M Eugenia Pérez-Ojeda1,2, Edison Castro3, Claudia Kröckel1,2, Matteo Andrea Lucherelli4, Ursula Ludacka5, Jani Kotakoski5, Katharina Werbach5, Herwig Peterlik5, Manuel Melle-Franco6, Julio C Chacón-Torres7, Frank Hauke1,2, Luis Echegoyen3, Andreas Hirsch1,2, Gonzalo Abellán4. 1. Department of Chemistry and Pharmacy, Chair of Organic Chamistry II, Friedrich-Alexander University of Erlangen-Nuremberg, Nikolaus-Fiebiger-Str. 10, 91058 Erlangen, Germany. 2. Joint Institute of Advanced Materials and Processes (ZMP), Friedrich-Alexander University of Erlangen-Nuremberg, Dr.-Mack-Str. 81, D-90762 Fürth, Germany. 3. Department of Chemistry, University of Texas at El Paso, El Paso, Texas 79968, United States. 4. Instituto de Ciencia Molecular, Universidad de Valencia, Catedrático José Beltrán 2, 46980 Paterna, Spain. 5. Faculty of Physics, University of Vienna, Boltzmanngasse 5, 1090 Vienna, Austria. 6. CICECO-Aveiro Institute of Materials, Department of Chemistry, University of Aveiro, 3810-193, Aveiro, Portugal. 7. School of Physical Sciences and Nanotechnology, Yachay Tech University, 100119-Urcuquí, Ecuador.
Abstract
Herein we report the synthesis of covalently functionalized carbon nano-onions (CNOs) via a reductive approach using unprecedented alkali-metal CNO intercalation compounds. For the first time, an in situ Raman study of the controlled intercalation process with potassium has been carried out revealing a Fano resonance in highly doped CNOs. The intercalation was further confirmed by electron energy loss spectroscopy and X-ray diffraction. Moreover, the experimental results have been rationalized with DFT calculations. Covalently functionalized CNO derivatives were synthesized by using phenyl iodide and n-hexyl iodide as electrophiles in model nucleophilic substitution reactions. The functionalized CNOs were exhaustively characterized by statistical Raman spectroscopy, thermogravimetric analysis coupled with gas chromatography and mass spectrometry, dynamic light scattering, UV-vis, and ATR-FTIR spectroscopies. This work provides important insights into the understanding of the basic principles of reductive CNOs functionalization and will pave the way for the use of CNOs in a wide range of potential applications, such as energy storage, photovoltaics, or molecular electronics.
Herein we report the synthesis of covalently functionalized carbon nano-onions (CNOs) via a reductive approach using unprecedented alkali-metal CNO intercalation compounds. For the first time, an in situ Raman study of the controlled intercalation process with potassium has been carried out revealing a Fano resonance in highly doped CNOs. The intercalation was further confirmed by electron energy loss spectroscopy and X-ray diffraction. Moreover, the experimental results have been rationalized with DFT calculations. Covalently functionalized CNO derivatives were synthesized by using phenyl iodide and n-hexyl iodide as electrophiles in model nucleophilic substitution reactions. The functionalized CNOs were exhaustively characterized by statistical Raman spectroscopy, thermogravimetric analysis coupled with gas chromatography and mass spectrometry, dynamic light scattering, UV-vis, and ATR-FTIR spectroscopies. This work provides important insights into the understanding of the basic principles of reductive CNOs functionalization and will pave the way for the use of CNOs in a wide range of potential applications, such as energy storage, photovoltaics, or molecular electronics.
