Treatment of Chronic Spinal Cord Injury in Dogs Using Amniotic Membrane-Derived Stem Cells: Preliminary Results.

INTRODUCTION: Intervertebral disc diseases (IVDD) represent the majority of neurological attendance and responsible for the most cases of paralysis in dogs. Treatments currently used do not show satisfactory results in patients with more severe and chronic neurological manifestations.
METHODS: To promote nerve and muscular recovery, as well as improve quality of life, we aimed to create a double-blind test method, associating spinal decompression surgery and allogeneic transplantation of amniotic membrane-derived stem cells (AMSCs) in dogs with chronic IVDD. Cells were characterized as fetal mesenchymal cells and safe for application. Eight animals completed the experiment: stem cell applications were made in four animals that had previously undergone an unsuccessful surgical procedure ("SC group", n = 4); two animals were submitted to surgery, followed by applications of stem cells ("Surgery + SC", n = 2); two other animals were submitted to surgery, followed by the application of saline solution ("Surgery + placebo", n = 2). During the surgical procedure, a topical application was performed on the lesion and after fifteen and forty-five days another two applications were made via epidural. Animals were monitored biweekly and reassessed three months after surgery, by functional tests and magnetic resonance exams.
RESULTS: Some animals presented significant neurological improvement, such as the recovery of nociception and ability to remain on station. Despite the need further studies, until the present moment, cell therapy has been feasible and has no harmful effects on animals.
CONCLUSION: The protocol of preclinical trial showed the association with decompressive surgery and cell transplantation in dogs with thoracolumbar IVDD proved feasible, and it was possible to observe neurological improvement after treatment. No tissue improvement through MRI was found. The double-blind test guaranteed reliability of the evaluations and results obtained that, even with a small sample size, generated satisfactory results for the animals and owners.

Introduction

Intervertebral disc disease (IVDD) is one of the most common causes of spinal cord compression and is responsible for most cases of paralysis in dogs. IVDD is characterized by the degeneration of the intervertebral disc and a neurological syndrome of compressive and/or contusive injury of the spinal cord that occurs due to the displacement of the disc or parts of it to the vertebral canal in a process known as herniation.1 According to Hansen,2 IVDD can be classified into two types: Hansen type I, characterized by extrusion of the material of the nucleus pulposus into the vertebral canal, where it will cause spinal cord compression; and Hansen type II, resulting from the deformation of the disc, which causes the disc to protrude into the medullary canal. Recently, at least three other types of herniated discs have been described: hydrated nucleus pulposus extrusion; acute non-compressive nucleus pulposus extrusion; and intradural/intramedullary intervertebral disc extrusion.3

Olby et al4 developed a functional 0- to 14-point scale that evaluates gait, locomotor improvement and tail movement. A neurological exam was also performed, where mental status and behavior, body posture, gait, postural reactions, and cranial nerve and spinal reflexes were evaluated. The treatment of choice for animals affected by these conditions is based on decompressive surgical techniques, conservative treatment or rehabilitation. However, for the most severe patients, in almost 50% of cases, these treatments are still ineffective.5

The use of stem cells in regenerative therapy has raised positive expectations, specially the mesenchymal, that are easy to isolate and expand and differentiate into various lineages, allowing wide use for therapy regenerative.6,7 Owing to these expectations, several experimental models are being tested at both the molecular and preclinical levels to resolve doubts regarding the actual efficacy of the therapy, possible complications of its application, and especially the carcinogenic potential of these cells.8 These stem cells have characteristics of precursor cells and can be differentiated into several cell types and replicated.9 Thus, cell therapy has provided hope in the treatment of spinal cord injuries.10–18

The placenta performs primordial functions in the embryonic development of mammals since it is responsible for the protection, nutrition and oxygenation of fetuses. It consists of four membranes: the chorion, allantois, yolk sac and amnion.19,68

Amniotic stem cells demonstrate high plasticity and are able to self-renew and differentiate in vitro into chondrogenic, adipogenic and osteogenic lines.20–27 Gene expression and tumorigenic tests were performed on Balb/c nude mice and showed no evidence of tumor formation at 60 days after the application of amniotic stem cells, which were shown to be safe for application in this animal model.27

Due to its immunomodulatory, anti-inflammatory, and regenerative effects, it is believed that cellular therapy is able to promote the modulation of the neuroinflammatory response28 and consequently of the glial scar, promoting functional and neurological improvement in animals.

