| Literature DB >> 34773665 |
Jake Linardon1,2, Mariel Messer1, Rachel F Rodgers3,4,5, Matthew Fuller-Tyszkiewicz1,2.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Research investigating the effects of COVID-19 on eating disorders is growing rapidly. A comprehensive evaluation of this literature is needed to identify key findings and evidence gaps to better inform policy decisions related to the management of eating disorders during and after this crisis. We conducted a systematic scoping review synthesizing and appraising this literature.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; carers; eating disorders; machine learning; mental health; open science; scoping review; systematic review; telehealth; treatment
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34773665 PMCID: PMC8646470 DOI: 10.1002/eat.23640
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Eat Disord ISSN: 0276-3478 Impact factor: 5.791
FIGURE 1Flow‐chart of literature search
Characteristics and findings summary of studies that sampled a non‐clinical cohort (individuals without an eating disorder)
| Study | Design | Country | Data collection | Sample description | Brief summary of relevant findings | Additional comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| (Aldhuwayhi et al., | Cross | Saudi Arab | Unclear | 296 adult dentists (30% women). Race/ethnicity N/R |
64% self‐reported engaging in binge eating as a method to cope with stress due to the pandemic. |
Only analyzed complete cases. Unclear how binge eating was assessed. |
| (Alessi et al., | Cross | Braz | Unclear |
120 adults with type 1/2 diabetes (56% women). 86% white |
76% scored above the clinical cut‐off on the EAT‐26, signaling a possible ED. |
Higher rates of probable EDs than other studies potentially due to target population. |
| (Athanasiadis et al., | Cross | US | Apr‐20 |
208 adult bariatric surgery patients (86% female). 86% white; 12% black; 1% Latino/Hispanic |
48% self‐reported an increase loss of control eating and 20% self‐reported an increase in binge eating during the pandemic. |
Items adapted from the eating loss of control scale. 29% survey completion rate was observed from emails sent to existing registry. |
| (Baceviciene & Jankauskiene, | Long (retro) | US |
pre‐pandemic Oct‐19 During pandemic Feb‐21 | 230 university students (79% female). Race/ethnicity N/R |
No significant changes in ED psychopathology (EDE‐Q global scores) were observed from before to during the pandemic/lockdown. |
Complete cases analyzed (12% total sample). No differences in BMI, disordered eating, or lifestyle factors were observed between completers and drop‐outs. |
| (Breiner, Miller, & Hormes, | Cross | US | Apr‐May20 | 158 community‐based adults (91% women). 90% white; 5% Hispanic; 6% Asian; 0.6% American Indian; 0.6% native American |
Based on retrospective recall, no changes in eating disorder psychopathology (EDE‐Q), binge eating, and purging were observed from before to during the pandemic. Decreases in overeating and loss of control eating were observed. |
Participants answered the EDE‐Q twice at the same time, once in relation to before the pandemic and the second in relation to during the pandemic. Recruitment was solely targeted at social media and online forums. |
| (Buckley, Hall, Lassemillante, & Belski, | Cross | Aus | Apr‐May‐20 | 204 current/former athletes (85% women). Race/ethnicity N/R |
21% scored above the clinical cut‐off on the EAT, signaling a possible ED. ~35% reported that their “relationship with food” and body image had worsened since the pandemic |
Complete cases analyzed. Recruitment targeted at social media and online forums. |
| (Calugi et al., | Long (retro) | Italy | June‐Oct‐20 |
206 adults (70% female) who completed CBT‐OB prior to the pandemic & matched control sample (70% female) who completed CBT‐OB prior to pandemic (70% women); race/ethnicity N/R |
No differences in binge eating between the two cohorts (one exposed to the pandemic and another who was not) at a follow‐up. |
Cohorts were matched on gender, age, and BMI. Follow‐up assessment was conducted by telephone, 6 months after completion of CBT. Follow‐up retention rate was ~55%, though no differences in clinical or demographic variables were observed between completers and dropouts. |
| (Cecchetto, Aiello, Gentili, Ionta, & Osimo, | Cross | Italy | May‐20 | 365 community‐based adults (73% female). Race/ethnicity N/R |
Significantly more individuals screened positive for binge‐eating disorder during (3%) the first lockdown compared to the second lockdown (2.46%). |
Participants answered the BED‐7 twice at the same time, once in relation to the first lockdown and the second in relation to the next lockdown. Recruitment was targeted at social media and online forums. Only complete cases were analyzed. |
| (Chan & Chiu, | Cross | China | Apr‐20 | 316 community‐based adults (71% female). Race/ethnicity N/R |
26% screened positive for a probable ED based on the SCOFF. |
Convenience, snowballing and social media advertisements were used for recruitment. Unclear how survey dropouts were handled. |
| (Christensen et al., | Cross | US |
Prelock Dec‐Mar‐20 During lock Apr‐20 |
Cohort 1 of 222 university students (73% women). Cohort 2 of 357 university students (78% women); 84% white; 3% black; 1% American Indian; 5% Asian; 5% mixed race |
No significant difference in prevalence of probable ED (based on EDDS) was observed between the cohort exposed (41.5%) or not exposed (37%) to the lockdown. Higher food insecurity scores were associated with greater likelihood of ED among the total sample. |
