| Literature DB >> 35106413 |
Eiji Oki1, Koji Ando1, Hiroya Taniguchi2, Takayuki Yoshino3, Masaki Mori4.
Abstract
Numerous clinical studies in an adjuvant setting have been conducted and the combination therapy of 5-fluorouracil and oxaliplatin has been established as the standard treatment for Stage III and as an option for high-risk Stage II patients. Biologics such as bevacizumab and antiepidermal growth factor receptor antibodies have failed to show additional survival benefits. The indication of adjuvant chemotherapy has been determined according to the pathological stage. Nevertheless, a pathological diagnosis does not necessarily result in selection of the optimal treatment. To improve treatment decisions, many trials have aimed to stratify patients into treatment groups using genomic testing. Recently, gene signature, Immunoscore, and circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) assays have been reported and among them, ctDNA was shown to be a promising accurate predictive marker for recurrence. Treatment of ctDNA-positive patients with aggressive chemotherapy may reduce recurrence rates. The ultimate goal is to accurately predict the risk of recurrence and to prevent recurrence in colon cancer patients. In this review we focus on the clinical development of adjuvant chemotherapy and stratification of patients according to risk of recurrence and the future direction of adjuvant chemotherapy.Entities:
Keywords: BRAF; MSI; RAS; adjuvant chemotherapy; colon cancer; ctDNA
Year: 2021 PMID: 35106413 PMCID: PMC8786685 DOI: 10.1002/ags3.12503
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Ann Gastroenterol Surg ISSN: 2475-0328
Pivotal phase III trial for adjuvant chemotherapy in colon cancer
| Study name | Publication Years | Control vs test arm | Sample size | DFS | OS | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 or 5 year (%) | HR |
| 3 or 5 year (%) | HR |
| ||||
| NSABP‐C‐03 | 1993 | 5‐FU/LV | 521 | 73 (3 y) | ND | .0004 | 71 (3 y) | ND | .003 |
| MOF | 524 | 64 (3 y) | 55 (3 y) | ||||||
| Andre T et al | 2003 | LV5FU2 (noninferiority) | 452 | 73 (3 y) | 1.04 | .74 | 86 (3 y) | 1.265 | .18 |
| Mayo regimen | 453 | 72 (3 y) | 87 (3 y) | ||||||
| NSABP C‐06 | 2005 | UFT/LV (noninferiority) | 551 | 77.8 (5 y) | 1.004 | .0236 | 87.5 (5 y) | 1.014 | ND |
| 5‐FU/LV(RPMI) | 550 | 79.3 (5 y) | 88.4 (5 y) | ||||||
| X‐ACT | 2005 | Capecitabine (noninferiority) | 1004 | 65.5 (3 y) | 1.06 |
| 81.3 (3 y) | 0.84 | .05 |
| 5‐FU/LV(RPMI) | 983 | 61.9 (3 y) | 77.6 (3 y) | ||||||
| MOSAIC | 2009 | FOLFOX4 | 1123 | 73.3 (5 y) | 0.80 | .003 | 78.5 (6 y) | 0.84 | .046 |
| LV5FU2 | 1123 | 67.4 (5 y) | 76.0 (6 y) | ||||||
| NSABP C‐07 | 2011 | FLOX | 1209 | 69.4 (5 y) | 0.82 | .002 | 80.2 (5 y) | 0.88 | .08 |
| 5‐FU/LV (RPMI) | 1200 | 64.2 (5 y) | 78.4 (5 y) | ||||||
| NO16968/XELOXA | 2015 | CAPOX | 944 | 63 (7 y) | 0.80 | .004 | 73 (7 y) | 0.83 | .04 |
| 5‐FU/LV (Mayo or RPMI) | 942 | 56 (7 y) | 67 (7 y) | ||||||
| CALGB 89803 | 2007 | IFL | 635 | 61 (5 y) | ND | .85 | 68 (5 y) | ND | .74 |
| RPMI | 629 | 59 (5 y) | 71 (5 y) | ||||||
| PETACC‐3 | 2009 | FOLFIRI | 1050 | 56.7 (3 y) | 0.86 (adjusted) | .106 | 73.6 (3 y) | 0.83 (adjusted) | .094 |
| LV5FU2 | 1044 | 54.3 (3 y) | 71.3 (3 y) | ||||||
| NSABP C08 | 2011 | mFOLFOX6 + Bevacizumab | 1334 | 77.4 (3 y) | 0.89 | .15 | ‐ | ‐ | ‐ |
| mFOLFOX6 | 1338 | 75.6 (3 y) | ‐ | ||||||
| AVANT | 2012 | A: mFOLFOX6 + Bevacizumab | 955 | 76 (3 y) |
1.17 (A vs C) |
.443 (A vs C) | ‐ |
1.27 (A vs C) | .02 |
| B:CAPOX + Bevacizumab | 960 | 73 (3 y) | ‐ | ||||||
| C:mFOLFOX6 | 952 | 75 (3 y) | ‐ | ||||||
| QUASAR 2 | 2016 | Capecitabine + Bevacizumab | 973 | 75.4 (3 y) | 1.06 | .54 | 87.5 (3 y) | 1.11 | .33 |
| Capecitabine | 968 | 78.4 (3 y) | 89.4 (3 y) | ||||||
| PETACC‐8 | 2014 | FOLFOX4 + Cetuximab | 791 | 75.1 (3 y) | 1.05 | .6562 | 88.3 (3 y) | 1.09 | .5583 |
| FOLFOX4 | 811 | 78.0 (3 y) | 90.5 (3 y) | ||||||
Abbreviations: CAPOX, capecitabin/oxaliplatin; DFS, disease‐free survival; FOLFIRI, irinotecan/leucovorin/5FU; FOLFOX, oxaliplatin/leucovorin/5FU; HR, hazard ratio; LV5FU2, leucovorin/infusional 5‐FU; MOF, methyl‐CCNU/Vincristine/5‐FU; ND, not determined; OS, overall survival; P, probability.
Noninferiority test.
Overview of four gene signatures and the Immunoscore
| Assay | Gene characteristics | Method | Requirement |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oncotype DX | 12 gene (7 prognostic genes and 5 reference genes) | RT‐PCR | Formalin‐fixed paraffin embedded tissue |
| ColoPrint | 18 genes | RT‐PCR | Fresh‐frozen tissue |
| ColDX | 634 genes | Microarray | Formalin‐fixed paraffin embedded tissue |
| Curebest 55GC Colon | 55 genes selected from Microarray | Microarray | Fresh‐frozen tissue or formalin‐fixed paraffin embedded tissue |
| Immunoscore | Proportion of CD3‐ and CD8‐positive T cells | Immunohistochemistry | Formalin‐fixed paraffin embedded tissue |
Abbreviations: RT‐PCR, reverse transcription real‐time polymerase chain reaction.