In addition, this is the first study in veterinary medicine to use stem cells derived from the amniotic membrane in dogs with chronic non-iatrogenic spinal cord injury, representing a major innovation in the area, which can be translated to other species.

Materials and Methods

Ethics Statement

The use of stem cells and animals for this experiment has been approved by the Animal Ethics Committee of the Faculty of Animal Science and Food Engineering of the University of São Paulo, under protocol CEUA nº. 2274160216. Best practice guidelines for veterinary care were followed.

Isolation, Culture and Cellular Cryopreservation

Canine amniotic membrane stem cells were derived from a single elective ovariosalpingohysterectomy at approximately 50 to 60 days of gestation, as observed in Figure 1. The material was obtained from castration campaigns.

Figure 1

Isolation and cell culture. Final gestational-stage fetus, enveloped by amniotic membrane. The material was obtained from castration campaigns. Dissection was performed with sterile material followed by washing with phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) solution containing antibiotic.

The isolation and cell culture protocol was adapted from Soncini et al29 and Lange-Consiglio et al.24 In a sterile laminar flow hood, the amniotic membrane was separated from the other fetal membranes and washed thoroughly with sterile PBS solution containing 2% penicillin/streptomycin and 1% amphotericin. The entire membrane was subjected to pre-digestion in dispase (2.4 U/mL) at 38.5 °C for 9 minutes. After this process, the samples were centrifuged at 200 x g for 5 minutes. The pellet was resuspended in 0.1% collagenase and incubated at 38.5 °C for 3 hours. The mixture was centrifuged at 200 x g for 10 minutes, and its supernatant was discarded. Ten milliliters of α-MEM supplemented with 10% FBS and 1% penicillin/streptomycin was added, and this combination was passed through a 100 μm filter and plated in 25 cm2 tissue culture flasks. The material contained in the filter was collected and subjected to enzymatic digestion by trypsin at 38.5 °C for 2 minutes. The digestion product was centrifuged at 200 x g for 10 minutes, and the pellet was plated. The flasks were incubated at 38.5 °C with 5% CO2 in an 80% relative humidity atmosphere. The cells were maintained until approximately 80% confluence (visual analysis by inverted microscopy).

In the cell passage process, the culture medium was discarded, 3 mL trypsin, previously heated in a water bath at 38 °C, was added, and the bottle was kept in an incubator at 38.5 °C. After a period of 3 to 5 minutes, the culture was evaluated by microscopy, and when no more cells were adhered, the resuspended cells were transferred to 15 mL Falcon-type tubes. More culture medium was added to the flask to perform a wash to aid in the removal of some cells that were still adhered, and later, that suspension was added to the tube corresponding to the respective bottle. The mixture was centrifuged at 200 x g for 5 minutes. The supernatant was discarded, and the pellet was resuspended and replenished until it reached P2 or was cryopreserved.

For cryopreservation, the cells were trypsinized, resuspended in 1 mL of αMEM medium, counted in a Neubauer chamber and aliquoted so that each cryotube contained 2.5×106 cells diluted in 450 μL DMEM F12 medium, 450 μL FBS and 100 μL DMSO. The cells were kept overnight in a Mr. Frosty container at −80 °C. After this period, the samples were transferred to a liquid nitrogen canister, where they were stored until use.

These cells were previously characterized by our group and published by Cardoso et al27 where they proved safe for application, according to the genetic expression and tumorigenic tests performed in Balb/c mice. The cells were prepared according to the protocol stipulated by Feitosa et al.13

Two random cryotubes were withdrawn from the liquid nitrogen and kept in a water bath at approximately 37 °C for 2 minutes. The contents were transferred to 15 mL Falcon-type tubes, added to 1 mL of saline solution and centrifuged at 200 x g for 5 minutes. The supernatant was discarded, and the pellet was resuspended in 1 mL of saline solution and again centrifuged at 200 x g for 5 minutes. The pellet resulting from the procedure was resuspended in 1 mL of saline solution. Ten microliters of the final suspension were homogenized with 10 μL of trypan blue dye and counted in a Neubauer chamber, totaling approximately 2×106 viable cells (80% viability).

