| Literature DB >> 35271738 |
Preeti Sharma1, Sangeeta Malik2, Vijay Wadhwan1, Suhasini Gotur Palakshappa1, Roli Singh1.
Abstract
Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) is a novel disease caused by a newly identified virus Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) causing diverse systemic manifestations. The oral cavity too is not spared and the symptoms appear either independently, concurrently, or sequentially. In view of the rising documented cases of oral lesions of COVID-19, this systematic review aims to assess the prevalence of oral manifestations in COVID-19 confirmed individuals. An extensive literature search was conducted in databases like Scopus, Pubmed/Medline, Livivo, Lilacs and Google Scholar and varied oral signs and symptoms were reported as per the PRISMA guidelines. Studies published in English language literature only were included and were subjected to the risk of bias using the Joana Briggs Institute Appraisal tools for prevalence studies, case series and case reports. In a two-phase selection, 34 studies were included: 21 observational, 3 case-series and 10 case reports. These observational studies included approximately 14,003 patients from 10 countries. In this review, we explored the most commonly encountered oral and dental manifestations in COVID-19 and identified that loss of taste acuity, xerostomia and anosmia were frequently reported. Elevated incidence of opportunistic infections like mucormycosis and aspergillosis were reported during the treatment due to prolonged intake of steroids. Immunosuppression and poor oral hygiene led to secondary manifestations like enanthematous lesions. However, it is not clear that oral signs and symptoms are due to COVID-19 infection itself or are the result of extensive treatment regimen followed [PROSPERO CRD42021258264].Entities:
Keywords: Covid-19; SARS-CoV-2 infection; oral manifestations
Year: 2022 PMID: 35271738 PMCID: PMC9111150 DOI: 10.1002/rmv.2345
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Rev Med Virol ISSN: 1052-9276 Impact factor: 11.043
FIGURE 1Flow‐diagram depicting selection criteria adapted from Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta‐analyses
Distinctive features of observational studies included in the systematic review (n = 21)
| S. No. | Study Id | Study design | Sample (total no) | Age,Y, mean | Covid‐19 grade/Severity | Clinical signs and symptoms | Oral manifestations | Time of oral presentation | Diagnostic method of oral manifestations | Conclusion | Risk of bias |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Gherlone EF et al (2021), Milan, Italy | Observational study | 122 (M‐75%, F‐25%) | 62.5 (53.9–74.1 y) for M, 30 (24.6) Y for F | Hospitalised (115), ICU (30 patients out of 122 transferred to ICU | Not reported (confirmed COVID‐19 cases included) | Salivary gland ectasia (46), both dry mouth and salivary gland ectasia (13), masticatory muscle weakness (23), TMJ abnormalities (9), dysgeusia (14), anosmia (12), facial tingling (4), trigeminal neuralgia(4), facial asymmetry (1) | Post‐recovery follow‐up | Extraoral and intraoral physical examination by experienced dental specialist | Oral cavity is a possible target of COVID‐19, with alterations persisting in the vast majority of survivors well after clinical recovery. | Low |
| 2 | Maia CMF et al, 2021, Brazil | Observational study | 8695 (observed during covid period) | Not reported | Hospitalised and non‐hospitalised | Not reported (confirmed COVID‐19 cases included) | Herpes zoster | Before and during COVID‐19 infection | Medical records | There was an increase in HZ cases during the COVID‐19 pandemic, which suggests a correlation between these diseases. | Moderate |
| 3 | Nuno Gonzalez A et al, 2020, Spain | Observational study | 666 | 55.67 years F‐ 58%, M‐42% (not reported) | Hospitalised | Confirmed cases of COVID‐19 | Oral cavity findings were seen in 78 (25.65%) cases, including transient lingual papillitis (11.5%), glossitis with lateral indentations (6.6%), aphthous stomatitis (6.9%), glossitis with patchy depapillation (3.9%) and mucositis (3.9%), enanthema (0.5%), white tongue (1.6%), candidiasis (1%). Burning sensation was reported in 5.3% of patients and taste disturbances (dysgeusia) was commonly associated. | During COVID‐19 infection | Extraoral and intraoral physical examination | Almost half of patients with mild to moderate COVID‐19 admitted in a field‐hospital during a 2‐week period show mucocutaneous findings. Oral cavity is frequently involved and deserves specific examination under the appropriate circumstances to avoid contagion risk. | Low |
