Prenatal stress is a neuropsychiatric risk factor, and effects may be mediated by prenatal oxidative stress. Cell types in the brain sensitive to oxidative stress-cortical microglia and cortical and hippocampal interneurons-may be altered by oxidative stress generated during prenatal stress and may be neurobiological substrates for altered behavior. Our objective was to determine the critical nature of oxidative stress in prenatal stress effects by manipulating prenatal antioxidants. CD1 mouse dams underwent restraint embryonic day 12 to 18 three times daily or no stress and received intraperitoneal injections before each stress period of vehicle, N-acetylcysteine (200 mg/kg daily), or astaxanthin (30 mg/kg before first daily stress, 10 mg/kg before second/third stresses). Adult male and female offspring behavior, microglia, and interneurons were assessed. Results supported the hypothesis that prenatal stress-induced oxidative stress affects microglia; microglia ramification increased after prenatal stress, and both antioxidants prevented these effects. In addition, N-acetylcysteine or astaxanthin was effective in preventing distinct male and female interneuron changes; decreased female medial frontal cortical parvalbumin interneurons was prevented by either antioxidant; increased male medial frontal cortical parvalbumin interneurons was prevented by N-acetylcysteine and decreased male hippocampal GAD67GFP+ cells prevented by astaxanthin. Prenatal stress-induced increased anxiety-like behavior and decreased sociability were not prevented by prenatal antioxidants. Sensorimotor gating deficits in males was partially prevented by prenatal astaxanthin. This study demonstrates the importance of oxidative stress for persistent impacts on offspring cortical microglia and interneurons, but did not link these changes with anxiety-like, social, and sensorimotor gating behaviors.
Prenatal stress is a neuropsychiatric risk factor, and effects may be mediated by prenatal oxidative stress. Cell types in the brain sensitive to oxidative stress-cortical microglia and cortical and hippocampal interneurons-may be altered by oxidative stress generated during prenatal stress and may be neurobiological substrates for altered behavior. Our objective was to determine the critical nature of oxidative stress in prenatal stress effects by manipulating prenatal antioxidants. CD1 mouse dams underwent restraint embryonic day 12 to 18 three times daily or no stress and received intraperitoneal injections before each stress period of vehicle, N-acetylcysteine (200 mg/kg daily), or astaxanthin (30 mg/kg before first daily stress, 10 mg/kg before second/third stresses). Adult male and female offspring behavior, microglia, and interneurons were assessed. Results supported the hypothesis that prenatal stress-induced oxidative stress affects microglia; microglia ramification increased after prenatal stress, and both antioxidants prevented these effects. In addition, N-acetylcysteine or astaxanthin was effective in preventing distinct male and female interneuron changes; decreased female medial frontal cortical parvalbumin interneurons was prevented by either antioxidant; increased male medial frontal cortical parvalbumin interneurons was prevented by N-acetylcysteine and decreased male hippocampal GAD67GFP+ cells prevented by astaxanthin. Prenatal stress-induced increased anxiety-like behavior and decreased sociability were not prevented by prenatal antioxidants. Sensorimotor gating deficits in males was partially prevented by prenatal astaxanthin. This study demonstrates the importance of oxidative stress for persistent impacts on offspring cortical microglia and interneurons, but did not link these changes with anxiety-like, social, and sensorimotor gating behaviors.
Prenatal stress is associated with an increased risk for neuropsychiatric illness
including attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder, autism spectrum disorder (ASD),
and schizophrenia [1-4], as well as increasing childhood behavioral, physiological,
and emotional problems in offspring [5-7]. Specifically, prenatal stress is associated
with disruptive behavioral problems in toddlers, increased risk for lower motor
function in kindergartners, and more externalizing behaviors in older children
[8-10]. Alterations to the developing brain during prenatal stress must
have enduring consequences to explain the development of neuropsychiatric illness
many years later [11].Prenatal stress may have persistent effects on brain function through redox
dysregulation that occurs during stress [12-15]. Embryonic brain is
vulnerable to changes in reactive oxygen species and redox dysregulation because of
its low antioxidant capacity and other characteristics [16-20]. Prenatal stress
increases oxidative stress in embryonic brain [21]. Maternal treatment during pregnancy with N-acetyl cysteine (NAC), a
glutathione precursor and well-established antioxidant, prevents learning and memory
deficits brain redox changes in adult offspring exposed to prenatal stress or
maternal inflammation [22-25]. These findings suggest that
neurobiological substrates sensitive to oxidative stress may underlie prenatal
stress effects on additional domains of behavior relevant to neuropsychiatric
disorders.Microglia are critical regulators of a range of brain functions during development
and in mature brain [26-30], with abnormalities of microglia linked with
neuropsychiatric disorders [31-33]. More microglia with reduced or thicker
ramifications in cortical regions of individuals with neuropsychiatric disorders
have been hypothesized to be linked to the role of these activated or “primed” cell
types in pathophysiological synaptic pruning [33,34]; a range of behaviors may
be affected by mis-targeted synaptic pruning by activated or primed microglia in
developing and/or mature brain. Microglia are reactive to oxidative stress [35-37]
and are altered by prenatal stress [38-41], further implicating oxidative stress in
persistent outcomes of prenatal stress.GABAergic cortical interneurons are also affected by prenatal stress [42-45]
and are implicated in the neuropsychiatric deficits linked to prenatal stress [46-49].
Cortical and hippocampal GABAergic populations contribute to excitatory/inhibitory
balance and oscillations within circuits, which coordinate neuronal firing necessary
for behavioral regulation and are hypothesized to have pathophysiological roles in
ASD, schizophrenia, and other neuropsychiatric disorders [50]. The appropriate proportion of interneurons expressing
parvalbumin and capable of fast-spiking activity are particularly important for
oscillating activity underlying cognition [51]. Cortical interneurons are vulnerable to oxidative stress during
development and in mature brain [15,52]. Effects of prenatal stress on both
microglia and cortical interneurons in the embryonic brain are ameliorated by
maternal administration of NAC or another antioxidant, astaxanthin (AST) [21,40].
