| Literature DB >> 34790905 |
Agustin Ibáñez1, Stefanie Danielle Pina-Escudero1, Katherine L Possin1, Yakeel T Quiroz1, Fernando Aguzzoli Peres1, Andrea Slachevsky1, Ana Luisa Sosa1, Sonia M D Brucki1, Bruce L Miller1.
Abstract
The prevalence of dementia in Latin America and the Caribbean is growing rapidly, increasing the burden placed on caregivers. Exacerbated by fragile health-care systems, unstable economies, and extensive inequalities, caregiver burden in this region is among the highest in the world. We reviewed the major challenges to caregiving in Latin America and the Caribbean, and we propose regional and coordinated actions to drive future change. Current challenges include the scarcity of formal long-term care, socioeconomic and social determinants of health disparities, gender-biased burdens, growing dementia prevalence, and the effect of the current COVID-19 pandemic on families affected by dementia. Firstly, we propose local and regional short-term strategic recommendations, including systematic identification of specific caregiver needs, testing of evidence-based local interventions, contextual adaptation of strategies to different settings and cultures, countering gender bias, strengthening community support, provision of basic technology, and better use of available information and communications technology. Additionally, we propose brain health diplomacy (ie, global actions aimed to overcome the systemic challenges to brain health by bridging disciplines and sectors) and convergence science as frameworks for long-term coordinated responses, integrating tools, knowledge, and strategies to expand access to digital technology and develop collaborative models of care. Addressing the vast inequalities in dementia caregiving across Latin America and the Caribbean requires innovative, evidence-based solutions coordinated with the strengthening of public policies.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34790905 PMCID: PMC8594860 DOI: 10.1016/s2666-7568(21)00031-3
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Lancet Healthy Longev ISSN: 2666-7568
Figure:From challenges to global responses in dementia caregiving
Timeline and workflow of current challenges, short-term strategies, and long-term responses for dementia caregiving.
Studies of challenges to dementia caregiving in LACs
| Study design or focus | Location | Main results in LACs | Take-home message | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Caruso et al (2017)[ | LTC services | LACs | About 1% of the population over the age of 60 years lives in nursing homes and formal LTC is not a priority (in comparison with other requirements of public policies in the region); informal LTC is delivered disproportionately by women | Better LTC policies and normative framework are necessary |
| González et al (2014)[ | Current initiatives for caregiving | LACs | Caregivers have poor access to medical care and social programmes; interventions target unpaid caregivers | There is insufficient capacity building (interventions that produce sustained change at individual to national levels) for caregiving; multicomponent interventions and an emphasis in gender needs and equality are necessary |
| Prince et al (2012)[ | Multicountry study of caregiver profiles | LACs, India, and China | LACs have the highest caregiving burden; paid caregivers are common only in Cuba, Venezuela, and urban areas of Peru | Cultural barriers and resource availability limit remunerated support to caregivers and respite care, increasing the burden on unpaid caregivers |
| Prince (2004)[ | Cross-sectional study | LACs, Asia, and Africa | 31% of caregivers are older than 65 years, 65% are unemployed, and 64% are depressed; single caregivers are often in charge of caring for multiple generations; caregivers spend a mean of 6 h per day with the patient | Caregivers face adverse social, economic, and mental health conditions |
| Elnasseh et al (2016)[ | Cross-sectional study | Argentina | Familial empathy determines resilience of caregivers and family communication increases the sense of coherence among caregivers | Personal strengths reduce caregiver stress and family interventions are required to support caregivers |
| Morlett Paredes et al (2017)[ | Epidemiological study | Argentina | Worse cognitive function in individuals with dementia is associated with higher caregiver burden, depression, and anxiety | Patients’ mood and caregiver burden affect quality of care of caregivers; mental health and cognitive interventions are required |
| Allegri et al (2007)[ | Cross-sectional study | Argentina | Caregiving burden increases with dementia severity and comorbidities (as reported by 88% of caregivers); 41% of caregivers left work or decreased their workload; indirect costs take 8 h per day of caregiver time | Dementia progression limits caregivers’ time for paid work; financial strain increases the burden |
| Rojas et al (2011)[ | Cross-sectional study | Argentina | Across Alzheimer’s, frontotemporal and vascular dementia subtypes, most caregivers are spouses; higher costs of caregiving are associated with depressive symptoms and functional impairment in caregivers | Frontotemporal dementia causes higher caregiving costs than does Alzheimer’s disease and vascular dementia |
| Sutter et al (2016)[ | Cross-sectional study | Argentina and Mexico | Personal strengths explained 32–50% of the variance in caregiver mental health in a sample of 127 primary family caregivers | Personal strengths are relevant to caregivers’ mental health; personal strengths and mental health approaches might partly compensate for the burden |
