Eugenia Elzer1, Philipp Strobel2, Volker Weiler2, Muhammad R Amin3, Peter J Schmidt2, Alexander Moewes3, Wolfgang Schnick1. 1. Department of Chemistry, University of Munich (LMU), Butenandtstrasse 5-13, (D) 81377, Munich, Germany. 2. Lumileds Phosphor Center Aachen, Philipsstrasse 8, 52068, Aachen, Germany. 3. Department of Physics and Engineering Physics, University of Saskatchewan, 116 Science Place, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, S7N 5E2, Canada.
Abstract
The nitridoberylloaluminate Ba2 [BeAl3 N5 ]:Eu2+ and solid solutions Sr2-x Bax [BeAl3 N5 ]:Eu2+ (x=0.5, 1.0, 1.5) were synthesized in a hot isostatic press (HIP) under 50 MPa N2 atmosphere at 1200 °C. Ba2 [BeAl3 N5 ]:Eu2+ crystallizes in triclinic space group P 1 ‾ (no. 2) (Z=2, a=6.1869(10), b=7.1736(13), c=8.0391(14) Å, α=102.754(8), β=112.032(6), γ=104.765(7)°), which was determined from single-crystal X-ray diffraction data. The lattice parameters of the solid solution series have been obtained from Rietveld refinements and show a nearly linear dependence on the atomic ratio Sr : Ba. The electronic properties and the band gaps of M2 [BeAl3 N5 ] (M=Sr, Ba) have been investigated by a combination of soft X-ray spectroscopy and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Upon irradiation with blue light (440-450 nm), the nitridoberylloaluminates exhibit intense orange to red luminescence, which can be tuned between 610 and 656 nm (fwhm=1922-2025 cm-1 (72-87 nm)). In contrast to the usual trend, the substitution of the smaller Sr2+ by larger Ba2+ leads to an inverse-tunable luminescence to higher wavelengths. Low-temperature luminescence measurements have been performed to exclude anomalous emission.
The nitridoberylloaluminate Ba2 [BeAl3 N5 ]:Eu2+ and solid solutions Sr2-x Bax [BeAl3 N5 ]:Eu2+ (x=0.5, 1.0, 1.5) were synthesized in a hot isostatic press (HIP) under 50 MPa N2 atmosphere at 1200 °C. Ba2 [BeAl3 N5 ]:Eu2+ crystallizes in triclinic space group P 1 ‾ (no. 2) (Z=2, a=6.1869(10), b=7.1736(13), c=8.0391(14) Å, α=102.754(8), β=112.032(6), γ=104.765(7)°), which was determined from single-crystal X-ray diffraction data. The lattice parameters of the solid solution series have been obtained from Rietveld refinements and show a nearly linear dependence on the atomic ratio Sr : Ba. The electronic properties and the band gaps of M2 [BeAl3 N5 ] (M=Sr, Ba) have been investigated by a combination of soft X-ray spectroscopy and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Upon irradiation with blue light (440-450 nm), the nitridoberylloaluminates exhibit intense orange to red luminescence, which can be tuned between 610 and 656 nm (fwhm=1922-2025 cm-1 (72-87 nm)). In contrast to the usual trend, the substitution of the smaller Sr2+ by larger Ba2+ leads to an inverse-tunable luminescence to higher wavelengths. Low-temperature luminescence measurements have been performed to exclude anomalous emission.
In recent years, the constant search for new phosphors pushed solid‐state lighting, based on light‐emitting diodes (LEDs), to one of the most popular lighting solutions. Especially, further improving luminous efficacy of white phosphor‐converted (pc) LEDs with high color rendition depends on phosphor materials with optimized luminescence properties.
The combination of a high color rendering index without compromising luminous efficacy is a key factor in the optimization of pc‐LEDs.
Here, particularly the emission maximum and the width of the emission band of the red‐emitting phosphor play a significant role to avoid emission in the deep red spectral area.In this context, Eu2+ doped nitrides are intensively investigated, as they do not only show good thermal and chemical stability, but also promising optical properties.
The luminescence observed in Eu2+ activated phosphors can be generally attributed to transitions between the 4f6(7F)5d1 exited state and the 4f7(8S7/2) ground state and is highly sensitive towards the local environment of the activator ion.
Red‐emitting nitrides like (Sr,Ba)2Si5N8:Eu2+[5] or (Ca,Sr)AlSiN3:Eu2+[6] already found their way into commercial application as phosphors in pc‐LEDs, due to their excellent photoluminescence properties. However, since both compounds exhibit rather broad emission bands, the luminous efficacy is limited due to spill‐over to the infrared region. Structures based on highly condensed anionic networks are shown to be beneficial for narrow‐band emission.The degree of condensation κ is defined as the ratio of tetrahedral centers T to coordinating N atoms (κ=n(T):n(N)). In theory κ can be increased by replacing higher charged tetrahedral centers (Al3+, Si4+) with lower charged ones like Li+ or Mg2+. Indeed, these substitutions led to the discovery of promising narrow‐band red‐emitting phosphors, such as Sr[LiAl3N4]:Eu2+ (SLA),
Sr[Mg3SiN4]:Eu2+ (SMS),
or Sr[Li2Al2O2N2]:Eu2+ (SALON).