Since the discovery
of the fullerene C60 in 1985,[1] carbon nanomaterials have been investigated in
different fields such as photovoltaics and biological applications.[2,3] In 1992, Ugarte[4] reported a new allotropic
form of carbon known as carbon nano-onions (CNOs), which were first
observed by Ijima in 1980.[5] These multishell
fullerenes have received considerable attention during the past decade
due to their outstanding properties such as a large surface area to
volume ratio, low densities, and a graphitic multilayer morphology,
which makes them excellent candidates for diverse applications, such
as energy conversion and storage,[6] supercapacitors,[7] solid lubricants,[8,9] and cellular
imaging and theranostics,[10,11] among others.[4,12−15]CNOs can be synthesized through several methods, such as ball
milling,[16] ion implantation,[17] arc discharge,[18] plasma
treatment,[19] chemical vapor deposition,[20] laser ablation,[21] electron irradiation,[22] thermal decomposition
of layered nanoreactors,[23,24] soft-chemistry methods,[25] and thermal
annealing of detonation nanodiamonds (d-NDs) under either vacuum[26] or inert atmosphere.[27,28] The most common method for the synthesis of CNOs is based on the
thermal annealing of d-NDs of about 5 nm diameter under a He atmosphere
at temperatures between 1500 and 1800 °C.[29] Moreover, this method is highly reproducible and CNOs are
obtained in quantitative yields, thus allowing a great potential for
industrial applications.Chemical functionalization has been
extensively explored in order
to modify the interfacial properties and modulate the solubility of
CNOs, representing the most promising route for controlling their
processability.[11,12,29,30] Their degree of functionalization is commonly
associated with the size and strain of the CNOs. Typically, small-size
CNOs (5–10 nm) are more reactive than larger-sized ones due
to their higher curvature, leading to an increase in the pyramidalization
of the C atoms.[28] Different synthetic procedures
for CNO functionalization have been investigated using always neutral
CNOs; however, the unambiguous characterization of the covalent functionalization
in CNOs remains challenging. When it comes to other carbon allotropes,
one of the probably most efficient routes for functionalization is
the reduction using alkali metals as performed in graphite intercalation
compounds (GICs), followed by the quenching of the intermediately
formed graphenides(2,31) with electrophiles.[3,32,33] Concerning the application of
reductive approaches to CNOs, the number of examples is very scarce,
with only one precedent employing a liquid Na–K alloy to activate
the surface of the CNOs prior to the reaction with C16Br.[30] It is important to highlight that CNOs exhibit
great potential as electrode materials in energy storage devices in
which thin-film processing and alkali-metal intercalation are key
aspects; therefore, understanding these processes is a matter of utmost
importance. Moreover, a controlled reductive functionalization would
allow one to envision novel hybrid materials, including covalent intercarbon-allotrope
architectures. However, the solid-state intercalation of CNOs with
potassium and its ulterior functionalization with electrophiles remains
completely unexplored.Herein, we developed the vapor-phase
intercalation of CNOs with
alkali metals using high-vacuum conditions as well as a bulk solid-state
reaction. For the first time, an in situ Raman study
of the controlled intercalation process with potassium has been carried
out in CNOs, revealing the development of a Fano resonance. Moreover,
X-ray diffraction (XRD) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM)
analysis allowed a direct observation of the change in the interlayer
distance in CNOs after their intercalation and the localization of
potassium atoms, respectively. Last but not least, we analyzed the
functionalized CNOs by statistical Raman spectroscopy[34,35] (SRS) and thermogravimetric analysis coupled with gas-chromatographic
separation and mass-spectrometric characterization (TGA/GC/MS), allowing
a precise characterization, establishing clear spectroscopic fingerprints
to understand the functionalization protocol in CNOs. This work provides
a better insight of potassium intercalation in CNOs and the ulterior
functionalization by different organic species.
Results and Discussion
The first objective of our work is to investigate the effects of
intercalation in CNOs by the intrusion of metallic potassium. The
reductive approach via potassium intercalation has already been widely
investigated on several carbon nanomaterials, such as graphene, graphite,
fullerenes, and carbon nanotubes,[36−43] as well as other postgraphene materials such as black phosphorus
or molybdenum disulfide.[44−47] Its advantages in terms of an increase in reactivity
and in yield of the reaction have been demonstrated by several studies
of interest,[48,49] paving the way for the translation
of this approach to CNOs. To the best of our knowledge, only a few
studies suggest the possibility of CNOs intercalation, but without
unambiguous demonstration.[30,50] In one case, Molina-Ontoria et al. showed the functionalization of CNOs after a liquid
Na/K activation.[30] But only Šiller
and co-workers have specifically investigated this intercalation compound
with potassium by XPS spectroscopy[50] showing
that potassium-treated CNOs behave as a graphite nanocrystal (closer
to graphene) instead of exhibiting a molecular behavior despite their
molecular-fullerene-like structure. Moreover, by means of carbon dioxide
treatment at 1020 K, the CNO structure is damaged and further opened,
derived from partial oxidation that creates pores to foster the intercalation.[51] Herein, to pursue the understanding of the intercalation
mechanism and final properties, CNO powder was intercalated with metallic
potassium at 180 °C for 3 days under an Argon atmosphere (K-CNOs)
(Figure a, see the Supporting Information (SI) for a detailed procedure).
