| Literature DB >> 35162096 |
Abstract
Objectives To investigate which United Kingdom (UK) amateur sporting organisations have published sports-related concussion (SRC) guidelines, their accessibility and the extent to which they follow the Berlin statement recommendations. This article is targeted at those involved with designing and implementing SRC guidelines in amateur sport. Design Scoping Review. Data Sources The SRC guidelines of 15 sporting organisations were accessed through public materials available from the official organisation website. Eligibility Criteria: To be included in this review, sports must enjoy broad participation by UK amateur athletes with a high risk of athletes sustaining an SRC.Entities:
Keywords: SRC; amateur sports; guidelines; sports related concussion
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35162096 PMCID: PMC8834413 DOI: 10.3390/ijerph19031072
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health ISSN: 1660-4601 Impact factor: 3.390
British sporting organisations under review.
| Sport | Sporting Organisation Concussion Guidelines | Sport(s) Played within Organisation |
|---|---|---|
| American Football | British American Football Associatio [ | American Football |
| Basketball | British Basketball [ | Basketball and Wheelchair Basketball |
| Boxing | England Boxing [ | Boxing |
| Cricket | England and Wales Cricket Board [ | Cricket |
| Cycling | British Cycling | Road, Off road (MTB), Track, Paracycling, Amateur |
| Gaelic | Gaelic Athletic Association [ | Gaelic, Hurling, Camogie and Handball |
| Gymnastics | British Gymnastics [ | Acrobatic Gymnastics, Aerobic Gymnastics, Disability Gymnastics, Men’s Artistic Gymnastics, Rhythmic Gymnastics, TeamGym, Trampoline, Double Mini Tramp, Tumbling and Women’s Artistic Gymnastics |
| Hockey | GB and England Hockey [ | Field Hockey |
| Equestrian | British Eventing [ | Dressage, show jumping and cross country |
| Ice Hockey | England Ice Hockey Association [ | Ice Hockey |
| Judo | British Judo [ | Judo |
| Netball | England Netball [ | Netball |
| Rugby League | England Rugby League [ | Rugby League |
| Rugby Union | England Rugby Union [ | Rugby Union, Sevens Rugby, Tag and Touch Rugby |
| Soccer | Football Association [ | Soccer/Football |
Abbreviations: BAFA, British American Football Association; BB, British Basketball; EB, England Boxing; ECB, England Cricket Board; BC, British Cycling; GAA, Gaelic Athletic Association; BG, British Gymnastics; GBH, Great British Hockey; BE, British Eventing; EIHA, England Ice Hockey Association, BJ, British Judo; EN, England Netball; ERL, England Rugby League; ERU, England Rugby Union; FA, Football Association.
Summary of SRC guidelines published by UK sporting organisations.
| Sporting Organisation | Assessment Tools | Initial Complete Rest (Hours) | GRTP Protocol | Return to Play | Notes | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Child | Adult | Child | Adult | ||||
| BAFA | SCAT3 | 48 | 24 | Yes | 23 | 19 | Athletes should not be left alone, consume alcohol or drive until all symptoms have gone |
| BB | SCAT3 | NA | NA | Yes | 23 | 19 | NA |
| EB | NA | 24–48 | 24–48 | Yes | 39 | 35 | Do not stay alone for the first 24 h post- injury |
| ECB | SCAT5 | NA | 24 | Yes | 23 | 7 | No alcohol, prescription or non- prescription drugs |
| GAA | SCAT5 | 48 | Male- 24–48 | Yes | 15 | Male- 7 | Should not be left alone for first 24 h. |
| BG | SCAT5 | NA | 48 | Yes | 28 | 14 | NA |
| GBH | SCAT5 | NA | 24 | Yes | 23 | 6 | Must be off all medications that modify symptoms of the concussion e.g., painkillers |
| EIHA | SCAT5 | NA | 24–48 | Yes | NA | 6 | NA |
| BJ | NA | 7–10 days | 7–10 days | Yes | 28 | 14 | If unconsciousness results from shime waza (strangulation technique) the player may be allowed to return following three days of rest |
| EN | SCAT5 | NA | NA | Yes | 23 | 6 | If no doctor present is suitably trained and experienced in the management of SRC a mandatory two week rest period must occur before commencing GRTP for all ages |
| ERL | SCAT5 | 48 | 24 | Yes | 23 | 19 | Individuals should avoid initially then gradually reintroduce; reading, TV, computer games and driving |
| ERU | SCAT5 | 24–48 | 24–48 | Yes | 23 | 19 | No driving, exercise, minimise screen time |
| FA | SCAT5 | 24–48 | 24–48 | Yes | 23 | 19 | Should not be left alone within the first 24 h, consume alcohol or drive a motor vehicle |
Abbreviations: SCAT—Sports Concussion Assessment Tool; PCRT—Pocket concussion recognition tool; VOMS—Vestibular Ocular Motor Screening; GRTP—Gradual return to play.
Summary of SRC guidelines published by UK sporting organisations continued.
| Sporting Organisation | Prolonged Recovery | Return to Work/Education | Record Concussion | Multiple Concussions | Medical Clearance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BAFA | NA | A player may need a day or two off work/study to rest and reasonable adjustments made to the player’s normal work/study | NA | NA | No |
| BB | Concussion lasting longer than 10 days needs specialist assessment | NA | NA | A second concussion within 12 months should be assessed and managed by HCPs | Yes |
| EB | If symptoms >four weeks post injury for children or >two weeks for adults contact your GP | When going back to school, you may need to go back gradually and have some changes to your schedule so that symptoms do not worsen. You should not return to sport until you have returned to full school/learning without symptoms | Yes | Two knockouts in 90 days = 90- day suspension <1 min = 90- day suspension >1 min = 180- day suspension Three LOC within a 12-month period = 18-month suspension | Yes |
| ECB | Urgent neurological or neurosurgical consultancy before continuing GRTP | Return-to-school guidelines, which include extra-time for | Yes | Player needs a prolonged recovery period | Yes |
| GAA | Symptoms lasting > 10–14 days should be referred to an appropriate specialist | A graduated return to school/education strategy is necessary. | NA | NA | Yes |
| BG | Individuals with symptoms >4 weeks for children and >2 weeks for adults may benefit from a supervised multidisciplinary approach | NA | NA | NA | Yes |
| GBH | Should be assessed and managed by experienced HCP | Athletes should partake in a graduated return to school programme. | NA | Should be assessed and managed by an experienced HCP | Yes |
| EIHA | NA | NA | NA | Yes | |
| BJ | NA | NA | Yes | NA | Yes |
| EN | Recovery >10 days need referred to an experienced HCP | Academic and non- academic work should cease until stage two of the GRTP and that workload is reduced until completion of GRTP | NA | If second concussion within a 12-month period or history of multiple concussions (>3) referral to experienced HCP should take place | Yes |
| ERL | NA | It is reasonable for a student to miss a day or two of studies but extended absence is uncommon and the young person’s academic teacher(s) or tutor should be consulted | Yes | NA | Yes |
| ERU | Athletes who fail to progress through GRTP should return to their GP for review | In some cases, it may be appropriate for the player to miss a day or two of work/study | NA | Anyone who sustains >2 concussions in a 12-month period should seek advice | No |
| FA | NA | Students may need to have allowances made for impaired cognition during recovery e.g., extra time | NA | Any player with a second concussion within 12 months should be assessed and managed by an experienced HCP | Yes |
Abbreviations: HCP- Health care professional; GRTP- gradual return to play.