Adam Szukalski1, Przemysław Krawczyk2, Bouchta Sahraoui3, Beata Jędrzejewska4. 1. Wroclaw University of Science and Technology, Faculty of Chemistry, Wyb. Wyspiańskiego 27, 50-370 Wrocław, Poland. 2. Nicolaus Copernicus University, Collegium Medicum, Faculty of Pharmacy, Kurpińskiego 5, 85-950 Bydgoszcz, Poland. 3. Laboratoire MOLTECH-Anjou, Université d'Angers, UFR Sciences, UMR 6200, CNRS, 2 Bd. Lavoisier, 49045, Angers Cedex, France. 4. Bydgoszcz University of Science and Technology, Faculty of Chemical Technology and Engineering, Seminaryjna 3, 85-326 Bydgoszcz, Poland.
Abstract
An optical control of many working optoelectronic systems (real-time sensors, optical modulators, light amplifiers, or phase retarders) giving efficient optical gain or remote signal modulation is currently included as scientifically and industrially interesting. In here, an oxazolone derivative as the multifunctional organic system is given in this contribution. The molecule possesses a stilbene group and an oxazolone heteroatomic ring, which implies effective refractive index manipulation and multimode lasing action, respectively. The light modulation is repeatable and stable, also in the hundreds of Hz regime. On the other hand, the amplified optical signal can be easily generated by an external optical pumping source. Thus, signal control is fully available, as is read-in and read-out of the information in real time. Furthermore, this third-order, nonlinear, optical phenomenon using a third harmonic generation technique was also observed. We discovered that only by changing the energy and time regime of the supplied optical signal is the optical or nonlinear optical response observed. Two heteroenergetic molecular states (trans (E) and cis (Z)) can efficiently operate in modern multifunctional optoelectronic systems, which can provide and generate an optical signal. Such functionalities are commonly used in all-optical photonic switchers and logic gates and can be utilized in optical-core networks and computers.
An optical control of many working optoelectronic systems (real-time sensors, optical modulators, light amplifiers, or phase retarders) giving efficient optical gain or remote signal modulation is currently included as scientifically and industrially interesting. In here, an oxazolone derivative as the multifunctional organic system is given in this contribution. The molecule possesses a stilbene group and an oxazolone heteroatomic ring, which implies effective refractive index manipulation and multimode lasing action, respectively. The light modulation is repeatable and stable, also in the hundreds of Hz regime. On the other hand, the amplified optical signal can be easily generated by an external optical pumping source. Thus, signal control is fully available, as is read-in and read-out of the information in real time. Furthermore, this third-order, nonlinear, optical phenomenon using a third harmonic generation technique was also observed. We discovered that only by changing the energy and time regime of the supplied optical signal is the optical or nonlinear optical response observed. Two heteroenergetic molecular states (trans (E) and cis (Z)) can efficiently operate in modern multifunctional optoelectronic systems, which can provide and generate an optical signal. Such functionalities are commonly used in all-optical photonic switchers and logic gates and can be utilized in optical-core networks and computers.
Hybrid organic materials
(OMs) have attracted attention recently
due to many reasons, namely, a broad range of chemical synthesis possibilities,
low fabrication costs, versatility in various applications, and their
biofriendly character.[1−3] Both active and passive organic systems were considered
due to their interesting linear and nonlinear optical (NLO) functionalities.[4−6] OMs have found plenty of recommendations in diversified disciplines,
such as photonics,[7−9] organic electronics,[10,11] and optical
networks, including logic gates[12] or sensing.[2,13] Therefore, a large number of practical devices are commonly used
in the industrial, analytical, or scientific domains. However, two
significantly different approaches are currently employed. The materials
are supposed to be individually featured for certain utilizations
(like in medicine, theranostics is used,[14] or in material science, where a peculiar polymer, with its unique
rheological or structural properties, is used[15]), or their high compatibility and multifunctionality (versatile
OMs[16−19]) are expected.Considering just the light-controlled organic
materials, the photochromic
polymers should be distinguished.[20,21] However, macromolecules
can also serve just as the inert and passive branched matrix. Then,
a low-molecular compound acts as the active component, and its properties
give the final multiple material functionality.[22] There are many examples of such working organic systems.
Interestingly, in the field of spectroscopy and nonlinear optics,
such OM utilization was observed recently. Multiarmed structures with
various symmetries characterized efficient two-photon absorption (TPA)
and a photorefraction phenomena.[23] Depending
on the arm type in such synthesized molecules, their NLO properties
are different. Intriguingly, the centrosymmetric NLO active system
did not give any of photorefraction effect. Such an investigation
approach leads to the construction of solid-state optical limiting
devices and TPA-excited photorefractive systems. Furthermore, an efficient
third-order NLO active system (polyoxometalates functionalized by
porphyrin-based Schiff base), also characterizing catalytic properties,
was recently presented in the literature.[24]Oxazolones have been of great interest in medicine since the
1980s.[25−27] They are used in chemically induced protocol models
of intestinal
inflammation.[28] However, the oxazolones
(together with pyrazolones and pyrazolines) were also investigated
in the context of their spectroscopic properties.[29] There are few contributions in the literature presenting
the oxazolone synthesis route and the basic spectroscopic properties
(absorption and emission spectra).[30] Giving
an example, the experimental and theoretical studies were performed
to describe the influence of solvent polarity on the spectroscopic
features of the oxazolone derivative.[31,32] Due to the
aforementioned properties, the oxazolones found an application in
sensing (in particular, in precise Fe3+ ion detection[33]) or biosensing (acetylcholine reversible detector[34]). It was found that oxazolone derivatives (as
the green fluorescent proteins) characterize photophysical properties
quite similar to the bioluminescent organisms existing in nature.[35] Importantly, the NLO properties also were determined
in the group of oxazolones. A significant TPA phenomenon,[36−38] or a third-order nonlinear optical response (investigated in the
degenerate four wave mixing experimental setup),[39] was reported.Here, we present a low-molecular multifunctional
oxazolone derivative
characterizing efficient optical and nonlinear optical properties.
The introduced compound can serve as a productive light amplifier,
generator (of higher harmonics of light), and electromagnetic wave
modulator in the submicroseconds time scale. To the best of our knowledge,
it is the first report on the oxazolone derivative being such a comprehensive
organic-based hybrid material. An acquired optical gain profile indicates
that the oxazolone derivative is a highly effective laser dye. Furthermore,
it was experimentally proven that the hybrid polymeric system doped
with the investigated molecule provides a three times higher third-order
NLO signal than the reference material. Finally, an all-optical switching
phenomenon was observed, giving a stable and reversible nonlinear
optical response when the pump channel is modulated in the range of
hundreds of Hz.
Experimental Section
Synthesis and Structural
Analysis
All solvents (spectroscopic
grade, Table S1 in the Supporting Information (SI)), hippuric acid, cinnamaldehyde, and acetic anhydride
were purchased from either Aldrich Chemical Co. or Chemat Co. Poland,
and they were used without further purification.The oxazolone
dye, 4-(3′-phenyl-2′-propenylidene)-phenylooxazol-5(4H)-one, was synthesized in our laboratory according to the
method described by Luna et al.[40] and Khan
et al.[41] The route for the synthesis is
presented in Figure , and details are given in the SI.
Figure 1
Route for the
synthesis of 4-(3′-phenyl-2′-propenylidene)-phenylooxazol-5(4H)-one (its acronym, Ox-π,π-Ph, with marked
significant regions; red: oxazolone ring; blue: two conjugated π-bonds
creating stilbene groups in the final product).
Route for the
synthesis of 4-(3′-phenyl-2′-propenylidene)-phenylooxazol-5(4H)-one (its acronym, Ox-π,π-Ph, with marked
significant regions; red: oxazolone ring; blue: two conjugated π-bonds
creating stilbene groups in the final product).
Characterization
Spectral Measurements of the Solutions
Electronic absorption
spectra for an approximately 10–5 M dye solution
in solvent of different polarities were recorded at room temperature
on a Shimadzu UV–vis Multispec-1501 spectrophotometer. Emission
spectra were obtained from a Hitachi F-7100 fluorescence spectrophotometer.
