| Literature DB >> 35203737 |
Bruno Amato1, Rita Compagna2, Salvatore De Vivo2, Aldo Rocca3, Francesca Carbone1, Maurizio Gentile4, Roberto Cirocchi5, Francesco Squizzato6, Andrea Spertino6, Piero Battocchio6.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Surgical site infections (SSIs) in lower extremity vascular surgeries, post-groin incision, are not only common complications and significant contributors to patient mortality and morbidity, but also major financial burdens on healthcare systems and patients. In spite of recent advances in pre- and post-operative care, SSI rates in the vascular surgery field remain significant. However, compliant antibiotic therapy can successfully reduce the SSI incidence pre- and post-surgery.Entities:
Keywords: antibiotic therapy; groin infection; systemic review; vascular surgery
Year: 2022 PMID: 35203737 PMCID: PMC8868080 DOI: 10.3390/antibiotics11020134
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Antibiotics (Basel) ISSN: 2079-6382
Figure 1Flowchart for references selection on “surgical site infection” AND “vascular surgery” AND “antibiotic therapy”. STRATEGY: Query: “surgical site infection” AND “vascular surgery” AND “antibiotic therapy”; Results by years: 1980–2020; Text availability: Full text; Article attribute: Meta-analysis, RCT, Review, Systematic Review, Clinical Trial, Observational Studies, Books and Documents.
Risk of biass assessment in the included randomized studies.
| Study | Random Sequence Generation (Selction Bias) | Allocation Concealment (Selection Bias) | Blinding (Performance Bias and Detection Bias) | Selective Reporting (Reporting Bias) | Other Bias | Jadad Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bratzler DW et al., 2005 [ | High | High | High | Low | Low | 2 |
| McDonald M et al., 1998 [ | Low | Low | High | Low | Low | 3 |
| Patrick S et al., 2010 [ | Low | Low | High | Low | Low | 3 |
| Stone PA et al., 2015 [ | High | High | High | Low | Low | 2 |
| Classen DC et al., 1992 [ | Low | Low | High | Low | Low | 3 |
| Argyriou C et al., 2017 [ | High | High | High | Low | Low | 2 |
| Harbarth S et al., 2008 [ | High | High | High | Low | Low | 2 |
| Friberg O et al., 2005 [ | Low | Low | High | Low | Low | 3 |
| Eklund AM et al., 2007 [ | Low | Low | High | Low | Low | 3 |
| Raja SG et al., 2012 [ | High | High | High | Low | Low | 2 |
| Chang WK et al., 2013 [ | High | High | High | Low | Low | 2 |
| Costa Almeida CEP et al., 2014 [ | High | Low | High | Low | Low | 3 |
| Holdsworth et al., 1999 [ | Low | High | Low | Low | Low | 3 |
Summary of the included study for pre-operative antibiotic therapy.
| References | Methods | Partecipants | Intervention | Outcomes | Primary Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Johnson JH et al., 1992 [ | Single blinded, | 2847 patients undergoing elective clean or “clean-contaminated” surgical procedures | Administration of antibiotics pre- v/s peri- and post-operatively | Surgical-wound infections | SSI rate of 0.6% for pre- vs. 1.4% peri- and 3.3% post-operative antibiotic administration ( |
| Bratzler DW et al., 2005 [ | Systematic review and meta-analysis | 22 trials of prophylactic systemic antibiotics | Prophylactic systemic antibiotics administration | Wound infection or early graft infection | Prophylactic systemic antibiotics reduced the risk of wound infection (RR, 0.25; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.17 to 0.38) |
| Stewart AH et al., 2007 [ | Guidelines review | Published North American guidelines for antimicrobial prophylaxis until 2002 | Pre- and post-operative antimicrobial prophylaxis | Surgical-wound infections | Infusion of the first antimicrobial dose should begin within 60 min before surgical incision and that prophylactic antimicrobial agents should be discontinued within 24 h of the end of surgery |
| Pitt HA et al., 1980 [ | Single blinded, | 217 patients scheduled for vascular surgery with groin incision | No antibiotic v/s topical cephradine prior to closure v/s 24-h perioperative e.v. cephradine and v/s both topical and intravenous cephradine. | Groin and abdominal incisional infections | - Groin and abdominal incisional infections significantly reduced ( |
| Bratzler DW et al., 2013 [ | Practice guidelines | Primary literature of Therapeutic Guidelines on Antimicrobial Prophylaxis in Surgery | - Single pre-incision dose of cefazolin or cefuroxime- Continuing prophylaxis. | Primary prophylaxis and eradication of wound infection | Recommendation of a single pre-incision dose of cefazolin or cefuroxime with appropriate intraoperative redosing. No evidence for continuing prophylaxis until all drains and catheters are removed. Clindamycin or vancomycin as alternative in patients with b-lactam allergy. Vancomycin used for prophylaxis in patients known to be colonized with MRSA. |