Participants recruited through emails sent to university students, stratified by race, gender, and ethnicity. Complete‐cases were analyzed. The two cohorts differed on age, but not gender, race, ethnicity, BMI. |
| (Coimbra, Paixão, & Ferreira, | Cross | Port | April – May‐20 | 508 community‐based adult women. Race/ethnicity N/R |
During the lockdown, ~25% reported increases in strict dietary rules, 30–60% reported increases in food restriction, and ~ 30% reported stricter exercise rules. Estimates differed as a function of BMI class. |
Recruitment strategy was unclear. Authors reported that there was no missing data. Items were self‐created. |
| (Colleluori, Goria, Zillanti, Marucci, & Dalla Ragione, | Cross | Italy | March – May‐20 | 76 healthcare providers who treated patients with ED during pandemic. Gender/ethnicity N/R |
Healthcare providers reported that >30% and > 40% of their patients had respectively increased their binge eating and compensatory behavior during lockdown, while >80% had reported a worsening of mood and anxiety. Providers reported that 15–25% of their patients increased the number of visitors for care due to the lockdown, and > 5% of new patients sought help because of the lockdown. |
Survey was emailed nationwide to all potential healthcare providers specializing in ED. Data were based purely on retrospective self‐report from an author‐created questionnaire. Complete cases analyzed. |
| (Czepczor‐Bernat, Swami, Modrzejewska, & Modrzejewska, | Cross | Pol | Dec20‐Feb‐21 |
671 community‐based adult women; 99% white. |
Higher COVID‐19 stress and anxiety, coupled with a higher BMI were associated with higher symptom severity (e.g., ., EDI subscales). |
Participants recruited via flyers distributed throughout the university and workplaces. Complete cases analyzed COVID‐19 stress and anxiety were assessed through a self‐created survey. |
| (De Pasquale et al., | Cross | Italy | Mar‐20‐Feb‐21 | 469 university students (53% women). Race/ethnicity N/R |
Fear of COVID‐19 was significantly correlated with higher eating disorder psychopathology (i.e., EDI bulimia, drive for thinness, and binge eating severity), but not significantly correlated with body dissatisfaction. |
No mention of how drop‐outs or missing data were handled. Unclear how many students were invited to complete the survey. |
| (Flaudias et al., | Cross | Fran | Mar‐20 | 5,738 university students (74% women). Race/ethnicity N/R |
38% scored above the clinical cut‐off for the SCOFF, indicating a probable ED. Higher COVID‐19 stress was associated with higher likelihood of binge eating and dietary restriction over the past 7 days. |
7.9% response rate from all emails sent to potential participants. COVID‐19 stress was assessed via self‐created items. |
| (Guo et al., | Long (prosp) | China | Mar‐20 | 254 carers of people with ED (84% female) and 254 carers of healthy controls (84% female); race/ethnicity N/R |
Carers of people with ED reported higher depression, anxiety and stress scores, and lower perceived social support. A brief psychoeducational intervention for carers did not lead to significant improvements in depression and anxiety. |
Carers and healthy controls were matched on key demographic variables. Attrition was 60% for the post‐test assessment. |
| (Haddad et al., | Cross | Leb | Apr‐20 |
Community‐based adults ( Race/ethnicity = N/A |
Financial difficulties, lack of contact with friends, a sense of insecurity, difficulty buying desired food, fear of COVID‐19, and more physical exercise were associated with ED psychopathology (EDE‐Q subscales). |
Recruitment geared toward social media advertisements and snowballing techniques. Unclear how drop‐outs or missing data were handled. Indices of COVID‐19 concerns were based on earlier work. |
| (Jordan et al., | Cross | US | Jul‐Sept‐20 |
140 community‐based adult carers (88% female) 84% white; other races/ethnicities N/R |
Stress and concern about weight gain during, but not before, COVID‐19 were associated with ED psychopathology (EDE‐Q global). |
Participants were assessed twice at the same time, once in relation to before the pandemic and the second in relation to during the pandemic. Recruitment methods were geared toward social media advertisements and snowballing techniques. Concern with weight gain assessed by single items created for the purpose of this study. |
| (Keel et al., | Long (pros) | US |
T1 Jan‐20 T2 Apr‐20 |
90 university students (87% female) 78% White; 22% Latino; 12% Black; 4% Asian; 1% American Indian |
~60% reported that their concerns with weight, shape and eating had increased since the COVID‐19 pandemic. |
No differences on study variables between completers and dropouts. Findings relevant for this review based on assessments at T2 (retrospective recall). Authors developed their own tool to assess perceived concerns due to COVID‐19. |
| (Kim et al., | Cross | US |
Pre‐pandemic Oct‐19 During pandemic May‐20 |
Pre‐pandemic cohort 1 During pandemic cohort 2 = 4,970 university students (68% women); 74% white; 5% black 14%; Asian; 1% American Indian; 1% native Hawaiian; 4% mixed race |
Compared to a pre‐pandemic cohort, higher rates of BN/BED were observed for a cohort exposed to the pandemic (10.7% vs. 14.4%); no cohort differences in anorexia nervosa rates were observed. |
Recruitment was targeted at different universities in geographically diverse states. Differences in sex, gender, race, and sexual orientation were observed between the two cohorts. Missing data were handled using pairwise deletion. |
