCS (1.3 or 1.5 eq.), Pd(OAc)2 (10 mol%), anthranilic acid (30 mol%), AgTFA (10 mol%), TFA (10 eq.), DCE, 60 °C, sealed tube, 24 h. (g) 3a, Pd(OAc)2 (10 mol%), K2S2O8 (2 eq.), MeOH (20 eq.), 3-(trifluoromethyl)aniline (40 mol%), CH2Cl2, 60 °C, sealed tube, 36 h. (h) 3a, NBS (1.5 eq.), Pd(OAc)2 (10 mol%), 2-amino-4-nitrobenzoic acid (50 mol%), AgTFA (10 mol%), TfOH (50 mol%), DCE, 90 °C, sealed tube, 24 h.

In our further attempt to demonstrate the synthetic utility, several bioactive compounds[20] that bear alkyl-substituted naphthalene frameworks have been obtained efficiently (Scheme 2). For example, the preparation of nordehydrocacalohastine (11), an antimicrobial eremophilane sesquiterpene first isolated from Cacalia and Senecio plants,[21] started from commercially available naphthol 5. Naphthaldehyde 7 was readily acquired by the Rieche reaction of compound 6 with high regioselectivity. After protection of the phenol group with α-bromoacetone, peri-methylation was successfully carried out to deliver the key intermediate 9 in a yield commensurate with the above standard conditions. Subsequent deformylation and cyclization accomplished the synthesis of the natural product in a total of 6 steps. Impressively, the employment of our methylation method saves 6 steps and improves the total yield 4.5-fold (11.7% vs. 2.6%) compared with the previously reported route.[22] Meanwhile, gram methylation of 3-bromo-naphthaldehyde gave the ortho-methylated naphthaldehyde 13 in 80% yield. Next, treatment with the standard Bayer–Villiger reaction and oxidation smoothly produced the key precursor quinone 15, providing an alternative route to vitamin K.[23] The final example was illustrated by the exchange of substitution on 4-fluoronaphthaldehyde. Peri-methylation and removal of the formyl group gave 16. Oxidation of the existing methyl group to another aldehyde 17 achieved ortho-methylation to form a rare 2-methyl-5-fluoronaphthaldehyde in 82% yield. These serial conversions highlighted the unique merit of our method in the preparation of naphthalene-based natural products and bioactive derivatives.

Scheme 2

Synthetic transformation of regioselective peri- and ortho-C–H methylation.

Mechanistic studies

To gain mechanistic insight into this reaction, a set of control experiments were carried out. In the absence of a catalyst or a TDG group, little product was detected under the standard conditions. The addition of a radical scavenger cannot quench the methylated products (Scheme 3, A1 and B1), indicating a non-radical process. Slightly reversible H/D exchange occurred at the peri-C–H position in the presence of Pd(OAc)2, while addition of glycine increased the ratio of the deuterated product. This observation verified the promotive effect of the TDG (Scheme 3, A2). Equivalent mixtures of EDG (1h) and EWG (1j) substrates under standard conditions of peri-methylation resulted in a large ratio of product 2h, illustrating that the electron-rich naphthaldehyde reacted faster than the electron-deficient one (Scheme 3, A3), while ortho-methylation had a much faster rate with electron-withdrawing substitutions (Scheme 3, B3). The stable palladacycle 19 was successfully captured by the pyridine ligand and could be further converted to the peri-methylated product 2a (Scheme 3, A4). Moreover, addition of product 2a was found to inhibit peri-methylation of 1a (Scheme S1†), which may explain the moderate yields of this conversion.

Scheme 3

Mechanistic studies.

Scheme 4

Possible mechanistic pathway.