Even though SMS exhibits an emission maximum in the desired spectral region at λ
max=615 nm and a very narrow emission band with a full width at half‐maximum (fwhm) of 43 nm/1170 cm−1, high thermal quenching prevents its application in pc‐LEDs. SLA (λ
max=654 nm, fwhm=50 nm/1180 cm−1) and the recently reported SALON (λ
max=614 nm, fwhm=48 nm/1286 cm−1) show better thermal performance, but emission band widths of both compounds do not yet match the target value of 30 nm, proposed for a high‐performance red phosphor.In the pursuit of Eu2+ doped host lattices with an even narrower emission band, the incorporation of Be2+ into the anionic networks of nitrides may evolve as a viable solution also for narrow‐red emitting materials. Compared to Al3+ or Si4+, Be2+ has a lower formal charge, which can lead to host lattices with a large κ, as already demonstrated with the discovery of the cyan‐emitting oxonitridoberyllate Sr[Be6ON4]:Eu2+,
the blue‐emitting oxoberyllates AELi2[Be4O6]:Eu2+ (AE=Sr, Ba),
the blue‐emitting nitridoberyllates MBe20N14:Eu2+ (M=Sr, Ba),
or the red‐emitting nitridoberylloaluminate Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+.As already mentioned, the 5d energy levels are highly sensitive towards the local environment of the activator ion. This enables tuning of the shape and position of the emission band by tailoring the local structure around the activator. With respect to a free Eu2+ ion, the energy of the lowest excited state of Eu2+ ions in a host lattice is affected by the nephelauxetic effect and the crystal field splitting. Usually, a covalent activator‐ligand bond and a strong crystal field result in a significant lowering of the energetic position of the 5d orbitals. Therefore, the distance between the ground state and the excited state is reduced, resulting in a red‐shifted emission. The crystal field splitting depends on the local environment, especially the activator‐ligand bond length, the coordination number and the shape of the coordination polyhedron around the activator. Thus, the size of the cations substituted by Eu2+ can be used to modify the emission color of a phosphor. If smaller cations (for example, Sr2+) are replaced by larger ones (for example, Ba2+), the metal‐ligand distances and the volume of the coordination polyhedra usually increase, leading to a weaker crystal field splitting, shifting the emission bands towards the blue spectral region. The opposite case is seen in M[Mg3SiN4]:Eu2+ (M=Sr, Ba),[
,
] and M[Mg2Al2N4]:Eu2+ (M=Ca, Sr, Ba),
where a trend to red‐shifted emission in the sequence CaIn the pursuit of the discovery of new phosphors with optimized luminescence properties different strategies have been proposed, for example mineral prototype evolution strategy, single‐particle diagnosis approach, machine learning or cation substitution strategy.
The relation of Eu2+ luminescence and the crystal structure of the host lattice motivates substitution in already known structures as well as exploration of completely new structures to contribute to the understanding of structure‐property relationships.In this contribution, we report on optical luminescence of Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ and the solid solution series Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (x=0.5, 1.0, 1.5), as well as their syntheses and electronic properties. Upon irradiation with blue light, the nitridoberylloaluminates exhibit intense orange to red luminescence. In contrast to the usual trend, the emission maximum in the nitridoberylloaluminates Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (x>0) is inversely shifted to higher wavelengths by the incorporation of the larger cation Ba2+. This contribution shows that even small changes in the local environment in the investigated nitridoberylloaluminates have a significant effect on the luminescence, since activator concentration and anomalous emission can be ruled out as causes for the unexpected, red‐shifted emission with increasing size of the alkaline earth element.
Results and Discussion
Synthesis and chemical analysis
A modification of the reported synthesis for Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+,
gave access to a solid solution series with the nominal composition Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (x=0.5, 1.0 and 1.5) and Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+. The products were obtained as crystalline powders with orange body color and red luminescence upon irradiation with blue light. The morphology of the crystals is shown in Figure S2. The atomic ratio of Sr : Ba:Al : N (Table 1), as obtained from EDX measurements, range within the estimated standard deviations from the intended sum formulas for the solid solution series Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+.
Table 1
EDX results of Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (x=0, 0.5, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0). Theoretical values (th.) and experimental values (exp.) in mol % for each composition with standard deviations in parentheses.
Sr2−xBax[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+
x
0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
th.
exp.
th.
exp.
th.
exp.
th.
exp.
th.
exp.
