Eisa Tahmasbpour Marzouni1, Hanieh Ilkhani2, Asghar Beigi Harchegani3, Hossein Shafaghatian4, Issa Layali5, Alireza Shahriary6. 1. Laboratory of Regenerative Medicine and Biomedical Innovations, Pasteur Institute of Iran, Tehran, Iran. 2. Islamic Azad University, Pharmaceutical Sciences Branch, Tehran, Iran. 3. Department of Medical Genetics, Faculty of Medicine, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran. 4. Chemical Injuries Research Center, Systems Biology and Poisonings Institute, Baqiyatallah University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran. 5. Department of Biochemistry, Islamic Azad University, Sari Branch, Sari, Iran. 6. Chemical Injuries Research Center, Systems Biology and Poisonings Institute, Baqiyatallah University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran. Email: shahriary961@gmail.com.
Human infertility is now considered as a serious health
problem affecting 15% of couples throughout the world
(1). Male infertility factors contribute to about 50% of
all infertile cases (2). It is a multifactorial syndrome that
can be caused by numerous factors (Fig .1). Anatomical
or structural defects such as varicocele and obstructive
problems, ejaculatory failures, genital tract infections,
hyperviscous semen, endocrinological disorders,
impaired spermatogenesis, chromosomal abnormalities,
and immunologic problems are the most common reasons
for male infertility (3-5). Environmental or occupational
factors such as smoking or opiate using, exposure to
pesticides or radiation can influence gamete health and
subsequently, male fertility (6). Males with normal
sperm parameters, but unexplained cause are defined as
idiopathic infertile men. Several factors such as oxidative
stress caused by the massive production of reactive
oxygen species (ROS), are categorized as the most
common causes of this type of male infertility. It seems
that ROS accompanied with sperm DNA fragmentation,
gene mutations, and genetic disorders (7). The molecular
genetic abnormalities rate in the male infertility etiology
are notable, ~15-30%, that affect various physiological
processes such as steroidogenesis, sperm production and
development, maturation, function and quality. Knowing
the molecular genetic factors, related genes and potential
regulatory mechanisms may provide better understanding
of this disease pathogenesis.
Fig.1
A schematic for the most common causes of male infertility. Male
infertility is a multifactorial syndrome that is caused by multiple factors.
Anatomical defects, endocrine deficiency, immunological defects,
molecular defects and chromosomal aneuploidy, as well as environmental
exposure to toxicants and lifestyle are the most common causes of male
infertility. Unexplained infertility may be resulted from idiopathic factors
such as oxide stress, over expression of ROS and unknown mutations.
ROS; Reactive oxygen species, LH; Luteinizing hormone, FSH; Follicle-stimulating hormone, and AZF; Azoospermia factor.
Chromosomal abnormalities, point mutations in single genes such as cystic fibrosis
transmembrane receptor (CFTR) gene, microdeletions of the Y chromosome,
mitochondrial genome (mtDNA) mutations, and imprinting disorders are the most important
causes of the molecular genetic basis of infertility in men (8, 9). Also, mutations and
polymorphisms in different genes, which may adversely affect sperm production and male
fertilization ability, can be associated with severe infertility in men (9). For instance,
deletions of the Y chromosome, particularly azoospermia factor A, B and C regions (AZFa,
AZFb and AZFc), are the most common causes of Y-linked male infertility which leads to
severe damage in spermatogenesis (10). Additionally, deletions in various autosomal and
X-linked genes such as androgen receptor (AR), and ubiquitin-specific
protease-26 (USP26) genes, which are considered as critical genes of normal
testis development and spermatogenesis, can be associated with male fertility disorder (11).
Therefore, any changes such as translocations, inversions, mutations, deletions or insertion
and etc. in the related chromosomes and/or genes can change the normal function of the male
reproductive system and result in severe damage to male fertility.A schematic for the most common causes of male infertility. Male
infertility is a multifactorial syndrome that is caused by multiple factors.
Anatomical defects, endocrine deficiency, immunological defects,
molecular defects and chromosomal aneuploidy, as well as environmental
exposure to toxicants and lifestyle are the most common causes of male
infertility. Unexplained infertility may be resulted from idiopathic factors
such as oxide stress, over expression of ROS and unknown mutations.
