| Literature DB >> 34791829 |
Kelsey Chomistek1, Cheryl Barnabe1,2,3, Syeda Farwa Naqvi1, Kathryn A Birnie1,4, Nicole Johnson1,5, Nadia Luca1,4,5, Paivi Miettunen1,5, Maria J Santana1,3,4,5, Jennifer Stinson6, Heinrike Schmeling1,2,4,5.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: The study objective was to test the acceptability of a self-management program (SMP) for adolescents with juvenile idiopathic arthritis (JIA) focused on disease information, self-management, and social support needs.Entities:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34791829 PMCID: PMC8843737 DOI: 10.1002/acr2.11373
Source DB: PubMed Journal: ACR Open Rheumatol ISSN: 2578-5745
Illustrative quotes of participant perceptions of SMP format and subsequent changes made
| Format | Sample Adolescent Comments | Sample Health Care Provider Comments | Subsequent Changes Made |
|---|---|---|---|
| Group‐based |
“I think it's smart to have the group‐based [SMP], because then you know that you're not alone and that if you have problems with how your pain is you can help other people and then they can learn from that and learn that maybe that's not the smartest thing to do.” (Patient 1, 14 years old) “Yeah, I agree with them about how it's good to be with someone and even if they are not helping you with it, it's good to at least know that someone else is going through the same thing.” (Patient 4, 13 years old) |
“I like the idea of the group based because then you have peer relation, you can mention your concerns and then others can say, ‘Oh, well this worked, or this didn't work.' So, I do like that there's a peer kind of participation with the group.” (HCP 2) “I think it is a great idea. …One thing I like is that it allows other kids to meet other people with similar diagnoses so they cannot be so alone.” (HCP 7) | No changes required. |
| Delivery method |
“I think for me it's hard to get to Calgary to attend it in person, so I would‐distance would be a barrier, if there was an option to do a video chat like this and be a part of the discussion, but not be there, that would be helpful.” (Patient 2, 14 years old) “I think it would be fine with either [in‐person or videoconference] because the main point is that you are still there. You are still communicating.” (Patient 6, 14 years old) |
“I think it might foster a better community within the kids if they are seeing each other in‐person and then they might be interested in building friendships or sharing contact information. That might be something that would be easier done in‐person than in telehealth. I think in‐person would allow more of an interaction outside the clinic session between the health care provider and the group of kids who are in that session.” (HCP 8) “Ideally in‐person I think is the best because communication is so much easier, but that doesn't always work because a lot of people are from out of town. In that case, like telehealth is a great way as well.” (HCP 9) | No changes required. |
Abbreviations: HCP, health care providers; SMP, self‐management program.
Delivery method was in‐person and video conference.
Illustrative quotes of participant perceptions of SMP structure and subsequent changes made
| Structure | Sample Adolescent Comments | Sample Health Care Provider Comments | Subsequent Changes Made |
|---|---|---|---|
| Age range of participants | Patient Group 1 and Group 2 all agreed that the age range of 12‐17 years was acceptable. | “I think you need to be really careful, like there lots of difference between what a 12‐year‐old needs and what a 17‐year‐old needs. So, thinking about the questions and maybe … break them up for two groups for part of it. Talking about the impact of pregnancy on methotrexate might be different … when you have a 12‐year‐old. So just recognizing that in that age group there's still different needs.” (HCP6) | Certain material may need to be tailored to the age of registered participants. |
| Facilitator selection |
“I would prefer it being delivered by the doctors, or like the physical therapists. Just because they might know a little bit more about arthritis, and they can tell us more ways to deal with it.” (Patient 3, 13 years old) “Yeah, I liked having a health care provider present; adds credibility.” (Patient 6, 14 years old) “Yeah, I liked having the HCP there just in case there was questions the presenter can't answer, the HCP can.” (Patient 5, 14 years old) “I also think there should also be some patients who present their stories or their opinions in order to have the health care team provide information and the patients delivers an experience or an example because they have the knowledge of what it's like to live it.” (Patient 2, 14 years old) |