The same protocol was performed as described above prior to the applications. The pellets were resuspended in 1 mL of saline solution and aspirated by an insulin syringe. For the placebo, the syringe was filled with 1 mL of saline solution. The solutions were inoculated in each animal according to the group to which the animal belonged.

Experimental Design

Twelve dogs that had chronic thoracolumbar IVDD for over one year, diagnosed clinically, through anamnesis, specific clinical examination, functional and neurological evaluation by the Olby scale4 and magnetic resonance imaging, were selected following a double-blinded protocol. Animals that presented other neurological diseases or any type of spinal trauma other than the lesion described previously were not included in the project. Twelve dogs were selected: 7 females and 5 males, age between 3 and 10 years old, with IVDD chronic from 12 to 17 months.

The owners of the selected animals signed a Free and Informed Consent Form, where they were informed about all the stages of the project, as well as their rights and duties. Four animals had already undergone to unsuccessfully decompressive surgery before, at least 12 months before. All these animals were included in the “group Stem Cells (SC)”. The other eight dogs that had IVDD for over 1 year with no previous surgical intervention were randomly divided into the “surgery + SC” group or the “surgery + placebo” group. For the assignment, four envelopes containing the word “cell therapy” inside and four containing the word “placebo” were produced and kept with one person on the team who managed the cells and delivered them during the experimental surgery. The owners chose one of the sealed envelopes and delivered it to the researcher, who prepared the syringe with either stem cells or saline solution. All the rest of the team members, including the PI, master’s degree students, surgeon, person who evaluated the outcomes and owner, were blinded to the group assignment. At the end of the experiment, the groups to which the animals belonged were revealed.

The dogs were distributed among three groups:

“SC group” (n=4): where the epidural applications of stem cells were performed on days 0, 15 and 45 in animals previously subjected to decompressive surgery;

“Surgery + SC” (n=4): where the stem cells were applied topically during decompressive surgery (day 0) and at 15 and 45 days after decompression by epidural injection, totaling 3 applications;

“Surgery + placebo” (n=4): The saline solution was applied under the same conditions as in the previous group.

Three months after the initial treatment, the MRI (magnetic resonance imaging) scans performed initially were repeated for comparison. Functional and neurological examinations repeated biweekly, as well as magnetic resonance imaging, provided qualitative results.

Functional and Neurological Evaluation

In addition to the detailed anamnesis and general clinical examination, the animals underwent biweekly functional and neurological evaluation, where their reflexes and motor abilities were scored based on the scale developed by Olby et al.4

A neurological exam was also performed, where we evaluated mental status and behavior (alert, depressed, stuporous, comatose), body posture (abnormal head position; abnormal posture, such as decerebrate or decerebellate rigidity, Schiff-Sherrington posture, kyphosis, lordosis, scoliosis, plantigrade, palmigrade), gait (lameness; ataxia; paresis/paralysis; abnormal movements, such as tremor, myotonia, or myoclonus), postural reactions (proprioceptive positioning, hopping, placing response), and cranial nerves and spinal reflexes (muscle tone, muscle reflex, patellar reflex, withdrawal reflex, nociception, perineal reflex).

Magnetic Resonance Imaging

The imaging findings of discopathies were calcification of the disc or nucleus pulposus, which is associated with the development of the intervertebral foramina, reduction in the intervertebral space, and radiopacity of the intervertebral foramina.30–35

For MRI exams, animals were previously anaesthetized and subjected to orotracheal intubation (propofol 6 mg/kg/EV, followed by maintenance with inhaled isoflurane 1%). The animals were maintained on fluid therapy with saline solution and monitored throughout the procedure through capnography, pulse oximetry, invasive blood pressure monitoring and cardiorespiratory frequency on an electrocardiogram monitor.

Animals were placed in the lateral recumbency position in the equipment (Vet-MR Grande XP – Esaote S.p.A., 0.25 Tesla-strength - Florence, Italy). The following sequences were performed: sagittal fast spin echo T2 (FSE T2), sagittal fast fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR), sagittal stir, transverse spin echo T2 (FSE T2), sagittal spin echo T2 (SE T1), sagittal gradient echo T2 (GE T2) and transverse spin echo T1 (SE T1) when there was a need for contrast application. In the sagittal sequences, the field of view (FOV) was approximately 24 cm, with 3-millimetre-thick slices and 0 space, while in the transverse sequences, the FOV was approximately 20 cm, with 4 mm slices and 0 space.