| McDonald M et al., 1998 [ | Systematic review | - 28 Clinical Trials | Antimicrobial single v/s multiple dose in surgical prophylaxis | Post-operative surgical site infections rate prevention | No clear advantage of either single or multiple-dose regimens of antibiotics |
| Stone PA et al., 2015 [ | Single center prospective double blinded randomized study | 178 patients were evaluated at 90 days for surgical site infection | Vancomycin v/s Vancomycin + Daptomycin pre-operative administration | Post-operative SSI rate prophylaxis | Vancomycin supplemental prophylaxis seems to reduce the incidence of Gram-positive infection compared with adding supplemental Daptomycin prophylaxis ( |
| Patrick S et al., 2010 [ | Single institution prospective randomized study | 169 low-risk patients undergoing elective vascular procedures | Cefazolin, cefazolin + vancomycin, or cefazolin + daptomycin surgical prophylaxis | Post-operative surgical site infections rate prevention | Significant fewer infectious complications in the cefazolin + daptomycin group |
| Mohammed S et al., 2013 [ | Retrospective Cohort study | 454 patients who underwent open vascular procedures | Systemic vancomycin v/s systemic + local application of vancomycin powder | Inguinal wound infection and dehiscence over a 30-day period | Addition of intraoperative local vancomycin did not improve the rates of inguinal wound dehiscence or deep infections but had a positive impact on superficial wound infections |
| Classen DC et al., 1992 [ | Single institution prospective randomized study | 2847 patients undergoing elective clean surgical procedures | Antibiotic administration 2 to 24 h before the surgical incision | Post-operative surgical wound infection rate | Prophylactic administration of antibiotics in the two hours before surgery reduces the risk of wound infection. |
| Cernohorsky P et al., 2011 [ | Multicenter retrospective cohort study | 1431 endovascular procedures | Prophylactic antimicrobial therapy | Incidence of endograft infection and mortality rate | Endograft infection rate below 1%, with a mortality rate of 25%. Antimicrobial therapy helps conservative treatment in selected cases of patients with an infected endograft. |
| Argyriou C et al., 2017 [ | Meta-Analysis | 12 studies reporting on 362 patients | Endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR) | Evidence on the outcomes of graft infection after EVAR | Supportive medical antimicrobial treatment without surgical intervention has a significant associated mortality. |
| Chehab MA et al., 2018 [ | Practice guidelines | Primary literature of Therapeutic Guidelines on Antimicrobial Prophylaxis Vascular and IR Procedures | Prophylactic antimicrobial therapy | SSI antimicrobial prophylaxis | Recommendation 1: intravenous (IV) antibiotic agents must be administered within 1 h of an incision. |
| Diekema DJ. et al., 2007 [ | Review | Evidence-based guidelines | Program for detection of methicillin-resistant | Steps that should be performed when planning active surveillance cultures for detection of methicillin-resistant | Preparing the laboratory and reducing the turnaround time for screening tests; monitoring and optimizing the intervention of instituting contact precautions; monitoring and ameliorating the known adverse effects of contact precautions. |
| Harbarth S et. al., 2008 [ | Prospective, interventional cohort study. Clinical trial | 754 patients | Compare rapid MRSA screening on admission plus standard infection control measures vs. standard infection control alone | Perioperative antibiotic prophylaxis of MRSA carriers and topical decolonization for 5 days. | A universal, rapid MRSA admission screening strategy did not reduce nosocomial MRSA infection in a surgical department with endemic MRSA prevalence but relatively low rates of MRSA infection |
| Malde DJ et al., 2006 [ | Retrospective Cohort study | 280 vascular patients | Data analysis of two period groups of MRSA positive vascular patients | Wound infection, major limb amputation and mortality rates | MRSA screening identifies patients at risk of serious complications and is associated with a reduction in these complications following both elective and emergency surgery |
Summary of the included study for intra-operative collagen-containing gentamicin implantation (CCGI).