The ratio between K and carbon atoms was about 1:8, following a similar
procedure reported to be the optimal ratio for KC8 GICs.[39] Similar to the case of GICs, high temperature
and mechanical mixing of the powder are aimed to promote the intercalation
of K between the shells of a single onion. It is worth mentioning
that the intercalation should proceed through lattice defects on the
surface of the CNOs (vide infra). The analysis of
intercalated CNOs needs to be assessed in situ, and
due to the high reactivity of this species special controlled conditions
for the analysis are required. With this intention, K-CNOs were vacuum-sealed
in glass vials, allowing the transportation and the direct analysis
of the intercalated compound. In situ Raman analysis
was performed at different times to follow the occurring change (Figure b). Raman spectra
of pristine CNOs are typically composed of D (1354 cm–1), G (1575 cm–1), and 2D (∼2680 cm–1) bands (Figure b,
red line) and evolve with intercalation time (Figures c and S3). The
G band decreases in intensity, while the 2D band disappears after
72 h. This effect is a characteristic feature of highly doped regimes
present in the carbon allotrope, which blocks the possibility of having
a double resonance process.[52] In addition,
a new peak appeared at ∼500 cm–1 (Figure c, red line). This
new peak, the so-called CZ band highlighted by the orange
line in the deconvoluted spectra of K-CNOs (Figure c), is characteristic for potassium intercalated
multiwalled carbon nanotubes (MWNTs)[36] and
KC8 graphite (537 to 565 cm–1 respectively).[53] This peak arises from the out-of-plane vibration
of the graphitic carbon atoms and only becomes Raman active under
intercalation, when the K atoms impose a superstructure within the
carbon lattice.[36] Conspicuously, the G
line exhibits a Fano resonance formation (Figure c, black line) associated with electron–phonon
couplings between the K atoms and the graphitic structure originating
from the in-plane E2g1 vibration of the carbon
atoms.[54,55] As observed in Figure c, the G-line in the CNOs turned from a Lorentzian
line into a Fano-like shape. This effect results from introducing
a high concentration of K within the lattice structure of the CNOs.
The Fano resonance is a characteristic signature from a highly doped
potassium intercalated compound as it has been shown from a stage
I GIC KC8 in MWCNTs KC8.[36] In addition, it is highly important to consider that an
asymmetric Fano line shape of the G-line originates from the strong
electron phonon-coupling existing between the K atoms and the graphitic
structure of the fullerene and other intercalation compounds. The
strong electron phonon-coupling in graphitic based intercalation compounds
is a signature of a superconducting potential behavior of the material.
In this sense, one can estimate the renormalized electron–phonon
scattering line width (γEPC) by measuring the G-line
frequency of the Fano line (ωG). However, in our
case, this is not possible, as the already established values for
adiabatic and nonadiabatic phonon frequencies in graphite[56] will not work for fullerenes as the model may
have to be restated for this particular nanostructure.
Figure 1
In situ Raman spectra
recorded under high-vacuum conditions (∼10–6 mbar) on intercalated CNOs and their Raman spectra
(λex = 532 nm). (a) Scheme of the intercalation reaction
and the instrumental setup. (b) Deconvolution of Raman spectra of
pristine CNOs that are vacuum sealed. Asterisks (pink lines) indicate
characteristic glass tube signals. D (1354 cm–1),
G (1575 cm–1), and 2D (∼2680 cm–1) bands characteristic for CNOs depicted in green, black, and blue,
respectively. (c) Deconvolution of Raman spectra of K-CNOs. The Raman
spectral lines from pristine CNOs evolve along intercalation into:
CZ band (orange line ∼500 cm–1), glass tube peak (pink line), D (green line), and Fano-like G (black).
In situ Raman spectra
recorded under high-vacuum conditions (∼10–6 mbar) on intercalated CNOs and their Raman spectra
(λex = 532 nm). (a) Scheme of the intercalation reaction
and the instrumental setup. (b) Deconvolution of Raman spectra of
pristine CNOs that are vacuum sealed. Asterisks (pink lines) indicate
characteristic glass tube signals. D (1354 cm–1),
G (1575 cm–1), and 2D (∼2680 cm–1) bands characteristic for CNOs depicted in green, black, and blue,
respectively. (c) Deconvolution of Raman spectra of K-CNOs. The Raman
spectral lines from pristine CNOs evolve along intercalation into:
CZ band (orange line ∼500 cm–1), glass tube peak (pink line), D (green line), and Fano-like G (black).This first analysis is confirming that the intercalation
treatment
is leading to changes in the CNOs’ electronic structure. To
further investigate the effects of intercalation in CNOs, we performed
a direct observation of the changes in the CNOs structure through
XRD and scanning TEM (STEM). All the analyses were performed under
vacuum, maintaining the samples under an inert atmosphere to avoid
the deintercalation/oxidation of the reduced species (see the SI). XRD analysis of K-CNOs revealed the presence
of two dominant interlayer distances, 0.38 and 0.76 nm (Figure a). The first value is close
to the one of conventional graphite/graphitic carbon but slightly
higher than that observed for the pristine CNOs (∼0.35 nm).