The solution concentration was about 10–6 M.The fluorescence quantum yield (FQY) was calculated from eq :[42]where ϕdye and ϕref are the FQY of the dye and the reference, respectively; Idye and Iref are
the integrated intensities (areas) of the sample and reference spectra,
respectively (in units of photons); ndye and nref are the refractive indexes
of the solvents used for the dye and the reference, respectively.
The absorbances (A) of both the dye and the reference
solution at an excitation wavelength (380–404 nm) were about
0.1. Coumarin 153 in ethanol (ϕref = 0.38[42]) was used as the reference. The solvent effect
on the spectral properties of the tested dye was analyzed, applying
a multilinear correlation based on the four-parameter Catalán[43] solvent scale (Table S1 in the SI).
Photostability
The photostability
experiments were
carried out in a quartz cuvette with dimensions of 4 × 1 ×
1 cm that was placed in a horizontal position to ensure complete absorption
of light (the optical path length = 4 cm). An approximately 1.5 ×
10–5 M solution of the dye in ethyl acetate was
stirred and irradiated through the bottom wall of the cuvette with
a diode-pumped solid state (DPSS, Shanghai Dream Lasers) laser light
at 408 nm (light power of 35 mW). The bleaching of the dye at the
absorption peak was monitored as a function of time. Therefore, the
absorption spectra were recorded at different times during the irradiation.
Computational Details
All geometrical parameters of
the investigated molecules in their ground (SGS) and excited
states (SCT) were calculated using density functional theory
(DFT) approach implemented in Gaussian 09 program package[44] with TIGHT threshold option and PBE0/6-311++G(d,p)
basis set. To verify that all the structures correspond to the minima
on the potential energy surface, an analysis of Hessians was performed.
The electronic properties were characterized by computations of the
vertical absorption and emission spectra, which were obtained using
the time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT/PBE0)[45] and by including the state-specific (SS) corrected
linear response (cLR) approach.[46] All spectroscopic
calculations were performed using the standard-hybrid PBE0[47,48] functional. The dipole moments and polarities of the charge-transfer
state (CT) were evaluated by numerical differentiation of the excitation
energies (E) in the presence of an electric field F of 0.001 au strength:where i stands for the Cartesian
component of the dipole moment difference. The isotropic average polarizability
(α), polarizability anisotropy (Δα), and first-order
hyperpolarizability (βvec) were determined based
on the Gaussian 09 program and defined aswhere
β (i = x, y, z) is given by .The density differences were obtained
at the PBE0/6-311++G(d,p) level and are represented with a contour
threshold of 0.02 au. In the graphs (e) and (f) in Figure , the blue (purple) zones indicate
density decrease (increase) upon electronic transition. The charge
transfer parameters, namely, the charge-transfer distance (DCT) and the amount of transferred charge (qCT), have been determined following a Le Bahers’
procedure.[49] The solvent effect on the
linear and nonlinear optical properties has been taken into account
using the Integral Equation Formalism for the Polarizable Continuum
Model (IEF-PCM).[50,51]
Figure 4
Physicochemical properties
of the E (left column)
and Z (right column) Ox-π,π-Ph isomers.
ΔG energy in a water environment and orientation
of the dipole moment vectors for the ground state (a, b); HOMO–LUMO
and their gap energy in gas (3.2488 and 3.6701 eV) and water (3.2292
and 3.6233 eV) environments (c, d); density difference for gas (DCT = 1.027 Å, qCT = 0.323e, and DCT =
1.505 Å, qCT = 0.505e) and water (DCT = 1.216 Å, qCT = 0.355e, and DCT = 1.685 Å, qCT = 0.504e) environments (e, f); and MEP in gas (±0.04640 and
±0.05160) and water (±0.05462 and ±0.06279) phases
for E and Z isomers, respectively.
Solid State Spectroscopy
For the needs of the spectroscopic
studies of the Ox-π,π-Ph chromophore in the solid state,
functionalized thin polymeric films were prepared. A commercially
available polymer–poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) in the powder
form (Mw = 120 kDa) served as the branched
matrix (host material). At first, a mixture of the dye (guest) and
polymer (host), using dichloromethane (DCM) solvent, was prepared.
The dye constituted a 2% dry mass of polymer. After mixing at room
temperature, a homogeneous solution (400 μL) was deposited separately
onto a silica glass plate by the drop casting (d-c) and spin-coating
(s-c) techniques (dependent on the future destination), respectively.
The d-c thin film was formed together with the DCM atmosphere over
the next 2 days. Such a prepared layer (drop-casted) was investigated
using a spectrophotometer (Hitachi U-1900) and a spectrofluorometer
(Hitachi Fluoromax-4). The spin-coated layer was stored in the darks
after being prepared at room temperature and in an ambient atmosphere.
Additionally, the d-c and s-c film thickness values were measured
by a profilometer (Dektak-3), and they are equal to 14.08 and 1.92
μm, respectively. The light amplification studies, but also
the following second and third-order NLO effects (optical Kerr effect
and second harmonic generation), require a significant active system’s
volume in order to (i) effectively induce the lasing
action (inverted Boltzmann distribution generation),
(ii) generate optical birefringence (induce molecular
reorientation), or (iii) break symmetry using the
corona poling technique toward noncentrosymmetry. For the purposes
of the third harmonic generation phenomenon investigation, where it
was previously required, the spin-coated layer was utilized (in that
way any of reabsorption processes during the experiment were minimized).The light amplification studies were performed using an experimental
setup, where a nanosecond pulsed laser source (Surelite II, Continuum, f = 10 Hz, t = 6 ns, λ = 355 nm)
was utilized (Figure S1(a)). However, the
fundamental laser beam wavelength was switched at 420 nm thanks to
the use of optical parametric oscillator (OPO, Horizon, Continuum).
Such an optical adjustment is allowed to develop the laser setup to
the investigated system (the incident laser beam was in resonance
with the laser dye, which provides its efficient Boltzmann redistribution
conversion, leading to the radiative nature of energy dissipation).[52] The linearly polarized incident laser spot (in
the typical round shape) was obtained after spatial conversion thanks
to the mounted lens system characterized the stripe-shape view. In
this manner, the excitation laser beam hit the sample in a controllable
way, localized close to the edge of substrate. The Variable Stripe
Length (VSL) method[53] was used in order
to investigate an optical gain profile in the active system (Figure S1(b)). Thanks to the linear shape of
the excited area, the output light amplification ray was directed
toward the sample’s edge, which resulted in its efficiency
maximization. The other directions of LA were laden according to light
diffusion or reabsorption phenomena (Figure S1(c)). The output signal was collected by a high resolution spectrometer
(Shamrock 163, ANDOR Solis) equipped with an external 200 μm
optical fiber. The acquired emission characterized the optical gain
profile, which is typical for a multimode random lasing (RL).[52,53] Since the light enhancement is represented by the existence of multiple
laser modes, the Power Fourier Transform (PFT) was helpful with the
optical resonator dimension estimation.[54,55] The optical
resonators can be defined in two various models, namely, in the Whispering
Gallery Modes (WGM)[56] (eq ) or in Fabry–Perot ones,
respectively[57] (eq ):where m and pm denote the ordering
and magnitude of the analyzed PFT
signals (the emission wavelength was expressed by a k factor (1/μm)). The pm number
should give periodically and proportionally increasing values with
the lower intensity, whereas the nres and nenv represent the refractive index value of
the active system and the experimental environment, respectively.
In our case, the nres was equal to 1.5031,
which corresponds to the PMMA refractive index value at 420 nm.[58] Subsequently, the nenv comes from the air (1.0003).[59] Thanks
to the additional RL spectra output analysis (average of 20 collected
spectra), like emission integration or the full width at half-maximum
(fwhm) parameter, the energy threshold estimation was performed.
