| Literature DB >> 35229394 |
Simon R E Davidson1,2, Steven J Kamper3,4, Robin Haskins5, Michael O'Flynn6, Karen Coss7, John Paul Smiles6, Amanda Tutty8, Jane Linton8, Joe Bryant9, Maree Buchanan10, Christopher M Williams1,2.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To describe the context of low back pain (LBP) presentations to emergency departments (EDs) by remoteness areas, hospital delineation level and staffing portfolios.Entities:
Keywords: musculoskeletal disorders; public hospital; regional health; rural health; service improvement
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35229394 PMCID: PMC9545685 DOI: 10.1111/ajr.12854
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Aust J Rural Health ISSN: 1038-5282 Impact factor: 2.060
Variables extracted
|
|
| Demographic data (age, gender, postcode, Indigenous status, private health insurance status), |
| Presenting problem description and code |
| Presentation date/time |
| Triage code |
| Date/time 1st seen by clinician |
| Discharge date/time |
| Facility name |
| ED referral source and ED visit type |
| Mode of discharge from ED |
| Principal diagnosis code and description |
| National Weighted Activity Unit (NWAU) type |
| NWAU value |
| NWAU version |
| Re‐presentation within 5 days (Yes/No) |
| Hours to re‐presentation (where relevant) |
|
|
| Admission date/time |
| Discharge date/time |
| Total length of stay (LOS) for the acute admission |
| Total NWAU for the acute admission |
| NWAU version |
| Australian refined diagnosis‐related group (DRG) description and code |
| Last acute ward, speciality code and speciality name during admission |
Triage codes use the Canadian Triage and Acuity Scale (CTAS), which is a 5‐point scale where patients are scored depending on their acuity of illness; it ranges from resuscitation (immediately life‐threatening condition) to non‐urgent (chronic or minor condition). ,
Baseline characteristics and analysis by facility remoteness classification
| Variable |
Total sample (36 EDs) |
Major cities (5 EDs) |
Inner regional (12 EDs) |
Outer regional (19 EDs) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total presentations, % ( |
100% (26 509) |
46.8% (12 399) |
37.1% (9824) |
16.2% (4286) |
| Age (years), mean (SD) |
49.2 (20.0) |
49.8 (20.3) |
48.1 (19.7) |
50.0 (19.4) |
| Gender (Female), % ( |
51.7% (13 701) |
52.3% (6482) |
51.2% (5030) |
51.1% (2189) |
| Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander, % ( |
10.3% (2738) |
6.6% (824) |
12.3% (1205) |
16.5% (709) |
| Geographical location of patient's postcode, % ( | ||||
| Major cities |
44.1% (11 699) |
88.5% (10 975) |
6.0% (583) |
3.3% (141) |
| Inner regional |
38.5% (10 205) |
10.3% (1276) |
88.4% (8688) |
5.6% (241) |
| Outer regional |
16.7% (4433) |
0.7% (81) |
5.1% (500) |
89.9% (3852) |
| Remote and very remote |
0.2% (51) |
<0.1% (8) |
0.1% (11) |
0.7% (32) |
| Triage code, % ( | ||||
| Resuscitation |
<0.1% (2) |
<0.1% (2) |
— (0) |
— (0) |
| Emergency |
4.4% (1164) |
5.9% (736) |
3.5% (341) |
2.0% (87) |
| Urgent |
25.6% (6775) |
21.1% (2610) |
26.0% (2552) |
37.6% (1613) |
| Semi‐urgent |
60.5% (16 045) |
64.6% (8006) |
60.1% (5902) |
49.9% (2137) |
| Non‐urgent |
9.5% (2522) |
8.4% (1044) |
10.5% (1029) |
10.5% (449) |
| Presentation time, % ( | ||||
| AM |
45.8% (12 128) |
46.0% (5700) |
46.0% (4516) |
44.6% (1912) |
| PM |
54.2% (14 381) |
54.0% (6699) |
54.0% (5308) |
55.4% (2374) |
| Within standard business hours (09:00–17:00) |
53.0% (14 042) |
53.1% (6578) |
52.9% (5196) |
52.9% (2268) |
| Outside standard business hours |
47.0% (12 467) |
46.9% (5821) |
47.1% (4628) |
47.1% (2018) |
| Referral source (top 2), % ( | ||||
| Self, family, friends |
93.4% (24 756) |
91.9% (11 397) |
94.4% (9269) |
95.4% (4090) |
| General practitioner or dentist, not hospital‐based |
2.8% (755) |
4.4% (546) |
1.5% (150) |
1.4% (59) |
| Minutes in ED, median (IQR) |
164 (92–255) |
206 (132–305) |
146 (84–231) |
89 (49–158) |
| >240 min in ED, % ( |
27.1% (7182) |
36.3% (4496) |
22.2% (2184) |
11.7% (502) |
| Cost per presentation (AUD$), median (IQR) |
$444 ($410–$649) |
$444 ($431–$678) |
$444 ($408–$634) |
$452 ($388–$643) |
| Re‐presentation within 5 days, % ( |
8.0% (2124) |
6.0% (748) |
8.8% (869) |
11.8% (507) |