ROS; Reactive oxygen species, LH; Luteinizing hormone, FSH; Follicle-stimulating hormone, and AZF; Azoospermia factor.Recent studies have provided new insight into the
role of a class of non-coding RNAs, micro RNAs
(miRNAs), in the sperm production, development and
fertilization (12, 13). A growing number of evidences
have shown that dysregulation of various specific
miRNAs, especially miR34a-c, can cause impaired
spermatogenesis and male infertility (12, 14). Epigenetic
modifications are the other significant factors that
regulate spermatogenesis and male fertility. Epigenetics
regulates gene regulation without any changes in the
DNA sequence. These modifications include methylation
of DNA, post-translational histone modifications and
chromatin rearrangement (Fig .2) (15). Regulation of
gene expression by epigenetic modifications is crucial
for normal spermatogenesis. Recent studies reveal that
several genes in the testicular cells are regulated through
the epigenetic process, that indicates the critical role
of epigenetic mechanism in spermatogenesis, sperm
development or maturation, fertilization process, as
well as male fertility (16). Therefore, there is a growing
interest in determining whether epigenetic modifications
serve their key regulatory role. In the following sections,
the association of epigenetic alterations with abnormal
spermatogenesis and male infertility, as well as their
significance in assisted reproduction will be reviewed.
Fig.2
The regulatory function of epigenetic modification in all stages of
male reproduction. Epigenetic modifications (EPs) are involved in nearly all
stages of the reproductive system, including, testicular cell development,
germ cell differentiation, steroidogenesis, spermatogenesis, sperm
maturation, fertilization, and embryo development.
The regulatory function of epigenetic modification in all stages of
male reproduction. Epigenetic modifications (EPs) are involved in nearly all
stages of the reproductive system, including, testicular cell development,
germ cell differentiation, steroidogenesis, spermatogenesis, sperm
maturation, fertilization, and embryo development.
Molecular basis of epigenetic alterations
The molecular mechanisms of epigenetic processes
come from covalent modifications of protein and
DNA components of chromatin. It consists of a range
of modifications, including methylation of DNA,
post-translational modifications of the core histone,
and chromatin remodeling (17). These modifications
are processed by three different enzymes, i. A writer
that adds epigenetic marks on DNA and histone, ii. A
reader that recognizes epigenetic marks, and iii. An
eraser responsible for removing these modifications
(18).Epigenetic alterations regulate gene expression
by changing the chromatin structure and DNA
accessibility. These modifications are extremely
important for the development and differentiation
of all cells, especially spermatozoa. Recent studies
have illustrated that epigenetic modifications affect
expression of various genes which are responsible
for the development of the male reproductive system,
sperm production, and male sexual behavior (19). This
indicates that incorrect modifications of DNA can cause
abnormal male sexual development and reproductive
dysfunction (20). Epigenetic modifications not only
control the process of spermatogenesis, but also they
modulate the process of sperm maturation, sperm-egg
interaction, fertilization, and embryo development. The
interesting chemical changes of the DNA molecule,
such as chromatin remodeling, methylation of DNA,
histones post-translational modifications, and gene expression regulation by miRNAs are the molecular
basis of epigenetic information during these processes
(Fig .3).
Fig.3
The basic molecular mechanisms of epigenetic modifications.
DNA methylation, histone modifications, chromatin remodeling and
miRNA biogenesis are the main mechanisms of epigenetic modifications
that regulate many physiological processes in various cells. DNA
methylation occurrence in the CpG islands regulates expression of various
spermatogenesis genes. Histone acetylation that reversibly occurs at
lysine residues within the N-terminal tail increases the propensity for
gene transcription and also modulates chromatin remodeling. Also,
miRNAs biogenesis is regulated by epigenetic modifications such as DNA
methylation. It plays a significant role in the numerous physiological
processes, particularly spermatogenesis, sperm maturation and
fertilization process.
The basic molecular mechanisms of epigenetic modifications.
DNA methylation, histone modifications, chromatin remodeling and
miRNA biogenesis are the main mechanisms of epigenetic modifications
that regulate many physiological processes in various cells. DNA
methylation occurrence in the CpG islands regulates expression of various
spermatogenesis genes. Histone acetylation that reversibly occurs at
lysine residues within the N-terminal tail increases the propensity for
gene transcription and also modulates chromatin remodeling. Also,
miRNAs biogenesis is regulated by epigenetic modifications such as DNA
methylation. It plays a significant role in the numerous physiological
processes, particularly spermatogenesis, sperm maturation and
fertilization process.
