| Literature DB >> 35368123 |
Annette W Burgess1, Georgina M Luscombe1, George Ramsey-Stewart1.
Abstract
Whole body dissection, once a long-held method of learning and teaching in anatomy medical education, has largely been replaced by cost and time-reduced methods of teaching. This paper reports on a longitudinal study of student knowledge acquisition and retention, following six annual intensive eight-week elective anatomy by whole body dissection (AWBD) courses implemented between 2010 and 2015, utilizing a modified team-based learning (TBL) pedagogy. A total of 160 students completed the intensive full-time courses. During each course, students, in groups of five or six, completed the dissection of a whole cadaver. Students were assessed by a standardized practical test involving the accurate identification of 20 different tagged anatomical structures. All students (n = 160) completed pre-course and end-course individual assessments. Seventy students were assessed again 1 month after the course ended. A further 71 students were assessed 7 months later. A marked increase in topographical relational anatomical knowledge was demonstrated. The median pre-course score was 9/20 (interquartile range 5). The median end-course score was 19/20 (IQR 2), a statistically significant increase (p < 0.001). The assessments for the 70 students reassessed 1 month after the course ended showed no significant statistical change. The assessments for the further 71 students assessed 7 months later also showed no significant statistical change. The results of this study demonstrate that AWBD, provides significant acquisition and maintenance of three-dimensional regional relational anatomical knowledge. As an elective, AWBD has a place in the medical curricula, particularly for students interested in a surgical or procedural based specialty career.Entities:
Keywords: anatomy by whole body dissection; medicine; surgery; team-based learning
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35368123 PMCID: PMC9320849 DOI: 10.1002/ca.23861
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Clin Anat ISSN: 0897-3806 Impact factor: 2.409
Anatomical regions covered each week and pre‐reading requirements from Cunningham's manual of practical anatomy (Romanes, 1986)
| Region covered | Pre‐reading requirements from Cunningham's manual of practical anatomy (Romanes, | Dissection directions |
|---|---|---|
| Week 1 | ||
| Pectoral region, breast, axilla | 1: 20–34 | Dissect #: 1–7 |
| Back and free upper limb | 1: 35–54 | Dissect #: 8–12 |
| Shoulder region, arm | 1: 54–73 | Dissect #: 13–16 |
| Flexor compart, forearm, hand | 1: 73–93 | Dissect #: 17–20 |
| Week 2 | ||
| Extensor compart, forearm, hand, osteology | 1: 93–113 | Dissect #: 21–29 |
| Osteology of thorax, walls of thorax, thoracic cavity | 2: 1–29 | Dissect #: 1–6 |
| Lungs, ant. Middle & post. Mediastinum, heart | 2: 30–5 | Dissect #: 7–13 |
| Heart (cont.), sup. Mediastinum, joints of thorax | 2: 57–82 | Dissect #: 14–24 |
| Skull, cervical vertebrae, scalp, temple, face. | 3: 1–21 | Dissect #: 1–3 |
| Week 3 | ||
| Side of neck, back of neck, anterior triangle. | 3: 21–43 | Dissect #: 4–18 |
| Cranial cavity, ant. Middle & post. Cranial fossae | 3: 43–64 | Dissect #: 19–29 |
| Deep dissect. Neck, thyroid, parathyroids, major vessels & nerves | 3: 64–86 | Dissect #: 30–34 |
| Deep dissect (cont.), prevertebral region, deep dissect face | 3: 86–104 | Dissect #: 35–43 |
| The orbit, parotid region | 3: 104–118 | Dissect #: 44–50 |
| Week 4 | ||
| Temporal and infratemp. Region, submandibular region | 3: 118–135 | Dissect #: 51–62 |
| Mouth & pharynx, cavity of nose | 3: 135–157 | Dissect #: 63–72 |
| Larynx, tongue, hearing and equilibration | 3: 157–183 | Dissect #: 73–85 |