| 4 | Biadsee A et al, 2020, Israel | Observational study | 128 (58 M, 70 F) | 36.25 (18–73 Y) | Non‐hospitalised | Cough, weakness, myalgia, fever, headache, impaired sense of smell, sore throat, runny nose, nasal congestion, gastrointestinal symptoms. | Changes in taste sensation, dry mouth, facial pain, masticatory muscle pain, burning sensation, change in tongue sensation, plaque‐like changes in the tongue | During COVID‐19 infection | Web based questionnaire | A considerable number of patients presented with olfactory and oral disorders. Interestingly, women presented with a different cluster of symptoms than men, which may suggest a new clinical approach to diagnosing COVID‐19 disease. | Moderate |
| 5 | Fantozzi PJ et al, 2020, Italy | Observational study | 111, 58 were males, 53 were females | Median age −57 years | Hospitalised, ICU | Fever, cough, dyspnoea, diarrhoea, sore throat, fatigue, myalgia, vomit | Taste dysfunction was the most common reported symptom (59.5%; | During COVID‐19 infection | Ouestionnaire based survey | Xerostomia, olfactory and gustatory dysfunctions are common symptoms reported as concomitant, and in some cases the sole manifestation of COVID‐19. | Low |
| 6 | Katz J and Yue S, 2021, Florida, USA | Observational study (retrospective cross‐sectional) | RAS and COVID‐19‐ (0.64%) | 18–34 Yr (66%), 10–17 (33%) | Hospitalised and non‐hospitalised | Confirmed cases of COVID‐19 | Prevalence of RAS in covid‐19 patients was 0.64%. | During COVID‐19 infection | Medical records | There is a strong association between COVID‐19 and aphthous ulcers | Low |
| 7 | Giacomelli A et al, 2020, Italy | Cross‐sectional study | 59 | 60 years (50–74) M‐40, F‐19 | Hospitalised | Fever, cough, dyspnoea, sore throat, arthralgia, coryza, headache, asthenia, abdominal symptoms | Olfactory and/or taste disorders (20), taste disorders only (6), olfactory disorders only (3), mixed taste and olfactory disorders (11) | 12 patients (20.3%) presented the symptoms before the hospital admission, whereas 8 (13.5%) experienced the symptoms during the hospital stay. Taste alterations were more frequently (91%) before hospitalisation, whereas after hospitalisation taste and olfactory alteration appeared with equal frequency. | Questionnare based survey | OTDs are fairly frequent in patients with SARS‐CoV‐2 infection and may precede the onset of full‐blown clinical disease. I | Moderate |
| 8 | Sinjari B et al, 2020, Italy | Observational study | 20 | 69.2 Y, 55% M, 45% F | Hospitalised | Confirmed cases of COVID‐19 (clinical manifestations not reported) | Xerostomia (30%), impaired taste (25%), burning sensation (15%), difficulty in swallowing (20%) | During COVID‐19 infection | Questionnaire based survey | This study demonstrates the importance of the close link between SARS‐CoV‐2 and oral manifestations. Dysgeusia may be a warning signal for the patients. | Low |
| 9 | Abubakr N et al, 2021, Egypt | Observational study | 573 | 36.19 ± 9.11 years (range: 19–50 years). | Non‐hospitalised (mild to moderate cases) | Mild to moderate cases | Oral or dental pain (23%), pain in jaw bones or joint (12.0%), halitosis (10.5%), ulcerations (20.4%), and xerostomia (47.6%). Some patients (28.3%) showed 2 or 3 manifestations simultaneously. | During COVID‐19 infection | Mild‐to‐moderate cases of COVID‐19 infection are associated with oral symptoms, and thus the significance of dental examination of patients with communicable diseases should be emphasised. | Low | |
| 10 | El Kady DM et al, 2021, Egypt | Observational study | 58 (53.4% M, 46.6% F) | 18–46 Y | Hospitalised | Fever, cough, shortness of breath, and myalgia or weakness, headache, sputum formation, haemoptysis, diarrhoea | The highest prevalence symptoms were dry mouth 39.7% ( | During COVID‐19 infection | Questionnaire based survey (online) | COVID‐19 significantly impacts the oral cavity and salivary glands, as salivary gland‐related symptoms and taste disorders are highly prevalent in COVID‐19 patients. | Low |