Role of DNA methylation/demethylation in the male
infertility
DNA methylation is the most common type of DNA
alteration in the somatic cells. It occurs frequently on
the cytosine-phosphate-guanine (CpG) islands that have
been located upstream of nearly 40% of mammalian
genes. Here, methylation occurs in a C5 position of
cytosine residues to create 5-methyl cytosine. In this
process, the methyl group is originated from S-adenosyl
methionine. Hypermethylation of DNA can suppress
transcription by preventing transcription factors binding
or inducing several transcriptional repressors binding
(20). DNA methylation is controlled by several classes of
DNA methyltransferases (DNMTs), including DNMT1,
DNMT3a and DNMT3b, that serve as writers (21).
All DNA methyl transferases serve as writers. DNMT
enzymes regulate both initiation and maintenance of
methylation marks.DNA demethylation can occur through passive or
active mechanisms. Active DNA demethylation occurs
when a methyl group is removed independently during
DNA replication, while we encounter passive DNA
demethylation when newly synthesized DNA strands are
replicated by DNMT1 (3). DNA demethylation is another
process that prevents transmission of inappropriate
epigenetic marks to the future generations. Despite of
DNA demethylation importance in the development
process , its action mechanism is unclear (22).CpG regions methylation/demethylation, one of the
important processes of gene expression regulation,
affects transcription factors binding and then represses
expression of imprinted and developmental genes, while
its deficiency may result in some disorders (21). Correct
DNA methylation plays critical role in the various
essential cellular processes such as X- chromosome
inactivation and chromatin stability (23).Recent evidence has indicated that correct methylation of DNA is essential for fertility
and embryo development. Also, abnormal DNA methylation pattern has been reported in
spermatozoa of idiopathic infertile men with poor semen quality (24). Some studies
demonstrated that there is a stable single CpG methylation pattern in sperm of fertile
men, while in the subfertile men show significantly modified pattern (25). Interestingly,
there is a correlation between DNA methylation level and sperm motility, sperm chromatin
and DNA integrity (26, 27). For example, promoters’ hypermethylation of genes, including
MTHFR, IGF2, H19, PLAG1, and SNRPN has been shown to
be correlated with poor sperm quality and increased risk of infertility. Houshdaran et al.
(28) found that hypermethylation of DNA, especially in the promoter regions of
PLAG1, PAX8, DIRAS3, MEST, SFN, NTF3, and HRAS genes,
can decrease counts, motility and normal morphology of sperm. Khazamipour et al. (29)
reported hypermethylation of MTHFR promoter in nearly 53% of the men with
non-obstructive azoospermia, while they observed no hypermethylation of
MTHFR promoter in the men with obstructive azoospermia. Similarly, Wu
et al. (30) found that the MTHFR gene promoter hypermethylation in human
spermatozoa causes idiopathic infertility. These findings indicate that
MTHFR hypermethylation is an important epigenetic abnormality which can
contribute to male infertility. A more recent study has revealed that hypermethylation of
SOX30 gene causes its silencing, impaired spermatogenesis and
non-obstructive azoospermia in mice (31).Abnormal methylation of the promoter regions of H19 and
MEST genes can be associated with impaired spermatogenesis and
oligozoospermia (32). Hammoud et al. (33), compared CpG methylation of LIT1,
SNRPN, MEST, H19, PLAGL1, PEG3, and IGF2 genes in spermatozoa
of fertile and infertile men. Methylation of DNA in spermatozoa of infertile patients was
significantly modified for all genes except IGF2. Furthermore, a
significant relationship was observed between impaired spermatogenesis and
hypermethylation of these six genes. Boissonnas et al. (34), found that H19 was
considerably hypomethylated in men with teratozoospermia and oligoasthenoteratozoospermia.
