| Literature DB >> 35137507 |
Nikolaos Kotsopoulos1,2, Mark P Connolly1,3, Michael Willis4, Andreas Nilsson4, Åsa Ericsson5, James Baker-Knight6.
Abstract
AIM: To estimate the fiscal burden for taxpayers in Sweden associated with type 2 diabetes (T2D) attributed to diabetes-related complications in patients failing to meet HbA1c targets.Entities:
Keywords: diabetes complications; economic evaluation; glycaemic control; public economics; taxes; type 2 diabetes
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35137507 PMCID: PMC9313875 DOI: 10.1111/dom.14667
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Diabetes Obes Metab ISSN: 1462-8902 Impact factor: 6.408
FIGURE 1Fiscal model design. BDR, background diabetic retinopathy; CHF, coronary heart failure; ESRD, end stage renal disease; IHD, ischaemic heart disease; IS, ischaemic stroke; LEA EV, lower extremity amputation extracellular vesicles; LEA HIST, lower extremity amputation history; MacroALB, macroalbuminuria; ME, macular oedema; MI, myocardial infarction; MicroALB, microalbinuria; No Nephr, no nephrological complication; No Neur, no neurological complication; No Ret, no retinopathy; PDR, proliferative diabetic retinopathy; PVD, peripheral vascular disease: SVL, severe visual loss; Sympt, symptomatic neurological complication
Selection of key studies describing the impact of type 2 diabetes complications on fiscal metrics
| Fiscal impact | Country | Measure | Relevance to complications | Quality | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Impact of diabetes diagnosis | Multiple | Several studies, across different geographies, describe diabetes‐attributable wage penalties and increased demand for transfer costs | Non‐complication–specific (generic) | High |
|
| Impact on employment | United States | People with diabetes‐related complications were 12% (5%‐19%) less probable to be in the workforce. Confirmed by several other studies | Non‐complication–specific (generic) | High |
|
| Reduction in wages/income | Canada | Individuals with diabetes complications have lower incomes at various age groups from 18 to 64 y confirmed by Kraut et al. study | Non‐complication–specific (generic) | Older but highly cited, of good quality |
|
| Early retirement (study in those aged >57 y) | United States |
Reduced odds ratio for not being retired: Any complication 0.35 ( Stroke 0.38 ( Coronary 0.64 ( Confirmed by four more studies | Data for, any complication; stroke; coronary | High |
|
| Receive disability pension | Sweden | Cumulative probability all‐cause disability over 48 mo: CV disease, depression, >1 complication, no complication. Confirmed by evidence from various studies | Data for CV disease, depression, >1 complication, no complication | High |
|
Abbreviation: CV, cardiovascular.
Data inputs used in the fiscal model
| Input | Description | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Age‐specific variables | ||
| Age‐specific employment rate and annual earnings | Income in Sweden 2018, personal communication with SCB |
|
| Proportion of individuals with disability | Social insurance in figures 2019: Page 40 graph with proportion of the population receiving disability allowance in December 2018. Data extracted from graph and averaged for men and women |
|
| Annual disability pension | Social insurance in figures 2019: average of monthly disability pension (pages 55‐56) for males and females multiplied by 12 |
|
| Average monthly pension | Average monthly pension x 12 from pensions |
|
| Non‐age–specific variables | ||
| Tax rates | Sum of tax wedge (2019), that is, 42.7% and percentage of income that goes to indirect tax (i.e. 12.3% based on OECD tax data [taxes of goods and services as % of GDP]) |
|
| Cost inflation | Labour cost index, percentage change from corresponding month last year by economic indicator and month |
|
| Wage penalty postdiabetes diagnosis | A 5% reduction of earnings as obtained from Kraut et al. (2001) |
|
| Risk ratios (i.e. impact of co‐morbidities on employment rates) | ||
| Macular oedema (0.580) | The economic impact of diabetic macular oedema in Australia |
|
| Severe visual loss (0.068) | OR 14.8 not working with diabetes. The reciprocal OR was used to estimate employment rate |
|
| Peripheral vascular disease; lower extremity, history of amputation (0.488) | RTW 0.67; 0.33 do not return to work. RR = 0.33:0.67 |
|
| Macroalbuminuria (0.248) | Socioeconomic status and type 2 diabetes complications among young adult patients in Japan. Model 2. Inverse of OR was used to calculate employment rate. The OR was used as a proxy for disability rate |
|
| Microalbuminuria (0.500) | We applied an intermediate work impairment rate between macroalbuminuria and 1.0. No specific input was found for microalbuminuria |
|
| ESRD (0.223) | Ghani et al. (2019) showed a 10.5% reduction in employment in transition from microalbuminuria and ESRD in Sweden. We applied the 10.5% reduction to the OR for macroalbuminuria to derive the OR for ESRD |
|
| IHD (0.640) | Impact of disease on employment for people nearing retirement age |
|
| MI, history of MI (0.710) | RTW data following MI |
|
| Subsequent MI (0.150) | Subsequent MI and employment, 82.4%/17.6%. Divide OR for RTW after first MI by 4.69 |
|
| Stroke (0.380) | Finance memo. Impact of disease on employment for people nearing retirement age |
|
| Subsequent stroke (0.114) | Squared value of first stroke | Assumption |
| Heart failure (0.760) | Return to the workforce after first hospitalization for heart failure. A Danish nationwide cohort study |
|
Abbreviations: ESRD, end stage renal disease; IHD, ischaemic heart disease; GDP, gross domestic product; MI, myocardial infarction; OR, odds ratio; OECD, Organization for economic co‐operation and development; RR, risk ratio; RTW, return to work; SCB, Swedish community board.
The per patient fiscal impact of delayed glycaemic control of 3 years in the population aged ≤65 years, baseline HbA1c 6.9% (52 mmol/mol), HbA1c 6.0% target (42 mmol/mol), with 10‐year time horizon (SEK) discounted
| 3‐y | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Economic variables | Immediate control (SEK) | delayed control (SEK) | Difference (SEK) |
| Earnings loss (societal perspective) | 42 299 | 44 157 | −1858 |
| Government perspective | |||
| Tax revenue loss (A) | 23 265 | 24 287 | −1022 |
| Excess disability payments (B) | 12 317 | 12 855 | −538 |
| Incremental fiscal effects (SEK) (A + B) | −1560 | ||
Abbreviation: SEK, Swedish krona.
Scenario analysis for baseline HbA1c 6.9% (52 mmol/mol) and achieving HbA1c target 6.0% (42 mmol/mol) based on variations in age, delays in achieving target, and time horizon
| Time horizon, y | Delay in achieving target, y | Age 45 y | Age 50 y | Age 54 y | Age 60 y |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| (SEK) | (SEK) | (SEK) | (SEK) | ||
| 3 | 1 | 39 | 64 | 92 | 150 |
| 3 | 88 | 144 | 206 | 334 | |
| 10 | 1 | 226 | 361 | 511 | 291 |
| 3 | 702 | 1110 | 1560 | 787 | |
| 5 | 1147 | 1800 | 2518 | 1037 | |
| 40 | 1 | 17 342 | 8560 | 589 | 291 |
| 3 | 19 101 | 10 083 | 1809 | 787 | |
| 5 | 20 950 | 11 617 | 2954 | 1037 |
Abbreviation: SEK, Swedish krona.
Base case.