Arne Ludwig1,2, Martin Pippel1,2, Gene Myers1,2, Michael Hiller1,2,3,4,5,6. 1. Max Planck Institute of Molecular Cell Biology and Genetics, Pfotenhauerstr. 108, 01307 Dresden, Germany. 2. Center for Systems Biology Dresden, Pfotenhauerstr. 108, 01307 Dresden, Germany. 3. Max Planck Institute for the Physics of Complex Systems, Nöthnitzer Str. 38, 01187 Dresden, Germany. 4. LOEWE Centre for Translational Biodiversity Genomics, Senckenberganlage 25, 60325 Frankfurt, Germany. 5. Senckenberg Research Institute, Senckenberganlage 25, 60325 Frankfurt, Germany. 6. Goethe-University, Faculty of Biosciences, Max-von-Laue-Str. 9, 60438 Frankfurt, Germany.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Long sequencing reads allow increasing contiguity and completeness of fragmented, short-read-based genome assemblies by closing assembly gaps, ideally at high accuracy. While several gap-closing methods have been developed, these methods often close an assembly gap with sequence that does not accurately represent the true sequence. FINDINGS: Here, we present DENTIST, a sensitive, highly accurate, and automated pipeline method to close gaps in short-read assemblies with long error-prone reads. DENTIST comprehensively determines repetitive assembly regions to identify reliable and unambiguous alignments of long reads to the correct loci, integrates a consensus sequence computation step to obtain a high base accuracy for the inserted sequence, and validates the accuracy of closed gaps. Unlike previous benchmarks, we generated test assemblies that have gaps at the exact positions where real short-read assemblies have gaps. Generating such realistic benchmarks for Drosophila (134 Mb genome), Arabidopsis (119 Mb), hummingbird (1 Gb), and human (3 Gb) and using simulated or real PacBio continuous long reads, we show that DENTIST consistently achieves a substantially higher accuracy compared to previous methods, while having a similar sensitivity. CONCLUSION: DENTIST provides an accurate approach to improve the contiguity and completeness of fragmented assemblies with long reads. DENTIST's source code including a Snakemake workflow, conda package, and Docker container is available at https://github.com/a-ludi/dentist. All test assemblies as a resource for future benchmarking are at https://bds.mpi-cbg.de/hillerlab/DENTIST/.
BACKGROUND: Long sequencing reads allow increasing contiguity and completeness of fragmented, short-read-based genome assemblies by closing assembly gaps, ideally at high accuracy. While several gap-closing methods have been developed, these methods often close an assembly gap with sequence that does not accurately represent the true sequence. FINDINGS: Here, we present DENTIST, a sensitive, highly accurate, and automated pipeline method to close gaps in short-read assemblies with long error-prone reads. DENTIST comprehensively determines repetitive assembly regions to identify reliable and unambiguous alignments of long reads to the correct loci, integrates a consensus sequence computation step to obtain a high base accuracy for the inserted sequence, and validates the accuracy of closed gaps. Unlike previous benchmarks, we generated test assemblies that have gaps at the exact positions where real short-read assemblies have gaps. Generating such realistic benchmarks for Drosophila (134 Mb genome), Arabidopsis (119 Mb), hummingbird (1 Gb), and human (3 Gb) and using simulated or real PacBio continuous long reads, we show that DENTIST consistently achieves a substantially higher accuracy compared to previous methods, while having a similar sensitivity. CONCLUSION: DENTIST provides an accurate approach to improve the contiguity and completeness of fragmented assemblies with long reads. DENTIST's source code including a Snakemake workflow, conda package, and Docker container is available at https://github.com/a-ludi/dentist. All test assemblies as a resource for future benchmarking are at https://bds.mpi-cbg.de/hillerlab/DENTIST/.
