| Literature DB >> 34702957 |
Danielle Cazabon1, Margaret Farrell2, Reena Gupta3, Lindsay Joseph2, Anupam Khungar Pathni4, Swagata Sahoo4, Abhishek Kunwar5, Kate Elliott2, Jennifer Cohn2,6, Thomas R Frieden2, Andrew E Moran2,7.
Abstract
Hypertension is the leading single preventable risk factor for death worldwide, and most of the disease burden attributed to hypertension weighs on low-and middle-income countries. Effective large-scale public health hypertension control programs are needed to control hypertension globally. National programs can follow six important steps to launch a successful national-scale hypertension control program: establish an administrative structure and survey current resources, select a standard hypertension treatment protocol, ensure supply of medication and blood pressure devices, train health care workers to measure blood pressure and control hypertension, implement an information system for monitoring patients and the program overall, and enroll and monitor patients with phased program expansion. Resolve to Save Lives, an initiative of global public health organization Vital Strategies, and its partners organized these six key steps and materials into a structured, stepwise guide to establish best practices in hypertension program design, launch, maintenance, and scale-up.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34702957 PMCID: PMC8545775 DOI: 10.1038/s41371-021-00612-6
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Hum Hypertens ISSN: 0950-9240 Impact factor: 2.877
Fig. 1Overview of the Six-Step Guide for National Hypertension Control Programs.
The six steps of hypertension control program implementation are presented in chronological order with a sample timeline. The timeline may vary based on specific national or subnational contexts.
Step 1: Resources for establishing administrative structure and to survey current resources.
| Sub-step | Task | Description | General tools and templates |
|---|---|---|---|
| Step 1A | Establish a memorandum of understanding (MOU) | This MOU (or equivalent agreement) is established between partner organization(s) and government entities that are collaborating on the HTN control program. | Memorandum of understanding template [ |
| Step 1B | Establish relevant contracts | Contracts can be created to legally bind partners to roles and expectations related to the program and for essential program components such as staffing and workspace. | |
| Step 1C | Form a technical working group | A working group will provide technical decision-making. | Guidelines on developing strategic advisory committee [ |
| Step 1D | Survey current resources and care delivery models | A baseline survey documents existing staff numbers, antihypertensive medications and BP measurement devices at the national level and the program scope of work. A situation analysis includes workflow planning related to treatment initiation and titration in new patients, along with a differentiated service delivery plan for delivering long-term treatment and retention care for stable controlled patients. | Baseline facility checklist [ Tool for situation analysisa |
| Step 1E | Budgeting | The budget should be comprehensive, including both product and operational elements for program start-up and maintenance | Program costing toola |
aDevelopment in progress.
Step 2: Resources for selecting a standard hypertension treatment protocol.
| Sub-Step | Task | Description | General tools and templates | Country-specific examples |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Step 2A | Convene a consensus conference to discuss and agree upon a drug and dose-specific treatment protocol. | Convene the technical working group and any other relevant stakeholders (e.g., MOH officials). Larger countries may opt to establish subnational conferences and protocols, e.g., provincial-level protocols. | WHO HEARTS Evidence-based treatment protocols module [ WHO tool for the development of a consensus protocol for treatment of HTN [ Simple, practical HTN treatment protocols (English, Spanish, Chinese) [ | Ethiopia Hypertension Prevention and Control project Consensus Planning Meeting Agenda [ |
| Step 2B | Secure stakeholder approval of protocol | All relevant stakeholders should approve the protocol. Typically, the MOH will have final approval. | ||
| Step 2C | Format and distribute protocol document | The protocol document should have a simple, clear design that lends itself to a poster, job aid or handout. It will be distributed at the facility level for display. | Calcium channel blocker initial monotherapy as first-line treatment [ Single pill combination as first-line treatment [ | Treatment protocols: [ Bangladesh Henan, China Ethiopia Kerala, India Madhya Pradesh, India Punjab, India Nigeria Philippines PAHO countries [ |
Fig. 2Two examples of simple hypertension treatment protocols for use at the primary care level.
Initial single-drug or “monotherapy” protocol (Panel A) and initial dual-drug combination therapy protocol (Panel B). Note that single pill combinations can be deployed at protocol step 2 (dual-drug combination therapy) and at protocol step 3 (triple-drug combination therapy) in the Panel A protocol (initial monotherapy). Dual-drug combination therapy and triple-drug combination therapy can be deployed at steps 1 and 3, respectively, in the Panel B protocol (initial dual-drug combination therapy).
