| Literature DB >> 35329682 |
Marcin Kozakiewicz1, Izabela Gabryelczak1.
Abstract
For some years now, fixation devices created with resorbable magnesium alloys for the mandibular head have been clinically available and are beginning to be used. It is thus valuable to evaluate the quality of unions in these cases. The aim of this study was radiological comparison of magnesium versus titanium open reduction and rigid fixations in the mandible condylar head. Thirty-one patients were treated for fractures of the mandibular head with magnesium WE43 alloy headless compression screws (diameter 2.3 mm) and, as a reference group, 29 patients were included with similar construction titanium screws (diameter 1.8 mm). The 12-month results of the treatment were evaluated by the texture analysis of CT. Near similar treatment results were found with magnesium screws in traditional titanium fixation. Magnesium screws result in a higher density of the bone structure in the mandibular head. Conclusions: The quantitative evaluation of bone union after surgical treatment of mandibular head fracture with magnesium compression headless screws indicates that stable consolidation was achieved. Undoubtedly, the resorption process of the screws was found to be incomplete after 12 months, evidenced by a marked densification of the bone structure at the fracture site.Entities:
Keywords: bone union; condylar head fracture; fixing material; fracture treatment; magnesium; mandible condyle; mandible head; open rigid internal fixation; osteosynthesis; surgical treatment
Year: 2022 PMID: 35329682 PMCID: PMC8950275 DOI: 10.3390/ma15062230
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Materials (Basel) ISSN: 1996-1944 Impact factor: 3.623
Data describing the test group versus the reference group.
| Variable | Test | Reference | Between-Group |
|---|---|---|---|
| Age | 30 ± 20 years | 35 ± 15 years | |
| Gender (female, male) | 13%, 39% | 8%, 39% | |
| Tabaco smokers | 11% | 0% | |
| Co-morbidity (internal) | 11% | 20% | |
| Taking systemic medication | 6% | 0% | |
| Reason of injury (RTA 1, assault, fall) | 15%, 26%, 28% | 17%, 7%, 7% | |
| Type of fracture (B, C) | 17%, 43% | 4%, 37% | |
| Mandible ramus shortening (M, P) 2 | 13%, 46% | 0%, 41% | |
| Location (single, bilateral fracture) | 41%, 19% | 13%, 28% |
1 Road Traffic Accident. 2 M—fracture without ramus shortening, P—fracture with ramus shortening.
Figure 1General appearance of the compressive headless screws used in the study. These screws are ChM’s dedicated designs for mandibular head fixation. (a) magnesium alloy 2.2 mm screw (test group); (b) titanium alloy 1.7 mm screw (reference group). Compressibility is ensured by different thread pitch. The large pitch at the tip of the screw ensures a large longitudinal movement with every turn in proximal bone fragments. On the other hand, a small thread pitch at the socket end leads to a small longitudinal movement of the screw in distal bone fragments, which ensures a compression effect in the fracture gap.
Figure 2The compression screws used have cross sockets and peripheral notches to collect bone chips. It is assumed that both screw types will be immersed in the bone in their entirety.
Comparison of the materials in the screws in the test and reference groups.
| Magnesium Alloy | Composition | Titanium Alloy | Composition |
|---|---|---|---|
| Magnesium | Balance | Titanium | Balance |
| Yttrium | 3.5–4.5% | Aluminium | 6.2950% |
| Rare Earth | 2.5–3.5% | Niobium | 6.8700% |
| Zirconium | <0.6% | Tantalum | <0.001% |
| Iron | <80 ppm | Iron | 0.175% |
| Manganese | <200 ppm | Oxygen | 0.166% |
| Aluminium | <200 ppm | Carbon | 0.0065% |
| Silicon | <100 ppm | Nitrogen | 0.003% |
| Copper | <100 ppm | Hydrogen | 0.0024% |
| Nickel | <30 ppm | Nickel | 0.0205% |
| Beryllium | <20 ppm | Vanadium | 0.0195% |
| Other Single Trace | <0.05% | ||
| Total Trace Elements | 0.104% |
Physical properties of the materials used in the experiment (see Table 2).
| Property | Magnesium Alloy | Titanium Alloy |
|---|---|---|
| Tensile strength Rm | Min. 280 MPa | Min. 988 MPa |
| Yield strength Rp0.2 | Min. 200 MPa | Min. 800 MPa |
| Elongation ε | Min. 10% | Min. 10% |
| Density | 1.84 g/cm3 | 4.52 g/cm3 |
| Young modulus | 44 GPa | 103 GPa |
| Poisson’s ratio | 0.27 | 0.33 |
| Melting range | 540–640 °C | 1530–1590 °C |
Figure 3Examples of bone union after 12 months from osteosynthesis in the Magnesium and Titanium group observed by computed tomography (CT) mapping of regions of interest for texture analysis (ROI red: post-fracture site; green: control cancellous bone in the mandible head). The results of calculating the sum of squares of optical densities over a distance of two pixels (SumOfSqr), the frequency of long chains of pixels of similar optical density (LngREmph), the differential entropy in the image (DifEntrp), and the Bone Index were mapped.
Comparison of the fracture site 12 months post-operation by means of texture analysis with SumOfSqr and Bone Index features.
| Measured Feature | Test | Reference | Between-Group |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sum of Squares in the fracture line | 109 ± 5 1 | 10 6 ± 6 1 | |
| Sum of Squares in cancellous control bone | 99 ± 7 | 94 ± 7 | |
| Bone Index in the fracture line | 0.70 ± 0.25 2 | 0.79 ± 0.23 2 | |
| Bone Index in the cancellous control bone | 0.97 ± 0.23 | 1.08 ± 0.07 | |
| Sum of Squares Relative | 1.11 ± 0.10 3 | 1.13 ± 0.11 3 | |
| Bone Index Relative | 0.73 ± 0.25 4 | 0.72 ± 0.19 4 |
1 Observed opaque islands in healed fracture site texture generated an increase in the value of SumOfSqrt. 2 The low value is due to the low diversity within the radio-opaque islands, detected as extensive areas of uniformly elevated optical density. 3 In both groups, the relative values increased, confirming that SumOfSqr was higher in the remodeled fracture line with both magnesium and titanium osteosynthesis. 4 In both groups, the BI value decreased similarly in the osteosynthesis site.