Vineeta Kaushik1,2, Manisha Goel1. 1. Department of Biophysics, University of Delhi South Campus, New Delhi 110021, India. 2. International Centre for Translational Eye Research, Institute of Physical Chemistry, Polish Academy of Sciences, Kasprzaka 44/5, Warsaw 01-224, Poland.
Abstract
The Archaea constitute separate domain of life and show resemblance with bacteria in their metabolic pathways while showing similarity with eukaryotes at the level of molecular processes such as cell division, DNA replication, protein synthesis, and proteostasis. However, the molecular machinery of archaea can be considered a simpler version of that found in eukaryotes because of the absence of multiple paralogs for any given molecular factor. Therefore, archaeal systems can possibly be used as a model system for understanding the eukaryotic protein folding machinery and thereby may help to address the molecular mechanism of various protein (mis)foldings and diseases. In the process of protein folding, the cis-trans isomerization of the peptide-prolyl bond is a rate-limiting step for the correct folding of proteins. Different types of peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerases can accelerate this reaction, e.g., cyclophilin, FKBP, and parvulin. Among the five phyla of the archaeal domain, homologs of the cyclophilin protein are found only in two. Here we have characterized a cyclophilin from an archaeal organism, Nitrosopumilus maritimus (NmCyp), belonging to the phylum Thaumarchaeota. Like other known cyclophilins, NmCyp also possesses PPIase activity that can be inhibited by cyclosporine A. Generally, archaeal proteins are expected to possess differential thermal stability due to their adaptation to extreme environmental niche conditions. However, NmCyp exhibits low thermal stability and starts to aggregate beyond 40 °C. The properties of NmCyp are compared to those reported for the cyclophilin from another archaeal organism, Methanobrevibacter ruminantium. The current study sheds light on the differential behavior of cyclophilin proteins from two different phyla of archaea.
The Archaea constitute separate domain of life and show resemblance with bacteria in their metabolic pathways while showing similarity with eukaryotes at the level of molecular processes such as cell division, DNA replication, protein synthesis, and proteostasis. However, the molecular machinery of archaea can be considered a simpler version of that found in eukaryotes because of the absence of multiple paralogs for any given molecular factor. Therefore, archaeal systems can possibly be used as a model system for understanding the eukaryotic protein folding machinery and thereby may help to address the molecular mechanism of various protein (mis)foldings and diseases. In the process of protein folding, the cis-trans isomerization of the peptide-prolyl bond is a rate-limiting step for the correct folding of proteins. Different types of peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerases can accelerate this reaction, e.g., cyclophilin, FKBP, and parvulin. Among the five phyla of the archaeal domain, homologs of the cyclophilin protein are found only in two. Here we have characterized a cyclophilin from an archaeal organism, Nitrosopumilus maritimus (NmCyp), belonging to the phylum Thaumarchaeota. Like other known cyclophilins, NmCyp also possesses PPIase activity that can be inhibited by cyclosporine A. Generally, archaeal proteins are expected to possess differential thermal stability due to their adaptation to extreme environmental niche conditions. However, NmCyp exhibits low thermal stability and starts to aggregate beyond 40 °C. The properties of NmCyp are compared to those reported for the cyclophilin from another archaeal organism, Methanobrevibacter ruminantium. The current study sheds light on the differential behavior of cyclophilin proteins from two different phyla of archaea.
Cyclophilins
(CyPs) are a family of evolutionarily conserved and
ubiquitous proteins present in prokaryotes, eukaryotes, and some species
of archaea, named so because they are specific receptors for the immunosuppressive
drug cyclosporine A (CsA).[1,2] These proteins are known
to have peptidyl prolyl isomerase (PPIase) activity and therefore
catalyze the cis–trans isomerization of peptide bonds at proline
residues in their substrate target proteins, thereby playing an essential
role in the protein folding homeostasis.[3] All cyclophilins share a conserved domain, commonly known as the
cyclophilin-like domain (CLD).[4,5] However, a few unusual
domains like the WD domain, Leu zipper, and phosphatase binding domain
have also been reported in proteins in addition to the CLD.[6] Depending upon the presence of these functional
segments, cyclophilins are classified into two classes, i.e., single-domain
and multidomain cyclophilins. Single-domain cyclophilins possess only
CLD and exhibit PPIase activity.[7] Multidomain
cyclophilins also possess other functional domains including TPR and
WD40 domains that have been reported to be involved in protein–protein
interaction and the assembly of multiprotein complexes. Cyclophilins
are present in all the cellular compartments of eukaryotes and have
been reported to influence processes like protein trafficking and
maturation, receptor complex stabilization, apoptosis, receptor signaling,
detoxification from reactive oxygen species, immune response, and
spliceosome assembly.[8−15] Most of the eukaryotic and prokaryotic cyclophilins exist in monomeric
form in their crystal structures. Their structure consists of β-barrels
made of eight antiparallel β strands with one α-helix
on each side.[1] There are a total 17 cyclophilin
isoforms present in humans, among which the following have been characterized
in more detail: hCypA, hCypB, hCypC, hCypD, hCypE, hCyp40, and hCypNK.[16]Drosophila, C. elegans, and Saccharomyces cerevisiae have 9, 11, and 8 cyclophilin homologs, respectively.[17,18,5] Cyclophilins from bacteria, i.e., E. coli,B. subtilis, and S. chrysomallus, are also known
in the literature; however, very limited information is available
for cyclophilins from archaeal organisms.[2,19−21]Archaea are considered to be a connecting link
between eukaryotes
and prokaryotes.[22,23] Protein folding in the archaea
is fascinating because archaeal species can grow under extreme environmental
conditions like high temperature, extreme pH, and high salt, which
are normally thought to be disruptive for protein structure and function.[24] Several studies have suggested that chaperones
play a major role in overcoming various kinds of stresses and help
the organism maintain a viable proteome. PPIase proteins like cyclophilins
may be important for the maintenance of the cellular viability in
archaea.[25] However, cyclophilins are present
only in two phyla of archaea: Euryarchaeota and Thaumarchaeota. The
biophysical and biochemical characterization of a cyclophilin from
an archaeal organism, Methanobrevibacter ruminantium of phylum Euryarchaeota, was reported recently.[20] No cyclophilin homolog from any member of Thaumarchaeota
has been characterized yet. The present work is an effort to establish
the similarities and differences in the cyclophilins from the two
archaeal groups. In this work, we have selected the Cyp protein from Nitrosopumilus maritimus, an aquamarine organism
that belongs to the order Nitrosopumilales of the phylum Thaumarchaeota,
for further characterization.[26] Thaumarchaeota
represents a distinctive phylum of the domain Archaea that encompasses
ammonia-oxidizing organisms from the soil, hot springs, and marine
waters. All the Thaumarchaeota discovered so far live under autotrophic
conditions and fixed CO2, but some are dependent on bacteria
for organic materials.[27] For further analysis,
the NmCyp protein (cyclophilin from Nitrosopumilus
maritimus) was overexpressed in E.
coli and the purified protein was used for various
functional assays including biophysical characterization.