| 11 | Moorthy A et al, 2021, Karnataka, India | Retrospective observational study | 18 (15 M, 3 F) | 35–73 years with a mean age of 54.6 years. | Hospitalised | Facial cellulitis, maxillary sinusitis, headache, necrosis of palatal bone/mucosa or acute loss of vision | The fungi noted was mucormycosis in 16 patients, aspergillosis in 1 patient and a mixed fungal infection in 1 patient. | During COVID‐19 infection | Physical extraoral and intraoral examination | There is a significant increase in the incidence of angioinvasive maxillofacial fungal infections in diabetic patients treated for SARS‐CoV‐2 with a strong association with corticosteroid administration. | Low |
| 12 | Bardellini E et al, 2021, Italy | Retrospective cross‐sectional study | 27 children | 4.2 years + 1.7) | Non‐hospitalised | Fever, cough, cutaneous flat papular lesions | Oral pseudomembranous candidiasis (7.4%), geographic tongue (3.7%), coated tongue (7.4%) and hyperaemic pharynx (37%). Taste alteration was reported by 3 patients. | During COVID‐19 infection | Medical records reviewed | As for paediatric sample, COVID‐19 resulted to be associated with non‐specific oral and cutaneous manifestations. There are no specific oral manifestations in children during a COVID‐19 infection. | Moderate |
| 13 | Klein H et al, 2021, Israel | Observational study | 103 (64 M, 39 F) | 35 ± 12 years | Non‐hospitalised | Headache, fever, muscle aches, dry cough, lack of appetite, runny nose, sore throat, productive cough, fatigue, smell change, diarrhoea, vomiting/nausea, breathing difficulty | Taste change. Taste and smell changes were the longest lasting symptoms | During COVID‐19 infection and during recovery period | Questionnaire (phone interview) | Long‐lasting effects of mild COVID‐19 manifested in almost half of the participants reporting at least one unresolved symptom after 6 months. | Moderate |
| 14 | Katz J, 2021, Florida, USA | Cross sectional study | 889 (385 M, 504 F) | Children<18 = 38 (4%) | Hospitalised | Not reported | Dry mouth (Sicca dry mouth and non‐sicca dry mouth) in 9 patients (1.01%) | During COVID‐19 infection | i2b2 data repository platform of university of Florida health centre | Dry mouth related to Sicca and not related to Sicca are strongly associated with COVID‐19. The causes for this are not clear and may include autoimmunity & comorbidities. | Low |
| Adults>18 = 851 (96%) | |||||||||||
| 15 | Villaroel‐Dorrego M et al, 2021, Spain | Observational study | 55 (25 F and 30 M) | 1–89 years, mean 51 ± 23.24 years | Hospitalised (19 in ICU) | Confirmed COVID‐19 cases (clinical manifestations not reported) | Candidiasis and ulcers (7 each), enanthems (2 pts.), geographic tongue and caviar tongue. Altered taste, dry mouth, and painful/burning mouth were noted in 60%, 27.3%, and 36.4% of patients, respectively. Oral mucosal alterations and lesions were prevalent in this series of COVID‐19 patients. Altered taste and a painful/burning mouth were common symptoms. | During COVID‐19 infection | Clinical examination of the lesions with findings recorded in a database | Ulcers were the most commonly observed lesions and included both haemorrhagic and aphthous‐like lesions. Both dysgeusia and oral pain or burning were common in patients with mucosal lesions (68.2% and 77.3%, respectively). In 22 patients (40%) at least one alteration or lesion was observed in the oral mucosa | Moderate |
| 16 | Katz J, 2021, USA | Cross sectional study | 889 | Not reported | Hospitalised | Not reported | Candidiasis only assessed. | During COVID‐19 infection | i2b2 data repository platform was used to analyse the interrelations between COVID‐19, oral candidiasis, and total candidiasis | Total candidiasis was significantly associated with increased risk for COVID‐19, whereas oral candidiasis showed an insignificant trend. COVID‐19 may be a risk factor for total candidiasis. | Low |
| 17 | Subramaniam T et al, 2021, Pune India | Observational study | 713 patients, 416 M, 297 F | 12–80 years | Hospitalised | Not reported | 9 patients reported oral discomfort due to varied forms of oral lesions ranging from herpes simplex ulcers to angular cheilitis (1.26%). | During COVID‐19 infection | Photographs taken of the lesions from a camera, assessed by specialists. | No specific pattern or characteristic oral lesions were noted in a study of 713 COVID‐positive patients in this study to qualify these lesions as oral manifestations of SARS‐CoV‐2 infection. | Low |
| 18 | Freni F et al, 2020, Italy | Observational study | 50 (30 M, 20 F) | 37.7 ± 17.9 | Non‐ hospitalised | Confirmed COVID‐19 cases | Xerostomia, difficult in swallowing food | During COVID‐ 19 infection | Questionnaire based survey | There was an alteration of the sense of taste, of the sense of smell, dry eyes and of the oral cavity and an auditory discomfort, symptoms probably linked to the neurotropism of the virus | Low |
