| Literature DB >> 35058294 |
Dexter Canoy1,2, Emma Copland1, Milad Nazarzadeh1, Rema Ramakrishnan3, Ana-Catarina Pinho-Gomes4,5, Abdul Salam6,7, Jamie P Dwyer8, Farshad Farzadfar9, Johan Sundström10, Mark Woodward6,11, Barry R Davis12, Kazem Rahimi13,2.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Evidence from randomised trials of pharmacological treatments on long-term blood pressure (BP) reduction is limited. We investigated the antihypertensive drug effects on BP over time and across different participant characteristics.Entities:
Keywords: clinical; hypertension; meta-analysis; pharmacology
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35058294 PMCID: PMC9340038 DOI: 10.1136/heartjnl-2021-320171
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Heart ISSN: 1355-6037 Impact factor: 7.365
Characteristics of trials and participants
| Characteristics | Blood pressure (BP) difference trials | Drug class comparison trials | All trials | ||
| BP-lowering intensity | Placebo controlled | All BP difference trials | |||
| Trials | |||||
| No. of trials | 9 | 21 | 30 | 29 | 52* |
| No. of trials by year of end of study | |||||
| Before 1990 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 0 | 3 |
| 1990–1999 | 2 | 7 | 9 | 7 | 14 |
| 2000–2009 | 2 | 10 | 12 | 19 | 27 |
| After 2009 | 4 | 2 | 6 | 3 | 8 |
| Mean (SD) trial duration (years) | 4 (2) | 4 (2) | 4 (2) | 4 (2) | 4 (2) |
| Mean (median) no. of follow-up BP measures | 14 (13) | 7 (6) | 8 (8) | 8 (7) | 8 (8) |
| Participants | |||||
| No. of participants (% women) | 35 934 (45) | 112 934 (35) | 148 873 (38) | 224 038 (44) | 363 684 (42) |
| % (n/N) Caucasian/European ethnicity | 46 (15 863/34 823) | 68 (58 851/86 908) | 61 (74 714/121 731) | 64 (118 128/185 351) | 63 (188 948/297 852) |
| % (N) current smoker at baselineb | 22 (8238/35 908) | 16 (17 702/111 190) | 18 (25 940/147 098) | 20 (44 173/220 708) | 19 (68 360/359 719) |
| Mean (SD) baseline SBP/DBP | 151 (21)/88 (15) | 146 (21)/83 (11) | 147 (21)/84 (12) | 156 (21)/90 (12) | 152 (21)/87 (12) |
| % (N) participants by baseline SBP (mm Hg) | |||||
| <120/<70 | 4 (2870)/11 (3806) | 8 (9176)/9 (10 037) | 7 (10 650)/9 (13 843) | 3 (7027)/5 (10 410) | 5 (17 128)/7 (23 803) |
| 120–129/70–79 | 9 (6228) / 17 (6075) | 13 (15 063)/24 (26 927) | 13 (18 448)/22 (33 002) | 6 (12 969)/14 (31 330) | 9 (30 720)/17 (63 091) |
| 130–139/80–89 | 18 (11,289) / 24 (8593) | 17 (19 674)/39 (43 738) | 18 (26 077)/34 (50 623) | 11 (23 906)/28 (62 292) | 14 (48 820)/30 (109 589) |
| 140–149/90–99 | 19 (11 393)/29 (14 890) | 18 (20 590)/21 (24 043) | 19 (27 386)/23 (34 324) | 18 (41 220)/30 (67 403) | 19 (66 928)/27 (98 994) |
| 150–159/100–109 | 17 (10 050)/14 (6342) | 14 (16 246)/7 (7355) | 14 (21 107)/8 (12 264) | 19 (42 509)/18 (39 839) | 17 (61 495)/14 (51 014) |
| ≥160/≥110 | 33 (19 050)/6 (2696) | 28 (32 114)/1 (750) | 30 (43 396)/2 (2994) | 43 (95 833)/5 (12 188) | 38 (136 226)/4 (14 810) |
| Mean (SD) age (years) at baseline | 61 (12) | 65 (10) | 64 (11) | 65 (9) | 65 (10) |
| % (N) of participants by age at baseline | |||||
| <50 years | 16 (7146) | 5 (5596) | 8 (11 256) | 4 (9542) | 5 (19 122) |
| 50–59 years | 34 (18 465) | 22 (24 668) | 25 (36 978) | 24 (52 819) | 24 (86 699) |
| 60–69 years | 27 (18 005) | 39 (44 374) | 36 (54 016) | 39 (87 144) | 38 (137 849) |
| 70–79 years | 18 (13 313) | 26 (28 921) | 24 (35 264) | 28 (63 119) | 27 (97 290) |
| ≥80 years | 6 (3999) | 8 (9342) | 8 (11 321) | 5 (11 369) | 6 (22 638) |
| % (N) with condition at baseline† | |||||
| Cardiovascular disease | 16 (5617/35 934) | 66 (72 209/110 020) | 54 (78 738/145 945) | 45 (98 944/221 993) | 49 (175 519/359 357) |
