| Literature DB >> 35155847 |
Besut Daryanto1, Nayla Rahmadiani2, Reza Amorga1, Intan Kautsarani3, Hery Susilo4, Satria Pandu Persada Isma5.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Burnout is experienced frequently by residents, especially during COVID-19 pandemic. Impacts of the pandemic on clinical workload and training program of the residents has also resulted in burnout, which may impact their clinical performance and safety. Therefore, this paper aims to assess burnout syndrome among surgical residents in Indonesia during COVID-19 pandemic.Entities:
Keywords: Burnout; COVID-19; Surgical residents
Year: 2022 PMID: 35155847 PMCID: PMC8824714 DOI: 10.1016/j.cegh.2022.100994
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Clin Epidemiol Glob Health ISSN: 2213-3984
Socio-demographic characteristics, academic, and work-related factors of study participants.
| Variable | N (%) |
|---|---|
| Age | |
| 24–29 years old | 41 (34.2) |
| 30–34 years old | 71 (59.2) |
| ≥35 years old | 8 (6.7) |
| Gender | |
| Male | 109 (90.8) |
| Female | 11 (9.2) |
| Marital Status | |
| Single | 22 (18.3) |
| Married | 98 (81.7) |
| Living Companion | |
| without family | 66 (55) |
| with family | 54 (45) |
| Residency Specialty | |
| General surgery | 39 (32.5) |
| Orthopedics | 51 (42.5) |
| Urology | 30 (25) |
| Residency Year | |
| 1st year | 17 (14.2) |
| 2nd year | 28 (23.3) |
| 3rd year | 22 (18.3) |
| 4th year | 27 (22.4) |
| 5th year | 26 (21.7) |
| Working Hours | |
| <70 h/week | 69 (57.5) |
| 70–100 h/week | 43 (35.8) |
| >100 h/week | 8 (6.7) |
Comparison between mean of each subscale scores of MBI-HSS and socio-demographic, academic, and work-related factors.
| EE | p-value | DP | p-value | PA | p-value | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mean | SD | Mean | SD | Mean | SD | ||||
| Age | |||||||||
| 24–29 yo | 14,59 | 11,70 | 0.865K | 4,59 | 5,43 | 0.974K | 35,54 | 8,43 | 0.594A |
| 30–34 yo | 13,28 | 10,53 | 4,75 | 5,19 | 36,85 | 8,97 | |||
| ≥35 yo | 12,13 | 6,94 | 3,25 | 1,67 | 38,50 | 6,44 | |||
| Gender | |||||||||
| Male | 13,33 | 10,70 | 0.231M | 4,58 | 5,14 | 0.829M | 36,48 | 8,61 | 0.901t |
| Female | 16,82 | 10,71 | 4,73 | 4,98 | 36,82 | 9,18 | |||
| Marital Status | |||||||||
| Single | 10,45 | 8,50 | 0.160M | 2,18 | 3,03 | 36,05 | 9,76 | 0.782t | |
| Married | 14,37 | 11,05 | 5,13 | 5,32 | 36,61 | 8,40 | |||
| Living Companion | |||||||||
| Without family | 13,55 | 10,35 | 0.945M | 4,68 | 4,88 | 0.553M | 36,52 | 7,36 | 0.993t |
| With family | 13,78 | 11,22 | 4,48 | 5,41 | 36,50 | 10,02 | |||
| Residency Specialty | |||||||||
| General surgery | 19,59 | 11,55 | 6,92 | 6,01 | 35,38 | 9,02 | 0.384A | ||
| Orthopedics | 11,24 | 10,31 | 3,84 | 4,67 | 36,33 | 9,18 | |||
| Urology | 10,03 | 6,40 | 2,83 | 3,23 | 38,27 | 6,96 | |||
| Residency Year | |||||||||
| 1st year | 18,65 | 14,59 | 0.082K | 6,53 | 6,98 | 0.424K | 34,88 | 8,27 | 0.404A |
| 2nd year | 16,96 | 12,50 | 4,64 | 5,11 | 37,61 | 7,69 | |||
| 3rd year | 8,18 | 6,42 | 3,18 | 3,86 | 37,95 | 8,29 | |||
| 4th year | 12,56 | 8,12 | 4,04 | 4,59 | 37,52 | 8,75 | |||
| 5th year | 12,58 | 8,91 | 5,04 | 5,02 | 34,12 | 9,84 | |||
| Working Hours | |||||||||
| <70 h/week | 10,65 | 7,92 | 3,33 | 3,84 | 37,43 | 8,39 | 0.265A | ||
| 70–100 h/week | 16,74 | 12,3 1 | 6,12 | 6,00 | 34,79 | 9,36 | |||
| >100 h/week | 22,88 | 13,60 | 7,25 | 6,69 | 37,75 | 5,12 | |||
SD = standard deviation.