Sr
20
25(3)
15
11(3)
10
9(1)
5
5(1)
0
0
Ba
0
0
5
7(2)
10
12(2)
15
14(1)
20
16(3)
Al
30
30(4)
30
32(4)
30
34(3)
30
33(2)
30
36(2)
N
50
45(6)
50
43(4)
50
44(3)
50
48(3)
50
49(3)
O
0
0
0
7(7)
0
1(1)
0
0
0
0
EDX results of Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (x=0, 0.5, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0). Theoretical values (th.) and experimental values (exp.) in mol % for each composition with standard deviations in parentheses.Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+x00.51.01.52.0th.exp.th.exp.th.exp.th.exp.th.exp.Sr2025(3)1511(3)109(1)55(1)00Ba0057(2)1012(2)1514(1)2016(3)Al3030(4)3032(4)3034(3)3033(2)3036(2)N5045(6)5043(4)5044(3)5048(3)5049(3)O0007(7)01(1)0000Beryllium usually cannot be detected with this method. The oxygen content is insignificant within the estimated standard deviations and was only detected for the Sr‐rich representatives of the solid solution series (x=0.5, 1.0). A possible reason might be the hydrolysis sensitivity of the investigated powder samples. As already mentioned in the experimental section the formation of MBe2N2 (M=Sr, Ba) and SrO as impurity phases hampered the preparation of a defined composition with regard to the atomic ratio of Sr : Ba for the solid solution phases.
Crystal structure
Based on the crystal structure solution and refinement (SHELX‐2014),
Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ crystallizes in space group
(no. 2) isotypical to Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+.
During the refinement of the crystal structure the small amount of Eu2+ was neglected, due to the insignificant contribution to the scattering density. Crystallographic data of the Ba‐containing phase show an increase of the unit cell volume (∼7 %) compared to Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+, due to the incorporation of the larger Ba2+ ion (Table 2).
Table 2
Crystallographic data of Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ compared to reported values for Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+.
Standard deviations in parentheses.
Crystallographic data of Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ compared to reported values for Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+.
Standard deviations in parentheses.Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+Formula mass /g mol−1335.24434.68Crystal systemtriclinicSpace groupP
(no. 2)Formula units/cell2Cell parameter /Å, °a=6.061(2) b=6.982(3) c=7.872(4) α=102.22(3) β=112.62(2) γ=104.02(2)a=6.1869(10) b=7.1736(13) c=8.0391(14) α=102.754(8) β=112.032(6) γ=104.765(7)Volume/Å3280.5(2)299.24(9)X‐ray density/g cm−33.9694.824Detailed crystallographic data, atomic coordinates, Wyckoff positions, isotropic displacement parameters, anisotropic displacement parameters and selected distances and angles of Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ are summarized in the Supporting Information (Tables S3–S7). Detailed information on the single‐crystal data of Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ are provided free of charge by the joint Cambridge Crystallographic Data Centre and Fachinformationszentrum Karlsruhe Access Structures service. Deposition Number CSD‐2121521 (for Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+) contains the supplementary crystallographic data for this paper.The crystal structure of Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (Figure 1a) consists of edge‐ and vertex‐sharing AlN4 tetrahedra and trigonal‐planar BeN3 units. Each AlN4 tetrahedron shares one edge with another AlN4 tetrahedron building a bow‐tie unit ([Al2N6]12−) and each BeN3 unit is connected to a second BeN3 unit over a common edge, building a planar [Be2N4]8− unit (Figure 1b). These building units are further connected by common vertices forming a three‐dimensional anionic network, which contains channels filled with Ba2+ (and Eu2+, when doped) for charge neutrality. The alkaline earth (AE) ions are distributed over three different coordination sites (Ba1, Ba2 and Ba3) and coordinated by seven (Ba1) and eight (Ba2 and Ba3) N atoms, respectively (Figure 1c).
Figure 1
Crystal structure representation of Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ with Al atoms (light blue), Be atoms (green),N atoms (blue) and Ba atoms (gray). a) view of 2×2×2‐unit cells along [100]; b) bow‐tie unit [Al2N6]12− (top, light blue) and [Be2N4]8− unit (bottom, green); c) coordination polyhedra (gray) around Ba1 (top), Ba2 (middle) and Ba3 (bottom).
Crystal structure representation of Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ with Al atoms (light blue), Be atoms (green),N atoms (blue) and Ba atoms (gray). a) view of 2×2×2‐unit cells along [100]; b) bow‐tie unit [Al2N6]12− (top, light blue) and [Be2N4]8− unit (bottom, green); c) coordination polyhedra (gray) around Ba1 (top), Ba2 (middle) and Ba3 (bottom).The interatomic distances between Ba atoms and N atoms are in the range of 2.719(5)–3.243(4) Å, which is comparable with other Ba‐containing nitrides with a coordination number (CN) of eight (Figure S3). The increase of the distances in the sequence d
Ba1−NThe bulk phase composition of the samples was determined by Rietveld refinement of powder X‐ray diffraction data (Table S8). For the refinement of Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (x >0), the structural model of Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ from single‐crystal X‐ray diffraction data was used. Representative for all samples, the plot of the Rietveld refinement of Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ is shown in Figure 2, confirming Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ as the main phase.
