| Literature DB >> 34836330 |
Balma García-Gozalbo1, Luis Cabañas-Alite1.
Abstract
Cancer is a prevalent disease worldwide, and treatments such as radiotherapy and chemotherapy sometimes lead to adverse events. Oral mucositis is one of the most disabling adverse events, and clinical guidelines do not take into account nutritional interventions. The primary endpoint was to gather the evidence about the efficacy of nutritional interventions in the prevention and/or treatment of antineoplastic-induced oral mucositis in oncological patients. A bibliographic review was carried out in the PubMed data base by combining MeSH terms with Boolean operators. Articles were selected based on inclusion and exclusion criteria; 50 final articles were found. Although further evidence is needed, glutamine, honey, and vitamins appear to be good therapeutic options. The rest of the compounds presented controversial or insufficient results, making it difficult to draw conclusions over their utilization as prevention or treatment options. Little evidence is reported about oral mucositis nutritional interventions in spite of them being attainable and affordable compounds. Scarce evidence is shown in paediatric patients compared with adults. Developing higher quality studies and combinations with the compounds researched is necessary for creating a stronger body of evidence.Entities:
Keywords: cancer; diet therapy; oral mucositis
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34836330 PMCID: PMC8618139 DOI: 10.3390/nu13114075
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Nutrients ISSN: 2072-6643 Impact factor: 5.717
Figure 1Data Collection for the study.
Summary of studies investigating prevention or treatment of Oral Mucositis in cancer patients with dietary components or prevention methods.
| Author (Year) |
| Study Design | Objective | Intervention | Time (Months) | Conclusions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Huang et al. (2019) [ | 59 | RCT | To evaluate whether oral glutamine prevents acute toxicities (OM and dermatitis) secondary to the treatment with RT in patients with head and neck cancers. | Glutamine (TG); | 19 | CG developed more OM (grades 2–4) than TG; nevertheless, the efficacy of the treatment with oral glutamine was not meaningful after RT in head and neck cancers. |
| Tsujimoto et al. (2015) [ | 40 | RCT, double-blind | To evaluate whether oral glutamine reduces mucositis severity induced by CRT in patients with head and neck cancer. | Glutamine (TG); | 36 | Oral glutamine reduced OM severity produced by CT in head and neck cancer patients with a maximum mean grade of OM lower for TG than for PG, a duration without meaningful difference between both groups, and a shorter duration of artificial nutrition required in TG. |
| Tanaka et al. (2016) [ | 30 | RCT | To assess whether glutamine and the combination of glutamine and elemental diet reduce the incidence of CT induced OM in patients with oesophageal cancers. | Placebo (PG); | 36 | No differences between PG and TG |
| Pachón-Ibañez et al. (2018) [ | 262 | Prospective cohort study | To evaluate whether oral glutamine prevents mucositis induced by oncological therapies (CRT or RT) in patients with head and neck cancer. | Oral glutamine (TG); | - | More OM in PG (RR:1.78), without remarkable differences in severity. Higher odynophagia in PG (RR:2.87), with more severity (R = 4.33). In PG, more discontinuity in the treatment. |
| Chang et al. (2019) [ | 60 | RCT | To measure the impact of oral glutamine as a supplement for the prevention of oesophagitis induced by CRT in patients with advanced non-small cell lung cancer (stages III–IV). | Placebo (PG); | 12 | TG had less severe ARIE than PG, as well as a reduction in the incidence of weight loss in TG. |
| Anturlikar et al. (2019) [ | 20 | In vitro and in vivo study | To measure the safety and efficacy of “HTOR-091516” (Tumeric, Triphala, and honey) as a treatment for OM induced by 5-FU (CT). | IN VITRO: gingival human fibroblast, mouse connective tissue, and human oral reconstructed epidermis culture. Later treatment with “HTOR-091516” and MTT test (cytotoxicity) + TNF-α inhibition test (inflammation)+ test INVITTOX | 0.5 (14 days) | The average weight loss in TG was lower; there also was less mortality and a reduction in OM grade (WHO scale). The product is proposed to prevent OM. |
| Cho et al. (2019) [ | 91 | CT | To assess the effect of glutamine-enriched parenteral nutrition (PN) on weight, infections, complications (mucositis, neutropenia, and graft-versus-host disease), and mortality in patients who underwent HSCT transplantation. | Control (CG); | 48 | No significant association in the case of OM duration. A reduction in 100-days mortality for TG was noted. |