Cell Therapy

Immediately after the MRI, the animals in the “SC group”, which had been subjected to previous decompressive surgery, underwent the placement of epidural catheters in the lumbosacral space. A confirmation of the Tuohy needle placement in the lumbosacral epidural space was performed through the “loss of resistance” and “drop” tests. The catheter was filled with saline solution and introduced into the site of the lesion where 2×106 stem cells were injected, as observed in Figure 2A.

Figure 2

Cell therapy. (A) catheter introduced into the site of the lesion for cell injection. (B) The “hanging drop” technique, to identify the position of the needle tip within the extradural space. (C) Stem cells diluted in 1 mL applied into the extradural space.

In dogs that underwent surgery, the “surgery + SC” group, the first application of 2×106 stem cells was performed by dripping on the lesion during the procedure, followed by two epidural applications fifteen and forty-five days after surgical decompression. In dogs in the “surgery + placebo” group, only 1 mL of saline solution was applied under the same conditions as in the previous group. Applications were performed in the L7-S1 intervertebral space, as shown in Figure 2B and C.

Decompressive Surgical Procedure

Standard protocols of analgesia and anesthesia (propofol 6 mg/kg/EV, followed by maintenance with inhaled isoflurane 1%) were followed for surgical techniques and postoperative recovery.

In all animals in the “surgery + placebo” and “surgery + SC” groups, the hemilaminectomy procedure was performed, since it is the most commonly used technique in cases of thoracolumbar syndromes; it is associated with better spinal cord decompression results and removal of extruded material, as well as higher rates of postoperative neurological recovery, a lower risk of fibrosis formation, and lower rates of mechanical instability.1

The surgical procedure was based on the removal of the lateral and dorsolateral lamina, pedicles and articular facets. When access was achieved, the spinal cord was exposed to achieve good visualization of the nerves and vessels, allowing delicate and safe removal of only the extruded material and avoiding manipulation of the spinal cord.36

After the procedure, the animals remained under observation until recovery from anesthesia, and then, they were discharged with prescriptions for anti-inflammatory agents and oral analgesics (Tramadol 4mg/kg; dexamethasone 1mg/kg; Ranitidine 2mg/kg; Cephalexin 20mg/kg). The postoperative recovery was monitored at a distance, and after 15 days, the animals returned to the clinic for suture removal and a second application of solution.

Results

All the stem cells used in the present study were obtained from a single bitch with a total of six fetuses, all in the final gestational stage. A dissection of the amniotic membrane was performed. All protocols to characterize and evaluate the quality of cells were performed routinely by our group. The cells were cryopreserved in the second passage in a total of 52 cryotubes, which remained in liquid nitrogen until use.

From May to July 2016, more than 200 owners of paraplegic dogs signed up to voluntarily participate in the project. A pre-screening was performed through a review of the patient history and previous exams. Of these, more than 40 were selected for preliminary functional and neurological evaluation. Twelve animals were selected according to the similarity of clinical signs and at least 12 months of chronicity (Table 1).

Table 1

Demographic Distribution of Selected Animals

Group	Animal	Gender	Age (YO)	Location of IVDD	Chronicity (M)	Olby Score Day 0	Olby Score Day 90	Outcome
SC	1	F	8	L3-4	14	0	0	No improvement
	2	M	5	L2-3/L3-4	12	0	4	Improved
	3	M	3	T12-13	17	0	10	Improved
	4	F	10	T10-11	12	0	0	No improvement
SURGERY + SC	5	F	7	T11-12/T13-L1	14	0	0	No improvement
	6	F	10	T11-12	12	0	9	Improved
	7	M	7	L3-4	18	0	-	Withdrawn
	8	M	13	L2-3	13	0	-	Excluded
SURGERY + PLACEBO	9	M	4	T11-12/T13-L1	13	0	0	No improvement
	10	M	3	T12-13		0	0	No improvement
	11	M	7	T12-13/T13-L1	16	0	-	Withdrawn
	12	F	5	L1-2/L2-3	15	0	-	Withdrawn

Abbreviations: SC, stem cell; M, male; F, female; yo, years old; IVDD, intervertebral disc disease; m, months.