| References | Methods | Partecipants | Intervention | Outcomes | Primary Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hussain ST et al., 2012 [ | Review | Five publications on development of SSI in vascular surgery | Prophylactic use of GCCI in fem-pop graft surgery | Reduction in SSI rate incidence | GCCI have a role to play in preventing and treating SSI following vascular reconstruction. |
| Ruszczak Z et al., 2003 [ | Review | Primary literature on collagen as a biomaterial in drug delivery systems for antibiotics | Treatment and prophylaxis of bone and soft tissue infections | Incidence of SSI | The incidence of SSI was 4.3% in the treatment group and 9.0% in the control group (relative risk 0.47; 95% confidence interval 0.33–0.68; |
| Friberg O et al., 2005 [ | RCT | 2000 cardio-vascular surgery patients | Standard prophylaxis combined with CCGI v/s standard alone (control) | Incidence of SSI | The incidence of SSI was 4.3% in the treatment group and 9.0% in the control group (relative risk 0.47; 95% confidence interval 0.33–0.68; |
| Eklund AM et al., 2007 [ | RCT | 557 patients who underwent elective cardio-vascular surgery | Standard prophylaxis combined with CCGI v/s standard alone (control) | Incidence of SSI | Postoperative SSI occurred in 11 of 272 patients (4.0%) in the study group and in 16 of 270 patients (5.9%) in the control group. This difference was not statistically significant ( |
| Raja SG et al., 2012 [ | RCT | 9 publications on prophylactic use of GCCI in cardiovascular surgery | Adjunctive use of GCCI in prophylaxis of SSI | Morbidity associated with SSI following surgery | The adjunctive use of GCCI is particularly beneficial in high-risk patients and also cost saving. |
| Chang WK et al., 2013 [ | Meta-analysis | 6979 patients from major medical databases and trial registers for RCTs | Use of GCCI in prophylaxis of SSI | Endpoint of interest was the incidence of SSI | GCCI reduced SSI [OR = 0.51; 95% CI: 0.33–0.77; |
| Modarai B et al., 2005 [ | Single institution prospective randomized study | Fifty-nine upper limb PTFE grafts in 48 patients | Use of GCCI in prophylaxis of SSI | Incidence of SSI | The use of prosthetic material is associated with a poor overall patency rate and high risk of infective complications. |
| Costa Almeida CEP et al., 2014 [ | Controlled Clinical Trial | 60 patients with lower limb ischaemia | GCCI in the groin incision adjacent to the prosthesis | SSI rate and in-hospital days | GCCI use decreasing SSI rate and in-hospital days, and also reduce health care costs. |
| Rasheed et al., 2021 [ | Review | Literature review of preventive strategies for groin SSI | Antimicrobial therapy and CCGI | Post-operative SSI | Collagen gentamicin implants are useful in preventing surgical site infection in the groin after vascular surgical procedures. |
| Holdsworth J et al., 1999 [ | Single institution prospective randomized clinical trial | 25 patients with infective and potentially infective complications of vascular bypass grafting | Use of GCCI in prevention and treatment of SSI | In situ prevention and treatment of graft infection | 7/11 in situ treatments of a graft infection were successfully aborted; in the other 4 grafts were removed. None of the other 14 patients treated with GCCI subsequently had infective sequelae. |