Step 3: Resources to ensure a start-up supply of medications and blood pressure measurement devices.
| Sub-step | Task | Description | General tools and templates | Country-specific examples |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Step 3A | Inventory current medications | Conduct an inventory survey. The inventory should include medications at the store and facility level. | Baseline facility checklist [ | |
| Step 3B | Inventory current BP devices | Conduct an inventory survey at the facility level. | Baseline facility checklist [ | |
| Step 3C | Forecast medication needs | Program supervisors work with facility level managers to project future needs. Initial drug supply forecasting should incorporate program growth scenarios. Forecasting should also plan for multi-month refills (six months or longer) for patients with stable, controlled blood pressure. | Forecasting tool template [ | Medication forecasting examples [ |
| Step 3D | Forecast BP device needs | Program supervisors work with facility-level managers to identify any gaps and project future needs of BP devices. | Blood pressure device forecasting for opportunistic screening [ | |
| Step 3E | Procure and monitor medications | Assess the current procurement process and consider alternative options as relevant. Monitor medications on a regular basis and reorder as appropriate. Stock should never fall below a 3-month supply. | Johns Hopkins University Global Hypertension Course (Module 5) [ | |
| Step 3F | Procure BP devices | Assess the current procurement process for BP devices and consider alternative options as relevant | How to choose an automated device [ Selecting BP devices [ Automated digital BP devices fact sheet [ WHO technical specifications for automated non-invasive BP measuring devices with cuff [ Suggested Requirements for External Validation Studies [ A 90-second primer on automated digital BP monitors [ Blood pressure measurement device selection in low‐resource settings: Challenges, compromises, and routes to progress [ | Example of a request for proposal for blood pressure devices [ |
| 3G | Utilize and strengthen supply chains | Strengthen supply chain for medicine distribution and establish procedures for monitoring and refilling medication inventory. | Drug stock tool—Template [ | Drug stock tool- Example (India) [ Min-Max inventory guidance [ Daily consumption record [ Ready reckoner job aid [ |
Step 4. Resources to train health care workers and activate health system supervisors.
| Sub-step | Task | Description | General tools and templates | Country-specific examples |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Step 4A | Develop training materials | When developing materials, consider adapting pre-existing training materials of good quality. | CDC Hypertension Management Training Curriculum [ PAHO Course: Management of hypertension for primary care team [ Johns Hopkins University Course: Fundamentals for Implementing a Hypertension Program in Resource-Constrained Settings [ Training Materials for Simple Application [ Training materials for implementing differentiated service delivery models for patients with stably controlled hypertensiona | India Hypertension Control Initiative Training Manual [ |
| Step 4B | Train program supervisors | A Training of Trainers program includes individuals such as facility managers and program coordinators, who in turn will train health care workers in their facilities. It is recommended to include a review of program goals as a part of the training. | Training of trainers agenda- Sample template [ | |
| Step 4C | Train health care workers | Supervisors facilitate practical training for health care workers. | BP measurement checklist [ Preparing an individual for BP measurement [ Why Hypertension is an important issue [ How to diagnose hypertension [ What to do after a diagnosis of hypertension [ Resolve to Save Lives Hypertension FAQs [ Hypertension differentiated service delivery toolkita | |
| Step 4D | Establish process for facility-level monitoring and mentorship. | Create a standard form recording intervention fidelity and practice supportive supervision. | Facility checklist – Follow-up visit (card) [ Supervisory visit facility form [ |
aDevelopment in progress.
Step 5: Resources to implement an information system for monitoring (digital or paper-based information system).
| Sub-step | Task | Description | General tool and templates | Country-specific examples |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Step 5A | Establish HTN indicators | Establish program indicators based on the HEARTS Systems for monitoring module indicators. | WHO HEARTS Systems for monitoring module [ Resolve to Save Lives Indicators [ Differentiated service delivery indicatorsa | |
| Step 5B | Create portable patient hypertension record | The patient card records patient information, cardiovascular health history, hypertension treatment dates, BP measurements and medications. If information system is digital, include a QR code on the patient card if technology allows. | Paper-based: India Hypertension Control Initiative Simple App digital patient record [ Digital: India Hypertension Control Initiative non-digital hypertension patient treatment card [ | |
| Step 5C | Establish process for monitoring and evaluation | Establish a method for calculating indicators. Plan to examine trends in key indicators and establish feedback loops for quality improvement. Ensure data security and privacy, as well as quality control. | Simplified Indicator Calculator [ Ten Guiding Principles for Data Collection, Storage, Sharing, and Use to Ensure Security and Confidentiality [ Standards to Facilitate Data Sharing and Use of Surveillance Data for Public Health Action [ | Country X Example: Simplified Indicator Calculator [ |
| Step 5D | Establish process and timeline for reporting and dissemination of results. | Prepare reports summarizing indicators. Disseminate reports to key stakeholders. Stakeholders could vary by program but may include national or subnational government officials, donors, civil society groups, academic community, patients. | Paper based: India Hypertension Control Initiative registry, annual & quarterly report (non-digital) [ Digital: Simple application - Hypertension management dashboard [ |
aDevelopment in progress.