| 19 | Omezli MM and Torul D, 2021, Ordu, Turkey | Observational study | 107 (56 M, 51 F) | 17–65 Y F, 13–70 Y M | Non‐ hospitalised | Confirmed COVID‐19 cases | Xerostomia, burning mouth, pain on chewing | After recovering from COVID‐ 19 infection | Questionnaire based survey | The most frequent finding in patients after the treatment was xerostomia. Taste and smell impairments were more frequently observed in females. | Low |
| 20 | D Giacomo P et al, 2021, Rome, Italy | Observational study | 214 | Not reported | Non hospitalised | Psychological impact of COVID‐19 pandemic on subjects with TMD | Temporomandibular disorders (TMD) | During COVID 19 pandemic | Questionnaire based survey | Awake and sleep bruxism, dental grinding, alteration in the quality and quantity of sleep and fatigue increased | Low |
| 21 | Colonna A et al, 2021, Ferrarra, Italy | Observational study | 506 | Not reported | Non hospitalised | Psychological status, bruxism in TMD reported individuals | Increase in symptoms of TMD | During COVID 19 pandemic | Online survey | 36% and 32.2% of participants reported increased pain in the TMJ and facial muscles, respectively, and almost 50% of the subjects also reported more frequent migraines and/or headaches | Low |
Abbreviation: TMJ, temporomandibular joint.
Distinctive features of case series(n = 3) and case reports (n = 10) included in the systematic review
| S. No. | Study Id | Study design | Sample (total no) | Age,Y, mean | Covid‐19 grade/Severity | Clinical signs and symptoms | Oral manifestations | Time of oral presentation | Diagnostic method of oral manifestations | Conclusion | Risk of bias |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tapia ROC etal, 2020, Mexico | Case series | 4 (3 F, 1 M) | 41 F, 51 F, 55 F, 42 M (mean age range‐47.2 ± 6.8.) | Non‐hospitalised (Case 1), hospitalised (Case 2), non‐hospitalised (Case 3), non‐hospitalised (Case 4) | Fever, myalgia, headache, dysphagia, hyposmia, nasal congestion | Angina bullosa hemorrhagica, vascular‐like purple macule on palatal mucosa, burning mouth, dysgeusia and erythematous macules | During COVID‐19 infection | Extraoral and intraoral physical examination | It is important to consider that oral mucosal lesions in COVID‐19 individuals could mimic others oral diseases, such as reactive, vascular and immunological disorders, being necessary to differentiate them to establish the correct diagnosis and clinical management in patients with SARS‐CoV‐2 infection. | Moderate |
| 2 | Fisher J et al, 2021, Boston, USA | Case report | 1 | 21 Y, F | Non‐hospitalised | Fever, cough, dyspnoea, left sided facial and neck swelling | acute infectious parotitis, malocclusion due to inflammation surrounding muscles of mastication | During COVID‐19 infection | Physical extraoral and intraoral examination | Atypical presentations of COVID‐19 are being increasingly recognized. Emergency department clinicians must have a high suspicion for COVID‐19 among any patient presenting with infectious symptoms or viral‐associated illnesses and don available PPE accordingly for the initial evaluation. | Moderate |
| 3 | Lima MA et al, 2020, Brazil | Case series | 8 | Females were 7, Male‐1, Mean‐36 years | Non‐hospitalised | Mild respiratory and systemic COVID‐19 SYMPTOMS | Facial palsy | During COVID‐19 infection | Physical extraoral and intraoral examination | Peripheral facial palsy should be added to the spectrum of neurological manifestations associated with COVID‐19. Most patients had an uncomplicated course with good outcome, and SARS‐CoV‐2 RNA could not be detected in Cerebrospinal Fluid (CSF) of any patient. | Low |
| 4 | Ferreira ACAF et al, 2020, Brazil | Case report | 1, M | 39 Y | Hospitalised | Fatigue, diarrhoea, fever | Left facial herpes zoster with intraoral mucosal lesions, hypogeusia | During COVID‐19 infection | Physical extraoral and intraoral examination | The emergence of the latent infection by VZV under a rare presentation might illustrate the impact at least locally of COVID‐19, once retrograde reactivation of VZV was possibly induced in a young immunocompetent patient. | Low |