Nonlinear Optics
Optical Kerr Effect (OKE) and third
harmonic generation phenomena represent third-order NLO effects. It
means that the active medium symmetry does not influence so far on
the output results, like in the case of the second-order phenomena,
for example, second-harmonic generation.[60,61] The OKE phenomenon is also connected with a molecular reorientation
process, or all-optical switching, where the NLO medium is susceptible
to the influence of a high energy laser light source, which complies
with the chromophore’s absorption resonance. In such a way,
the conformational conversion induced by the electromagnetic wave
reflects in the optical anisotropy generation. It is strictly involved
with molecular movements and transformations between lower in energy
and stable states (usually, trans (or E) conformers) and higher in energy, metastable forms (cis (or Z) ones). Due to the photons absorption probability
(P = cos2(α), where α denotes
an angle between the input laser polarization direction and its molecular
equivalent), the molecules are oriented in a particular way, giving
as the result the refractive index anisotropy (photoinduced birefringence,
Δn (Ipump,t)).[60,61] The just-mentioned interaction
between laser light and the NLO active medium is responsible for the
refractive index indicatrix deformation, which reflects on the second,
nonlinear refractive index (n2) generation,
according to the following equation:Optical anisotropy generation is strictly
involved with phase change (Δφ), which is consequently
related with pump laser beam intensity (Ipump) over time Δφ(Ipump, t)a:where d denotes the sample
thickness, λref is the monitoring laser beam wavelength
(called also reference or reading beam), n∥(Ipump, t) and n⊥(Ipump, t) refer to the parallel and perpendicular components of
the NLO chromophore refractive index (coming from its indicatrix)
with respect to the polarization direction of the pump; Δn(Ipump, t)
means the photoinduced birefringence in Ipump and time and function, respectively.[60,61] After a few
simple transformations of eq , a clear relation can be distinguished between NLO and the
experimental setup parameters, which is shown below:[60,61]where Iout and Iin denote to the
reference laser beam intensity
behind the analyzer and before the polarizer (the initial one), respectively.
The geometrical component (sin2(2α)) from eq was simplified and is
equal to 1, because the pump laser polarization configuration was
aligned at 45° due to the reference one.Second and third
harmonic generations (SHG and THG, respectively)
represent second and third-order NLO effects,[60,61] accordingly. Only noncentrosymmetric NLO active media can efficiently
give SHG signal. The other ones, due to the theoretical reasons described
elsewhere, cannot (it stems from the annihilation of the second-order
susceptibility).[60,61] From this reason, the centrosymmetric
systems (i.e., thin polymeric films doped with NLO chromophores) need
to undergo a special thermoelectric treatment (corona-poling).[62,63] Drop-casted thin film is at first (1) heated up slightly above the
glass temperature (this parameter corresponds directly to the utilized
polymer); (2) controlled high voltage (typically 5 or 10 kV) is then
applied to two opposite plates or other electrical conductors (needles/wires,
oriented perpendicular to the sample’s surface), but at the
same moment, the heating system is switched off; (3) thermal relaxation
with the electric current ordering is ongoing until the thin film
again reaches the room-temperature conditions. Usually, after a few
hours, the thin polymeric film doped with polar low-molecular chromophores
is solidified and the characteristic symmetry is broken, and in that
shape, it is able to give the SHG signal. THG experiments do not require
any particular conditions related with molecular symmetry, so that
step can be skipped during sample preparation. The laser setup, where
Maker fringes are generated and investigated via a comparable method,
is already described in detail elsewhere in the literature.[64−66] Briefly, a fundamental beam, provided by a picosecond pulsed laser
equipped with an electronic system that controls and triggers all
signals, is focalized on the sample surface. The active medium in
the shape of film or crystal is then twisted on the rotational stage,
typically from −80° up to 80° (or −60°
to 60°).[64−66] Before and behind the sample there is a crossed-polarizer
system that can provide additional information about spatial SHG properties.
Finally, generated NLO response (SHG or THG) is delivered to the photomultiplier
equipped with a dedicated filter (to separate fundamental and generated
laser modes). The SHG signal can be analyzed according to the Lee
model (eq ):[67]where
χ(2) and χq(2) refer to the
second-order nonlinear optical susceptibility value for the investigated
and reference material, which is quartz in our case (),[68] respectively.
Subsequently, the lc,q defines
the quartz coherence length (eq ), and d refers to the thickness of
the investigated system. The I2ω and Iq2ω refer to the measured second harmonic signal intensity
for the sample and quartz, respectively.where λω denotes the
fundamental beam wavelength and nqω and nq2ω are the
refractive indices values for 1064 nm (1.534) and 532 nm (1.547),
respectively.[69]While the third harmonic
of light generation phenomenon can be
estimated in a reliable way thanks to the Kubodera and Kobayashi theoretical
model (eq ).[70] In this case, a silica slab serves as the reference
material with a known third-order NLO susceptibility value ( at 1064 nm[71,72]). Whereas,
according to eq ,
it is possible to define the considered third-order NLO parameter
for the investigated medium as follows:where α and d define
the absorption coefficient at the third harmonic of light (355 nm)
and sample thickness, accordingly (such approach is correct, when
transmittance is less than 0.9). The I3ω and I3ωs refer to the THG signal intensity collected
for the investigated material and silica, accordingly, while the Lcs parameter is the coherence length of silica, defined as follows
(eq ):where ns3ω and nsω describe
the refractive indices for the silica at 355 nm (1.4761) and 1064
nm (1.4496), respectively.[73,74]
Results
and Discussion
Synthetic Procedure and Molecular Design
The 4-(3′-phenyl-2′-propenylidene)-phenylooxazol-5(4H)-one (Ox-π,π-Ph) was synthesized using a method
described earlier,[40,41] taking hippuric acid as the substrate
in the reaction with cinnamaldehyde in the presence of acetic anhydride
and anhydrous sodium acetate. The detailed synthetic route with NMR
and IR spectra analysis is presented in the SI.The design concept of the compound is based on the 5-(4H)-oxazolone ring, which is the precursor of the green fluorescent
proteins chromophore and constitutes an electron-withdrawing part
of the molecule. From both sides of the heterocycle ring (at 2 and
4 positions) there are aromatic rings that create terminal moieties
with an electron-donating character. They have the net effect of increasing
electron density in the molecule. One of the phenyl rings is bonded
to the 5-(4H)-oxazolone by two π-conjugated
double bonds that are responsible for high molecular flexibility.
Thus, its structure, especially the presence of methine groups and
an oxazolone ring, will have an influence on the photophysical and
photochemical properties of the dye due to the possibility of conformational
transformations (i.e., E-Z-E) or partial molecular
rotation.Since the dye may exist in different isomers, the
DFT equilibrium
geometries of the compound were optimized both in the gas phase and
in water environments. The optimized structures of the most stable E and Z conformers of the Ox-π,π-Ph
molecule are presented in Figure , and the data are collected in Tables S2 and S3 (atom numbering is shown in Figure S2).
Figure 2
Optimized structures of the Ox-π,π-Ph isomers.
Transition
state geometry obtained from the QST3 approximation (wb97xd/TZVP).
Optimized structures of the Ox-π,π-Ph isomers.
Transition
state geometry obtained from the QST3 approximation (wb97xd/TZVP).There are several local minima on the Potential
Energy Surface
(PES); however, in this study, a detailed analysis of the linear and
nonlinear optical properties is presented only for the minima characterizing
the lowest energy of the E and Z isomers. The Z conformer is 7 kcal/mol higher in
energy than the E one. The estimated barrier of E → Z isomerization amounts to slightly
over 10 kcal/mol in GP, whereas the ΔE decreases
to 9.14 kcal/mol in a water environment. According to the relaxed
scan of the PES along two torsion angles (Figure S3), based on the wB97xd functional,[75] it results mainly from the change in the ΘC6=C8—C9=C10
angle, that is, from 0.00° to 94.36° during the forming
of the TS structure. In the case of the ΘC8—C9=C10—C11
angle, the change is from 180.00° to 178.78°. For the discussed
derivative, the path of formation of the TS structure follows the
rotation of the C=C double bond. At the point of the π-bond
rupture, a zwitterionic intermediate forms, generating an anionic
carbon center and a corresponding carbocation. The zwitterion contains
a C—C single bond, thus, permitting the complete rotation.