Authors: W James Kent; Robert Baertsch; Angie Hinrichs; Webb Miller; David Haussler Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2003-09-19 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Wesley C Warren; R Alan Harris; Marina Haukness; Ian T Fiddes; Shwetha C Murali; Jason Fernandes; Philip C Dishuck; Jessica M Storer; Muthuswamy Raveendran; LaDeana W Hillier; David Porubsky; Yafei Mao; David Gordon; Mitchell R Vollger; Alexandra P Lewis; Katherine M Munson; Elizabeth DeVogelaere; Joel Armstrong; Mark Diekhans; Jerilyn A Walker; Chad Tomlinson; Tina A Graves-Lindsay; Milinn Kremitzki; Sofie R Salama; Peter A Audano; Merly Escalona; Nicholas W Maurer; Francesca Antonacci; Ludovica Mercuri; Flavia A M Maggiolini; Claudia Rita Catacchio; Jason G Underwood; David H O'Connor; Ashley D Sanders; Jan O Korbel; Betsy Ferguson; H Michael Kubisch; Louis Picker; Ned H Kalin; Douglas Rosene; Jon Levine; David H Abbott; Stanton B Gray; Mar M Sanchez; Zsofia A Kovacs-Balint; Joseph W Kemnitz; Sara M Thomasy; Jeffrey A Roberts; Erin L Kinnally; John P Capitanio; J H Pate Skene; Michael Platt; Shelley A Cole; Richard E Green; Mario Ventura; Roger W Wiseman; Benedict Paten; Mark A Batzer; Jeffrey Rogers; Evan E Eichler Journal: Science Date: 2020-12-18 Impact factor: 47.728
Authors: Aaron M Wenger; Paul Peluso; William J Rowell; Pi-Chuan Chang; Richard J Hall; Gregory T Concepcion; Jana Ebler; Arkarachai Fungtammasan; Alexey Kolesnikov; Nathan D Olson; Armin Töpfer; Michael Alonge; Medhat Mahmoud; Yufeng Qian; Chen-Shan Chin; Adam M Phillippy; Michael C Schatz; Gene Myers; Mark A DePristo; Jue Ruan; Tobias Marschall; Fritz J Sedlazeck; Justin M Zook; Heng Li; Sergey Koren; Andrew Carroll; David R Rank; Michael W Hunkapiller Journal: Nat Biotechnol Date: 2019-08-12 Impact factor: 54.908
Authors: Christopher M Lee; Galt P Barber; Jonathan Casper; Hiram Clawson; Mark Diekhans; Jairo Navarro Gonzalez; Angie S Hinrichs; Brian T Lee; Luis R Nassar; Conner C Powell; Brian J Raney; Kate R Rosenbloom; Daniel Schmelter; Matthew L Speir; Ann S Zweig; David Haussler; Maximilian Haeussler; Robert M Kuhn; W James Kent Journal: Nucleic Acids Res Date: 2020-01-08 Impact factor: 16.971
Authors: Arang Rhie; Shane A McCarthy; Olivier Fedrigo; Joana Damas; Giulio Formenti; Sergey Koren; Marcela Uliano-Silva; William Chow; Arkarachai Fungtammasan; Juwan Kim; Chul Lee; Byung June Ko; Mark Chaisson; Gregory L Gedman; Lindsey J Cantin; Francoise Thibaud-Nissen; Leanne Haggerty; Iliana Bista; Michelle Smith; Bettina Haase; Jacquelyn Mountcastle; Sylke Winkler; Sadye Paez; Jason Howard; Sonja C Vernes; Tanya M Lama; Frank Grutzner; Wesley C Warren; Christopher N Balakrishnan; Dave Burt; Julia M George; Matthew T Biegler; David Iorns; Andrew Digby; Daryl Eason; Bruce Robertson; Taylor Edwards; Mark Wilkinson; George Turner; Axel Meyer; Andreas F Kautt; Paolo Franchini; H William Detrich; Hannes Svardal; Maximilian Wagner; Gavin J P Naylor; Martin Pippel; Milan Malinsky; Mark Mooney; Maria Simbirsky; Brett T Hannigan; Trevor Pesout; Marlys Houck; Ann Misuraca; Sarah B Kingan; Richard Hall; Zev Kronenberg; Ivan Sović; Christopher Dunn; Zemin Ning; Alex Hastie; Joyce Lee; Siddarth Selvaraj; Richard E Green; Nicholas H Putnam; Ivo Gut; Jay Ghurye; Erik Garrison; Ying Sims; Joanna Collins; Sarah Pelan; James Torrance; Alan Tracey; Jonathan Wood; Robel E Dagnew; Dengfeng Guan; Sarah E London; David F Clayton; Claudio V Mello; Samantha R Friedrich; Peter V Lovell; Ekaterina Osipova; Farooq O Al-Ajli; Simona Secomandi; Heebal Kim; Constantina Theofanopoulou; Michael Hiller; Yang Zhou; Robert S Harris; Kateryna D Makova; Paul Medvedev; Jinna Hoffman; Patrick Masterson; Karen Clark; Fergal Martin; Kevin Howe; Paul Flicek; Brian P Walenz; Woori Kwak; Hiram Clawson; Mark Diekhans; Luis Nassar; Benedict Paten; Robert H S Kraus; Andrew J Crawford; M Thomas P Gilbert; Guojie Zhang; Byrappa Venkatesh; Robert W Murphy; Klaus-Peter Koepfli; Beth Shapiro; Warren E Johnson; Federica Di Palma; Tomas Marques-Bonet; Emma C Teeling; Tandy Warnow; Jennifer Marshall Graves; Oliver A Ryder; David Haussler; Stephen J O'Brien; Jonas Korlach; Harris A Lewin; Kerstin Howe; Eugene W Myers; Richard Durbin; Adam M Phillippy; Erich D Jarvis Journal: Nature Date: 2021-04-28 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: David Jebb; Zixia Huang; Martin Pippel; Graham M Hughes; Ksenia Lavrichenko; Paolo Devanna; Sylke Winkler; Lars S Jermiin; Emilia C Skirmuntt; Aris Katzourakis; Lucy Burkitt-Gray; David A Ray; Kevin A M Sullivan; Juliana G Roscito; Bogdan M Kirilenko; Liliana M Dávalos; Angelique P Corthals; Megan L Power; Gareth Jones; Roger D Ransome; Dina K N Dechmann; Andrea G Locatelli; Sébastien J Puechmaille; Olivier Fedrigo; Erich D Jarvis; Michael Hiller; Sonja C Vernes; Eugene W Myers; Emma C Teeling Journal: Nature Date: 2020-07-22 Impact factor: 49.962