The second value of ca. 0.76 nm reflects the potassium-intercalated
onion shells. Comparing this with the family of GICs, the interlayer
distance roughly suggests a stage II compound rather than a conventional
stage I compound. Specifically, stage I, where the interlayer distance
is ∼0.535 nm and corresponding to a ratio between K:C = 1:8
(Figure b, top), and
stage II, in which ∼0.875 nm corresponds to a ratio of K:C
= 1:24, with the coexistence of two interlayer distances: intercalated
and nonintercalated ones (Figure b, bottom). Additionally, the formation of Daumas–Hérold
type defects cannot be ruled out.[57] The
increase of the interlayer distance is a first suggestion of the occurrence
of a potassium intercalation, due to the penetration of the metal
between the shells. Moreover, the comparison with GICs is suggesting
that not all the potassium employed for the intercalation penetrates
inside the onions, from which an interlayer distance that lies in
between KC8 and KC24 is obtained.[58−60] This phenomenon could be explained by the difficulty for potassium
to enter the first shell of CNOs, which can only occur via defects,
and then diffuse between the other inner shells.
Figure 2
(a) X-ray powder diffraction
of pristine and intercalated K-CNOs.
Pristine CNOs (black line) are characterized by a broad peak with
interlayer distance of ∼0.35 nm (qaverage= 17.9 nm–1). K-CNOs (blue line) characterized
by two major peaks corresponding to interlayer distances of ∼0.38
and ∼0.76 nm (q = 8.2 and 16.4 nm–1) are shown. (b) Top: scheme of stage I intercalation compound corresponding
to K:C = 1:8. Bottom: stage II intercalation compound, corresponding
to K:C = 1:24. (c) STEM-MAADF image of pristine CNOs. (d) STEM-MAADF
image of intercalated K-CNOs.
(a) X-ray powder diffraction
of pristine and intercalated K-CNOs.
Pristine CNOs (black line) are characterized by a broad peak with
interlayer distance of ∼0.35 nm (qaverage= 17.9 nm–1). K-CNOs (blue line) characterized
by two major peaks corresponding to interlayer distances of ∼0.38
and ∼0.76 nm (q = 8.2 and 16.4 nm–1) are shown. (b) Top: scheme of stage I intercalation compound corresponding
to K:C = 1:8. Bottom: stage II intercalation compound, corresponding
to K:C = 1:24. (c) STEM-MAADF image of pristine CNOs. (d) STEM-MAADF
image of intercalated K-CNOs.To gain further insights into the structure and morphology of the
intercalated CNOs, all samples were characterized using the aberration
corrected Nion UltraSTEM 100 dedicated scanning transmission electron
microscope in Vienna. The intercalated samples were transported in
an inert atmosphere and placed on sample holders inside an argon glovebox.
They were then moved in the argon atmosphere to the vacuum system
connected to the microscope.[61] Pristine
samples were transferred through air. All images were recorded with
an acceleration voltage of 60 kV using the medium angle annular dark
field (MAADF) detector. Based on a statistical analysis of STEM-MAADF
images (similar to the ones shown in Figure c), the average number of shells is around
six. Interestingly, instead of being round, the onions typically exhibited
ellipsoidal shapes with different degrees of polygonization, which
is also observed for CNO obtained by computer models (vide
infra). These modifications of the structure can locally
affect the interlayer distance which plays an important role in the
intercalation. There was no apparent difference in the shape of the
onions after the intercalation (see Figure d for an example), suggesting that, if potassium
enters the onions shells, it does not disrupt the layered structure.Despite Z-contrast, the STEM-MAADF images did
not allow us to unambiguously locate potassium within the structures.
Therefore, we also employed electron energy loss spectroscopy and
spectral mapping within the same instrument. A spectral map of a larger
nano-onion is shown in Figure a (each pixel shows the total intensity of the spectrum recorded
at that location, which roughly corresponds to a Z-contrast image). The spectra were recorded with a dispersion of ca. 0.33 eV/pixel (512 pixels in total) and were centered
at 300 eV. Figure b shows a map where the original spectrum map was binned from 256
× 256 to 11 × 11 pixels, and for each pixel the signal corresponding
to an energy window of 293–297 eV was divided by that from
289–293 eV (pixels with very low signal corresponding to vacuum
were set to zero). As can be seen from the spectra in Figure c, that correspond to the marked
locations in Figure a, the first energy window (pink shaded area) contains both potassium
peaks K-L2 and K-L3,whereas the second energy
window (light blue shaded area) corresponds to the σ* peak of
the carbon K edge. Correspondingly, the red areas in Figure b (mostly between the outer
layers of the onion) correlate to locations with a high potassium
concentration. Notably, in several of the shown spectra, the two potassium
peaks are clearly visible (for example, in 3, 4, 8, 9, 10 and 11)
despite the overlap with the carbon K peak. Overall, these results
support the observation of partial intercalation of CNOs. Additionally,
as previously shown by XRD analysis, EELS also suggests an intercalation
ratio K:C closer to 1:24, with the remaining potassium being free
around the onions.