| Shumsky et al. (2019) [ | 15 | Pilot RCT | To evaluate the efficacy of Oncoxin (ONCX) in oncologic patients with OM who underwent CT, RT or both. | Control group (CG); | 0.6 (20 days) | Lower-grade OM was found in OG (after 7 days of treatment and towards the end of their treatment). |
| Widjaja et al. (2020) [ | 48 | Double-blind RCT | To measure whether oral glutamine prevents OM during CT (methotrexate (MTX) in paediatric patients with acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL). | Placebo group (PG); | 0.5 (14 days) | There was a reduction in the incidence and severity of OM in TG after CT. |
| Harada et al. (2018) [ | 50 | In vitro and in vivo study | To appraise the efficacy of Elental© (dietetic liquid formulation enriched with amino acids, which is a source of L-glutamine) in 5-FU (CT)-induced OM and dermatitis treatment. | In vivo: | 0.25 (8 days) | In vivo, OM healed faster than in EG. |
| Oosterom et al. | 99 (A) and 81 (B) | Cohort study | (1) To study the prevalence of vitamin D deficiency in paediatric patients; | Vitamin D levels before and after MTX therapy. | 2004–2012 | There was no association between basal vitamin D levels and MTX-induced OM, but low levels of vitamin D during MTX therapy were found to be related to severe OM. |
| Sun et al. (2019) | 100 | Double-blind RCT | To examine the effects of a group B multivitamin complex combined with GeneTime© (human recombinant growth factor) on the treatment of OM in patients with head and neck cancer undergoing RT. | Control group with vitamin B complex.Observational group with (OG) vitamin B complex + GeneTime©. | 12 | Less severity, affected area, and healing time of the OM ulcers in OG. |
| Nejatinamini et al. (2018) | 28 | Cohort | To evaluate the changes in vitamin status during the treatment of head and neck cancers related to body composition, inflammation, and mucositis. | Dietetic intake measurement (3 days). | 1–1.5 | Higher rates of OM were observed related to less vitamin D, B12, E, and B9 intake and lower blood levels of vitamin A and D. |
| Tanaka et al. (2018) [ | 19 | RCT | To measure the intake of Elental© during two cycles of CT and to determine the incidence of OM in patients with oesophageal cancers treated with CT who completed their intake and those who did not completed it. | Elental© group (CG); | 2 (56 days) | Less severity of OM in CG during CT with the use of Elental©. |
| Pathak et al. (2019) [ | 56 | RCT | To assess the efficacy and role of oral glutamine in the treatment of OM and dysphagia induced by chemoradiotherapy (CRT) in patients with oropharynx and larynx carcinoma. | Control group (CG); | 1.75 (49 days) | TG had fewer hospitalizations due to OM and dysphagia. |
| Mamgain et al. (2020) [ | 127 | RCT | To evaluate the efficacy of an ayurvedic preparation (based on | Comparison between basal and post-RT characteristics: | 24 | Less severity, less pain, and shorter onset time of mucositis, both in ATG and HTG, but especially in ATG. |
| Harada et al. (2019) [ | 50 | Open RCT | To evaluate changes in OM (injuries’ size, pain, and redness + CRP in plasma) in patients with oral squamous cell carcinoma undergoing CRT or RT with Elental© administration. | Elental group (EG); | 24 | In EG, milder OM development in CRT; no difference in RT. |
| Rao et al. (2017) [ | 49 | Blinded single-centre RCT | To evaluate whether honey causes interference with RT-induced tumoral response or whether it exhibits a positive effect against OM in patients with head and neck cancer. | Povidone–iodine group (CG); | 6 | Lower incidence of OM and less severity in HG. The implications for treatment interruption were not significant. |
| Branda et al. (2004) [ | 68 | Pilot cohort study | To study the influence of B12 vitamin, folate, and dietetic supplements on CT-induced toxicity in breast cancer patients. | Blood samples (B12, B9, and neutrophils) before/after the first CT cycle; | - | No evidence of influence was found. |
| Okada et al. (2017) [ | 20 | Pilot single-centre RCT | To evaluate the influence of Elental© on CT-induced OM and diarrhoeas in patients with oesophageal cancer. | IG: use of | 0.5 (14 days) | Less severe OM incidence in IG. |
| De Sousa et al. (2018) [ | 40 | In vivo study | To evaluate the effects of glycine in the expression of collagen and platelet and epidermal growth factors (PDGF, EGF) in an OM murine model. | Control group (CG); | - | Positive effects in IG, with a better recovering rate (collagen increase and growth factors reduction). |
| Nihei et al. (2018) [ | 67 | Single-centre | To evaluate the efficacy and safety of L-Glutamine sodium azulene sulphonate in the treatment of CT-induced OM in patients with colorectal and breast cancer. | Intervention group (IG); | 24 | Lesser OM severity in IG. No significant differences were found regarding incidence. |