However, treatment of 1a with [Cp*IrCl2]2 in AcOD delivered deuterated products at both peri- and ortho-positions. The higher D-ratio at the peri-position with standard and extended reaction times consistently showed that the peri-position is more likely to have the metal inserted due to its higher electronic density than the ortho-position,[16] and even the introduction of TDG25 had no influence on this outcome (Scheme 3, B2). Although the rate of peri-metallation may be superior to the rate of methylation at the ortho-position in the C–H metal insertion step, it was found that the peri-iridacycle was readily hydrolysed, which also explains the higher yield of the deuterated product at this position. In contrast, resistance to ortho-hydrolysis resulted in the capture of iridacycle 21 and its NTf2 ligand exchanger 22 (Scheme 3, B5). Treatment with CH3BF3K produced iridacycle 24 and the desired ortho-methylated product 3a in the absence of an oxidant. However, in the presence of an oxidant, ortho-iridacycle 22 was converted to peri-iridacycle 23 when the ortho-position was occupied by the methyl group. And peri-iridacycle 23 was readily acid hydrolyzed to product 3a rather than successive methylation at the peri-position. Notably, the observations that ortho-iridacycle 22 was resistant to acid hydrolysis and peri-blocked substrates (3z and 4a, Table 3) diminished the ortho-productivity further corroborated the fact that the reactivity of and interconversion between these iridacycles together controlled the ortho-selectivity (Scheme 3, B4). Additionally, the poor reactivity of simple benzaldehyde in our method showed that the methylation method had unique properties in the selective activation of the proximal C–H bonds of naphthaldehyde (Scheme S2†). Finally, determination of the kinetic isotope effect (KIE) of the C–H cleavage was carried out (Scheme S3†). The intermolecular KIE of 1a and 1a-peri-D was found at 0.99 (kH/KD), which indicated that the cleavage of the peri-C–H bond is not involved in the rate-determining step. Similarly, the KIE of the ortho-C–H bond was studied at a low temperature to slow the conversion for measurement. The intermolecular KIE of 1a and 1a-ortho-D is 1.30 (kH/KD), which suggested that the cleavage of the ortho-C–H bond may not be involved in the rate-determining step.

Computational studies

Since the control experiment suggested that the peri-palladacycle directed the following methylation, the mechanism for the palladium-catalyzed peri-C–H activation process was thus investigated using M06-2X DFT calculations. As shown in Fig. 2A, the transition state of TS2 possessed a lower energy barrier (ΔG‡ = 11.9 kcal mol−1) at the peri-position, in comparison with the transition state TS1 guiding the ortho-C–H insertion (ΔG‡ = 16.5 kcal mol−1). At the same time, the lower energy level of peri-intermediate Int3 over Int2 also indicated that the higher electron density at the peri-position of 1-naphthaldehyde controlled the selectivity. In order to obtain details on the actual electron flow in the conversion, an intrinsic bond orbital (IBO) analysis was performed (Fig. 2B).[24] In the TS2 structure, the electrons in the σ-orbital [aromatic C–H] interact with the π*-orbital [CO] of acetate to abstract a proton. The electrons of [σ(Pd–O)] become a lone pair [LP(Pd)] of the palladium complex, and at the same time, the electrons in the 4d-orbital of palladium [LP(Pd)] form a new palladium–carbon σ-bond [σ(Pd–C)] in the palladacycle intermediate. The bond recombination occurs via a concerted mechanism.[25]

Fig. 2

(A) The calculated reaction energy profile of palladacycle complex formation steps. (B) IBO analysis of the palladium-assisted peri-C–H activation of TS2.

The mechanism of the ortho-C–H activation process with the iridium catalyst was also investigated following the experimental findings (Fig. 3A). As anticipated, starting from the relative zero point of the iridium-Schiff base complex, peri-metallation had a lower energy barrier of 3.5 kcal mol−1 than ortho-metallation. After C–H insertion, the peri-iridacycle was also found to be more stable than its ortho-counterpart 22. Subsequent transmetallation with CH3BF3K flipped over the Gibbs energy, in which ortho-product 24 was exothermic by 7.4 kcal mol−1, 11.1 kcal mol−1 higher than that of the process that yielded the peri-product. The addition of the Cl ligand to the intermediates Int5 and Int6 also reversed their stability, which was exactly validated by the isolation of iridacycle 21 rather than peri-21. In the intrinsic bond orbital (IBO) analysis, a similar pattern of electron flow to that of the palladacycle had been verified (Fig. 3B).