Results
The cyclophilin homologs were searched in the predicted
proteomes
of all the 196 archaeal organisms in the NCBI database for which the
whole genome has been sequenced, using P. torridus cyclophilin as the seed sequence.[21] A
total of 122 cyclophilin homologs were identified. The length of the
protein homologs identified from archaeal organisms ranged from 145
to 980 amino acids. It was observed that some cyclophilin-like proteins
were present as multidomain proteins, where a pro-isomerase superfamily
domain was found at the N-terminus of the cyclophilin domain resulting
in a much longer protein length (approximately 900 amino acids). All
of such proteins (16 protein homologs) were found in 15 organisms
of phylum Thaumarchaeota. These organisms also had a smaller and single
domain cyclophilin homolog in all the 15 cases. Therefore, only the
single domain cyclophilins were retained for the current study and
the longer multidomain cyclophilin proteins (16 in number) were removed
from the data set, resulting in 106 sequences of archaeal cyclophilin
proteins where the protein length varied between 140 and 250 amino
acids. A total of 16 genomes of organisms belonging to Thaumarchaeota
were reported, and 15 of them possess a cyclophilin gene in their
genomes. We had selected the cyclophilin protein from one representative
organism from the phylum Thaumarchaeota, Nitrosopumilus
maritimus (named NmCyp in this study), and compared
it with the cyclophilin protein from Methanobrevibacter
ruminantium (MrCyp) of phylum Euryarchaeota, which
has been characterized earlier.[20]Nitrosopumilus maritimus is the first organism reported
from class Thaumarchaeota.[28,29]
Structural
Modeling of the NmCyp Protein
Sequence alignment of the selected
106 cyclophilin protein sequences
was performed with the ClustalOmega software, and a reliability score
for the alignment (score = 95) was generated with T-COFFEE. From the
multiple sequence alignment, it was observed that there are two small
stretches of about 7–10 amino acids each that are found only
in few cyclophilin proteins. The first such stretch was near the N-terminus
of protein homologs found in proteins from organisms of order Halobacteriales
of phylum Euryarchaeota. The other stretch was observed in proteins
from organisms of phylum Thaumarchaeota (Figure S1). Lysine is the conserved residue that was observed in the
unique stretch of cyclophilins of Thaumarchaeota (Figure S1). The significance of this stretch in cyclophilins
of Thaumarchaeota is still unknown. The grand average of hydropathy
(GRAVY) values of cyclophilins from all the organisms of Thaumarchaeota
lie between −0.2 and −0.4, which predict the hydrophilic
nature of cyclophilins from Thaumarchaeota (Figure S2A and Table S1).The physiochemical properties of NmCyp
and MrCyp recombinant proteins are compared (Table S2). The NmCyp protein consists of a total of 158 residues.
Of them, 22 and 17 residues are positively and negatively charged,
respectively. The grand average of hydropathy (GRAVY) is negative
(−0.442), which indicates that the protein is hydrophilic and
therefore might be soluble in water. The cyclophilin from phylum Euryarchaeota
(MrCyp) has a higher GRAVY score (−0.251) as compared to NmCyp,
which implies that NmCyp is less hydrophobic than MrCyp (Figure S2B). The aliphatic index of a protein
is defined as the relative volume of the protein occupied by the aliphatic
side chains. A high aliphatic index is often taken as an index of
a higher thermostability of a protein.[30] The aliphatic index was calculated to be 66.01 and 72.04 for NmCyp
and MrCyp, respectively, suggesting the higher thermostability of
MrCyp over NmCyp.
Functional Annotation and
Modeled 3D Structure
of the NmCyp Protein
To explore the conserved residues in
the archaeal cyclophilin protein NmCyp, the protein sequence was aligned
with other cyclophilins, human CypA, Geobacillus kaustophilus, E. coli, and Methanobrevibacter
ruminantium, which have been studied before. This
sequence comparison with known sequences suggests 16 amino acids (R45,
F50, M51, Q53, T69, Y74, N75, A93, Q96, S100, S103, Q104, F106, F114,
L115, and Y119) to be part of the active site in NmCyp.The
158 amino acid long NmCyp has only one domain, i.e., PpiB (3–143
amino acids). The sequence comparison of NmCyp with the previously
known MrCyp suggests that several binding site residues like R45,
F50, M51, Q53, A93, F106, L115, T69, S103, and Q104 are common among
both the organisms (Figure ). Few other amino acid sites appear to be conserved among
archaeal cyclophilins (apart from the binding site residues), and
their relevance requires further study.
Figure 1
Schematic representation
of the NmCyp protein. NmCyp has 158 amino
acids with one PPiB domain. Binding sites as predicted in comparison
to other known cyclophilins and the sites conserved among all archaeal
cyclophilins are represented by the red dot and blue star, respectively.
Schematic representation
of the NmCyp protein. NmCyp has 158 amino
acids with one PPiB domain. Binding sites as predicted in comparison
to other known cyclophilins and the sites conserved among all archaeal
cyclophilins are represented by the red dot and blue star, respectively.Structures of many bacterial and eukaryotic cyclophilins
are known,
but no structural information is available for any archaeal cyclophilin.
We therefore modeled the structure of NmCyp using the Geobacillus kaustophilus structure (PDB ID: 2MVZ) as a template[31] via the homology modeling approach using the
Modeller 9.17 software.[32]Figure shows the modeled structure
of NmCyp. A total of two alpha helices and eight antiparallel β-strands
are present and make a signature cyclophilin fold. The electrostatic
surface was generated with the help of PyMOL. The accuracy of the
modeled structure was further validated after a refinement process
using Ramachandran map calculations computed with the RAMPAGE software.[33] In the Ramachandran map, total numbers of residues
that lie in favored, allowed, and outlier regions are 94.2, 5.8, and
0%, respectively. It is evident that the conserved binding site residues
lie in the biggest cavity of the protein. The extra stretch of eight
amino acids observed in Figure S1 lies
near the active site of NmCyp. The cavity burrow of NmCyp appears
to be neutral in charge but is surrounded by positively and negatively
charged residues.
Figure 2
Modeled structure of NmCyp. (A) Cartoon representation
of NmCyp
using PyMOL. (B) Active site residues and an extra stretch of eight
amino acid residues are marked on the cartoon structure of NmCyp in
blue and red, respectively. (C) Surface representation of NmCyp with
active site residues and an extra stretch of eight amino acid residues
in blue and red, respectively. (D) Electrostatic potential surface
diagram of NmCyp, where red, blue, and white symbolize negative, positive,
and neutral charge.
Modeled structure of NmCyp. (A) Cartoon representation
of NmCyp
using PyMOL. (B) Active site residues and an extra stretch of eight
amino acid residues are marked on the cartoon structure of NmCyp in
blue and red, respectively. (C) Surface representation of NmCyp with
active site residues and an extra stretch of eight amino acid residues
in blue and red, respectively. (D) Electrostatic potential surface
diagram of NmCyp, where red, blue, and white symbolize negative, positive,
and neutral charge.
Functional
Characterization of NmCyp
To functionally characterize the
overexpressed NmCyp protein, several
assays like the PPIase and chaperone-like activity assay were performed
with the purified protein. PPIase activity was performed against the
target peptide, N-succinyl-ala-ala-pro-phe-p-nitroaniline. The aggregation prevention assay for chaperone-like
activity was performed against bovine carbonic anhydrase II (BCAII)
and citrate synthase (CS) as substrate proteins.
Peptidyl-prolyl
Cis–Trans Isomerase
Assay
The PPIase activity of NmCyp was estimated using the
standard PPIase assay.[34] The peptide N-Suc-ala-ala-pro-phe-p-nitroaniline was
used as a substrate, and the reaction was measured at 15 °C for
20 min. The PPIase activity assay of NmCyp shows that it accelerates
the rate of cis–trans isomerization of the substrate as compared
to the control reaction (Figure ). The PPIase activity of NmCyp was also confirmed
by incubating the protein with its inhibitor cyclosporine A (CsA).
CsA is the known inhibitor of cyclophilin and so is expected to inhibit
the PPIase activity of NmCyp. In the presence of CsA (40 μM),
the PPIase activity of NmCyp diminished significantly. Different concentrations
of CsA below and above 40 μM were also tried; however, the reaction
never reached saturation, which makes the calculation of the reaction
rate unreliable. Therefore, the data accumulated at 40 μM CsA
concentration are used. The speeding up of peptidyl-prolyl cis to
trans isomerization upon adding PPIase in the reaction mixture as
well as its inhibition upon adding the inhibitor CsA proves that NmCyp
acts as a PPIase. The initial rate of cis–trans isomerization
for the substrate only is 0.36 ± 0.02 min–1, which was enhanced 1.4-fold (0.52 ± 0.02 min–1) upon the addition of the NmCyp protein. The rate of reaction is
significantly reduced (approximately 4-fold) (0.13 ± 0.02 min–1) upon the addition of the inhibitor.
