| Literature DB >> 35350735 |
Lívia Balogh1, Attila J Pulay1, János M Réthelyi1.
Abstract
Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is a neurodevelopmental disorder with a childhood prevalence of 5%. In about two-thirds of the cases, ADHD symptoms persist into adulthood and often cause significant functional impairment. Based on the results of family and twin studies, the estimated heritability of ADHD approximates 80%, suggests a significant genetic component in the etiological background of the disorder; however, the potential genetic effects on disease risk, symptom severity, and persistence are unclear. This article provides a brief review of the genome-wide and candidate gene association studies with a focus on the clinical aspects, summarizing findings of ADHD disease risk, ADHD core symptoms as dimensional traits, and other traits frequently associated with ADHD, which may contribute to the susceptibility to other comorbid psychiatric disorders. Furthermore, neuropsychological impairment and measures from neuroimaging and electrophysiological paradigms, emerging as potential biomarkers, also provide a prominent target for molecular genetic studies, since they lie in the pathway from genes to behavior; therefore, they can contribute to the understanding of the underlying neurobiological mechanisms and the interindividual heterogeneity of clinical symptoms. Beyond the aforementioned aspects, throughout the review, we also give a brief summary of the genetic results, including polygenic risk scores that can potentially predict individual response to different treatment options and may offer a possibility for personalized treatment for the therapy of ADHD in the future.Entities:
Keywords: attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD); comorbidity; endophenotype; genetics; neurodevelopment; polygenic risk score (PRS); psychiatry
Year: 2022 PMID: 35350735 PMCID: PMC8957927 DOI: 10.3389/fpsyg.2022.751041
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Front Psychol ISSN: 1664-1078
Association of VNTR polymorphisms in candidate genes DRD4 and DAT1 with various ADHD-related neuropsychological, eletrophysiological and neuroimaging measures emerging as putative endophenotypes.
| Imaging modality | Putative endophenotypes | References | |
|
|
| ||
| Neuropsychological test | Cognitive endophenotype studies found an association between DRD4 7R allele and processing speed, cognitive impulsiveness and attention shift, while the absence of the 7R allele was linked to high reaction time variability. No association found with the behavioral indicators of response inhibition. | Contradicting results. The most evidence has been found in relation to response inhibition, verbal and visuospatial working memory, executive functions and sustained attention. 10R allele showed a positive association with higher commission error and reaction time variability on CPT and SART tests. | |
| Electrophysiology: event related potential (ERP) parameters | Children carrying the risk allele demonstrated lower Cue-P300 and contingent negative variation (CNV) event-related potential amplitudes suggesting a possible specific effect on attentional orienting and response preparation processes. | Reduced NoGo anteriorization (NGA) in Go/No-Go task (indicating impaired cognitive response control) in adult ADHD 9R carriers. Decreased error positivity (Pe) amplitude and feedback anticipatory negativity (SPN) in feedback-based learning task in children 10R/10R -carriers vs. 9R carriers. | |
| Electrophysiology: quantitative EEG measures | Inreased frontal theta power and decreased global beta power in children 7R carriers. Adult 7R carriers (parents): similar beta2 power in ‘eyes closed’ condition, but decreased beta2 power in ‘eyes open’ and CPT conditions. | Medication-related EEG changes (single dose of 10mg methylphenidate) of increased central and parietal beta power, and decreased right frontal theta power and lower theta/beta ratios in children 10R/10R carriers vs. 9R carriers (in sustained attention task). | |
| Structural brain imaging | Decreased cortical volume in DLPFC. (Decreased superior frontal and cerebellar cortex volumes associated with the 7R allele in ADHD were described in adult patients.) An emerging hypothesis from a longitudinal study is that carrying the 7R allele may be associated with cortical development. | Smaller nucleus caudatus volume in 10R/10R homozygous children compared to 9R/10R heterozygotes. Enlarged striatal volume in adults carrying 9-6 haplotype (risk haplotype for adults). | |
| Functional braing imaging | DRD4 VNTR may play a role in the development of white matter connectivity as well. | Decreased dorsal striatum (nucleus caudatus) activity described in adolescent ADHD patients in a reward processing paradigm. Increased activity in frontal, medial, and parietal regions, in left striatum, and right dorsal premotor cortex compared to 9R carriers in Go/No-Go task (in children and adolescent samples). | |
Summary of the pharmacogenetic studies assessing the most extensively investigated candidate genes and/or using genome-wide method in ADHD patients on methylphenidate and atomoxetine treatment.