Another important feature is the development of the C=C double
bond character within the transition state.[76] The analysis of structural parameters revealed a high sensitivity
to the environmental changes for the bond lengths and dihedral angles
of Ox-π,π-Ph, as well as to those occurring during photoexcitation
to the first singlet excited state (SCT). The most important
selected geometry parameters for these conformers are listed in Tables S2–S4. Primarily, during the reduction
of the C1—C2 bond length as the solvent polarity increases,
the approach of the phenyl ring to oxazolone can be observed. At the
same time, the C4=O5 double bond is elongated, and the O5 oxygen
atom approaches the O3 atom. This is the result of a decrease in the
ΘO3—C4—O5 angle with a simultaneous increase in
the ΘO5—C4—C6 and ΘO5—C4—C6—C8
angles. The environment polarity also affects the π-electron
bridge. The C6=C8 and C9=C10 double bonds are elongated
with a simultaneous reduction of the C8—C9 and C10—C11
single bonds. The length of the sternum also changes. The angles ΘC6=C8—C9
and C9=C10—C11 are elongated, while the C8—C9=C10
angle is slightly shortened. The solvent polarity does not affect
the C12—O14 bond, however, it promotes the extension of O14—C15.According to the experimental results, the compound showed good
photochemical stability under the measurement conditions (Figure S4), since visible light irradiation of
the oxazolone dye in ethyl acetate does not cause distinct changes
in the electronic absorption spectra. After 85 min of irradiation
with a DPSS laser (408 nm) with a light intensity of 35 mW at room
temperature, the intensity of the long-wavelength absorption band
decreased only 5% without any changes in its position.
UV–Vis
Absorption and Fluorescence Spectra in Solutions
The solvent
effect on the UV–vis absorption and fluorescence
spectra of the Ox-π,π-Ph studied in various organic solvents
at room temperature is shown in Figure , whereas the corresponding photophysical data are
collected in Table .
Figure 3
Normalized electronic absorption (a) and fluorescence (b) spectra
of Ox-π,π-Ph in n-hexane (Hex), tetrahydrofuran
(THF), and dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO).
Table 1
Main Photophysical Parametersa of Ox-π,π-Ph
solvent
λmaxAb
ε
fwhmAb
λmaxFl
fwhmFl
Δν
ϕFl
Hex
381
64000
3892.7
454
3925.7
4220
0.256
TMP
381
58600
3937.1
453
3986.9
4172
0.279
MCH
382
63300
3895.1
455
3911.9
4200
0.285
Bu2O
383
52000
3898.3
461
4116.3
4418
0.247
Et2O
382.5
58100
4041.5
466
4573.6
4685
0.065
EtOAc
386
60600
3920.4
476
5050.4
4898
0.068
THF
388
58500
3931.3
479
4707.1
4896
0.069
MeAc
384
51700
4254.2
480
5383.9
5208
0.039
MeCN
384.5
55500
4008.0
482
5877.2
5261
0.026
DMF
389
54100
3994.4
488
5375.5
5215
0.033
DMSO
392
51400
3944.6
492
5078.0
5185
0.038
1-BuOH
385.5
54470
3975.0
472
4432.2
4754
0.066
2-PrOH
386.5
51800
3963.1
470
4573.6
4597
0.057
1-PrOH
385.5
50800
4036.5
472
4560.7
4754
0.066
EtOH
386.5
49400
3962.7
477
4738.0
4909
0.053
MeOH
385.5
50600
4270.0
480
5364.5
5107
0.024
Absorption (λmaxAb, nm), maximum
extinction coefficient (ε, 104 M–1 cm–1), fluorescence maxima (λmaxFl, nm), full
width at half-maximum (fwhm; cm–1), Stokes shift
(Δν, cm–1), and fluorescence quantum
yield (ϕFl, %).
Normalized electronic absorption (a) and fluorescence (b) spectra
of Ox-π,π-Ph in n-hexane (Hex), tetrahydrofuran
(THF), and dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO).Absorption (λmaxAb, nm), maximum
extinction coefficient (ε, 104 M–1 cm–1), fluorescence maxima (λmaxFl, nm), full
width at half-maximum (fwhm; cm–1), Stokes shift
(Δν, cm–1), and fluorescence quantum
yield (ϕFl, %).The UV–vis absorption spectra of Ox-π,π-Ph (Figures a and S5(a)) show one main band in which the position,
intensity, and shape change with the solvent used. In aprotic nonpolar
solvents, the absorption maximum is localized at ∼380 nm, and
the spectra reveal a clear vibrational fine structure. With increasing
solvent polarity, the first (S0 → S1)
band is slightly red-shifted and reaches a maximum at 392 nm in DMSO.
It is almost structureless. In the case of polar protic solvents,
the dye shows a limited absorption band maxima diversity with a maximum
located close to 386 nm. Additionally, the long-wavelength band of
the dye in nonpolar aprotic solvents is about 15% more intense (the
higher ε) than the one recorded in alcohols. In general, the
molar extinction coefficient has a large value (ε ∼ 6.4
× 104 to 5.06 × 104 M–1 cm–1) and slightly decreases with increasing solvent
polarity. All of this indicates that the absorption originates due
to the π → π* transition of a charge-transfer character.Similarly, to the electronic absorption spectra, in nonpolar solvents,
such as hexane and methylcyclohexane, the fluorescence spectra of
Ox-π,π-Ph exhibits fine structure. However, when the polarity
of the solvents increased, the fluorescence bands are structureless
and red-shifted (Figures b and S5(b)). For example, in hexane,
the fluorescence emission bands of Ox-π,π-Ph exhibit a
vibrational structure and appear at 454 nm, whereas Ox-π,π-Ph
is structureless with band maximum at 492 nm in DMSO. Red-shifting
of the fluorescence maxima in the case of alcohols reaches only 8
nm, which may be due to the hydrogen-bonding ability of the solvents
that influences the stabilization of the electronic states of the
dye in a different way.However, the observed positive solvatochromism,
large Stokes shifts
(such as 5185 cm–1 in DMSO), and broadening of the
emission band, as well as the higher sensitivity of fluorescence spectra
(with respect to absorption) to the dielectric constant of the environment,
hint at an intramolecular charge transfer (ICT) character in the compound,
which is consistent with its molecular structure.[77−80]According to the computational
calculations, the charge-transfer
(CT) excitation for both conformers (E and Z) corresponds basically to the HOMO → LUMO transition
(Figure , graphs c and d). HOMO electrons are delocalized on
the entire surface of the compound, while the LUMO electrons are mostly
on the π-electron bridge. The transfer of electrons from the
benzene rings, as a donor group, toward oxazolone and the carbon bridge
is observed. This indicates that the lowest-lying excited state can
be assigned as a π–π* transition mixed with an
intramolecular charge-transfer process. Isomerization does not change
the distribution of both frontier molecular orbitals.Physicochemical properties
of the E (left column)
and Z (right column) Ox-π,π-Ph isomers.
ΔG energy in a water environment and orientation
of the dipole moment vectors for the ground state (a, b); HOMO–LUMO
and their gap energy in gas (3.2488 and 3.6701 eV) and water (3.2292
and 3.6233 eV) environments (c, d); density difference for gas (DCT = 1.027 Å, qCT = 0.323e, and DCT =
1.505 Å, qCT = 0.505e) and water (DCT = 1.216 Å, qCT = 0.355e, and DCT = 1.685 Å, qCT = 0.504e) environments (e, f); and MEP in gas (±0.04640 and
±0.05160) and water (±0.05462 and ±0.06279) phases
for E and Z isomers, respectively.There is also no significant change in the value
of the energy
separation between the HOMO → LUMO orbitals (EGAP). The ΔEGAP difference is equal to 0.42 eV in the gas phase, and it is
reduced to 0.39 eV in the aqueous phase. Although the E GAP is slightly decreased in the function of solvent polarity (Table S5), the investigated conformers are characterized
by a low value of chemical hardness (η) and should be treated
as the soft molecules with very high reactivity. Moreover, the calculated
electronegativity (χ), which is greater than 4.0 eV, indicates
an easy formation of covalent bonds during various chemical processes.
To predict reactive sites for nucleophilic (positive, blue regions)
and electrophilic (negative, red and yellow regions) attack of the
investigated conformers, the Molecular Electrostatic Potential (MEP)
surfaces were calculated (Figure , graphs g and h). The most negative region is located
on the oxygen atom O5 in the oxazolone ring (V(r) > −0.04 au). The maximum positive site is localized
on the π-electron bridge.According to the experimental
data, analyzed dye is characterized
by one strong absorption and emission band, corresponding to the HOMO
→ LUMO photoexcitation, which is described as π–π*
transition. However, non-negligible contributions from the other orbitals
may occur. For this reason, the density variation upon photoexcitation
(Δρ(r)), calculated for the first electronic
transition is graphically depicted in Figure , graphs e and f, and Table S6. For all compounds, the Δρ(r) plots show that the density depletion zones (marked in blue) are
mostly delocalized on the benzene rings. The disappearance places
on both rings are almost equally acceptable. In turn, for the molecule,
the regions of density increment (purple) are mostly localized on
the carbon bridge and oxazolone ring. At the same time, the solvent
polarity does not significantly change in the location of these regions.
