| Literature DB >> 35243018 |
Max Deschner1, Lakshman Vasanthamohan2, Sondos Zayed3, Alejandro Lazo-Langner4,5, David Palma3, David D'Souza3, Syed Omar Gilani1, R Gabriel Boldt6, Ziad Solh4,7.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Packed red blood cell (RBC) transfusion is frequently used in patients undergoing radiotherapy (RT) because retrospective data suggest that anemic patients may respond sub-optimally to RT. No high-quality evidence currently exists to guide transfusion practices and establish hemoglobin (Hb) transfusion thresholds for this patient population, and practice varies significantly across centers. This systematic review investigated whether maintaining higher Hb via transfusion in radiation oncology patients leads to improved outcomes.Entities:
Keywords: Hemoglobin; Radiation oncology; Radiation therapy; Red blood cell transfusion
Year: 2021 PMID: 35243018 PMCID: PMC8885402 DOI: 10.1016/j.ctro.2021.12.002
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Clin Transl Radiat Oncol ISSN: 2405-6308
Fig. 1PRISMA flowchart of article selection process.
Qualitative summary of studies included in the narrative review.
| Girinski et al., 1988, France | Retrospective review | Patients with advanced cervical carcinomas (Stage IIB or III) treated with RT | 386 | 57.7 (mean) | Not reported | Local regional and distant failure | Reviewed effect of Hb level (threshold of 10.0 g/dL) and transfusions in subgroup analyses before or during RT on locoregional or distant failures | Hb levels only prognostic during RT; patients with at least one Hb < 10.0 g/dL had a higher risk of locoregional failure; suggested transfusion may be beneficial if given before RT, but not during treatment | |
| Retrospective review | Patients undergoing TURP with high dose RT for prostate carcinoma | 71 | 66 (median) | Not reported | Total and local recurrence 5-year survival | Reviewed effect of transfusion in patients who have received RT after TURP | 5 year survival in transfused group was 17% and in non-transfused group was 66%, suggesting that perioperative transfusion post-RT may be associated with worse survival and increased recurrence (but not local recurrence) | No transfusion threshold defined | |
| Retrospective review | Pediatric patients with medulloblastoma treated with surgical resection followed by craniospinal irradiation +/- adjuvant chemotherapy | 72 | Not reported | Not reported | Local control | Reviewed relationship between Hb levels (threshold of 10.0 g/dL) and RT response, local control and survival in patients medulloblastoma. | Posterior fossa relapse occurred in patients who did not undergo total resection; no difference in local control or survival for patients with Hb below or above 10.0 g/dL during RT. | Only four patients were transfused; small sample size | |
| Retrospective review | Patients with cervical carcinoma (Stage IB, II, III or IVA) treated with radical RT | 605 | 56 (mean) | 41 (median) | OS | Reviewed effect of Hb level [defined thresholds of 10.0 /dL ( | Suggest average weekly nadir Hb is predictive of outcome (second to disease stage in prognostic significance); Hb level was significant on univariate analysis (not multivariate analysis); increase in OS with increasing Hb from < 11.0 g/dL to > 12.0 g/dL whether achieved via transfusion or spontaneously; Hb level > 13.0 g/dL not associated with additional survival gain | Over 3 years of study, number of patients who received transfusions decreased in subgroup of 4 centers with transfusion policies. | |
| Retrospective review | Patients with cervical cancer (IB, II, IIIB, IV) treated with radical RT (including external beam irradiation and brachytherapy) | 204 | 66 (median) | 48 (median) | DSS | Reviewed effect of transfusion for Hb < 11.0 g/dL versus no transfusion in cervical cancer | Outcomes for transfused and non-transfused patients did not differ significantly; DSS, pelvic control and metastases-free survival decreased in patients not responding to transfusion (p < 0.001) | Subgroup analysis suggests etiology of anemia should be further investigated given lack of prognostic impact of transfusion on patients with anemia from other comorbidities | |
| Retrospective review | Patients with cervical cancer (IIB, III) treated with external radiation and intracavitary brachytherapy +/- platinum | 130 | 51 (transfused), 56 (non-transfused) | 50 months (median) for transfused, 49 months (median) for not transfused | OS | Compared anemic patients who were transfused to not transfused | OS of transfused patients significantly lower versus patients not transfused after adjusting for age, no chemotherapy and histology | ||