Another study indicated that MEST hypermethylation has more adverse effects on sperm
quality than H19/ IGF2-ICR1 hypomethylation. In this study, Rajender et
al. (35) compared hypermethylation of MEST with hypomethylation of H19/IGF2.The X-linked reproductive homeobox (RHOX) gene clusters, are essential
for normal spermatogenesis, germ cell survival and male fertility. These Homeobox genes
are exclusively expressed in the reproductive system. A recent study has introduced
ROHX cluster functions as an appropriate biomarker for idiopathic male
infertility. This study also revealed that hypermethylation of RHOX
cluster can cause severe abnormalities in the sperm parameters (36). It is also assumed
that hypermethylation of DNA may suppress RHOX gene clusters transcription. Incorrect DNA
methylation in the promoter region of the deleted-inazoospermia-like
(DAZL) gene has been shown to be associated with impaired
spermatogenesis and sperm dysfunction (37). It is estimated that approximately 10% of men
with impaired spermatogenesis suffered from DAZL deletion (38). Recently
it has been reported that decreased expression of DNMTs genes is
associated with azoospermia and infertility (39). Hammoud et al. (33), revealed a
substantial relationship between modified methylation of H19, LIT1, SNRPN, MEST,
PEG3, PLAGL1, and IGF2 genes in human sperm and male
infertility. In another study, DNA methylation at MEST gene was
considerably correlated to increased level of FSH, decreased testicular volume and
resulted in oligozoospermia (40). Also, it has been found that abnormal methylation
reaches to about 41% in the sperm cells of patients who undergoing ART (41). Decreased
level of DNA methylation in the H19-ICR has been reported that is
negatively correlated with sperm count. A significant decrease of DNA methylation in the
H19 gene was found in testicular sperm of azoospermic men in comparison
with fertile men (42). In another study by Vieweg et al. (25), methylation of sperm DNA in
normozoospermic men exhibited low standard deviation, while a higher variability in the
percentage of DNA methylation was observed in the promoters of subfertile men. These data
suggest that DNA methylation abnormalities in the human sperm impact on sperm parameters
quality and male infertility.
Histone modifications Role in male infertility
Nucleosome, fundamental unit of chromatin, includes
a short turn of DNA that wrapped around a histone
octamer, two copies of each H2A, H2B, H3, and H4.
This organization provides a rigid structure to chromatin.
Histone modification is a covalent post-translational
change on the lysine rich tail of any of the histone
proteins, particularly H3 and H4 histones (43). Histone
modifications serve as a key regulator for activation and
inactivation of various genes. This reversible process is
controlled by acetyltransferases, deacetyltransferases,
methyltransferases and demethylases enzymes (44).
Different types of post-transcription or modifications
may occur by targeting the N-terminal tail of histones via
acetylation, methylation, phosphorylating, ubiquitination,
simulation, ADP-ribosylation, glycosylation, butyrylation,
citrullination, and propionylation (Table 1) (45). However,
histone acetylation, methylation and phosphorylation are
the most frequently events during sperm development,
spermatogenesis, fertilization and embryo development.
Table 1
Different types of histone modifications
Modification types
Residue (s)
Acetylation
Lysine
Methylation
Lysine/Arginine
Phosphorylation
Serine/Threonine
Ubiquitylation
Lysine
Sumoylation
Lysine
ADP-Ribosylation
Lysine
Glycosylation
Serine/Threonine
Butyrylation
Lysine
Propionylation
Lysine
Different types of histone modificationsHistone modification is a key regulator of mitosis
and spermatogenesis. Some studies have found that
abnormal histone modifications during spermatogenesis
may result in severe damage to sperm development
and male fertility (35). The whole-genome of the male
germ cells is entirely reorganized during the post-meiotic differentiation of spermatids into spermatozoa.
While the core of the spermatid extends and condenses,
most somatic histones are replaced progressively by
protamines. Protamines are small basic sperm-specific
nuclear proteins which are responsible for haploid
genome condensation. This crucial process, tight
packaging, protects sperm genome against side effects
of physical and chemical agents during fertilization
process (46). The exact molecular mechanisms of histone
replacement by protamines during the spermatogenesis
process have been not well-understood. Recent evidence
has indicated that epigenetic modifications of histones
are probably the most important regulators for histones/
protamines exchange in the human spermatozoa (47).