This is reflected in the amount of transferred charge (qCT) and charge-transfer distance (DCT). Both qCT and DCT values are large for the Z isomer.
The ΔρCT is equal to 0.15
au (Table S6), while the ΔDCT is 0.5 Å in less
polar solvents and 0.45 Å in more polar ones. The DCT indicates the CT character and confirms the contributions
from the HOMO → LUMO transition, although minor contributions
from other orbitals should be expected.The excitation and observation
wavelengths do not significantly
influence the position and shape of both the fluorescence and fluorescence
excitation spectra (Figure S6). However,
a high discrepancy between the absorption and the fluorescence excitation
spectra occurs when the dye concentration increases (Figure S7). For high compound loadings (100 μM), the
main absorption band disappears with the simultaneous appearance of
two bands in the short and long wavelength regions of the spectrum,
respectively. The increase of the Ox-π,π-Ph concentration
up to 1 mM results in an intense, narrow band centered at 439 nm.
This behavior is typical for dyes whose molecules self-associate to
form J-aggregates.[81] The
same relation was obtained by comparing the theoretically determined
absorption maxima band for the monomer and the optimized dimer (Figure S8). The absorption bands of the J-aggregates are shifted toward longer wavelengths. In solutions
with specific interactions of the test compound with solvent molecules
(MeCN and water), the bathochromic shift is smaller (approximately
35 nm). In environments where these interactions are absent (DMF and
DMSO), the solvatochromic shift is greater and amounts to about 46
nm. Upon increasing the concentration, the fluorescence spectra becomes
broad, narrower, and moves toward longer wavelengths, which also implies
that aggregates are formed (Figure S7(b)).[81]The Ox-π,π-Ph demonstrates
a significant variability
in the fluorescence quantum yields (FQY) in different solvents. As
can be seen in Table , the FQY returned the higher values (ϕFl of 25.6%,
27.9%, 28.5%, and 24.7%, respectively) in nonpolar aprotic solvents,
like Hex, TMP, MCH, and Bu2O, than in other solvents for
which it is about an order of magnitude smaller. The decrease in the
emission intensity with increasing solvent dielectric constant is
typical for dyes exhibiting a large charge separation in their excited
state.[82,83] The lack of dual emission in polar solvents
suggests that the ICT state of Ox-π,π-Ph undergoes a nonradiative
relaxation to the ground state. Similar results were observed for
aminated derivatives of the GFP chromophore[84] and for some arylacetylenes.[85] Thus,
the vibrations and rotations around the single and double bonds separating
the oxazolone scaffold and the side phenyl rings and the charge-transfer
(CT)[86] interaction are likely to quench
the emission of the dye in solution.[87−89] The CT excited state
is a covalent (bonding) state with an opposing charge and bond localization
relative to the ground state (GS). Moreover, a low FQY in polar protic
solvents may relate to the site-selective hydrogen-bonding-induced
fluorescence quenching effect proposed by Yang et al.[90]The specific and nonspecific interactions[91,92] between the dye and solvent were analyzed by means of the Linear
Solvation Energy Relationships (LSERs) concept using Multiple Linear
Regression Analysis (MLRA) based on the four parameters scale proposed
by Catalán et al.[43]The solvatochromic
behavior of Ox-π,π-Ph is in good
agreement with the Catalán model, which correlates the spectral
shift ν of the solute with the solvent parameters that are responsible
for the polarizability (SP), dipolarity (SdP), acidity (SA), and basicity
(SB) properties of the latter:[43,93,94]Multivariable regression of the absorption and emission as
well
as Stokes shift and FQY data of Ox-π,π-Ph are summarized
in Table . The applied
Catalán linear regression analysis resulted in good fits for
all data for the oxazolone dye with correlation coefficients of 0.889,
0.938, 0.876, and 0.902 for absorption, fluorescence, Stokes shift,
and FQY, respectively. Besides FQY, these data correlate even better
with the applied model when protic solvents (alcohols) are excluded.
The standard errors are equal to 0.918, 0.988, and 0.998, respectively
(see Table S7).
Table 2
Solvatochromic
Spectral and FQY Parameters
of the Ox-π,π-Ph Dyea
ν
νAb
νFl
ΔνSS
ϕFl
ν0
27671 ± 243
23216 ± 470
4454 ± 476
0.04789 ± 0.10845
aSP
–(2247 ± 389)
–(1955 ± 752)
–(292 ± 763)
0.35721 ± 0.17372
79.7%
53.5%
13.0%
47.2%
bSdP
–(163 ± 69)
–(1360 ± 133)
1198 ± 135
–(0.25225 ± 0.03072)
5.8%
37.2%
53.5%
33.3%
cSA
–(225 ± 125)
222 ± 242
–(447 ± 245)
0.0688 ± 0.0559
8.0%
6.1%
20.0%
9.1%
dSB
–(184 ± 97)
117 ± 188
–(301 ± 191)
–(0.07857 ± 0.04339)
6.5%
3.2%
13.5%
10.4%
R2
0.889
0.938
0.876
0.9016
The corresponding coefficients
were calculated using multivariable linear regression analysis, applying
the Catalán approach. R2 is the
correlation coefficient.
The corresponding coefficients
were calculated using multivariable linear regression analysis, applying
the Catalán approach. R2 is the
correlation coefficient.Based on the contribution percentages of different polarity parameters,
solvent polarizability (SP) was found to have the highest influence
on the positions of the absorption band, whereas the solvent dipolarity,
acidity, and basicity reveal low contributions. The negative sign
of all Catalán coefficients in the absorption process indicates
a bathochromic shift with increasing solvent polarizability (SP),
dipolarity (SdP), acidity (SA), and basicity (SB), thus, the ground
state’s energy level increases through these parameters. Additionally,
since the absorption band position is mainly controlled by nonspecific
interactions resulting from solvent polarizability (SP), the absorption
arises from a polarized π–π* transition.[29]Excitation led only to insignificant changes
in the SA and SB terms,
which indicates similar acidity and basicity of the ground and excited
states[87] of the Ox-π,π-Ph dye.
On the other hand, the polarizability is reduced (a decrease in the
SP coefficient) accompanied by an increase in SdP. Thus, solvent’s
polarizability and dipolarity play an important role in solvation
of the dye upon excitation, indicating that the nonspecific solvent
effect is the factor contributing the most to the fluorescence spectral
shifts. Moreover, a marked red shift is observed with increasing both
the polarizability and the dipolarity of the environment for the compound
(negative value for a and b), whereas
an increase in acidity and basicity of the medium causes a weak blue
shift in the fluorescence maximum (positive value for c and d). However, the latter terms are negligible
in fluorescence analysis since they are characterized by the lowest
values and high standard errors. Thus, the overall shift of the fluorescence
maximum is bathochromic in more polar solvents due to a high contribution
of SdP and SP in the regression. This means that the excited state’s
energy level decreases via these parameters, and evidently, the stabilization
of the excited state increases by increasing solvent polarity.Since the shift of fluorescence maximum with an increasing of the
solvent polarity is higher than the absorption shift, it may be concluded
that there is better stabilization of the excited electronic state
relative to the ground state in a more polar environment, and there
is a rise in the dipole moment upon excitation. Analysis of the contribution
percentages of different polarity parameters highlights the importance
of the solvent dipolarity that is responsible for the Stokes shift,
whereas the solvent polarizability, acidity, and basicity have a moderate
influence. However, the correlation results, obtained according to eq (Table ), imply that the solvent polarizability
is subjected to a large error and is negligible. Furthermore, the
acidity and basicity terms, characterized by the lowest values and
significant standard errors in the Stokes shift analysis, diminished
the influence of these parameters. A high contribution of the solvent
dipolar effect may result from a balanced contribution of the two
opposing effects, that is, two aryl moieties constituting π-electronic
entities and an oxazolone ring acting as an electron-accepting group,
that cause a separation of charges by the creation of dipolar structures
oriented differently in space. Such behavior was observed in compounds
with a substituent displaying a low or moderate effect.[95]Negative values of the coefficients a, c, and d indicate a
decrease in the shift
between absorption and fluorescence spectra with an increasing polarizability
SP, acidity SA, and basicity SB, while the increase of the Stokes
shift of the dye in the Catalán solvent scale results in solvent
dipolarity (positive value for b coefficient). Following
the experimental data, the changes in the Stokes shifts with solvent
type are rather small, that is, they vary from 4200 cm–1 in MCH to 5261 cm–1 in MeCN and 5107 cm–1 in MeOH. The values of the Stokes shift are indicative of the charge
transfer transition differences in the shift when changing the solvent
from nonpolar to highly polar.Analysis of the solvent dependence
of the FQY for the Ox-π,π-Ph
chromophore indicates that the dipolarity and basicity of the solvent
contribute to the decrease in the FQY (negative sign of the parameters),
whereas the polarizability and acidity of the solvent had a positive
impact on the FQY. However, the low contribution percentages of acidity
and basicity terms as well as high standard errors for the estimated
coefficients diminished the influence of these parameters on Ox-π,π-Ph
FQY.
