| Literature DB >> 34661764 |
Kirsten R Müller-Vahl1, Danielle C Cath2, Natalia Szejko3,4,5, Sally Robinson6, Andreas Hartmann7, Christos Ganos8, Nanette M Debes9, Liselotte Skov9, Martina Haas10, Renata Rizzo1, Jeremy Stern11, Alexander Münchau12, Virginie Czernecki7, Andrea Dietrich13, Tara L Murphy14, Davide Martino15, Zsanett Tarnok16, Tammy Hedderly6.
Abstract
In 2011 a working group of the European Society for the Study of Tourette Syndrome (ESSTS) has developed the first European assessment guidelines for Tourette syndrome (TS). Now, we present an updated version 2.0 of these European clinical guidelines for Tourette syndrome and other tic disorders, part I: assessment. Therefore, the available literature has been thoroughly screened, supplemented with national guidelines across countries and discussions among ESSTS experts. Diagnostic changes between DSM-IV and DSM-5 classifications were taken into account and new information has been added regarding differential diagnoses, with an emphasis on functional movement disorders in both children and adults. Further, recommendations regarding rating scales to evaluate tics, comorbidities, and neuropsychological status are provided. Finally, results from a recently performed survey among ESSTS members on assessment in TS are described. We acknowledge that the Yale Global Tic Severity Scale (YGTSS) is still the gold standard for assessing tics. Recommendations are provided for scales for the assessment of tics and psychiatric comorbidities in patients with TS not only in routine clinical practice, but also in the context of clinical research. Furthermore, assessments supporting the differential diagnosis process are given as well as tests to analyse cognitive abilities, emotional functions and motor skills.Entities:
Keywords: Assessment; Scales; Tics; Tourette syndrome
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34661764 PMCID: PMC8521086 DOI: 10.1007/s00787-021-01842-2
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry ISSN: 1018-8827 Impact factor: 4.785
Differences between DSM-IV-TR, DSM-5, ICD-10, ICD-11
| Labels | Parent category | Criteria of TS | Criteria of chronic/persistent vocal and/or motor tic disorder | Criteria of provisional/transient tic disorder | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DSM-IV-TR | Tourette’s disorder; chronic motor or vocal tic disorder; transient tic disorder; tic disorder not otherwise specified | Disorders of infancy, childhood, and adolescence | Multiple motor and one or more vocal tics at some point in illness Tics occur daily or periodically, but 1 year since onset, and no tic-free period of more than 3 consecutive months Onset before 18 years Not caused by substance or other condition | One or more motor or vocal tics present at some point, not both motor and vocal symptoms Tics occur daily or periodically, but 1 year since onset, and no tic-free period of more than 3 consecutive months Onset before 18 years Not caused by substance or other condition No history of TS | One or more motor and vocal tics Tics occur daily or periodically, but for 4 weeks and 12 months Onset before 18 years Not caused by substance or other condition No history of TS Specify if single episode or recurrent |
| ICD-10 | Combined vocal and multiple motor tic disorder (de la Tourette); chronic motor or vocal tic disorder; transient tic disorder; other tic disorders; tic disorder, unspecified | Behavioural and emotional disorders with onset usually occurring in childhood and adolescence | Multiple motor and one or more vocal tics, not necessarily occurring at the same time | One or more motor or vocal tics, but not both types Symptoms occur 12 months | One or more motor and/or vocal tics Symptoms occur 12 months |
| DSM-5 | Tourette’s disorder; persistent (chronic) motor or vocal tic disorder provisional tic disorder; other specified tic disorder; unspecified tic disorder | Neurodevelopmental disorders | Multiple motor and one or more vocal tics at some point in illness May wax and wane, but have persisted 1 year since onset Onset before 18 years Not caused by substance or other condition | One or more motor or vocal tics present at some point, not both motor and vocal symptoms May wax and wane, but have persisted 1 year since onset Onset before 18 years Not caused by substance or other condition No history of TS Specify if motor tics only, vocal tics only | One or more motor and/or vocal tics Tics present for 1 year since onset Onset before 18 years Not caused by substance or other condition No history of TS or persistent tic disorder |