Figure 2
Rietveld refinement of Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (Mo K
α1=0.71073 Å). Experimental data (black line), calculated pattern (red line) and difference curve (gray line). Tick marks: position of Bragg reflections of Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (green), AlN (blue), and BaBe2N2 (orange).
Rietveld refinement of Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (Mo K
α1=0.71073 Å). Experimental data (black line), calculated pattern (red line) and difference curve (gray line). Tick marks: position of Bragg reflections of Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (green), AlN (blue), and BaBe2N2 (orange).The sample contains small amounts of AlN and BaBe2N2 as impurity phases. Rietveld refinement plots for Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (x>0) are provided in the Supporting Information (Figure S4).Due to the larger ionic radius of Ba2+ compared to Sr2+, the lattice parameters of the samples are increasing with Ba2+ partially or completely occupying the Sr sites. Comparing the lattice parameters (Figure 3), an almost linear dependence on the atomic ratio Ba : Sr is observed.
Figure 3
Comparison of the lattice parameters a (red), b (black), and c (light blue), and the volume of the unit cell V (green) of Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ with x=0, 0.5, 1.0, 1.5 and 2.0 obtained from Rietveld refinements.
Comparison of the lattice parameters a (red), b (black), and c (light blue), and the volume of the unit cell V (green) of Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ with x=0, 0.5, 1.0, 1.5 and 2.0 obtained from Rietveld refinements.As already discussed above, the structure provides three crystallographically independent AE
2+ (AE
2+=Sr, Ba) sites (Figure 1c) with coordination polyhedra of different sizes and shapes. Since the local coordination around the cation replaced by Eu2+ can have a strong influence on the photoluminescence properties of the nitridoberylloaluminates, the occupation of Sr/Ba1, Sr/Ba2 and Sr/Ba3 sites was investigated using Rietveld refinements. A graphical representation of the site occupation factors is illustrated in Figure 4, indicating a mixed occupancy of all three sites.
Figure 4
Graphical representation of the site occupation factors of the three crystallographic sites occupied by Sr and/or Ba in the solid solution series Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+. Wyckoff positions of the respective sites are given in brackets. The darker color represents Sr, while the lighter color stands for Ba.
Graphical representation of the site occupation factors of the three crystallographic sites occupied by Sr and/or Ba in the solid solution series Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+. Wyckoff positions of the respective sites are given in brackets. The darker color represents Sr, while the lighter color stands for Ba.The refinement was restrained to allow only electroneutral sum formula. Therefore, the three crystallographic sites were assumed to be fully occupied while the Sr : Ba ratio was refined. According to the refinements, the atomic ratios of Sr : Ba are 1.3 : 0.7 (x=0.5), 1.1 : 0.9 (x=1.0) and 0.7 : 1.3 (x=1.5).Due to the different ionic radii of Ba2+ (1.42 Å, CN=8) and Sr2+ (1.26 Å, CN=8),
an ordering of the heavy atoms is plausible. The members of the solid solution, however, do not show ordering of the AE
2+ ions, but indicate a mixed occupancy of all three sites (Figure 4). But the distribution of the larger Ba2+ ion is uneven across the possible sites. Ba2+ ions prefer the occupation of Sr/Ba2 and Sr/Ba3, probably based on the larger polyhedral volumes compared to the Sr/Ba1 site. The impact of these results will be further discussed in the luminescence section.
Electronic properties
The electronic properties of M
2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (M=Sr, Ba) were investigated by a combination of synchrotron‐based soft X‐ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) and X‐ray emission spectroscopy (XES), as well as DFT calculations. As the results for both compounds are quite similar, the XES, XAS, resonant inelastic X‐ray scattering spectra (RIXS) and a non‐resonant X‐ray emission spectrum (NXES) for Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ are shown in Figure 5, while the spectra for Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ can be found in the Supporting Information (Figure S5). The solid black line shown in Figure 5b corresponds to the experimental PFY for Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+, which is compared to core hole (solid orange line) and ground state (dash‐dotted orange line) calculations.
Figure 5
Experimental and calculated N K‐edge XES and XAS spectra of Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+. a) NXES spectrum (black) excited at 440.0 eV and RIXS spectra (red, magenta, and blue) collected at 398.3 eV, 399.8 eV, and 401.2 eV are compared with ground state calculations (orange). The vertical dotted magenta line indicates that the highest emission energy is observed at the highest excitation energy in the RIXS spectra, which indicates an indirect band gap; b) Comparison of experimental PFY (black), core hole (C.H.) and ground state (G.S.) calculations of N K‐edge XAS spectra. The small color coded arrows in the embedded figure indicate where in the conduction band (CB) the N 1s electron was excited to obtain the emission spectra of the corresponding color; c) Second derivative of the NXES spectrum, with peaks that are above the noise level and are corresponding to the valence band edge indicated by the arrow; d) Second derivative of PFY of XAS spectrum with peaks corresponding to CB edge indicated by the arrow.