AST is a naturally occurring carotenoid that reduces oxidative stress in the brain
[53-55]. AST given to adult offspring ameliorates anxiety- and
depressive-like behavioral deficits arising from prenatal maternal inflammation
[56], but AST has not been used during
prenatal stress to determine oxidative stress mechanisms for persistent
neurobehavioral outcomes. Studies in which only a single antioxidant agent is used
do not provide convergent data to more precisely address oxidative stress as a
mechanism, rather than off-target mechanisms of individual agents.We sought to determine whether oxidative stress during prenatal stress plays a role
in its persistent impacts in offspring by examining adult neurobiological and
behavioral outcomes with manipulation of oxidative stress during the prenatal period
using either NAC or AST, similar to previous work on embryonic brain [21]. These two antioxidants have similar
efficacy for reducing oxidative stress but different mechanisms by which this
occurs: NAC provides substrate for producing glutathione, a critical component of
reducing reactions, but also acts through other non-oxidative stress mechanisms in
the brain which may be a confound with use of only NAC to manipulate oxidative
stress [57,58]. AST broadly augments endogenous antioxidant processes in multiple
ways [59], and other non-oxidative stress
processes it may affect are poorly understood. Our study is unique in use of these
two different antioxidants to convergently determine the necessity of prenatal
oxidative stress. We hypothesized that outcomes due to oxidative stress-related
mechanisms would be affected similarly by maternal administration of either, but
oxidative stress-related mechanisms were less likely implicated if only one agent
has effects. We evaluated cortical microglia and medial frontal cortical and
hippocampal GABAergic interneurons with the hypothesis that, because of their
sensitivity to oxidative stress, they would be altered in the adult brain by
prenatal stress; we also hypothesized that either maternal antioxidant treatment
during prenatal stress would prevent these changes as modifiers of prenatal redox
mechanisms. Prenatal stress-exposed rodent offspring consistently have altered
anxiety-like behavior, social behavior, locomotor activity, and sensorimotor gating
[41,42,60-63]. We hypothesized that we would find these same deficits
which would also be prevented by either maternal antioxidant. Lastly, we expected
that neurobiological and behavioral outcomes would be correlated across all
individual animals, given previous findings demonstrating the contribution of
microglial morphologies and interneuron populations in these complex behaviors
[34,50,51]. The goal of this study of
prenatal stress models is to elucidate the critical role of prenatal oxidative
stress in neuropsychiatric risk, information that can be used to develop better
preventive measures and treatments for those at risk for neuropsychiatric
disease.
Methods
Mice
GAD67-GFP+/- knock-in mice used to assess GABAergic interneuron populations were
bred on a CD1 background, housed, and tested in accordance with our
Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC) policies. All mice were
housed in cages on a 12-hour light/dark cycle with free access to food and
water. For timed pregnancies, breeding-naïve GAD67-GFP-/- female mice were bred
with GAD67-GFP+/- males. The detection of a vaginal plug established embryonic
day 0 (E0). Prenatally-stressed dams were singly housed from E12 onward and
non-stressed dams were co-housed.
Prenatal Stress and Treatments
Beginning on E12 and for the duration of their pregnancies, prenatally- and
non-stressed dams (PS and NS, respectively) were given intraperitoneal
injections of either: 1) N-acetylcysteine (NAC) (once daily 200 mg/kg of 40
mg/mL phosphate buffered saline (PBS) solution with 30% sodium hydroxide (1 μM)
to bring pH to 7.4; Sigma A7250) [64-66], 2) astaxanthin (AST;
three times daily due to shorter half-life: 30 mg/kg [first daily injection] or
10 mg/kg [second and third daily injections] in a 10mg/mL PBS solution; with 3%
dimethyl sulfoxide [DMSO]; Sigma SML0982) [67,68], or 3) PBS alone (once
daily 200 μL), 20 minutes prior to restraint stress sessions or at equivalent
times in non-stressed dams. Half of pregnant females underwent prenatal stress
in a clear, plastic restraint under bright lights for 45 minutes, three times a
day, at 3 to 4 hour intervals [63]. All
pregnant dams (n=18, 3 per condition) gave birth to between 6-13 pups, with the
average litter size of 10 pups. On the day of birth, postnatal day 0 (P0),
litters were culled to six to eight with even distribution of male and female
pups. On P24, mice were weaned from their mothers and then single-sex
group-housed by condition.
Behavioral Tests of Adult Offspring
All behavioral tests were performed on 10-14-week-old male and female mice,
representing all offspring from 18 litters. Sample sizes ranged from nine to 12
animals from each condition and sex. During the light cycle, mice were allowed
to habituate to the testing room 30 minutes prior to testing. All behavioral
tests were conducted on consecutive days with only one test per day in the order
listed here in the methods (least to most stressful). Mice remained in their
home cage with their cage-mates immediately before and after testing to limit
the inherent stress of behavioral testing. All cages were equipped with hoppers
that provided food and water for the duration of the testing period. Each
testing apparatus was cleaned with 70% ethanol and dried prior to each daily
assessment and between the assessment of each mouse.Open field (OF): In a 1,500 cm2 rectangular, clear plastic
arena, offspring mice were tested on the open field test for 30 minutes on two
consecutive days. The amount of time spent in the center 50% of the arena was
measured. Trials were video-recorded by a suspended, overhead camera and
movement data were analyzed using Anymaze software (Stoelting, Wood Dale,
Illinois, USA). This task was performed to assess anxiety-like behaviors on Day
1 and locomotor activity on Day 2 in the offspring mice.Elevated plus maze (EPM): Offspring mice were tested on a
plastic Elevated Plus Maze approximately two feet above the ground, consisting
of two, 36 cm long closed arms with 20 cm tall walls and two open arms without
any walls for 5 minutes on a single day. The amount of time spent in each type
of arm, in entries into the closed and open arms, and the center of the maze
were video-recorded using Anymaze software. The ratio of time in the open to the
closed arms was calculated for each individual. This test was performed to
evaluate the anxiety-like behaviors in the offspring mice.Social approach: In a three-chamber sociability and social
recognition apparatus, offspring mice were tested for sociability and social
recognition on a single day. The clear, plastic apparatus consisted of three,
equally-sized 20 x 40 x 22 cm chambers with two 5 x 8 cm doors allowing access
to all three chambers. The left- and right-side chambers contained a single 9 cm
diameter, 10 cm tall wire cup. The social approach task consisted of three
phases. During the first phase, the doors to the other chambers were closed and,
for 10 minutes, the experimental mouse was allowed to habituate to the center
chamber.During the second phase or the “sociability” phase, a non-experimental mouse
(“mouse”) of the same age, sex, and strain was placed under the wire cup of one
of the two side chambers. During the third phase or the “social recognition”
phase, the same, non-experimental mouse (previously known as “mouse,” but
denoted the “familiar mouse” during this phase) was placed under the wire cup of
the opposite chamber and another mouse (“novel mouse”) of the same age, sex, and
strain was placed under the wire cup of the other chamber. Each phase lasted for
10 minutes and the movements of the experiment mouse across all three chambers
were video-recorded by Anymaze software. The amount of time spent in close
proximity to the original “stranger mouse cup” or “empty cup” and the “novel
mouse cup” or “familiar mouse cup” were recorded and statistically analyzed.
Social approach task was performed to examine both general sociability and
recognition of social novelty. Sociability index was calculated as: time with
stranger/total time in close proximity to either stranger mouse or empty cup.