| ICD-11 | Tourette syndrome (combined vocal and motor tic disorder); persistent (chronic) motor or phonic tics; provisional tic disorder; substance-induced tic disorder; tic disorder due to general medical condition | Disorders of nervous system—primary; mental and behavioural disorders—secondary; obsessive–compulsive and related disorders; neurodevelopmental disorders | One or more motor and/or vocal tics occurring over the same period of time Symptoms occur 12 months | One or more motor and one or more vocal tics Symptoms occur 12 months | One or more motor or vocal tics, but not both types Symptoms occur 2 weeks and 12 months |
For the previous version of this Table, refer to the 2011 ESSTS Guidelines [4]
DSM-IV-TR The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders Text Revision 4th edition, DSM-5 The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders 5th edition, ICD-10 the International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems, 10th edition, ICD-11 the International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems, 11th edition
Different types of tics and their characteristics
| Type of tic | Typical features |
|---|---|
| Motor | Arise in the voluntary musculature and involve discrete muscles or muscle groups |
| Vocal | Consist of any noise produced by movement of air through the nose, mouth or pharynx |
| Stimulus-bound | Occur in response to internal or external stimuli (visual, phonic, tactile or mental) |
| Blocking | Motor or vocal tics that interrupt the voluntary action without alteration of consciousness (dysfluency of speech or gait) |
| Simple | Are restricted to one muscle or a single muscle group (e.g. eye blinking, nose twitching, tongue protrusion), simple, meaningless sounds (e.g. grunting, throat clearing, coughing, sniffling and barking) |
| Complex | Involvement of more muscle groups (e.g. repetitive touching of objects or people, repetitive obscene movements (copropraxia), mimicking others (echopraxia) complex vocal tics are words or phrases, expressing obscenities (coprolalia), repeating others (echolalia) or repeating oneself (palilalia)) |
| Clonic | Last less than 100 ms |
| Dystonic | Last more than 300 ms Repetitively abnormal posture of a kind that one may see in dystonia |
| Tonic | Last more than 300 ms Relatively long duration of the contraction (in e.g. back muscles) without exhibiting abnormal postures |
Tic and comorbidity assessment in children and adults
| Topic | Measurement instrument children | Measurement instrument adults | Time (min) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Demographics | Age, sex, education level child and parents, work status parents, ethnicity, child and parents (based on country of origin info), marital status parents | Age, sex, education level, work status, ethnicity patient and parents (based on country of origin info), marital status | Max. 20 |
| Age at onset tics, OCD, ADHD | Age at onset, age at worst ever | Age at onset, age at worst ever | Max. 10 |
| Family history tics/OCD/ADHD | Family tree, including disease in family members | Family tree, including disease in family members | Max. 20 |
| Tic diagnosis according to DSM | Interview (derived from DCI or parts of DISC) | Interview (derived from DCI) | Max. 10 |
| Other DSM diagnoses | Kiddie-SADS-PL | MINI/SCID | Max. 60 |
| Tic symptoms (past/present) | YGTSS | YGTSS | Max. 30 |
| Tic symptoms | STSS | STSS | Max. 30 |
| Tic symptoms | TODS | TODS | Max. 30 |
| Tic symptoms | RVBTRS | RVBTRS | Max. 30 |
| OCD symptoms (past/present) | CY-BOCS, CY-BOCS-II, OCI-CV, LOI-CV, CHOCI | Y-BOCS/D-YBOCS, OCI-R | Max. 30 |
| ADHD | SNAP/CAARS (parent/teacher/self-rating), Qb + © DSM-5 criteria of ADHD [ ADHD-RS | SNAP/CAARS, Qb + ©, Adult ADHD Self-Report Screening Scale for DSM-5 [ | Max. 50 |
| Autism symptoms | Social Responsiveness Scale (SRS) | Autism Questionnaire (AQ) | Max. 25 |
| Impulsive behaviour | BIS-15 | BIS-15 | Max. 5 |
| Sensory premonitory urges | PUTS (10 items) I-PUTS (10 items) | PUTS (10 items) I-PUTS (10 items) | Max. 5 Max. 5 |
| Course of psychopathology | |||
| Severity-tics | YGTSS (11 items; current & worst ever; age at worst ever) | YGTSS (11 items; current & worst ever; age at worst ever) | Max. 15 |
| Severity OC symptoms | CY-BOCS severity (2 9 10 items; current & worst ever) | Y-BOCS severity (2 9 10 items; current & worst ever) | Max. 10 |
| Severity depression and anxiety | RCADS (47 items) | BDI/BAI (42 items) | Max. 20 |