| (Koenig et al., | Cross | Germ |
Pre‐pandemic Nov18‐Mar20 During pandemic mar‐Aug20 |
Cohort 1 = 324 adolescents (69% female). Cohort 2 = 324 matched adolescents (69% female). Race/ethnicity N/R |
The two cohorts (pre vs. during pandemic) did not differ on ED psychopathology (EDE‐Q) |
Cohorts matched on gender, age, and school type. A convenience sub‐sample was used from a larger, representative sample of German adolescents. |
| (Kohls, Baldofski, Moeller, Klemm, & Rummel‐Kluge, | Cross | Germ | Jul‐Aug‐20 | 3,382 university students (70% women). Race/ethnicity N/R |
3.8% screened positive for an ED based on the SEED. |
Authors reported no significant differences in demographic characteristics between survey completers and drop‐outs. |
| (Martínez‐de‐Quel, Suárez‐Iglesias, López‐Flores, & Pérez, | Long (pros) | Spain |
T1 Mar‐20 T2 mar‐Apr‐20 | 161 community‐based adults (37% female). Race/ethnicity N/R |
No change in ED psychopathology (EAT‐26 total scores) was observed from T1 to T2. |
Convenience sample of mostly university students. Both time‐points were during the pandemic period, spaced 5 days apart. Time 2 drop‐outs did not differ to completers on physical activity, eating disorder risk, sleep problems, weight, and wellbeing (unclear if demographics differed). |
| (Meda et al., | Long (pros) | Italy |
Prelockdown Oct‐19 During lockdown Apr‐20 After lockdown Jun‐20 | 358 university students (79% women). Race/ethnicity N/R |
ED symptom severity (EDI scores) did not change from before, during, and after the lockdown. Post‐hoc, exploratory analyses show that students with a prior ED experienced worsening of symptoms during the lockdown. |
Students recruited at one university site. Unclear the extent of missing data, attrition biases, and how missing data were handled. |
| (Muzi, Sansò, & Pace, | Cross | Italy |
Prelockdown Jan‐19/20 During lockdown mar‐May‐20 |
During pandemic cohort of adolescents (61% female). Race/ethnicity N/R |
Binge eating severity scores did not differ between the two cohorts of participants. Significantly differ on binge eating severity (BES) scores. |
No cohort differences in age and gender, although other potential differences were not reported. Recruitment was geared toward one university. |
| (Phillipou et al., | Cross | Aus | Apr‐20 | 5,469 community‐based adults (80% women; 184 self‐reporting current ED). Race/ethnicity N/R |
3% of the total sample indicated that they had an eating disorder. Of self‐reported ED cases, 47% reported more exercise, 35% more frequent binge eating, 19% reported more purging, 64% reported more dietary restriction, and between 16–27% reported severe mental health problems due to the pandemic. For the total sample, 27% reported greater dietary restriction, 35% reported increased binge eating, and 35% reported more exercise behavior due to the pandemic. |
Respondents were recruited through social media and other advertisements, participant registries and non‐discriminative snowball methods. Assessments were based on retrospective recall and self‐created items relevant to COVID‐19. Complete‐cases used for analyses (68% retention rate); unclear whether drop‐outs differed to completers. |
| (Quittkat et al., | Cross | Germ | Apr‐May20 | 2,233 community‐based adults (80% women); race/ethnicity N/R |
2.7% scored above the clinical cut‐off for the EDE‐Q, indicating a possible ED. Of these, 45% reported slight worsening of mental health during the pandemic, whereas 17% reported considerable worsening. |
Recruitment included university press releases and e‐mail lists, flyer, social media, institutions for education in psychotherapy, outpatient departments, mental hospitals, psychotherapist associations, self‐help groups and assisted living departments. Complete cases were used for analyses (73% of the sample who began the survey); unclear whether dropouts differed to completers. Assessments were based on retrospective recall and self‐created items relevant to COVID‐19. |
| (Racine, Miller, Mehak, & Trolio, | Cross | Can | Apr‐Jun‐20 | 877 community‐based adults (74% women); 80% white; 6% Hispanic; 5.7% Chinese; 3.1% south Asian; 2.4% Arab; 2.2% black; 1.6% southeast Asian; 1.5% west Asian; 0.9% Filipino; 0.8% indigenous; 0.6% Japanese; 0.1% native Hawaiian |
25.8% scored above the clinical cut off on the EDE‐QS, signaling a possible ED. COVID‐19 stress did not moderate relationships between putative risk/protective factors on ED psychopathology. |
Recruitment included social media and online forum advertisements, snowballing, mental health organizations, and organizations for underrepresented minorities. Complete cases were analyzed (65% retention rate); unclear whether drop‐outs differed to completers. COVID‐19 stress was assessed via self‐created items. |
| (Ramalho et al., | Cross | Port | May‐20 | 254 community‐based adult participants (83% women). Race/ethnicity N/R |
During lockdown, 53% self‐reported skipping meals, 81% grazing and overeating, 47% loss of control eating, and 39% binge eating. |
Recruitment aimed at social media and academic mailing lists. Complete cases were analyzed (69% retention rate), although it was unclear whether drop‐outs differed to completers. Single items used to retrospectively assess the prevalence of ED behaviors in the past month, during the lockdown. |
| (Robertson et al., | Cross | UK | May‐Jun‐20 | 264 community‐based adults (78% women). Race/ethnicity N/R |