Social Recognition index was calculated as: time with novel mouse/total time in
close proximity to either novel or familiar mouse cups.Prepulse inhibition: Mice were place into a Plexiglas cylinder
and secured onto the platform in a lighted, soundproof chamber, the SR-LAB
startle apparatus. A piezoelectric accelerometer measured and recorded the
startle reflex response. A loudspeaker mounted within the chambers generated the
startling acoustic stimuli as well as the ambient, 70-dB white background noise.
The sessions began with a 5-minute habituation period and then proceeds with 90
different trials broken up over three blocks over the course of a single day.
The first block consisted of five 20msec 120 dB pulse alone (no prepulse)
trials. The second block consisted of 10 randomized trials of pulse alone, 5 dB,
10 dB, and 15 dB prepulses before the 120dB pulse. The third block consisted of
a final block of five consecutive pulse-alone trials. Deficits in sensorimotor
gating were assessed by calculating the prepulse inhibition percentage (PPI%,
calculated as: 100 x [startle reflex from acoustic pulse alone – startle reflex
from prepulse-elicited stimulus (5, 10, or 15 dB)] / startle reflex from
acoustic pulse alone).
Immunohistochemistry
Brain tissue from the GAD67GFP+/- offspring adult offspring mice from behavioral
testing were used for immunohistochemistry. Sample sizes ranged from two to five
animals from each condition and sex across at least two litters and typically
representing all three litters per condition. Four weeks after the final day of
behavioral testing, to avoid effects of testing stress, brains were collected
for examination. Adult offspring mice were perfused first with cold PBS and then
with 4% paraformaldehyde. Brains were collected from male and female mice and
placed directly into 4% paraformaldehyde. After overnight paraformaldehyde
incubation, brains were rinsed in PBS and transferred to 20% sucrose for at
least 20 hours. Brains were embedded in optimal cutting temperature compound,
coronally cryosectioned at 50 μm, and then incubated in 10% goat serum/PBS++
blocking solution (with 0.025% Triton X-100, 0.0125% Tween 20) at room
temperature for at least 1 hour. Immunohistochemistry was performed with 5% goat
serum/PBS++ and primary antibodies, anti-Iba1 (1:500, WAKO; #019-19741), anti-PV
(1:1000, Sigma Aldrich; SAB4200545) and anti-GFP (1:1000, Abcam, AB13970), and
allowed to incubate overnight. Sections were stained with the Alexa
dye-conjugated secondary antibody (1:500–1000; Molecular Probes) in 5% goat
serum/PBS++ incubation for 2 hours. Tissue section slides were then cover
slipped using DAPI mounting medium (Vector Laboratories, #H-1200).
Cell Counting
Stereological estimates of total cortical densities of Iba1+ microglia and
hippocampal cornus ammonis (hippocampus) and medial frontal cortex (mFC)
densities of GAD67GFP+ cells and PV+ cells were calculated using an optical
fractionator approach and unbiased counting rules with 3-dimensional counting
frames: 150 × 100 × 10 μm counting frames, on a 1000 x 600 μm grid for total
neocortex, 450 × 450 μm grid for mFC and 600 x 600 μm grid for hippocampus,
using a 40× objective lens (Stereoinvestigator; MBF Biosciences, Williston, VT,
USA). Stereological counting to determine cell density, displayed as means and
standard errors of the mean, was performed in 3 to 8 serial coronal sections
(every 20th section of the neocortex; every 10th section of the mFC and
hippocampus) as previously described [41,44,63]. Microglia morphologies were defined as: amoeboid
(those with zero to one process), lowly ramified (those with two or three
processes) which may reflect an activated state, moderately ramified (those with
four processes or those with multiple thin, spindly processes and a small soma),
and highly ramified (those with five or more processes and a large soma, also
referred to as bushy microglia) which may reflect a primed state. Iba1+,
GAD67GFP+, and PV+ cells in coronal tissue sections was counted using
fluorescent microscopy with a Zeiss Axiolmager M2 microscope.
Data Analysis
A priori two-tailed student’s t-tests were used in each
assessment to first detect any baseline differences between the control
non-stressed and control prenatal stress groups (non-stressed PBS vs.
prenatally-stressed PBS). For prepulse inhibition data, a
priori ANOVA across intensities was used. Two-way ANOVAs were also
used to evaluate the effects of prenatal stress and each antioxidant
manipulation independently for each assessment, looking for main effects and
interactions that would indicate the ability of each antioxidant treatment
manipulation to significantly modify effects of prenatal stress. When
appropriate, post-hoc Bonferroni tests were performed to
determine specific group differences, correcting for multiple comparisons.
Because of the relatively small sample sizes of some of the groups, trending
significant values of p≤0.07 were reported to avoid type II
error.
Results
Cortical Microglia Populations
A shift in cortical microglia morphology with prenatal stress in male offspring
has been previously shown [38,41]. Here, prenatal stress led to this same
effect in both male and female offspring (Figure
1a-h). In males, percent of amoeboid and lowly ramified microglial
morphologies were reduced by prenatal stress and highly ramified microglia
morphology was increased in the neocortex (Figure
1a, c, g, a priori t-tests: lowly ramified
p<0.05; highly ramified p=0.06; ANOVA
stress main effects: amoeboid across PBS and NAC F[1,12]=10.00,
p=0.008, lowly ramified across PBS and NAC F[1,12]=15.18,
p=0.002 and PBS and AST F[1,12]=9.141,
p=0.0106; highly ramified across PBS and NAC F[1,12]=9.383,
p=0.0098 and PBS and AST F[1,12]=7.673,
p=0.017). The reduced percent of lowly ramified microglia with
prenatal stress in males was prevented by NAC (Figure 1c, ANOVA interaction: F[1,12]=6.284,
p=0.0276).
Figure 1
Prenatal stress decreased lowly ramified and increased highly ramified
cortical microglia, prevented by antioxidants. Prenatal stress (PS)
compared to non-stressed (NS) condition reduced amoeboid microglia in male
(a) and female (b) mice (ANOVA main effects across
PBS and NAC male groups αα p<0.01 and across PBS and AST
female groups α p<0.05). AST trend increased female amoeboid
microglia (ANOVA main effect of AST # p=0.05). Prenatal stress
and AST interacted to in effects on female amoeboid microglia (&&
p<0.01 two-way ANOVA), demonstrating AST prevention from
of stress effects (post-hoc test * p<0.05).
Prenatal stress also reduced lowly ramified microglia in male (c)
and female (d) mice (a priori t-tests *
p<0.05 in males, ** p<0.01 in
females; ANOVA main effects across PBS and NAC or AST groups: α
p< 0.05, αα p<0.01, ααα
p<0.001) with prevention by NAC for males (ANOVA
interaction & p<0.05) and AST and NAC for females (ANOVA
interactions &&& p<0.001,
post-hoc tests *** p<0.05). NAC and AST
both increased lowly ramified microglia (ANOVA main effects for NAT and AST ###
p<0.001). No effects on moderately ramified microglia
were found in males (e) or females (f). Highly
ramified microglia were increased by prenatal stress in males (g)
and females (h) (a priori t-tests males
p=0.06; females: ** p<0.01: ANOVA main
effects across PBS and NAC or AST groups: α p<0.05, αα
p<0.01, ααα p<0.001). NAC and AST
prevented this effect in females (ANOVA interaction of prenatal stress NAC or
AST ααα p<0.001; post-hoc tests ***
p<0.001). NAC and AST both reduced highly ramified
microglia (ANOVA main effect of NAC or AST, ### p<0.001).