Linear and Nonlinear Spectroscopic Properties: Theoretical Aspects
To characterize the nature of the electronic transitions and to
assign the bands observed in the experimental absorption spectra,
the theoretical spectral properties were determined. The obtained
excitation energies (λAb) are given in Table .
Table 3
Theoretical Linear
and Nonlinear Spectroscopic
Properties of the Ox-π,π-Ph Isomers
GP
water
Z
E
Z
E
λAbvert (nm)
406.97
422.37
422.61
444.80
λAbcLR (nm)
411.36
423.85
415.79
425.79
λFLvert (nm)
491.63
487.08
529.68
475.15
μGS (D)
1.83
1.55
2.70
2.25
x
1.16
0.16
1.51
0.39
y
0.10
–1.54
–0.15
–2.22
z
–1.41
0.00
–2.23
–0.00
μCT (D)
3.98
3.10
5.40
5.74
x
–3.79
–3.24
–3.84
5.21
y
2.67
1.18
4.08
0.96
z
0.30
0.00
–0.65
0.00
linear polarizabilities
xx
359.84
582.97
496.97
801.05
xy
19.45
–6.98
32.14
–15.11
yy
218.42
215.37
318.44
317.37
yz
23.94
0.00
41.19
0.00
zx
–20.48
0.00
–29.38
0.01
zz
172.29
110.39
247.01
153.94
⟨α⟩ (a.u.)
250.18
302.91
354.14
423.94
Δα (a.u.)
171.23
429.84
226.99
582.94
first-order hyperpolarizabilities
xxx
–534.93
2396.07
–568.88
7889.80
xyy
–153.95
31.70
–443.31
87.80
xyz
–2.03
0.00
–7.36
–0.03
yzz
–22.96
–18.38
–51.80
–60.45
yxx
541.06
189.09
1656.25
647.33
yyy
227.01
35.90
683.51
55.87
yzz
0.18
13.49
37.48
34.25
zxx
–138.32
0.00
–232.65
0.67
zyy
–6.15
0.00
–53.42
0.09
zzz
60.37
0.00
71.96
–0.03
βvec (a.u.)
206.66
10.05
332.99
278.98
The effect of the solvent
on λAb is shown in Table S8. As previously
reported,[29,92,96,97] calculations of the linear optical properties were
performed using
only PBE0. Considering the vertical values, the values closest to
the experimental ones are obtained for the E isomers.
The average error for these conformers is 19.02 nm. For Z isomers, the maximum λAb shifts toward longer waves, and the
relative error of the measured values increases to 29.93. Employing
the state-specific corrected linear response (λAbcLR) approach increases
the size of this displacement (Table S9). Taking into account λAbvert and λAbcLR, it should be assumed that the occurrence
of the tested dye in the form of a Z isomer will
cause a bathochromic shift relative to E by an average
of 25 nm. Moreover, the position of the absorption maximum band of E and Z isomers is sensitive to changes
in the environmental polarity. Increasing the solvent polarity results
in a bathochromic shift of the λAbvert and λAbcLR. However, the nonmonotonous behavior
of λAb is observed. The most intense maximum above 450 nm is
almost a pure HOMO → LUMO transition for each isomer. However,
the contributions from other orbitals are not negligible. Therefore,
an additional maximum shifting toward shorter wavelengths may appear.
In the case of the Z isomer, it is associated with
HOMO–1 → LUMO and HOMO–2 → LUMO transitions,
while for the E isomer, it is associated with HOMO–1
→ LUMO and HOMO–4 → LUMO transitions.The
use of PBE0 also leads to reliable maximum fluorescence (λFL)
results (Table S10). Similar to λAb,
the closest measured values are obtained for the E isomer, with an average error of 2.89 nm. Isomerization causes a
significant bathochromic shift, and the error increases to 58.84 nm
for Z. In this case, the maximum λFL shift
cannot be clearly determined during E–Z isomerization,
as this relationship is closely dependent on the solvent. For example,
ΔλFL in Bu2O is
4.84 nm and in DMSO is 71.1 nm. In addition, in contrast to the experimental
values, theoretical ones exhibit nonmonotonous behavior in the function
of solvent polarity. In conjunction with absorption considerations,
therefore, specific interactions in the solvent–solute system
are to be expected, as well as the occurrence of H-bonds. This is
confirmed by microsolvation studies performed for the trans isomer (Figure S9), taking into account
two solvent molecules in the environment of the studied molecule.
In the case of solvents for which an increase in excitation energy
is observed during transition to a more polar solution (MeCN, H2O), a hydrogen bond is formed in the solvent–solute
system.The dipole moment values for both conformers of the
Ox-π,π-Ph
chromophore are presented in Figure (graphs a and b) and Table S11. First, for both isomers μGS and μCT, there is an increase as a function of solvent polarity. However,
the ΔμCT–GS does not exceed 3.9 D for
both isomers in the tested solvents. The highest values of μGS were observed in water for both isomers, whereas the calculated
values of the dipole moments for the CT excited state were at a maximum
in THF (μCT = 5.53 D) and in Et2O (μCT = 5.84 D) for cis and E isomers, respectively. Moreover, the Z isomer reveals
a slightly higher μGS relative to the E one irrespective of the solvent used (ΔμGS: 0.28 → 0.45 D from vacuum to water). Meanwhile,
the E isomer is characterized by a higher value of
the CT excited state dipole moment relative to Z isomer
(ΔμCT: 0.88 → 0.34 D
from vacuum to water).The polarizability and hyperpolarizability
of the molecule irradiated
with an intense laser light is given when the electric field is the
subject of much research in terms of understanding various linear
and nonlinear optical properties (NLO). In particular, these studies
include the inter-relationship of nonlinear optical properties with
the electronic structure to design new multifunctional molecules.
The calculated values for E/Z conformers
are collected in Tables and S12. For both E and Z conformers, the α, Δα, and βvec values increase monotonously with the solvent polarity.
For the E isomer, a higher value of α and a
smaller βvec relative to Z isomer
are observed. Moreover, for both conformers, linear polarizability
is higher than first-order hyperpolarizability.
Optical Gain
Investigations
The spectroscopic properties
of the considered thin film was presented in Figure . The Ox-π,π-Ph multifunctional
chromophore (2% dye content) absorbs the light in the UV–vis
range of the spectrum, namely, 300–450 nm (with maximum localized
at 385.2 nm; Figure a), whereas the fluorescence spectra were collected in the range
of 450–550 nm (maximum positioned at 480.6 nm, full width at
half-maximum is equal to 43.7 nm). However, the stimulated emission
(ST) was also observed at 478.0 nm, and its fwhm parameter was estimated
as 9.8 nm. The last-mentioned value indicates that the optical gain
profile (significant spectral narrowing) was observed. The inset (Figure a) shows separated
laser mode maxima, which indicates a random lasing character of the
obtained emission. However, the PL spectra were also collected for
the set of polymeric films with increasing laser dye concentration
(Figure b). The dye
content in the range of a 0.5–5.0% dry w/w ratio with polymer
seems to characterize the same spectroscopic character, with a stable
fluorescence at the same wavelength. However, the most concentrated
sample gave a PL signal with the significant red-shifted maximum at
521.2 nm, which is probably implied from the J-aggregate
formation. For further studies, only the sample containing 2% of the
laser dye was taken into account. The fluorescence lifetime of the
Ox-π,π-Ph chromophore was shown in Figure c, and its time constant of PL decay curve
was estimated at 0.32+/–0.01 ns, with high precision
of the implemented monoexponential function approximation (inset).
