Mark Alan Fontana1, Cathlyn K Medina2, Eleni C Kohilakis3, Andrew D Pearle4, Catherine H MacLean5, Alexander S McLawhorn6. 1. Center for Analytics, Modeling, and Performance, Hospital for Special Surgery, New York, NY, USA; Center for the Advancement of Value in Musculoskeletal Care, Hospital for Special Surgery, New York, NY, USA; Department of Population Health Sciences, Weill Cornell Medical College, New York, NY, USA. 2. Center for the Advancement of Value in Musculoskeletal Care, Hospital for Special Surgery, New York, NY, USA; Duke University School of Medicine, Durham, NC, USA. 3. Center for the Advancement of Value in Musculoskeletal Care, Hospital for Special Surgery, New York, NY, USA. 4. Sports Medicine Institute, Hospital for Special Surgery, New York, NY, USA. 5. Center for the Advancement of Value in Musculoskeletal Care, Hospital for Special Surgery, New York, NY, USA; Department of Medicine, Weill Cornell Medical College, New York, NY, USA. 6. Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Hospital for Special Surgery, New York, NY, USA; Center for the Advancement of Value in Musculoskeletal Care, Hospital for Special Surgery, New York, NY, USA.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Decisions regarding care for osteoarthritis involve physicians helping patients understand likely benefits and harms of treatment. Little work has directly compared patient and surgeon risk-taking attitudes, which may help inform strategies for shared decision-making and improve patient satisfaction. METHODS: We surveyed patients contemplating total joint arthroplasty visiting a high-volume specialty hospital regarding general questions about risk-taking, as well as willingness to undergo surgery under hypothetical likelihoods of moderate improvement and complications. We compared responses from surgeons answering similar questions about willingness to recommend surgery. RESULTS: Altogether 82% (162/197) of patients responded, as did 65% (30/46) of joint replacement surgeons. Mean age among patients was 66.4 years; 58% were female. Surgeons averaged 399 surgeries in 2019. Responses were similar between groups for general, health, career, financial, and sports/leisure risk-taking (P > .20); surgeons were marginally more risk-taking in driving (P = .05). For willingness to have or recommend surgery, as the chance of benefit decreased, or the chance of harm increased, the percentage willing to have or recommend surgery decreased. Between a 70% and 95% chance of moderate improvement (for a 2% complication risk), as well as between a 90% and 95% chance of moderate improvement (for 4% and 6% complication risks), the percentage willing to have or recommend surgery was indistinguishable between patients and surgeons. However, for lower likelihoods of improvement, a higher percentage of patients were willing to undergo surgery than surgeons recommended. Patients were also more often indifferent between complication risks. CONCLUSION: Although patients and surgeons were often willing to have or recommend joint replacement surgery at similar rates, they diverged for lower-benefit higher-harm scenarios.
BACKGROUND: Decisions regarding care for osteoarthritis involve physicians helping patients understand likely benefits and harms of treatment. Little work has directly compared patient and surgeon risk-taking attitudes, which may help inform strategies for shared decision-making and improve patient satisfaction. METHODS: We surveyed patients contemplating total joint arthroplasty visiting a high-volume specialty hospital regarding general questions about risk-taking, as well as willingness to undergo surgery under hypothetical likelihoods of moderate improvement and complications. We compared responses from surgeons answering similar questions about willingness to recommend surgery. RESULTS: Altogether 82% (162/197) of patients responded, as did 65% (30/46) of joint replacement surgeons. Mean age among patients was 66.4 years; 58% were female. Surgeons averaged 399 surgeries in 2019. Responses were similar between groups for general, health, career, financial, and sports/leisure risk-taking (P > .20); surgeons were marginally more risk-taking in driving (P = .05). For willingness to have or recommend surgery, as the chance of benefit decreased, or the chance of harm increased, the percentage willing to have or recommend surgery decreased. Between a 70% and 95% chance of moderate improvement (for a 2% complication risk), as well as between a 90% and 95% chance of moderate improvement (for 4% and 6% complication risks), the percentage willing to have or recommend surgery was indistinguishable between patients and surgeons. However, for lower likelihoods of improvement, a higher percentage of patients were willing to undergo surgery than surgeons recommended. Patients were also more often indifferent between complication risks. CONCLUSION: Although patients and surgeons were often willing to have or recommend joint replacement surgery at similar rates, they diverged for lower-benefit higher-harm scenarios.
Authors: Stephen Lyman; Yuo-Yu Lee; Patricia D Franklin; Wenjun Li; David J Mayman; Douglas E Padgett Journal: Clin Orthop Relat Res Date: 2016-02-29 Impact factor: 4.176
Authors: Jesse M Pines; Judd E Hollander; Joshua A Isserman; Esther H Chen; Anthony J Dean; Frances S Shofer; Angela M Mills Journal: Am J Emerg Med Date: 2009-06 Impact factor: 2.469
Authors: Robert B Bourne; Bert M Chesworth; Aileen M Davis; Nizar N Mahomed; Kory D J Charron Journal: Clin Orthop Relat Res Date: 2010-01 Impact factor: 4.176
Authors: Carolyn A Hutyra; Juan Marcos Gonzalez; Jui-Chen Yang; F Reed Johnson; Shelby D Reed; Annunziato Amendola; Michael P Bolognesi; Keith R Berend; Michael E Berend; Steven J MacDonald; Richard C Mather Journal: J Bone Joint Surg Am Date: 2020-12-02 Impact factor: 5.284
Authors: Christopher M Bono; Mitchel B Harris; Natalie Warholic; Jeffrey N Katz; Edward Carreras; Andrew White; Miguel Schmitz; Kirkham B Wood; Elena Losina Journal: Spine (Phila Pa 1976) Date: 2013-01-15 Impact factor: 3.468