Means and Standard errors of the mean are displayed.
In females, the neocortical percentages of lowly ramified microglia was also
decreased and highly ramified increased by prenatal stress (Figure 1b, d, a priori t-test: lowly
ramified p=0.0019, high ramified p=0.0074;
ANOVA stress main effects: lowly ramified across PBS and NAC F[1,10]=20.60,
p=0.0011 and across PBS and AST F[1,13]=67.91,
p<0.0001, high ramified across PBS and NAC
F[1,10]=13.72, p=0.0004 and across PBS and AST F[1,13]=25.65,
p=0.0002). All prenatal stress effects on microglial
morphology in female offspring were prevented by NAC or AST (Figure 1b, d, f, h, ANOVA stress interactions with NAC
lowly F[1,10]=29.92, p=0.0003, post-hoc PBS PS
vs NAC PS p=0.003, highly F[1,10]=27.47,
p=0.0003, post-hoc PBS PS vs NAC PS
p=0.005; AST amoeboid F[1,13]=11.43,
p=0.0049, post-hoc PBS PS vs AST PS
p=0.016, lowly F[1,13]=36.89, p<0.0001,
post-hoc PBS PS vs AST PS p,0.0001, highly
F[1,13]=27.32, p=0.0002, post-hoc PBS PS vs
AST PS p<0.0001). Total cortical microglia density was not
affected in males or females by stress, NAC, or AST (data not shown).
Medial Frontal Cortical GABAergic Populations
A larger proportion of parvalbumin (PV) subtype of GABAergic interneurons has
been found in medial frontal cortex (mFC) of prenatally-stressed male offspring
[63]. Here, prenatal stress did not
show this effect in male offspring mFC a priori, but when the
effect of prenatal stress was assessed across both PBS and AST groups, this same
effect was found (Figure 2a, ANOVA main
effect: F[1,13]=9.13, p=0.009). Furthermore, there was an
interaction between the effects of prenatal stress and NAC administration on
PV+/GAD67+ cell ratio in mFC (F[1,13]= .84, p=0.01); NAC
prevented the increase of the PV subtype. Prenatal stress in PBS exposed mothers
resulted in an increased male offspring ratio of PV+/GAD67+, but in NAC exposed
mothers, decreased the PV+/GAD67+ cell ratio in the male offspring mFC (Figure 2a). Antioxidants overall decreased
the ratio of PV+/GAD67+ cells in the mFC compared to PBS (NAC: F[1,13]=18.89,
p=0.002 and AST: F[1,13]=4.71, p=0.04),
suggesting prenatal redox down-regulation reduced maturation of cortical
interneurons into this subtype in male offspring. This may have been affected by
a trend increased density of total GAD67+ cells with AST (F[1,14]=3.92,
p=0.07, Figure 2c) and
a trend decreased density of PV+ cells with NAC (F[1,13]=4.62,
p=0.05, Figure
2e).
Figure 2
Prenatal stress increased the PV+/GAD67+ cell ratio in mFC in male offspring and
decreased this ratio in females. NAC and AST prevented these impacts in males
and females respectively. (a) Prenatally-stressed (PS) compared to
non-stressed (NS) male mice had a higher ratio of PV+/GAD67+ cells in the mFC
(αα p<0.01 main stress effect by two-way ANOVA across PBS
and AST groups). A prenatal stress by NAC interaction was found in PV+/GAD67+
cells (& p<0.05 by two-way ANOVA). A
post-hoc test revealed a significant decrease in PV+/GAD67+
proportion between the PS PBS and the PS NAC mice (*
p<0.05). NAC and AST decreased the ratio of PV+/GAD67+ cells
in the mFC compared to PBS (## p<0.01 and #
p<0.05 by two-way ANOVA, respectively). (b)
A priori t-test found that PS PBS female mice had a lower
ratio of PV+/GAD67+ cells in the mFC ($$ p<0.01 by t-test).
Prenatal stress led to lower ratios of PV+/GAD67+ cells in female mice as
revealed by a main effect of stress (α p<0.05 by two-way
ANOVA across PBS and NAC groups). An interaction between the effects of prenatal
stress and maternal AST treatments on the ratio of PV+/GAD67+ cells (&
p<0.05) suggests that AST prevented this impact of
prenatal stress. (c) AST males had trend higher densities of GAD67+
cells in the mFC than PBS males (trend sig., p=0.07 by two-way
ANOVA). (d) An interaction of NAC treatment and prenatal stress was
found for female mPFC GAD67+ density (& p<0.05 by
two-way ANOVA). (e) NAC-treated offspring had lower densities of
PV+ cells compared to PBS offspring (trend sig., p=0.05 by
two-way ANOVA). (f) A priori t-test found that PS
PBS female mice had a lower density of PV+ cells in the mFC (**
p<0.01 by t-test). Interactions of NAC and AST with
prenatal stress effects on PV+ cells were observed (&
p<0.05, respectively), suggesting that these antioxidants
prevented the effect of prenatal stress. Means and Standard errors of the mean
are displayed.
In female offspring, prenatal stress induced the opposite effect, decreasing the
PV+/GAD67+ cell ratio in the mFC (a priori t-test:
p=0.005, ANOVA main effect across PBS and NAC:
F[1,10]=8.46, p=0.01; Figure
2d). AST administration interacted with prenatal stress (ANOVA:
F[1,12]=6.40, p=0.03), suggesting prevention of the prenatal
stress effect. These effects in females were mainly due to altered PV+ cell
densities in the mFC (Figure 2f). A
priori t-test showed that prenatal stress reduced PV+ cells in the
mFC (p=0.009, Figure 2f).
Interactions of NAC and AST with prenatal stress effects on PV+ cell density was
observed (NAC: F[1,10]=7.25, p=0.02, and AST: F[1,13]=7.30,
p=0.02) suggesting that the decrease with stress did not
occur when prenatal antioxidants buffered oxidative stress. An interaction of
NAC treatment and prenatal stress was also found for GAD67+ total density
(F[1,10]=6.28), p=0.03, Figure 2d).
Hippocampal GABAergic Populations
No difference was found in male offspring hippocampal PV+/GAD67+ cell proportion
due to prenatal stress by a priori assessment or analysis
across groups (Figure 3a). NAC groups, but
not AST groups, decreased the PV+-to-GAD67+ cell ratio in the male hippocampus
(F[1,10]=6.28, p=0.03) similar to its effects in the mFC.
