| Literature DB >> 34655247 |
Gabriele d'Ettorre1, Elio Gentilini Cacciola2, Letizia Santinelli2, Gabriella De Girolamo2,3, Ornella Spagnolello2,3, Alessandro Russo2,3, Lorenzo Tarsitani3,4, Massimo Ciccozzi5, Claudio M Mastroianni2,3, Gabriella d'Ettorre2,3, Giancarlo Ceccarelli2,3.
Abstract
Despite the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic not yet being under control, post-Covid-19 syndrome is already a challenging topic: long-term multiorgan sequelae, although increasingly described, have not yet been systematized. As post-Covid-19 syndrome can significantly impact both the working capacity and the relationship life of surviving patients, we performed a systematic review of the evidence published over the last year and currently available in medical literature search databases (MEDLINE/Pubmed) and searching clinical trial registries, to evaluate the available evidence among workers. From 31 publications that initially matched inclusion criteria, 13 studies have been considered suitable for relevance and age of subjects. A wide range of patients (16%-87%) have post-Covid syndrome; pneumological and neuropsychological symptoms were the most common disorders reported. The most frequent organic sequel found in post-Covid patients was pulmonary fibrosis. The number of symptoms during acute SARS-CoV-2 infection, severity of the disease, and high serum levels of d-dimer were related to high risk of post-Covid syndrome. In conclusion, post-Covid-19 syndrome can significantly impact the health conditions of surviving patients. Rehabilitation and follow-up in multidisciplinary rehabilitation programs should be considered for working-age patients.Entities:
Keywords: Covid-19; SARS-CoV; neuropsychological symptoms; pneumological symptoms; post-Covid syndrome; sequelae; systematic review; working age patients
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34655247 PMCID: PMC8661973 DOI: 10.1002/jmv.27399
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Med Virol ISSN: 0146-6615 Impact factor: 20.693
Figure 1Flow chart of the search and selection process in the systematic review and main results
Post‐Covid syndrome in subjects aged 15–67 years
| Study | Study design and sample size | Study location | Lasting symptoms/signs or diseases following Covid‐19 and occurrence (%) | Follow up after symptom onset or after hospital discharge | Main findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Huang et al. | Longitudinal 1773 | China |
Fatigue or muscle weakness (63%), sleep difficulties, and anxiety or depression (26%) Lung diffusion impairment (up to 56% for severe Covid patients). In women, compared with men, was reported: | Median follow‐up time after symptom onset: 186.0 (175.0–199.0) days | Increasingly impaired pulmonary diffusion capacities and abnormal chest imaging manifestations were reported in patients with a more severe illness |
|
OR: 2.22 (95% CI: 1.24–3.98) for diffusion impairment | |||||
|
OR: 1.80 (1.39–2.34) for anxiety or depression | |||||
|
OR: 1.33 (1.05–1.67) for fatigue or muscle weakness | |||||
| Goërtz et al. | Cross‐sectional 2159 | Netherlands and Belgium | Fatigue (87%), dyspnea (71%), chest tightness (44%), headache (38%) | 79 (SD ± 17) days after symptoms onset | The study excluded patients admitted to ICU. Number of symptoms during the infection was responsible for the largest unique contribution to post‐Covid syndrome ( |
| Greenhalgh et al. | Case report 1 | United Kingdom | Inability to exercise continued shortness of breath both motionless and when exerting, small waves of anxiety, considerable depression, continued loss of smell | 12 weeks after hospital admission | Indications for specialist assessment including clinical concern along with respiratory, cardiac, and neurological symptoms that are new, persistent, or progressive |
| Zhao et al. | Retrospective multicenter cohort study 55 | China |
Gastrointestinal symptoms (30.91%), headache (18.18%), fatigue (16.36%), exertional dyspnea (14.55%) Residual abnormalities of pulmonary function (25.45%); diffusion reductions in DLCO (16.36%) | 3 months after discharge | The level of |
| Raahimi et al. | Case report 1 | United Kingdom | Guillain–Barré syndrome | 5 months after symptom onset | Hypothesis that it is the immune response to Covid‐19 and not the virus itself or the acute vascular changes that underly the pathophysiology of long Covid‐19 syndrome |
| Novak | Case report 1 | United States | Orthostatic cerebral hypoperfusion syndrome (OCHOS) | >2 months after discharge | Indications for immunotherapy in patients with post‐Covid OCHOS |
| Walsh‐Messinger et al. | Case‐control 43 (21 post‐Covid patients vs. 22 Covid‐recovered patients) | United States | Impaired concentration was the most frequently reported symptom (48%), followed by headache (38%), rhinitis (20%), exercise intolerance, dyspnea, sleep impairment, brain fog, appetite loss, fatigue, and chest pain | From 28 to 291 days after symptoms onset | 51% of participants were affected by post‐Covid syndrome; females were more vulnerable than males |