53% agreed/strongly agreed that they had difficulty controlling their eating during lockdown, 60% agreed/strongly agreed that they are more preoccupied with food, 48% agreed/strongly agreed that they have experienced more body concerns. Ratings were higher in self‐reported ED cases. |
Social media recruitment. Complete cases were analyzed (65% retention rate), although it was unclear whether drop‐outs differed to completers. Assessments were based on retrospective recall and self‐created items relevant to COVID‐19. |
| (Scharmer et al., | Cross | US | Mar‐Apr‐20 | 295 university students (65% women). Race/ethnicity N/R |
Fear of virus and intolerance of COVID‐19 uncertainty scores were positively associated with ED psychopathology (EDE‐Q global scores), but not compulsive exercise. The relationships between COVID‐19 anxiety and criterion variables were stronger for people with lower intolerance of uncertainty scores. |
Unclear how missing data were handled. Some survey instruments were modified to make it relevant to the COVID‐19 pandemic. |
| (Simone et al., | Cross | US | Apr‐May‐20 |
720 community‐based adolescents/adults (62% female/women); 29% white; 24% Asian; 16% Latino/Hispanic; 18% black/African American; 11% mixed |
8% endorsed extreme weight control behaviors, 53% endorsed less extreme weight control behaviors, 14% endorsed binge eating during the pandemic period. Significant correlates of weight control behaviors were low stress management, financial difficulties, food insecurity and depressive symptoms. |
Presents on a sub‐sample drawn from a large‐scale, population‐based study (project EAT). 46% survey completion rate. Some items were adapted to make it specific to the pandemic. |
| (Thompson & Bardone‐Cone, | Cross | US | Apr‐20 |
Postpartum adult women ( Control women ( 83% white; 8% Latina. |
8% scored above the clinical cut‐off criteria for the EAT, indicating a possible ED. For the total sample, no significant relationship between COVID‐19 distress and eating disorder psychopathology was observed. |
Recruitment included local health centers, social media advertisements, and emails to list servers. Complete cases were analyzed (61% retention rate). COVID‐19 distress was assessed using author‐created items. |
| (Troncone et al., | Cross | Italy | Apr‐20 |
138 youth with type 1 diabetes (52%) and 276 matched controls (59% female). Race/ethnicity N/R |
9% of participants with type 1 diabetes and 13% of control participants scored above the cut‐off for the EAT, indicating a possible ED. |
Complete cases analyzed. |
| (Trott, Johnstone, Pardhan, Barnett, & Smith, | Long (retro) | UK |
Pre‐pandemic Apr‐Jul‐19 During pandemic Aug‐Sept‐20 | 319 adults (84% women); race/ethnicity N/R |
No difference in rates of probable ED classification (based on EAT‐26) from pre to post‐lockdown (30% vs. 28%). Levels of ED psychopathology increased significantly from pre to post lockdown. |
No description of the recruitment method. No description of attrition rates or potential attrition biases. |
| (Wang et al., | Cross | China | May‐Jul‐20 | 12,186 children (48% girls); race/ethnicity N/R |
31% self‐reported a possible eating disorder during the pandemic period. |
Participants were recruited from five geographical regions of China, representative of the broader Chinese child population. The authors excluded 122 participants from an entire city as the target sample size was not achieved. Complete cases appeared to be analyzed; little detail on dropout. |
| (Zhang et al., | Cross | China | Mar‐Apr‐20 | 315 carers for offspring with ED (79% women) and 315 carers for healthy offspring (80% women). Race/ethnicity N/R |
Carers of offspring with ED reported significantly higher depression, anxiety, and stress, and significantly lower perceived social support than carers for healthy controls. Perceived stress, social support, family conflicts were unique correlates of distress. |
Appears to be overlap in the sample in the Guo et al. ( Two groups were matched using propensity score matching methods. |
| (Zhou & Wade, | Long (retro) | Aus |
Pre‐pandemic mar‐Sep‐19 During pandemic Apr‐20 |
Pre‐pandemic During pandemic |
92% reported engaging in disordered eating in the past month (71% fasting; 71% driven exercise; 65% binge eating; 13% self‐induced vomiting; 7% laxative misuse). The percentage who reported disordered eating behaviors increased during COVID‐19: Fasting (from 61% to 78% of participants), binge‐eating (61% to 68%), vomiting (7% to 17%), and driven exercise (66% to 75%). Significantly higher weight concerns (WCS), eating disorder psychopathology (EDE‐Q global), and negative affect were observed for the pandemic cohort. Exposure to the pandemic did not interact with treatment condition and pre‐post assessment to influence outcomes. |
Little description of recruitment strategy. No matching of pre and during COVID‐19 samples were applied, though groups did not differ on age. |
Abbreviations: Aus, Australia; Braz, Brazil; Can, Canada; CBT‐OB, cognitive‐behavior therapy for obesity; Cross, cross‐sectional; EAT, Eating Attitudes Test; ED, eating disorders; EDE‐Q, Eating Disorder Examination Questionnaire; EDI, Eating Disorders Inventory; Fran, France; Germ, Germany; Leb, Lebanon; long (pros), longitudinal prospective design; long (retro), longitudinal retrospective design; N/R, not reported or unclear; Port, Portugal; SEED, Short Evaluation of Eating Disorders; UK, United Kingdom; US, United States; WCS, Weight Concern Scale.