| Hospital admissions, % ( |
18.4% (4888) |
20.4% (2525) |
15.8% (1557) |
18.8% (806) |
| Admission length of stay (days), median (IQR) |
2 (1–5) |
2 (1–5) |
2 (1–5) |
2 (1–5) |
| Cost per admission (AUD$), median (IQR) |
$3214 ($1521–$6644) |
$3299 ($1521–$7506) |
$3089 ($1521–$5446) |
$3336 ($1937–$5025) |
Analysis by NSW Health delineation level
| Variable |
6 (1 ED) |
5 (2 EDs) |
4 (3 EDs) |
3 (8 EDs) |
2 (16 EDs) |
1 (6 EDs) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total presentations, % ( |
19.3% (5128) |
22.3% (5924) |
21.5% (5691) |
23.1% (6131) |
12.1% (3220) |
1.6% (415) |
| Age (years), mean (SD) |
49.1 (20.8) |
47.8 (19.5) |
49.6 (20.1) |
48.7 (19.6) |
52.4 (19.5) |
48.1 (19.7) |
| Gender (female), % ( |
52.7% (2704) |
50.2% (2971) |
52.1% (2966) |
51.4% (3150) |
52.2% (1680) |
55.4% (230) |
| Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander, % ( |
5.7% (293) |
16.4% (836) |
8.6% (492) |
12.6% (770) |
9.7% (312) |
8.4% (35) |
| Minutes in ED, median (IQR) |
230 (156–342) |
165 (105–240) |
186 (115–277) |
128 (70–217) |
93 (50–170) |
58 (33–113) |
| >240 min in ED, % ( |
44.4% (2279) |
24.7% (1465) |
30.7% (1748) |
19.7% (1209) |
13.8% (444) |
8.9% (37) |
| Cost per presentation (AUD$), median (IQR) |
$491 ($438–$774) |
$439 ($431–$600) |
$467 ($438–$649) |
$439 ($408–$621) |
$556 ($408–$754) |
$410 ($369–$620) |
| Re‐presentation within 5 days, % ( |
5.6% (286) |
7.9% (469) |
8.0% (457) |
8.4% (514) |
11.0% (353) |
10.8% (45) |
| Hospital admissions, % ( |
30.4% (1558) |
19.2% (1136) |
9.8% (560) |
13.5% (826) |
24.1% (775) |
8.0% (33) |
| Admission length of stay (days), median (IQR) |
2 (1–5) |
1 (1–3) |
4 (2–7) |
3 (1–6) |
2 (1–5) |
3 (1–5) |
| Cost per admission (AUD$), median (IQR) |
$3089 ($1352–$7483) |
$2407 ($885–$4295) |
$4274 ($2569–$8866) |
$3544 ($2274–$7060) |
$3307 ($1843–$4303) |
$3336 ($1642–$8356) |
Level 1 (7 facilities)—provides primary care assessment within designated area. 24‐h on‐site staff with basic life support (BLS), minimum level of service. Level 2 (16 facilities)—provides emergency care within designated area, BLS and advanced life support (ALS) should be available and may have access to allied health, and emergency caseload may be intermittent. Level 3 (8 facilities)—manages full range of emergency presentations, provides 24‐h triage service and provides primary emergency care, incl short‐term mechanical ventilation, allied health available, medical practitioner available 24 h. Level 4 (3 facilities)—Level 3 PLUS provides definitive care for most emergency presentations, incl invasive monitoring. Specialist emergency medicine staff on‐site, allied health available. Level 5 (2 facilities)—Level 4 PLUS ability to manage critically ill patients, speciality services on‐site for consultation, extended hour access to selected allied health (e.g. social worker and/or physiotherapist). Level 6 (1 facility)—Level 5 PLUS ability to manage all complex emergencies, referral centre for complex patients from lower level service, speciality services on‐site (e.g. neurosurgery, cardiothoracic surgery).
Description based on NSW Ministry of Health.
Analysis by ED staffing portfolio
| Variable |
Fellowship of Australasian College of Emergency Medicine (FACEM) staff (7 EDs) |
General Practitioner Visiting Medical Officer (GPVMO) (29 EDs) |
|---|---|---|
| Total presentations, % ( |
70.0% (18 563) |
26.6% (7043) |
| Age (years), mean (SD) |
49.4 (20.2) |
49.1 (19.4) |
| Gender (female), % ( |
51.7% (9597) |
52.0% (3659) |
| Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander, % ( |
9.3% (1719) |
13.4% (943) |
| Minutes in ED, median (IQR) |
192 (122–287) |
94 (52–167) |
| >240 min in ED, % ( |
32.9% (6108) |
12.6% (890) |
| Cost per presentation (AUD$), median (IQR) |
$444 ($431–$649) |
$442 ($408–$643) |
| Re‐presentation within 5 days, % ( |
7.1% (1319) |
10.3% (728) |
| Hospital admissions, % ( |
18.6% (3451) |
18.6% (1312) |
| Admission length of stay (days), median (IQR) |
2 (1–5) |
2 (1–5) |
| Cost per admission (AUD$), median (IQR) |
$3089 ($1340–$7122) |
$3336 ($1989–$5031) |
NB: It does not include 903 presentations from the facility with a shared model of care. These unadjusted findings may be confounded by the ED setting/location.