Prenatal stress decreased GAD67+ cell density (a priori t-test:
p=0.07; ANOVA main effect across PBS and NAC:
F[1,14]=11.43, p=0.008, Figure
3c). AST and prenatal stress interacted (F[1,15]=5.01,
p=0.04) to show that the decrease of hippocampal GAD67+
cell density with prenatal stress trend returned to the non-stressed level
(post-hoc, trend sig., p=0.07). No
differences in PV+ cell densities were detected in the hippocampal CA between
any of the groups of male offspring (Figure
3e).
Figure 3
Prenatal stress also decreased PV+/GAD67+ ratio in female hippocampus, prevented
by NAC. (a) No baseline differences were detected in
prenatal stress (PS) PBS and non-stressed (NS) PBS male offspring PV+/GAD67+
cell proportion and no main effect of prenatal stress was found. Maternal
treatments of NAC decreased the PV+-to-GAD67+ cell ratios in the male
hippocampal CA (# p<0.05 by two-way ANOVA). (b)
A priori t-test found that PS PBS females had a lower
proportion of PV+/GAD67+ cells in the hippocampal CA compared to NS PBS female
mice (** p<0.01 by t-test). Prenatal stress led to lower
PV+/GAD67+ cell ratios in female mice as revealed by a main effect of stress (αα
p<0.01 by two-way ANOVA). An interaction of prenatal
stress effects and maternal treatment of NAC (& p<0.05
by two-way ANOVA) revealed that effects of prenatal stress on the PV+/GAD67+
ratio was prevented by NAC. AST did not prevent the effects of prenatal stress
and PS AST mice had significantly lower PV+/GAD67+ ratios compared to NS AST
mice (& p<0.05). (c) A
priori t-test showed that PS PBS male mice had a trend lower GAD67+
cell density than NS PBS mice (trend sig., p=0.07). Prenatal
stress led to lower GAD67+ cell densities in male mice as revealed by a main
effect of stress (αα p<0.01 by two-way ANOVA across PBD and
NAC groups). An interaction of prenatal stress effects and maternal treatment of
AST (& p<0.05 by two-way ANOVA) revealed that AST
prevented the effect of prenatal stress on GAD67+ density in hippocampus.
Post-hoc tests revealed a trend increase in GAD67+ cell
density in PS AST hippocampus compared to PS PBS hippocampus (trend sig.,
p=0.07). (d) No baseline differences in the
densities of GAD67+ cells in control (PBS) female mice and no main effects of
stress were found. (e) No differences in PV+ cell densities were
detected in the hippocampus between any of the groups of male offspring mice.
(f) A priori t-test found that PS PBS female
mice had a trend lower proportion of PV+ cells in the hippocampal CA (trend
sig., p=0.06). AST-treated offspring mice had PV+ cell
densities similar to the NS PBS and PS PBS mice, revealing a main effect of
prenatal stress (αα p<0.01 by two-way ANOVA). AST did not
rescue the effects of prenatal stress and PS AST mice had significantly lower
densities of PV+ cells compared to NS AST mice as revealed by a
post-hoc test (& p<0.05). Means and
Standard errors of the mean are displayed.
In female offspring, prenatal stress decreased the PV+/GAD67+ cell ratio in the
hippocampus as in the mPFC (a priori t-test:
p=0.04; ANOVA main effect across PBS and AST: F[1,12]=23.08,
p=0.001, Figure 3b).
NAC interacted with prenatal stress effects (F[1,10]=8.13,
p=0.04) suggesting prevention of this effect by NAC. While
there were no differences in GAD67+ cell density, prenatal-stress reduced PV+
cell density in the hippocampus (a priori t-test: trend sig.,
p=0.06; ANOVA main effect across PBS and AST:
F[1,12]=14.77, p=0.008; Figure
3f), suggesting that prenatal stress impaired parvalbumin cell
maturation in females.
Anxiety-like Behavior
We found generally that prenatal stress increased anxiety-like behavior in
offspring. PS PBS male mice compared to NS PBS controls had decreased ratio of
open:closed arm time of the EPM, suggesting an anxiety-like phenotype (a
priori t-test p=0.03, Figure 4a). Prenatal stress decreased ratio of
open:closed arm time across both PBS and NAC groups, demonstrating that NAC
manipulation did not return anxiety-like behavior to normal levels (ANOVA time
ratio across PBS and NAC: F[1,44]=4.45, p=0.04; Figure 4a). Similar outcomes were shown for male
offspring in closed arm time (a priori t-test
p=0.048; ANOVA main effect across PBS and NAC:
F[1,44]=8.18, p=0.006. Data not shown). The ratio of open to
closed arm entries also demonstrated an effect of stress (Figure 4c, ANOVA main effect of stress across PBS and
NAC: F[1,44]=5.55, p=0.02). This main effect of stress was not
found across AST groups, but no interactions for AST and stress were present to
address moderation of effect either. No differences were found in open arm time
or entries for male offspring (data not shown).
Figure 4
Prenatal stress increased anxiety-like behavior on the EPM. (a)
A priori difference of prenatal stress (PS) versus
non-stressed (NS) condition in the PBS groups (* t-test
p<0.05) and main effect of stress in the ratio of time spent
in the open arm to the closed arm of the EPM (α p<0.05 by
two-way ANOVA across PBS and NAC groups). (b) Prenatally-stressed
females had lower open to closed arm time ratio, an anxious-like phenotype (α
p<0.05 by two-way ANOVA across PBS and AST groups).
(c) A main effect of stress was found in the ratio of
open:closed arm entries in male mice (α p<0.05 by two-way
ANOVA across PBS and NAC groups). (d) A priori
t-test found that PS PBS female mice had a lower open:closed arm entry ratio,
also an anxious-like phenotype (* p<0.05).
Prenatally-stressed mice had fewer open:closed arm entries compared to
non-stressed female mice (main effects of PBS groups with NAC groups: αα
p<0.01 and AST groups: α p<0.05 by
two-way ANOVAs). (e) No prenatal stress baseline differences or
main effects of stress in male offspring were found, but NAC and
AST increased time in the center of the open field (##
p<0.01 and # p<0.05, respectively by
two-way ANOVA and post-hoc * p<0.05
compared to PS PBS). (f) No differences due to prenatal stress or antioxidant
administration in female offspring were found. (g) A trend interaction of AST
and prenatal stress effects was found (trend sig., & p=0.06
by two-way ANOVA), suggesting AST may affect locomotor activity differently
depending on whether the mouse experienced prenatal stress. (h) No
baseline differences were detected in PS PBS and NS PBS female mice and no main
effects of prenatal stress were found. An interaction of NAC with prenatal
stress effects was revealed (&& p<0.01 by two-way
ANOVA). NS NAC female mice exhibited increased locomotor activity compared to PS
NAC (post-hoc * p<0.05). Means and Standard
errors of the mean are displayed.