| Psychosocial functioning | CGI, GTS-QOL (28 items) | CGI, GTS-QOL (28 items) | Max. 17 |
| Life events | Brugha (29 items) | Brugha (29 items) | Max. 15 |
| Estimation of patients’ time for the specific baseline measurements | Max. 175 min | Max. 165 min |
DCI Diagnostic Confidence Index [127], DISC Diagnostic Interview Schedule for Children [128], Kiddie-SADS-PL Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia for School-Age Children [129], SCID Structured Clinical Interview on DSM-5 axis I disorders[130], MINI Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview[131], CY-BOCS Children’s Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale [132], CY-BOCS-II the Children's Yale-Brown Obsessive–Compulsive Scale Second Edition [133], Y-BOCS Yale-Brown Obsessive–Compulsive Scale [134], DY-BOCS Dimensional Yale-Brown Obsessive–Compulsive Scale [135], SNAP-IV Swanson, Nolan and Pelham questionnaire, 4th edition [136], CAARS the Connors ADHD Rating Scale, RS Social Responsiveness Scale [137], BIS Barratt Impulsivity Scale [138], PUTS Premonitory Urge Tics Scale [139], I-PUTS the Individualised Premonitory Urge for Tics Scale [140], YGTSS the Yale Global Tic Severity Scale [141], RCADS Revised Child Anxiety and Depression Scale [142], BDI Beck Depression Inventory-II [143], BAI Beck Anxiety Inventory [144], CGI Clinical Global Impression [145], GTS-QOL Gilles de la Tourette Syndrome–Quality of Life Scale [146], Qb + © Quantified Behaviour Test Plus [147], OCI-CV Obsessive Compulsive Inventory; child’s version [148], LOI CV Leyton Obsessive Inventory Child Version; (in children)/LOI (in adults) [149], WURS the Wender Utah Rating Scale [150], STSS Shapiro Tourette-Syndrome Severity Scale [151], TODS Tourette’s Disorder Scale [152], RVBTRS Rush Video-Based Tic Rating Scale [153]
Scales “recommended”, “suggested” and “reasonable” for evaluation of tics, premonitory urges, impairment and psychiatric comorbidities. Results are based on the ESSTS Survey and recommendations by Martino et al. [151]
| Domain of assessment | Scale | Recommendation (in clinical practice or research) |
|---|---|---|
| Tics | YGTSS | Recommended |
| PTQ/ATQ | Suggested | |
| TSSL | Suggested | |
| STSS | Reasonable | |
| TS-CGI | Reasonable | |
| CGI-S | Reasonable | |
| TODS | Reasonable | |
| RVBTRS | Reasonable | |
| TSGS | Reasonable | |
| GTRS | Reasonable | |
| MOVES rater | Reasonable | |
| MOVES patient | Reasonable | |
| PRQPT | Reasonable | |
| Apter 4-q | Reasonable | |
| Tics and comorbidities | A-TAC | Reasonable |
| Premonitory urges | PUTS | Recommended |
| Impairment | Impairment in YGTSS | Recommended |
| GTS-QOL | Recommended | |
| C&A-GTS-QOL | Recommended | |
| CTIM | Suggested | |
| C-GAS | Suggested | |
| OCD | Y-BOCS | Recommended |
| CY-BOCS | Recommended | |
| ADHD | SNAP | Recommended |
| CAARS | Recommended | |
| WURS | Suggested | |
| Qb + © | Reasonable |
YGTSS the Yale Global Tic Severity Scale, STSS Shapiro Tourette-Syndrome Severity Scale, TS-CGI Tourette Syndrome-Clinical Global Impression, TODS the Tourette’s Disorder Scale, PUTS Premonitory Urge for Tics Scale, RVBTRS Rush Video-Based Tic Rating Scale, TSGS Tourette Syndrome Global Scale, GTRS Global Tic Rating Scale, MOVES Motor tic, Obsessions and compulsions, Vocal tic Evaluation Survey, PTQ Parent Tic Questionnaire, ATQ Adult Tic Questionnaire, TSSL Tourette Syndrome Symptom List, A-TAC Autism–Tics, ADHD, and other Co-morbidities inventory, PRQPT Proxy Report Questionnaire for Parents and Teachers, Apter 4-q Apter 4-questions screening, GTS-QOL The Gilles de la Tourette Syndrome-Quality of Life Scale, C&A-GTS-QOL Gilles de la Tourette Syndrome-Quality of Life Scale in children and adolescents, CTIM Child Tourette’s Syndrome Impairment Scale, Y-BOCS Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale, CY-BOCS Children’s Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale, SNAP Swanson, Nolan and Pelham questionnaire, CAARS Children’s version of the Connors ADHD Rating Scale, WURS the Wender Utah Rating Scale, Qb + © Quantified Behaviour Test Plus, C-GAS The Children's Global Assessment Scale, CGI-S The Clinical Global Impression—Severity scale, ADHD attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, OCD obsessive–compulsive disorder
Impairment assessments in children and adults with tics
| Scale | Clinical usefulness | Age Group recommended | Rater | Range of scores | Time (min) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Impairment measured with the Yale Global Tic Severity Scale (YGTSS) [ | Separately rates impairment due to motor or vocal tics | Adults and children | Health professional and the patient | 0–50 (0 is the best score) | Max. 5 |