However, histone/protamine exchange may differ in
species because of the different amounts of protamine
in mature mammalian sperm.Histones acetylation, a reversible process, takes place
at certain lysine residues on the amino-terminal ends of
the core histones, which neutralizes the positive charge
on the histones tails and therefore, decreases their
affinity for DNA and provides open chromatin structure
for transcription (48). In other hand, histone acetylation
enhances the transcription level, such as acetylation
of histones H3K4 (H3K4ac) and H3K39 (H3K39ac)
(49). Histone acetyl transferases (HATs) and histone
deacetylases (HDACs) are key regulators of histone
acetylation/deacethylation (50). While HDACs suppress
gene expression, HATs activity enhances gene expression.
In other words, deacetylation is associated with gene
expression suppression, but acetylation is associated
with genes overexpression. Also, Histone acetylation
throughout the human spermatogenesis has been reported.
Increased level of histone H4 hyperacetylation (Hypac-H4)
has been shown in spermatogonia, spermatocyte and also, spermatids (44). Histone H4 hyperacetylation facilitates
interaction of transcription factors with the chromatin.
Hypac-H4 in spermatids increases accumulation of
bromodomain protein, which in turn triggers nuclear
reorganization. Recently, Oikawa et al. (51), have revealed
a significant decrease in the number of spermatogonia
cells with Lys12ac-H4 or Hypac-H4. Several studies
considered the relationship between Hypac-H4 and
impaired spermatogenesis (47). A significant reduction in
the number of spermatids with Hypac-H4 can be found
in men with spermatogenesis deficiency and spermatid
arrest. Shirakata et al. (44), demonstrated that hypac-H4
may trigger histones replacement by protamines during
spermatogenesis. They also found different specific
patterns of histone H4 modification during each stage
spermatogenesis. For example, H4K8ac, H4K12ac,
H4K5ac, H4K20me2 and H4me were increased in
preleptotene spermatocytes, while H4me3 was decreased.
These data suggest a significant association between
histone H4 modifications and gene expression patterns
during spermatogenesis process.Recent evidence has identified several post-translational
modifications, including S42 and K49 acetylation on
protamine-1 (PRM1) and K64 acetylation on protamine-2
(PRM2). Although acetylation of histones is associated
with genes transcription, sperm cells are transcriptionally
inactive. Therefore, it can be hypothesized that histone
acetylation displays an epigenetic mark which is
transmitted from spermatozoa to oocyte. This event
regulates expression of various genes involved in embryo
development (25).Histone methylation is another type of histone
modifications which can be associated with activation or
repression of chromatin state. For example, histone H3
trimethylation at lysine 36 (H3K36me3) and 4 (H3K4me3)
are often associated with an open chromatin structure for
active transcription, while H3 trimethylation at lysines 9
(H3K9me3) and 27 (H3K27me3) can cause transcriptional
repression (25). A histone methyltransferases (HMTases)
involved in methylation of histone that is generally
associated with genes suppressing. Recent studies have
shown different patterns of histone methylation in
human spermatozoa. Therefore, abnormal methylation
of histones can cause severe damages to spermatogenesis
process and incorrect epigenetic programming in human
spermatozoa (51).Also, enzyme histone demethylases (HDMs), a member of the Jumonji protein family, involve
in the histone demethylation. Recently, scientists have reported a tight link between the
activity of JHMD2A (Jumonji C-terminal containing histone demethylase 2A) histone
demethylase and spermatogenesis (47). JHMD2A regulates the expression of protamine 1
(Prm1) and transition nuclear protein 1 (Tnp1), which
are necessary for condensation and proper packaging of sperm chromatin. A recent study has
found histone H3 lysine 4 hypermethylation (H3K4me) or H3 lysine 27 (H3K27me)
hypermethylation in sperm of infertile individuals compared to fertile subjects (25).Histone phosphorylation , another kind of epigenetic
modifications , is associated with transcription process
activation and plays an important role in chromatin
rearrangement during spermatogenesis (44). Also,
Histone phosphorylation can regulate several biological
events, including mitotic/meiotic chromosome
condensation, activation and inactivation of genes
transcription, and double-strand DNA breaks (DSB)
repair (47). Phosphorylation of histones is also involved
in regulation of meiotic replication, chromatin remodeling
and compaction in the nucleus of spermatozoa. Therefore,
defects in histone phosphorylation can be associated with
sperm dysfunction and male infertility problems.
