| Literature DB >> 34753073 |
Wahab A Khan1, Rachael E Barney2, Gregory J Tsongalis3.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The well-recognized genome editing ability of the CRISPR-Cas system has triggered significant advances in CRISPR diagnostics. This has prompted an interest in developing new biosensing applications for nucleic acid detection. Recently, such applications have been engineered for detection of SARS-CoV-2. Increased demand for testing and consumables of RT-PCR assays has led to the use of alternate testing options. Here we evaluate the accuracy and performance of a novel fluorescence-based assay that received EUA authorization for detecting SARS-CoV-2 in clinical samples.Entities:
Keywords: CRISPR technology; Cas13 enzymology; Fluorescence readout; RT-Lamp; SARS-CoV-2
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34753073 PMCID: PMC8553369 DOI: 10.1016/j.jcv.2021.105019
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Clin Virol ISSN: 1386-6532 Impact factor: 3.168
Fig. 1Basic workflow of CRISPR-Cas13 detection of SARS-CoV-2 as it relates to pre-processing, analytical and post-analytical steps. (a) Upon collection of nasopharyngeal swab and nucleic acid extraction, the purified RNA is subjected to an (b) isothermal amplification (green depicts the reverse transcriptase enzyme). (c) The amplified target upon being bound by the Cas13 enzyme (yellow), with its guide RNA (purple-red) cleaves the reporter (blue). A standard output generated on a plate reader is shown form which data export using a macro language function is performed. All sequence of events are shown in succession left to right in panels a-c.
Fig. 2Settings on BioTek plate reader applied during SARS-CoV-2 detection step. (a) The read speed was set to normal and standard filter excitation and emission spectra were all collected at 485/528 respectively. (b) Settings for collecting data is broken up into 2.5-minute intervals with a total kinetic read time of 10 min.
List of ratio combinations and interpretation for reporting SARS-CoV-2 results on clinical samples. Three targets are listed, including the RNAse P POP7 gene which serves as a control for the extraction of the clinical sample in the absence of a positive SARS-CoV-2 result. Note the experiment should also be considered invalid if the NTC (not shown in table) shows a ratio >5.
| ≥ 5 | ≥ 5 | n/a | Detected |
| ≥ 5 | ≤ 5 | n/a | Detected |
| ≤ 5 | ≥ 5 | n/a | Detected |
| ≤ 5 | ≤ 5 | ≥ 5 | Not Detected |
| ≤ 5 | ≤ 5 | ≤ 5 | Invalid |
Summary of clinical SARS-CoV-2 nasopharyngeal samples processed on the SHERLOCK CRISPR-Cas13 assay with comparable concordance to the RT-PCR CDC (Ct cut off for detection = 41.5) and chromacode HDPCR SARS-CoV-2. * Indicates pooled set of samples processed on Abbott's M2000rt platform. Note; some of the highest reported Ct values (weak positives**) from the CDC and chromacode assays were tested with the SHERLOCK chemistry and showed close concordance with RT-PCR.
| 1 | 335,840 | 257,916 | 222,233 | 20,408 | 7625 | 10,149 | 16.46 | 33.83 | 21.90 | Detected/Ct = 17.44 | Y |
| 2 | 11,112 | 9133 | 224,657 | 0.54 | 1.20 | 22.14 | Not Detected | Y | |||