Fig. 3Resolve to Save Lives Simple app hypertension program management dashboard example.
Includes control rates, loss-to-follow-up rates, and compares facility performance.
Step 6: Resources to guide patient enrollment and observe the program in a pilot setting.
| Sub-step | Task | Description | General tools and templates | Country-specific examples |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Step 6A | Opportunistic screening | Encourage placement of BP devices in highly trafficked areas of health care facilities so that all patients receive a BP measurement at registration. Establish new patient referral linkages from district hospital facilities to local primary care facilities. | ||
| Step 6B | Manage existing HTN patients | Establish a standardized system for patient follow-up during treatment initiation and for patients with stably controlled BP. Consider implementing a team-based care model, which can alleviate shortages of medical doctors and nurses and allow more decentralized care. | Line-lists and follow-up systems to retain patients in care during treatment initiationa Standard operating procedures for implementing differentiated service delivery models for retaining stably controlled patients in carea WHO HEARTS Team-based care module [ Task sharing with non-physician health care workers for management of blood pressure in low-income and middle-income countries [ | Innovations to Sustain Non-Communicable Disease Services in the Context of COVID-19: Report from Pakkred District, Nonthaburi Province, Thailand [ Community drug distribution at doorsteps: Essential health services decentralized to care for hypertensives under the India Hypertension Control Initiative [ |
| Step 6C | Community-based screening and management | Identify well-trafficked locations or events in the community where community health care workers can conduct screening. Establish new patient referral linkages and lost-to-follow-up patient retrieval process from community to local primary care facilities. Consider house-to-house hypertension screening. Consider delivering hypertension treatment in the community through a differentiated service approach that provides medications and monitoring in the community and fewer clinic visits for stably controlled patients. | Hypertension Control in Integrated HIV and chronic disease clinics in Uganda in the SEARCH study [ |
aDevelopment in progress.
Ongoing challenges in existing hypertension programs and corresponding solutions.
| Step | Challenge | Solution |
|---|---|---|
| 1→ Establishing administrative structure | • Transitioning from donor-funded program to government-owned program. | • Jointly implement program with ministry of health from program start. • Develop a transition plan that considers roles, responsibilities, and budgeting for products and services long-term. |
| 2 → Treatment protocols | • Converging on a universal treatment protocol. | • Build evidence for treatment protocols through demonstration programs. |
| 3→ Medications and BP devices | • Medication stock-outs • Limited uptake of fixed dose combination medications. • Variable medication quality and affordability • Lack of availability of validated BP devices. • Poor awareness among providers and program managers of the importance of BP device validation. • High cost of BP devices. | • Market shaping to reduce prices of fixed dose combination antihypertensive medications. • Strengthen procurement and supply chains in LMICs. • Build capacity of ministry of health staff to forecast medication supply needs. • Advocate for reduced out-of-pocket medication fees for patients • Advocate for coverage of NCD medications and services under national health insurance schemes. |
| 4→ Training of health care workers and supervision | • Learnings from training not being implemented or sustained. • Need for frequent trainings due to frequent turnover of staff. | • Assess the impact of training and areas for improvement. • Conduct refresher training. • Provide ongoing clinical mentorship. • Expand training to include community health workers, patient champions, and community-based providers. |
| 5→ Information systems | • Lack of electronic health records • Limited use of data for program improvement. | • Government investment in electronic health records. • Build capacity for continuous quality improvement utilizing program data. • Include key hypertension control indicators in program reviews at national/subnational levels. |
| 6→ Enroll patients and pilot | • Transitioning from pilot projects to scale-up. • Lack of human resources for scale-up. | • Scale-up team-based care through capacity building of existing health care workers and training new cadres of health care workers. • Roll-out packages of differentiated service delivery specific to location context. • Government investment in hypertension care. |