Figure 3
Electron energy loss spectroscopy analysis of an intercalated
nano-onion
(K-CNO). (a) Spectrum image with each pixel having the intensity corresponding
to the sum of the spectrum recorded there leading essentially to thickness
contrast. (b) A 11 × 11 pixel map made from the spectrum image
of panel (a) by binning the spectra and dividing the integrated intensity
within an energy window of 293–297 eV with the intensity from
289–293 eV (except for pixels recorded in vacuum). The energy
windows are marked with shaded areas in panel (c). (c) Averaged spectra
from the areas marked in panel (a) with numbered squares. Potassium
L3 and L2 peaks are at 294 and 296 eV (inside
the pink shaded area), whereas the C-K σ* peak is within the
second energy window (area shaded light blue).
Electron energy loss spectroscopy analysis of an intercalated
nano-onion
(K-CNO). (a) Spectrum image with each pixel having the intensity corresponding
to the sum of the spectrum recorded there leading essentially to thickness
contrast. (b) A 11 × 11 pixel map made from the spectrum image
of panel (a) by binning the spectra and dividing the integrated intensity
within an energy window of 293–297 eV with the intensity from
289–293 eV (except for pixels recorded in vacuum). The energy
windows are marked with shaded areas in panel (c). (c) Averaged spectra
from the areas marked in panel (a) with numbered squares. Potassium
L3 and L2 peaks are at 294 and 296 eV (inside
the pink shaded area), whereas the C-K σ* peak is within the
second energy window (area shaded light blue).Once the intercalation of potassium in CNOs has been demonstrated,
we used DFT computer models to explore the different energetics of
the intercalation process. For this, we simulated the transition states
for insertion of K through polyaromatic hydrocarbons with central
rings of increasing sizes ranging from 6 to 10 as well as inside a
C60 fullerene, Figure . The activation energy was computed at the M06-2X-6-31G(d)
level with the Gaussian09 software.[62]
Figure 4
Transition
states and corresponding activation energies of K entering
C60 (a) and trespassing coronene (b), heptacoronene (c),
and circulenes with a central octagon (d), nonagon (e), and decagon
(f).
Transition
states and corresponding activation energies of K entering
C60 (a) and trespassing coronene (b), heptacoronene (c),
and circulenes with a central octagon (d), nonagon (e), and decagon
(f).The comparison of the mechanism
and the energies between the insertion
through coronene (33 eV) and fullerene C60 (11 eV) through
a window opening mechanism is illustrative of how the different curvature
and local bonding structures might play a significant role on the
activation energy, especially for smaller rings. Nevertheless, these
results indicate that only, for relatively large pores, with rings
of ≥10 bonds and 0.48 nm in diameter, the insertion barrier
for K is low enough (0.4 eV) for the process to proceed at low temperatures.As previously mentioned, CNOs are often reported as spherical particles,
due to their matryoshka-like structure, similar to fullerenes. In
contrast, STEM images show different structures such as deformed spheres
or ellipsoids. The origin of these modifications remains unclear and
has been traditionally attributed to either defects, tension, chemical
bond distribution, dimension of the onions, or even temporary deformations
as a consequence of the “breathing” of the structures
under the electron beam.[63] To better understand
this observation, we carried out a computational study where we, through
simulated annealing dynamics, transformed 40 different all-carbon
nanodiamond particles ranging from C35 to C969 to CNOs.[64] For this, simulations were
run with the Brenner bond order potential implemented in a home version
of the TINKER code during 2 ns runs with linearly increasing temperatures
from 1300 to 3500 K.[65] Here, 2000 snapshots
were taken from each dynamic trajectory and subsequently minimized
to find the most thermodynamically stable nanoparticle for each system.
In the last step, the so-obtained molecular structures were minimized
with the GFN2 extended tight-binding methodology which allows for
the efficient computation of large molecular systems with quantum
mechanical Hamiltonians.[66]Two representative
systems comprising a pseudospherical CNO, C753, and a polygonal
one, C674, were selected and
will be discussed comparatively. In both cases, the transformation
started by reconstructing the external, and more undercoordinated,
region of the initial nanoparticles. The pure octahedral C674 nanodiamond kept its regular shape, while the truncated octahedral
C753 nanodiamond transformed into a pseudospherical CNO
(Figure ). This difference
was also reflected by the different simulated annealing temperatures
needed: 2093 and 2804 K, respectively. Interestingly, the C674 CNO shows a nearly octahedral shape with a defect-free external
shell composed exclusively of hexagons and pentagons matching what
is found in most fullerenes. In contrast, C753 CNO possesses
an irregular pseudospherical shape with pentagons, hexagons, and heptagons
together with some larger holes with sizes up to undecagons which
would be the most likely entry point in this case for the K in the
intercalation mechanism. Altogether, these findings confirm the suggestion
by Šiller and co-workers that the intercalation of CNOs occurs
due to the presence of surface defects, as a result of the synthetic
CNO preparation, and strongly support the experimental results shown
here.[50,63]
Figure 5
Transformation from nanodiamond to three layer
CNOs through simulated
annealing. C753 nanodiamond (a) and three-layer CNO in
two representations (b, c) and C674 nanodiamond (d) and
three-layer CNO in two representations and two perspectives (e–h).