| Retrospective review | Patients with unresectable esophageal cancer treated with RT and concurrent cisplatin and 5-fluorouracil | 56 | Not reported | 62 (median) | OS | Reviewed effect of transfusion for Hb < 12.0 g/dL versus no transfusion on survival in esophageal cancer | Transfusion associated with improved OS (OS was 65% versus 21% in patients treated with versus without a transfusion); no significant association between low pretreatment Hb and survival | Small sample size | |
| Bhide et al., 2008, UK | Retrospective review | Patients with SCCHN treated with sequential CCRT | 169 | 60 (median) | 23.6 | LRC | Reviewed incidence of anemia in patients treated with CCRT for locally advanced SCCHN, and examined effect of policy of Hb maintenance (threshold of 12.0 g/dL) by blood transfusion on LRC, DSS and OS | RFS, DSS and OS were better among patients not transfused versus those who were; Nadir Hb level > 12.0 g/dL and > 4 units transfused associated with worse LRC, RFS, DSS and OS | Study suggests transfusion during sequential treatment for SCCHN may be harmful |
| Retrospective review | Patients with cervical cancer (IIB) treated with RT +/- chemotherapy | 119 | 60 (median) | 39.3 (median) | OS | Reviewed effect of transfusion for Hb < 10.0 g/dL versus no transfusion | Pre-treatment transfusion showed higher risk of distant metastases and lower OS compared to transfusion during RT | ||
| RCT | Patients with SCCHN treated with RT | 1166 | Not reported | 60 or death | LRC | Stratified patients with SCCHN with low pre-radiation Hb levels (females < 13.0 g/dL and males < 14.5 g/dL) to RBC transfusion (235 patients) versus no transfusion (230 patients) | No significant differences between groups in locoregional disease control or overall survival after five years of follow up, despite increased Hb levels in the transfused group; patients with low baseline Hb had a decreased probability of LRC, DSS and OS | Pooled results from two RCTs | |
| Tuan et al., 2013, UK | Retrospective review | Patients with esophageal cancer (Stage IIIA/B/C, IVA) treated with induction chemotherapy and RT | 151 | 65 (non-anemic), 69 (anemic with transfusion), 71 (anemic without transfusion) | 16.1 (median) | OS | Reviewed survival among patients who were not anemic, anemic with transfusion and anemic without transfusion based on threshold of Hb < 12 g/dL | Multivariate analysis demonstrated that anemic patients transfused had improved OS, DFS and LRFS versus non-transfused patients | Small sample |
Abbreviations: CCRT, chemotherapy followed by concomitant chemoradiation; DSS, disease-specific site; Hb, hemoglobin; LRC, locoregional control; LRFS, locoregional recurrence-free survival; MFS, metastases-free survival; OS, overall survival; PFS, progression-free survival; RCT, randomized controlled trial; RFS, relapse-free survival; RT, radiotherapy; SCCHN, squamous cell cancer of the head and neck; TURP, transurethral resection of the prostate.
| PubMed (Medline) search strategy: |
|---|
| (hgb[tw] OR hemotherapy[tw] OR red blood cell*[tw] OR Eryhem[tw] OR hemoglobin*[tw] OR haemoglobin*[tw] OR hemoglobins[mh] OR blood transfusion[mh] OR transfusion*[tw] OR hematocrit[tw]) |
| AND |
| (radiotherapy[mh] OR irradiation[tw] OR radiotherapy[tw] OR radiation[tw]) |
| AND |
| cancer[sb] |
| Limits: Humans |
| Results: 4585 |
| EMBASE search strategy: (RIS 63–75) |
| exp hemoglobin/ or hgb.mp. or hemotherapy.mp. or exp blood transfusion/ or red blood cell*.mp. or Eryhem.mp. or hemoglobin*.mp. or haemoglobin*.mp. or transfusion*.mp. or hematocrit.mp. or exp hematocrit/ |
| and |
| radiotherapy.mp. or exp radiotherapy/ or irradiation.mp. or exp irradiation/ or exp radiation/ or radiation.mp. |
| and |
| oncology.mp. or exp oncology/ or cancer.mp. or exp malignant neoplasm/ |
| Limits: (human and exclude medline journals) |
| Results: 1256 |
| Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews strategy: (RIS 76–83) |
| hgb.mp. or hemotherapy.mp. or red blood cell*.mp. or Eryhem.mp. or hemoglobin*.mp. or haemoglobin*.mp. or hemoglobins.mp. or blood transfusion.mp. or transfusion*.mp. or hematocrit.mp. |
| [mp = ti, ot, ab, tx, kw, ct, sh, hw] |
| and |
| radiotherapy.mp. or irradiation.mp. or radiation.mp. [mp = ti, ot, ab, tx, kw, ct, sh, hw] |
| and |
| (cancer or oncology or neoplasms).mp. [mp = ti, ot, ab, tx, kw, ct, sh, hw] |
| Limit: Humans |
| Results: 614 |