| Literature DB >> 34719072 |
Luz M Garcini1,2,3, Tommy Tam Pham2, Arlynn M Ambriz2, Sarah Lill1, Joel Tsevat1,2.
Abstract
In the U.S., Latinos are disproportionately affected by the COVID-19 pandemic. A critical step to reduce the spread of COVID-19 is diagnostic testing. Yet, for testing to be effective, barriers must be reduced or eliminated and facilitators promoted. Guided by principles of community-based participatory research, we collected data from 64 community health workers and Promotor/as (CHW/Ps) in Texas to identify relevant personal, community-level, and testing-related barriers and facilitators to diagnostic testing for COVID-19 among underserved Latino communities. Data were collected through an online survey and focus groups. A large majority of CHW/Ps (90.6%) reported that they perceived diagnostic testing to be important for their communities; however, only 42.2% believed that their communities understand the use of testing. Personal barriers to diagnostic testing included mistrust and fear, including fear of: becoming infected and infecting others, job/income loss, discrimination/stigmatisation, uncovering other diseases, and mishandling of personal information. Community-level barriers to testing included fear-inducing myths and beliefs. Test-related factors included cost and accuracy of testing, testing procedures, inadequate and insufficient information, and logistics pertaining to testing sites. Facilitators to testing included building trust between communities and those administering testing, along with receiving culturally and contextually appropriate testing information. Diagnostic testing for COVID-19 among underserved Latino communities is complex and suboptimal. Targeted efforts are needed to overcome personal, community and test-related barriers in a culturally and contextually sensitive manner in order to prevent harm and to reduce further risk among underserved communities.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; community; diagnostic; disparities; latinos/hispanics; testing
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34719072 PMCID: PMC8652902 DOI: 10.1111/hsc.13621
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Health Soc Care Community ISSN: 0966-0410
Demographic characteristics of community health workers and Promotor/as
| Characteristics |
Total ( |
|---|---|
| Sex | |
| % Women | 89.8 |
| Age, years ( | 45.3 (13.7) |
| Race/ethnicity | |
| % Latino | 91.5 |
| Education | |
| % High school graduate or beyond | 89.8 |
| Employment | |
| % Full or part time | 85.7 |
| Years as CHW/ | |
|
| 6.4 (7.0) |
Personal and community barriers to diagnostic testing and their associated psychological consequences, according to community health workers and Promotor/as
| Barriers sub‐categories | Sample quotations | Psychosocial consequences | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fear | 1. Becoming infected or exposed | They were afraid that there would be a lot of people [at the testing centre], and … if they were not sick that there was a possibility of getting infected by going. |
Disappointment Shame Guilt Stigmatisation Fear of rejection |
| 2. Getting others sick | I felt like a putrid person … because [the clinic staff member] is blaming me for infecting others … there is a stigma … you got people sick because you did not use protection and people are going to find out about that … it is feeling the guilt of knowing that you are responsible if somebody else gets sick. | ||
| 3. Uncovering other diseases (e.g., STDs, HIV) | I am working with the LGBTQ community and they are scared that something else might come up: HIV, AIDS, STDs … that is another fear, that you may go for COVID, but you will bring back more diseases. | ||
| 4. Failure (i.e., self‐care, care for family, care for community) | Nobody wants to look like they failed … they failed to – to take care of themselves, they failed to keep their families safe, and they feel like they let the community down. They are just embarrassed. | ||
| 5. Discrimination | People are afraid to test positive because they are going to be discriminated against … they will get labelled … their families will find out they had the virus, so they will not want to get close to them… their families can make them feel less because now they have the virus, they do not want to visit with them … It is a type of discrimination. | ||
| There are a lot of people who do not want to say they have had it or that they have it, because of fear of rejection … if someone says that they have it … [the community looks] at them weird … do not touch them, do not look at them … do not visit them. | |||
| 6. Caregiving concerns | If you are sick and people don't want to be near you, who is going to help you, right? It is that sense of being left alone and left behind. | ||
| 7. Job or income loss if testing positive | People are afraid to say they have the virus because they are afraid that they are going to be sent home, and they will not get paid … there is fear of lack of employment. | ||
| If I test positive, I am going to have to stay home and not work … I can't miss work … I have bills to pay … I am afraid of getting tested because what if I am [positive]? Who is going to pay for the bill … that is the worst fear. | |||
| 8. Immigration legal status |
There were immigration trucks parked in one of the testing sites [at the border] …. when people who are undocumented see the truck, they leave … they tell me, “they are going to take down my information there, and what if they pick me up?” | ||
| Mistrust | 1. Mishandling personal information | Their biggest worry is to give out their personal information and that they are tracked … we hear that for people who test positive, human services are taking their children away … and they would rather not get it done, so they do not get them separated. |