The rectangle in C753 CNO (c) serves to highlight the undecagon
hole on the CNO surface.
Transformation from nanodiamond to three layer
CNOs through simulated
annealing. C753 nanodiamond (a) and three-layer CNO in
two representations (b, c) and C674 nanodiamond (d) and
three-layer CNO in two representations and two perspectives (e–h).
The rectangle in C753 CNO (c) serves to highlight the undecagon
hole on the CNO surface.Finally, to prove the
efficiency of the potassium intercalation
strategy, K-CNOs were functionalized using two reactive species, hexyl
iodide and phenyl iodide, well-known and investigated for the functionalization
of GICs (Scheme , SI for reaction conditions). Both reagents allow
a covalent bulk functionalization with the employment of a low amount
of reacting species, avoiding the occurrence of side reactions and
the formation of coupling products.[39] Moreover,
the choice of well-known reagents allows an easy characterization
of the onions due to the simple moieties introduced on their surface.
Scheme 1
Reaction Scheme of CNO Intercalation (First Step) followed by Functionalization
with Hexyl Iodide or Phenyl Iodide (Second Step) and Schematic Representation
of Functionalized CNOs
Differently from classic organic synthesis, the characterization
of nanomaterials requires a cross-correlated analysis of several techniques
to prove an intended functionalization. Following this line, we evaluated
the number of functional groups and their integrity. Raman spectroscopy
is one of the most commonly employed techniques to analyze modifications
on the nanomaterials lattice.[67−69] Similar to graphene, Raman bands
such as the D band (∼1350 nm), G band (∼1580 nm), and
2D band (∼2680 nm) are characteristic for CNOs. In contrast
to graphene, in which the information about functionalization, number
of layers, and surface change can easily be extracted, for CNOs, the
presence of an intense D band makes a precise estimation of the ID/IG ratio quite
difficult. Moreover, the analysis of hundreds of single point spectra
of pristine CNOs reveals a broad distribution of ID/IG ratios ranging from ca. 1.1 to 1.4, pointing out the importance of a statistical
assessment for the correct interpretation of the functionalization
reactions. Indeed, D and G band intensities are very close for onions
synthesized by thermal annealing, reducing the change on the spectra
due to chemical functionalization. Herein, we performed a unique statistical
Raman analysis and temperature dependent Raman analysis on functionalized
CNOs (f-CNOs) in order to obtain an accurate estimation of the functionalization
reaction. Areas of 10 μm were analyzed, obtaining more than
200 points for the pristine material and more than 600 points for
f-CNOs. Figure shows
the results of the ID/IG ratio and I2D/IG ratio. The average values of the pristine and the f-CNOs
do not show a highly significant difference, with 1.23 ± 0.0002,
1.30 ± 0.0009, and 1.37 ± 0.0010, respectively, for pristine,
hexyl, and aryl functionalized onions (see Figure , table). However, clear evidence of the
functionalization that occurred is shown by the ID/IG and I2D/IG ratio distribution.
The first column shows a shift on the ID/IG ratio distribution for both hexyl
and aryl functionalized CNOs compared to the pristine onions, with
an increase of the intensity of the D band, typically attributed to
the functionalization of carbon nanomaterials. Accordingly, the I2D/IG ratio of functionalized
CNOs shows a significant shift to lower values and broadening with
respect to the pristine one. These observations highlight the importance
of the statistical Raman analysis for the characterization of nanomaterials.
In fact, from the simple comparison of the average Raman spectra (Figure g, h), the information
about the intensity ratio would have been lost, resulting in the misleading
conclusion that no reaction occurred on the material. Additionally,
the analysis of few Raman spectra could have led to errors as well,
because of the low number of cases analyzed.
Figure 6
Statistical Raman analysis
performed on a 10 μm surface area.
First row: Pristine CNOs, 200 points collected for each map., (a) ID/IG ratio and (b) I2D/IG ratio. Second
row: Hexyl functionalized CNOs, 625 single points collected, (c) ID/IG ratio and (d) I2D/IG ratio. Third
row: Aryl functionalized CNOs, 625 single points collected, (e) ID/IG ratio and (f) I2D/IG ratio. (g) Comparison of the mean
Raman spectra from the Raman mapping, CNOs pristine (black line),
CNOs-hexyl (red line), and CNO-aryl (blue line). (h) Higher magnification
of the Raman spectra shown in (g) . (i) Table summarizing the ID/IG ratio and I2D/IG ratio.
