BACKGROUND: Finite element analysis (FEA) can be used to determine ascending thoracic aortic aneurysm (aTAA) wall stress as a potential biomechanical predictor of dissection. FEA is dependent upon zero-pressure three-dimensional geometry, patient-specific material properties, wall thickness, and hemodynamic loading conditions. Unfortunately, determining material properties on unoperated patients using non-invasive means is challenging; and we have previously demonstrated significant material property differences among aTAA patients. Our study objective was to determine the impact of patient-specific material properties on aTAA wall stress. Using FEA, we investigated if patient-specific wall stress could be reasonably predicted using population-averaged material properties, which would greatly simplify dissection prediction. METHODS: ATAA patients (n=15) with both computed tomography (CT) imaging and surgical aTAA specimens were recruited. Patient-specific aTAA CT geometries were meshed and pre-stress geometries determined as previously described. Patient-specific material properties were derived from biaxial stretch testing of aTAA tissue and incorporated into a fiber-enforced hyper-elastic model, while group-averaged material properties were estimated using mean values of each parameter. Population-averaged material properties were also calculated from literature and studied. Wall stress distribution and its magnitude were determined using LS-DYNA FEA software. Peak and averaged stresses and stress distributions were compared between patient-specific and both group- and population-averaged material property models. RESULTS: Patient-specific material properties had minimal influence on either peak or averaged wall stress compared to use of group- or population-averaged material properties. Stress distribution was also nearly superimposed among models with patient-specific vs. group- or population-averaged material properties and provided similar prediction of sites most prone to rupture. CONCLUSIONS: FEA using population-averaged material properties likely provides reliable stress prediction to indicate sites most prone to rupture. Population-averaged material properties may be reliably used in computational models to assess wall stress and significantly simplify risk prediction of aTAA dissection.
BACKGROUND: Finite element analysis (FEA) can be used to determine ascending thoracic aortic aneurysm (aTAA) wall stress as a potential biomechanical predictor of dissection. FEA is dependent upon zero-pressure three-dimensional geometry, patient-specific material properties, wall thickness, and hemodynamic loading conditions. Unfortunately, determining material properties on unoperated patients using non-invasive means is challenging; and we have previously demonstrated significant material property differences among aTAA patients. Our study objective was to determine the impact of patient-specific material properties on aTAA wall stress. Using FEA, we investigated if patient-specific wall stress could be reasonably predicted using population-averaged material properties, which would greatly simplify dissection prediction. METHODS: ATAA patients (n=15) with both computed tomography (CT) imaging and surgical aTAA specimens were recruited. Patient-specific aTAA CT geometries were meshed and pre-stress geometries determined as previously described. Patient-specific material properties were derived from biaxial stretch testing of aTAA tissue and incorporated into a fiber-enforced hyper-elastic model, while group-averaged material properties were estimated using mean values of each parameter. Population-averaged material properties were also calculated from literature and studied. Wall stress distribution and its magnitude were determined using LS-DYNA FEA software. Peak and averaged stresses and stress distributions were compared between patient-specific and both group- and population-averaged material property models. RESULTS: Patient-specific material properties had minimal influence on either peak or averaged wall stress compared to use of group- or population-averaged material properties. Stress distribution was also nearly superimposed among models with patient-specific vs. group- or population-averaged material properties and provided similar prediction of sites most prone to rupture. CONCLUSIONS: FEA using population-averaged material properties likely provides reliable stress prediction to indicate sites most prone to rupture. Population-averaged material properties may be reliably used in computational models to assess wall stress and significantly simplify risk prediction of aTAA dissection.
Entities:
Keywords:
Aortic failure; Ascending aortic disease; Finite element; material property
Authors: P G Hagan; C A Nienaber; E M Isselbacher; D Bruckman; D J Karavite; P L Russman; A Evangelista; R Fattori; T Suzuki; J K Oh; A G Moore; J F Malouf; L A Pape; C Gaca; U Sechtem; S Lenferink; H J Deutsch; H Diedrichs; J Marcos y Robles; A Llovet; D Gilon; S K Das; W F Armstrong; G M Deeb; K A Eagle Journal: JAMA Date: 2000-02-16 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: Andrew D Wisneski; Aart Mookhoek; Sam Chitsaz; Michael D Hope; Julius M Guccione; Liang Ge; Elaine E Tseng Journal: J Heart Valve Dis Date: 2014-11
Authors: Michael D Hope; Thomas A Hope; Alison K Meadows; Karen G Ordovas; Thomas H Urbania; Marcus T Alley; Charles B Higgins Journal: Radiology Date: 2010-04 Impact factor: 11.105
Authors: M Breeuwer; S de Putter; U Kose; L Speelman; K Visser; F Gerritsen; R Hoogeveen; R Krams; H van den Bosch; J Buth; T Gunther; B Wolters; E van Dam; F van de Vosse Journal: Med Biol Eng Comput Date: 2008-09-23 Impact factor: 2.602
Authors: A K Venkatasubramaniam; M J Fagan; T Mehta; K J Mylankal; B Ray; G Kuhan; I C Chetter; P T McCollum Journal: Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg Date: 2004-08 Impact factor: 7.069