| 3 | 8055 | 4966 | 170,538 | 7885 | 4792 | 6883 | 1.02 | 1.04 | 24.78 | Not Detected | Y |
| 4 | 7982 | 4490 | 160,942 | 1.01 | 0.94 | 23.38 | Not Detected | Y | |||
| 5 | 212,383 | 162,298 | 180,997 | 26.94 | 33.87 | 26.30 | Detected/Ct = 20.96 | Y | |||
| 6 | 303,393 | 230,758 | 216,275 | 38.48 | 48.15 | 31.42 | Detected/Ct = 29.85** | Y | |||
| 7 | 387,741 | 198,326 | 190,924 | 49.17 | 41.39 | 27.74 | Detected/ Ct = 19.52 | Y | |||
| 8 | 6483 | 5449 | 178,434 | 6976 | 4942 | 5961 | 0.93 | 1.10 | 29.93 | Not Detected | Y |
| 9* | 398,533 | 236,583 | 176,738 | 57.13 | 47.87 | 29.65 | Detected/Ct = 7.11 | Y | |||
| 10* | 57.13 | 47.87 | 29.65 | Detected/Ct = 6.61 | Y | ||||||
| 11* | 57.13 | 47.87 | 29.65 | Detected/Ct = 9.72 | Y | ||||||
| 12 | 12,762 | 6152 | 287,888 | 9956 | 7251 | 6246 | 1.28 | 0.85 | 46.09 | Not Detected | Y |
| 13 | 10,212 | 6124 | 266,406 | 1.03 | 0.84 | 42.65 | Not Detected | Y | |||
| 14 | 332,171 | 296,684 | 287,583 | 33.36 | 40.92 | 46.04 | Detected/Ct = 27.7 | Y | |||
| 15 | 338,260 | 326,265 | 257,692 | 33.98 | 45.00 | 41.26 | Detected/Ct = 33.3** | Y | |||
| 16 | 325,267 | 336,348 | 227,281 | 32.67 | 46.39 | 36.39 | Detected/Ct = 17.7 | Y | |||
| 17 | 5194 | 10,836 | 176,183 | 5606 | 3952 | 5078 | 0.93 | 2.74 | 34.70 | Not Detected | Y |
| 18 | 5662 | 3582 | 202,351 | 1.01 | 0.91 | 39.85 | Not Detected | Y | |||
| 19 | 5036 | 19,513 | 186,814 | 0.90 | 4.94 | 36.79 | Not Detected | Y | |||
| 20 | 5102 | 3586 | 189,368 | 0.91 | 0.91 | 37.29 | Not Detected | Y | |||
| 21 | 7625 | 4375 | 178,607 | 7003 | 4473 | 7253 | 1.09 | 0.98 | 24.63 | Not Detected | Y |
| 22 | 246,413 | 4297 | 159,377 | 35.19 | 0.96 | 21.97 | Detected/Ct = 36.06** | Y | |||
| 23 | 335,543 | 545,207 | 238,894 | 8833 | 4433 | 7879 | 37.99 | 122.99 | 30.32 | Detected/Ct = 33.3** | Y |
| 24 | 7147 | 248,867 | 218,673 | 0.81 | 56.14 | 27.75 | Detected/Ct = 32.88** | Y | |||
| 25 | 346,489 | 498,365 | 340,415 | 39.23 | 112.42 | 43.21 | Detected/Ct = 24.05 | Y | |||
| 26 | 381,772 | 561,364 | 315,811 | 43.22 | 126.63 | 40.08 | Detected/Ct = 22.42 | Y | |||
| 27 | 280,690 | 305,274 | 305,007 | 31.78 | 68.86 | 38.71 | Detected/Ct = 17.52 | Y | |||
| 28 | 276,274 | 270,071 | 315,212 | 31.28 | 60.92 | 40.01 | Detected/Ct = 18.1 | Y | |||
| 29 | 324,165 | 257,089 | 225,351 | 6347 | 4492 | 6447 | 51.07 | 57.23 | 34.95 | Detected/Ct = 21.9 | Y |
| 30 | 345,856 | 234,039 | 186,853 | 54.49 | 52.10 | 28.98 | Detected/Ct = 31.8** | Y | |||
| 31 | 311,710 | 244,545 | 191,391 | 49.11 | 54.44 | 29.69 | Detected/Ct = 28.5 | Y | |||
| 32 | 300,441 | 239,601 | 202,344 | 47.34 | 53.34 | 31.39 | Detected/Ct = 24.7 | Y | |||
| 33 | 324,643 | 207,806 | 187,956 | 51.15 | 46.26 | 29.15 | Detected/Ct = 15.6 | Y | |||
| 34 | 305,808 | 244,574 | 190,052 | 48.18 | 54.45 | 29.48 | Detected/Ct = 21.0 | Y | |||
| 35 | 322,784 | 274,537 | 200,890 | 50.86 | 61.12 | 31.16 | Detected/Ct = 17 | Y | |||
| 36 | 306,715 | 255,320 | 163,073 | 48.32 | 56.84 | 25.29 | Detected/Ct = 27.7 | Y | |||
| 37 | 325,232 | 246,979 | 193,283 | 51.24 | 54.98 | 29.98 | Detected/Ct = 21.1 | Y | |||
| 38 | 325,197 | 168,880 | 171,895 | 51.24 | 37.60 | 26.66 | Detected/Ct = 23.2 | Y | |||
| 39 | 317,602 | 249,112 | 242,150 | 50.04 | 55.46 | 37.56 | Detected/Ct = 30.8** | Y | |||