Statistical Raman analysis
performed on a 10 μm surface area.
First row: Pristine CNOs, 200 points collected for each map., (a) ID/IG ratio and (b) I2D/IG ratio. Second
row: Hexyl functionalized CNOs, 625 single points collected, (c) ID/IG ratio and (d) I2D/IG ratio. Third
row: Aryl functionalized CNOs, 625 single points collected, (e) ID/IG ratio and (f) I2D/IG ratio. (g) Comparison of the mean
Raman spectra from the Raman mapping, CNOs pristine (black line),
CNOs-hexyl (red line), and CNO-aryl (blue line). (h) Higher magnification
of the Raman spectra shown in (g) . (i) Table summarizing the ID/IG ratio and I2D/IG ratio.Furthermore, we performed a temperature-dependent
Raman analysis,
from 0 to 425 °C, to investigate the reversibility in the functionalization
of CNOs. This technique was already employed by our group to understand
the response of functional groups and nanomaterials to temperature.[39,48,70] Starting from 0 °C, a Raman
map was collected by 25 °C steps. In this case, the scanning
and warming time was minimized, performing maps of 25 single points
each, to avoid the prolonged warming of the sample at high temperatures.
The results are depicted in Figure for CNOs-aryl (Figures S4 and S5 for pristine and CNOs-hexyl, respectively). A concomitant
narrowing and decrease of the D band upon defunctionalization and
an increase of intensity of the 2D band, corroborating the defunctionalization
due to the increase of the temperature, were observed. Furthermore,
the disappearance of the D′ shoulder at around 1620 cm–1 is observed upon heating. Finally, and perhaps most
importantly, the recovery of the pristine CNOs’ ID/IG ratio after thermal treatment
demonstrates that the carbon lattice is not damaged during the reduction
or the functionalization process. A reference map analysis on pristine
CNOs was also performed to discard possible effects due to temperature.
As expected, no significant changes in the Raman spectra were found.
Figure 7
Temperature-dependent
Raman analysis of CNOs-aryl. (a) Stacking
of Raman spectra from 25 to 350 °C. (b) Evolution of the ID/IG and I2D/IG ratios with
increasing temperature. The ratios of the statistical map for pristine
CNOs (represented by the blue triangle and the green rhombus) at 425
°C are recovered after the thermal defunctionalization treatment.
(c) Magnification of CNOs D band; the decrease of D band intensity
with increasing temperatures is highlighted by a black arrow. (d)
Magnification of CNOs G and D′ bands, showing D′ disappearance
with increasing temperatures. (e) Magnification of CNOs 2D band, showing
the increase of 2D band intensity with increasing temperatures.
Temperature-dependent
Raman analysis of CNOs-aryl. (a) Stacking
of Raman spectra from 25 to 350 °C. (b) Evolution of the ID/IG and I2D/IG ratios with
increasing temperature. The ratios of the statistical map for pristine
CNOs (represented by the blue triangle and the green rhombus) at 425
°C are recovered after the thermal defunctionalization treatment.
(c) Magnification of CNOs D band; the decrease of D band intensity
with increasing temperatures is highlighted by a black arrow. (d)
Magnification of CNOs G and D′ bands, showing D′ disappearance
with increasing temperatures. (e) Magnification of CNOs 2D band, showing
the increase of 2D band intensity with increasing temperatures.To analyze the fragments of the organic molecules
detached from
the samples upon heating, a special technique based on the coupling
of thermogravimetric analysis, gas chromatography, and mass-spectrometry
(TGA/GC/MS) was performed. This technique is known for its efficacy
in the characterization of other carbon nanomaterials, even in the
presence of multiple functional groups.[70] Several advantages arise from the combination of these techniques:
first, the possibility of choosing the temperature at which to analyze
the gas developed and the precise separation of the components through
gas chromatography. Second, the high sensitivity of mass spectrometry
and cross-reference with mass-fragmentation libraries allow a deep
understanding of the composition of each eluted compound, in direct
correlation to the defunctionalization of the materials. Initially,
simple TGA analysis was carried out (Figure a and entire TGA profile in Figure S6a), showing the high stability of pristine CNOs up
to a temperature of 700 °C. The CNO-hexyl presents a constant
weight loss starting from a temperature of ∼120 °C, while
CNO-aryl presents a more marked weight loss at ∼140 °C
and then from 200 °C (Figure S6b).