Of the twelve selected animals, three dogs were withdrawn from the study, and one dog had a car accident and was eliminated from the project, as shown in Figure 3. Therefore, eight selected dogs completed the proposed protocol, 4 males and 4 females, of mixed breeds and small size, with paraplegia secondary to thoracolumbar disc herniation and the absence of deep pain. The oldest animal was 10 years old, and the youngest was 3 years old. All patients had paraplegia for an average of 1 year and 4 months at the time of selection.

Figure 3

Diagram of protocol: Experimental design and group organization.

All animals subjected to surgery and/or stem cell application presented no adverse effects, tumors or worsening of the condition.

Outcomes

First, the animals were evaluated biweekly. However, most of the owners did not attend the scheduled dates, so some animals were evaluated every three weeks. This pattern of evaluation was not detrimental, since even after a longer period, the results remained the same as those of previous evaluations. Four animals in the SC group initially had an Olby scale score of 0. As shown in the chart below, one of the animals progressed to score 8, as it reacquired the deep pain reflex and was able to perform protraction with weight support more than 50% of the time, while animal 2 presented voluntary tail movement.

One of the animals subjected to surgery and cell therapy did not show any improvement. The other animal showed significant improvement, managed to put himself in position to feed himself and took some voluntary steps when supported, even without being fed. He was referred to physical therapy after the project and has been making progress.

Among the animals that received the placebo solution after the surgical procedure, no neurological improvement according to Olby’s scale was noticed. However, one of the animals started to drag differently, presenting scabs in places where they had not previously. The owners of this dog still reported that the dog started to “warn” when there was a need to urinate.

All those clinical outcomes are expressed in Figure 4.

Figure 4

Clinical outcomes. Clinical outcomes of all the animals, were animal 1–4 represents SC group; animal 5–6 are from surgery + SC; and animal 7–8 are surgery + placebo group.

In MRI scans of the group that had previously undergone the surgical procedure (Figure 5), it was possible to observe hypo- and hyperintense areas through the dorsal soft tissues, suggestive of the surgical scar, and the loss of signal intensity from the nucleus pulposus of intervertebral discs, suggesting dehydration and disc degeneration. In some of the animals, it was still possible to observe the loss of the definition of the ventral column of the cerebrospinal fluid and dorsal displacement of the adjacent spinal cord, characteristic of disc protrusion, even after the previous decompression procedure. There was no change in the images taken after D90 in this group.

Figure 5

Magnetic resonance imaging. Significant areas of hypointense signal and disc degeneration in the sagittal (A) and transverse (B) sections from animals from the surgery group.

In all the animals that underwent the decompression procedure, a metal-compatible image artefact was observed. This image artefact possibly resulted from filings derived from the wear of the surgical milling cutter in contact with the free stripper, used to prevent and protect structures during bone wear. Because of this artefact, the images were inappropriate for evaluation.

Clinical Outcomes

As observed in , prior to cell therapy, the animal had no deep pain or proprioception. Ninety days after the application of stem cells, the animal regained nociception and proprioception, which allowed him to walk again. The dog was referred to physical therapy, where it remains in treatment to improve its movements.

Discussion

Stem cells receive a great deal of attention because of their regenerative potential and their possible use in regenerative therapy, including xenogeneic transplants,37–39 due to their immunomodulatory properties, which are also therapeutic assets.40 Stem cells have shown promising results in several species and in spinal cord injuries.10–13

Amniotic membrane stem cells are easy to obtain, culture, expand and use;15,41,42 they involve little ethical concern since they are derived from a material that is discarded, and their use for research purposes can possibly be expanded to human species. They present good results when used in the treatment of chronic kidney disease,43 infertility,44 ophthalmic lesions,45,46 burns and skin wounds,47,48 osteoarthritis,49 fasciitis and tendinitis,50 ligament injuries51 and nervous pathologies.52 However, this cell type is still little explored in the treatment of spinal cord injuries in dogs,37,39 and our work is the first to use them in dogs with chronic, non-iatrogenic intervertebral disc disease.