Chromatin remodeling role in male infertility
Chromatin remodeling is the dynamic rearrangement of
chromatin structure in which several protein complexes
such as a SWI/SNF, ISW1 and MI-2 proteins change the
nucleosomes location and structure in an ATP-dependent
process (52). During the chromatin remodeling process
the condensed chromatin of spermatozoa transmits
imprinting and epigenetic information to the embryo (53).
Miller et al. (54), showed that incorrect DNA packaging
in the mice spermatozoa causes infertility. Correct DNA
packaging is essential for normal spermatogenesis
because approximately 85% of the histones are
substituted by protamines during the spermatogenesis
process (55). During the initial stages of spermiogenesis,
histones are hyperacetylated and undergo other
epigenetic modifications. Nucleosomes are progressively
disassembled in the final stage of spermatogenesis and
then replaced by TNPs and eventually protamines.Protamines incorporation into the chromatin of
spermatozoa induces DNA condensation, which is critical
for sperm production and migration. Phosphorylation/
dephosphorylation of protamines is a key mechanism
regulating interaction between them and DNA.
Phosphorylation of protamines by a protein kinase A
(PKA) increases their affinity or binding to DNA. Also,
protamines dephosphorylation occurs concomitantly with
the maturation of nucleoprotamine. Mutations in calcium/
calmodulin-dependent protein kinase 4 (CaMK4),
which is involved in phosphorylation of protamine 2,
causes impaired spermiogenesis and consequently, male
infertility (56). In the mature spermatozoa, DNA is
packaged densely with protamines during the fertilization
process, while the maternal genome is densely packaged
with histones. Therefore, the highly condensed structure
of nucleoprotamine must be unpacked and rearranged into
a nucleosomal structure during the fertilization process.
Incorrect epigenetic modifications during each stage of
these processes can lead to severe male infertility. Given
the critical roles of PRM1 and PRM2 in normal sperm
function and fertilization process, the haploinsufficiency
of these proteins can be associated with decreased amount
of the respective protein, which in turn increases the percentage of sperm with abnormal chromatin structure
and damaged DNA (35). Additionally, it has been shown
that the optimal proportion of PRM1 to PRM2 (PRM1/
PRM2 ratio), which is critical for normal fertilization,
is tightly regulated (57). It has been indicated that the
PRM1/PRM2 ratio in the fertile individuals ranges from
0.8-1.2 and deviation from this ratio may negatively affect
sperm quality, sperm DNA integrity and increase the risk
of infertility in men. Men with an increased PRM1/PRM2
ratio are characterized by poor quality of sperm and
reduced fertilizing capacity. Aberrant H4 acetylation has
been shown to be correlated to impaired spermatogenesis
(42). Sonnack et al. (58), observed that a decreased level
of histone H4 acetylation in men with infertility problems
is significantly associated with impaired spermatogenesis.
Histone H4 hyperacetylation, which decreases the affinity
of histone to DNA, is essential for histone to protamine
transition (35). Hyperacetylation of histone H4 is also
found in the infertile men with Sertoli cell-only syndrome
(SCOS) (59).
Genetic imprinting role in male infertility
Genetic imprinting is an epigenetic process in which the expression of alleles occurs in
a parent-of-origin-specific manner. This process is a consequence of changes in
methylation of CpG islands in one allele. Genetic imprinting determines the origin of
genes expression from the parental or maternal genomes, a process which is critical for
embryo development (41). There are multiple loci imprinting in human. For example, human
spermatogonia from the fetal period are often unmethylated at H19 differentially
methylated regions (DMR), while spermatogonia from the testis are highly methylated in DMR
(35). Several imprinted genes such as the paternally imprinted GTL2 and
H19 genes were previously considered in men with infertility problems
(60). The relationship between reduced methylation of the paternal
IGF2⁄H19 imprinting control region 1 (ICR1) and GTL2
imprints in spermatozoa of men with disturbed spermatogenesis indicates the importance of
genetic imprinting during spermatogenesis. In a study, Poplinski et al. (61), demonstrated
that fertile individuals have high levels of IGF2⁄H19-ICR1, while
methylation of MEST shows a significant decrease. They also showed that
hypermethylation of IGF2⁄H19-ICR1 and MEST has a
correlation with low sperm counts. These data indicated that imprinting deficiencies in
the IGF2⁄H19 ICR1 and MEST can be associated with idiopathic male
infertility. Therefore, aberrant MEST methylation can be considered as a strong indicator
of sperm quality. Recent evidence has indicated that ART techniques such as
intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI), in vitro fertilization (IVF) and
round spermatid injection (ROSI) can enhance the prevalence of imprinting defects and
also, negatively affect human embryonic development through selecting immature sperm cells
which may not have proper imprints or global methylation (3). More importantly, ART
techniques may transmit epigenetic modifications to the next generation and cause the
birth of children with a higher risk of infertility and other congenital abnormalities.
