| Literature DB >> 34868617 |
Dominic Cushnan1, Rosalind Berka2, Ottavia Bertolli2, Peter Williams1, Daniel Schofield1, Indra Joshi1, Alberto Favaro2, Mark Halling-Brown3,4, Gergely Imreh2, Emily Jefferson5,6, Neil J Sebire5, Gerry Reilly5, Jonathan C L Rodrigues7, Graham Robinson7, Susan Copley8, Rizwan Malik9, Claire Bloomfield10,11, Fergus Gleeson10,11, Moira Crotty12, Erika Denton13, Jeanette Dickson14, Gary Leeming15, Hayley E Hardwick16, Kenneth Baillie17, Peter Jm Openshaw18, Malcolm G Semple19, Caroline Rubin20, Andy Howlett12, Andrea G Rockall8,21, Ayub Bhayat22, Daniel Fascia23, Cathie Sudlow24, Joseph Jacob25,26.
Abstract
The prevalence of the coronavirus SARS-CoV-2 disease has resulted in the unprecedented collection of health data to support research. Historically, coordinating the collation of such datasets on a national scale has been challenging to execute for several reasons, including issues with data privacy, the lack of data reporting standards, interoperable technologies, and distribution methods. The coronavirus SARS-CoV-2 disease pandemic has highlighted the importance of collaboration between government bodies, healthcare institutions, academic researchers and commercial companies in overcoming these issues during times of urgency. The National COVID-19 Chest Imaging Database, led by NHSX, British Society of Thoracic Imaging, Royal Surrey NHS Foundation Trust and Faculty, is an example of such a national initiative. Here, we summarise the experiences and challenges of setting up the National COVID-19 Chest Imaging Database, and the implications for future ambitions of national data curation in medical imaging to advance the safe adoption of artificial intelligence in healthcare.Entities:
Keywords: Imaging; artificial intelligence; coronavirus SARS-CoV-2 disease; general; machine learning; medicine; radiology; respiratory
Year: 2021 PMID: 34868617 PMCID: PMC8637703 DOI: 10.1177/20552076211048654
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Digit Health ISSN: 2055-2076
Learnings summary from the National COVID-19 Chest Imaging Database (NCCID) for future data collection initiatives.
| Category | Learning for future data collection | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Information governance (IG) | Data governance processes must be clarified and standardised to reduce barriers to NHS Trust participation in future national data collection exercises |
| 2 | Database linkages | Collaboration and linking with other databases improve the quality, completeness and coverage of the data collected, increasing opportunities for discovery |
| 3 | Automation | Incorporating automation is vital to enable mass data collection and reduce manual data capture and burden for hospital staff |
| 4 | Trusted research environments (TREs) | Building national infrastructure enables data to be accessed and analysed in a safe and secure way, facilitating research and innovation |
| 5 | Availability of validation datasets | Creation of large-scale high-quality validation datasets helps to accelerate the route to market for new artificial intelligence models |
| 6 | Funding | Defining a variety of funding mechanisms to support NHS Trust data collection activities and infrastructure engineering is key to the sustainability of any national programme |
| 7 | Patient and public engagement | Consulting patients and the wider public is important to ensure that concerns regarding how patient data is used and stored are addressed and that this is done in a safe, secure and ethical way |
| 8 | Benefit share models | Defining benefit share frameworks helps to ensure that the NHS benefits at the local site level, which can incentivise participation in national data collection exercises |
Figure 1.National COVID-19 Chest Imaging Database (NCCID) infrastructure and explanation.
Database linkages for the National COVID-19 Chest Imaging Database (NCCID).
| Database linkage | Objective | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | International Severe Acute Respiratory and Emerging Infection
Consortium (ISARIC) 4C repository
| To enhance the number of clinical variables that can be evaluated alongside clinical imaging and to reduce duplication of data gathering efforts for hospital sites during a period of stretched limited resources. |
| 2 | NHS England and Improvement | To provide comprehensive ethnicity data, which can be
challenging to collect when relying solely on hospital records.
Collecting reliable ethnicity data is essential given the
disproportionate impact of COVID-19 on the Black, Asian and
Minority Ethnic (BAME) populations, and to avoid introducing
inherent biases during artificial intelligence model development.
|
| 3 | National Scottish Picture Archiving and Communications System
(PACS) and Safe Haven Network[ | To increase the geographic coverage of the database to the
entirety of Scotland.
|
Examples of existing initiatives facilitating collection of medical imaging data.
| Data initiative | Description of their work | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | National Consortium of Intelligent Medical Imaging (NCIMI) | Led from Oxford's Big Data Institute and brings together expertise across 14 NHS partners, academia and 13 industry partners to support the development, testing, validation and adoption of new clinical imaging AI tools into the NHS. |
| 2 | PICTURES (Interdisciplinary Collaboration for the Efficient and Effective Use of Clinical Images in Big Data Health Care Research) | Led by the University of Dundee in conjunction with NHS Scotland and other academic bodies. The study is collating 30 million images from the Scottish National PACS, across all 14 Scottish health boards, to support the development of AI technologies. PICTURES will allow researchers to work on vast amounts of data in a secure environment that protects individual patient information. |
| 3 | East Midlands Radiology Consortium (EMRAD) | Working with Kheiron Medical to develop and test a CE-marked
Mammography Intelligent Assessment (MIA) tool that can help
detect breast cancer, using the historic data and images
provided by EMRAD.
|
| 4 | Yorkshire Imaging Collaborative | Partnered with Leeds University to develop a Trusted Research
Environment that extracts data from across the network to
predict future capacity and demand requirements for each imaging
modality across the region.
|
Future aspirations to support the end-goal of implementing artificial intelligence (AI) technologies in the NHS.
| Future aspiration | Explanation | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Central cloud-based infrastructure, managed by a neutral national body | To facilitate the automated collection of medical imaging data into comprehensive training and validation datasets. |
| 2 | Improved collaboration between the entrepreneurial community and the NHS | To encourage the identification of new life-saving technologies through more widely accessible data. |
| 3 | Greater engagement with the radiology community as users of AI | To ensure that the AI tools being prioritised for deployment are designed for optimal utility and address the needs of radiologists. |
| 4 | Further guidance and support on regulatory approvals and AI model evaluation criteria | For both technology developers and commissioners of AI
technology – to ensure that AI products are deemed safe and
effective for use in a clinical setting. NHSX has already
published an ‘AI Buyers Guide’ to advise commissioners of AI
technology on this matter, which is a useful starting point.
|
| 5 | A centralised, vendor-agnostic deployment infrastructure | To implement AI technologies for use in complex environment, and support the pathway from innovation to deployment |