Figure 3
PPIase activity of NmCyp.
The PPIase activity of purified recombinant
NmCyp was determined using the synthetic peptide N-succinyl-ala-ala-pro-phe-p-nitroaniline. In the
absence of NmCyp, the reaction proceeds to completion based on the
intrinsic rate of the cis-to-trans isomerization
of the peptide only (black). The addition of NmCyp to the reaction
mixture results in an increase of the initial rate of cis–trans
isomerization reaction (red). The addition of CsA, a cyclophilin family
inhibitor, again lowers the rate of reaction (blue). The PPIase activity
of NmCyp was recorded for 20 min at 390 nm.
PPIase activity of NmCyp.
The PPIase activity of purified recombinant
NmCyp was determined using the synthetic peptide N-succinyl-ala-ala-pro-phe-p-nitroaniline. In the
absence of NmCyp, the reaction proceeds to completion based on the
intrinsic rate of the cis-to-trans isomerization
of the peptide only (black). The addition of NmCyp to the reaction
mixture results in an increase of the initial rate of cis–trans
isomerization reaction (red). The addition of CsA, a cyclophilin family
inhibitor, again lowers the rate of reaction (blue). The PPIase activity
of NmCyp was recorded for 20 min at 390 nm.
Chaperone-like Activity of NmCyp
Chaperones
are known to prevent the aggregation of proteins by binding
to their exposed hydrophobic sites. Such chaperone activity has been
reported in a variety of cyclophilins earlier, so it was imperative
to study if NmCyp does the same. To assay the chaperone-like function,
bovine carbonic anhydrase II (BCAII) and citrate synthase (CS) are
frequently used as substrates, and therefore, these were selected
for assaying the chaperone activity of NmCyp. In the first experiment,
different molar ratios of NmCyp (0.75 and 1.50 μM) were incubated
with BCAII (0.75 μM) at 65 °C (Figure A; only the 1:1 result is shown). It was
observed that with the increase in incubation time (10 min) at 65
°C, NmCyp starts to aggregate, resulting in increased intensity
from 10 to 200 A.U. This study highlights that NmCyp is unstable at
high temperatures, so it could possibly not prevent the aggregation
of other substrate proteins like BCAII.
Figure 4
Thermal aggregation prevention
of BCAII and citrate synthase by
NmCyp. (A) The aggregation prevention of BCAII with the NmCyp protein
using 1:1 molar concentration. (B) The aggregation prevention of citrate
synthase with varying concentrations of the NmCyp protein. The zoom-in
view shows the spectra of citrate synthase at 45 °C. In the figure,
A.U. stands for ″arbitrary units″.
Thermal aggregation prevention
of BCAII and citrate synthase by
NmCyp. (A) The aggregation prevention of BCAII with the NmCyp protein
using 1:1 molar concentration. (B) The aggregation prevention of citrate
synthase with varying concentrations of the NmCyp protein. The zoom-in
view shows the spectra of citrate synthase at 45 °C. In the figure,
A.U. stands for ″arbitrary units″.To overcome the limitation of the temperature sensitivity of NmCyp
when assaying chaperone-like activity with the BCAII substrate, citrate
synthase (CS) was tried as an alternate substrate because this substrate
is known to become inactivated and aggregate at a lower temperature,
i.e., 45 °C.[35] Thus, different molar
ratios of NmCyp were incubated with citrate synthase, and the aggregation
kinetics of the reaction were recorded. It was observed that NmCyp
alone starts aggregating at 45 °C (Figure B). It shows no protective effect on the
aggregation of CS. Collectively, from these studies, we concluded
that NmCyp is unable to prevent the thermal aggregation of the aggregation-prone
proteins probably because of its own instability at higher temperatures;
thus, the chaperone-like function of NmCyp could not be assayed at
high temperatures. To overcome the limitation of high temperatures,
we had performed the assay with a chemical denaturant, but due to
less stability of NmCyp with the denaturant, it was difficult to measure
the chaperone-like activity.
Structural
Characterization of NmCyp
CD and fluorescence spectroscopies
are efficient tools for the measurement
of the secondary and tertiary structure as well as folding–unfolding
properties of proteins.[36,37] The far-UV CD spectrum
showed the predominance of β-sheet content followed by α-helices,
a typical signature secondary structure of cyclophilin proteins. The
positive ellipticity in the near-UV CD spectrum at 290 nm signifies
the presence of tryptophan residue in the native NmCyp protein (Figure A,B). The fluorescence
emission spectrum of the native NmCyp protein was recorded as 314
nm (Figure C). A single
tryptophan (Trp67) is present in the NmCyp structure, and the value
of λmax indicates that this tryptophan is buried
in the native structure. This λmax was further used
for monitoring the changes in the NmCyp tertiary structure when the
protein was exposed to extreme conditions of temperature, pH, and
chemical denaturants.
Figure 5
CD and fluorescence spectra of native NmCyp. (A) Far-UV
CD spectrum
of native NmCyp from 200 to 250 nm. (B) Near-UV CD spectrum of native
NmCyp from 260 to 350 nm. (C) Fluorescence emission spectrum of NmCyp
on excitation at 280 nm. In the figure, A.U. stands for ″arbitrary
units″.
CD and fluorescence spectra of native NmCyp. (A) Far-UV
CD spectrum
of native NmCyp from 200 to 250 nm. (B) Near-UV CD spectrum of native
NmCyp from 260 to 350 nm. (C) Fluorescence emission spectrum of NmCyp
on excitation at 280 nm. In the figure, A.U. stands for ″arbitrary
units″.
Thermostability
of the NmCyp Protein
Molecular chaperones are generally expected
to exhibit high thermal
stability. The effect of temperature (25–90 °C) on the
structural stability of the NmCyp protein was studied by far-UV CD,
near-UV CD, and fluorescence spectroscopies. CD spectra recorded at
different temperatures reveal that the secondary and tertiary structure
of NmCyp protein remains stable only up to 40 °C (Figure A). Beyond 40 °C, significant
changes in the ellipticity values (mdeg) of both far-UV and near-UV
scans signify the low stability of NmCyp (Figure A,C). During the refolding studies, the protein
was unable to regain its secondary and tertiary structure (spectra
of native and refolded protein do not overlap) due to irreversible
aggregation. This indicates that the thermal unfolding of the NmCyp
protein is irreversible (Figure B,D).
Figure 6
Thermostability of NmCyp. (A) Far-UV CD spectra of NmCyp
at different
temperatures (25–90 °C). (B) Far-UV CD spectra of the
native NmCyp (25 °C), unfolded NmCyp (90 °C), and irreversible
denatured NmCyp (cooled from 90 to 25 °C). (C) Near-UV CD spectra
of NmCyp at different temperatures (25–90 °C). (D) Near-UV
CD spectra of the native NmCyp (25 °C), unfolded NmCyp (90 °C),
and irreversible denatured NmCyp (cooled from 90 to 25 °C). (E)
Fluorescence emission spectra of NmCyp at different temperatures.
(F) Emission spectra of the native NmCyp (25 °C), unfolded NmCyp
(90 °C), and irreversible denatured NmCyp (cooled from 90 to
25 °C). In the figure, A.U. stands for ″arbitrary units″.