The individual output spectra when the sample was induced by increasing
the Ipump value are gathered in Figure d. Such a gain profile
can be investigated using the PFT analysis, where the RL emission
wavelength is transferred into the k wave vector
expressed in μm–1 (Figure e). That approach leads to defining the frequently
repeated maxima values, characterizing the collected emission, and
defining the optical resonator dimension according to the well-described
models. Two of them were considered in this Article, namely, WGM[98−100] and Fabry–Perot.[101,102] In Figure e, the less and more significant
maxima marked in blue and green colors, accordingly, were taken under
consideration. The estimated and averaged optical resonator sizes
were gathered in Table . Approximated optical resonator sizes are in agreement with similar
ones, for both models (WGM and Fabry–Perot) currently available
in the literature (which are in the range of tens of microns).[98−102] Finally, the energy threshold value to obtain an efficient light
amplification process in the random lasing fashion was estimated according
to the relation between the output integrated intensity or fwhm parameter
and the pump beam intensity (Figure f). The ρth value was calculated as
22.8 and 22.4 mJ/cm2, respectively. The estimated values
indicate that the system geometry might be optimized in order to reduce
this parameter as it was shown in literature for the pyrazolines group
of the laser dyes.[103]
Figure 5
Absorption (solid blue),
fluorescence (solid green), and light
amplification in the way of random lasing (solid red) spectra of the
Ox-π,π-Ph laser dye and its pump beam wavelength (dash
black) (a); in the inset, enlarged RL sharp spikes are shown; PL spectra
in dye concentration function (b); fluorescence lifetime decay curve,
and in the inset, its enlarged fragment, in (y)log
scale (c); LA spectra induced by increasing the pump beam intensity
(d); PFT analysis defining the optical gain resonator size based on
the RL spectrum (inset), where the x axis is presented
as k (1/μm) (e); and the RL energy threshold
estimated in two ways: spectra integration (red color) and fwhm method
(blue color) (f).
Table 4
Optical Resonators Size Analysis
pm1a
pm2a
pm3a
pm4a
p̅ma
pm1b
pm2b
pm3b
pm4b
p̅mb
WGM
13.4
14.9
17.3
16.8
15.6
21.7
21.8
20.1
18.6
20.5
Fabry–Perot
21.1
23.4
27.2
26.4
24.5
34.1
34.3
31.5
29.3
32.3
The weaker signal series on the
PFT chart (Figure c).
The stronger signal
series on the
PFT chart (Figure c).
The weaker signal series on the
PFT chart (Figure c).The stronger signal
series on the
PFT chart (Figure c).Absorption (solid blue),
fluorescence (solid green), and light
amplification in the way of random lasing (solid red) spectra of the
Ox-π,π-Ph laser dye and its pump beam wavelength (dash
black) (a); in the inset, enlarged RL sharp spikes are shown; PL spectra
in dye concentration function (b); fluorescence lifetime decay curve,
and in the inset, its enlarged fragment, in (y)log
scale (c); LA spectra induced by increasing the pump beam intensity
(d); PFT analysis defining the optical gain resonator size based on
the RL spectrum (inset), where the x axis is presented
as k (1/μm) (e); and the RL energy threshold
estimated in two ways: spectra integration (red color) and fwhm method
(blue color) (f).
All-Optical Switching Phenomenon
To follow the general
requirements of the pump–probe laser setup, we have utilized
two different wavelengths. The first one was inscribed into the absorption
resonance of the active medium (marked in dashed black line in Figure a) and served as
the pump beam (Figure b, right panel). On the other hand, the wavelength of the reference
laser line marked in red in Figure a,b was out of the absorption range of the investigated
organic system. In this way, the probe line monitors the refractive
index conditions and all kinds of changes (thanks to the introduced
cross-polarizer system), whereas the pump beam modulates optical parameters,
including a phase change causing the refractive index indicatrix deformation
and a second, nonlinear n2 generation (Figure b). When the inducing laser
line is not applied, the output signal is not achieved as well. It
is because of the presence of the initial optical isotropy that the
organic system is characterized without any external stimuli. The
kinetics of the photoinduced optical birefringence when the applied Ipump is increased is shown in Figure c. The inset presents a linear
correlation between the applied laser light excitation intensity and
the generated Δn, which confirms the existence
of the optical Kerr effect in the considered hybrid system.[60,61] The maximum gained photoinduced birefringence in the Ox-π,π-Ph/PMMA
system was 5.3 × 10–4, which was acquired after
about 100 s of UV laser light treatment. Moreover, based on the above
relation, the n2 was estimated and it is equal to
3.74 × 10–6 cm2/mW (2.89 ×
10–8 m2/W), which is consistent with
the similar organic systems characterizing the all-optical switching
behavior recently shown in the literature.[22,29,104−107] Namely, a pyrazolone derivative
gave the maximum photoinduced birefringence equal to 5.5 × 10–4, whereas the n2 parameter was estimated
at (4.1 ± 0.2) × 10–6 cm2/mW,
which indicates that the NLO properties are on the same order of magnitude
like the investigated molecular hybrid system.[29] Then, comparing the current results with the other low-molecular
NLO chromophores, such as thiophene or pyrazoline derivatives, their n2 parameter was estimated around 1.6 × 10–7[22] and 3.9 × 10–7 cm2/mW,[104] respectively, which
are even 1 order of magnitude lower values. While making another comparison
between the investigated organic system and the photochromic polymers,[105,106] or polymers doped with photosensitive azo-functionalized polyhedral
oligosilsesquioxane (POSS),[107] the conclusions
are the same. The experimental results given in the literature show
that the multifunctional organic system introduced in here is highly
effective due to the remote optical anisotropy modulation. Furthermore,
it can even be competitive with much more expanded systems, like photochromic
or functionalized polymers.
Figure 6
Absorption spectra of the Ox-π,π-Ph
NLO chromophore
together with marked λpump (405 nm) and λref (638 nm) in the black dashed line and the solid red line,
respectively (a); scheme of the pump–probe experimental setup,
when the inducing beam is utilized (right panel) and when it is not
utilized (left one) (b); Δn kinetics induced
by various Ipump values; as the inset
in a linear correlation between photoinduced birefringence and Ipump (c); complete photoinduced birefringence
kinetics (up to the plateau range), together with its thermodynamic
decay curve (d). Full description in the text.
Absorption spectra of the Ox-π,π-Ph
NLO chromophore
together with marked λpump (405 nm) and λref (638 nm) in the black dashed line and the solid red line,
respectively (a); scheme of the pump–probe experimental setup,
when the inducing beam is utilized (right panel) and when it is not
utilized (left one) (b); Δn kinetics induced
by various Ipump values; as the inset
in a linear correlation between photoinduced birefringence and Ipump (c); complete photoinduced birefringence
kinetics (up to the plateau range), together with its thermodynamic
decay curve (d). Full description in the text.The so-called “static” (or total) photoinduced birefringence
kinetics was analyzed in detail and graphically presented in Figure d. For both and increase
and decrease in Δn, a total of 500 s was devoted.
A photostationary state (plateau range; Δn saturation)
was achieved after about 300 s (5 min), and during the next 200 s
it was stable. Afterward, when the pump laser was in the “OFF”
state (marked by black dashed line in Figure d), a significant signal drop was observed,
and after about 500 s the Δn value reached
close to 1 × 10–4. Such an observed signal
indicates the reversibility level (on the same time scale as signal
recording) at about 83%. Photoinduced birefringence kinetics was analyzed
in two various approaches, the graphical and analytical ones. The
first one brought time constants for a signal increase and decrease
as follows: τinc = 82.1 s and τdec = 2.9 s, respectively. These values define the photocontrolled process
as the slower one, which needs a lot of energy to achieve efficient
molecular reorientation. Indeed, the thermal dark relaxation process
is energetically preferred and much faster (1 order of magnitude lower).