Characteristics and findings summary of studies that sampled a clinical cohort
| Study | Design | Country | Date | Sample | Brief summary of relevant findings | Additional comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| (Akgül et al., | Cross | Turk | May–Jun‐20 | 38 adolescents (95% girls); AN‐restrict (68%); AN‐binge‐purge (13%); atypical AN (8%); BN (8%); OSFED (2%); race/ethnicity N/R |
21% reported that their ED overall was worse because of lockdown. 53% reported that lockdown affected their access to mental healthcare. 37% spent more time trying to control their weight/shape during lockdown. 37% reported that their general and ED‐specific quality of life had been negatively affected by lockdown. |
Unclear how ED was confirmed. Items were self‐created. Regressions were conducted to explore correlates of symptom deterioration, but variables modeled were not clear. |
| (Baenas et al., | Long (retro)) | Spain |
Prelockdown unclear During lockdown Apr‐20 |
74 adult treatment‐seeking patients confirmed via interview (96% women); |
19 patients self‐reported symptom deterioration while 55 self‐reported no change in symptoms during the lockdown. Depressive & anxiety symptoms were associated with symptom deterioration during lockdown. 41% and 29% of participants reported significant symptoms with anxiety and depression, respectively. |
Data were collected via telephone interview. Description of missing data was missing. Symptom deterioration items were self‐created. |
| (Branley‐Bell & Talbot, | Cross | UK | Apr‐20 |
129 community‐based adolescents/adults with current ED or recovering from ED based on self‐report (94% females). Race/ethnicity N/R |
87% reported that their symptoms had worsened, with 30% reporting that their symptoms were “much worse” because of the pandemic. |
Recruitment targeted towards social media advertisements and snowballing methods. Description of missing data was lacking. |
| (Brothwood, Baudinet, Stewart, & Simic, | Cross | UK | Mar–Nov‐20 | 14 adolescents with AN and 19 parents participating in an intensive treatment program (93% female). Race/ethnicity N/R |
16% of young people perceived online family therapy sessions to be more helpful than face‐to‐face family therapy sessions. 8% of young people perceived online individual therapy sessions to be more helpful than face‐to‐face individual sessions. Parents generally rated online therapy higher than the young people. Many young people felt that the quality of treatment was impacted by transitioning to online. |
Survey response rate was 58% for young people and 37% for parents. Unclear how ED diagnosis was confirmed. Items were self‐created for the purpose of this study. |
| (Castellini et al., | Long (retro) | Italy |
Pre‐pandemic Jan–Sept‐19 During pandemic Apr–May‐20 |
74 treatment‐seeking adults with BN/AN confirmed via interview (100% women) 97 healthy controls (100% female); 100% white; other races/ethnicities N/R |
A significant increase in binge eating and compensatory behaviors (but not total levels of ED psychopathology) was observed from before to during the lockdown in people with ED. 10 patients who were considered recovered prior to the pandemic had relapsed during the lockdown. |
Clinical sample was assessed pretreatment, before lockdown, and during lockdown. Control group was matched on gender and age (but not on living situation or education level) to clinical group and recruited via “local advertisements” Only complete cases were analyzed. Regressions were conducted to explore correlates of symptom deterioration, but the variables modeled were not clear. |
| (Favreau et al., | Cross | Germ | Apr–Dec‐20 | 88 individuals with AN and 30 with BN drawn from a large sample of 538 psychiatric inpatients (70% women). Race/ethnicity N/R |
35% and 23% of patients with AN and BN strongly agreed that their symptoms had worsened during the pandemic, respectively. Ratings of perceived burden of contact restrictions were higher for AN and BN relative to individuals with anxiety disorder. Daily structuring as a coping strategy was perceived to be more helpful by people with AN relative to people with depression and OCD. |
Completion rate for the online survey was 64%; unclear how partial completers were handled. All participants received inpatient treatment at six hospitals in Germany during COVID‐19. Unclear how diagnoses were established. Items were self‐created. |
| (Fernandez‐Aranda et al., | Cross | Spain | Jun–Jul‐20 | 127 adults, including 87 in‐patients with an eating disorder ( |
For people with AN (but not for BN and OSFED), significant reductions after COVID‐19 confinement were observed for factors “impact on eating symptoms,” “changes in eating style,” and “changes in emotion regulation” from the COVID isolation eating scale. There were no significant differences in telemedicine acceptability ratings between AN, BN, and OSFED. |
Recruitment occurred at six different child/adolescent units in Spain, which are representative of the public and private health sectors in Barcelona. The self‐created COVID isolation eating scale asks participants to rate their symptoms twice, once before confinement and one after confinement. Retrospective recall likely a significant bias in this study. Unclear whether missing data were present or how it was handled. |
| (Giel, Schurr, Zipfel, Junne, & Schag, | Long (retro) | Germ |
Pre‐pandemic May–Jun‐17 During pandemic May–Jul‐20 | 42 adults with BED who previously participated in an RCT, confirmed via interview (80% women). Race/ethnicity N/R |
Confirmed BED cases were lower after the lockdown period compared to prelockdown period (50% vs. 100%). A significant increase in binge eating was observed for the 4 weeks during lockdown as compared to immediately before COVID‐19 outbreak. Self‐reported ED psychopathology (EDE‐Q global) at the lockdown follow‐up was higher as compared to both previous assessments (when entering the trial and prelockdown). Fewer individuals fulfilled a comorbid mental health diagnosis after COVID‐19 lockdown (8%) as compared to pre‐pandemic time‐points (23%). |
52% retention rate for the follow‐up period after COVID‐19 lockdowns. Description of missing data was lacking. |
| (Graell et al., | Long (retro) | Spain | Mar–May‐20 |
Medical records of children and adolescents with ED seeking treatment before ( |