Thermostability of NmCyp. (A) Far-UV CD spectra of NmCyp
at different
temperatures (25–90 °C). (B) Far-UV CD spectra of the
native NmCyp (25 °C), unfolded NmCyp (90 °C), and irreversible
denatured NmCyp (cooled from 90 to 25 °C). (C) Near-UV CD spectra
of NmCyp at different temperatures (25–90 °C). (D) Near-UV
CD spectra of the native NmCyp (25 °C), unfolded NmCyp (90 °C),
and irreversible denatured NmCyp (cooled from 90 to 25 °C). (E)
Fluorescence emission spectra of NmCyp at different temperatures.
(F) Emission spectra of the native NmCyp (25 °C), unfolded NmCyp
(90 °C), and irreversible denatured NmCyp (cooled from 90 to
25 °C). In the figure, A.U. stands for ″arbitrary units″.The fluorescence emission of tryptophan is highly
sensitive to
the environment polarity and is a useful tool to measure the conformational
changes in proteins. The λmax (314 nm) of the NmCyp
protein does not show any shift up to 40 °C, which indicates
the stability of NmCyp up to 40 °C (Figure E). Beyond 45 °C, a significant red
shift in λmax was observed (314 to 354 nm). The increase
in emission intensity and red shift in λmax indicates
that the tryptophan residue of the NmCyp protein gets exposed to a
polar environment, which might be due to the unfolding of the protein’s
tertiary structure after 45 °C (Figure E). It is well known that a completely exposed
tryptophan in an aqueous buffer is expected to have a λmax of over 350 nm.[31,38,39]To check the reversibility in the unfolding process, the NmCyp
protein was cooled again from 90 to 25 °C in a stepwise manner.
The λmax of the unfolded protein (354 nm) does not
shift back to the native λmax (314 nm) and remains
the same as the unfolded protein (354 nm) (Figure F). This suggests that the unfolding of NmCyp
is irreversible. In contrast, its comparison with the reported cyclophilin
from another archaeal organism (MrCyp) suggests that MyCyp can maintain
its structure up to 65 °C and tends to regain the folded structure
on cooling from 90 to 25 °C.[20]
Reversible Unfolding of NmCyp under the Influence
of Urea
The effect of the chemical denaturant on the secondary
and tertiary structure of NmCyp was monitored using far-UV, near-UV,
and intrinsic fluorescence spectroscopy. In the presence of urea from
0 to 2.5 M, no significant change in the secondary structure of NmCyp
was observed. After 2.5 M urea concentration, a significant fraction
of the secondary structure was lost as inferred from the change in
ellipticity signal at 222 nm (Figure A). The change in ellipticity at 290 nm (in the near-UV
range) reflects a loss of the tertiary structure of the protein at
2.5 M urea concentration. At 290 nm, a positive ellipticity was mainly
caused by tryptophan residue, and no change in intensity was observed
up to 2.5 M urea; however, beyond 2.5 M, there was a drastic decrease
in the intensity with an increase in urea concentration (Figure B). This observation
suggests the loss of the secondary and tertiary structure of NmCyp
beyond 2.5 M urea concentration. The unfolding experiment data obtained
from CD were further fitted into a two-state equation (Figure C).[20,40−42] The obtained m (cooperativity) and
Cm (mid-point of unfolding) from fitted data were used for the calculation
of ΔGNUH2O, and the obtained value was 2.7 ± 0.97 kcal mol–1 (Table S3).
Figure 7
Equilibrium
unfolding and refolding of NmCyp with different concentrations
of urea. (A) Far-UV CD spectra of NmCyp at different urea concentrations.
(B) Near-UV CD spectra of the native NmCyp at different urea concentrations.
(C) Unfolding data (222 nm) of NmCyp at different concentrations of
urea fitted into a two-state model. (D) Refolding of NmCyp after diluting
the urea.
Equilibrium
unfolding and refolding of NmCyp with different concentrations
of urea. (A) Far-UV CD spectra of NmCyp at different urea concentrations.
(B) Near-UV CD spectra of the native NmCyp at different urea concentrations.
(C) Unfolding data (222 nm) of NmCyp at different concentrations of
urea fitted into a two-state model. (D) Refolding of NmCyp after diluting
the urea.During refolding studies, the
highly concentrated unfolded NmCyp
protein was diluted with a refolding buffer up to the minimum possible
denaturant concentration in the solution. The far-UV CD spectra show
that after diluting the denaturant concentration, NmCyp tends to refold
back to its native structure (Figure D). The spectra of the unfolded and refolded protein
overlap with each other, signifying the reversibility of the NmCyp
denaturant mediated unfolding.Urea unfolding probed by intrinsic
fluorescence was helpful in
giving a detailed picture of structural changes. The protein structure
is intact up to 1.5 M urea concentration as there is neither any shift
in λmax nor any change in fluorescence emission intensity.
At 2.5 M urea concentration, a sharp shift in λmax from 314 to 364 nm was observed. However, the fluorescence emission
intensity does not change significantly. A large red shift of 50 nm
in the emission maxima is considered a signature of change in the
environment of aromatic residues. On further increase in concentration
of the denaturant to 4 M, a significant increase in emission intensity
was observed, while the λmax is 364 nm (Figure A). In the last phase,
where the urea concentration varies from 4 to 8 M, the fluorescence
intensity and λmax remain constant, suggesting that
the protein is completely unfolded at 4 M urea. The comparison of
unfolding profiles obtained from the CD and fluorescence data helped
us to conclude that the tertiary structure compactness of the proteins
loosened at a lower urea concentration of ∼1.10 M followed
by the complete unfolding of the secondary and tertiary structure
at higher urea concentrations.
Figure 8
Equilibrium unfolding and refolding of
NmCyp with different concentrations
of urea using fluorescence spectroscopy. (A) Emission spectra of NmCyp
at different concentrations of urea. (B) Emission spectra of the refolded
protein on diluting the denaturant concentration till 0.2 M. (C) Comparison
of λmax of the unfolded and refolded NmCyp protein
in the presence of urea. (D) The pattern of the unfolding of NmCyp
monitored by the change in fluorescence emission intensity. The data
were fitted to a three-state equation, and thermodynamic parameters
were calculated[41−44] (Table S4). In the figure, A.U. stands
for ″arbitrary units″.
Equilibrium unfolding and refolding of
NmCyp with different concentrations
of urea using fluorescence spectroscopy. (A) Emission spectra of NmCyp
at different concentrations of urea. (B) Emission spectra of the refolded
protein on diluting the denaturant concentration till 0.2 M. (C) Comparison
of λmax of the unfolded and refolded NmCyp protein
in the presence of urea. (D) The pattern of the unfolding of NmCyp
monitored by the change in fluorescence emission intensity. The data
were fitted to a three-state equation, and thermodynamic parameters
were calculated[41−44] (Table S4). In the figure, A.U. stands
for ″arbitrary units″.During the refolding studies, the λmax of unfolded
protein (361 nm) reverts to 314 nm (native protein), which shows that
the unfolded protein refolds back to its native structure (Figure B,C). The unfolding
experiment data obtained by the fluorescence spectrophotometer was
further fitted into a three-state equation, and thermodynamic parameters
were calculated for NmCyp (Figure D and Table 2). A comparison of NmCyp unfolding in
the presence of urea with MrCyp under similar conditions[20] (Figure S8A) suggests
that NmCyp is significantly less stable than MrCyp. This pattern also
coincides with the lesser thermal stability of NmCyp in comparison
to MrCyp.The ANS dye was used to estimate the exposure of hydrophobic
patches
upon the unfolding of NmCyp under the influence of urea. The λmax of the native protein in the presence of ANS was ∼508
nm. As the concentration of urea was increased from 0.1 to 0.5 M,
a slight blue shift in the λmax along with an increase
in fluorescence intensity was observed. The blue shift in the λmax and increased emission fluorescence intensity signify the
exposure of the hydrophobic structure in the presence of urea. When
the urea concentration was further increased from 1 to 4 M, a red
shift from ∼508 to 520 nm was observed, indicating the unfolding
of the tertiary structure of the NmCyp protein. After the 4 M urea
concentration, there was no significant red shift or increase in intensity,
which indicates the complete unfolding of the NmCyp protein (Figure A,B).