If considering the numerical data analysis, the biexponential approximation
function was the best solution (R2 was
equal to 0.9948 and 0.9308, accordingly). In this case, two time constants
were found for each process. τinc1 = 140.5 s and
τinc2 = 8.6 s, while the reverse spontaneous process
is described by the following numbers: τdec1 = 8.2
s and τdec2 = 22.1 s, respectively. For the photoinduced
Δn state, the first step seems to be much slower,
which needs a lot of energy to reorient the active molecules. The
second part, when a majority of available fragments are aligned, it
is faster and leads to the photostationary state. However, the reversible
process first is faster (significant signal drop) and then much slower,
which demands much more time to provide the initial molecular misalignment.
Indeed, after the first 10 s of thermal darkness conditions, about
40% was obtained before Δn is reduced (Figure d). Estimated time
constant values in both approaches are in a good agreement with their
equivalents for previously cited low-molecular NLO active systems,
as well as the photochromic polymers.[22,29,104−107] Finally, the third-order susceptibility
parameter was estimated at 2.3 × 10–10 (m/V)2. Comparing this parameter with the one quoted earlier, it
can be stated that the fourth-order NLO tensor is similar to the thiophenes
(χ(3) = 2.4 × 10–10 (m/V)2) or pyrazolines (χ(3) = 1.8 × 10–11 (m/V)2), respectively.[22,104] whereas in the pyrazolone derivative system, it was observed to
be a 3 orders of magnitude higher third-order NLO susceptibility (χ(3) = 1.1 × 10–7 (m/V)2)[29] than in the case of the considered organic system.As a supplement to the static photoinduced birefringence analysis,
the dynamic ones (Δndyn) were provided
in Figure . Light
driven molecular transformations (E-Z-E or, in particular, trans–cis–trans) can also be determined using
the OKE experimental setup. Since the active medium is modulated by
the pump laser channel with various lightning frequencies, the efficiency
of the aforementioned transitions can be observed. The highest molecular
transformation was observed for the lowest modulation frequency, 10
Hz (Figure a,b). However,
such a signal modulation can be observed also under higher f values, up to the 300 Hz (or higher), and what is more
important, the Δndyn changes are
still significant (Figure b). Furthermore, based on the experimental results, the Kerr
constant (B) was estimated to be equal to around
2.92 × 10–5 m/V2. Such a number
is slightly higher than the other numbers, defined for various low-molecular
NLO active systems, like the thiophene derivative (B = 3.6 × 10–6 m/V2)[22] or pyrazolines (B = 4.1 ×
10–7 m/V2 for DCNP,[104] or B = 3.9 × 10–7 m/V2 for PY-pNO2[108] molecules), or significantly lower than for
the pyrazolone derivative (3.5 × 10–3 m/V2).[29] Additionally, the multiple
NLO dynamic responses for the implemented modulation frequency at
200 Hz was acquired, and it is presented in Figure c. Gray panels indicate the minima and maxima
of the collected signals localized almost on the same Δndyn level and prove their high stability over
time and pump line modulation. Interestingly, the dynamic component
of the photoinduced birefringence is clearly visible when Ipump is modulated (f = 10 Hz)
and the time scale is elongated to the range of seconds (typically
used for the static OKE measurements). It confirms the mechanism of
the observed third-order NLO phenomenon.[6061]
Figure 7
Kinetics
of the dynamic part of Δn (trans–cis–trans conformational changes), when
various signal modulations are applied (f in the
range 10–300 Hz) (a); photoinduced birefringence amplitude
of the dynamic OKE signal (b); multiple NLO dynamic responses for
the implemented modulation frequency 200 Hz (c); Ipump for (a)–(c) = 22.2 mW/cm2; and
both static and dynamic Δn inducement when Ipump is equal to 23.4 mW/cm2 and
modulation frequency is applied (f = 10 Hz) (d);
inset shows enlarged dynamic OKE signal modulation.
Kinetics
of the dynamic part of Δn (trans–cis–trans conformational changes), when
various signal modulations are applied (f in the
range 10–300 Hz) (a); photoinduced birefringence amplitude
of the dynamic OKE signal (b); multiple NLO dynamic responses for
the implemented modulation frequency 200 Hz (c); Ipump for (a)–(c) = 22.2 mW/cm2; and
both static and dynamic Δn inducement when Ipump is equal to 23.4 mW/cm2 and
modulation frequency is applied (f = 10 Hz) (d);
inset shows enlarged dynamic OKE signal modulation.
Second and Third Harmonic Generation
The NLO response
of the investigated organic system in the context of higher harmonics
of light generation is presented in Figure . If considering the THG signal (Figure a,b), and comparing
with the reference material, the Ox-π,π-Ph NLO chromophore
characterizes more efficient electron cloud distribution modulation
under a fundamental laser beam, which implies it has a three times
higher third-order NLO susceptibility (χ(3) = 6.0
× 10–22 m2/V2). Such a property
could be significantly improved by minimizing the sample thickness
below 1 μm. The optical path determines any kind of absorption,
but also the reabsorption processes, which in fact were taken under
consideration during the χ(3) value estimation. However,
since there is less external stimuli or signal aberration and, that
is, the reabsorption processes can be neglected, then the output feature
is more reliable due to its character and value. Whereas the frequency-generated
wavelength is doubled, it is less efficient in both experimental setup
polarization configurations. Indeed, the χ(2) parameter
of the organic active system is equal to 0.05 and 0.14 pm/V for S and P laser light polarization directions,
respectively. Since the quartz characterizes the same tensor value
as 1.00 pm/V, the investigated organic system should not be considered
as the efficient SHG signal generator. It is important to note that
the reabsorption processes were also taken under consideration during
the NLO parameters value estimation. Another reason for such an inefficient
SHG signal from the organic system can be its thickness and applied
external optical anisotropy. Since the corona poling was introduced,
the polar molecule ordering depends on its efficiency, which is difficult
to control. Additionally, the NLO chromophore concentration can strongly
influence the SHG/THG signal magnitude, which was proven for a push–pull type group of pyrazoline derivatives, where
a nonlinear optical response in dye content variable was investigated.[65] For the numbers higher than 2% of NLO chromophore
concentration, a THG output increase was noticed. Albeit, the idea
of the performed investigation was to use exactly the same sample
shape for all conducted experiments.
Figure 8
THG signal in the shape of Maker fringes
for the reference material
(silica) (a) and investigated NLO chromophore (b); SHG signal of the
reference material (quartz) in S and P polarization configurations (c, e) and the same results for the
Ox-π,π-Ph NLO chromophore, respectively (d, f).
THG signal in the shape of Maker fringes
for the reference material
(silica) (a) and investigated NLO chromophore (b); SHG signal of the
reference material (quartz) in S and P polarization configurations (c, e) and the same results for the
Ox-π,π-Ph NLO chromophore, respectively (d, f).
Conclusions
In summary, we have
introduced a newly synthesized laser dye, being
an appealing alternative working as a multitask organic-based hybrid
material. We have experimentally proven that the oxazolone derivative
presents significant and remarkable spectroscopic features, which
might be utilized in photonics, spectroscopy, and optoelectronics.
It can be easily designed for light amplifier or light modulator construction,
where full and remote control is expected. Furthermore, the observed
light amplification phenomena can be guided by setup geometry, as
the result might deliver particular laser modes. On top of that, the
well-working all-optical switching process in the considered hybrid
system at the same time may change its optical anisotropy and give
the 0–1 optical output channel, which is necessary in many
types of optoelectronic networks or computers. The multifunctional
organic hybrid system reported here can be adopted in real-time holographic
applications[109−111] as an efficient light-sensitive remote-controlled
medium. Such a created, self-organized disordered system constitutes
a promising material for the fast manufacturing of organic and miniaturized
lasers, which additionally can generate the higher harmonics of light
as well. Aforementioned application versatility makes the oxazolone
derivative a highly attractive organic laser dye/NLO chromophore for
multiple employments. This family of compounds should undoubtedly
be explored in the future in the context of other possible subjects,
such as waveguiding.
Authors: Mikhail S Baranov; Kyril M Solntsev; Nadezhda S Baleeva; Alexander S Mishin; Sergey A Lukyanov; Konstantin A Lukyanov; Ilia V Yampolsky Journal: Chemistry Date: 2014-08-29 Impact factor: 5.236
Authors: Adam Szukalski; Maria Moffa; Andrea Camposeo; Dario Pisignano; Jaroslaw Mysliwiec Journal: J Mater Chem C Mater Date: 2018-12-11 Impact factor: 7.393