| Chattopadhyay et al. (2014) [ | 70 | Single-centre RCT | To evaluate the influence of oral glutamine on RT-induced OM in patients with head and neck cancer. | Intervention group with oral glutamine (IG); | 8 | Lower incidence, severity, and duration of RT-induced OM in IG. |
| Üçüncü et al. (2006) [ | 35 | Laboratory CT | To determine the preventive effect of Vitamin E (VE) and L-Carnitine (LC), alone or in combination, on OM and myelosuppression by RT. | 5 groups: | Follow-up: | VE and LC proved to be radioprotective agents on their own and not combined together, with lower severity and longer time to histological appearance of OM. |
| Amanat et al. (2017) [ | 82 | Single-centre RCT | To assess the effect of honey on clinical grades of OM. | Honey group (HG); | 12 | Lower incidence and severity of OM in HG during the RT. |
| Podlesko et al. (2018) [ | 3 | Case series | To evaluate the effects of topical application of deoxyribonucleic acid on three OM (moderate–severe) cases in patients with head and neck cancer. | Oral spray of polydeoxyribonucleotide (PDRN) as treatment. | 1 | Increased relief and remission of OM over time, without interruption in treatment or opioid intake. |
| Perrone et al. (2017) [ | 73 | CT | To analyse the influence of dietary supplementation with whey protein concentrate (WPC) on the incidence of OM in patients undergoing HSCT. | WPC group (WG); | Not specified | No significant differences between WG and CG in incidence, duration, and severity of OM concerns. However, in WG2, shorter duration and lower incidence of severe OM was found. |
| Ogata et al. (2017) [ | 22 | Pilot prospective study | To evaluate the preventive effects of Elental ® on CT-induced OM in patients with colorectal cancer (CRC). | 22 patients in Elental (1 group); | 36 | Significantly reduced CT (5-FU)-induced OM grade. |
| Al Jouni et al. (2017) [ | 40 | Open RCT | To evaluate the effects of honey on grade 3–4 OM, reduction in bacterial/fungal infections, duration of OM episodes, and body weight in paediatric leukaemia patients undergoing CT or RT. | Control group (CG) with Lidocaine, Mycostatin, Daktarin, and oral cleaning; | 12 | Significant reduction in severity and pain in HG. Significant improvement in weight and time to OM onset in HG. |
| Lopez-Vaquero et al. (2017) [ | 49 | Phase II double-blind RCT | To evaluate whether glutamine is effective in reducing the incidence and severity of mucositis and dermatitis induced by RT or CRT in patients with head and neck cancer. | L-Glutamine group (TG); | 6 | Incidence and severity with no significant differences between groups. |
| Howlader et al. (2019) [ | 40 | RCT (single-blinded). | To assess whether honey improves mucositis injuries and the quality of life of patients with RT/CT-induced OM (for head and neck cancer). | Treatment group (HG) with honey (both rinsed and ingested honey); | From CT start—4 weeks after RT. | Less OM and associated symptoms induced by RT in HG. Shorter time towards the recovery of a regular quality of life. |
| Elsass (2017) [ | 10 | Case series | The aim was to improve OM (oral comfort and feeding) with standard oral care and the use of Leptospermum honey in paediatric oncology patients after proven CT. | Application of honey on the buccal surface with a cotton swab, 3 times/day, Then spat or suctioned out. | - | Shorter healing time with lower pain rate in all cases. |
| Elkerm and Tawashi (2014) | 20 | Pilot study | To evaluate whether date palm pollen (DPP) can be effective in the prevention and treatment of RT- and CT-induced OM in patients with head and neck cancer. | DPP group (one daily suspension); | 1.5 (6 weeks) | Significant reduction in incidence, severity, and pain in OM and dysphagia in DPP. |
| Raeessi et al. (2014) [ | 61 | Single-centre double-blind RCT | To evaluate the effects of coffee + honey in the treatment of OM by CT and compare them with the effects of steroids. | 3 groups: | 36 | Significant reduction in the severity of OM in all three groups. |
| Baydar et al. (2005) [ | 99 | CT | To research the effects of local cryotherapy on the prevention of CT (5-FU)-induced OM. | Intervention group (IG): CT courses with local cryotherapy (ice in the mouth during the CT course up to 10 min afterwards); | Not specified. | 5-FU-induced OM incidence lower in GI (OR = 11.5). |
| Peterson et al. (2007) [ | 305 | Phase III, double-blind RCT | To observe the efficacy of Saforis ® in the prevention and treatment of OM caused by CT treatment in breast cancer. | Saforis group (SG); | Not specified. | Lower severity and incidence rate in SG. |
| Fogh et al. (2016) [ | 119 | Multicentric phase II RCT | To evaluate the effect of Manuka honey (liquid and tablets) in the prevention of RT-induced oesophagitis in lung cancer patients. | G1: Manuka honey (liquid); | 12 | There were no significant differences for groups G1, G2, or G3, so the use of honey did not prove to be superior to standard health care. |
