| Literature DB >> 34783055 |
Saurabh Chandan1, Shahab R Khan2, Smit Deliwala3, Babu P Mohan4, Daryl Ramai4, Ojasvini C Chandan5, Antonio Facciorusso6.
Abstract
Healthcare workers (HCWs) remain on the front line of the battle against severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) and coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) infection and are among the highest groups at risk of infection during this raging pandemic. We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis to assess the incidence of postvaccination SARS-CoV-2 infection among vaccinated HCWs. We searched multiple databases from inception through August 2021 to identify studies that reported on the incidence of postvaccination SARS-CoV-2 infection among HCWs. Meta-analysis was performed to determine pooled proportions of COVID-19 infection in partially/fully vaccinated as well as unvaccinated individuals. Eighteen studies with 228 873 HCWs were included in the final analysis. The total number of partially vaccinated, fully vaccinated, and unvaccinated HCWs were 132 922, 155 673, and 17 505, respectively. Overall pooled proportion of COVID-19 infections among partially/fully vaccinated and unvaccinated HCWs was 2.1% (95% confidence interval [CI] 1.2-3.5). Among partially vaccinated, fully vaccinated and unvaccinated HCWs, pooled proportion of COVID-19 infections was 2.3% (CI 1.2-4.4), 1.3% (95% CI 0.6-2.9), and 10.1% (95% CI 4.5-19.5), respectively. Our analysis shows the risk of COVID-19 infection in both partially and fully vaccinated HCWs remains exceedingly low when compared to unvaccinated individuals. There remains an urgent need for all frontline HCWs to be vaccinated against SARS-CoV-2 infection.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; healthcare workers; vaccine
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34783055 PMCID: PMC8661690 DOI: 10.1002/jmv.27457
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Med Virol ISSN: 0146-6615 Impact factor: 20.693
Study characteristics and patient details
| Author | Design | Vaccine type | Total patients enrolled | Healthcare worker type | Total COVID‐19 positive patients | Age, years [ | Sex (male/female) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Physician | Nonphysician | |||||||
| Amit, 2021 | Retrospective, NR, Single‐Center, December 2020–January 2021, Israel | Pfizer‐BioNTech COVID‐19 vaccine (BNT162B2) | 4081 | NR | NR | 22 | 45.3 (9.85) [31–61] | 8/14 (positives) |
| Azamgarhi, 2021 | Retrospective, NR, Single‐Center, UK | Pfizer‐BioNTech COVID‐19 vaccine (BNT162B2) | 2235 | 231/2235 (Surgeons/medics) [PV 183, FV 48] | Administrative and clerical 629, Nursing 494, Allied health professionals 240, Clinical support staff 234, Portering and catering 225, Professional scientific and technical staff 182 | 49 | 584 (16–34), 1234 (35–54), 417 (>55) | 722/1513 (total) |
| Bouton, 2021 | Prospective, NR, Single‐Center, December 9, 2020 and February 23, 2021, USA | Pfizer‐BioNTech COVID‐19 Vaccine (BNT162B2) and Moderna Covid Vaccine (mRNA‐1273) | 10 590 | NR | NR | 425 | 40 (13) | 18/78 (positives) |
| Tang, 2021 | Prospective, NR, Single‐Center, December 17, 2020–March 20, 2021, USA | Pfizer‐BioNTech COVID‐19 vaccine (BNT162B2) | 5217 | NR | NR | 236 | – | 1038/2014 (vaccinated) |
| Cucunawangsiha, 2021 | Retrospective, NR, Single, Center, Indonesia | 2021, CoronaVac (Sinovac Biotech) | 1040 | NR | NR | 13 | 32.5 (5.9) | 5/8/2021 (positives) |
