| Literature DB >> 35187851 |
Adam S Tenforde1, Haylee E Borgstrom1, Stephanie DeLuca1, Molly McCormack1, Mani Singh2, Jennifer Soo Hoo3, Phillip H Yun4.
Abstract
Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35187851 PMCID: PMC9321712 DOI: 10.1002/pmrj.12790
Source DB: PubMed Journal: PM R ISSN: 1934-1482 Impact factor: 2.218
Proposed cellular mechanisms of action for extracorporeal shockwave therapy
| Increased collagen synthesis | Enhanced fibroblast proliferation (increased transforming growth factor beta [TGF‐β]) and upregulation of collagen I and III |
| Regulation of scleraxis, tenomodulin | |
| Cellular proliferation and wound healing | Upregulation of tendon‐derived tenocytes |
| Increased ATP release and downstream extracellular signal‐regulated kinase activation | |
| Enhancement of osteogenesis | |
| IL‐6 and IL‐8 mediated tendon remodeling | |
| Pain reduction | Gate‐control theory |
| Modifies substance P release | |
| Decreased calcitonin‐gene‐related peptide | |
| Neovascularization | Induction of TGF‐βI and insulin‐like growth factor I |
| Decrease in soft tissue calcifications | |
| Decrease in inflammation | |
Specific postulated mechanisms of action of extracorporeal shockwave therapy
| Pathology | Mechanism of action |
|---|---|
| Tendons |
Decreased edema and inflammatory cell infiltration within tendons Tissue regeneration via conversion of mechanical stimulation to biochemical signal Increase transforming growth factor beta‐1 and insulin‐like growth factor I levels to stimulate tenocyte and collagen proliferation (important in healing) Scleraxis upregulation (promotes tendon growth and development) Proliferation of anti‐inflammatory cytokines Increased proliferation and migration of tendon‐derived tenocytes Decreased metalloproteinase expression (enzymes that can degrade collagen) Reduction of inflammatory interleukins |
| Bones |
Protein upregulation may enhance angiogenesis and neovascularization of the bone Osteogenesis and bone remodeling by release of growth factors Bone morphogenic protein 2 Vascular endothelial growth factor Promotion of periosteal bone formation Decreased osteoclast activity Increased osteoblast activity |
| Joints (knee) |
Decreased inflammation Decreased edema Improvements in subchondral bone architecture Increased chondrocyte activity (cartilaginous repair) |
| Spasticity |
Decreased spasticity at the level of the muscle and neuromuscular junction Reduced rigidity of connective tissues (muscle level) Stimulate synthesis of nitric oxide Neuromuscular junction formation Neovascularization |
Extracorporeal shockwave therapy treatment parameters
| Parameter/Variable | Description or unit |
|---|---|
| Depth of focus | Dependent on targeted pathology |
| Shockwave device | Multiple types on market |
| Time interval between treatments | Typically 1 week |
| Total number of treatments | Typically 3–5 |
| Local anesthesia | Recommend none |
| Image guidance | Recommend clinical focusing |
| Type of shockwave therapy | Focused, radial, combined |
| Total number of impulses per treatment | Pulses |
| Impulse frequency | Number of shockwaves applied per second |
| Maximal positive pressure | Maximal positive pressure reached during treatment, measured in bar |
| Energy flux density (EFD) | Amount of energy/surface area, measured in mJ/mm2 |
| Total energy dose (TED) | EFD x total number of impulses = TED |
Didactic and clinical components for extracorporeal shockwave therapy (ESWT) core curriculum
| ESWT core curriculum components | |
|---|---|
| Didactic | |
| Lectures | Principles of ESWT: Introduction to physics, knobology, safety protocols/techniques, ergonomics, informed consent (risks, benefits, side effects), time‐out protocols, and basic ESWT applications |
| Hands‐on demonstration sessions | Led by senior residents, fellows, and/or attendings |
| Trainee practice sessions | Direct supervision and feedback from senior residents, fellows, and/or attendings |
| Clinical | |
| Rotation orientation | Review of milestones, competencies, and rotation goals |
| Faculty observation | Preprocedural, procedural, and postprocedural protocols |
| Progressive trainee performance | Direct faculty supervision with procedural invovlement based on current milestone achievement |
| Feedback sessions | Both formal sessions at specific time points during rotation (ie, midpoint), as well as informal/immediate feedback during procedure or debriefing session afterward to allow for focused practice aligned with milestone goals |
| Procedural documentation | Review of necessary elements and/or billing procedure if applicable |
| Competency assessment | Based on outlined ESWT milestones in Table |