For females, prenatal stress produced an anxiety-like phenotype in the ratio of
open to closed arm time (Figure 4b, ANPVA
main effect of stress across PBS and AST: F[1,41]=4.92,
p=0.03). There were no differences in open or closed arm time
themselves (data not shown). Ratio of open to closed arm entries also indicated
anxiety-like behavior by both a priori assessment and
comparisons across multiple groups (Figure
4d, t-test p=0.04, ANOVA main effects of stress
across PBS and NAC: F[1,41]= 6.36, p=0.02; and across PBS and
AST: F[1,39]=4.87, p=0.03).Another anxiety-like behavior measure was made examining time in the center of
the open field in the first 5 minutes on the first day (Figure 4e, f). No difference was detected between
prenatally-stressed and non-stressed PBS male or female mice based on the
a priori t-test, and no main effects of prenatal stress
were found (Figure 4e, f). Neither NAC nor
AST had significant effects on this anxiety-like measure in females (Figure 4f), but both maternal antioxidants,
NAC and AST, reduced anxiety-like behavior in males overall (increased center
time, ANOVA for NAC: F[1,41]=9.44, p=0.004; AST: F[1,40]=5.57,
p=0.02, post-hoc PBS PS vs AST PS
p=0.04; Figure 4e),
suggesting an impact of prenatal redox changes in affecting later anxiety-like
behavior.
Locomotor Activity
Movement in the open field on the second day was used to assess locomotor
activity in offspring. With a priori t-tests, no baseline
differences were detected in prenatally-stressed and non-stressed control (PBS)
male or female offspring, and no overall effect of prenatal stress across groups
was found (Figure 4g, h). However, in
males, AST administration and prenatal stress had a trend interaction (trend
sig., F[1,41]=3.61, p=0.06, Figure 4g), suggesting that prenatal AST specifically increased male
locomotor activity when combined with prenatal stress exposure.In females, NAC administration and prenatal stress interacted (F[1,41]=8.57,
p=0.006, Figure 4h),
showing that prenatal NAC increased locomotor activity in non-stressed female
mice (post-hoc, p=0.003).No differences were found across groups in adult body weight for male or female
offspring (data not shown).
Sociability
Prenatal stress did not reduce sociability in male offspring by sociability
index, total time spent with a stranger mouse by a priori
tests, or comparisons across group (Figure 5a, c). Prenatally-stressed male
offspring in both PBS and NAC groups spent less time with the empty cup (ANOVA
main effect of stress across PBS and NAC: F[1,43]=5.72, p=0.02;
Figure 5a).
Figure 5
Sociability but not social recognition was reduced by prenatal stress in female
mice. (a) No male differences in time spent in proximity to the
mouse cup. (b) Prenatally-stressed (PS) compared to non-stressed
(NS) male mice spent less time with the empty cup compared to non-stress mice (α
p<0.05 by two-way ANOVA comparing across PBS and NAC
groups). (c) No male differences in the ratio of time spent with
the mouse cup to time spent with the empty cup. (d) There were no
differences in the time with the mouse cup across female offspring groups.
(e) Interactions of prenatal stress with NAC and AST show that
impacts of prenatal stress on empty cup time are reversed by NAC and AST (&
p<0.05 by two-way ANOVAs). (f) A
priori difference was found in the ratio of time spent with the
mouse cup to the empty cup by prenatal stress (* p<0.05) but
no other differences across groups. (g) No prenatal stress baseline
differences or main effects of stress in male offspring behavior were found for
time spent with novel mouse, (h) time spent with the familiar
mouse, or (in) time with novel:familiar mouse. (j)
While no prenatal stress baseline differences or main effects of stress in
female offspring were observed in time spent with the novel or (k)
familiar mouse, NAC trend interacted with stress for effects on time with novel
mouse (& p=0.06 trend interaction by ANOVA) and
maternally-treated AST female mice spent less time with the familiar mice (#
p<0.05 by two-way ANOVA). (l) ratio of time
spent with novel:familiar in female offspring mice trended high with AST. Means
and Standard errors of the mean are displayed.
Female prenatally-stressed offspring did have lower sociability by a
priori comparison of the sociability index similar to previous
findings in males (Figure 5f) [63]. Across PBS and AST groups, time spent
with a stranger mouse trended lower with prenatal stress (ANOVA main effect:
F[1,42]=3.96, p=0.065; Figure
5e). NAC and AST also impacted time females spent with the empty cup,
shown by an interaction of NAC or AST with prenatal stress (ANOVA: NAC
F[1,41]=6.76, p=0.01 and AST F[1,42]=5.84,
p=0.02, Figure 5e). Empty
cup time is an important factor in calculating the sociability index, but
antioxidants did not statistically interact with prenatal stress on the index
itself (Figure 5f) so the reduced female
sociability deficit was not sufficiently affected by antioxidants to show
prevention.
Social Recognition
No differences in social recognition were found due to prenatal stress in male or
female offspring by a priori comparisons or main effect across
groups (Figure 5g-l). This was evident in the lack of differences found across
groups in recognition indices or time spent with novel stranger mice. Of note,
female offspring showed a trend interaction of NAC with stress on time with the
novel stranger (Figure 5j, ANOVA:
F[1,41]=4.0, p=0.06) and those exposed to AST spent less time
with the familiar stranger (Figure 5k, l,
familiar cup ANOVA: F[1,42]=5.81, p=0.02), but antioxidants did
not affect male social recognition in any way.
Sensorimotor Gating
No baseline differences in startle response in males or females were found across
groups (Figure 6a, b). Male PBS offspring
showed reduced pre-pulse inhibition (PPI) across all intensities by prenatal
stress with a priori ANOVA (F[1,62]=4.77,
p=0.03, Figure 6c). AST,
but not NAC, interacted with prenatal stress effects on PPI in males at all
intensities showing prevention of stress effects (ANOVAs: 5 dB: F[1,42]=4.64,
p=0.04; 10 dB: F[1, 40]=8.20, p=0.007; 15
dB: F[1,41]=8.80, p=0.005; post-hoc PBS PS vs
AST PS 10 dB: p=0.07). AST also showed an effect in reducing
sensorimotor gating in non-stressed males (15 dB: post-hoc PBS
NS group vs AST NS group p=0.04).
Figure 6
Prenatal stress altered sensorimotor gating in male offspring, and a trend
for AST to prevent this was found. No differences in the baseline
startle response were observed in (a) male offspring or
(b) female offspring groups. (c)
prenatally-stressed (PS) PBS male mice showed lower PPI across all three decibel
(dB) levels (α p<0.05 by two-way ANOVA). Non-stressed (NS)
AST male mice showed lower PPI across the three dB levels compared to PS AST
mice (αα p<0.01 by two-way ANOVA). At the 10 dB level, PS
AST showed trend higher sensorimotor gating compared to PS PBS male mice
(post-hoc, trend sig., p=0.07).