Experimental and calculated N K‐edge XES and XAS spectra of Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+. a) NXES spectrum (black) excited at 440.0 eV and RIXS spectra (red, magenta, and blue) collected at 398.3 eV, 399.8 eV, and 401.2 eV are compared with ground state calculations (orange). The vertical dotted magenta line indicates that the highest emission energy is observed at the highest excitation energy in the RIXS spectra, which indicates an indirect band gap; b) Comparison of experimental PFY (black), core hole (C.H.) and ground state (G.S.) calculations of N K‐edge XAS spectra. The small color coded arrows in the embedded figure indicate where in the conduction band (CB) the N 1s electron was excited to obtain the emission spectra of the corresponding color; c) Second derivative of the NXES spectrum, with peaks that are above the noise level and are corresponding to the valence band edge indicated by the arrow; d) Second derivative of PFY of XAS spectrum with peaks corresponding to CB edge indicated by the arrow.It is found that the experimental XAS spectrum is in good agreement with the core hole calculations, as all major features are reproduced at the correct energy positions and approximately at the correct peak heights. The comparison of the two calculated absorption spectra (Figure 5b, orange) to the measured spectrum (Figure 5b, black) makes it clear that the core hole concentration in the experiment lies somewhere between the two calculated cases. Therefore, the core hole concentration should be more dilute than the case we calculated, and which reflects 1 of 20 atoms in the supercell missing a 1s electron. A more diluted core hole concentration (and hence larger supercell) was computationally not feasible due to the increased cpu time that would be required.As the absorption and emission spectra are proportional to the unoccupied and occupied pDOS, respectively their separation can be used to determine the electronic band gap, using the second derivative method. Here, the valence band (VB) and the conduction band (CB) edges are taken to be the first peaks in the second derivative above the noise at the upper edge of the NXES and lower edge of the XAS spectra, respectively, as indicated by the arrows in Figure 5c+d. From the band edges (Figure 5 and Figure S5) the estimated band gap is found to be 3.4±0.3 eV for Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ and 3.1±0.3 eV for Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+, respectively. This result must be adjusted to account for the effect of the N 1s core hole that is created during the excitation process. Applying a DFT‐derived correction of 0.1 eV the final experimental band gaps are found to be 3.5±0.3 eV (M=Sr) and 3.2±0.3 eV (M=Ba), respectively. The calculated band gap using PBE‐GGA is found to be 2.8 eV (M=Sr) and 2.56 eV (M=Ba), respectively. This underestimation is typical for DFT and can be improved by using the modified Becke‐Johnson (mBJ) exchange‐correlation potential.
In this case, the calculated band gaps are found to be 4.2 eV (M=Sr) and 3.6 eV (M=Ba). A summary of the band gap values can be found in Table 3.
Table 3
Determined band gap (Δ) values for M
2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (M=Sr, Ba) in eV obtained from X‐ray spectroscopy (XES/XAS), DFT‐calculations (GGA/mBJ) and UV‐Vis spectroscopy (Tauc, direct and indirect).
M
ΔXES/XAS
ΔGGA
ΔmBJ
ΔTauc, direct
ΔTauc, indirect
Sr
3.5±0.3
2.8
4.2
3.8[13]
3.1
Ba
3.2±0.3
2.6
3.6
3.5
3.0
Determined band gap (Δ) values for M
2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (M=Sr, Ba) in eV obtained from X‐ray spectroscopy (XES/XAS), DFT‐calculations (GGA/mBJ) and UV‐Vis spectroscopy (Tauc, direct and indirect).MΔXES/XASΔGGAΔmBJΔTauc, directΔTauc, indirectSr3.5±0.32.84.23.83.1Ba3.2±0.32.63.63.53.0The band structure of M
2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (M=Sr, Ba) was calculated using the mBJ exchange‐correlation potentials (Figure S6). The calculations indicate an indirect band gap for both materials with the valence band (VB) maximum at the Τ point for both compounds and the conduction band (CB) minimum at the Γ point for Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ and Ζ point for Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+, respectively. The pDOS of both compounds (Figure S7) show high similarity with other materials based on XN4 (X=Li, Al, Mg, Si) tetrahedra, for example, SLA,
Li2Ca2[Mg2Si2N6]:Eu2+,
or Ba[Li2[Al2Si2]N6]:Eu2+,
where the upper VB is dominated by N p states and the lower VB is characterized by X s/p states. Meanwhile, the alkaline earth ion d states strongly contribute to the lower CB. Based on the definition of Dorenbos, there are two types of compounds: type I compounds, where the bottom of the CB is dominated by alkaline earth ions which are replaced by rare earth ions, and type II compounds, where the lower CB is dominated by ions that are not replaced by the rare earth ion.