| Soh et al. | Case report 1 | Japan | Posttraumatic stress disorder | 46 days after ICU discharge | Indications for establishing a follow‐up system for the long‐term outcomes of patients after ICU discharge |
| Yu et al. | Retrospective 32 | China | Pulmonary fibrosis (43.7%) | 9 days after discharge | Fibrosis was more likely to develop in elderly patients with severe clinical conditions, especially in patients with high inflammatory indicators |
| You et al. | Follow up 18 | China | Restrictive ventilatory defect (33.3% in severe cases), small function dysfunction (41.7% in nonsevere cases); pulmonary fibrosis (22.2%) | 40 ± 11.6 days in cases with nonsevere illness, and 34.7 ± 16.5 days in cases with severe illness | In Covid‐19 survivors after discharge, restrictive ventilatory defect and small function dysfunction can be persistent, which are not associated with disease severity |
| Alhiyar et al. | Case report 1 | Qatar | Pulmonary fibrosis | 5 months after symptoms onset | Authors suggest doing a 6‐min walk test to assess exertional desaturation in patients who are fulfilling other discharge criteria for Covid‐19 pneumonia and acute respiratory distress syndrome |
| Tolba et al. | Cross‐sectional 287 | Egypt | Fatigue (72.8%), anxiety (38%), joints pain (31.4%), continuous headache (28.9%), chest pain (28.9%), depression (28.6%), dyspnea (28.2%) | N/A | Severity of post‐Covid‐19 manifestations was related to the severity of Covid‐19 |
| Puchner et al. | Cross‐sectional 23 | Austria | Impairment of pulmonary function (87%) neuropsychological dysfunction (85%) | Mean = 24 days, SD 5 days after discharge | Post‐acute multidisciplinary rehabilitation led to significant clinical and functional improvements in individuals who suffered from severe or critical Covid‐19 |
Ongoing studies investigating Covid‐19 sequelae in working‐age patients (last updated on March 6, 2021)
| Types of sequelae | Title of the study–ClinicalTrials. gov Identifier | Methodology and sample size | Objectives of the study | Outcomes for sequelae |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| Follow‐up of Respiratory Sequelae of Hospitalized Patients With COVID‐19 (SISCOVID)—NCT04505631 | Study type: observational | To assess respiratory sequelae in hospitalized patients with severe Covid‐related pneumonia requiring oxygen supply and followed up for 6 months after hospital discharge | Primary: The presence of respiratory sequelae assessed by low‐dose thoracic TC |
| Estimated enrollment: 100 | Secondary: respiratory functional exploration and arterial gasometry evaluation at rest and after physical activity | |||
| Observational model: cohort | ||||
| Time perspective: prospective | ||||
| Medium and Long Term Follow‐up of COVID‐19 Infected Patients: Research and Characterization of Pulmonary Sequelae (COV‐RECUP)—NCT04519320 | Study type: intervention (clinical trial) | To assess respiratory sequelae in Covid‐19 survivors who have had a stay in intensive care and supported with respiratory assistance | Primary: proportion of patients with alteration of the capillary alveolus barrier at 12 months of follow‐up, characterized by a decrease of the diffusing capacity for carbon monoxide (DLCO) below the lower limit of normal | |
| Estimated enrollment: 140 | ||||
| Predicting the Progression to Chronic Fibrosis of Lung Lesions Related to Covid‐19 Infection From Chest CT Images (PREDISCAN)—NCT04483752 | Study type: intervention (clinical trial) | To assess: | Primary: description of the different types of lesions at 3 months | |
| Estimated enrollment: 100 |
The kinetics of lung involvement in Covid‐19 | Secondary: quantification of circulating antibodies and correlation between the level of immunization against SARS CoV2, the severity of the initial disease, and the existence or not of long‐term pulmonary sequelae at 3‐month follow up | ||
| Intervention model: single group assignment | ||||
|
The predictivity of the chest CT scan performed at the patient's discharge on the existence of radiological sequelae at 3 months and 1 year | ||||
| Long‐term Evolution of Pulmonary Involvement of Novel SARS‐COV‐2 Infection (COVID‐19): Follow the Covid Study— NCT04605757 | Study type: observational | To assess: | Primary: Long‐term evolution of clinical involvement due to SARS‐COV‐2 pneumonia symptoms, respiratory rate, blood gas exchange parameters, pulmonary function tests, six minute walking test distance | |
| Estimated enrollment: 100 |
The 6/12 month evolution of lung involvement in patients discharged after respiratory failure due to Covid‐19 pneumonia | |||
| Observational model: cohort | ||||
| Secondary: identifying possible factors associated to the persistency of clinical, functional and radiological long‐term lung involvement due to Covid‐19 | ||||
|
Factors associated to lasting clinical, functional, or radiological abnormalities collecting data from hospital stay, 1‐month, 3‐months, and 6‐to‐12‐months after hospital discharge | ||||