During confinement period, 1818 outpatient contacts were carried out (73% by phone and 27% face‐to‐face). 22 patients were newly admitted and 68 emergencies were treated. 42% of patients reported a reactivation of symptoms due to COVID‐19. 68.2% of patients and their families identified the onset of confinement as a possible precipitating factor for admission. On admission 45.5% of patients presented irritability and 22.7% presented mood disturbances due to confinement. Higher rates of comorbidities, affective disorders and suicide risk were observed in the pandemic compared to pre‐pandemic periods (number of admissions and source of referrals did not differ between the two periods). |
Records presented from outpatient, day hospital and inpatient program of the Child & Adolescent Eating Disorders Unit of the hospital Infantil Universitario Niño Jesús in Madrid during the 8 weeks of confinement. |
| (Hansen et al., | Long (retro) | NZ |
Pre‐pandemic Jan–Dec‐19 During pandemic 2020 period |
236 electronic records of child, adolescent, and adult inpatient and outpatient admissions pre‐pandemic postpandemic (95% female); 94% European; 6% Māori; 2% other |
2020 monthly admission numbers were higher than in the corresponding month in 2019, with a noticeable rise in march–April (first lockdown). Overall impatient admissions doubled in 2020 compared to 2019 for adults but not for children. Adults and children doubled in the proportion of first‐ever admissions during pandemic period (mainly in the second half of 2020). Child and adolescent outpatient services saw an average 60% increase in referrals per month following lockdown. |
Clinical records were gathered from referrals for eating disorders in the Waikato District health board catchment. |
| (Leenaerts, Vaessen, Ceccarini, & Vrieze, | Long (pros) | Belg | Unclear |
15 adults with BN confirmed via interview (100% women); 87% European 13% Asian |
During lockdown, patients reported higher levels of negative affect and lower levels of positive affect. Patients who experienced a higher binge eating frequency during the lockdown also experienced a stronger change in negative and positive affect. Time spent at home, and time spent with family, housemates, partner were unrelated to binge eating during lockdown periods. |
Subset of participants extracted from larger study; unclear why this sub‐sample was used. Eight signals over nine days were sent to participants to respond to EMA items. Very small sample size. |
| (Levinson, Spoor, Keshishian, & Pruitt, | Long (pros) | US |
Pre‐pandemic Mar‐2018/2020 During pandemic Mar‐2020–Jan‐2021 |
93 treatment‐seeking adults confirmed via interview (86% women) who received either in‐person or telemedicine treatment (43% AN; 10% BN; 34% OSFED; 9% BED; 2% ARFID); 95% white; 2% black; 1% Asian; 1% mixed race |
Both groups (telemedicine & face‐to‐face) reported significant improvements in ED psychopathology (EDE‐Q global), depressive symptoms and perfectionism scores, with no between‐group differences noted. |
The two cohorts did not differ on clinical variables except parental criticisms; unclear whether the two cohorts were matched on demographic variables. The two treatment groups were identical in content. Missing data/attrition not mentioned. |
| (Lewis, Elran‐Barak, Grundman‐Shem Tov, & Zubery, | Cross | Israel | Apr–May‐20 | 63 treatment‐seeking individuals (90% women); 38% AN; 32% BN; 25% BED. race/ethnicity N/R |
~40% agreed that the transition to online treatment adversely affected the quality of care and the effectiveness of treatment. 9% would prefer to continue to use online treatment than face‐to‐face treatment. The only correlate of positive perceptions of online treatment transition was a longer duration of illness. |
Diagnoses determined via clinical discussions. 80% survey completion rate description of missing data was lacking) Items were self‐created. |
| (Lin et al., | Long (retro) | US |
Pre‐pandemic Jan‐2018–Mar‐2020 During pandemic Apr‐2020–Feb‐2021 | Service utilization data were analyzed (no participant information provided) |
At the onset of the pandemic, there was no immediate shift in number of inpatient medical admissions and inpatient bed‐days; however, at post‐pandemic periods, number of admissions per month increased over time. Completed new outpatient assessments began increasing over time as the pandemic continued. Pre‐pandemic patient inquiries were stable over time, while post‐pandemic inquiries increased. |
ED program is within a tertiary care children's hospital in Boston caring for patients approximately 8–26 years old with any ED diagnosis. |
| (Machado et al., | Long (retro) | Port |
Pre‐pandemic unclear During pandemic Apr–May‐20 | 43 adults (95% women) patients (46% AN; 32% BN; 5% BED; 16% OSFED). Race/ethnicity N/R |
Level of ED psychopathology (EDE‐Q global), impairment and emotion dysregulation did not change over time (pre to during pandemic). Coronavirus impact scale scores were significantly associated with each criterion variable 58% reported moderate/severe stress related to the pandemic, 16% reported family conflict related to the pandemic, 37% reported abrupt changes to mental health care access. |
Participants recruited from an ongoing naturalistic study (45% agreed to participate). Assessments were conducted via telephone. Not clear how ED diagnosis was confirmed or when the first assessment was conducted. |
| (Mansfield et al., | Long (retro) | UK |
Pre‐pandemic Jan‐2017/2019 During pandemic Aug‐20 |
> 10 million electronic records of adult health care contacts (50% women); 49% white; 5% south Asian; 3% black; 2% other; 1% mixed |
There was a reduction in general practitioner contact behavior for EDs when comparing pre and during pandemic time periods. |
Records were based on anyone over age 11 years. |
| (Monteleone et al., | Cross | Italy | Jun‐20 |
312 adults with ED confirmed via interview (96% women); 57% AN; 27% BN; 15% BED; 7% OSFED. race/ethnicity N/R |
Ineffectiveness, impulsivity, and self‐induced vomiting were higher both during and after lockdown relative to pre‐COVID‐19 periods. Social security, body dissatisfaction and binge eating scores were higher during lockdown compared to after lockdown periods. |
Participants answered survey items in relation to three time‐periods (prior, during, and after lockdowns). Description of missing data was lacking. Items were adapted from previously established surveys. |
| (Pensgaard, Oevreboe, & Ivarsson, | Long (pros) | Italy |
T1 Mar‐Apr‐2020 T2 Jun‐2020 |
40 treatment‐seeking patients confirmed by interview (98% women); |