| Hall, 2021 | Prospective, NR, Multi‐center, December 8, 2020–February 5, 2021, USA | Pfizer‐BioNTech COVID‐19 vaccine (BNT162B2) and Oxford‐AstraZeneca COVID‐19 Vaccine (ChAdOx1 nCoV‐19 adenoviral [AZD1222]) | 23 324 | 2451 (Vaccinated 2332, Unvaccinated 189) | Administrative or executive 3600, Nursing or health‐care assistant 9826, Midwife 566, Specialist staff 1418, Estates, porters, or security 222, Pharmacist 351, Health‐care scientist 820, Others 4000 | 80 | 46.1 (36–54.1) | 3632/19 692 (total) |
| Issac, 2021 | Prospective, NR, Single‐Center, January 27, 2021–July 15, 2021, India | ChAdOx1 nCoV‐19 | 324 | 18/324 (Vaccinated 18, Unvaccinated 0) | Nurses 165, Pharmacist 17, Physiotherapist 4, Dietician 1, Administration 8, Accounts & Finance 24, Medical records 4, Lab & Diagnostics 50, Housekeeping 23, Biomedical Engineering 1, Maintenance 4, Quality department 4, Ambulance driver 1 | 41 | 34.09 (9.43) | 52/272 (vaccinated) |
| Jacobson, 2021 | Retrospective, December 18, 2020–April 02, 2021, USA | Pfizer‐BioNTech COVID‐19 Vaccine (BNT162B2) and Moderna Covid Vaccine (mRNA‐1273) | 30 000 | NR | NR | 189 | 40.8 [11.2] [Mean], 38 (32–48) [Median] | 64/125 (positive) |
| Maroof, 2021 | Prospective, Feburay 2021–June 2021, Multicenter, Pakistan | Sino‐pharm Vaccine | 39 512 | NR | NR | 124 | 38.8 [11] | 86/38 (positives) |
| Mathema, 2021 | Retrospective, December 2020–April 2021, Multicenter, USA | Pfizer‐BioNTech COVID‐19 Vaccine (BNT162B2) and Moderna Covid Vaccine (mRNA‐1273) | 37 500 | NR | NR | 138 | 45 (19–77) [Median] [ | 31/90 [N = 121] (positives) |
| North, 2021 | Prospective, cohort, December 30, 2020–April 2, 2021, Multicenter, USA | Pfizer‐BioNTech COVID‐19 Vaccine (BNT162B2) and Moderna Covid Vaccine (mRNA‐1273) | 2247 | 873/2247 (Physician/Nurse practitioner/Physician assistant) | Administration 104, Environmental/Food services 10, Nursing 558, Patient Care Services (PT, OT, SLP, etc.) 217, Research‐related activities 357, Others 125 | 19 | 37 (30–50) | 476/1760 (total) |
| Pandurangaiah, 2021 | Retrospective, Feburary 2021–May 07, 2021, Single‐center, India | Covishield/Covaxin | 182 | 32/182 (Doctors) | 71/182 (Nurses), 37/182 (Para‐medical staff), 42/182 (Other) | 6 | – | 47/135 (total) |
| Sabnis, 2021 | Prospective, First dose of COVID‐19 vaccine till June 10, 2021, Single‐center, India | Covishield (SII‐ChAdOx1 nCoV‐19) | 461 | 51/461 (Doctors) | 410/461 (Others) | 86 | 34.18 (22–77) | NR |
| Vaishya, 2021 | Retrospective, observational, cohort, January 16, 2021–June 15 2021, Multicenter, India | AstraZeneca Covid Vaccine (ChAdOx1‐S/nCoV‐19 [recombinant]) (Covishield 26,375, Covaxin 1,967) | 28 342 | 2256/28,342 (Clinical) | 7760/28 342 (Nursing), 5172/28 342 (Administration), 3000/28 342 (Para‐medical staff) | 1,438 | 33.04 (18–80) | 14 980/13 362 (total) |
| Keehner, 2021 | Retrospective, December 16, 2020–February 9, 2021, Multicenter, USA | Pfizer‐BioNTech COVID‐19 Vaccine (BNT162B2) and Moderna Covid Vaccine (mRNA‐1273) | 36 659 | NR | NR | 379 | – | – |
| Tyagi, 2021 | Retrospective, January 16, 2021–till date, Single‐center, India | 85 (Covishield), 28 (Covaxin) 113 (vaccinated) | 123 | NR | NR | 19 | 42 (22–70) | 75/48 (total) |
| Sharma, 2021 | Cross‐sectional study (May 31, 2021–June 6, 2021), January 2021–March 2021 (Subjects Data), Single‐center, India | 158 (Covishield), 168 (Covaxin) | 326 | 259/326 (Medical doctors and Interns) | 52/326 (Frontline health workers), 12/326 (Lab technicians), 3/326 (Nurses) | 65 | 29.1 (85.9) | 212/114 |
| Angel, 2021 | Single‐center, retrospective cohort study, December 20, 2020, and February 25, 2021, Israel | Pfizer‐BioNTech BNT162b2 | 6710 | 1231/5953 (Vaccinated), 44/757 (Unvaccinated) | 2421/5953 (Vaccinated), 324/757 (Unvaccinated) [Administration], 1438/5953 (Vaccinated), 263/757 (Unvaccinated) [Nursing], 721/5953 (Vaccinated), 98/757 (Unvaccinated) [Other health professions], 142/5953 (Vaccinated), 28/757 (Unvaccinated) [Missing data] | 270 | 44.3 [12.5] | 2245/4465 |