(d) An interaction between NAC and prenatal stress at 5 dB was
found and suggests that NAC on its own is decreased 5 dB PPI in female mice
(& p<0.05 by two-way ANOVA). At the 5 dB level, PS NAC
and PS AST showed improvements in sensorimotor gating compared to PS PBS female
mice (post-hoc, * p<0.05, respectively) and
a main effect of AST demonstrated its general improvement of PPI in female mice
(## p<0.001 by two-way ANOVA). At the 10 dB and 15 dB levels, a main effect
of NAC demonstrated its improvement of PPI (# p<0.05 by two-way ANOVA for 10
dB and 15 dB, post-hoc for 10 dB, *
p<0.05). Means and Standard errors of the mean are
displayed.
In female offspring, there was no effect of prenatal stress on PPI across or at
any specific intensity. When all groups were analyzed, AST and NAC both had an
independent effect of increasing sensorimotor gating across non-stressed and
prenatally-stressed females at some intensities (main effects: NAC 10 dB:
F[1,42]=4.27, p=0.04; NAC 15 dB: F[1,42]=4.23,
p= 0.04; AST 5 dB: F[1,41]=13.57, p=0.007;
Figure 6d). A notable specific finding
in females was significantly higher PPI in prenatally-stressed offspring with
NAC and AST at the lowest intensity (5dB NAC: ANOVA interaction F[1,42]=10.52,
p=0.002 and post-hoc, PBS PS vs NAC PS:
p=0.04 and NAC NS vs PBS PS p=0.02; PBS PS
vs AST PS: p=0.01).
Correlations of Behavior and GABAergic Populations
All results were synthesized in Table 1. Some correlations were found between mFC
and hippocampal GABAergic populations and behavior across individual animals. In
male mice, lower hippocampal GAD67+ cell density trend correlated with decreased
open field center time (R=0.36, p=0.07) as
found previously [63]. For females,
higher GAD67+ cell density in the mFC correlated with reduced open field center
time (R=-0.67, p=0.002) and trend correlated
with increased closed arm time of the EPM (R=0.41,
p=0.06). Higher female hippocampus GAD67+ cell density
correlated with greater social recognition (R=0.46,
p=0.03). Notably, GAD67+ cell density, social recognition,
EPM closed arm time and open field center time were not altered by stress or
treatment in females, but GAD67+ cell density was reduced by stress in males in
hippocampus. No correlations were found of behavioral outcomes with cortical
microglia morphology.
Table 1
Summary of Effects of Prenatal Stress and Maternal Antioxidant in CD1
Mice
Outcome
Prenatal stress effect?
Antioxidant prevention?
Other effects
Cortical Microglia
M: ↓lowly, ↑highly ramified morphologies
M: NAC prevented effects on lowly ramified microglia
M: N/A
F: ↓lowly, ↑highly ramified morphologies
F: NAC & AST prevented effects on lowly, highly ramified microglia;
AST prevented effects on amoeboid microglia
F: AST prevented both mPFC effects, NAC prevented mPFC PV effect and
Hippocampal effect
F: N/A
Anxiety-like Behavior
M: ↓open/closed ratio on EPM
M: no
M: NAC & AST ↑OF Ctr time in all males, Hippocampal GAD67 correlated
with OF Ctr time
F: ↓open/closed ratio on EPM
F: no
F: N/A
Locomotion
M: no effect
M: N/A
M: N/A
F: no effect
F: N/A
F: NAC ↑distance in NS females
Social Behavior
M: no effect
M: N/A
M: N/A
F: ↓sociability
F: no
F: N/A
Sensori-motor Gating
M: ↓PPI (5, 10, 15 dB)
M: AST trend prevented ↓ PPI
M: AST ↑PPI in PS male, AST ↓PPI in NS males
F: no effect
F: N/A
F: NAC & AST ↑PPI in PS females
M = males, F = females, NAC = N-acetylcysteine, AST = astaxanthin, mFC = medial
frontal cortex, PV = parvalbumin+ cells, GAD67 = GAD67GFP+ cells, EPM = elevated
plus maze, OF Ctr = center of the open field, PPI = pre-pulse inhibition, dB =
decibels, PS = prenatally-stressed, NS = non-stressed
Discussion
In this study, we assessed the hypothesis that effects on offspring brain and
behavior from prenatal stress are due to oxidative stress that occurs during
pregnancy. Specifically, we predicted that prenatal stress effects in male and
female mouse offspring would be prevented by the administration to pregnant dams of
either N-acetylcysteine or astaxanthin, two antioxidants with different mechanisms.
We confirmed this hypothesis for offspring cortical microglia morphology and
interneuron population effects. Female offspring had a clear increase in highly
ramified microglia morphologies after prenatal stress and both antioxidants
prevented these effects (Figure 1). Similarly,
for female medial frontal cortical interneuron populations, prenatal stress
decreased the density of the parvalbumin interneuron subtype and this effect was
prevented by either antioxidant (Figure 2).
Male neurobiological outcomes after prenatal stress and their prevention by maternal
antioxidant were also found but were less clear and less consistent (Figures 1-3).
For behavioral outcomes with relevance to neuropsychiatric disorders, the prenatal
stress effect in male offspring in decreasing sensorimotor gating, as measured
through prepulse inhibition, was the only behavioral impact prevented through
maternal antioxidant administration, specifically with N-acetylcysteine (Figure 6). Other effects on anxiety-like and
social behaviors were not prevented by either antioxidant (Figures 4,5).The dissociation we found of prenatal-stress induced neurobiological (antioxidant
prevented) and behavioral (little effect of antioxidants) outcomes in terms of their
involvement of prenatal oxidative stress is interesting. First, it is important to
acknowledge that regardless of offspring sex, we found that antioxidants had clear
impacts on offspring suggesting that both types and dosing used were biologically
relevant. We used the same dosing as in previous studies demonstrating a clear
impact on these same neurobiological domains in embryonic brain after prenatal
stress [21,40]. Interestingly, for outcomes affected by prenatal stress, we found a
trend correlation between decreased hippocampal GAD67+ cells and increased
anxiety-like behavior in male offspring, suggesting a connection that has been made
previously [47,63] and deserves continued investigation. However, results do
not generally support the hypothesis that microglia morphology and interneuron
populations underlie changes in anxiety-like, social, and sensorimotor gating
behavior. Most behavioral outcomes were not correlated with neurobiological
measures, and effects of prenatal stress on anxiety-like and social behavior
persisted despite some neurobiological protection from antioxidants. These data
suggest a few possible scenarios concerning prenatal stress mechanisms which are not
mutually exclusive: one possibility is the cellular neurobiology assessed here may
have relevance for other behavioral outcomes not assessed here and vice-versa; a
related potential implication is break-through levels of oxidative stress may have
exceeded the capacity of antioxidant effects resulting in neurobiological impacts
other than those studied here and demonstrated effects on behavior; and/or other
co-occurring mechanisms of prenatal stress effects (ie, inflammation and/or
glucocorticoid actions) may have initiated changes in offspring responsible for the
behaviors assessed here. Further investigations of the neurobiological underpinnings
of disrupted behavior after prenatal stress will be important, particularly in
relation to the role of prenatal processes in male offspring targeted by
N-acetylcysteine in establishing sensorimotor gating functions of the brain.The role of oxidative stress in prenatal stress outcomes in this study was most clear
for cortical microglia changes, converging with many lines of research showing the
importance of oxidative stress for microglia development [35,37]. Prenatal stress
results in oxidative stress in both placenta and offspring brain [21,24,69,70] which are both theoretically targets for
maternally-administered NAC and AST; NAC crosses the placenta [71] and AST’s properties suggest it has placenta transfer.