“I think that's the best to have people from your health care team presenting. It should be coming from a health care provider to provide accurate information. … If you have people asking questions you want somebody from health care team to be answer those questions. … There's lots of positives with having the kids together and meeting other kids, but I feel it is really important for the group to still be facilitated by someone who has expertise and working in treating kids with arthritis just for that fact of misinformation … so the information doesn't get derailed by someone who has had a really bad experience.” (HCP6) “I think here a patient who's got the condition would be best to deliver… even somebody from the adult clinic that has graduated and has coped with different things.” (HCP1) |
Facilitated by interdisciplinary pediatric rheumatology health professionals. Young adult with JIA will be invited to share their lived experience during the sessions. |
| Group size |
“I think four or five people, because it's still small enough … people may not be scared that it's a big group, … but it's also big enough that people could … still have a sense of community.” (Patient 2, 14 years old) “Smaller group size, more welcoming when there is a smaller group of people.” (Patient 8, 14 years old) |
“Five to 10 participants so they feel included but not on their own.” (HCP5) “I think 4 to 5 [participants].” (HCP7) | Smaller group size (fewer than 10 adolescents). |
| Session components |
“Yeah, I would say four sessions is a lot. You could group a few together.” (Patient 5, 14 years old) “Yeah, you could do three and add 10 minutes to each one.” (Patient 7, 12 years old) Patient Group 1 and Group 2 agreed that sessions should be approximately 1.5 hours long and held on a weekday evening or weekend. |
“Even three sessions, depending on what you want to cover, would be enough. We do cover a lot of individualized information when they come to the clinic, and that time when they are being diagnosed is a quick turnaround before you want to get them educated.” (HCP7) Both health care provider groups agreed that sessions should be approximately 1.5 hours long and held on a weekday evening. | The program was adapted to be used as separate 1.5‐hour sessions based on individual need and patient availability. The recommended time to host the SMP is a weekday evening. |
Abbreviations: HCP, health care providers; JIA, juvenile idiopathic arthritis; SMP, self‐management program.
Illustrative quotes of participant perceptions of SMP design aesthetics and subsequent changes made
| Design Aesthetics | Sample Adolescent Comments | Sample Health Care Provider Comments | Subsequent Changes Made |
|---|---|---|---|
| Color |
“Maybe you could have more color make it more interesting, but the way it was easy to read and straightforward.” (Patient 1) “The colors were good. … There was a lot of blue so maybe adding a color or two?” (Patient 5, 14 years old) |
“Could include more colors.” (HCP3) “I have no complaints about the look. … Maybe a bit more color, a lot of the pictures had neutral colors, that would be my only comment.” (HCP3) | Added more color to PowerPoint slides. |
| Images |
“It looked all pretty good to me, I liked the pictures and my favourite one was probably where it showed the erosion on … the knee joint.” (Patient 3, 13 years old) “I liked the photos and stuff. It felt welcoming, and when you were talking about the splints and stuff that you would show photos about them.” (Patient 6, 14 years old) |
“I like the visuals for the comparison of what a normal joint looks like to an arthritic joint looks like, so actually what damages, so we can talk about … what that actually means to them. So, I do like the visuals.” (HCP2) “There was a slide that talked about the relaxation with tension. Can we have pictures for that?” (HCP3) | Added or replaced images. |
| Layout and slide order |
“Maybe a little less information, and a bit more straightforward?” (Patient 4, 13 years old) “I liked it all, there were a couple things where I might've changed just the order that the slides were in, but I think it was all good.” (Patient 2, 14 years old) “Yeah, I liked the layout of the slides. It was in a good order, which was nice.” (Patient 5, 14 years old) |
“I thought the slides overall were easy follow; nice presentation. As I mentioned before, some of the slides were quite wordy; a bit overwhelming.” (HCP7) “This might be a personal preference, it is nice that you started with a shared experience and that they can talk about it, but I think it would make more sense to talk first about coping with a JIA diagnosis then coping with the psychological impact and the pain impact because it just flows better to me that way.” (HCP8) | Reduced content on select slides and changed slide order. |
| Visual appeal | “I really liked the design of it. It's a bit technical, but there's a lot of photos and stuff which is nice.” (Patient 5, 14 years old) | “The look and layout were good and nice, clean, but I think the interactive part of it… doing that will really stick in people's brains.” (HCP3) | No changes required. |
Abbreviations: HCP, health care providers; SMP, self‐management program.