| Global Assessment of Functioning (C-GAS) [ | Axis five of DSM-IV TR (2002 [ | Adults and children | Health professional and the patient | 0–90 (90 is the best score) | Max. 10 |
| Clinical Global Severity Scale (CGI-S) [ | Assesses change in global daily functioning | Adults and children | Health professional | 0 = much deteriorated and, via 3 = no change, to 6 = very much improved | Max. 5 |
| The Gilles de la Tourette Syndrome-Quality of Life Scale GTS-QOL [ | 27 item scale is based on the health-related quality of life scale (HR-QOL), contains four domains: psychological problems, cognitive problems, physical/activity of daily living problems and obsessive–compulsive themes | Adults | Self-rating | Response ranges between 0 and 4, range 0–100 (0 is the best score) | Max. 30 |
| The Gilles de la Tourette Syndrome-Quality of Life Scale for Children and Adolescents (C&A-GTS-QOL) [ | A 27-item scale consisting of 4 subscales (psychological, physical, obsessive–compulsive and cognitive) | Children | Two age-adjusted versions: (1) an interview to be administered by a qualified clinician for children aged 6–12 years and (2) a self-report questionnaire for adolescents aged 13–18 years | Response ranges between 0 and 4, range 0–100 (0 is the best score) | Max. 30 |
| The Mini Child Tourette’s Syndrome Impairment Scale (CTIM) [ | 37-item parent rated instrument covering school, home, and social activities that may be impaired by tics or comorbid problems (including OCD symptoms, depression, anxiety, oppositional/disruptive behaviour, hyperactivity, and inattention) | Children | Parent also self-evaluation and short version are available [ | Each item is rated as: not at all (0), just a little (1), pretty much (2), or very much (3) problematic for the child due to tics or non-tic symptoms. Range 0–111 separately for tics and non-tics (0 is the best score) | Max. 30 |
Suggested neurocognitive assessments for use in children and adults with TS
| Neuropsychological domains | Children | Adults |
|---|---|---|
| Intellectual function | WPPSI–IV WISC-V | WAIS-IV |
| Attention | ||
| Sustained attention | CPT | CPT |
| Selective attention | TEA-Ch–II | TAP |
| Working memory auditory/spatial | Digit span, Corsi blocks | Digit span, Corsi blocks, WMS-IV |
| Executive functions–cognitive aspects | ||
Conceptual elaboration/categorization Planning Flexibility Inhibition | D-KEFS BADS-C Rey CFT Stroop GNG Wisconsin CST Trail making A,B | D-KEFS BADS Rey CFT Wisconsin CST Stroop GNG Trail making A,B |
| Executive functions–behavioural/emotional aspects | ||
| Behavioural inhibition | BRIEF–2 | BRIEF-A |
| Emotional regulation | BADS-C | BADS |
| Social cognition | Facial expression recognition | Faux-pas test, facial expression recognition, FEEST, SEA |
| Memory | RVDLT, AVLT | MEM-IV |
| Visual spatial skills | Benton Test | VOSP, BJLO |
| Literacy and numeracy | WIAT-III | BDAE (BNT) & CAB-DC |
| Motor skills and coordination | VMI–6 | PP |
AVLT Auditory Verbal Learning Test [174], BADS Behavioural Assessment of the Dysexecutive Syndrome [175], BADS-C Behavioural Assessment of the Dysexecutive Syndrome for Children [175], BDAE Boston Diagnostic Aphasia Examination [176], BJLO Benton Judgement of Line Orientation [177], BNT Boston Naming Test [178], BRIEF-2 Behaviour Rating Inventory of Executive Function-Second edition [179], BRIEF-A Behaviour Rating Inventory of Executive Function for Adults [180], CAB-DC Cognitive Assessment Battery for Dyscalculia, CPT-III Continuous Performance Test-Connors Third Edition [181], D-KEFS Delis Kaplan Executive Function System [182], FEEST Facial Expression of Emotions [183], GNG Go no go task [184], PP Purdue Pegboard [185], RVDLT Rey Visual Design Learning Test [186], Rey CFT Rey complex Figure Test [187], TEA-ch-2 Test of Everyday Attention in Children-Second edition [188], TAP Test of Attentional Performance [188], VOSP Visual Object and Space Perception [189], VMI-6 Beery Buktenika Test of Visual Motor Integration-Sixth edition [190], WAIS-IV Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale-Fourth Edition [191], Wisconsin CST Wisconsin Card Sorting Test [192], WIAT-III Wechsler Individual Achievement Test-third edition [193], WPPSI-4 Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence-Fourth edition [194], WISC-V Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Fifth Edition [195], WMS-IV Wechsler Memory Scale [196], SEA Social Cognition and Emotional Assessment