| Medication | Results of candidate genes studies | Results of GWAS studies | ||
| Gene | Polymorhism(s) | Association between the genotype and drug response | ||
| Methylphenidate | DAT1 | 3’ UTR 40bp VNTR | Conflicting results. Reduced efficacy for 10R homozygotes: | No genome-wide significant hits identified on methylphenidate response: |
| Intron 8 VNTR | Lack of 6R homozygosity associated with faster MPH response over time: | |||
| DRD4 | Exon 3 48bp VNTR | Homozygous 4 repeat genotype associated with improved MPH response. No association between 7R genotype and MPH response: | ADHD PRS associated with higher symptom improvement following stimulant treatment: | |
| 120bp promoter duplication | Decreased response with homozygous short allele promoter duplication: | No correlation between 23 genes identified as targets of methylphenidate and ADHD GWAS gene-level summary statistics. Within the loci associated with ADHD 5 druggable genes encode proteins interacting with FDA-approved or clinical trial drugs:PTPRF, TIE1, MPL, SLC6A9 and KCNH3: | ||
| ADRA2A | rs1800544 | G allele associated with improved response compared with patients carrying C allele: | ||
| COMT | rs4680 | Val/Val genotype associated with improved response compared with Met allele carriers: | ||
| CES1 | 8 SNPs | No association between genotype and responder status: | ||
| LPHN3 | rs5661665, rs1947274 | No significant association: | ADHD and ASD PRS not associated with stimulant initiation, discontinuation or switch. No GWAS hits were found for stimulant initiation or discontinuation: | |
| rs6551665 | G allele carriers exhibited better response in the inattentive symptom domain: | |||
| SLC6A2 | rs5569 | G/G genotype associated with improved response compared to A allele carriers: | ||
| rs28386840 | T allele associated with improved response: | |||
| Atomoxetine | DBH | rs2519154 | Decreased response with C allele: | No association with drug (MPH+ATX) response neither in SNP nor in gene-level analyses in a study investigating neurodevelopmental genes identified in ADHD. ADHD PRS not associated with symptom improvement following ATX treatment (possibly due to the limited sample size): |
| SLC6A2 | rs3785143 | Non-response linked to the presence of T allele: | ||
| 108 SNPs | No association for any SNP: | |||
| CYP2D6 | allelic variants related to poor, intermediate, normal and ultrarapid metabolization | Poor metabolizers are more likely to experience improvement in ADHD symptoms compared to extensive metabolizers: | ||
| ADRA1A | 3 SNPs | No effects on drug response: | ||
| ADRA2A | rs1800544 | GG haplotype linked to non-remission status (not significant after correction for multiple comparisons): | ||
DAT1, dopamine transporter; DRD4, dopamine receptor D4; ADRA2A, Adrenergic α2A Receptor; COMT, catechol-O-methyltranspherase; CES1, Carboxylesterase; LPHN3, latrophilin-3 gene; NET, Norepinephrine Transporter; DBH, dopamine β-hydroxylase; CYP2D6, Cytochrome P-450 2D6; ADRA1A, Adrenergic α1A; MPH, methylphenidate; ATX, atomoxetine. Meta-analyses and/or reviews are highlighted in italics.
Summary of potential approaches bridging ADHD genetic research and clinical issues.
| Approach | Methods | Results | Limitations | Perspectives | Utility for persisiting ADHD |
| Candidate-gene association study | Investigation of genetic variants based on a priori neurobiological hypotheses. | Conflicting | Scarcity of longitudinal and normative data. Results based predominantly on patient cohorts. | Future utility for gene-environment interactions, can be connected to neurotransmitter systems, more heuristic for trait-based approaches (e.g. EEG, brain imaging, cognition). | Results do not support this utility. |
| GWAS/PRS | Investigation of 500.000-1M SNPs without any a priori hypothesis. PRS calculation based on original learning sample and weighted summation of variants. | Promising results, although the interpretation of GWAS hits remains challenging. Can provide information for animal models and cell-based research. | Sample size has to be increased and phenotyping has to be refined, rather than using broad diagnostic categories. Interpretation of PRS scores needs to be extensively studies for clinical samples. | Promising in future for comorbidity and persistence risk-assessment. | Childhood and adult ADHD GWAS data is extensively studies, interpretation remains conflicting. |
| Cross-disorder analysis | Comparison of GWAS and PRS data across diagnoses. | Results interesting but need further interpretation. | These studies should move from DSM-based diagnostic comparisons to trait-based investigation. | Sheds light on longitudinal course of different diagnostic groups, therefore very interesting for clinicians. | Could provide insight on ADHD comorbidities. |
| Endophenotypes/Biomarkers | Investigation of neurobiological traits that are more stable than clinical characteristics. | Conflicting | Terminology needs to be improved, causality is often not examined. | Will add to our understanding of underlying neurobiological processes. | Genetic or other biomarker associated with persistence would be extremely important. |
| Pharmacogenetics | Investigation of genetic variants in receptors and drug-metabolizing enzymes to improve pharmacological treatment. | Is already used for the prediction for metabolism of ADHD medications. Caution is needed for the larger scale implementation of these findings. | Scarcity of data, besides effectiveness, side-effects should also be monitored in such studies. | Drug-repurposing, individual prediction. | Prediction of long-term therapeutic response and side-effects. |