| Samdariya et al. (2015) [ | 69 | Open RCT | To study the intake of honey in pain relief caused by RT-induced OM in patients with head and neck cancer. | (1) Gargle with soda and benzidamine (PG); | November 2011–January 2013. | Slightly greater relief in HG during the entire follow-up (3 months), with a significant reduction in the severity of OM-associated pain and fewer treatment interruptions. |
| Matsuda et al. (2015) [ | 90 | Double-blind phase III RCT. | To research whether TJ-14 (Hangeshashinto) prevents and/or controls CT-induced OM in patients with colorectal cancer. | TJ-14 treatment group (IG); | 0.5 (14 days). | Significant reduction in the duration of severe OM, with no effect on the severity or incidence of OM itself. |
| Bateman et al. (2013) [ | Not specified (approximate number = 48). | Laboratory in vivo study | To investigate the protective effects of nutritional drinks on the development of methotrexate (MTX)-induced gastrointestinal mucositis in animals with and without cancer. | G1: ClinutrenProtect ® (whey protein, short-chain fatty acids, TGF-b, L-glutamine); | Not specified. | Administered diets offered no observed protection against MTX-induced mucositis. |
| Jayachandran and Balaji (2012) [ | 60 | RCT | To evaluate the effect of natural honey and benzidamine hydrochloride on the development and severity of RT-associated OM in patients with oral cancers. | 3 groups (oral rinses): | 6 | Lower severity and earlier healing of OM not significant in HG. |
| Sugita et al. (2012) [ | 118 | Retrospective CT | To ascertain the effects of folinic acid administration (systemic and rinsed) on the incidence of OM and acute graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) after GVHD prophylaxis with MTX in patients undergoing HSCT. | Systemic folic acid was administered to patients at increased risk of developing OM ( | 48 | Folinic acid could be useful in reducing the incidence of severe OM, both in systemic use and rinsed. |
| Sorensen et al. (2008) [ | 206 | Double-blind RCT | To evaluate prevention of OM using chlorhexidine compared with cryotherapy during 5-FU CT in gastrointestinal cancer. | 3 groups: | - | Higher severity rate of OM in PG and lower in CG, with a lower incidence and duration in IG and CG than in PG; therefore, prophylaxis seems effective in both IG and CG. |
| Das et al. (2011) [ | 52 | RCT | Observe protective/healing effect against RT and CT effects (OM, skin reaction, xerostomia, or voice changes) when using | 4 groups: | 1.75 (7 weeks) | Lower incidence and severity in GLHG and LHG compared with CG, but similar to HG. |
| Thornley et al. (2004) [ | 37 | CT | To determine the feasibility and potential efficacy of a fixed combination of agents in reducing RRT (regimen-related toxicity) in children undergoing HSCT. | Combination group of ursodeoxycholic acid (UDCA), vitamin E, folinic acid, and titrated parenteral nutrition (IG); | 36 | Significant decrease in the incidence and severity of OM in IG. |
| Iyama et al. (2014) [ | 44 | RCT | To research whether supplementation with GFO (glutamine, fibre, oligosaccharides) decreases the severity of mucosal injury post-HSCT. | GFO group (IG); | 36 | Significant decrease in OM and higher survival rate in IG. |
| Takano et al. (2015) | 96-well plates | In vitro study | To investigate whether γ-tocotrienol (vitamin E) can enhance survival of oral human keratinocytes (RT7) against 5-FU-induced cell toxicity. | RT7 cells were treated with 5-FU and γ-tocotrienol. | - | In C there was a significant inhibition of ROS production induced by 5-FU. |
| Agha-Hosseini et al. (2021) | 59 | Triple-blind RCT | To evaluate whether a vitamin E, hyaluronic acid, and triamcinolone mouthwash was effective in the treatment of radiotherapy-induced OM grades 3–4. | Group with vitamin E + hyaluronic acid + triamcinolone rinses (IG); | 4 weeks | Significant reduction in the severity of RT-induced OM in IG over time. |
| Yeshurun et al. (2020) [ | 52 | Multicentre double blind RCT | To determine whether folinic acid (FA) reduces methotrexate (MTX)-induced toxicity in patients undergoing myeloablative conditioning (CM) for allogeneic haematopoietic cell transplantation, who have also received MTX prophylaxis for graft-versus-host disease. | TG with FA; | 17 (4.5–50) | There were no significant TG and PG differences in incidence, duration, or severity of OM. |
| Pattanakitsakul et al. (2020) | 30 | Preliminary and single-centre quasi-randomized trial | To examine the protective effect of vitamin A supplementation against mucosal damage of the gastrointestinal tract after CT in paediatric patients undergoing HSCT. As a secondary objective, to assess the occurrence of OM. | TG with single dose (200000 IU) of vitamin A; | 12 | There were no significant differences in incidence or severity of OM. |