Therefore, more efforts are necessary to optimize current ART techniques. Additionally,
selection of appropriate procedures needs careful evaluation. Since epigenetic
modifications can be maintained throughout the human lifespan and can potentially be
transmitted to the next generations, long-term follow-up and health evaluation of ART
offspring are essential to provide more robust clinical evidence (62).
miRNAs role in the male infertility
Epigenetic modifications may also extend on
mechanisms, including non-coding RNA such as micro-RNAs (miRNAs). Non-coding RNAs, especially miRNAs
and PIWI interacting RNAs (piRNAs), consist the most
contents of RNAs in a cell and regulate gene expression
at different levels. Also, miRNAs negatively regulate
the expression pattern of various genes at the post-transcriptional level. Recent investigations confirmed
the role of miRNAs in the regulation of development,
differentiation, and progression of various diseases.
Expression pattern alterations of these RNAs in the sperm
cells can be associated with severe abnormalities of
these cells and next generations (12). In an experimental
study, Skinner et al. (63), demonstrated that alteration in
the DNA methylation and ncRNA of sperm by Dichloro
Diphenyl Trichloroethane (DDT) can be transferred and
inherited in the next generation.
Epigenetic regulation of sperm development
Epigenetic modifications control all steps of fertilization
from testicular cells development to embryo development
(Fig .2). The initial stage of reprogramming event
takes place in the developing gonads. The testes of all
mammals involve all stages of spermatogenesis from
germ cells to mature spermatozoa. In the normal germ
cells, epigenetic alterations are reversible and cause
changes in the various genes expression whenever it is
necessary. Epigenetic modifications are highly active
in developing germ cells, where sperm and oocyte are
equipped with an appropriate epigenetic information
before embryonic development (15). Germ cells undergo
a series of dramatic morphological alterations, as well as
specific and extensive chromatin remodeling during their
differentiation into mature spermatozoa (64).Spermatozoa are highly specialized cells, which are
produced during spermatogenesis from germ cells. It is
a highly conserved process that regulates by extensive
cellular, epigenetic and chromatin modifications. Sperm
cells transfer the genetic information from one generation
to the next and are thus critical for maintenance of life.
Genetic and epigenetic mechanisms, especially unique
gene expression patterns, histone modifications and DNA
methylation, have important functions in the regulation of
germ-cell development (45). Meiosis, a process in which
a germ cell is divided to four gametes, is associated with histone modifications. After meiosis division, germ cells
undergo several chromatin rearrangements, especially
histone replacement with protamine.Dynamic epigenetic alteration is central for
differentiation of mammalian sperm; however, the
mechanism of these modifications is still unknown.
Spermatogenesis is a unique process which is precisely
regulated by epigenetic modifications and results in the
formation of haploid spermatozoa with the fertilization
ability. The process of spermatogenesis is accompanied
by chromatin rearrangement from a nucleosomal
histones-based structure to a protamines-based structure.
Mitotic amplification, meiotic, and post-meiotic phase
(also known as spermiogenesis) are the critical phases
of spermatogenesis. Replication and differentiation of
spermatogonial stem cells into primary spermatocytes is
the initial phase of spermatogenesis process. In meiosis,
the primary spermatocytes are developed into haploid
secondary spermatocytes through genetic recombination.