Study details
| Author | Patients | COVID‐19 positive | COVID + HCW type | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Partial vaccination | Full vaccination | Unvaccinated | Partial vaccination | Full vaccination | Unvaccinated | Physician | Nonphysician | |
| Amit, 2021 | 4081 | – | – | 22/4081 | – | – | 6/22 | Nurse 5/22, Secretary 3/22, Laundry handler 1/22, Food handler 1/22, Technologist 1/22, Psychologist 1/22, Scientist 1/22, Phlebotomist 1/22, Cleaning services 1/22, Logistics 1/22 |
| Azamgarhi, 2021 | 1409 | – | 826 | 23/1409 | – | 26/826 | NR | NR |
| Bouton, 2021 | 7109 | 5913 | 3481 | 96/7109 | 17/5913 | 329/3481 | 13/96 | Health care support worker 9/96, Nurse 31/96, Nurse Practitioner/Physician Assistant 5/96, Administrative Staff 3/96, Environmental Services 2/96, Medical technician 6/96, OT, PT or speech therapist 1/96, Pharmacy worker 5/96, Respiratory Therapist 2/96, Others 17/96 |
| Tang, 2021 | 3052 | 2776 | 2165 | 41/3052 | 10/2776 | 185/2165 | NR | NR |
| Cucunawangsiha, 2021 | – | 1040 | – | – | 13/1040 | – | NR | Nurse 5/13, Admission clerk 2/13, Housekeeper 1/13, Lab staff 1/13, Finance staff 1/13, Hospital security 1/13, ICU staff 1/13, Medical treatment center staff 1/13 |
| Hall, 2021 | 20 641 | 1607 | 2683 | 71/20641 | 9/1607 | 977/2683 | NR | NR |
| Issac, 2021 | – | 243 | 80 | – | 16/243 | 35/80 | 1/41 | Nurses 34/41, Pharmacist 2/41, Lab & Diagnostics 9/41, Housekeeping 2/41, Physiotherapy 1/41, Medical records 1/41, Maintenance 1/41 |
| Jacobson, 2021 | 23 090 | 22 271 | 6910 | 150/23090 | 39/22 271 | 471/6910 | 22/189 (Physician/physician assistant/nurse practitioner) | Nursing 42/189, Medical Assistant 17/189, Respiratory therapy/physical therapy/occupational therapy 5/189, Other 76/189, Housekeeping/food services 22/189 |
| Maroof, 2021 | – | 39 512 | – | – | 124/39 512 | – | 31/124 (Doctors) | 28/124 (Nurses), 20/124 (Paramedics), 45/124 (Support Staff) |
| Mathema, 2021 | 23 697 | 22 458 | – | 105/23697 | 33/22 458 | – | NR | NR |
| North, 2021 | 2036 | 1923 | 593 | 10/2036 | 3/1923 | 6/593 | 10/19 (Physician/Nurse practitioner/Physician assistant) | 2/19 (Admin), 3/19 (Research), 1/19 (Food services), 2/19 (Nursing), 1/19 (Patient care services) |
| Pandurangaiah, 2021 | 18 | 164 | – | 1/18 | 5/164 | – | NR | NR |
| Sabnis, 2021 | – | 461 | – | – | 86/461 | – | 19/86 (Doctors) | 27/86 (Nurses/Technicians), 40/86 (Para‐medical staff) |
| Vaishya, 2021 | 5125 | 23 217 | – | 269/5125 (within 2 weeks 46, after 2 weeks 223) | 1169/23 217 (within 2 weeks 69, after 2 weeks 1100) | – | 153/1438 (Clinical) | 448/1438 (Nursing), 264/1438 (Administration), 140/1438 (Para‐medical) |
| Keehner, 2021 | 36 659 | 28 184 | – | 342/36 659 | 37/28 184 | – | NR | NR |
| Tyagi, 2021 | 6 | 107 | 10 | 1/6 | 18/107 | – | NR | NR |
| Sharma, 2021 | 46 | 280 | – | 12/46 | 53/280 | – | 55/65 | 10/65 |
| Angel, 2021 | 5953 | 5517 | 757 | 127/5761 | 27/5372 | 116/757 | NR | NR |
PV: Partial vaccination, FV: Full vaccination, HCW: Healthcare workers, NR: Not reported
Figure 1Forest plot, pooled proportion of coronavirus disease 2019 infections in fully, partially, and unvaccinated healthcare workers
Figure 2Forest plot, pooled proportion of coronavirus disease 2019 infections in partially vaccinated healthcare workers
Figure 3Forest plot, pooled proportion of coronavirus disease 2019 infections in fully vaccinated healthcare workers