Many papers used the lineage previously characterized, which proved to be safe for in vivo application.27,53 The animals in the present study were followed up, even after 90 days. To date, cell therapy has proven to be feasible, with no adverse effects.

In a study conducted by Sankar et al37 the efficiency of stem cells derived from the human amniotic membrane was tested when applied in iatrogenic spinal cord injury in monkeys. Good interaction of the cells with the nervous tissue and significant remyelination, as well as their capacity to modulate the glial scar, were observed; however, no clinical improvement was observed at the 60-day evaluation.

A similar study, conducted by Wu et al54 evaluated the application of the same cells in rats. The histopathological findings were similar; however, the animals showed clinical improvement, including a return of the motor function of the pelvic limbs.

Nevertheless, Meng et al39 confirmed, through electrophysiological and immunohistological analysis, the success of the co-transplantation of stem cells from the amniotic membrane of rats with fibroblast growth factor and stem cells of neuronal origin in rats with chronic spinal cord injury. The results demonstrated that there was significant locomotor improvement in addition to neuronal survival and differentiation, suggesting that these sources may be beneficial in the treatment of spinal cord injuries. Hemilaminectomy is an elective procedure since it preserves the mechanical and structural integrity of the spine, is less traumatic, and reduces the chances of scar formation that compresses the spinal cord. In addition, access to the disc is better, and fenestration is performed in an easier way.36,55

The fenestration of the affected disc, as well as the discs anterior and posterior to it, is still a discussion among authors and surgeons. While some consider it the appropriate practice, as it allows the removal of remnants of the extruded material in the intervertebral space and the prevention of the recurrence of the frame,1,56,57 others consider it unnecessary, since the recurrence rate of herniation in animals that have not undergone fenestration is rare (less than 5%). Among the animals that had already undergone decompression procedures, none experienced disc fenestration, and two presented significant improvements. However, on magnetic resonance imaging, it was possible to observe that there were still signs of compression, which may have impaired their improvement.

Many professionals still believe that decompression is ineffective if it occurs after a period of 72 hours after the loss of nociception. Such a belief has already been disproven by studies such as those of Scott and McKee,58 Olby et al59 Kazakos et al60 and Arias et al.61 One of the animals that received the stem cell solution after surgery presented improvement. However, due to the small sample size, we cannot determine whether this improvement was due to the decompression procedure, cellular therapy or the combination of both.

Animals with chronic lesions, in addition to the glial scar, which is an anatomical barrier to nerve regeneration,62 also have evident muscular deficits. The animals that presented neurological improvement could have recovered voluntary movement if they had undergone physiotherapy and exercises to gain muscle mass.63

Unfortunately, even after very rigorous selection, some owners chose to withdraw from the project for several reasons. This left us with an even smaller sample. However, due to the high costs of the exams and procedures involved in the project, it would not be possible to achieve the necessary sample size for the results to be statistically significant. Therefore, there is a need for more studies to prove that the therapy is, in fact, beneficial. Even in randomized studies performed at exemplary institutions by experienced researchers, the desired sample size was not reached. For example, in research conducted by Lim et al64 only 13 of the 19 dogs completed the project; in a study conducted by Tsai et al65 36 out of 40 completed the project; and in a study conducted by Olby et al66 94 of 150 dogs completed the project. Another recent experiment in dogs showed tooth stem cells were associated with electroacupuncture with benefits to the animals.67

However, when the owners are provided clarifications about the risks, odds and benefits involved with the therapy, even if there are animals that do not show improvement, this type of alternative therapy is worth pursuing in an attempt to at least promote the well-being of these animals and restore some physiological functions.

Conclusion

The protocol of preclinical trial showed feasible to create a canine amniotic membrane stem cell bank from the final gestational stage.

The protocol associated with decompressive surgery and cell transplantation in these dogs with chronic thoracolumbar IVDD proved feasible, and it was possible to observe neurological improvement in some animals after treatment, such as proprioceptive ability and the return of nociception.

It was not possible to analyze the tissue improvement through MRI, since the surgery resulted in artefacts of images that did not allow its evaluation.

Despite being very laborious, the performance of the double-blind test guaranteed reliability of the evaluations and results obtained that, even with a small sample size, generated satisfactory results for the team and the owners. Further research is needed with a larger number of animals but this blinded preclinical trial showed improved of quality life in animal and owners.