Typically, type I compounds show an increasing band gap with smaller size of the alkaline earth, which is in accordance with the values obtained for M
2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (M=Sr, Ba), where Sr‐containing phosphor show larger band gap values (Table 3).
UV‐vis spectroscopy
Additionally, the optical band gaps of Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ and Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ were estimated from reflectance data and compared to the ones obtained from XAS/XES experiments and DFT calculations. The reflectance spectra R were converted to pseudoabsorption spectra using the Kubelka‐Munk function F(R)=(1−R)2/(2R) (Figure S8).
The optical band gaps were determined through a linear fit of the data at the infliction point from the Tauc plots ([F(R) hν]1/ with n=
for a direct and n=2 for an indirect allowed transition for a better comparison with the literature (direct band gap for Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ of 3.8 eV).
The values are summarized in Table 3 and are approximately in the same range, as the calculated (GGA and mBJ) and experimentally (XES/XAS) determined band gaps.
Luminescence
Luminescence measurements were carried out on samples with various compositions. Excitation and emission spectra of single particles of the solid solution series Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (x=0–2.0) are displayed in Figure 6 (2 mol % Eu2+ concentration referred to Sr/Ba).
Figure 6
Normalized photoluminescence spectra of single particles of Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ with x=0 (dark blue), 0.5 (light blue), 1.0 (green), 1.5 (orange), 2.0 (pink)). a) Excitation spectra (λ
obs=626–670 nm), b) Emission spectra (λ
exc=440–450 nm).
Normalized photoluminescence spectra of single particles of Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ with x=0 (dark blue), 0.5 (light blue), 1.0 (green), 1.5 (orange), 2.0 (pink)). a) Excitation spectra (λ
obs=626–670 nm), b) Emission spectra (λ
exc=440–450 nm).The excitation spectra in Figure 6a show that all members of the solid solution series can be excited with blue light with a maximum absorption around 440 nm. Compared to the Sr‐containing nitridoberylloaluminate, Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ exhibits a red‐shifted emission maximum at λ
em=656 nm with a fwhm of ≈87 nm/2025 cm−1. The position of the emission maximum and the shape of the emission band obtained from single particles are comparable to those obtained from bulk samples (Supporting Information, Figure S10). Therefore, the luminescence properties of the bulk samples can be assigned to Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ and rules out a possible contribution to the red emission by the side phase BaBe2N2. The value of the internal quantum efficiency (IQE) at room temperature for Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ is 44 %, which is similar to Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (33 %).
Overall, the photoluminescence properties for Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ are comparable to other nitrides, some of which are summarized in Table 4.
Table 4
Luminescence properties and coordination number (CN) of selected orange‐red emitting Eu2+ doped (oxo)nitrides.
Compound
λem /nm
λexc /nm
Fwhm /nm
Fwhm /cm−1
CN
Ref.
Ba2[BeAl3N5]
656
440
87
2025
7, 8
Ca[Mg2Al2N4]
606
440
67
1815
8
[15]
Sr[Mg2Al2N4]
612
440
82
1823
8
[15]
Sr2[BeAl3N5]
612
440
71
1899
7, 8
[13]
Sr[Li2Al2O2N2]
614
460
48
1286
8
[9]
Sr[Mg3SiN4]
615
440
43
1170
8
[8]
Sr2[MgAl5N7]
633
440
78
1940
8
[26]
Sr[LiAl3N4]
654
440
50
1180
8
[7]
Ba[Mg2Al2N4]
666
440
104
2331
8
[15]
Sr4[LiAl11N14]
670
460
85
1880
8
[27]
Luminescence properties and coordination number (CN) of selected orange‐red emitting Eu2+ doped (oxo)nitrides.Compoundλ
em /nmλ
exc /nmFwhm /nmFwhm /cm−1CNRef.Ba2[BeAl3N5]6564408720257, 8Ca[Mg2Al2N4]6064406718158Sr[Mg2Al2N4]6124408218238Sr2[BeAl3N5]6124407118997, 8Sr[Li2Al2O2N2]6144604812868Sr[Mg3SiN4]6154404311708Sr2[MgAl5N7]6334407819408Sr[LiAl3N4]6544405011808Ba[Mg2Al2N4]66644010423318Sr4[LiAl11N14]6704608518808To investigate the effect of the substitution of Sr2+ with Ba2+ on the Eu2+ luminescence in Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+, luminescence emission spectra of samples with x=0, 0.5, 1.0, 1.5 and 2.0 were measured (Figure 6b). The emission maxima obtained from samples of the solid solution series show tunable emission between 610 to 656 nm through the compositional variable x (Figure 7).
Figure 7
Correlation between the increasing Ba content with different x values and the emission wavelength from the luminescence measurements of bulk samples.