| Eyeball, vertebral canal, joints of neck | 3: 183–206 | Dissect #: 86–98 |
| Week 5 | ||
| Hip, front of thigh | 1: 123–136 | Dissect #: 1–4 |
| Deep dissect front of thigh, femoral triangle, adductor canal | 1: 137–150 | Dissect #: 5–11 |
| Gluteal region, popliteal fossa | 1: 151–165 | Dissect #: 12–19 |
| Back of thigh, hip joint, osteology of leg & foot | 1: 165–181 | Dissect #: 20–23 |
| Week 6 | ||
| Front of leg, dorsum of foot, lateral side & back of leg | 1: 181–196 | Dissect #: 24–31 |
| Back of leg (cont.), sole of foot (layers 1–6) | 1: 197–214 | Dissect #: 32–40 |
| Joints of lower limb | 1: 214–234 | Dissect #: 41–52 |
| Osteology of abdo., abdominal wall, inguinal region | 2: 83–104 | Dissect #: 1–6 |
| Male external genitalia, loin, abdominal cavity, omental bursae |
2: 104–124 | Dissect #: 7–17 |
| Week 7 | ||
| Lesser omentum, spleen, coeliac trunk, stomach, mesentery, small bowel |
2: 124–141 | Dissect #: 18–25 |
| Large bowel, duodenum, pancreas & portal venous system | 2: 141–155 | Dissect #: 26–33 |
| Liver, coeliac plexus, suprarenals, kidneys & abdominal ureters | 2: 155–172 | Dissect #: 34–42 |
| Diaphragm, post. Abdom. wall, IVC, aorta, nerves of post. Abdom. wall | 2: 172–186 | Dissect #: 43–47 |
| Osteology & ligaments of lesser pelvis, male & female perineum | 2: 187–202 | Dissect #: 1–4 |
| Week 8 | ||
| Anal & urogenital regions, pelvic viscera, ureters & bladder | 2: 202–219 | Dissect #: 5–16 |
| Prostate & male urethra, uterus & female urethra, rectum & anal canal | 2: 219–232 | Dissect #: 17–19 |
| Vessels, nerves, lymphatics, muscles & joints of pelvis | 2: 232–244 | Dissect #: 20–24 |
Test examples
|
Accurately name the following tagged anatomical structures
A…Left tibialis anterior tendon B…Left common peroneal nerve C…Left popliteal vein D…Right profunda femoris artery E…Right pudendal nerve
A…Portal vein B…Left gastric artery C…Left ureter D…Falciform ligament E…Right gonadal vein
A…Left superior thyroid artery B…Left lingual nerve C…Left maxillary artery D…Right vagus nerve E…Left phrenic nerve
A…Left flexor carpi radialis tendon B…Recurrent branch of left median nerve C…Right flexor pollicis longus tendon D…Right median nerve E…Right radial nerve
Accurately name the following tagged anatomical structures
A…Right radial nerve B…Right pectoralis minor muscle C…Right radial artery D…Right flexor digitorum profundus tendon to digit five E…Right biceps brachii tendon and bicipital aponeurosis
A…Left hypoglossal nerve B…Right recurrent laryngeal nerve C…Marginal mandibular branch of left facial nerve D…Left phrenic nerve E…Right Inferior thyroid artery
A…Left obturator internus tendon with superior and inferior gemelli B…Left pudendal nerve C…Left semimembranosus muscle D…Left peroneus longus muscle E…Left sural nerve
A…Common hepatic duct B…Left gastric artery C…Superior mesenteric artery D…Inferior mesenteric vein E…Neck of the pancreas |
FIGURE 1(a) shows the cumulative marks of 160 students at the pre‐course assessments for the six dissection courses. (b) shows the marks of the same 160 students at the end‐course assessments. The difference is statistically highly significant (n = 160, z = −10.98, p < 0.001, Wilcoxon signed ranks test)
FIGURE 2(a) shows the matched end‐course assessments for the same 70 students. (b) shows the marks of the 70 students at the one‐month post‐course assessments. There is no statistically significant difference between the two assessments (n = 70, z = −0.94, p = 0.35, Wilcoxon signed ranks test)
FIGURE 3(a) shows the matched end‐course assessments for the same 71 students. (b) shows the marks of 71 students at the seven‐months postcourse assessments. There is no statistically significant difference between the two assessments (n = 71, z = −1.85, p = 0.06, Wilcoxon signed ranks test)