Fig. 3

(A) The calculated reaction energy profile of the formation of intermediate 24. (B) IBO analysis of the iridium-assisted ortho-C–H activation of TS3. (C) The calculated reaction energy profile of the formation of product 23.

Previous findings prove that the energy barrier of reductive elimination is lowered at least by 15–30 kcal mol−1 by increasing the oxidation state of iridium from product-like Ir(iii) to reactant-like Ir(v).[26] We postulated that oxidatively enhanced reductive elimination was also dominant in our ortho-methylation after iridium was oxidized to hypervalent species by the silver oxidant. As shown in Fig. 3C, active ortho-Ir(v) species Int7 underwent reductive elimination and coupled the methyl group to the naphthalene ring releasing a large amount of energy (41.4 kcal mol−1), in which the energy barrier of ortho-methylation was 14.2 kcal mol−1 (2.7 kcal mol−1 lower than that of the unfavorable peri-methylation). Next, the iridacycle rebounded to the peri-position to produce intermediate 23 as experimentally observed, by continuing to release 4.9 kcal mol−1 of energy. Overall computational calculations indicated by the energy profile of transient states were in complete agreement with experimental investigations and supported the regioselectivity.

Collectively, we proposed a plausible catalytic cycle that is believed to be different from previously reported Pd(ii)/(iv)[15] and Ir(i)/(III)[19] catalysis (Scheme 4). Starting from the formation of imine A or E, metal catalysts are incorporated into the activated C–H bond and afforded a 5,6-fused bicyclic or 6-membered ring at the peri-position. Insertion of CH3BF3K to the palladacycle induces subsequent reductive elimination to forge precursor D. For the iridacycle, hydrolysis and re-iridation promote the conversion of 6-membered ring F to 5-membered ring G, which is ready to perform transmetallation with a methylated reagent. After the oxidatively induced reductive elimination of iridacycle H,ortho-methylation brings about another peri-iridation to form intermediate I which is reactively inert to methylation. D and I further furnish the desired products 2a and 3a by in situ hydrolyzation, respectively. Concomitantly, the active catalysts are regenerated for the next catalytic cycle.

Conclusions

We have developed a highly regioselective peri- and ortho-C–H methylation of 1-naphthaldehyde by using the transient ligand strategy. Mechanistically, capture of reaction intermediates and isotopic exchange experiments identified variable reactive metallacycles formed with different transient directing ligands in the metal-insertion and methylation steps. As suggested by DFT calculations and IBO analysis, although peri-metalation is energetically favorable compared to ortho-metalation in both palladium and iridium catalyses, transmetallation of CH3BF3K with iridium(iii) readily takes place on the ortho-iridacycle rather than on the peri-iridacycle, which primarily explained the dichotomic selectivity on the two proximal positions of the naphthalene ring. We believe that this finding would greatly advance the future studies toward exquisite transformation control of polyaromatic rings. Moreover, the regioselectivity and broad utility of this method provide an unconventional tactic for the supply of multi-substituted naphthalene-based bioactive derivatives and natural products, thus building a stage for the use of dual metal/TDG catalysis approaches in the creation of molecules that are synthetically practicable and structurally attractive.

Data availability

All the experimental data have been included in the ESI.†

Author contributions

Y. M., J. J. and Y. Z. conceived and designed the project. Y. M., J. J. and D. Y. performed the experiments and collected the data. D. Y. and Y. M. contributed to the theoretical and experimental mechanistic investigation. X. C. and Y. W. contributed to the optimization of the transient directing strategy and the interpretation of the related results. Y. M., L. H. and Y. Z. prepared the manuscript with input from all contributing authors.

Conflicts of interest

There are no conflicts to declare.