| 5 | Taslidere B et al, 2021, Turkey | Case report | 1 | 51 Y, F | Hospitalised | Malaise, pneumonia | Hyperaemic, firm oedema in the right lower lip extending towards the jaw, right facial paralysis, fissured tongue, (Melkersson‐Rosenthal syndrome) | During COVID‐19 infection | Physical extraoral and intraoral examination | Activated mast cells also play a part in the pathogenesis of COVID‐19 infection, as they release cytokines in the lungs. COVID‐19 may be associated with which was not previously included in the aetiology of the disease. | Low |
| 6 | Figueiredo R et al, 2020, Portugal | Case report | 1 | 35 years, F | Non‐hospitalised. (Admitted due to 39‐week pregnancy in gynaecology department) | Lagophthalmos, No other symptoms including fever, dyspnoea, cough, anosmia, ageusia | Bell's palsy showing involuntary drooling, left side labial commissure deviation | During COVID‐19 infection | Physical extraoral and intraoral examination | COVID‐19 may be a potential cause of peripheral facial paralysis.Neurological symptoms could be the first and only manifestation of the COVID‐19 | Low |
| Pregnant women have higher susceptibility for peripheral facial palsy and functional prognosis can be worse. | |||||||||||
| 7 | Lechien JR et al, 2020, Belgium | Case series | 3 | 23/F, 31/F, 27/F | Non‐hospitalised | Anorexia, arthralgia, myalgia, fatigue, headache, nasal obstruction, rhinorrhoea, postnasal drip, sore throat, face pain, loss of smell and taste | Parotitis characterised by ear pain, retromandibular oedema, sticky saliva, pain during chewing | During COVID‐19 infection | Physical extraoral and intraoral examination | Parotid inflammation might be encountered in COVID‐19 patients and could be related to intraparotid lymphadenitis. | Low |
| 8 | Caamano DSJ and Beato RA, 2020, Spain | Case report | 1 | 61/M | Non‐hospitalised | Fever, cough | Bilateral facial nerve palsy with unresponsive blink reflex on both eyes, Guillain‐Barré syndrome (GBS) | During COVID‐19 infection | Physical extraoral and intraoral examination | There is a clear emerging group of neurological manifestations during and after SARS‐CoV‐2 infection; some directly linked, others not so much.case is a highly probable GBS DP variant. | Low |
| 9 | Kammerer T et al, 2021, Germany | Case report | 1 (M) | 46Y | Hospitalised (ICU) | Fatigue, dry cough, fever, respiratory distress | Multiple sharply circumscribed ulcerations of the oral mucosa covered by yellow–grey membranes. Secondary herpetic gingivostomatitis | During COVID‐19 infection | Physical extraoral and intraoral examination | COVID‐19 infection and prolonged inpatient care were causal factors of stress induction and immunosuppression, leading to the distinct oral manifestations. | Low |
| 10 | Kitakawa D et al, 2020, Brazil | Case report | 1 | 20 Y/F | Non‐hospitalised | Severe sore throat and headache | Lesions in the median lower lip semimucosa and severe pruritus, with a clinical course of 14 days, clinical diagnosis of herpes simplex infection. | During COVID‐19 infection | Physical extraoral and intraoral examination | Most of these cases could occur in patients who have experienced COVID‐19 infection | Low |
| 11 | Andrews E et al, 2020, USA | Case report | 1 | 40 Y/F | Hospitalised (ICU) | Fevers, shortness of breath and diarrhoea, acute respiratory distress | Severe, persistent macroglossia following prone positioning as part of treatment for COVID‐19. | During COVID‐19 infection | Physical extraoral and intraoral examination | Patient's macroglossia was the result of a prolonged course of prone positioning for treatment of COVID‐19. | Low |
| 12 | Gil JM et al, 2021, Spain | Case report | 1 | 65 Y/M | Non‐hospitalised | General malaise, arthromyalgia, dry cough, and low‐grade fever. | Paroxysmal lancinating pain in the right V1 region that lasted a few seconds and was triggered by a light touch of the skin at a specific point on the scalp. Diagnosed as trigeminal neuralgia. | During COVID‐19 | Physical extraoral and intraoral examination | The new coronavirus SARS‐CoV‐2 is a possible aetiology of secondary Trigeminal neuralgia (TN). Nevertheless, more studies are needed to elucidate the neuropathology of this viral infection. | Low |
| 13 | Soares CD et al, 2020 | Case report | 23 Y/F | 23 Y | Non‐hospitalised | Fever and dry cough 3 days prior to oral presentation | Vesiculobullous lesions in the lips with an erythematous halo | During COVID‐19 | Physical extraoral and intraoral examination | This is the first report showing the SARS‐CoV‐2 spike protein in oral lesions of patients with COVID‐19. | Low |
Abbreviation: PPE, personal protective equipment.