Figure 9
ANS-based extrinsic fluorescence
studies of NmCyp at different
urea concentrations. (A) ANS-based emission spectra of the protein
in the presence of an increasing concentration of urea. (B) A change
in emission maxima (λmax) on increasing concentration
of urea.
ANS-based extrinsic fluorescence
studies of NmCyp at different
urea concentrations. (A) ANS-based emission spectra of the protein
in the presence of an increasing concentration of urea. (B) A change
in emission maxima (λmax) on increasing concentration
of urea.
Equilibrium
Unfolding and Refolding of NmCyp
in the Presence of GdnHCl Using CD and Fluorescence Spectroscopy
To observe the effect of GdnHCl on the structural stability of
NmCyp, GdnHCl-induced denaturation was measured with different probes.
The NmCyp protein maintains its native structure only up to 1.0 M
GdnHCl concentration. A decrease in CD signals (change in the ellipticity
values) was observed when the concentration of GdnHCl increased beyond
1.0 M (Figure ).
The loss of ellipticity (mdeg values) at [θ]222 signifies
the loss in the secondary structure of a protein. Similarly, the tertiary
structure of the NmCyp protein was also lost beyond 1 M GdnHCl concentration
(Figure ). The change
in ellipticity beyond 1.0 M remains constant, which signifies the
complete unfolding of the NmCyp protein at this denaturant concentration.
The data were further fitted into a two-state equation to estimate
the thermodynamic parameters of NmCyp (Figure and Table S3).[20,40−42] The mid-point of unfolding
(CmNU) and cooperativity (m) for NmCyp
is 0.75 ± 0.02 M and 4.45 ± 0.48 kcal mol–1 M–1, respectively.
Figure 10
Equilibrium unfolding
and refolding of NmCyp in the presence of
GdnHCl. (A) Far-UV CD spectra from 200 to 250 nm at different concentrations
of GdnHCl (0–7 M). (B) Near-UV CD spectra from 260 to 350 nm
at different concentrations of GdnHCl (0–6 M). (C) Far-UV CD
spectra of refolded proteins on diluting the denaturant. (D) GdnHCl
dependent unfolding of NmCyp monitored by the change in mdeg values
by CD spectroscopy. The data were fitted to a two-state equation,
and thermodynamic parameters were calculated. (E) Normalized data
of the NmCyp unfolded and refolded protein at different concentrations
of GdnHCl.
Equilibrium unfolding
and refolding of NmCyp in the presence of
GdnHCl. (A) Far-UV CD spectra from 200 to 250 nm at different concentrations
of GdnHCl (0–7 M). (B) Near-UV CD spectra from 260 to 350 nm
at different concentrations of GdnHCl (0–6 M). (C) Far-UV CD
spectra of refolded proteins on diluting the denaturant. (D) GdnHCl
dependent unfolding of NmCyp monitored by the change in mdeg values
by CD spectroscopy. The data were fitted to a two-state equation,
and thermodynamic parameters were calculated. (E) Normalized data
of the NmCyp unfolded and refolded protein at different concentrations
of GdnHCl.The unfolding transition of the
NmCyp protein was also monitored
by plotting the change in λmax (emission wavelength)
and fluorescence intensity at different GdnHCl concentrations. Like
the urea unfolding profile, we found that the native structure of
the protein is intact up to 0.3 M GdnHCl. The increase in GdnHCl concentration
beyond 0.3 M results in a significant red shift in the λmax with a decrease in fluorescence emission intensity. At
3 M GdnHCl concentration, we found a significant increase in fluorescence
emission intensity in addition to a shift in λmax from 314 to 350 nm (Figure A). The red shift in fluorescence emission indicates that
the Trp (W67) residue is getting more exposed to the polar environment
because of the unfolding of the protein in the presence of GdnHCl.
On addition of GdnHCl, the intensity and λmax follow
a sigmoidal-shaped curve, which is an indication of protein denaturation.
It is clear from the plot that NmCyp loses its structure at a very
low concentration of GdnHCl. The unfolding data fit best into the
three-state equation to obtain the thermodynamic parameters (Figure B and Table S4).[41−44]
Figure 11
Equilibrium unfolding of NmCyp in the presence of GdnHCl
using
fluorescence spectroscopy. (A) Emission spectra of NmCyp in the presence
of different concentrations of GdnHCl (0–6 M). (B) GdnHCl-dependent
unfolding of NmCyp monitored by the change in λmax of emission via fluorescence spectroscopy. The data were fitted
to a three-state equation, and thermodynamic parameters were calculated.
(C) The emission spectra of refolded proteins upon diluting the denaturant.
(D) λmax of the unfolded and refolded NmCyp protein
at different concentrations of GdnHCl. In the figure, A.U. stands
for ″arbitrary units″.
Equilibrium unfolding of NmCyp in the presence of GdnHCl
using
fluorescence spectroscopy. (A) Emission spectra of NmCyp in the presence
of different concentrations of GdnHCl (0–6 M). (B) GdnHCl-dependent
unfolding of NmCyp monitored by the change in λmax of emission via fluorescence spectroscopy. The data were fitted
to a three-state equation, and thermodynamic parameters were calculated.
(C) The emission spectra of refolded proteins upon diluting the denaturant.
(D) λmax of the unfolded and refolded NmCyp protein
at different concentrations of GdnHCl. In the figure, A.U. stands
for ″arbitrary units″.During refolding studies, the NmCyp protein (unfolded in the presence
of a highly concentrated GdnHCl) was diluted with a refolding buffer
to the minimum possible denaturant concentration, where NmCyp regained
its native secondary and tertiary structure after incubation for 1
h. This shows that NmCyp has the capacity to refold back to its native
structure after denaturation with GdnHCl (Figure C,D). Gibbs free energy change as calculated
for MrCyp (10.37 ± 1.5 kcal/mol) and NmCyp (4.8 kcal/mol) in
the presence of GdnHCl suggested that the latter is significantly
less stable than the former.
ANS Binding Reveals Surface
Hydrophobicity
in Unfolded NmCyp
The emission maxima of ANS bound to the
NmCyp protein were monitored as a function of the increasing concentration
of GdnHCl (Figure A). When the concentration of GdnHCl increased from 0 to 1 M, there
were a slight blue shift in the emission maxima and an increase in
intensity signifying the conformational changes in the structure even
at lower GdnHCl concentrations. When the GdnHCl concentration was
increased from 2.0 to 3.0 M, there was a slight red shift (508 to
516 nm) in λmax that suggests that NmCyp unfolds
on increasing GdnHCl concentration. Beyond 3 M GdnHCl concentration,
no significant shift in the λmax was observed, which
indicates that the unfolding of the protein structure was complete
at this concentration and all the hydrophobic patches were exposed
to the polar environment (Figure B).
Figure 12
ANS-based extrinsic fluorescence studies of NmCyp at different
GdnHCl concentrations. (A) Emission spectra of the protein in the
presence of increasing concentrations of GdnHCl. The concentration
of ANS used was 50 μM. (B) Change in emission maxima (λmax) on increasing concentration of GdnHCl. In the figure,
A.U. stands for ″arbitrary units″.
ANS-based extrinsic fluorescence studies of NmCyp at different
GdnHCl concentrations. (A) Emission spectra of the protein in the
presence of increasing concentrations of GdnHCl. The concentration
of ANS used was 50 μM. (B) Change in emission maxima (λmax) on increasing concentration of GdnHCl. In the figure,
A.U. stands for ″arbitrary units″.