Impacts of prenatal stress on interneuron populations were not consistently
prevented by both antioxidants, but the efficacy of NAC and AST for protecting
specific outcomes suggests that distinct, non-redox aspects of these antioxidants
may have played a role, including the NMDA receptor modulatory effects of NAC and
the anti-inflammatory and mitochondrial functional impacts of AST which are
important pathways relevant to the development of neuropsychiatric disorders [57,58,64,67,68]. Either redox and
non-redox mechanisms may also have accounted for the impacts of NAC and AST on
neurobiology and behavior of control (non-stressed) offspring (Table 1).The impacts of prenatal stress on cortical microglia and their prevention by maternal
antioxidants suggests that in utero oxidative stress programs
either the embryonic microglia and/or their milieu to result in adult microglia
morphology with less activated morphologies but more bushy morphologies which may
reflect more primed cells. Interestingly, this diverges from the
traditionally-conceptualized paradigm of oxidative stress inducing more active
microglia [37], but like others who have
studied these phenomena across different developmental stages [38], this may demonstrate the complexity of microglia
development and their multiple forms. Our findings align with reports of more primed
microglia in neuropsychiatric disorders [33,34] which may be sensitive to
additional insults. Primed microglia have the capacity more quickly and to a greater
extent to activate and alter synapses and other components of their milieu critical
for neuronal control of behavior [72]. Primed
microglia may underlie behavioral changes in settings of acute stress or insults,
which is a hallmark of many neuropsychiatric disorders and could be assessed in
future studies for dependence on prenatal oxidative stress.The impacts of prenatal stress on cortical and hippocampal interneurons in general
demonstrates the vulnerability of the parvalbumin subtype to pro-oxidant states, but
also the potential for pro-oxidant disruption of development and/or function of
other GABAergic interneuron subtypes as reflected in the total GAD67+ density. While
we found no correlations of parvalbumin populations with behavior, reduced
parvalbumin cell density and proportion of total GABAergic cells in female offspring
aligns with findings in patients with ASD; hypofunction of these subsets of neurons
would be predicted to disrupt multiple ASD-relevant behaviors through altered
sensory tuning and circuit oscillation, impacting sensory discrimination and
perceptual learning [73]. Correlations
between cortical and hippocampal total GAD67+ cell density and anxiety-like behavior
in male offspring converges with other data suggesting their critical role in
behavioral inhibition through impaired fidelity of cortical information processing
or increased suppression of limbic responses [47,74]. By examining these and
other interneuron subtypes in future studies, specific neuropeptides may be
identified as targets for neuropsychiatric treatments.We examined both males and females for the effects of prenatal stress on neurobiology
and behavior and how antioxidant administration prevented these. Our study’s
conclusions and its statistical differences were limited by the small sample size.
However, some outcomes were consistent across males and females, suggesting
in utero pathways of effect not dependent on sexual dimorphism
of the placenta or early brain development. The increase in cortical microglia
ramification with prenatal stress that was prevented by NAC or AST in females was
similar to the significant microglia change in males: the decrease in lowly ramified
microglia with prenatal stress and the significant impact of NAC and AST on lowly
ramified microglia (Figure 1c). Male and female
similarity of prenatal stress effect was also found on anxiety-like behavior,
although was not prevented by antioxidants (Figure
2a-d). However, prenatal stress effects on cortical and hippocampal
interneurons diverged with offspring sex, with PV+/GAD67+ ratio decreased in females
(mainly due to decreased PV+ density, prevented by NAC and AST, Figure 2f) and increased in males (mainly due to decreased
GAD67+ density, prevented only by AST, Figure
3c). This potential for the same prenatal antioxidant to rescue distinct
impacts of prenatal stress on interneurons—either PV subtype differentiation or
total GABAergic population—suggests that common elements across males and females in
interneuron development may interact with later sex-specific divergent paths.
Effects of prenatal stress on sociability were only found in females (Figure 4f) and on sensorimotor gating (prevented by AST,
Figure 5c) were only found in males. Sex
differences are common in prenatal stress studies, although we did not find a
predominant male vulnerability for these outcomes, as in other studies [75,76].
Sex differences in neurobehavioral outcomes in prenatally-stressed adult offspring
may originate from effects of prenatal stress interacting with pubertal sexual
dimorphism or from earlier sex differences—one increasingly important origin of
neurodevelopmental abnormalities and their sex-specificity are placenta changes
[69,77,78] which represent a more
accessible target for preventive intervention targeting oxidative stress and other
effects. Targeting of only maternal and placental oxidative stress with the
nanoparticle-bound antioxidant MitoQ has demonstrated prevention of sex-specific
interneuron and anxiety-like behavior changes after prenatal stress [69].In conclusion, we observed that prenatal stress effects on cortical microglia,
cortical and hippocampal interneurons, and sensorimotor gating were preventable with
maternal antioxidants but effects on anxiety-like behavior and sociability were not.
Interestingly, early exposure to antioxidants in utero prevented
changes in adult offspring cortex microglia to atypical morphologies after prenatal
stress including a substantial increase in highly ramified cells suggestive of a
primed population. Finally, sex differences were clear in cortical and hippocampal
interneuron changes after prenatal stress; despite this, divergent male and female
neurobiological change may result from some common mechanisms due to the ability of
antioxidants to prevent effects across sexes. The relationship of these
neurobiological changes to neuropsychiatric vulnerability will be an important area
of future investigation.
Authors: Md Mamun Al-Amin; Hasan Mahmud Reza; Hasan Mahmud Saadi; Waich Mahmud; Abdirahman Adam Ibrahim; Musrura Mefta Alam; Nadia Kabir; A R M Saifullah; Sarjana Tarannum Tropa; A H M Ruhul Quddus Journal: Eur J Pharmacol Date: 2016-02-27 Impact factor: 4.432