| Coronary heart disease | 11 (4120/35 934) | 41 (45 591/110 008) | 34 (49 711/145 942) | 38 (67 766/177 363) | 37 (115 562/316 125) |
| Stroke | 3 (966/34,840) | 34 (32 650/95 800) | 28 (36 521/130 643) | 11 (17 830/168 003) | 18 (51 320/292 559) |
| Diabetes | 24 (8540/35 934) | 36 (36 179/100 697) | 33 (44 719/136 631) | 26 (58 404/223 654) | 28 (99 375/351 357) |
| Chronic kidney disease | 33 (4854/14 799) | 9 (2845/25 789) | 19 (7699/40 588) | 17 (18 917/108 612) | 17 (24 289/145 895) |
| % (N) previously on BP-lowering medication† | 34 (12 141/35 934) | 71 (73 833/103 766) | 65 (73 237/126 502) | 77 (119 454/155 069) | 69 (202 428/293281) |
| Mean (SD) body mass index† (kg/m2) | 29 (6) | 28 (5) | 28 (5) | 28 (5) | 28 (5) |
*Some trials provided data to more than one trial design.
†Data limited to those with relevant information and N refers to the denominator for number of participants with information on the relevant variable.
SBP, systolic blood pressure; DBP, diastolic blood pressure.
Figure 1Blood pressure (BP) trajectories according to different trial designs. Results are in red for active group and black for control group, from 3 months to 5 years of follow-up. Estimates were based on separate models for treatment and control groups, with random intercepts at individual and trial levels, a random slope for time at the individual level (see Method for details) and adjusted for baseline BP, age and sex. Baseline systolic/diastolic BP for active and control groups were: BP-lowering trials=151/88 mm Hg; placebo-controlled trials=146/83 mm Hg and drug class comparison trials=156/90 mm Hg. Estimated BP at specific time points are shown in online supplemental table S8). Results for all BP difference trials are shown in online supplemental figure S2.
Figure 2Effects of blood pressure (BP)-lowering treatment on mean BP at fixed follow-up time points and across all follow-up period. (A) Systolic BP; (B) Diastolic BP. For mean difference at fixed follow-up time periods, estimates were based on separate models for each time period with a fixed treatment effect and random intercept for individuals. For mean difference achieved across all time period (showing results based on all follow-up BP measures and measures obtained from 12 months until end of follow-up), estimates were based on fixed treatment effect and random intercepts at individual and trial levels, a random slope for time at the individual level. All mean difference values were adjusted for baseline BP, age and sex. The area of the square is inversely proportional to the variance of the estimated difference. Negative values indicate lower BP in the active than in the control group. Additional information provided in online supplemental table S9 and S10), and results for all BP difference trials are in online supplemental figure S3.
Figure 3Effects of blood pressure (BP)-lowering treatment on mean BP, by baseline characteristics. (A) mean systolic BP difference; (B) mean diastolic BP difference. Estimates based on fixed treatment effect and random intercepts at individual and trial levels, a random slope for time at the individual level (see Method for details) and adjusted for baseline BP), age and sex except when these variables are used as stratification factors. The area of the square is inversely proportional to the variance of the estimated difference. Negative values indicate lower BP in the active than in the control group. Results for all BP difference trials are in online supplemental figure S4. To provide context of background BP levels, baseline BP by these subgroups are shown in online supplemental table S2.