Effect of pH on NmCyp Structural Stability
No significant conformational changes in the secondary and tertiary
structure of NmCyp were observed at alkaline pH (Figure ). This suggests that NmCyp
is more stable at a pH range (6–11) as compared to an acidic
pH range (<5).
Figure 13
Effect of pH on the secondary and tertiary structure of
NmCyp.
(A) Far-UV CD spectra of NmCyp at different pHs (1–11). (B)
A zoom-in view of the regions clustered close together in the pH range
5–11 for better visualization.(C) Near-UV CD spectra of NmCyp
at different pHs (1–11). (D) A zoom-in view of the regions
clustered close together in the pH range 5–11 for better visualization.
Effect of pH on the secondary and tertiary structure of
NmCyp.
(A) Far-UV CD spectra of NmCyp at different pHs (1–11). (B)
A zoom-in view of the regions clustered close together in the pH range
5–11 for better visualization.(C) Near-UV CD spectra of NmCyp
at different pHs (1–11). (D) A zoom-in view of the regions
clustered close together in the pH range 5–11 for better visualization.The accessibility of tryptophan residue often varies
from a completely
buried to partially solvent-exposed state depending upon the folding
and unfolding states of any protein. NmCyp at neutral pH has an emission
maximum at 314 nm, which indicates that the single tryptophan residue
(W67) is buried inside the protein core. Fluorescence emission spectra
at acidic pH show a drastic red shift in λmax (314
to 345 nm) suggesting that the NmCyp protein unfolds under these conditions
(Figure ). The fluorescence
intensity and λmax remain unchanged in the pH range
(5–11), which indicate the stability of NmCyp at the pH range
(5–11). The ANS fluorescence intensity was maximum at the acidic
pH range (1–5), which suggests that hydrophobic patches are
more exposed at acidic pH as compared to pH 7.0. The spectra of NmCyp
at alkaline pH are like native spectra (pH 7), and overlapping spectra
signify that the tertiary structure of protein is not affected by
alkaline pH (Figure ). NmCyp is more stable at the pH range (6–11)
as compared to the acidic pH (pH < 5).
Figure 14
(A) The intrinsic fluorescence
of NmCyp at different pHs from 1
to 11. Panel 1 shows a zoom-in view of the spectra recorded at pH
5–11 (for better visualization), and panel 2 shows the change
in λmax and emission intensity at different pHs.
(B) The ANS-mediated extrinsic fluorescence of NmCyp at different
pHs ranging from 1 to 11. Panel 3 shows a zoom-in view of the spectra
recorded at pH 6–11, and panel 4 shows the change in λmax and intensity of NmCyp in the pH range 1–11 after
incubating with 50 μM of ANS. In the figure, A.U. stands for
″arbitrary units″.
(A) The intrinsic fluorescence
of NmCyp at different pHs from 1
to 11. Panel 1 shows a zoom-in view of the spectra recorded at pH
5–11 (for better visualization), and panel 2 shows the change
in λmax and emission intensity at different pHs.
(B) The ANS-mediated extrinsic fluorescence of NmCyp at different
pHs ranging from 1 to 11. Panel 3 shows a zoom-in view of the spectra
recorded at pH 6–11, and panel 4 shows the change in λmax and intensity of NmCyp in the pH range 1–11 after
incubating with 50 μM of ANS. In the figure, A.U. stands for
″arbitrary units″.
Discussion
This is the first elaborate study
of biochemical and biophysical
characterization of any cyclophilin from Thaumarchaeota. Sixteen genomes
of organisms from Thaumarchaeota have been sequenced up to now, and
15 of these contain the cyclophilin gene (Figure S1). From the alignment of protein sequences, it has been observed
that a unique stretch of 7–10 amino acids is present in the
cyclophilin homologs from Thaumarchaeota organisms, which is absent
in cyclophilin orthologs coming from the organism of different phyla.
This stretch lies close to the active site and may influence the function
of this protein. The functional activity analysis of NmCyp established
that the characteristic PPIase activity and its inhibition by CsA
are conserved in this protein (similar to those seen earlier in cyclophilins
from Methanobrevibacter ruminantium (MrCyp) of phylum Euryarchaeota) (Figure ).[20] Additionally, both NmCyp and MrCyp are similar in their response
to pH changes as both exhibit structural stability in the pH range
of 6–11 (Figures and 14). In contrast, the structural
loss and aggregation of NmCyp beyond 40 °C made it inept for
the aggregation prevention assay of different aggregation-prone substrates,
e.g., citrate synthase and BCAII. In our previous study, it was observed
that the overexpression of MrCyp in E. coli cells made them more resistant to heat shock (at 45 °C), suggesting
the chaperone-like activity of this protein in enhancing cell viability in vivo.[20] Yet, a similar assay
was not feasible for NmCyp since our current studies establish that
it is a thermolabile protein that starts aggregating at 40 °C
(Figure ). Therefore,
the chaperone-like activity, especially under conditions of heat stress,
could not be generalized for all the archaeal cyclophilins.Our current study suggests that NmCyp is more tolerant of chemical
denaturation but is quite sensitive to thermal stress since it folds
back in a reversible manner after the removal of denaturing agents
but does not recover from the heat stress (Figures and 10). A comparison
between the MrCyp and NmCyp suggests that MrCyp is more resistant
to urea denaturation, tolerating up to 6 M denaturant concentration,
while NmCyp loses its structure in a lower urea concentration of 4
M urea. A similar pattern was also observed for their stability in
GdnHCl. NmCyp unfolding–refolding in the presence of chemical
denaturing conditions fits best to the two-state model (as observed
by CD experiments), while a better fit to the three-state model (suggesting
an additional intermediate state) was observed with fluorescence studies.
The quantitative estimation of Gibbs free energy changes shows that
NmCyp is significantly destabilized over the highly stable PPIase
MrCyp from phylum Euryarchaeota (Tables S3 and S4). This again suggests the higher stability of MrCyp over
NmCyp. In conclusion, the collective comparison of chemical and thermal
stabilities and PPIase activity between two PPIases from two different
phyla suggests that although the PPIase activity may be the basic
conserved function of the cyclophilin protein, the thermal stability
and chaperone-like activity (especially under heat stress) may be
an add-on feature not necessarily found in all cyclophilins.[45,46] The study may therefore pave the path for more studies that could
deduce the evolutionary history of the different functions in cyclophilin
proteins.
Materials and Methods
Sequence
Selection, Multiple Sequence Alignment,
and Phylogenetic Tree Analysis of Archaeal Cyclophilin Proteins
A total of 122 protein sequences for cyclophilins from different
archaeal species were retrieved from NCBI and downloaded in FASTA
format. To remove the redundancy of sequences, CD-HIT[47] was used with an identity threshold of 100%. The cyclophilins
from a total of 106 archaeal organisms were selected for further analysis
and were aligned by using different multiple alignment tools, i.e.,
Clustal Omega,[48] Guidance,[49] and T-COFFEE,[50] to find the
best alignment pattern and sequence conservation among the cyclophilin
sequences. Protparam was used to calculate the physiochemical properties,
e.g., molecular weight, pI value, amino acid composition grand average
of hydropathicity (GRAVY), and aliphatic index for the protein sequence
of cyclophilin from Nitrosopumilus maritimus (NmCyp). In the ExPasy server,[51] the
ProtScale tool was used for amino acid scale representation (Kyte
and Doolittle hydrophobicity scale).[52]
Functional Annotations of Selected Cyclophilin
Sequences
Conserved domains and motifs were analyzed by sequence
similarity with other members of the cyclophilin family and various
protein databases like CDD-BLAST[53] and
InterProscan.[54] InterProscan provides functional
analysis of proteins by classifying them into families and predicting
domains and functionally important sites.