Restrictive eating and depression, anxiety and stress scores did not change from pre to during lockdown periods among the clinical sample, but loss of control eating, body image concerns, and psychological wellbeing scores improved |
Dropouts differed to completers only on a measure of food preoccupation. |
| (Plumley, Kristensen, & Jenkins, | Long (pros) | UK | Unclear |
9 patients with AN undergoing day‐patient treatment virtually (89% women); 77% white; other races/ethnicities N/R |
Patients transitioning to a day‐patient program online (i.e., videoconferencing) experienced large improvements in core ED symptoms, and depression and anxiety symptoms. |
Conclusions are difficult due to the very small sample size. |
| (Raykos, Erceg‐Hurn, Hill, Campbell, & McEvoy, | Long (pros) | Aus | Mar–Apr‐20 | 25 treatment‐seeking patients (93% women) confirmed via interview; 48% AN; 20% BN; 28% OSFED; 4% UFED. 70% Anglo‐European‐Australian; other races/ethnicities N/R. |
Participants who were forced to transition to telehealth experienced large reductions in ED psychopathology, impairment, and mood states. The level of change from telehealth was almost identical to historical benchmarks at the same clinic (face‐to‐face treatment). 71% perceived telehealth to be as good as or better than face‐to‐face treatment. The quality of the therapeutic relationship during telehealth sessions was rated as being “as good as usual” (88%). |
Unclear whether historical benchmarks were matched on key demographics, although they did not differ on symptom severity. Different treatment approaches were delivered based on the age and diagnosis of the patient. |
| (Richardson, Patton, Phillips, & Paslakis, | Long (retro) | Can |
Pre‐pandemic Mar–Apr‐2018/2019 During pandemic Mar–Apr‐20 | All individuals (87% female) who contacted NEDIC through the helpline or instant chat function (demographic info N/R). |
NEDIC was contacted 609 times (120 calls, 418 instant chats, 71 emails) during the pandemic period; most were for support (64%) or referral (20%), and 78% of help‐seekers were women. Number of NEDIC contacts was higher during the pandemic period than during a 2018 (but not 2019) period. Most affect people using NEDIC services were women (86%), and the most prevalent diagnoses were AN (31%) and BED (41%). Self‐reported symptoms of dieting, over‐exercising, perfectionism, purging, depression and anxiety were higher in the pandemic period compared to pre‐pandemic periods (no differences in binge eating and weight preoccupation). 73% of people who contacted NEDIC because of COVID‐19 reported that their symptoms had gotten worse during isolation. |
NEDIC is a national non‐profit organization (Canada) that uses free helpline and instant chat services to assist those affected by ED. |
| (Schlegl, Maier, et al., | Cross | Germ | May‐20 | 159 former inpatients with AN (100% women). Race/ethnicity N/R |
41% agreed/strongly agreed that their symptoms were worse during the pandemic; 20% agreed/strongly agreed that they developed new symptoms; 51% agreed/strongly agreed that their quality of life had worsened; 27% agreed/strongly agreed that their therapy was impaired. The percentage stating that the following symptoms had worsened “much more” during the pandemic was: Drive for thinness (28%), fear of weight gain (36%), body dissatisfaction (35%), eating concerns (42%), shape and weight concerns (~30%), restrictive eating (14%), binge eating (4%), self‐induced vomiting (6%), laxative and diuretic abuse (2%). Feelings of sadness (30%), loss of pleasure (30%), interest (22%) and energy (28%), loneliness (41%), and symptoms of anxiety (>10%) had worsened during the pandemic. 28% of the total sample agreed/strongly agreed that the pandemic had impacted their treatment experience. |
Participation rate was 59% overall. Items were self‐created. Description of missing data was lacking. |
| (Schlegl, Meule, et al., | Cross | Germ | May‐20 |
55 former inpatients with BN confirmed via interview (100% female) Race/ethnicity = N/A |
49% reported that their ED had worsened during the pandemic; 61% reported that their quality of life had been negatively affected; 45% reported significant disruptions to their treatment; 40% reported that they had developed new symptoms; >75% reported more pronounced symptoms of depression and general psychopathology. >80% reported increases in eating, shape and weight concerns, fear of weight gain, and drive for thinness. Binge eating increased in 47% of patients, self‐induced vomiting in 36%, and laxative and diuretic abuse increased in 9% and 7% of patients, respectively. Use of videoconference‐based therapy increased from 3.6% to 21.8% and use of telephone contacts from 18.2% to 38.2%, whereas the use of additional online interventions decreased from 3.6% to 0%. 45% of the total sample agreed/strongly agreed that the pandemic had impacted their treatment experience. |
25% survey completion rate among all participants invited. Survey was self‐created. Description of missing data was lacking. |
| (Shaw et al., | Long (retro) | UK |
Pre‐pandemic Mar–Jul‐19 During pandemic Mar–Jul‐20 | Service evaluation conducted at the eating disorder young person service (UK), including 12 adolescent patients with an ED, 19 parents/carers, and 12 staff members. Gender /race/ethnicity N/R |
Number of urgent referrals increased to 35% from March–July (2020) compared to 21% in the same period in 2019. The number of appointments offered increased during the lockdown period ( 92% of service staff disagreed that young patients were coping with COVID‐19, while 26% of carers and 16% of patients disagreed that they were coping better. Patient satisfaction ratings slightly increased during COVID‐19, but carers and staff ratings slightly decreased. |
Authors created their own items for purpose of the study. |
| (Spettigue et al., | Long (retro) | Can |
Pre‐pandemic Apr–Oct‐19 During pandemic Apr–Oct‐20 | 91 adolescents (43 pre‐pandemic and 48 during pandemic) with an ED (83% female); ~85% AN. Race/ethnicity N/R |
39% reported that their ED was triggered by the pandemic. Those who had their ED triggered had a lower BMI, were more medically unstable, and were more likely to be admitted four weeks after assessment than a 2019 cohort and those who were not triggered by COVID‐19. The cohort exposed to the pandemic reported higher dietary restraint and impairment scores than a separate pre‐pandemic cohort; no differences on other symptom measures were observed. |