During the haploid stage of spermatogenesis, round
spermatids are differentiated into spermatozoa (65). In this
process, histone H4 hyperacetylation causes nucleosome
disassembly, DNA breaks and incorporation of non-allelic
variants of histones (43). Histones are largely exchanged
by transition proteins and then by the protamines PRM1
and PRM2. Recent evidence has indicated that ~99% of
histones in the mice mature spermatozoa and ~85% of
histones in the human sperm are exchanged by PRM1
and PRM2. Human sperm protamines are phosphorylated
at several specific sites, including PRM1S11, PRM2S59
and PRM1S9; however, the exact mechanism of this
phosphorylation is still unclear. These proteins also
undergo further post-translational modifications during
sperm maturation and transition in the epididymis. During
this process, protamines form disulfide bonds and zinc
bridges which stabilize the sperm chromatin structure
(57). The relationship between protamines and DNA
results in significant structural and molecular remodeling
which subsequently compacts sperm DNA in the
nucleoprotamine toroidal structures. The protamine-DNA
interaction not only facilitates the normal morphology and
hydrodynamic shape of the sperm head, but also protects
the paternal genome against physical and chemical
damages.During the fertilization process, oocyte and spermatozoa
fuse to form a single totipotent cell called zygote which
can produce a new organism. Although sperm chromatin
is extensively rearranged, histones are associated with the
paternal genome postfertilization process and contribute
to zygotic chromatin. The highly compacted sperm DNA
is decondensed from its transcriptionally inactive state and
expands to active state found in the paternal pronucleus.
In the zygote, the paternal histone proteins might then
serve as a template for newly synthesized histones
during replication. In postfertilization, the programmatic
sperm DNA packaging can therefore deliver epigenetic
information to the oocyte and the zygote (53).The patterns of DNA methylation are first acquired
during gametogenesis. A growing number of evidences
has illustrated the importance of DNA methylation for
male germ cell development in a mouse model. It has
been shown that gene targeting of enzymes responsible
for DNA methylation leads to loss of germ cells
methylation, meiosis deficiency and male infertility (42).
A recent study has demonstrated that mono-, di- and trimethylations of different histones, H3K9, H3K4, and
H3K27, tightly regulate temporal expression and correct
progression of spermatogenesis (44). Methylation level
of H3K4 is enhanced in the spermatogonial stem cell.
Reduced methylation level of histone H3K4 decreases
the activity of Mll2 (an H3K4 methyl transferase) which
in turn declines the number of spermatocytes. This
suggests the important role of H3K4 methylation in
differentiation of spermatocyte from the stem cell stage
(64). Conversely, the methylation of histones H3K9 and
H3K27 in the stem cell is low, but its level increases
during meiosis. Several lines of studies indicated the
association between the methylation of histone H3K9 and
euchromatin, heterochromatin and sex chromosomes in
the late pachytene stage. However, the H3K9 methylation
level decreases during the completion of meiosis, which
is associated with an increase in H3K4me levels.
Conclusion
The advent of new technologies has revealed differential
expression patterns of various genes in testicular cells
and spermatozoa which opened a new window to male
infertility etiology. Epigenetics alterations of DNA,
histones, chromatins and miRNAs are significant factors
that regulate spermatogenesis and impact fertility. These
modifications not only involve in the regulation of
somatic and germ cells development, but also control all
stages of spermatogenesis process. Epigenetic alterations
also control the correct expression patterns of various
genes during the spermatogenesis and subsequently,
fertilization. In other words, epigenetic alterations are
necessary for the correct expression of various genes in
normal conditions. Although ART technologies such as
ICSI and IVF have provided a good opportunity for most
infertile couples to have their own child, the abnormal
epigenetic information transmission to the next generation
may associate with increased risk of infertility and other
health problems.
Authors: Saher Sue Hammoud; David A Nix; Ahmad O Hammoud; Mark Gibson; Bradley R Cairns; Douglas T Carrell Journal: Hum Reprod Date: 2011-06-17 Impact factor: 6.918
Authors: Darshan P Patel; Tim G Jenkins; Kenneth I Aston; Jingtao Guo; Alexander W Pastuszak; Heidi A Hanson; James M Hotaling Journal: Fertil Steril Date: 2020-02-20 Impact factor: 7.329
Authors: Mami Oikawa; Angela Simeone; Eva Hormanseder; Marta Teperek; Vincent Gaggioli; Alan O'Doherty; Emma Falk; Matthieu Sporniak; Clive D'Santos; Valar Nila Roamio Franklin; Kamal Kishore; Charles R Bradshaw; Declan Keane; Thomas Freour; Laurent David; Adrian T Grzybowski; Alexander J Ruthenburg; John Gurdon; Jerome Jullien Journal: Nat Commun Date: 2020-07-13 Impact factor: 14.919