Therefore, we collected and analyzed the gas produced at 200 °C
for CNO-aryl (Figure b) and 180 °C for CNOs-hexyl (Figure S7b). The CNO-aryl sample presents the main peak of benzene after 4.61
min, corresponding to m/z of 78
(Figure c). Together,
at 9.92 min, a peak corresponding to unreacted iodobenzene is present
(m/z = 204). A similar behavior
was observed by the CNO-Hexyl sample, with three main peaks at 4.14,
4.18, and 5.99 min (Figure S7c). The fragmentation
analysis corresponds to different fragments arising from the hexyl
chain during the warming of the materials. A similar behavior was
shown by conventional TGA-MS direct analysis performed on CNO-hexyl
(Figure S8b). The temperature/ion current
spectra show three main fragments formed at ∼300 °C during
heating of the CNOs. The m/z fragments
of 43, 57, and 86 correspond to linear aliphatic compounds from C3H7, C4H9, and C3H7–CO–CH2+. The high
temperature at which the fragments are detected (>300 °C)
confirms
their origin as a functional group of CNOs, discarding adsorbed organic
molecules, expected to appear at lower temperatures. Other common
characterization techniques such as attenuated total reflectance Fourier-transformed
infrared spectroscopy (ATR-FTIR), absorption spectroscopy (UV–vis),
and dynamic light scattering (DLS) corroborate our results and can
be found in the Supporting Information (see SI Figures S9 and S10).
Figure 8
TGA-GC-MS analysis from CNOs-aryl. (a) TGA profile
of CNO-aryl
(blue line); blue arrow indicates sample injection at 200 °C
during TGA analysis. (b) CNOs-aryl GC chromatogram; peaks marked with
a colored box are relative to fragments from functional groups. (c)
MS fragment analysis of GC peaks at 4.61, 8.95, and 9.92 min. Residual
benzonitrile presence from the workup protocol is shown by the peak
at ∼8.95 min.
TGA-GC-MS analysis from CNOs-aryl. (a) TGA profile
of CNO-aryl
(blue line); blue arrow indicates sample injection at 200 °C
during TGA analysis. (b) CNOs-aryl GC chromatogram; peaks marked with
a colored box are relative to fragments from functional groups. (c)
MS fragment analysis of GC peaks at 4.61, 8.95, and 9.92 min. Residual
benzonitrile presence from the workup protocol is shown by the peak
at ∼8.95 min.
Conclusion
In
this study, we carried out a combination of different in situ and ex situ characterization techniques
supported by extensive theoretical calculations. This demonstrates
that CNOs can be successfully intercalated with potassium through
surface defects by means of thermal heating at relatively low temperatures. Moreover,
we developed the reductive covalent functionalization of CNOs with
both hexyl iodide and aryl iodide, showing unambiguous spectroscopic
fingerprints thanks to the cross-analysis of statistical Raman spectroscopy
and TG-GC-MS, among others. This work provides an important insight
into the structure of intercalated and functionalized CNOs as well
as the understanding of the basic principles of their alkali metal
intercalation and reductive functionalization. This work may lay the
foundations for future applications of CNOs in which metal intercalation
and surface engineering play a crucial role.
Authors: Milan Schirowski; Gonzalo Abellán; Edurne Nuin; Jonas Pampel; Christian Dolle; Vincent Wedler; Tim-Patrick Fellinger; Erdmann Spiecker; Frank Hauke; Andreas Hirsch Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2018-02-21 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: Ferdinand Hof; Sebastian Bosch; Jan M Englert; Frank Hauke; Andreas Hirsch Journal: Angew Chem Int Ed Engl Date: 2012-10-25 Impact factor: 15.336
Authors: Agustín Molina-Ontoria; Manuel N Chaur; Marta E Plonska-Brzezinska; Luis Echegoyen Journal: Chem Commun (Camb) Date: 2013-03-25 Impact factor: 6.222
Authors: Kathrin C Knirsch; Jan M Englert; Christoph Dotzer; Frank Hauke; Andreas Hirsch Journal: Chem Commun (Camb) Date: 2013-11-28 Impact factor: 6.222
Authors: Gonzalo Abellán; Milan Schirowski; Konstantin F Edelthalhammer; Michael Fickert; Katharina Werbach; Herwig Peterlik; Frank Hauke; Andreas Hirsch Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2017-03-31 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: Amit Palkar; Frederic Melin; Claudia M Cardona; Bevan Elliott; Amit K Naskar; Danny D Edie; Amar Kumbhar; Luis Echegoyen Journal: Chem Asian J Date: 2007-05-04
Authors: Alberto Trentino; Jacob Madsen; Andreas Mittelberger; Clemens Mangler; Toma Susi; Kimmo Mustonen; Jani Kotakoski Journal: Nano Lett Date: 2021-06-09 Impact factor: 11.189