The two cohorts differed on BMI but not on gender distribution or age. Extent and handling of missing data were not clear. |
| (Spigel et al., | Cross | US | Jul‐20 |
73 treatment‐seeking young people with self‐reported ED (93% female); white = 79%; Asian = 7%; Hispanic = 6%; black = 1% mixed race = 6%; other = 1%. |
32% reported a disruption to treatment as a result of the pandemic. 67% with telehealth access found care to be better or as good as usual. 81% endorsed increased intrusive eating disorder thoughts and behaviors due to the pandemic. Those who perceived treatment disruption and still had access to care had a higher odds of intrusive ED thoughts. |
Authors created their own items for purpose of the study. |
| (Stewart et al., | Cross | UK | May–Jul‐20 | 53 adolescents with an ED (AN/OSFED), 75 parents, and 23 clinicians. Gender /race/ethnicity N/R |
Clinicians perceived the levels of engagement from their patient were not changed by the transition to online treatment. Young people and parent's indicated that their overall experience of online therapy was positive and that they felt understood, with a low level of impact of technology on their treatment experience. Both parents and young people indicated little impact on the therapeutic relationship when transitioning to online treatment. Parents were more likely to opt for online treatment preferences compared to the patients when restrictions ease (17% vs. 6%). |
All clinicians, patients and parents from Maudsley Centre for Child and Adolescent Eating Disorders were invited. Survey completion rate was 33% for young patients, 47% for parents, and 66% clinicians. Description of missing data was lacking. All responses were based on retrospective recall Items were self‐created for the purpose of this study |
| (Taquet, Geddes, Luciano, & Harrison, | Long (retro) | US |
Pre‐pandemic 2017–2020 During pandemic 2020–2021 |
> 5 million electronic health records of adolescent patients (55% female; 8,471 diagnoses with an ED during the pandemic period). |
During the pandemic, an increase of ED diagnoses of 15% was observed compared with the prior year, with significant excesses observed in each 2‐month period during the pandemic period except for March–May 2020. Increased risk was observed for females, those aged 10–19 years, and mostly affected AN diagnoses. Compared to those diagnosed with an ED in the past 3 years, those diagnosed during the pandemic were at higher risk of attempting suicide and having suicidal ideation (no differences in death rates). |
Records were drawn from a federated EHR network with anonymized data from 81 million patients (93% from the US) seeking hospital, primary care and specialist provider services |
| (Termorshuizen et al., | Cross | US | Apr‐20 | 511 adults from the US (97% women) and 510 adults from Netherlands (99% women) who self‐reported a current or lifetime ED. race/ethnicity N/R |
Between 3–53% of the total sample reported being “very concerned” about the impact of COVID‐19 on their ED depending on the specific item asked. Most common reasons for concern levels were “lack of structure,” “triggering environment,” and “lack of social support.” Percentage of participants who reported engaging in specific ED behaviors daily due to the pandemic was: 5–6% for binge eating, 14–19% for restriction, 15% for compensatory behaviors, and 28% for exercise anxiety. >50% of the total sample reported that they were worried that COVID‐19 was going to impact their mental health. 47% of patients in the US and 74% in Netherlands rated their treatment in the last 2 weeks as “somewhat” or “much worse” than usual |
Recruitment was aimed at social media or via emails to participants from other studies. Items were self‐created. Description of missing data was lacking. |
| (Vitagliano et al., | Cross | US | Jun–Aug‐20 | 89 younger individuals with a self‐reported ED (89% women); 78% white; other races/ethnicities N/R |
73% reported an increase in depressive symptoms due to COVID‐19, 77% reported an increase in anxiety, 80% reported an increase in isolation and 74% reported an increase in intrusive eating disorder thoughts. 29% reported a decrease in motivation to recover due to the pandemic. Living in a triggering environment was correlated with intrusive ED thoughts, reported increases in depression/anxiety, and lower motivation to recover. |
Items were self‐created for the purpose of this study, but adapted from previously published work. Participants were a sub‐sample from a larger study (56% response rate). Completers did not differ to dropouts on age at enrolment, race/ethnicity, or sex, but did differ in restrictive ED rates. |
| (Vuillier, May, Greville‐Harris, Surman, & Moseley, | Cross | UK | Unclear | 207 adults with a self‐reported ED (64% women); 94% white; 5% Asian; 0.5% black; 0.5% Asian |
83% reported that their ED symptoms had worsened as a result of the pandemic, with no differences between ED subtypes. Changes to routine, changes to physical activity, and difficulties with emotion regulation were cited as the three most influential exacerbating factors. |
Participants recruited through prolific website and social media. Items were self‐created. Description of missing data was unclear. |
| (Yaffa et al., | Long (retro) | Israel |
Pre‐pandemic 2015–2019 During pandemic Jan–Oct‐20 | Service data at a pediatric ED treatment Centre in Israel. sample demographics N/R |
Compared to means reported for the period of 2015–2019, means reported for 2020 were higher for number of treatment sessions offered (5,926 vs. 4,001), and meetings with a psychiatrist (662 vs. 433), clinical nutritionist (1,722 vs. 750), and mental health professional (3,318 vs. 1,690). The mean number of existing (242 vs. 257) and new patients (127 vs. 166) between the two periods were highly similar. |
The ED treatment Centre offers inpatient, day care, and ambulatory services for children and adolescents with EDs. |
Abbreviations: AN, anorexia nervosa; Aus, Australia; BED, binge‐eating disorder; BN, bulimia nervosa; Braz, Brazil; Can, Canada; Cross, cross‐sectional; Fran, France; Germ, Germany; Leb, Lebanon; long (pros), longitudinal prospective design; long (retro), longitudinal retrospective design; N/R, not reported or unclear; NZ, New Zealand; OSFED, other specified feeding or eating disorder; Port, Portugal; UK, United Kingdom; US, United States.