| 40 | 359,819 | 181,938 | 193,781 | 56.69 | 40.50 | 30.06 | Detected/Ct = 23.3 | Y | |||
| 41 | 320,959 | 219,460 | 234,646 | 50.57 | 48.86 | 36.40 | Detected/Ct = 18.6 | Y | |||
| 42 | 422,682 | 202,531 | 163,150 | 66.60 | 45.09 | 25.31 | Detected/Ct = 15.1 | Y | |||
| 43 | 7721 | 3474 | 161,671 | 4791 | 3097 | 5088 | 1.61 | 1.12 | 31.77 | Not Detected | Y |
| 44 | 4566 | 3699 | 155,285 | 0.95 | 1.19 | 30.52 | Not Detected | Y | |||
| 45 | 4395 | 3412 | 165,760 | 0.92 | 1.10 | 32.58 | Not Detected | Y | |||
| 46 | 4392 | 3486 | 141,616 | 0.92 | 1.13 | 27.83 | Not Detected | Y | |||
| 47 | 4265 | 3469 | 165,297 | 0.89 | 1.12 | 32.49 | Not Detected | Y | |||
| 48 | 3911 | 3444 | 163,259 | 0.82 | 1.11 | 32.09 | Not Detected | Y | |||
| 49 | 241,836 | 171,766 | 170,847 | 50.48 | 55.46 | 33.58 | Detected/Ct = 19.5 | Y | |||
| 50 | 335,201 | 140,939 | 179,742 | 69.96 | 45.51 | 35.33 | Detected/Ct = 19.9 | Y | |||
| 51 | 533,800 | 173,437 | 191,745 | 73.17 | 23.96 | 35.97 | Detected/Ct = 10.84 | Y | |||
| 52 | 387,490 | 226,264 | 144,137 | 7295 | 7238 | 5331 | 53.12 | 31.26 | 27.04 | Detected/Ct = 5.21 | Y |
| 53 | 560,698 | 237,724 | 4902 | 76.86 | 32.84 | 0.92 | Detected/Ct = 7.23 | Y | |||
| 54 | 663,657 | 296,031 | 7003 | 90.97 | 40.90 | 1.31 | Detected/Ct = 3.41 | Y | |||
| 55 | 560,017 | 188,136 | 130,854 | 85.39 | 49.47 | 25.68 | Detected/Ct = 27.64 | Y | |||
| 56 | 422,493 | 389,908 | 149,072 | 64.42 | 102.53 | 29.25 | Detected/Ct = 14.72 | Y | |||
| 57 | 560,179 | 377,374 | 156,198 | 85.42 | 99.23 | 30.65 | Detected/Ct = 32.99** | Y | |||
| 58 | 456,913 | 195,350 | 173,756 | 69.67 | 51.37 | 34.10 | Detected/Ct = 16.18 | Y | |||
| 59 | 410,677 | 6911 | 157,596 | 62.62 | 1.82 | 30.93 | Detected/Ct = 30.92** | Y | |||
| 60 | 436,841 | 140,768 | 132,389 | 6558 | 3803 | 5096 | 66.61 | 37.01 | 25.98 | Detected/Ct = 19.93 | Y |
Contingency table summarizing RT-PCR results compared to Sherlock SARS-CoV-2 kit detecting positive and negative nasopharyngeal clinical samples (n = 60; N gene 95% CI 29.9–43.8, ORF1ab gene 95% CI 30.1–46.3). The overall concordance, sensitivity, and specificity of all the samples processed compared to the reference method was 100%.
| RT-PCR (Ref. Method) | ||||
| Positive | Negative | Total | ||
| SHERLOCK CRISPR (Candidate method) | Positive | 43 (TP) | 0 (FP) | 43 |
| Negative | 0 (FN) | 17 (TN) | 17 | |
| Total | 43 | 17 | 60 |
Fig. 3Raw fluorescence (Y-axis) shown as a function of time (X-axis in minutes) from representative samples processed on a standard multimode plate reader. (a) N – gene target not detected in this clinical specimen whereas (b) a prominent spike in fluorescence is noted from a separate clinical sample in which the N – gene target is robustly detected (note RFU is an order of magnitude greater on Y-axis compared to panel 'a'). A similar pattern is shown in the bottom two panels where the ORF1ab target is not detected (panel c) versus detected (panel d). Similarly, the Y-axis values are an order of magnitude higher between the two scenarios (e.g. detected/not detected) due to the collateral activity of the CRISPR Cas13 guide RNAs to cleave and release fluorescence in the presence of SARS-CoV-2.