Sample extracorporeal shockwave therapy (ESWT) milestones for trainee education with associated target competencies
| Procedural skills: Extracorporeal shockwave therapy | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Level 0 | Level 1 | Level 2 | Level 3 | Level 4 (Graduation target) | Level 5 (Aspirational) |
|
Foundational understanding of ESWT principles: ‐Physics ‐Knobology ‐Ergonomics ‐Safety protocols |
Clinical knowledge of ESWT application: ‐Indications for use (radial vs. focused) ‐Risks ‐Benefits ‐Side effects ‐Contraindications |
Demonstration or verbal description of appropriate protocols in a simulated setting: Preprocedural: ‐Setup ‐Positioning & ergonomics ‐Informed consent Procedural: ‐Device placement & settings ‐Titration goal ‐Anatomic landmarks, etc. Postprocedural: ‐Patient counseling ‐Device cleaning Performance of informed consent and time‐out in a clinical setting Performance of beginner level ESWT procedures with |
Performance of beginner/intermediate level ESWT procedures with supervision + little to no hands‐on assistance (may require verbal assistance) Ability to titrate dose based on clinical response Generates appropriate documentation |
Performance of advanced level ESWT procedures with supervision + little to no assistance Experience across an expanding spectrum of diagnoses and patient‐specific factors, requiring individualization of care Ability to suggest protocol modifications based on clinical response Teaching of peers Publication of peer‐reviewed work related to ESWT with significant faculty mentorship |
Performance of Independent modification of treatment protocols to achieve targeted and measurable patient outcomes with integration of current literature and evidence‐based treatment plans Teaching of peers and faculty Independent publication of peer‐reviewed work related to ESWT |
|
□ □ □ □ □ □ □ □ □ □ □ Selection of a box between levels indicates that some, but not all, milestones in the higher level have been achieved. | |||||
| Comments: | |||||
Proposed progression of clinical teaching based on trainee experience and procedural complexity
| Procedural experience | Appropriate clinical teaching with example diagnoses |
|---|---|
| Beginner |
Superficial soft tissue structures Plantar fasciopathy Large muscle‐tendon units (without inclusion of adjacent bone) Achilles tendinopathy (noninsertional) |
| Intermediate |
Muscle‐tendon‐bone units (with inclusion of adjacent bony origin or insertion) Achilles tendinopathy (insertional) Patellar tendinopathy Proximal hamstring tendinopathy Spasticity |
| Advanced |
Bone stress injury/stress fracture Joints/periarticular structures Tibiotalar, subtalar joints Arthropathy‐related marrow edema Avascular necrosis Structures that require ultrasound expertise for targeted treatment Calcific tendinopathy Structures adjacent to key neurovascular, reproductive, or other anatomy including lung parenchyma Osteitis pubis Spine/axial indications |
FIGURE 1Left photograph with poor ergonomic positioning. Right photograph with proper ergonomic positioning
Summary of shockwave procedure and postprocedure guidelines
| Procedure Guidelines |
Shockwave dose Start with low energy levels, titrate up as tolerated. Treatment Use of analgesia may reduce ability to use clinical focusing technique. Treatment timeline Generally 3‐5 sessions with the exception of treatment for bone and spasticity at 1 week intervals. |
| Post‐Procedure Guidelines |
Medications/modalities Avoidance of nonsteroidal anti‐inflammatory drugs, ice, fluoroquinolones, and corticosteroids. Acetaminophen can be used for pain relief. Physical therapy Couple with ESWT to restore tissue function and potentially optimize treatment response. Return to activity Lack of post‐procedure immobilization except in selective cases Activity limitation |
Potential risks and side effects of extracorporeal shockwave therapy
| Local effects | Pain at applicator site |
| Skin erythema | |
| Skin bruising | |
| Hematoma formation | |
| Nerve irritation with numbness or tingling | |
| Superficial edema | |
| Systemic effects | Headache |
| Migraine |
Contraindications to extracorporeal shockwave therapy
| Absolute contraindications (all energy treatments) | Active infection (ie, osteomyelitis) |
| Malignant tumor (focused shockwave) | |
| Pregnancy | |
| Relative contraindications (high‐energy treatments) | Brain or nerve in treatment focus |
| Lung or pleura in treatment focus | |
| Significant coagulopathy | |
| Epiphyseal plate in treatment focus | |
| Important considerations | Cardiac pacemakers or other implantable devices |
| Current nonsteroidal anti‐inflammatory druguse | |
| Current anticoagulation use | |
| Recent corticosteroid injections |