| Lung Function, Exercise Capacity and Health‐Related Quality of Life After Severe COVID‐19—NCT04410107 | Study type: observational | To assess the early and late effects of severe acute respiratory syndrome on lung function, exercise capacity, respiratory symptoms, and HRQoL in Covid‐19 survivors | Primary: forced expiratory volume in the first second/forced vital capacity, total lung capacity, lung diffusion capacity for carbon monoxide, 6‐min walk test distance at 6‐month follow‐up | |
| Estimated enrollment: 134 | ||||
| Observational model: cohort | ||||
| Secondary: comprehensive assessment of respiratory function at 12‐month follow up | ||||
| Time perspective: prospective | ||||
|
| Lung Function, Exercise Capacity and Health‐Related Quality of Life After Severe COVID‐19–NCT04661657 | Study type: observational (patient registry) | To assess factors associated with the development of cardiovascular conditions in Covid‐19 survivors using cardiovascular magnetic resonance and transthoracic echocardiography | Primary: evaluation of the percentage of myocardium demonstrating late gadolinium enhancement, extracellular Volume Fraction, left ventricular ejection fraction |
| Estimated enrollment: 70 | ||||
| Observational model: cohort | ||||
| Time perspective: prospective | ||||
|
| The Norwegian Study of Nervous System Manifestations and Sequelae After COVID‐19 (NeuroCovid)–NCT04576351 | Study type: observational | To assess the burden of neurological, psychiatric, and psychological complications in Covid‐19 survivors and identify clinical characteristics and biomarkers for both short‐ and long‐term neurological treatment and rehabilitation | Primary: rate of neurological, psychiatric, and neuropsychological manifestations of Covid‐19 at 6 and 12 months follow‐up |
| Estimated enrollment: 150 | Secondary: rate of stroke, death, peripheral nervous affection, myopathy, brain MRI pathology, post‐Covid neurological, cognitive, or neuropsychiatric manifestations at 6 and 12 months follow up | |||
| Observational model: cohort | ||||
| Time perspective: prospective | ||||
| Neurological and Neuropsychological Sequelae of COVID‐19 Infection (NeNeSCo)–NCT04745611 | Study type: observational (patient registry) | The aim of this study is to fill these gaps in research through: | Primary: change in life participation (social, occupational, mobility), quality of life at 6–9 months and 12–15 months after hospital discharge | |
| Estimated enrollment: 400 | ||||
| Observational model: case only |
The identification of Covid‐19‐related brain abnormalities, cognitive impairments, and emotional deficits after the (sub)acute stages of illness (i.e., 6–9 months posthospital discharge), (2) a comparison of Covid‐19‐related brain abnormalities, cognitive impairments, and emotional deficits to historical PICS cohorts, (3) a comparison between Covid‐19 ICU survivors and Covid‐19 non‐ICU patients to assess a potential PICS gradient, and (4) a follow‐up examination of the aforementioned groups 6 months after the first assessment to gain insight into the persistence of deficits | Presence of MRI abnormalities and neurological symptoms at 6–9 months and 12–15 months after hospital discharge | ||
| Time perspective: prospective | Presence of deficits in cognition, memory, visual attention and task switching, selective attention, cognitive flexibility, and processing speed, working memory, attention, and executive function at 6–9 months and 12–15 months after hospital discharge | |||
| Change in subjective cognitive complaints, depression/anxiety, posttraumatic stress symptoms, family burden, family quality of life at 6–9 months and 12–15 months after hospital discharge | ||||
| Secondary: MRI abnormalities such as cerebral microinfarctions/bleedings, and white matter hyperintensities at 6–9 months after hospital discharge | ||||
|
| Physiopathology and Sequelae of COVID‐19 Infection (SEQ‐COV‐PHYSIO)–NCT04563676 | Study type: intervention (clinical trial) | To assess the thyroid function (thyrotropic axis) as well as the corticotropic adrenal function in Covid‐19 survivors | Primary: cortisol and TSH levels at 3 months from hospitalization |
| Estimated enrollment: 400 | ||||
| Time perspective: screening | ||||
|
| Ocular Sequelae of Patients Hospitalized for Respiratory Failure During the COVID‐19 Epidemic (SOCOVID)–NCT04387292 | Study type: intervention (clinical trial) | To assess ophthalmologic damages in Covid‐19 survivors | Primary: description of the ophthalmological problems observed 6 months after discharge of hospitalization |
| Estimated enrollment: 100 | ||||
|
| Sarco‐COVID Study: Measuring the Loss of Skeletal Muscle Mass in the Hospitalized Patient With the Diagnosis of COVID‐19 (SARCO‐COVID)–NCT04780126 | Study type: observational (patient registry) | To evaluate sarcopenia in Covid‐19 survivors | Primary: quantify the loss of muscle mass in COVID‐19 patients after one month of hospitalization |
| Estimated enrollment: 64 | Secondary: analyze the clinical characteristics and the prevalence of sarcopenia, the thickness of the rectus femoris, vastus medialis, vastus lateralis, medial gastrocnemius, the correlation between C reactive protein and the presence of sarcopenia | |||
| Observational model: ecology and community | ||||
| Time perspective: prospective |