Secondary
and Tertiary Structure Prediction
The PDBSum[55] and CDD-BLAST were used
for predicting the secondary structure features. There is currently
no structure available for any archaeal cyclophilin, so we modeled
the structure of NmCyp using Modeller 9.17.[32] Several parameters were taken into consideration when selecting
the template for modeling, such as sequence identity (%), query coverage,
and conserved domains. The electrostatic potential surface diagram
and cartoon structure were visualized by PyMOL.[56] The accuracy of the modeled structures was further validated
using Ramachandran map calculations computed with the RAMPAGE software.[33]
Cloning of the NmCyp Gene
and Heterologous
Overexpression of the NmCyp Protein
The gene encoding cyclophilin
from Nitrosopumilus maritimus was artificially
synthesized and further subcloned into a pET28a(+) vector. Once the
gene sequence was confirmed, the pET28a (+)_NmCyp recombinant plasmid
was transformed in E. coli BL21-DE3.
The expression of NmCyp was checked in auto induction media (AIM)
and grown at 37 °C and 180 rpm. The pelleted cells were then
resuspended in a lysis buffer (25 mM Tris, 100 mM NaCl, 10% glycerol,
and 1 mM PMSF) and lysed through sonication. The overexpression of
the recombinant protein was verified by western blot. An overexpressed
NmCyp protein having a His-tag at the N-terminus was purified by affinity
chromatography using a Ni2+-NTA resin (Qiagen). The mixture
was incubated at 4 °C for 3 h and eluted with an increasing concentration
of imidazole (50–500 mM). The fractions obtained after elution
were dialyzed against 1× PBS buffer at 4 °C to remove imidazole.
After dialysis, the sample was subjected to size exclusion chromatography
column to obtain the pure homogeneous protein. All the collected factions
were analyzed by separation on 15% SDS-PAGE at each step. The final
protein yield was estimated to be ∼36 mg/L. A molar extinction
coefficient of 9970 M–1 cm–1 at
280 nm was used to determine the protein concentration.
Functional Activity Assays of the NmCyp Protein
PPIase Activity Assay
The PPIase
activity of the purified protein was estimated by a chymotrypsin-coupled
reaction that exploits the conformational selectivity of chymotrypsin
toward the chromogenic substrate of N-succinyl-Ala-Ala-Pro-Phe-4-nitroanilide.[57] The assay is based on the difference in absorbance
determined for the cis and trans isomers of Suc-Ala-Ala-Pro-Phe-4-nitroanilide.
The peptide substrate N-succinyl-Ala-Ala-Pro-Phe-4-nitroanilide
(Sigma) was resuspended in 0.47 M LiCl/trifluoroethanol (TFE) to produce
a cis-proline isomer, and a stock solution of 5 mM
was constituted. Chymotrypsin used in the study was dissolved in 0.1
mM HCl. Chymotrypsin dissolved in the assay buffer (35 mM HEPES-KOH,
pH 7.8) served as the blank. The reaction was initiated by the addition
of substrate (35 μM) to chymotrypsin, and then NmCyp (1.4 mM)
in the same assay buffer was added to this mixture to study its effect
on the PPIase activity. The PPIase activity was monitored by recording
the absorbance at 390 nm every 0.1 s for 20 min. Inhibition of the
reaction in the presence of the specific inhibitor cyclosporine A
(CsA) was also checked by adding the inhibitor to the assay mix 30
min before the start of the reaction and incubating at 4 °C.
The change in absorbance at 390 nm was measured, and experimental
data fitting was performed using Origin 9.0. The catalytic efficiency
of NmCyp was calculated using relation Kcat/km = (Kp – Kn)/E, where Kp and Kn are the first-order rate constant of
reaction in the presence and absence of the enzyme, respectively. E is concentration of the PPIase enzyme.
Chaperone-like Activity Assay
The
chaperone activity of NmCyp was checked by estimating its ability
to prevent the aggregation of bovine carbonic anhydrase (BCAII) and
citrate synthase (CS).[35,58] The substrate protein BCAII (0.75
μM) was placed at 65 °C in the thermostat cuvette holder
of the Cary Eclipse Fluorescence Spectrophotometer to check the independent
aggregation pattern of BCAII. The excitation and emission wavelength
for BCAII was set at 400 nm with a slit width of 5 nm. The extent
of light scattering of BCAII was monitored for 15 min. BSA was used
as a negative control in both the experiments. The different molar
ratios of NmCyp (1:1 and 1:2) and BCAII (0.75 μM) were also
tried to see the concentration-dependent aggregation inhibition. Another
substrate, citrate synthase (CS 0.15 μM), was also used for
estimating the aggregation prevention efficiency at 45 °C. The
same parameters mentioned above were used for measuring the aggregation
kinetics. Concentration-dependent aggregation inhibition was tried
at different molar ratios of NmCyp and CS.
Secondary and Tertiary Structure Estimation
of the NmCyp Protein
Far-UV and near-UV CD measurements were
recorded using a JASCO J-815 CD spectrometer. Far-UV CD measurements
in the range of 250–200 nm were performed with 0.2 mg/mL protein
using a cuvette of path length 1 mm. Near-UV CD measurements were
recorded in the range of 260–350 nm using a higher protein
concentration of 5 mg/mL in a cuvette of path length 1 mm. The data
were recorded for both the ranges using a scan speed of 100 nm/min
and a spectral bandwidth of 1.0 nm. Three spectra were collected for
both the ranges in the continuous mode and averaged to minimize the
noise. The buffer was subtracted from the spectra to avoid buffer
contribution.Changes in the tertiary structures of the protein
were analyzed by intrinsic fluorescence spectroscopy. The spectra
were recorded on a spectro-fluorimeter (Cary Eclipse) using a quartz
cuvette of 10 mm path length. NmCyp was excited at a wavelength of
280 nm with a slit width of 5 nm, and the fluorescence emission spectra
were collected from 300 to 400 nm. A final concentration of 0.2 mg/mL
of NmCyp in the PBS buffer was used for all unfolding studies.
Thermal Unfolding and Refolding Studies of
NmCyp Using CD and Fluorescence Spectroscopy
For CD spectroscopy
based thermal denaturation studies, NmCyp was diluted in the PBS buffer
and placed in a 1 mm quartz cuvette. The samples were heated from
25 to 90 °C, incubating the sample at each temperature step for
5 min. Far-UV and near-UV spectra at all were collected at an interval
of 5 °C. The millidegree (mdeg) values obtained were plotted
against the respective temperatures. For the fluorescence-based thermal
denaturation studies, 0.2 mg/mL NmCyp protein in a 10 mm quartz cuvette
was placed in the thermostat holder of the spectrofluorimeter. At
each selected temperature ranging between 25 and 90 °C, the protein
was incubated for 5 min. The sample was excited at a wavelength of
280 nm, and spectra were recorded in the 300–400 nm range.
The fluorescence intensity was plotted against the respective temperatures.For far-UV and near-UV CD spectroscopy based thermal refolding
studies, 90 °C heat denatured NmCyp was gradually cooled to 25
°C with 5 min incubation at each temperature (5 °C intervals).
A continuous far-UV and near-UV scan was taken in the range of 250–190
and 260–350 nm, respectively, at each temperature step from
90 to 25 °C. The obtained mdeg data were plotted against the
respective temperature.For the fluorescence-based thermal refolding
studies, 90 °C
heat denatured 0.2 mg/mL NmCyp was gradually cooled to 25 °C
after incubating for 5 min at each temperature step. The denatured
protein was excited at a wavelength of 280 nm, and a continuous scan
was recorded over the wavelength range of 300–400 nm from 90
to 25 °C. The fluorescence intensity values obtained were plotted
against the respective temperatures.