| Trapp et al (2015)[ | Cross-sectional study | Argentina and Mexico | Personal strengths, including resilience, optimism, and a sense of coherence were associated with better mental and physical HRQOL | Interventions based on personal strengths and sense of coherence are recommended |
| Ferretti et al (2018)[ | Cross-sectional study | Brazil | Caregivers had a mean of 9·43 (±5·68) years of education; substantial burden to private household expenditures due to dementia; dementia costs were influenced by the educational level of the caregiver | Low education increases dementia costs; education programmes can decrease financial burden |
| Gratão et al (2010)[ | Cross-sectional observational study | Brazil | 49 (54%) of 90 caregivers (of whom 80% were women) did not receive assistance (formal or informal); emotional burden was higher at the early and late stages of dementia | There is insufficient support for caregivers; the emotional burden on caregivers is higher in the early and late stages of dementia |
| Laks et al (2016)[ | Cross-sectional study | Brazil | Caregiving is associated with psychiatric symptoms, high rates of presenteeism-related impairment, and work impairment | There is a need to develop support programmes, including for health care of caregivers and prevention of chronic non-communicable diseases in caregivers |
| Lima-Silva et al (2015)[ | Cross-sectional study | Brazil | Caregivers of patients with behavioural variant frontotemporal dementia have more neuropsychiatric symptoms and distress than caregivers of patients with Alzheimer’s disease; dementia, anxiety, and depression positively correlate with burden in behavioural variant frontotemporal dementia caregivers | Caregiver distress is higher in families affected by behavioural variant frontotemporal dementia than by Alzheimer’s disease |
| Nogueira et al (2014)[ | Cross-sectional study | Brazil | 13% of male caregivers and 58% of female caregivers reported moderate to severe sexual dissatisfaction; impaired awareness and lower QOL of people with dementia is related to lower QOL of caregivers | QOL of caregiver not related to gender; lower QOL of people with dementia were related to the spouse’s QOL |
| Topic | Location | Caregiving characteristics in LACs | Take-home message | |
| Santos et al (2013)[ | Cross-sectional study | Brazil | Disease awareness in caregivers of people with dementia and coping strategies were influenced by familism, religiosity, and duty | Religious beliefs relate to the importance of caregiving; cultural differences in norms and beliefs should be considered for caregivers’ interventions in the region |
| Sousa et al (2016)[ | Cross-sectional study | Brazil and Spain | Caregivers’ sex, attendance of daycare centres, and neuropsychiatric symptoms had different effects in Brazilian and Spanish caregivers’ burden | Caregiver burden differed between Spain and Brazil; there are cross-cultural differences in caregiving |
| Hojman et al (2017)[ | Cross-sectional survey | Chile | The highest cost of productivity loss is in female informal caregivers from low socioeconomic backgrounds; indirect costs (74%) are higher than in high-income countries (40%) | Socioeconomic status is inversely related to dementia care costs; socioeconomic status-related costs determine caregivers’ burden |
| Slachevsky et al (2013)[ | Cross-sectional survey | Chile | Severe burdens were reported by 184 (63%) and psychiatric morbidity was found in 137 (47%) of 292 informal caregivers | Most caregivers are women and exhibit neuropsychiatric symptoms and functional impairment |
| Moreno et al (2015)[ | Cross-sectional study | Colombia | 102 informal caregivers presented poor mental health symptoms and reduced HRQOL | Culturally appropriate interventions should focus on preventing and treating depression and promoting life satisfaction of caregivers |
| Lloyd-Sherlock et al (2018)[ | Qualitative family case study | Mexico and Peru | Family caregivers do not usually have days off; unmarried daughters and wives are typical caregivers; wives might require permission from a husband to provide care to another family member with dementia | Cultural norms and values are gender-biased and increase the caregiver’s burden |
| Mayston et al (2017)[ | Household studies (LACs, Asia, Africa) | Mexico and Peru | Health-care systems prioritise acute illness management; external support is viewed as temporary and paying family members is preferred | Governmental support is insufficient, private costs are unsustainable, and long-term care capacity is unmet |
| Custodio et al (2015)[ | Retrospective cost study | Peru | People with low socioeconomic status cannot afford care in private settings; the total costs to families of frontotemporal dementia are higher than those of Alzheimer’s disease and vascular dementia due to caregiver demands | Reductions in family income increase caregivers’ burden; costs vary according to dementia subtype |
| Matus-López et al (2016)[ | LTC policy | Uruguay | Domiciliary LTC is underfunded; public and daycare LTC are very scant; there is no financial aid for private care | LTC facilities and services are scarce and non-privileged; unpaid caregivers do not have specific training |
HRQOL=health related quality of life. LACs=Latin American and Caribbean countries. LTC=long-term care. QOL=quality of life.