A ANOVA test; K Kruskal-Wallis test; t independent t-test; M Mann-Whitney test.
Bold case indicates statistical significancy (p < 0.05).
Overall EE, DP, and PA scores of Surgical Residents in The Study.
| EE | DP | PA | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| N | % | N | % | N | % | |
| Low | 87 | 72.50% | 81 | 67.50% | 52 | 43.33% |
| Moderate | 18 | 15.00% | 23 | 19.17% | 31 | 25.83% |
| High | 15 | 12.50% | 16 | 13.33% | 37 | 30.83% |
| Overall mean ± SD | 13.65 ± 10.66 | 4.59 ± 5.08 | 36.5 ± 8.59 | |||
Comparison between EE, DP, and PA subscale scores and socio-demographic, academic, and work-related factors.
| EE Classification (N, %) | p-value | DP Classification (N, %) | p-value | PA Classification (N, %) | p-value | ||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Low | Moderate | High | Low | Moderate | High | Low | Moderate | High | |||||||||||||
| Age | |||||||||||||||||||||
| 24–29 yo | 29 | 33,3% | 5 | 27,8% | 7 | 46,7% | 0.634 | 26 | 32,1% | 11 | 47,8% | 4 | 25,0% | 0.116 | 17 | 32,7% | 9 | 29,0% | 15 | 40,5% | 0.823 |
| 30–34 yo | 52 | 59,8% | 11 | 61,1% | 8 | 53,3% | 47 | 58,0% | 12 | 52,2% | 12 | 75,0% | 32 | 61,5% | 19 | 61,3% | 20 | 54,1% | |||
| ≥35 yo | 6 | 6,9% | 2 | 11,1% | 0 | 0,0% | 8 | 9,9% | 0 | 0,0% | 0 | 0,0% | 3 | 5,8% | 3 | 9,7% | 2 | 5,4% | |||
| Gender | |||||||||||||||||||||
| Male | 81 | 93,1% | 14 | 77,8% | 14 | 93,3% | 0.114 | 74 | 91,4% | 21 | 91,3% | 14 | 87,5% | 0.884 | 46 | 88,5% | 29 | 93,5% | 34 | 91,9% | 0.713 |
| Female | 6 | 6,9% | 4 | 22,2% | 1 | 6,7% | 7 | 8,6% | 2 | 8,7% | 2 | 12,5% | 6 | 11,5% | 2 | 6,5% | 3 | 8,1% | |||
| Marital Status | |||||||||||||||||||||
| Single | 16 | 18,4% | 6 | 33,3% | 0 | 0,0% | 18 | 22,2% | 3 | 13,0% | 1 | 6,3% | 0.246 | 9 | 17,3% | 4 | 12,9% | 9 | 24,3% | 0.464 | |
| Married | 71 | 81,6% | 12 | 66,7% | 15 | 100,0% | 63 | 77,8% | 20 | 87,0% | 15 | 93,8% | 43 | 82,7% | 27 | 87,1% | 28 | 75,7% | |||
| Living Companion | |||||||||||||||||||||
| Without family | 46 | 52,9% | 13 | 72,2% | 7 | 46,7% | 0.254 | 45 | 55,6% | 10 | 43,5% | 11 | 68,8% | 0.291 | 26 | 50,0% | 19 | 61,3% | 21 | 56,8% | 0.587 |
| With family | 41 | 47,1% | 5 | 27,8% | 8 | 53,3% | 36 | 44,4% | 13 | 56,5% | 5 | 31,3% | 26 | 50,0% | 12 | 38,7% | 16 | 43,2% | |||
| Residency Specialty | |||||||||||||||||||||
| General surgery | 21 | 24,1% | 7 | 38,9% | 11 | 73,3% | 21 | 25,9% | 8 | 34,8% | 10 | 62,5% | 16 | 30,8% | 10 | 32,3% | 13 | 35,1% | 0.240 | ||
| Orthopedics | 40 | 46,0% | 7 | 38,9% | 4 | 26,7% | 35 | 43,2% | 11 | 47,8% | 5 | 31,3% | 24 | 46,2% | 9 | 29,0% | 18 | 48,6% | |||
| Urology | 26 | 29,9% | 4 | 22,2% | 0 | 0,0% | 25 | 30,9% | 4 | 17,4% | 1 | 6,3% | 12 | 23,1% | 12 | 38,7% | 6 | 16,2% | |||
| Residency Year | |||||||||||||||||||||