Correlation between the increasing Ba content with different x values and the emission wavelength from the luminescence measurements of bulk samples.The fwhm values for x=0 (72 nm/1922 cm−1) and x=2 (87 nm/2025 cm−1) are slightly smaller with values around 2000 cm−1, while in Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ with x=0.5, 1.0 and 1.5 the fwhm is increased up to 2200 cm−1. The fwhm broadening is caused by varying Eu−N distances, resulting from mixed occupation of the three alkaline earth sites as discussed in the crystal structure section. Furthermore, in the samples with mixed occupation of the Sr/Ba sites, a second emission maximum occurs at shorter wavelengths, peaking around 550 nm. The intensity of this second emission maximum is very weak and almost identical for the samples with x=0.5 and 1.0 and decreases even further in the sample with x=1.5. Comparing the low‐temperature measurements of Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+[13] and Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (Figure S10) only one broad emission band is observed for the Ba compound, while the superposition of three emission maxima is observed at 6 K for Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+. In the mixed phases, it can be observed that this second emission maximum also decreases in intensity as the Sr content of the compound decreases. Therefore, the assumption is that this emission maximum originates from Eu2+ on the Sr/Ba1 site which contains the highest Sr content according to the Rietveld refinement (Figure 4).Cationic substitution is often used to alter the emission color of nitride phosphors, as the emission is strongly influenced by the local environment around the activator Eu2+. Generally, the substitution of a smaller ion by a bigger one should lead to a smaller crystal field splitting and therefore shifting the emission color to shorter wavelengths.
Contrary to such observations, the emission of the solid solution series Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ is inversely shifted from 610 towards 656 nm with increasing Ba content as illustrated in Figure 7. The small leap in the position of the emission maximum observed between x=0 and x=0.5 is consistent with the interval observed analyzing the lattice parameter dependence on the Ba : Sr ratio, displayed in Figure 3.Possible reasons for the uncommon, inverse‐tunable red emission of Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ will be discussed in the following section. Such a red‐shifted emission can be associated with the activator concentration, the occurrence of anomalous trapped exciton emission or occur due to a change in the local environment around Eu2+ without necessarily changing the crystal structure of the compound.[
,
]In crystal structures with multiple crystallographic sites for the incorporation of the activator, the activator can act as donor and acceptor, enabling energy transfer between the activator ions. Typically, the probability for an energy transfer depends on the distance between the Eu2+ atoms, therefore a red‐shift of the emission with increasing activator concentration can take place, as already observed in different phosphors (for example, M
2Si5N8:Eu2+ (M=Sr, Ba),[
,
] or Ca2−Eu
SiO4
). Luminescence spectra of bulk samples of Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ with a nominal Eu2+ concentrations of 0.3, 1, 2, 3, and 4 mol % referred to Ba are shown in the Supporting Information (Figure S9) and were compared with the reported spectra for Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+.In the literature, it has been reported that the location of the emission maximum does not change as the Eu content increases for Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+.
A comparable behavior was observed for Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+. Phase‐pure samples will be necessary to further investigate luminescence properties in even more detail. Based on the current data, a red‐shift of the emission due to increasing activator concentrations seems to be rather unlikely.As anomalous trapped exciton emission is known to occur more likely in phosphors with Eu2+ on sites with high coordination number and large activator‐ligand bond lengths,
temperature‐dependent emission measurements were performed to investigate the luminescence properties of the title compounds at lower temperatures (Figures S10–S12). The obtained spectra show no significant shift of the emission maxima at lower temperatures, suggesting that anomalous emission is an unlikely explanation for the unusual inverse shift of the emission maxima to higher wavelengths.The third option to discuss is the dependence of the emission on structurally related properties, especially of Eu2+ states influenced by its surrounding ligands. As already stated in the introduction, the 4f–5d transition, which defines the excitation and emission properties of Eu2+ doped phosphors, is highly sensitive toward the local coordination environment around the activation ion. When Eu2+ replaces Sr2+ in Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+, no structural changes are expected, as the ionic radii of both ions are quite similar [Eu2+: 1.25 Å (CN=8) and 1.20 Å (CN=7); Sr2+: 1.26 Å (CN=8) and 1.21 Å (CN=7)].
The situation is quite different with Ba2+, as the ionic radius is larger than that of Eu2+ [Ba2+: 1.42 Å (CN=8) and 1.38 Å (CN=7)].
Therefore, incorporation of Eu2+ on a larger crystallographic site can lead to red‐shifted emission due to local lattice rearrangement. Considering the stepwise substitution of the lighter alkaline earth ion by the heavier homologue in the solid solution series, the activator Eu2+ preferentially replaces Sr atoms due to the similar ionic radii. When the neighboring Sr atoms are gradually replaced by the larger Ba2+, the strain of the Ba−N bond distances increases leading to shorter Sr−N and Eu−N bond lengths, in order to release lattice strain. The more Sr atoms are replaced by Ba2+, the shorter the Eu−N (and Sr−N) distances become. Shorter activator‐ligand distances increase the crystal field splitting of the 5d orbitals resulting in a continuous red‐shifted emission, as discussed for example for (Sr0.98−Ba
Eu0.02)Si2O2N2 (x=0–0.63).