Chemical
Denaturant Mediated Unfolding and
Refolding of NmCyp Monitored by CD Spectroscopy
For equilibrium
unfolding studies, the protein samples were prepared by incubating
0.2 mg/mL of proteins with different concentrations of GdnHCl (0–8
M) and urea (0–8 M) for 30 min at 25 °C in the PBS buffer
containing the respective amount of GdnHCl or urea. All the measurements
were performed in both far-UV region (250–200 nm) and near-UV
(260–350 nm) ranges. Each spectrum was corrected for contribution
from a urea (0–8 M) or GdnHCl (0–8 M) containing a buffer
solution. The obtained millidegree values were plotted against the
respective urea and GdnHCl concentrations. For the equilibrium unfolding
transition curve, data obtained at 222 nm were plotted with the respective
concentration of the denaturant.The highly concentrated NmCyp
protein was incubated with 6 M urea and GdnHCl. The resulting unfolded
protein was diluted, resulting in a final concentration of protein
of 0.2 mg/mL and denaturant concentration of 0.2 M. The far-UV scan
was recorded for the NmCyp protein in the range of 250–200
nm. For the spontaneous refolding, the far-UV CD signal for each refolded
sample at 222 nm was recorded. Each signal was corrected for the contribution
of the buffer solution containing urea and GdnHCl each. To see the
percentage reversibility, the mdeg values obtained from the refolding
data were plotted with unfolding data obtained from the equilibrium
unfolding experiment.
Chemical Denaturant Mediated
Unfolding Studies
of NmCyp Monitored by Intrinsic Fluorescence Spectroscopy
For studying the effect of the chemical denaturant on the tertiary
structure of MrCyp and NmCyp, urea and GdnHCl were used as denaturants.
Samples were prepared by incubating 0.2 mg/mL protein with different
concentrations of urea (0–8 M) and GdnHCl (0–8 M) at
25 °C for 30 min in the PBS buffer. The equilibrated samples
were excited at 280 nm, and the emission spectra were recorded between
300 and 400 nm with excitation and emission slit width of 5 nm each.
To see the equilibrium transition, the relative fluorescence intensity
observed at 314 nm for NmCyp was plotted against the respective denaturant
concentrations.The highly concentrated protein sample was unfolded
with 6 M urea and GdnHCl at 25 °C. The unfolded protein was diluted
in a way resulting in a final concentration of 0.2 mg/mL and the denaturant
concentration being diluted to 6 to 0.2 M in the PBS buffer. The refolding
mixture was incubated for 1 h at 25 °C. The refolded protein
was excited at 280 nm, and emission fluorescence spectra were recorded
at 300–400 nm. To see the extent of reversibility of the unfolding
transition, the relative fluorescence intensity at 314 nm (NmCyp)
of each refolded sample was plotted with the unfolding transition
curve obtained from the equilibrium unfolding experiment. The unfolding
transition curves (urea and GdnHCl) were fitted to a two-state and
three-state model for the calculation of thermodynamic stability parameters
of the protein.[20,40,41,43]
Data Fitting
The urea and GdnHCl
induced unfolding data obtained from CD and fluorescence spectroscopy
were further fitted into two- and three-state models. The two-state
denaturation equilibrium indicates only native (N) and unfolded (U)
states, while the three-state denaturation equilibrium indicates native
(N), intermediate (I), and unfolded (U) states of a protein that are
significantly present in the transition process. The equilibrium for
the two-state and three-state models can be represented by Keq as follows:[41,43,44]For the two-state model:KNU = equilibrium constant for
reaction
N ⇋ U.The observed signal of the protein from both CD
and fluorescence
intensity of the protein [Sobs(c)] at any concentration of the denaturant is given by the
sum contribution of all the two states asfN(c) and fU(c) are the fractions of two states
at different urea and GdnHCl concentrations
of c, and SN and SU are the signal for pure N and U states, respectively.The fractions fNand fU are also related to the equilibrium constant KNU of unfolding transition from N ⇋ U
and hence related to corresponding free energy changes ΔGNU, as follows:For the two-state equilibrium
equation:where R is
the gas constant and T is the absolute temperature.
The free energy changes of unfolding are known to vary linearly with
denaturant concentration such thatSo from
combining eqs –5, we can get the equation shown below
for the two-state model:Here, we assume that SN and SU are linearly
dependent on the denaturant concentration, so SN = a1 + b1.c and SU = c1 + p1.c, where a1, b1, c1, and p1 are constants obtained from the intercept and slope of the native,
intermediate, and unfolded state baseline, respectively. By using
all the above-discussed equations, the denaturant mediated unfolding
data were analyzed and thermodynamic parameters were calculated.For the three-state model:KNI = equilibrium constant for
reaction
N ⇋ I.KIU = equilibrium
constant for reaction
I ⇋ U.KNU = equilibrium
constant for reaction
N ⇋ U.The observed signal of protein from both CD and
fluorescence intensity
of the protein [Sobs(c)] at any concentration
of the denaturant is given by the sum contribution of the entire three-state
model asfN(c), fI(c), and fU(c) are the
fractions of three states at different urea and GdnHCl concentrations
of c, and SN, SI, and SU are the
signal for pure N, I, and U states, respectively.The fractions fN, fI, and fU are also related
to equilibrium constants KNI and KNU of the unfolding transition from N ⇋
I and N ⇋ U, respectively, and hence are related to corresponding
free energy changes ΔGNI and ΔGNU, as follows:where R is
the gas constant and T is the absolute temperature.
The free energy changes of unfolding are known to vary linearly with
denaturant concentration such thatΔGNUH2O and ΔGNIH2O are ΔGNU and ΔGNI at the 0 M denaturant concentration. mNU represents the dependence of respective free energy change on the
denaturant concentration (c) and the co-operativity
of transition.So, from combining eqs –4, we can get
the equation shown below
for three-state model:Here, we assume that SN, SI, and SU are linearly dependent on the denaturant concentration
(c), so SN = a1 + b1.c, SI = c1 + p1.c, and SU = e1+ g1.c, where a1, b1, c1,p1,e1, and g1 are constants obtained from
the intercept and slope of the native, intermediate, and unfolded
state baseline, respectively. By using all the above-discussed equations,
the denaturant mediated unfolding data were analyzed and thermodynamic
parameters were calculated.
Spectrofluorimetric Estimation
of the Surface
Hydrophobicity of NmCyp Proteins
ANS serves as a sensitive
fluorogenic substrate for detecting exposed hydrophobic sites of a
protein. The native and unfolded proteins (mediated by urea and GdnHCl)
were incubated with ANS (50 μM) for 1 min at 25 °C before
recording the spectra. The samples were excited at 390 nm, and emission
spectra were recorded in the range of 400–600 nm with excitation
and emission slit width of 5 and 2.5 nm, respectively. The protein
in the PBS buffer with a concentration of 0.2 mg/mL was used for all
the experiments. The buffer containing ANS and denaturant (Urea/GdnHCl)
served as the blank.
pH-Dependent Secondary
and Tertiary Structural
Changes in NmCyp as Monitored by CD and Fluorescence Spectroscopy
The samples of the NmCyp protein were prepared in buffers of different
pHs ranging from 1 to 11. The spectrum for all the protein samples
was recorded in both the far-UV (250–190 nm) and near-UV (350–260
nm) range. Each spectrum was corrected for the buffer solution of
the particular pH. The effect of pH on the tertiary structure was
also monitored using fluorescence spectroscopy. The samples were excited
at 280 nm, and the emission spectra were collected from 300 to 400
nm at 25 °C. To see the effect of pH on the surface hydrophobicity
of NmCyp, the protein was incubated with 50 μM ANS and excited
at 390 nm; emission spectra at different pHs were recorded in the
range of 400–600 nm.
Authors: Elisabeth Gasteiger; Alexandre Gattiker; Christine Hoogland; Ivan Ivanyi; Ron D Appel; Amos Bairoch Journal: Nucleic Acids Res Date: 2003-07-01 Impact factor: 16.971