| 1st year | 9 | 10,3% | 3 | 16,7% | 5 | 33,3% | 10 | 12,3% | 4 | 17,4% | 3 | 18,8% | 0.586 | 5 | 9,6% | 6 | 19,4% | 6 | 16,2% | 0.652 | |
| 2nd year | 16 | 18,4% | 5 | 27,8% | 7 | 46,7% | 16 | 19,8% | 8 | 34,8% | 4 | 25,0% | 12 | 23,1% | 9 | 29,0% | 7 | 18,9% | |||
| 3rd year | 21 | 24,1% | 1 | 5,6% | 0 | 0,0% | 16 | 19,8% | 5 | 21,7% | 1 | 6,3% | 12 | 23,1% | 3 | 9,7% | 7 | 18,9% | |||
| 4th year | 20 | 23,0% | 5 | 27,8% | 2 | 13,3% | 19 | 23,5% | 3 | 13,0% | 5 | 31,3% | 14 | 26,9% | 5 | 16,1% | 8 | 21,6% | |||
| 5th year | 21 | 24,1% | 4 | 22,2% | 1 | 6,7% | 20 | 24,7% | 3 | 13,0% | 3 | 18,8% | 9 | 17,3% | 8 | 25,8% | 9 | 24,3% | |||
| Working Hours | |||||||||||||||||||||
| <70 h/week | 57 | 65,5% | 11 | 61,1% | 1 | 6,7% | 53 | 65,4% | 11 | 47,8% | 5 | 31,3% | 31 | 59,6% | 19 | 61,3% | 19 | 51,4% | 0.750 | ||
| 70–100 h/week | 26 | 29,9% | 6 | 33,3% | 11 | 73,3% | 23 | 28,4% | 12 | 52,2% | 8 | 50,0% | 18 | 34,6% | 9 | 29,0% | 16 | 43,2% | |||
| >100 h/week | 4 | 4,6% | 1 | 5,6% | 3 | 20,0% | 5 | 6,2% | 0 | 0,0% | 3 | 18,8% | 3 | 5,8% | 3 | 9,7% | 2 | 5,4% | |||
Statistical significancy was determined using Chi-square test.
Bold case indicates statistical significancy (p < 0.05).
Fig. 1Scatter plots of statistically significant correlations between EE, DP, and PA subscale scores and socio-demographic characteristics, academic, and work-related factors.
Comparison between the presence of burnout and socio-demographic, academic, and work-related factors.
| BURNOUT (N, %) | p-value | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Absent | Present | ||||
| Age | |||||
| 24–29 years old | 18 | 34,6% | 23 | 33,8% | 0.501 |
| 30–34 years old | 29 | 55,8% | 42 | 61,8% | |
| ≥35 years old | 5 | 9,6% | 3 | 4,4% | |
| Gender | |||||
| Male | 48 | 92,3% | 61 | 89,7% | 0.625 |
| Female | 4 | 7,7% | 7 | 10,3% | |
| Marital Status | |||||
| Single | 13 | 25,0% | 9 | 13,2% | 0.099 |
| Married | 39 | 75,0% | 59 | 86,8% | |
| Living Companion | |||||
| Without family | 29 | 55,8% | 37 | 54,4% | 0.882 |
| With family | 23 | 44,2% | 31 | 45,6% | |
| Residency Specialty | |||||
| General surgery | 13 | 25,0% | 26 | 38,2% | 0.079 |
| Orthopedics | 21 | 40,4% | 30 | 44,1% | |
| Urology | 18 | 34,6% | 12 | 17,6% | |
| Residency Year | |||||
| 1st year | 7 | 13,5% | 10 | 14,7% | 0.651 |
| 2nd year | 13 | 25,0% | 15 | 22,1% | |
| 3rd year | 9 | 17,3% | 13 | 19,1% | |
| 4th year | 9 | 17,3% | 18 | 26,5% | |
| 5th year | 14 | 26,9% | 12 | 17,6% | |
| Working Hours | |||||
| Less than 70 h/week | 34 | 65,4% | 35 | 51,5% | |
| 70–100 h/week | 15 | 28,8% | 28 | 41,2% | |
| More than 100 h/week | 3 | 5,8% | 5 | 7,4% | |
Statistical significancy was determined using Chi-square test.
Bold case indicates statistical significancy (p < 0.05).