| Literature DB >> 34816135 |
Jerry Tan1,2, Andrew Alexis3, Hilary Baldwin4,5, Stefan Beissert6, Vincenzo Bettoli7, James Del Rosso8,9, Brigitte Dréno10, Linda Stein Gold11, Julie Harper12, Charles Lynde13,14, Diane Thiboutot15, Jonathan Weiss16, Alison M Layton17,18.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Acne is a chronic disease with a varying presentation that requires long-term management. Despite this, the clinical guidelines for acne offer limited guidance to facilitate personalized or longitudinal management of patients.Entities:
Keywords: Delphi process; HCP, health care professional; PACE, Personalising Acne: Consensus of Experts; PACP, Personalised Acne Care Pathway; acne care pathway; acne guidelines; acne patient pathway; acne scarring; acne sequelae; acne vulgaris; consensus; longitudinal management; personalised acne care pathway; personalized care; shared decision-making; truncal acne
Year: 2021 PMID: 34816135 PMCID: PMC8593752 DOI: 10.1016/j.jdin.2021.09.006
Source DB: PubMed Journal: JAAD Int ISSN: 2666-3287
Fig 1The modified Delphi process used by Personalising Acne: Consensus of Experts panel. PACP, Personalised Acne Care Pathway.
Fig 2Overview of the PACP. Based on consensus recommendations and discussion from the Personalising Acne: Consensus of Experts panel, 7 key domains consisting of distinct consideration points to discuss with patients and “pivot points” (defined as a central point on which a management decision depends) were identified and incorporated into the PACP. AE, Adverse event; OTC, over-the-counter; PACP, Personalised Acne Care Pathway.
Determining patient profile—detailed considerations and discussion points
| Consider |
|---|
Acne location Facial vs truncal: assess independently Presence/risk of acne-induced scarring Family history Patients with a family history of acne may be at increased risk of sequelae or uncontrolled disease Skin phototype For example, acne-induced macular hyperpigmentation in patients with darker skin phototypes (Fitzpatrick scale IV-VI) Duration of acne Length of previously unsuccessful treatment Socioeconomic status Parent/child dynamic |
Indicates topics that were voted on via the Delphi process (Comprehensive list of statements available as Supplementary Material via Mendeley at https://data.mendeley.com/datasets/fy6mnvt7t7/1).
Topics to consider for discussion at each consultation
| Discuss |
|---|
Patient-reported satisfaction with acne treatment Administration/application technique Treatment goals and expectations: It is of paramount importance to discuss long-term treatment expectations with acne patients Treatment goals and expectations should be discussed with patients at the first consultation and revisited frequently Efficacy expectations (including timelines) Duration of treatment Adverse effects/tolerability Importance of adherence Daily skincare routine Risk of sequelae Changes to patient's general medication (eg, contraception) or diet Cost of treatment Access to treatment |
Indicates topics that were voted on via the Delphi process (Comprehensive list of statements available as Supplementary Material via Mendeley at https://data.mendeley.com/datasets/fy6mnvt7t7/1).
Treatment initiation/modification phase—gaps and detailed considerations, discussion points, and pivot points
| Gaps |
|---|
There is a need for high-quality evidence for when to escalate, switch, or de-escalate both acne initiation and maintenance treatment Common reasons for nonadherence to initiation and maintenance treatment include treatment intolerance (eg, local irritation) |
Indicates topics that were voted on via the Delphi process (Comprehensive list of statements available as Supplementary Material via Mendeley at https://data.mendeley.com/datasets/fy6mnvt7t7/1).
Maintenance treatment/modification phase—gaps and detailed considerations, discussion points, and pivot points
| Gaps |
|---|
There is a need for guidance on the most appropriate time to initiate maintenance therapy Clinical practice guidelines do not provide sufficient guidance on the choice of acne maintenance treatment Clinical practice guidelines do not provide sufficient guidance on when to escalate, switch, or de-escalate acne maintenance treatment There is a need for high-quality evidence for when to escalate, switch, or de-escalate both acne initiation and maintenance treatment Common reasons for nonadherence to initiation and maintenance treatment include treatment intolerance (eg, local irritation) |
Indicates topics that were voted on via the Delphi process (Comprehensive list of statements available as Supplementary Material via Mendeley at https://data.mendeley.com/datasets/fy6mnvt7t7/1).
Sequelae management—detailed considerations, discussion points, and pivot points
| Consider |
|---|
Risk factors for sequelae Impact on quality of life Skin phototype |
Indicates topics that were voted on via the Delphi process (Comprehensive list of statements available as Supplementary Material via Mendeley at https://data.mendeley.com/datasets/fy6mnvt7t7/1).
Additional factors to consider for patients with specific clinical presentations
| Patients with specific clinical presentations | Consider |
|---|---|
| Children aged <10 years | Lack of established skin care routine and potential hormonal conditions |
| Patients with darker skin phototypes (Fitzpatrick scale IV-VI) | Acne-induced macular hyperpigmentation |
Additional hyperpigmentation caused by irritation from topical medication | |
Potential inappropriate use of bleaching creams | |
Cultural cosmetic practices that may influence acne (eg, the use of oils in hair) | |
| Patients with hormonal conditions | Difficulty in counteracting the effects of exogenous androgens |
The need for interdisciplinary management with an endocrinologist | |
Requirements for laboratory examinations | |
| Heavy exercisers/athletes | Potential use of anabolic steroids or supplements |
| Patients at risk of psychiatric issues | The potential to be engaging in harsh cleaning routines or excoriation/manipulation of lesions |
Drug-induced acne | |
The need for interdisciplinary management with a psychiatrist or other allied health care professionals | |
| Women who are pregnant or breastfeeding (11/13) | |
| Transgender patients | |
| Patients with medication-induced acne | Patients with medication-induced acne (including those receiving cancer treatment, eg, epidermal growth factor receptor inhibitors) |
| Adult male patients | Steroid or supplement-induced acne |
| Adult female patients | Use of hormonal treatments (eg, contraception) |
Potential polycystic ovary syndrome | |
Use of make-up and other cosmetic skincare products | |
Pregnancy and lactation | |
| Specific populations of acne patients may benefit from an interdisciplinary approach to management (11/12) | |
Indicates topics that were voted on via the Delphi process (Comprehensive list of statements available as Supplementary Material via Mendeley at https://data.mendeley.com/datasets/fy6mnvt7t7/1).