Especially in crystal structures, where cations have a close proximity to each other, it is reasonable that the successive substitution of the smaller cations by a larger one can lead to local distortion and an increased lattice strain.
As discussed in the crystal structure the anionic network of the nitridoberylloaluminates contains several channels which are filled with the alkaline‐earth ions, therefore, replacing Sr2+ by Ba2+ would have a strong impact on several neighboring ions in this crystal structure. Therefore, it seems most likely, that the uncommon, inverse‐tunable red emission of Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ is the result of a change in the local Eu2+ coordination, depending on the Sr : Ba ratio.
Conclusion
In this contribution we report on the synthesis of Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ and the solid solution series Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (x=0.5, 1.0, 1.5) by high‐temperature reaction in a hot isostatic press under 50 MPa N2. The crystal structure of Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ was solved and refined from a single‐crystal, while the lattice parameters of the members of the solid solution series were determined by Rietveld refinement. The crystal structure is isotypic to the recently discovered nitridoberylloaluminate Sr2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ and consists of edge‐ and vertex‐sharing AlN4 tetrahedra and trigonal‐planar BeN3 units creating a highly condensed 3D network with three mixed occupied crystallographic Sr/Ba sites. Ba2[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ shows an emission maximum at λ
em=656 nm with a fwhm of ≈87 nm/2025 cm−1, which is comparable to other narrow‐band red‐emitting phosphors like M[Mg2Al2N4]:Eu2+ (M=Sr, Ba), MAlSiN3 (M=Ca, Sr),
α‐ and β‐Sr2[MgAl5N7]:Eu2+, or Sr8[LiMg2Al21N28]:Eu2+.
The Eu2+ emission can be continuously tuned from 610 to 656 nm by increasing the Ba content. Compared to narrow‐band red‐emitting phosphors like Sr[LiAl3N4]:Eu2+, the members of the solid solution series show somewhat broader emission bands, most probably due to the convolution of the emission from three differently coordinated Eu2+ sites. In contrast to the usual trend, the emission maximum in the nitridoberylloaluminates Sr2−Ba
[BeAl3N5]:Eu2+ (x=0–2) is inversely shifted to higher wavelengths by the incorporation of the larger cation Ba2+. This fact emphasizes the importance of studies regarding the structures and properties of potential phosphors, since the Eu2+ emission can be significantly influenced by small local changes and distortions of the environment without necessarily changing the symmetry of the crystal.In summary, the synthesis of the presented compounds and the study of their electronic and optical properties contributes to the elucidation of the so far little explored class of nitridoberylloaluminates and emphasizes their role in the discovery and development of new luminescent materials.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.As a service to our authors and readers, this journal provides supporting information supplied by the authors. Such materials are peer reviewed and may be re‐organized for online delivery, but are not copy‐edited or typeset. Technical support issues arising from supporting information (other than missing files) should be addressed to the authors.Supporting InformationClick here for additional data file.
Authors: Philipp Pust; Volker Weiler; Cora Hecht; Andreas Tücks; Angela S Wochnik; Ann-Kathrin Henß; Detlef Wiechert; Christina Scheu; Peter J Schmidt; Wolfgang Schnick Journal: Nat Mater Date: 2014-06-22 Impact factor: 43.841
Authors: Philipp Strobel; Christian Maak; Volker Weiler; Peter J Schmidt; Wolfgang Schnick Journal: Angew Chem Int Ed Engl Date: 2018-06-06 Impact factor: 15.336
Authors: Julius L Leaño; Carl Osby M Mariano; Wen-Tse Huang; Sebastian Mahlik; Tadeusz Lesniewski; Marek Grinberg; Hwo-Shuenn Sheu; Shu-Fen Hu; Ru-Shi Liu Journal: ACS Appl Mater Interfaces Date: 2020-05-08 Impact factor: 9.229
Authors: Gregor J Hoerder; Markus Seibald; Dominik Baumann; Thorsten Schröder; Simon Peschke; Philipp C Schmid; Tobias Tyborski; Philipp Pust; Ion Stoll; Michael Bergler; Christian Patzig; Stephan Reißaus; Michael Krause; Lutz Berthold; Thomas Höche; Dirk Johrendt; Hubert Huppertz Journal: Nat Commun Date: 2019-04-23 Impact factor: 14.919
Authors: Eugenia Elzer; Philipp Strobel; Volker Weiler; Muhammad R Amin; Peter J Schmidt; Alexander Moewes; Wolfgang Schnick Journal: Chemistry Date: 2022-02-02 Impact factor: 5.020