Fear of persecution Fear of deportation Fear of family separation Deception |
| People are terrified of getting tested because they are fearful that the government will track them and follow them … there are immigration trucks parked in one of the testing sites … when people see the truck, they leave … they tell me, “They are going to take down my information and what if they pick me up?” | |||
| 2. Concern about financial scams | There is a rumour going around and people feel fearful … supposedly, for every positive test, the hospital or the clinic receives an X amount of money from the state so they are giving false positives just to get money. They do not have… | ||
| Myths/Beliefs | 1. Rumours | A lot of people are saying that they regret getting tested because there is a rumour that those [testing positive] will be the first to receive the vaccine, whether they want to or not, because they had the virus already … that sets us back a step in having people going in to get tested. |
Fear Doubt Disappointment |
| [People] are afraid to get tested because they are afraid that the test may have the virus … they are afraid they may be inserting the virus through the test … there is a conspiracy and [testing] is government's way of eliminating the weak. | |||
| 2. Spiritual/religious beliefs | Why has this whole wrath of God arrived? … People say, the wrath of God is on this country or this community or these people … it is a lot about God being upset, so when somebody from the community gets COVID, it is hard to accept because it is, like, wait a minute. We were supposed to be protected. | ||
LGBTQ, lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer; STD, sexually transmitted disease.
Test‐related factors as barriers to diagnostic testing and their associated psychosocial consequences, according to community health workers and Promotor/as
| Barriers | Sub‐categories | Sample quotations | Psychosocial consequences |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost of test | 1. Affordability | Often, when they do the blood test, they charge $75 or $50 and [people] don't have [the money] … if you are active with COVID‐19, what is going to happen next? Who is going to carry the bill? A lot of [people] in my area do not have medical insurance. So it seems l. |
Worry Fear Confusion Doubt Frustration Despair Perceived discrimination Sense of unfairness |
| What they have heard is horror stories that the testing is very expensive … they rather not get tested and just wait and see if they have symptoms. | |||
| Test characteristics | 1. Accuracy | It is costing people a lot of money, with unreliable results. They know that the accuracy of the test is not good, so they do not trust in those things … people are scared and frantic …. they are paying just to find out and then it is not even 100 percent [accurate]. | |
| 2. Variations in test administration | I do not think it is that accurate, because … if you did it [tested] yourself, you do not know if everyone does it [that way]. You wonder if you did it correctly because you are not someone who knows or has practiced doing those types of [self‐administered nasal swab] tests. | ||
| Testing Information | 1. Confusion between diagnostic and antibody testing |
they rather not ge It seems like there is a disparity in [testing] price and confusion in terms of what test [to take] … [people] have a lot of questions because one [test] is through the nasal cavities and another is with a blood sample … [people] do not know which test to get done. | |
| Someone that I knew took a test … they did blood work and then they did the swab … she did say, “Well, with the blood, I came out negative, so I am good” … I did not understand what she meant by that. | |||
| One of the employees ended up being positive with COVID … he was so scared because his wife was pregnant … he ended up going to get tested somewhere else but with the nasal [swab] … it ended up saying that he was negative. | |||
| 2. Poor understanding or rumours about the testing procedure | I heard that it is dangerous to have the test go down so far into your nose and it may choke you … they say they hurt you, that they make you bleed … I am afraid of doing the test myself. | ||
| [People say] that [testing] is painful … I had a client who claimed it was as if they were touching the brain. | |||
| 3. Not knowing where to test | The information they are lacking is where to go … several people have called me because they do not know where to go get tested. | ||
| 4. Not knowing when to test | There is a lot that we need to know… when is it a right time to check? What to do? | ||
| 5. Testing requirements (e.g., documentation) | A big question is whether or not they will accept their | ||
| Testing logistics | 1. Scarcity of tests | There are not enough tests … many times [people] do not get tested because by the time their turn comes, they are turned away and told there are no more tests available, even though they are getting up very early to get tested. | |
| A lot of testing sites are booked … it is a big problem because you go to the website and it is constantly booked and you cannot book a week in advance. | |||
| 2. Not convenient (e.g., long wait; competing demands; safety protocols) | I have to work, and I do not have the time to go stand in line, so I am not going to get tested. | ||
| I had an experience with an individual who came to the local clinic … upon arrival, a staff member told her she had to get in her car, because she couldn't be outside there because she was putting others at risk … she replied, “Miss, look, I do not have a car, I took the bus” … the staff member told her, “Then, I am terribly sorry, but I can' |
Other people to know. It is like.