Illustrative quotes of participant perceptions of SMP content and subsequent changes made
| Content | Sample Adolescent Comments | Sample Health Care Provider Comments | Subsequent Changes Made |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quality and credibility: the extent to which participants viewed the information as accurate and trustworthy |
“I thought the information was accurate, and I like that there was multiple different ways you could cope with arthritis and manage your pain.” (Patient 2, 14 years old) “I thought it sounded really trustworthy and accurate.” (Patient 7, 12 years old) |
“The content was accurate.” (HCP4) “I think it was overall really good and accurate.” (HCP8) | No changes required. |
| Amount and detail of information |
“I think that it's a good amount of information for the amount of time that we have, and it definitely taught me about stuff that I can use later on.” (Patient 3, 13 years old) “It was nice, I liked the amount of information, it could help people who are newly diagnosed” (Patient 7, 12 years old) | “All the information to me was accurate. I just thought maybe you went into too much details when you were talking about cognitive behavioral therapy and different psychotherapy methods. … It is good information, I just don't know if the person relates to the topic, and if you're tight on time that area can be summarized or shortened just to say that there are different ways that the psychologist can help you with your pain and stress.” (HCP8) | Summarized and reduced the amount of information on certain PowerPoint slides. Removed detailed information on certain PowerPoint slides. |
| Completeness: the extent to which the SMP content contained all the desired information | “No, I don't think there's anything you really missed. I think most of it was covered.” (Patient 2, 14 years old) |
“I can't say there's a category of medication or lifestyle that you didn't cover. … You didn't really talk about acne with prednisone, which is important for the teenagers.” (HCP4) “When you are talking about post‐secondary, it might be a good time to bring up the UCBeyond Scholarship. … It is good for kids to be aware of that.” (HCP6) | Additional information (eg, disease‐specific content, scholarship resources) was added to the content. |
| Transferability of information between tertiary care sites | Not applicable. |
“We do a lot of purchased splints; we don't make lot of custom splinting. … You say occupational therapists make splints, but I would say recommend splints because we don't make a lot of them.” (HCP 7) “I don't know about any of our kids having IEPs. IEPs would not be common for our kids up here, so I don't know if that is a difference between sites. We do have school letters that are templated for each diagnosis.” (HCP6) | The PowerPoint can be adapted to address site‐specific needs as required. |
| Understand‐ability: eg, readability (reading level), use of plain language, and explanation of medical terminology |
“I think it was well laid out, it was very simple. It was like easy to read, and it wasn't overwhelming.” (Patient 1, 14 years old) Moderator: “Do you think it was easy to understand and read?” Response: “Yeah, it was great.” (Patient 8, 14 years old) |
“Use the word “If we are going to use certain terminology, they would have to be explained up front (eg, symptoms, inflammation).” (HCP5) | Defined medical terminology and/or replaced with lay terms. |
| Relevance: applicability of the content of the SMP to the needs of adolescents with JIA |
“Yeah, I think this information will because they gave a lot of examples from different things I could do to help me … in terms of like, if I'm in pain or if I'm tense, I could do these things to take my mind off the pain a little and help me relax.” (Patient 2, 14 years old) “Yeah, I think this information is helpful, maybe not for me as much as I've been diagnosed for a long time, but for newly diagnosed patients it would be really helpful.” (Patient 5, 14 years old) | “I think it's very practical knowledge. Like, people will probably consider drinking at some point. Or someone will be telling them all about, you know, this new diet. That's just everyday life stuff that is going to happen. So, I think it's very practical and important when they won't necessarily think to ask it at a rheumatology appointment. So, the fact that you have it in a session will be really helpful.” (HCP3) | No changes required. |
Abbreviations: HCP, health care providers; IEP, individualized education plan; JIA, juvenile idiopathic arthritis.